ControlsFreak
No bio...
User ID: 1422
There were tons of atheists who wanted to reject big bang cosmology on the grounds that it felt like it had implications that seemed too close to creationism (to be clear, I am not taking the position that it actually has such implications, only that those folks felt that it did). Yes, sure, one can observe that they eventually lost this fight, but many have persisted in coming up with non-empirically-justified epicycles (e.g., multiverse) in efforts to cling to implications they prefer.
It's the strawiest of strawmen to declare that one must leap fully into every aspect of an entire worldview in a single bound. And it's not a demand that you would make of other worldviews, either. One doesn't leap in a single bound to believing a world of quantum mechanics, general relativity, probability theory, some presumably materialist metaethical theory, etc etc etc. It takes a lot of time, a lot of work, and a lot of details.
- Prev
- Next

Suppose a chain of reasoning has a hundred propositions. A person realizes that their interlocutor has an issue with the very first proposition. They will likely 'trot out' an argument that gets at that first proposition. That does not imply that it is the only argument that they have for the entire chain of propositions, and it's pretty shameful to claim that they're expecting others to accept every other proposition without any argument just because they present an argument for the first proposition.
I've only ever seen people trot out the "well actually, you must be making a huge leap from a discrete statement about step one to a claim that it implies everything about your worldview" when they're erecting a strawman and trying to make their opponent sound unreasonable... and usually that's because they feel bad about the truth of the discrete statement and want to deflect and feel smug.
More options
Context Copy link