CommittedToTheG
No bio...
User ID: 3371
Like MadMonzer says below, I think it's more that quokka Christians and quokka Leftists both want to deny aspects of evolution to justify a moral approach that fits their quokka nature. I agree that the post-Christian Right tends to despise both and sees ideas about "the moral equivalence of humans" as fatal flaws in both Christianity and Leftism. I do not endorse those sentiments myself.
In general, I wonder how many spaces are truly open to free inquiry. I had a conversation with someone who expressed frustration that fellow Christians did not respond positively when he questioned the Trinity and other basic dogmas (instead of properly reading the subtext and commiserating, I autistically tried to explain the phenomenon). This same person then turned around and got quite upset when modern narratives about the continued relevance of actions taken during WWII were JAQed in a similar way, proving that in some areas, at least, he was not himself a high decoupler. People live in stories and are not happy when their sacred narratives are threatened (and arguments tend to be soldiers, so they are often rightfully suspicious). I do think that Christianity is ultimately quite compatible with all forms of truth and truth seeking, even if most Christians are not empirical saints, same as the vast majority of people. We need a healthy minority of empirical saints, but faithful people who live in the Christian story and embody Christ are the heart of the faith.
I agree, many Christians instinctively reject modernity's use of evolution as a cosmology (and are right to do so). The Christian cosmology is given in Genesis and takes the form of an Ancient Near East creation myth, not a historical account written with the purpose of giving the curious a scientific understanding of the origins of the universe.
Pretty sure he's saying that mainstream Science-believing culture has a blank-slatist view of humans that gets stubbornly defended in a way that borders on science denial, analogous to the way YECs defend their beliefs. Plenty of quokka types are either true believers (trusting The Science) or keep their mouths shut (like Scott did for a long time).
All reasonable, thanks for sharing.
I think the main thing about embryo selection that currently conflicts with church teaching is that some fertilized embryos are discarded in the process. Then down the line you have sex becoming decoupled from reproduction, etc.
I think something less “wasteful” could be accepted by the church (I am Eastern Orthodox, and I think our current stance is that IVF is allowed but you have to do one embryo at a time, so selection is out), which is partly why I mentioned advances that would make some of this less invasive (something like gene editing in the womb to eliminate genetic disease seems fine). But that’s all short term stuff. Down the line I’m not sure what it will mean for humanity to have the power to shape itself in a direct way (as opposed to through the “natural” ways this tends to happen). In an advanced enough future you could decouple sex from sexual pleasure, decouple sexual pleasure from attraction to other people, make humans asexual, make humans totally monogamous… lots of options here and it’s not clear what we “should” do with this power.
Though I have thought fairly optimistically about how the future might offer more opportunities to consciously remove one’s vices. In the same way Ozempic made being overweight more of a direct choice, you could imagine similar technologies that allow someone to make a direct decision to remove almost any negative pattern of behavior.
Enormous opportunities for good, but also enormous opportunity for evil (as with every advance that increases the power of humanity). Whose image will we ultimately optimize ourselves in, I wonder? Everyone doing the “best” for them and theirs can destroy a commons real quick.
As a traditional Christian, I instinctively recoil from some of this, so I’m open to the possibility that my biases are not helpful here. Thy kingdom come, Thy will be done, I suppose.
How do you see this as a Catholic? (albeit a fairly idiosyncratic one, from what I’ve picked up) What makes you optimistic and how do you fit this in with the church’s teachings?
It’s an interesting counterfactual to consider… The Soviets had already begun to taboo eugenics before the Nazis rose to power (and ended up tabooing the whole field of hereditarian genetics), so I think that biological realist principles are just not very compatible with egalitarianism in general and would have always come into conflict with universal rights and modern notions of equality.
I agree that without the Nazis the First World could probably have kept eugenics (and the associated race realism) from becoming totally taboo the way it has been for the last 80 years. But the US, at least, would still have had the legacy of slavery and the Civil War and then the pressures that led to the Civil Rights Movement to deal with. And the rise of knowledge work and meritocracy means that intelligence has become more important than ever for determining who can accrue money and status. It’s hard for people to accept that their tribal identity might be one that is fated to be on the bottom for the foreseeable future and that their lack of relative success is fair.
Also, like you pointed out, it’s only in the last few decades that we have begun to have the understanding of genetics and the beginnings of the technology that might make eugenics work for the masses, so it wasn’t that much of a sacrifice for free market nations to taboo it in the past. They gained more of a competitive advantage from leaning into capitalism and individual freedoms than they stood to gain from trying to shape genetics they didn’t really understand. Nazi central planning and authoritarianism could have put in place a sweeping selective breeding program, but returns that might have allowed them to theoretically gain an advantage over the USSR and / or the capitalist nations would have taken generations to manifest. Meanwhile the US became the richest, attracted all the best people, and won. Even if there had been no direct conflict, and instead a multipolar Cold War, I am guessing capitalism would have won before mid-20th century genetic science could have made the difference.
It will be interesting to see how things change, maybe in the very short term. Embryo selection seems like it works, but it doesn’t really scale. If there’s a technological advance that is not as invasive, offers obvious benefits, and “just works”, then I could see widespread adoption (at least for disease prevention and optimizing your children within the “natural” range of outcomes, I’m not sure how the possibility of further augmentation might play out politically). Or maybe AI will end democracy and the elites will be able to augment themselves and leave the rest of us behind without needing our approval. Or maybe the AI will just leave us all behind. Many exciting possibilities!
It's funny, I was thinking about sex-based role reversals, and I think that they are even harder to make "work" because most people so deeply feel that there is a difference between men and women and that they should be held to different standards, even when they say otherwise.
I had a phase in high school / college where I was something of a true believer in racial blank slatism, probably because it supported the classical liberalism I absorbed from the red state milieu I grew up in. I was uncritically reading people like Malcolm Gladwell and Jared Diamond, along with people like Thomas Sowell, who studiously avoids direct engagement with hereditarian questions (Sowell I still respect, the others not so much). But I always had a strong sense that men and women were different. It probably helps that I played sports, and when I was growing up I picked up benevolent sexism from the conservative adults around me. I did have some problems in college when I took all the talk about men and women being psychologically identical (if not for social conditioning) literally. It wasn't till later that I realized that most people just intuit that there is a difference and instinctively learn when it is appropriate to "treat women equally" and when it is not. My conversations with the ladies did not go so well for a while there...
Not the OP, but the classic cases for me are racial role reversals, where a conservative is appealing to color-blind classical liberalism to counter something like "white people are the worst because..." with "imagine if you said black people are the worst...". I would say that this sort of hypocrisy being pointed out did "work" on me when I was younger. It made me realize that most people are not actually committed to consistent principles and helped me to identify that we were moving into a new post-liberal politics in the early 2010s, where the motte was liberal equality and the bailey was a sex and race based hierarchy.
Like many on this site I probably feel an unusually strong need for consistency and logical coherence, and when I was younger I did not have good theory of mind for others. I didn't have good theory of mind for myself, either, to be honest. Now that I have done more self reflection, I can see how my own desire to impose coherence and consistency is quite selective and self-serving when it comes to tribal battles or arguments where my ego gets involved.
the idea that a certain floor of intelligence is a prerequisite for empathy is a disquieting one
I think this is true, if consciously modeling others in a System 2 sort of way (what the breakfast question measures) is necessary for empathy. I don't think it is, though this may just be a definitional quibble. Empathy is an emotional response. You "feel their pain". You feel what (your body thinks) they feel. Empathy is a very tribal emotion. People who score higher in empathy also tend to score higher in antipathy towards their outgroups, i.e. those that threaten the people you empathize with. Empathy is something women, especially mothers, tend to feel more strongly than men. The mother grizzly and her relationship with her cubs might be the ultimate example of low IQ, strong (selective) empathy.
The way empathy is popularly spoken about is as a sort of mixture between empathy (emotionally identifying with the feelings of others, feeling their feelings), sympathy (modelling what others are feeling, usually leading to feeling for them as well), and compassion (feeling for the suffering of others). I think that a certain level of intelligence is necessary to consciously model these things, and that doing so can lead to expanding one's circle of concern and feeling more universal empathy. But I think that many unintelligent people have a high capacity for empathy, they may just be stuck at a more basic, tribal sort of "default setting" (which is still very powerful, and includes machinery like mirror neurons, etc.).
Definitional quibble aside, I do agree that low IQ violent criminal types are probably not going to be able to reason their way to greater empathy. There might be some System 1 approaches that could change their feelings and behavior (though I broadly agree with your pessimism).
I am familiar with the stereotype of the diva WR. But I'm not sure that being a diva or having irrational confidence helps you run hard on all your routes. In fact, NFL WR divas are known for not making much of an effort if they aren't happy with how much they're getting the ball. My point was that in general the game of football imposes discipline on players who may have been able to get away with diva behavior at lower levels of play where their raw talent allowed them to dominate. The game does not teach poor impulse control and irrational confidence. The players you cited could get away with a lot because they were all time greats. Most NFL WRs cannot be distractions or they will not be long for the league.
If I was going to create a synthesis between myself and FiveHour, I would say we agree that the WR position attracts great athletes in the WR/DB mold who want to score and get attention. I would say that as the level of competition improves, though, the game tends to select for disciplined players who give great effort and do their job. Only the rarest talents can get away with poor impulse control and irrational confidence at the highest levels.
A WR, not just in the NFL but in their entire formative years leading up to it in high school and college, has to have irrational confidence or he can't play. An average NFL game features about 70 snaps of offense, a top tier clear #1 option might get 10-12 targets out of those plays, while a second or third banana will only get 3-5, and a lot of players run a ton cardio routes and get 0-2 a game. To make it as a WR, a guy has to be willing to run those routes and have confidence he can make it happen, even when for long periods he never gets targeted and nothing he does matters.
Most future NFL WRs did not have to work that hard in high school. They were stars who could effortlessly dominate and get away with taking plays off if they wanted to. Starting in college and then in the pros they begin to be selected strongly for work ethic, relative to their talent level, with the most talented being able to get away with doing less.
A wide receiver has to stay motivated to keep running his routes perfectly with high effort, even though he'll only get targeted on a handful of them, and he'll only convert about 60% of those targets into catches. The WR who lacks that kind of irrational confidence will fail, in the NFL if not earlier, because he won't be able to commit to running those routes expecting to make a big play.
It seems like you are conflating confidence and grit. Running your routes hard when you know you are not that likely to be targeted seems like a discipline and work ethic question rather than a confidence question, irrational or otherwise. To make it in the NFL you need to combine elite talent with exceptional grit (or just have hyper-elite talent, like Randy Moss). The GOAT, Jerry Rice, had an incredible work ethic that allowed him to maintain an elite level of fitness and play into his 40s. I'm sure he had confidence in his ability to run hard all game, but it was a rational confidence that came from proving it to himself all offseason.
It both attracts players with poor impulse control and irrational confidence, and teaches them poor impulse control and irrational confidence.
Contra the second half of the above, I think that the game teaches WRs impulse control and forces them to work harder and be more disciplined. For the majority, who will not be WR1s in the pros, making it in the NFL requires losing some of their ego and toning down their "irrational confidence". At the NFL level, you are not that guy and you need to block and run hard or you will be out of the league.
If I had to choose an irrational confidence position it would be cornerback. You have to be able to shake off getting beaten and get right back to it on the next play. Dealing with constant failure and the risk that on any given passing play you might be embarrassed takes a mentality that could be described as "irrationally confident". Tirelessly doing your job as a WR3 who used to be the man in high school and college takes humility and discipline.
Yeah, it's hard to successfully carry out the Fabian strategy when you are Carthage by analogy.
What is the essence of Left and Right to you? I'm having trouble making sense of your model.
To me, political Left and Right, to the degree that they represent something coherent that can be applied across different historical contexts, are something like hierarchy (Right) vs. egalitarianism (Left). You could think of this in terms of their differing stances towards hierarchy, where the extreme rightist says that a hierarchy is good by virtue of its very existence, the extreme leftist says no hierarchy is good, it is always suspect and corrupt and should be abolished. The golden mean / enlightened centrist take on this spectrum is something like, "Hierarchies are inevitable, but we need hierarchies based on competence and virtue that have checks against oppression and corruption" (though the awareness of the inevitability of hierarchy is probably seen as somewhat Right wing in our Post-WWII narrative context).
Individualism (the classical liberalism you describe) vs. Communalism represents a separate political axis. Communists and Fascists are both communalists, but one represents the Left and the other the Right. Likewise, classically liberal individualism can totally work for someone who appreciates hierarchy. It allows the great to differentiate themselves. Elite Human Capital types are Right wing individualists.
I don't think these behaviors make sense when you model people as individuals who are trying to maximize fairness, but they do make sense when you think of people as members of groups that are in competition (whether they wish to be or not, we are all members of some recognizable group). Scott has a good post about these sorts of dynamics called Weak Men Are Superweapons.
I think most people exhibiting these behaviors (hypocrisy, unfairness) are using pre-rational heuristics, albeit heuristics that are rational when the goal is for you and your group to win.
I feel like it should be standard in schools, starting from as soon as any sort of essays or argumentation is taught, to always use examples of correct arguments for things almost everyone in the tribe considers extremely evil or odious (i.e. fascism, racism, murder, rape, genocide, slavery) to always use examples of incorrect arguments for things almost everyone in the tribe considers good (i.e. democracy, equal rights, feeding babies).
This would be a fascinating experiment. There would still be strong societal influences from outside of school that would shape the students, but in general I would expect that this would make some of the "extremely evil or odious" things much less taboo to them. For most people, the ability to even voice a "correct" argument in favor of something means that it is within the Overton Window. I say this as someone who used to be a much lower decoupler and can still somewhat model my past self.
if I were a teacher, I'd try to make sure that the most popular high status kids are assigned to make arguments in favor of the most apparently evil things and the least popular low status kids are assigned the ones in favor of the most universally beloved and apparently good things.
I'm imagining a Hitler Youth of Chads and Stacys running things by the time the experiment reaches high school...
he listens to his favorite song, “Take It to the Limit”
The fact that he is an Eagles fan is so jarring. I wonder if this detail is one of the only actually true things in the memoir, or if he (or his ghostwriter) just thought it was an appropriately dramatic choice? The idea of woke Black Britons listening to the Eagles gives me a strange worlds-collide sort of feeling.
One of the best analyses of this phenomenon that I have read is this one by Johann Kurtz: Young adults are poor despite every metric which suggests otherwise
His main thesis:
I think that Millennials and Zoomers are not doing fine. In fact, I think there have been structural changes to our economy and society which clearly explain why these cohorts are failing to move through the five pillars of a stable middle-class existence: education, stable employment, marriage, homeownership, children.
Some of these negative changes stand out in the normal datasets, while some do not, for reasons I will explain. In short, what has happened is that previous generations were able to take advantage of highly valuable and productive social capital as well as their exploding financial capital to move through each of these life stages in a fiscally efficient manner. (Don’t worry: I will define what I mean by social capital and back my argument with data).
Our current young, lacking access to this social capital, must engage in enormous outlays of purely financial capital in order to achieve the same levels of stability and accomplishment — capital that they do not have. We see this clearly in the data on schooling, homeownership, and family formation.
Reminds me of The Sun Also Rises.
“Hello, Robert,” I said. “Did you come in to cheer me up?”
“Would you like to go to South America, Jake?” he asked.
“No.”
“Why not?”
“I don’t know. I never wanted to go. Too expensive. You can see all the South Americans you want in Paris anyway.”
“They’re not the real South Americans.”
“They look awfully real to me.”
I had a boat train to catch with a week’s mail stories, and only half of them written.
“Do you know any dirt?” I asked.
“No.”
“None of your exalted connections getting divorces?”
“No; listen, Jake. If I handled both our expenses, would you go to South America with me?”
“Why me?”
“You can talk Spanish. And it would be more fun with two of us.”
“No,” I said, “I like this town and I go to Spain in the summer-time.”
“All my life I’ve wanted to go on a trip like that,” Cohn said. He sat down. “I’ll be too old before I can ever do it.”
“Don’t be a fool,” I said. “You can go anywhere you want. You’ve got plenty of money.”
“I know. But I can’t get started.”
“Cheer up,” I said. “All countries look just like the moving pictures.”
But I felt sorry for him. He had it badly.
“I can’t stand it to think my life is going so fast and I’m not really living it.”
“Nobody ever lives their life all the way up except bull-fighters.”
“I’m not interested in bull-fighters. That’s an abnormal life. I want to go back in the country in South America. We could have a great trip.”
“Did you ever think about going to British East Africa to shoot?”
“No, I wouldn’t like that.”
“I’d go there with you.”
“No; that doesn’t interest me.”
“That’s because you never read a book about it. Go on and read a book all full of love affairs with the beautiful shiny black princesses.”
“I want to go to South America.”
He had a hard, Jewish, stubborn streak.
“Come on down-stairs and have a drink.”
“Aren’t you working?”
“No,” I said. We went down the stairs to the café on the ground floor. I had discovered that was the best way to get rid of friends. Once you had a drink all you had to say was: “Well, I’ve got to get back and get off some cables,” and it was done. It is very important to discover graceful exits like that in the newspaper business, where it is such an important part of the ethics that you should never seem to be working. Anyway, we went down-stairs to the bar and had a whiskey and soda. Cohn looked at the bottles in bins around the wall. “This is a good place,” he said.
“There’s a lot of liquor,” I agreed.
“Listen, Jake,” he leaned forward on the bar. “Don’t you ever get the feeling that all your life is going by and you’re not taking advantage of it? Do you realize you’ve lived nearly half the time you have to live already?”
“Yes, every once in a while.”
“Do you know that in about thirty-five years more we’ll be dead?”
“What the hell, Robert,” I said. “What the hell.”
“I’m serious.”
“It’s one thing I don’t worry about,” I said.
“You ought to.”
“I’ve had plenty to worry about one time or other. I’m through worrying.”
“Well, I want to go to South America.”
“Listen, Robert, going to another country doesn’t make any difference. I’ve tried all that. You can’t get away from yourself by moving from one place to another. There’s nothing to that.”
How seriously you take it probably depends on your jurisdiction and church culture, but I was always aware of it growing up. In part because I attended an Antiochian-run summer camp where they would serve us fasting food on Wednesdays, Fridays, and during the Apostles Fast. This year I will probably not fast very strictly since my wife is pregnant and we have a young child.
orthoxerox - if you don't mind me asking, what is your relationship to Orthodoxy? In my time lurking I think I have pieced together that you are a Russian who identifies as Orthodox in some sense and follows some of the practices, but that you are not really a believing Christian. Is this accurate?
(I realized I may have to ask the above question again later if I hope to get orthoxerox's attention, since the fast started today!)
They were interested in what the Word of God was, not what the Word of God was.
Did you mean for the first "what" to be "who"?
This is not a good argument, because Jesus is clear that we are all born again from God, that we all become a son of God with the same oneness as Jesus is the son of God (John 17:22-23). Of course we are not turned into sons of God in the sense that we are suddenly turned into a divine being. Neither are we the preeminent Son of God, the firstfruits. But it’s totally anachronistic to make this into an argument for his being God, and it just reads as someone trying to trick those unfamiliar with how words were actually used at the time period.
It is basically the same argument Gregory of Nyssa uses. I am far from an expert in ancient or Koine Greek, though, so it is hard for me to independently evaluate what is or is not anachronistic. I agree that we are all called to be sons of God, and also that there is one (Only Begotten) Son of God; we are to attain by grace what He is by nature. And I think that Christ's (eternal) divinity is necessary for salvation. Irenaeus, who stated that man was created in the image and to attain the likeness of God, says:
Jesus Christ was not a mere man, begotten from Joseph in the ordinary course of nature, but was very God, begotten of the Father most high, and very man, born of the Virgin.
- But again, those who assert that He was simply a mere man, begotten by Joseph, remaining in the bondage of the old disobedience, are in a state of death having been not as yet joined to the Word of God the Father, nor receiving liberty through the Son, as He does Himself declare: If the Son shall make you free, you shall be free indeed. (John 8:36) But, being ignorant of Him who from the Virgin is Emmanuel, they are deprived of His gift, which is eternal life; (Romans 6:23) and not receiving the incorruptible Word, they remain in mortal flesh, and are debtors to death, not obtaining the antidote of life. To whom the Word says, mentioning His own gift of grace: I said, You are all the sons of the Highest, and gods; but you shall die like men. He speaks undoubtedly these words to those who have not received the gift of adoption, but who despise the incarnation of the pure generation of the Word of God, defraud human nature of promotion into God, and prove themselves ungrateful to the Word of God, who became flesh for them. For it was for this end that the Word of God was made man, and He who was the Son of God became the Son of man, that man, having been taken into the Word, and receiving the adoption, might become the son of God. For by no other means could we have attained to incorruptibility and immortality, unless we had been united to incorruptibility and immortality. But how could we be joined to incorruptibility and immortality, unless, first, incorruptibility and immortality had become that which we also are, so that the corruptible might be swallowed up by incorruptibility, and the mortal by immortality, that we might receive the adoption of sons?
Ultimately, the importance of adoptionism and “low Christology” is not because it’s the oldest and original, but because it’s essential for the religion to actually have an effect.
Makes sense, I can see how an overemphasis on Christ's divinity causes problems. But I also think that part of the magic of the faith is its ability to hold certain opposites in tension.
Jesus is God (the Father) is not in the Nicene Creed either. Nathan Jacobs addresses the issue here: https://nathanajacobs.substack.com/p/does-jesus-claim-to-be-god
- Prev
- Next

Shrike already responded below, and I agree with both you and him that the content of Genesis 1-2 is quite different than what's found in other ANE creation myths. The God of Israel is quite different than the gods of the surrounding nations. But I think an ancient Babylonian Marduk worshipper would have instantly recognized it as a rival creation myth working within a similar frame and playing with some of the same tropes as his own, whereas your average modern thinks of it as a somewhat arbitrary story that was trying to do what science now does better.
More options
Context Copy link