@Capital_Room's banner p

Capital_Room

rather dementor-like

0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2023 September 18 03:13:26 UTC

Disabled Alaskan Monarchist doomer


				

User ID: 2666

Capital_Room

rather dementor-like

0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2023 September 18 03:13:26 UTC

					

Disabled Alaskan Monarchist doomer


					

User ID: 2666

is that leftists are only really permitted [insured] property damage and the occasional murder as the contained scope of their violence.

Permitted by who? And why can't that change?

In any case, one more turn on the escalation spiral.

Doesn't an escalation spiral require two sides escalating? If the right doesn't escalate in response, is there a "spiral"?

I think Trump is now sure to win.

Why? After all, he could still end up in jail. Or a second assassin could get luckier despite the likely increased security to follow. Or we could get an October surprise. Or some last-minute tricks to get him off the ballot/votes disqualified (I remember one particularly wacky-yet-memorable proposal for a way to declare Trump an invalid candidate and votes for him null and void). Or he could get over 100 million votes… and the Democrat candidate be declared the winner with an "official vote count" of several million more, particularly concentrated in "battleground" states.

It's not over until it's over, and nothing's certain except death and taxes.

Idle culture war prediction: "stochastic terrorism" is quietly retired as a term. 95% of people who ever used that unironically have spent the last few months saying Trump is a fascist who is going to end democracy and everyone should be doing their best to make sure he doesn't win.

Or, per recounting by @stolen_brawnze above of NPR's reporting, one can place any attempts by people on the right to draw this connection squarely in the classic "Republicans pounce!" frame.

Edit: also add in comments like this one on Reddit, in keeping with Sailer's "frontlash" model.

And now I see Steve himself on X predicting such a frontlash.

Edit 2: Plus, among the many gems on Reddit — declaring this is a false flag by Trump to distract the public from his felony conviction/project 2025/the Epstein files/whatever; how it's oh-so-convenient that the shooter is dead; that this is just another example of how Trump "just attracts bad news", this is a symptom of "the rage he projects," that Trump "enabled this culture," and he's to blame for 'making politics dangerous in America'; that it's entirely understandable given that "people don't like pedophiles or rapists"; that if elected, Trump's going to use this as an excuse to silence the media 'exactly like Putin does'; how our priority must be stopping Trump from 'take his anger out on opponents'; how this is going to be our Reichstag Fire and we're about to become Nazi Germany 2.0; and so on, and so on, I'll specifically highlight this one in its (brief) entirety:

Amazing, the Republicans, who have developed a list of 350 political opponents that they believe should be incarcerated and/or put to death, and assert they have the right to be violent to achieve their goals of overthrowing our government, have the nerve to complain of political violence tonight. 😡

Edit 3: add in another proposed reason for it to be a "false flag" — so that Trump can drop out of the race without losing face:

He probably faked it so he can call off his campaign for being in fear for his life. Probably because we are coming too close to actually putting his criminal lying as in jail. I wouldn’t hold it past him for one second that he didn’t outright say to go ahead and shoot someone innocent to bring it all home.

In which sense? Is it a problem like Islamophobia was said to be a problem, or is it a problem like satanic panics or "pizzagate" conspiracies are a problem?

and are equally connected to their surrounding community

Except they're not equally connected to the surrounding community, and cannot be, because one of those connections — perhaps the most important connection — is ties of blood, of kinship. This is something I'd say most people in history, from ancient Athens to modern Dubai, have understood well. "Nation" and "state" are not synonyms, and their conflation by many modern people reduces our grasp on the relevant concept spaces.

it's about not capriciously punishing the kids

I think you're smuggling in an assumption here: that the kids in question in some sense deserve or are entitled to citizenship, such that it constitutes a "punishment" for them to be deprived of it. Does a club "punish" everyone to whom it fails to grant membership?

if no solution is implemented, then this is what people will resort to.

Not if you prohibit them from doing so, and consistently enforce this prohibition with serious punishments.

You cannot expect them to sit around for years waiting for enlightened technocrats to come up with the most humane remedies for societies' ills while they are harassed and threatened on a daily basis on the subway, going to a grocery store, or walking home.

Why not? What are they going to do about it? Particularly after anyone who decides not to just sit around gets prosecuted and sent to prison for decades pour encourager les autres.

By most accounts and metrics, we in modern Western nations live in the wealthiest, safest society ever. We have some of the broadest and strongest social "safety nets" in history, and lower inequality than most large societies of the past. Thus, the downsides to risk-taking are presumably the lowest ever; never has "the price of failure" been so low.

So, why then, do we seem to be some of the most risk-averse people ever? Why do we appear to be more terrified of failure than our ancestors who were one bad harvest away from starvation?

(I wonder about this, because it seems to me to be a factor in our modern allergy to authority, specifically how scared people seem to be at the idea of stepping up and taking charge of something.)

Why haven't we seen more political groups that meet the needs of disillusioned?

At least for the US, the primary reason here is Duverger's Law.

As for the former, I don't have any answers, and the only one I've ever seen proposed, I find somewhat implausible — that being that actual turnout has indeed declined, but growth in ballots fraudulently cast in the names of non-voting voters rise to compensate.

* The mods have asked me not to call it goatfucker patriarchy, so I won't.

That's a rather straightforward example of apophasis you've got there.

There's another suggestion I see mooted pretty often that isn't on your list: Michelle Obama. Mostly, that she's got name recognition, a lot of the same identity politics positives as Harris without some of the latter's particular negatives, and she's only 60. I'm not sure how plausible the argument for her as a candidate is though.

Another one I've seen raised a couple times, that I do think is rather implausible, but which I'll also include for completeness, is to replace Biden with Biden… that is, with Jill Biden. Besides the usual "first woman president" thing, the argument goes that, as she's clearly one of the main people actually making the decisions and running things, she can run on this "job experience."

Exactly the same point I keep making as well.

Yes but Rousseau seems to be entirely incorrect.

I agree, but it doesn't stop people from invoking concepts from his work… or, more specifically, Jacobin-derived interpretations thereof.

The General will is simply not available to us at this scale.

Here, the people I've read break from Rousseau, in that it's not the simple peasants who identify the common good. Instead, it is only elite technocratic experts who have the right mix of talent and education to work out the correct choices, and it is by "deliberation in small groups" of these rare people that the General Will can be divined. And thus, "democracy" is when these experts become the intellectual vanguard of the ruling elite, and the greatest threat to "democracy" is the "populist" who would unseat them by appealing to the superstitions and prejudices of the less-enlightened masses.

We're a representative democracy, and the elected officials are to represent the people. Well, to quote from a previous comment of mine:

…consider individuals who need a “representative” to act on their behalf. Children, the senile, the mentally ill, and so on. What makes a parent, a legal guardian, a representative with “power of attorney,” a good representative? Well, one who acts to their own personal benefit, to the expense of the person they’re representing — one who embezzles funds, for example — is definitely a bad one. This is analogous to the “non-democratic elites” outlined above

But consider the opposite end. I’m reminded here of Bill Cosby’s “chocolate cake for breakfast” stand-up routine. If your kids answer the question of what they want for breakfast with chocolate cake, should you give them what they want? If a schizophrenic wants a doctor to open up their skull and remove the CIA mind-control chip beaming thoughts into their head, does a good guardian start looking for a brain surgeon?

No, a good representative acts in the best interest of the person they represent. A good representative respects their clients wishes… so long as it isn’t against their best interests. Here, the analogy to the overly-permissive parent or guardian is the sort of politician people like the essayist denounce as a “populist” (with or without the “authoritarian” modifier), and you or I might call genuinely democratic. Someone who enacts the popular will — which, per Rousseau, is just another “particular will” — instead of the “general will”. (As I once saw it put, the difference is that the “popular will” is the will of The People (plural) while the “general will” is the will of The People (singular).)

Note that there’s not a strict binary. It’s not “let your kids have chocolate cake or ice cream for breakfast” vs. “you dictate entirely what your kids will have for every meal, they get no choice at all.” You can let them pick which breakfast cereal they might want, or between pancakes and waffles, between oatmeal or French toast, and so on. You can give them a constrained choice among a menu of acceptable meal choices. Even an institutionalized schizophrenic, or an elderly person with senile dementia, has rights to some measure of choice around their activities, circumstances, treatment, and so on; but only when it’s not counter to their own best interests.

Hence, a “stage managed” “defensive democracy” with a strictly limited menu of choices for an electorate who, between public choice theory “rational ignorance” and Marxist “false consciousness”, don’t always know what’s in their own best interest, nor which potential representative is most skilled at determining what that societal best interest is.

Generally, it seems to me like many have come to hold two apparently contradictory propositions:

  1. Liberal democracy is the only legitimate form of government. Our governments are democracies, and it is from this that they draw their legitimacy.

  2. The masses are too ignorant, misinformed, bigoted, and superstitious to generally know what's in their own best interest; nor to determine which potential representative would be most skilled at determining what that societal best interest is; and thus the government cannot afford to allow their input much weight on how it governs them.

One way to square these is to simply ditch #1 — this is the Moldbug "formalist" position. Tell people our "Brahmin/Elf" elite caste are legitimate rulers not because of "consent of the governed," but because they're literally the only people with the smarts and know-how to be capable of governing a complex modern society.

Of course, this runs against centuries of deeply-ingrained cultural mythology, particularly in the US. I mean, we're coming up on the 4th of July. Freedom, democracy, the Founding Fathers standing up to King George, et cetera. Many wouldn't take such an ideological u-turn very well (hence Yarvin's cryptographic weapon locks, VR, and so on).

But then, we notice that #1 and #2 are only actually incompatible if we define "democracy" in #1 to mean something that includes "the masses having significant input on how they are governed." And, like Carroll's Humpty-Dumpty noted, definitions are flexible; modern academia has made an artform of playing games with the definitions of words. Thus, one can resolve the paradox by adopting a definition of "democracy" wherein the influence of the electorate plays little role, a “stage managed” “defensive democracy” where the voters are free to choose… among a strictly-limited menu of elite-acceptable choices. And if you look at the methodologies used by many of the "democracy indices" that purport to measure how "democratic" various countries are, you'll see something that puts a lot more weight on 'does it have these various things left-leaning technocrats like?' and less on 'how responsive to the electorate is it?'

In short, we're definitely still a democracy… where "democracy" means whatever our unaccountable elites say it does.

We’ve had bad kings before.

Sure, but how much more power did the monarch wield back then?

It really isn't. Democracy is about letting people have a say. They may be wrong, they may vote for candidates I think are stupid. They may hold ideas I think are harmful. But democracy isn't about making the best decisions. There is no wisdom of crowds in this situation. Thats not why democracy is good.

That's one way of defining democracy. But it's very different from the Rousseauan view (particularly the Jacobin variety), wherein "democracy" becomes about government acting in accord with Rousseau's "General Will" — which is not the same thing as the will of the majority. As you note, the latter can be wrong, while the former is always correct by definition.

Competence at the top of a ticket should pale in comparison to competence as President.

What constitutes "competence" for a president? How much does he need? How much "competence" does King Charles III need to do his job?

and that thing is that Biden maybe shouldn't continue to serve in the current moment

Why not? He seems to be doing his job quite well — said job being a powerless figurehead while the unelected "deep state" permanent bureaucracy does all the actual governing.

This unavoidable truth has likely doomed Biden's 2024 campaign.

I see people saying this, but I don't see it. I don't get why this really makes much of a difference; many of the scenarios I see circulated and speculated about in many of the other places I frequent are of the sort that won't be affected by this.

However, it has likely also struck a crippling blow against the Democrat Party's primary value proposition: "Democracy."

Except, as I've noted before, many on that side tend to define "Democracy" rather differently than what you imply. The people voting for whatever representative they want — whether approved by elites or not — is "populism," which is the greatest threat to Our Democracy; "Democracy" meaning rule by an intellectual vanguard party of elite technocrats who are the only people with the smarts to enact the Rousseauan "general will," which is what the masses would vote for were they all properly educated and enlightened enough to know what's truly good for them, instead of being loaded down with ignorant bigots and bitter clingers, vulnerable to exploitation by the next Hitlerian populist demagogue.

But, according to the Democrats, being forced to vote for an unnamed, unelected cabal of unaccountable lobbyists, bureaucrats, and special interests is no vote at all.

Do you have a citation for this, because I've only seen the reverse — people on the left arguing that "being forced to vote for an unnamed, unelected cabal of unaccountable lobbyists, bureaucrats, and special interests" is the very definition of Democracy.

The Democrat's only argument is that "if we don't run the country anti-democratically, it will be the end of Democracy!"

Yes, which, via redefinitions of "Democracy" along the lines of places ranging from Germany to Ukraine to China, will work just fine — because "if we don't run the country anti-democratically insulated from people who vote wrong, it will be the end of Democracy rule by those who know best."

(I can't find it via a quick search, but I remember back in 2016 over at the subreddit linking to a professor who argued for stripping the franchise from Trump voters, on the grounds that it's legitimate — the right thing for democracy, even — to remove the vote from those who've demonstrated that they will misuse it by supporting an unacceptable candidate.)

Again, we saw once and for allwhat happens when you let the people vote for whoever they want — instead of from a carefully-curated menu of elite-acceptable figureheads for the "unnamed, unelected cabal of unaccountable lobbyists, bureaucrats, and special interests" — and let said representatives have actual power… in 1930s Germany. "Never again" means never again.

It will be a genuinely hilarious day if at some point Christianity, the religion of widows and orphans

It is also the religion of Charles the Hammer and Arnaud Amalric. The religion of Crusaders and Conquistadors. The religion of King Olaf II of Norway, whose warring, conquest, and being 'inclined to violence and brutality" didn't prevent Pope Alexander III from officially recognizing his (earlier) local canonization as Saint Olaf.

You can't just kick out everyone who prays the rosary, because then you'd have to shut down almost every parish in the diocese.

And why is that a problem?

Closing or merging parishes massively upsets people.

So what? Let them be upset. Extra Ecclesiam nulla salus. They can suck it up, or they can choose to leave the One True Church, and thereby condemn themselves to eternal hellfire.

The ruling class's morals either don't incorporate the available evidence (i.e. are unscientific), don't follow from logical reasoning (i.e. are inconsistent), or start from different principles.

So what? They're still the ruling class despite this, which means they get to make the rules, not the rationalists. Having "reasonable moral principles and following logical reasoning using the available evidence" on your side matters little compared to having power on your side.

I think the most parsimonious explanation is that the ruling class uses morals as tools, and chooses the set of morals that get them what they want.

Yes, and so what? The lords are the lords — and the peasants are the peasants — all the same.

It's reasonable to criticize the ruling class on these grounds

Sure, but don't expect to escape the consequences of criticizing those who rule you, valid criticism or not. In the real world, the kid pointing out the emperor is naked doesn't get the crowd all agreeing with him, he gets executed (probably along with his parents) for lèse-majesté and treason, and everyone else doubles down on praising the beauty and refinement of His Majesty's raiment.

and to think it unjust that people are punished for advocating for a less selfish set of morals.

You can think it unjust all you want, but it's what the powerful think is "just" that matters.

Can anyone explain to me what this image is supposed to be about?

for priests below the age of 47 social conservatism is the norm.

The norm, but not universal. There've got to be at least some liberal priests among the younger generation. So then, just kick out enough of the young conservatives out of the Catholic church so that those liberals become the majority of those left.

The Catholic church is going to lurch to the right. Well over 70% of Catholic priests ordained in the US during the past 14 years are conservative or very conservative/orthodox.

Couldn't a left-leaning pope prevent such a rightward "lurch"? Maybe by such means as, for example, picking the more notable of the "very conservative/orthodox" priests and having them defrocked and excommunicated from the church pour encourager les autres?

This is of course retarded and will lead to populists who end emissions regulations getting elected.

Not if they ensure all such populists are excluded from the ballot.

This is really interesting to me because it's rare to see somebody openly work from a foundation that social harmony is of higher moral value than truth.

I had a therapist who strongly believed this, and considered having anything other than "fitting in" with one's peer group as highest priority in determining one's beliefs to itself constitute some manner of psychological disorder. Her go-to defense for any view was to cite its popularity, and even more so her go-to criticism of a position is that it's "unpopular" or "weird." She was a firm believer in vox populi, vox Dei, and when I pointed out that this was the framework of her arguments and that I, as a monarchist, rejected it utterly, she was completely at a loss. I mean, stunned silence for quite a noticeable length. It seemed so deeply imbedded in her worldview, so base an assumption, that she didn't seem to know how to respond to having it so bluntly challenged.

(I'm also once reminded of a blog comment exchange — I think it was pre-disqus The American Conservative — involving the Japanese honne/tatemae distinction, that also included something like a defense of "social harmony over truth." Though, there the argument was that Westerners have an "overly simplistic" and "narrow" view of what "truth" is, thanks mostly to Plato (this is the main part that made this exchange memorable), and thus fail to grasp that "social consensus" is "truth," just as much as personal understanding of the facts is also "truth," they're just different kinds of truth. Needless to say, most everyone else commenting at TAC disagreed with this view.)

Per your second paragraph, on the sci-fi end, this is why I think DS9 was one of the best Star Trek series — the stationary setting, longer story arcs, and (particularly in later seasons) less reliance on Negative Space Wedgie or Strange New Life of the Week stories (though there's still quite a bit) allowed it to get further away from the "planet of hats." We get Bajoran political and religious disputes, Ferengi feminists, Cardassian dissidents of various stripes, and even a Klingon restauranteur who played a concertina-like instrument as he serenaded his customers. And as for D&D specifically, this isn't nearly the issue that some critics make it out to be, as Samueldays touches on in his reply to that Tumblr post.