@Capital_Room's banner p

Capital_Room

rather dementor-like

0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2023 September 18 03:13:26 UTC

Disabled Alaskan Monarchist doomer


				

User ID: 2666

Capital_Room

rather dementor-like

0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2023 September 18 03:13:26 UTC

					

Disabled Alaskan Monarchist doomer


					

User ID: 2666

When every single nominee you got is going to be pilloried as Literally Hitler, unless they're so obviously hopeless they don't stand a chance, what do you go? Who do you go with?

I've seen some argue that the answer to this is "someone who actually is Literally Hitler?" In the tale of the boy who cried "wolf," eventually a wolf arrived.

Of course, there appears to be a dearth of notable would-be wolves.

In any case, given the nature of our system, the parties, and the available candidates, I simply don't see how you "stop playing the gentlemanly loser game" without, at a minimum, abandoning electoral politics altogether.

I believe that where this regime is taking us is evil, and inhumane, possibly also unsustainable...

Agreed — particularly on the unsustainable, at least in the very long term.

But where I differ is that it doesn't matter how much you or I or anyone else "don't wanna go there," there's nothing we can do about it. It's inevitable. So what does convincing people that the establishment is "illegitimate" matter? What difference can it possibly make?

[ASOIAF exerpt]

Arguing from fictional evidence (and not very good, at that).

Sometimes you need to fight even if you lose.

Not if losing is guaranteed. An unwinnable battle is never worth fighting.

I don't believe that what the powers that be want is particularly sustainable

Sure, but I think there's enough civilizational "seed corn" for it to consume to keep it going longer than the rest of us can hold out (which is why I also expect them to take out industrial civilization with them when they go — permanently, given that an industrial revolution is a once-per-planet event).

Surely, though, you can see why there would want to be a façade over this reality.

Not really.

There has to be an attempt at showing that the government is doing things to improve the lives of the people it rules.

Perhaps, but not that much of one, I'd say. What do you suppose the average 3rd Century BC Chinese peasant felt about what Qin Shi Huangdi was doing to improve his life (imposing an infamously-harsh legal code and conscripting him to start building the impressive-but-useless boondoggle known as the Great Wall)? What sort of "carrot" was dangled before the average Neo-Assyrian subject during the reign of Ashurbanipal?

The point of the "stationary bandit model" is that the stationary bandit is, by his nature as such, preferable to the mobile bandit. The primary "carrot" for most regimes has been protection from said mobile bandits, and that looks to have been enough for the majority of recorded history.

When it comes for "improv[ing] the lives of the people," you don't have to be all that great, you just have to be better, in the eyes of enough people, than Lord Humungus.

I'm still convinced that his win in 2016 was mostly driven by the populace trying to signal this: "more carrots, or else".

And the elite reply, near as I can tell, continues to be "no carrots for you, and what 'or else,' anyway?"

I'd say that last is the real question. Or else what, exactly?

convince people that the establishment is illegitimate

Why? What is "legitimacy," anyway? The difference between "Don Corleone" and "King Vito I" isn't that one has "legitimacy" and the other doesn't, it's whether or not there's a bigger, stronger "stationary bandit." Whatever group can most credibly tell you "follow this rule or I hurt you" is the government (and that's what "government" simply is).

I wish I could remember where I encountered the argument that Westerners deeply misunderstand the "Mandate of Heaven," mistaking it for a Chinese "divine right of kings" when it's really a much more materialist concept. That what it really means is that "legitimacy" follows from — is a product of — the de facto exercise of imperial power. Whoever most performs the functions of government (however badly) is the government (until someone else is actually doing it better).

and we need to build alternatives.

…but what makes you think this is possible? Both in terms of the forces in opposition, and the qualities of the people in question?

Assuming everyone returns home according to the plan

How likely do you think that is to actually happen? And failing that, how do you prevent this single-state solution from undergoing Dan Carlin's "conquest via democracy"?

The closest is probably the eastern euro countries where public homosexuality has legal restrictions(eg no pride parades, can’t be out to minors) but there are no sodomy laws.

That seems to be the position of most of the "conservative" sorts I know IRL. As one crudely but pithily summarized it: "I don't care if you're gay, just don't be a fag about it."

But infertile opposite-sex couples could always get married...?

I have a pet analogy I've been using for over a decade on this point, and I recently encountered a term that helps better encapsulate what said analogy is gesturing toward: "ordered toward"

Consider hand grenades. Then consider a movie prop "grenade" that looks like the real thing, but isn't. The law treats those two things very differently, and for a clear and obvious reason: real grenades explode, fake movie props don't.

But, one might argue, some subset of "real" grenades are "duds": due to manufacturing defects, the effects of time, or whatever, don't explode when you release the spoon. But the law makes no effort to carefully identify and separate out the duds, to be classed with the movie props as "non-explosive" — instead, it classifies them with the fully-functional grenades. Therefore, the law can't actually be about "explosive vs. non-explosive," and the line drawn between real and movie-prop grenades is illegitimate and should be removed.

Of course, most people would likely reject this argument. The key is precisely the phrase I spoke of before: ordered toward. A real grenade is ordered toward exploding — even if, thanks to our living in an imperfect, entropic universe, some subset fall short of that purpose — while a movie prop is not ordered toward exploding. For a "dud" grenade, the "non-explosiveness" is incidental, accidental. For the look-alike movie prop, the non-explosiveness is inherent.

In short, this is an argument that teleology can constitute a valid "joint" upon which reality may be "cleaved," particularly when it comes to law.

(It continues to dismay me how many secular people firmly accept the creationist philosophical principle that "purpose" requires a conscious purpose-giver, when an important element of the theory of evolution by natural selection is that it provides an explanation of how an undirected, atelic process can produced directed, telic entities. The usual rejoinder people make, when I argue this, is to conflate the process of natural selection with the products of natural selection; which, as I like to say, is like confusing tennis shoes with a tennis shoe factory.)

Polygamy has always been odious among the northern and western nations of Europe, and, until the establishment of the Mormon Church, was almost exclusively a feature of the life of Asiatic and of African people. At common law, the second marriage was always void, and from the earliest history of England polygamy has been treated as an offence against society....

–Chief Justice Morrison Waite, in the US Supreme Court's decision in Reynolds v. United States

(Now try to imagine a modern Supreme Court decision making this sort of 'this just isn't done in our culture' argument in a decision.)

Jailing him before the election is suicidal,

How so? I'm not so sure about it increasing Trump's chances of winning — I'm from Alaska; I remember what happened with Ted Stevens, and that was a much more egregious case of patent railroading.

And, indeed having him win from in jail would indeed be a problem for the establishment, but what then comes to my mind is the case of Tsar Nicholas II.

I don't know what analogous options Linux and MacOS have.

At least with a standard MacOS keyboard setup, "option" key + "-" gives you en dash: –, and "shift"+"option"+"-" gives you em dash: —.

Previous posts on the Dutch election can be found here and here.

You seem to be missing your links here.

It seems like your big mental hurdle is this dogmatic assertion that a Republican president couldn't find even one DC cop to escort an uncooperative bureaucrat out of the office.

Well, suppose he does find a few. Then those few guys get outnumbered and outgunned by the FBI, who arrest them for the Federal crime of interfering with a Federal official — the aforementioned uncooperative bureaucrat — in the course of his duties. Because that's what it's called when you try to forcibly drag a non-fired Federal employee out of what is still his place of work.

I'm not sure if you've noticed, but there aren't any more peasants in the world and the regimes you're describing have in fact fallen over and collapsed.

That was because of those collapses were all in the Age of the Gun. Many writers have noted the correlation between whether a society, at a given time, is more "aristocratic" or "democratic," and whether its methods of war-fighting are more capital-intensive or labor-intensive, respectively.

I remember once reading a legal paper on the 2nd Amendment, specifically the debate as to whether it's about a right of the people to own civilian weapons for hunting/personal defense, or a right of the people to have the means to overthrow a tyrannical government, with both views finding support in the writings of the Founders. The author's position was that the Founders clearly meant for it to do both, because they lived in a time when the means of meeting both goals pretty much overlapped — "civilian" guns were also useful as weapons of war, the weapons of war were broadly affordable, and it did not take much time or money to turn a "militia" of ordinary civilian riflemen into an effective war-fighting force. Hence, why they thought we could do without a standing military, relying entirely upon the general citizenry for national defense. But, the author then noted, changes in military technology over the centuries mean that no longer holds. The modern "tip of the spear" soldier is an expensive, well-equipped, highly-trained elite. Our jurisprudence has, in practice, favored the "personal defense" goal/interpretation of 2Am over the other… because it's the only one that's remotely practical in our present world. The Age of the Gun was already on its way out during the First World War. (Hence, why you get people arguing that we're now entering the Age of the Drone, with drone operators as the "new knights.") It's been slow, and papered over by various illusions, but over the last century, we've all been becoming peasants again.

lose legitimacy in the eyes of the military.

What makes you think they would?

they'd engender too much resistance.

What form do you picture this "resistance" taking, and why wouldn't those who engage in it not end up arrested for said crimes (or, at the extreme, meeting a Waco/Ruby Ridge fate)?

Donald Trump.

Even if he somehow gets elected, Donald Trump will be even less effective in his second term than his first, because they're not being taken by surprise this time, and they've been preparing to more effectively #Resist him — or any other GOP president.

The "powers" of the president are all dependent on having large numbers of people in DC enforce his decisions and orders. If they all simply don't…

Stern Gang and Lehi managed to achieve their goals despite not being part of the elite.

They might not have been elite, but they had people who were part of the elite in agreement with those goals — if they didn't, they'd never have won. This is a point Boot makes about guerrilla warfare in Invisible Armies; one of the necessary (but not sufficient) conditions for a guerrilla force to win is for some portion of the "elites" on the other side to sympathize with them. I'd argue that the only reason the American Revolution succeeded is because too many on the British side, like Burke (and, I would argue, the Howe brothers) were sympathetic to the American side.

Again, it only works when it provides some portion of the elite an excuse to do what they want anyway.

and their strategies to neuter his political effectiveness won't work a second time.

Why not?

How long did the Roman republic last after they were forced to assassinate Caesar?

Trump is not our Julius Caesar. At best, he's the Gracchi brothers. And just who is our Augustus, then?

There's a very real way in which losing legitimacy and perceived respect damages the authority of a governing elite, and that authority is required for the elites to maintain power.

How so? All you need to maintain power is sufficient ability to punish disobedience, so as to sufficiently incentivize compliance. How did feudal nobles maintain power over vastly more numerous serfs? (See the German Peasants' War.) How much "perceived respect" did beaten-down eastern European serfs really have for their overlords?

Have you read up on any of the historical analogues to the current system?

Which historical incidents do you think are analogous to our current situation? Because I think the historical analogies are things like the Stellinga, late 10th century Norman peasants —

Peasant leaders who brought complaints to the regent Rodulf of Ivry had their hands and feet cut off, after they were captured.[2][3] Others were blinded, impaled, or burnt alive, land owners forfeited their land.[5]: 51

— the Jacquerie, the Merfold brothers, Carinthian peasants, the Bundschuh movement(s), the "Poor Conrad" leagues, Turkish Celali, or any number of other situations on Wikipedia's "List of peasant revolts" where the result box is red and reads "Suppression of the rebellion."

When some 300,000 or so angry German peasants rose up in "Europe's largest and most widespread popular uprising before the French Revolution of 1789," did the aristocracy attempt to win back the peasants' "trust" and "respect"? No, they sent out 6,000–8,500 knights and mercenaries to suppress the peasants, killing a third of them (while themselves taking "minimal" losses), and after the rebellion was crushed, they "restored the old order in a frequently harsher form" and cracked down on the peasants even harder, leading to "a reduction of rights and freedoms of the peasant class, pushing them out of political life."

Decreasing their own credibility

Again, the only "credibility" they need is the ability to credibly threaten punishment for those who disobey them.

increasing support for opposition figures

What opposition figures are there that they need possibly worry about?

ineffective and counterproductive forms of political activism.

They don't need political activism, and as various people (including Curtis Yarvin) have pointed out, modern "political activism" is a sham that only "works" when it serves to provide the elites a pretext to do something they already wanted to do anyway.

but even posting your extremely well justified advice on winning elections

Again, I see them not caring about winning elections, and take this as evidence that they don't need to win elections, that losing elections does little-to-nothing to their power, and that elections don't matter. Why don't you?

They don't need elections or "activism." They have all the power they need via their control of the institutions, first and foremost the massive Permanent Bureaucracy in DC, which is now fully insulated from any mechanism of "democratic" control.

They act like they don't have to worry about losing their power because they can't lose their power. They are so powerful, nobody on Earth can stop them.

Painting someone's house is unmistakably a normal job, but if your boss demanded that you paint his house, that would be inappropriate.

Counterpoint: my maintenance man dad has done quite a bit of (paid) work on his boss's house. And, contra ControlsFreak's point about

Your boss is often also an employee of the company that is employing you. You're being paid to do work for the company, not for your boss.

my dad's boss is a small landlord — a guy who owns several buildings — and it's a "sole proprietorship"-type thing. His boss is the company. (Is there really that much of a difference, in this particular case, between "fix what needs fixing on this apartment building your boss owns," "fix what needs fixing on this house your boss owns and intends to 'flip' after it's fixed up," and "fix what needs fixing on this house your boss owns and happens to live in"?)

people realise that Academia has transformed into a left-wing advocacy group rather than serving its original function

So what if people realize this, so long as they still need the credential Academia issues to get hired?

People were willing to listen to experts when they believed they were getting expertise, but that imprimatur of authority and trust was too tempting a target for political activists.

So what if the ordinary people no longer trust or listen to “experts” — so long as the elites continue to listen, they can in turn use their power to force ordinary people to obey “expert opinion” whether they “trust” it or not.

They're going to see that they're hurting both their own institution and the cause of the left more broadly

Except, how are they actually hurting it?

It sounds insulting when phrased like that, but you can just go and read them talking about how they're going to keep doing it even though it has a negative political outcome for their own team!

I don’t see how people can look at how these folks keep doing things that hurt their electoral position, and not see that as evidence that elections don’t matter. These people aren’t (all) blind or stupid. Why assume that they’re missing what’s obvious to you, rather than taking it as evidence that they know something you don’t?

I have a pet analogy I like to use. Suppose I see a nice black car with tinted windows run a red light… right past a cop car. I then think “how blind must that driver have been, to have missed that obvious cop car.” Only, as the cop car first turns to pursue, then drops that pursuit, it becomes clear that the driver probably knew about the cop, and that I’m the one who missed something, the very thing the cop came to see: the diplomatic license plates, indicating the vehicle is covered by the Vienna Protocols and diplomatic immunity, and the cop can’t ticket its driver no matter how he violated the traffic laws.

Again, if these people don’t care about hurting their electoral chances, maybe they have a reason not to care.

I'd basically interpret a belief system that concludes, after looking realistically at things, that children are a net negative as self-centered hedonism.

Not necessarily; there's the pessimistic anti-humanism of more philosophical antinatalism, wherein children are also a net negative to themselves.

Trump goes to ICE and says, "Some fucking lefties at EPA who want to take your big ass trucks from you need to be taught a lesson, and I'm giving you the authority to take over security at EPA." Do you think that some rednecks from ICE will "obey"?

Obey Trump? No. Because while the rank and file might be "rednecks," they're going to do what their immediate supervisor back in the office tells them, and that guy's another Lefty permanent bureaucrat.

I wish I remember where it was, but I recall about a year or so ago, reading a bit on a "2nd Amendment" forum, where the usual narrative on "door-to-door confiscation" — that "they" can't get the people needed to do it because the cops are 1. on our side and/or 2. too afraid of getting shot, and thus won't do it even if ordered — was raised, and a Chicago cop chimed in to disagree. If "his boss" tells him to go door-to-door taking people's guns? He'll do it, no matter his personal opinion on the 2nd Amendment, because he has kids, and a mortgage, and his pension to think about, and what would happen to you at your work if you told your immediate supervisor that you weren't going to obey an explicit order from him? And besides, the people he'd be confiscating the guns from skew old and law-abiding, and he's patrolled some of Chicago's worst neighborhoods, so he'd rather be doing the door-to-door confiscation over returning to the latter, because he's probably less likely to be shot.

The rank and file guy is going to put concern for his [Gollum voice]precious pension[/Gollum voice] over abstract political principles and a distant (and questionable) authority. "The mountains are high, and the Emperor is far away." Your immediate superior has a lot more power over your job and your pension than a distant, embattled, GOP president. In this scenario, they might as well be meat robots.

And the supervisor at ICE will point out that he has no authority to arrest the EPA guys even if they were doing something wrong — which he doesn't think they are — and so he's not going to issue illegal orders to obstruct Federal employees in performance of their duties, in response to illegal orders from a would-be dictator.

So no, I don't think "current lowest cost contract security at the EPA" will physically fight them, or anyone else, because nobody will be coming.

It doesn't matter who Trump (or DeSantis, or any other Republican president) orders to enforce his attempts to remove the disobedient bureaucracy — FBI, ICE, or anyone else, none of them will obey. Not one. The "separate agencies" are all one big, singular machine, in lockstep, and not one part of it will turn against the rest on orders of a Republican.

Thank you.

As I recently said elsewhere online: I recall reading somewhere that growing up with the internet has changed how younger generations remember things. That is, instead of remembering some specific piece of information itself, they instead remember the path to look up/retrieve such information. I, however, am definitely part of the older generations, then. I read a lot of stuff, online and offline, and while I can remember a lot of facts and details I’ve read, I don’t so much remember just where or when I read them. Thus all my “ I recall reading somewhere.”

Which isn't great for my participation in the link-and-citation heavy argumentation one finds here.

This is an important point. When you're part of an elite that has captured the institutions, then your rise can be very disconnected from your performance. Ursula von der Leyen was caught plagiarising her PhD, she was a failure as German Ministry of Defence, and thus became President of Europe.

Yet she was born to parents in the first Brussels elites, attended the right educational establishments, and she was skilled at being an ostensibly conservative politician who did/said what the German centre-left wanted.

Yeah, and then people try to tell me that "modern democracy" has made such great strides away from the bad old aristocratic past.

Again, I'm not so much saying we need to change the system so much as we need to stop lying about the system we already have.

means the right very much will feel locked out of the Federal government entirely

Why shouldn't we feel that way, given that we pretty much are locked out? And even if we do start realizing that, so what?

when they very much shouldn't be

Shouldn't be locked out, or shouldn't be feeling locked out? This reads unclearly to me. And in either case, why not? Why shouldn't the Left do everything they can to lock their hated enemy out of every institution, every power center, every decision-making process?

What reason does a stronger party have not to crush utterly their weaker foe?

And so what happens if more and more of the population stops accepting the authority of those various institutions?

The institutions reassert their authority by cracking down, making showy examples of people, and changing people's incentives toward compliance as needed.

There is no endpoint where the bifurcations sharpens much further, and meaningful consent of the governed somehow remains.

Which is why, to the (debatable) extent "consent of the governed" ever existed, it will be removed. Most of the history of large, settled societies has been a tiny elite ruling over a vast body of disenfranchised, ground-down peasants. I see no reason why our current society could not be run the same (to the extent it isn't already there).

All true, but there's no obvious mechanism from here to there.

What was the mechanism by which William and his fellow Normans ruled the Anglo-Saxons? How did any Chinese emperor rule a realm as large and populous as China? How did the East India Company end up with power over the subcontinent? How did the Romans successfully suppress revolt after revolt against their rule for century after century?

We've already seen the current Supreme Court take a wrecking ball to topics of abortion and affirmative action.

I would dispute this characterization of these decisions. Dobbs was a purely symbolic victory; one where there were plenty of legal minds on the other side who, even though they agreed with Roe's outcome, thought it was on shaky ground as a legal ruling; and which has had negligible effect on actual abortion rates. And I remember when the affirmative action decision came out, people were already pointing out how schools in California have been straightforwardly bypassing the similar state-level restriction with 'totally-not-a-quota "holistic admissions,"' and that the majority decision itself lays out the start of a path for academia to essentially ignore it. These are more a feather duster than a wrecking ball.

leads to partisan conservatives in the Supreme Court taking a sledge hammer to the foundation of some of those institutions.

How, exactly? What means does the Court have to enforce any decision it might make against them?

think pieces about the Chevron doctrine in particular recently, and the potential damage the court could do to the entire unelected federal bureaucracy and its power if that doctrine is significantly revised.

Again, I don't see how that could work.

I expect that pillarization eventually fixes this.

How? Pillarization requires a relatively neutral central power that allows multiple parallel institutions to keep existing.

but among a big chunk of society Christendom College will have the same effect

How so — assuming said school even remains open and accredited? One gives you a whole bunch of employment options and elite connections, the other is a useless piece of paper no employer will respect (for fear of getting sued, if nothing else).

Something with which my parents are dealing with respect to their plans to build their retirement home on our place out in the Bush, exacerbated by the issues that permafrost — and the assorted inspections, regulations, effects on the water table, et cetera — adds to things.

They backed up even my silliest teachers.

Yeah, my parents definitely didn't do that. I heard all about my mother's ongoing struggle with teachers and the ASD's administration over my education since preschool, and by 4th grade, I'd already corrected my teachers too many times on math and science mistakes to assume competence. I vividly remember a junior high vice-principal telling me outright I had "no business being that smart," and if he could, he'd've had me denied access to math or science classes until my age-peers could "catch up." I had a teacher tell me to 'quit pointing out that you're smarter than me.'

(Well, it also didn't help that my mom, even now, describes her late mother to people by starting with "remember the meanest teacher you had in school." This was a woman who taught Special Ed primarily because learning-disabled kids are easier to bully.)

My brothers and I also got our own version of "the Talk" about police, and to always be perfectly compliant and deferential to them… because they are all trigger-happy petty tyrants who will go out of their way to wreck your life if they think you don't respect their authoritah.

My parents are also fond of that Reagan quote our education secretary tried to turn on its head. "Government is simply the name we give to the things we choose to do together." Bullshit. Government is not "us," government is "them." Government is that asshole up in the castle sending the Sheriff of Nottingham out to squeeze you dry.

adults were basically competent until proven otherwise, which was the correct assumption given my social milieu.

Perhaps this comes down to me growing up at the bottom edge of the working class — materially poorer than the neighbors on government handouts. Did you ever have to hunker down in an apartment bathtub at age seven or so with your brothers because it was the safest place from a stray bullet, waiting for the gunshots to stop?