Dean
Flairless
Variously accused of being a hilarious insufferable reactionary post-modernist fascist neo-conservative neo-liberal conservative classical liberal critical theorist Nazi Zionist imperialist hypernationalist NATO-consensus warmongering isolationist Jewish-Polish-Slavic-Anglo race-traitor masculine-feminine bitch-man idiosyncratic party-line Fox News boomer. No one yet has guessed a scholar, or multiple people. Add to our list of pejoratives today!
User ID: 430
Anyway has anything to say about it?
The alleged article or the sentiment behind it?
The report is very likely a fake, for reasons already mentioned. I will note that the use of roman numerals isn't discrediting in and of itself- RAND does use sometimes publish reports and use roman numerals for the agenda / methodology / executive summary portion before the main report itself- but rather the cover page itself is a red flag. The image claims this is a research report, but RAND Research Reports have a general style of presentation, include front-page opening images and color. You can peruse RAND Research Reports via a search of their website, as the pictures show.
https://www.rand.org/pubs.html?pub-date=20211210%3A&series=Research+Reports
Another formatting red flag is the mis-classification label. The first page graphic- which says this is 'Confidential' under 'January 25, 2022'- is mixing a few things. For one, RAND isn't an American government agency, and while it's a common belief in various circles that it's a distinction without a difference, classification (mis)labeling is one of those areas where it matters. 'Confidential' is an American classification labeling, and when reports are classified, the documents have various formatting requirements such as having the label on each page, and portion-marking individual paragraphs. This is so that the readers can reference various parts of the document at various levels or contexts. If the implicit argument is RAND is part/an extension of the American government, this would be a job-retraining failure. If the more defensible position is that this is something RAND wrote for the government, it would be customer abuse. A lot of companies/groups with regular engagement with governments will develop their own, internal control measures rather than mis-use the government's own classification system.
A third red flag is the front page distribution list. Aside from the placement on the page- above the Executive Summary, which is where the RAND logo is placed? Really?- I assume by WHCS they mean White House Chief of Staff, but that's not an office, and wouldn't be in the same context as three letter agencies. Also conspicuously absent from the distribution list is the Treasury Department- a kind of big omission of any report nominally on economic analysis. Instead, the list is primarily the big spooky externally known 3-letter agencies... when there isn't a need for that information to be on the Executive Summary Page in the first place. That's the sort of information you track on a cover sheet, so you don't need to re-publish a report every time some new office is involved.
Overall, the formatting has a lot of red flags, and most of the potential explanations- 'they didn't follow their usual practices because of the need for secrecy'- ask people to be dumb in different ways. 'This was made by someone who thinks this is how the Americans work' is much more likely...
...not least because the article really doesn't reflect how the American government national-security types think about this general topic, or Europe, and so the report reads like 'this was written by someone who thinks this is how the Americans think,' or even 'this is written by someone who wants other people to think this is how the Americans think.'
The Americans don't talk about the Europeans in terms of 'sovereignty.' The American establishment viewpoint is that the Europeans already have it- it's the anti-American/anti-American-empire-ists who would frame the European alliances as non-sovereign, not a quasi-government report. Nor is a Biden-administration solicited report going to talk about Europe in terms of 'if one day we abandon Europe,' when the opening year of the Biden administration was ABT, or Anything But Trump, with even the exceptions subject to rebranding for the 'we're back' theme. Nor would the US of Jan 2022 been talking about Ukraine causing a 'controlled economic crisis' to plan for the duration of 2022... because the Americans were planning for a relatively quick and short Russia-Ukraine War. The Americans were flowing insurgency-friendly weapons into Ukraine, but not heavier conventional equipment, because of the expectation that Russia would have a conventional victory in short order. Second and third order effects of that would be the expectation that- as happened repeatedly before- German and other European interests would press for normalization of Energy supplies (and even currently, with the gas price cap, set a price above what was generally being charged, ie. not actually capping prices or flow). Broader pushback against sanctions primarily has not happened because Ukraine remained in the fight... but Ukraine remaining in the fight was manifestly not something the Americans were planning on. If Ukraine's government had toppled in the first month, months 2-10 of the war, and all the sanctions discussions that occurred, would have gone very differently.
Meanwhile, the report doesn't identify various things the American national-security types would raise about if it WAS an American product. Like the description of the German economic pillars: that wouldn't be Russian gas and 'cheap French electrical power.' The other pillar would be something akin to 'exports to China,' because that's something the Americans care about far more than French electrical imports, and is relevant to the strategic-level topic. There would be mentions that the German military under-spending, because that's been a long, long on-going complaint from the American perspective that goes hand-in-hand with the Russian energy reliance- both are decades-long-issues that have been persistent issues in mind.
Add to this the plethora of pejorative framings and boo-light words almost specifically driven to incite German/European emotions ('trap,' 'lack of professionalism of current leaders,' 'thanks to our precise action,' the whole 'French dependent on AUKUS' framing)- which just so coincidentally predicted a political context almost a year later after multiple unpredicted inflection points in the Ukraine unforeseeable at the time, which is just so coincidentally being leaked at a time when those framing devices and predictions are most salient to ongoing contexts...
...while also embracing the framing that Ukraine was an American trap, and that Russia was 'provoked' so that it would be 'possible' to declare Russia the aggressor...
...in a report nominally authored in late January 22, when the Russians had already been moving their invasion hardware along the various invasion axis assembly areas in the clear logistical buildup that the American government was publicizing at the time, but that this report makes no reference to...
Obvious false-flag information effort, targeting people who are only vaguely familiar with the alleged participants or Ukrainian context, or stroking the biases of those vulnerable to agreeing by what Stephen Colbert once called the truthiness of it.
Most people won't take it as anything other than light entertainment. Some people may believe it's true, however. And I guess some of those might believe in some ur-Aryan white master race nonsense, but I can't be bothered to get het-up about that.
I'm reminded of when Paradox Interactive, a Swedish gaming studio who does historical strategy games like Crusader Kings (about the dynasties of the middle-ages) and the Victorian eras, started getting tarred for having too many white supremacist fans.
I have long been convinced that such complainers miss a rather critical point. If you believe someone is a awful white supremacist, what would you expect them to be doing if they weren't dumping hundreds to thousands of hours into video games?
Because you explicitly asked me to. Don’t ask me a question and then turn around and cast aspersions on me for answering it. That doesn’t incline me to take on your questions in good faith going forward.
I asked you to because you made an insinuation/claim for the public record without making an argument. When challenged, you simultaneously claimed you were not making any assumptions, after providing a favorable assumption, and since claimed you could not make an equivalent assumption on the same amount of information.
This is less a challenge of faith and more a challenge to you to speak clearly, with the intended purpose of letting any late-readers of your thread read your last position with the note that the implied argument was not only contested, but identified.
when the thread was already going cold
Then why didn’t you just let it cool, and instead decide to pepper me with elliptical, leading questions which have obviously been motivated by drawing out some perceived fault on my part, rather than just forthrightly saying what you thought I was doing and why you objected to it? That would have saved us both some time.
Because I was curious how you would respond in hopes of being proven wrong, and how you did was telling (and expected).
Also, as a framing device for future readers, and a tertiary goal of nudging you into being a bit better meta-awareness next time you want to post a thread.
I also note that you didn’t match the favorable section with a section that was not conceded or dismissed as wrong
McFaul didn’t give any such section. I looked at all his tweets and replies since the piece came out. I can’t do the impossible.
You did, however, feel comfortable assuming a section that agreed with you despite the same lack of information. Which was the point- that you would assume a favorable and expansive interpretation when allowed, but then retreat to a more defensible position when challenged.
IE, the archetypical motte-and-bailey fallacy this community is named for.
Though your response were more demonstrative than descriptive, it highlighted in the possible final exchange of the thread your approach to the topic, and how your prior positions on the topic further down (in the default sorting way) will be perceived going forward.
Yes, this is pure meta.
Without an argument being made, McFaul is only relevant to be raised or identified to appeal to his authority.
Or to inform interested parties as to the reaction of the subject of the piece to that piece. Not exactly an alien practice! You seem determined to interpret a one-line comment in the most expansive and least charitable terms possible.
Over-representing a one-line twitter comment in a more expansive and less charitable (to your opposition) way was rather the point of citing him. This is why we are calling out the contrast for meta purposes.
As for lack of charity, this sort of flaw is expected from you, hence why this response focuses on the meta-argumentive structure.
And I simply forgot to write a submission statement. I haven’t been very active here of late, so I’m not fresh on those rules, and if you look at my other link posts you’ll notice that I have a bad habit of forgetting to write them in general. With that said, I agree with Lemoine’s position, so he does speak for me in that sense, as should have been clear from the rest of my comments.
This is, alas, far too late to be particularly relevant to your execution of this debate, which has shifted firmly to the meta of this thread, and will continue to be meta so long as you lack an opening argument. Nor is it about the rules about this website specifically. While they are helpful reminders, it's hardly unique that a link to a source is not an implicit endorsement of the source or its framing, and that assuming so is a fallacious assumption.
If you want to speak clearly, you have to speak. It is not on the other party of a debate to strawman a position you may or may not agree with, nor are they obliged to have the debate you might prefer but didn't set out.
when the very premise of disagreement is being questioned
Sorry, what does this mean? I can’t tell from context.
It means that your argument of providing more information for the original debate is flawed, because the original debate never existed.
The common theme of the top-level reply to your link is that the posters consistently felt that the link-author's argument lacks what they consider extremely relevant information needed to discuss the topic, which challenges the very premise of a debate on the article's subject. It innately turns any debate on the argument itself into a meta-argument not on the original link's line of argument, but on the argument construction and composition. In a thread literally including 'lies of omission' in the threat title, these amount to charges of... omission, a central challenge to the thesis.
Counter-arguing a meta-argument of insufficient evidence never relies on introducing new evidence not previously included. If you are convincing on the grounds of the new evidence provided, it demonstrates the objection's point that the original argument was lacking sufficient data. If you are not convincing on the grounds of new evidence provided, the meta-objection still stands.
The proper way to counter-argue a meta-argument of insufficient evidence is not to bring in new information, but to refute the relevancy of the categories of insufficient information. This is, however, a much harder task in the context of NATO expansion and Russia, as categories of relevancy referred to (contemporary and early post-cold-war Russian history, nuclear deterrence modeling, the relative relevance of sincerity, the presumption of spheres of influence to be respected, etc.) have relatively obvious relevance in an article touching on several of these things, to which you tried to counter by... making new arguments that the author didn't. Which is adding new arguments. Which returns to the previous paragraph on meta-argument by new information.
So, I leave it to any future thread finder to enter the thread, read through this latest exchange as one of their firsts based on the default thread formating, and approach the rest of the thread with the mindset this exchange is intended to give them.
Now is your turn, of course, to have the last reply in a dead and dying thread, to prove that you do not, in fact, have better things to spend your time on than the last word, etc. etc. I'm here for the framing, not the last word, so I'll even let you keep it.
Now, mind you, responding for the last word after describing it as wasting your time, and thus demonstrating you both did not, in fact, have better things to do with your time and were predicted in doing so. A successful prediction would indicate my successful modeling of you, and thus a handling of the meta of the conversation, regardless of what you actually say and do, and whether or not I reply. Whereas you not replying would undercut that specific argument, but would leave the main thesis present, and from a public perception of loss of control of the argument. If you continue, I am validated, if you do not, non-continuation comes off as a retreat.
...is what I would end with if the goal were to patronize you rather than try to improve you.
Yes, it would be a meta trap of sorts... but I bring this in the spirit of concluding meta-arguments, which is that seeking the last word in a public argument (such as the post-thread reference) isn't always an advantage, and if you're arguing for effect, can be actively detrimental. Which is why one should rarely refer to the end of the argument in final terms unless one is willing to leave without the last word. Continuing after you characterize an argument a waste of time is self-defeating, as is being predictable in one's reaching arguments. Rhetorical over-reach is something that can be leveraged against you, which is why identifying fallacies is a regular form of discrediting someone's position.
If you intend to argue for effect- which you clearly intended to by the way you approached this thread and topic in general- this is the sort of meta-dynamics you need to be cognizant of lest you undermine your own side. It is not enough to go 'this person's arguments are my own.' You will be in the position of defending the flaws of the other's argument, and in ways you are not capable of correctly defending against but will become party in discrediting them.
I would leave with asking if you thought this exchange brought about by your after-the-fact addition of a reaching insinuation strengthened or weakened the audience perception of the link-author's position, which you share. I will leave with asking you if you think that replying in any form will do the same. The answer will likely demonstrate the difference between arguing to argue, or arguing to have an impact.
[Insert sign off joke here]
Probably the part about how Putin was not in fact totally gung-ho about NATO expansion in the early 2000s, seeing as that’s the sole topic of the article. But I know exactly as much as you do right now, so I don’t see much point in speculating.
Apparently you do, or else you wouldn't have speculated a favorable interpretation of a non-position and thought it relevant a day later when the thread was already going cold.
I also note you didn't match the favorable section with a section that was not conceded or dismissed as wrong. This would have better demonstrated your awareness of the strengths, and limits, of the arguments being made, which might have helped justify the assumption of what section was being referred to positively.
I’m puzzled as to what you mean by an “appeal to authority.” The subject of the piece that I posted responded to the post, and I simply updated the thread with that fact, because it’s obviously relevant to anyone who was interested in the original debate. There’s no argument being made here. If and when McFaul expounds in more detail, I will edit the above post to reflect that as well, and for the same reason.
Without an argument being made, McFaul is only relevant to be raised or identified in order to appeal to his authority. This authority may be 'as the person this argument is critiquing, my concession of legitimacy bestows weight on the argument's validity,' but (a) this is still appealing to the authority of a target to bestow legitimacy to the critique, and (b) there isn't actually a concession here to carry weight or bestow validity. It's only 'obviously relevant' in so much that it is used to present an assumption of agreement with an inferred argument to buttress on un-made stance because you started this thread without any sort of submission statement or position.
To update, there must be a date to 'up' so to speak, but so far your debate has been primarily in counter-arguments of people critiqueing the linked article. In the motte and bailey metaphor, that may be an attempt at guerrila warfare behind the attacker's line, but it's not clear there's an attacker here in the first place. An article writer made a critique. One of the personal subjects of the critique made a polite but non-committal concession of nothing specific or in particular. This changes, or challenges, none of the arguments involved by any of the players, on either side.
One of the common themes of the comments regarding this article has been it ignores relevant context, ie that it doesn't actually challenge a real position as much as a strawman or a framing. Counter-arguments by you to these charges do not constitute the original debate when the very premise of disagreement is being questioned. It may be an awkward attempt to have a debate, but it's poorly structured as one, not least for the fact that you neither claim the author speaks for you, which would tie you to a position you'd have to defend, nor do you speak for the author, which means your disputes on his intended meaning are as much a matter of opinion and position as anyone else's.
Really this thread is just an awkwardly formatted comment thread for an opinion peace on another website.
Which part of the article do you assume was relevant, and which parts were not?
As is, this seems a very awkward appeal to an authority, except without tying the authority to any specific position that can be questioned. It's a favorable expansive claim, but not a particularly meaningful one justifying a day-later 'look, even this person agrees (except I don't know how or about what or when).'
Which part of his views?
Whatever fantasies get you off, I suppose.
I had a similar first impression.
It was a bit disappointing, as was the article. Basically another variant of 'the Russians were sincere about opposing NATO expansion,' but without the second or third order argument needed to make it relevant as to why that matters without resting on assumed arguments and strawmen.
We are probably going to see a major shift away from American banking and financial infrastructure to a system that is less feasible to deplattform from and it won't be Japanese porn or political dissidents leading the way. It is going to be countries moving away when they realize that their financial infrastructure is being built on a legal framework that is increasingly functioning like the youtube terms and services.
The issue being that these other countries aren't going to be particularly concerned about the sacred inviolability of contracts, but will want to retain their own ability to deplatform/end contracts on their own terms, thus reducing their ability to function as a meaningful alternative.
That is an interesting option. Especially if you timed the withdrawal to Wakanda's entry into isolation- as in, the reason the oppression/occupation ended was because the evil imperialist/oppressors, at least those on top, recanted/changed rulers to T'Chala's line/entered into their multi-century isolationism. IE, Shuri isn't the direct descendant of the oppressor per see, but the liberator/ones who ended the oppression, and thus create the point that not only are children not guilty of the sins of the fathers, but of course that hatred blinds to distinctions in the out-group.
Though, if you were going this sort of grudge-match, it might make sense that Wakanda is being deliberately framed as the geo-political conflict back drop, not Namor planning an invasion himself. Namor plotting to frame Wakanda, playing on Wakanda's own secrecy and mutual paranoia, would also work well as the set-up, as the backdrop could be a race for evidence before the Americans start a likely ruinous war... which Namor could be setting up to be the spoiler/decisive element in.
Let the surfacers kill eachother, yada yada yada.
I don't mind the decision, nor am I blaming Shuri. I mind/blame the writers who didn't do anything with the decision. What could have been an excellent theme-establishing line of dialogue- of Shuri's rejecting the counsel of others, to her own later regret, of establishing a character flaw to overcome ('I'm the smart one, I know better than everyone else')... this would be a good character arc that would support the general plot of the movie, while keeping the theme of grief.
This could have been the establishing character moment, of Shuri trying to solve everything herself without considering the consequences to those she ignores. T'Challa off-screen is one- and one that can give her something to bond over/reflect with T'Challa's ex-girlfriend (someone else who wasn't there at his death bed)- but it can be a reoccuring thematic touch point. Shuri ignoring bald-general's guidance, and getting American police killed- especially if the police are reframed as trying to protect/rescue Riri from a kidnapping, rather than being cast of the villians, in a chaotic three-way where Shuri is trying to 'solve' the problem of the mystery assassins against Riri but doesn't trust/talk with the CIA Liasion Ross dude. It could come across in the discussion with Namor, where rather than Shuri being 'charmed but unwilling to compromise her morals,' let Namor actually tempt/manipulate Shuri, playing the dark counselor and the person whose advice she shouldn't trust (because it appeals to her own ego). Let her think that she's in control, that she knows best and can solve this diplomatically... so that she brings him into Wakanda, against the advice/warnings of others, only to be faced with treachery, right after she appeals to her mother to trust her / let her in / becomes complicit in the tragedy of her mother's death. Then let it come again with Gorilla Tribe chieftan dude, who plays the mentor schtick in the later movie, and who deals with her in a crisis of guild/trust as she doesn't trust herself or know who else to trust. And, of course, let it come down to the thematic tension between Killmonger from the vision- another dark influence- and T'Challa's ex, who asks for her trust and to confidence. Let that culminating moment- of when Shuri truly listens to others over what she wants and rationalizes over what is right- be when she let's her late brother's counsel, and his words, come through the meaningful echo.
Shuri can have agency if she makes mistakes. She can overcome weaknesses, without fundamentally overhauling the plot. Let the twin themes of guilt and struggling to accept the advice of others (while being wary of those who would mislead her) be character themes.
As-is, Shuri (and to a different degree, Riri) is closer to a black female Tony Stark, only without the flaws and the charisma and the character conflicts internal and external that made him gripping.
I don't blame Shuri for that, but I do blame the writers for that. Shuri in Wakanda Forever is flat. Shuri in Wakanda Forever could have been incredibly interesting with the early set-up.
I've made jokes in the past that Black Panther was a love-letter to American supremacy. For all it was supposed to be Strong African Country, the plot is basically that a small central-african country gets couped and counter-couped by the American government twice in about a week... as an accident. First as a rogue former agent, but second by a isolated agent cut off from the state. So great is the power of the CIA that it's agents on their own overthrow the most powerful African Country in the world, twice, before really knowing it exists, and so great is the power of America that Wakandan royalty defects from their civilizational mission of isolation and starts giving aid to that most needy African population there is... American citizens.
Black Panther (the film) always had its own unfortunate implications- steotyping 'authentic' africans as shoe-less tribals with animal motiffs, much use of the noble savage trope, but at it's heart it was also a personal story of a man coming to grips between the tension of the virtues and flaws of something he loves, but knows needs to change for the better. The set dressing is set dressing, because the core story is emotional conflict of ideology and overcoming flaws, and if that's enough to get people to give a pass to the Unfortuante Implications, who am I to say nay?
I don't get that feeling from Wakanda Forever.
As a story protagonist, Shuri works as a 'working through grief' story, but she doesn't actually address or grappel with any really character flaws. Shuri's flaw is that she is grieving, and her grieving is corrupting her otherwise unimpeachable nature, but this isn't an actual character flaw, or anything but the most blameless of guilts. Shuri feels bad for not being able to cure an incurable disease... not, say, refusing to be at her brother's side as a man on his deathbed, denying him a final request. Not for getting a bunch of American police killed in the midst of a coerced kidnapping attempt. Nor for anything else she did, but only for what she couldn't- and couldn't be expected to do- achieve.
This is closer to the suffering-Sue stereotype than an actual character challenge for her to overcome, and the same extends to Wakanda as a whole. T'Challa struggles with the fact that the father he loves is a hypocrite and his people need to change, that his nation's policy is fundamentally flawed, and that Wakanda isn't as good as it tells itself it is. T'Challa loves his people and his friends, but the 'we follow the throne, not you' dynamic is explicit and a major point of divergence where T'Challa, the warrior-king, has to give way to T'Challa, the hero, to save his people from themselves.
Shuri... does not address that her mother broke treaties and promises to share technology and resources, is returning to isolationism, and that the Wakandan foreign policy is being governed again by xenophobic distrust of the outside and secrecy that is threatening to turn the world against them. They can't tell the truth that they are in danger because... Wakanda is in danger? This would be an excellent context for Shuri to break the mold- to reach out for help, and going against her mother's well-meaning strength-in-isolationism- but no. The writing doesn't tie the hero's growth the nation's improvement, because there is no real growth here. There is a reversion to the unquestioned norm, and as an extension the state of Wakanda isn't changing either.
Wakanda, as a character, isn't exactly asserting itself either. No one expresses any opinions on the state of the monarchy's foreign policy, of the direction of the nation is going until it's an actual war council. The people of Wakanda are presented as generally conformist- not even the spark of rebelliousness that faced T'Challa in the challenge for the throne. The advisors are inconsequential early on, and literally dismissed later. Decisions are made for them more than by them as a people. Peasants are going by wooden boat while the royalty flies above them in tech-future spaceships. T'Challa is grieved by the people of Wakanda, but the people of Wakanda fleet their only real city after the first raid in modern memory which takes the queen. Wakanda is no longer an unquestioned superpower, the fundamentals of their assumed superiority dashed by an open an unequivicable defeat on their own home soil and then the deaths of many in a losing battle their princess took them to... but no one has any issues of the new losses, because Princess Shuri didn't let her grief drive revenge?
There are a lot of interesting things you could do here from a writing point. Wakanda is implicitly an incredibly stratified society. It's gone through a seminal moment of it's unquestioned supremacy not only being questioned, but overturned. They lost the battles, they lost their queen, and they've just lost the royal dynasty. It's isolated, and keeping the secrets that have murdered innocent citizens of other countries. You can make interesting stories with this.
But they won't, since that wasn't the goal here, and won't be the goal when the superhero teamup needs to happen.
Yup. Article 5 is thought of as the war clause, in large part because it was created with an unambiguous war in mind, but it doesn't actually require a war in response.
From the text, the agreement is that the members, if one of them is attacked,
will assist the Party or Parties so attacked by taking forthwith, individually and in concert with the other Parties, such action as it deems necessary, including the use of armed force
Armed force is an option, but not a requirement. 'Such action as it deems necessary' could include moving active air defense units to the border, or the movement of NATO forces, or a massive influx of military aid.
It's basically a politics/negotiation game between the members, which is part of the organizing principle of consultation. 'Individually and in concert' is the lee-way for the Americans/smaller groups to be able to act within the alliance without any one party sabotaging like in a unanimous consensus requirement, but a party invoking the articles can also have their concerns addressed in various ways, subject to the context and consultations. It's not a guarantee you'll get what you want (see, Turkey and Greece), but in this context the flexibility is precisely what doesn't necessitate NATO bombers and tanks moving on Moscow.
The problem here, I think, is simple to state, but devilishly complicated to solve: is NATO membership worthwhile?
What do you think the Polish view on the value of NATO is?
If things did unfold as it seems, then Russia is responsible for a military attack on a NATO country. If it's "accidental," Russia essentially has to sacrifice someone's head on a platter--even though there's no reason to think Putin wouldn't just send some of his own troops to take responsibility, to keep the West guessing. But if there is no reprisal, then Poland, at least, has to be asking, what's the point of belonging to NATO? NATO, the alliance that was specifically created to deter Russian military incursions?
The point of NATO is not to deter Russian military incursions. The point of NATO is that if the Russian military invades, the other members and the Americans destroy Russian battalions in such numbers that they will be removed and the member government restored. It is fundamentally not a deterence-only alliance, but an alliance for what happens after deterence fails.
This is a point where technical language can get conflated by casual use. A missile strike, even if true, wouldn't be an incursion. Nor does reprisal require military action unacceptable to the members of the alliance, ie disproportionate in scale. The value of a military alliance is not solely in deterrence. Etc.
On the other hand, if there is reprisal... maybe WW3?
Against what army where with what allies to justify the name?
Russia notably had 80% of its military forces in Ukraine before it was bringing the post-WW2 tanks out of storage, and was unable to supply invasion lines very far in a country that it shared rail gauge with. This is as a rail-dependent logistical system.
Meanwhile, the CSTO in the last few months ago wouldn't get involved in a minor border war between its own members. If not them, who is supposed to be allying with Russia to give a truly global scale of conflict? The Chinese?
A big NATO fight in Europe basically guarantees an attack-of-opportunity on Taiwan, and god-only-knows where else.
How does a NATO land war in Europe give the Chinese an opportunity they didn't already have to launch an amphibious invasion they're not prepared contested by the Pacific and Middle Eastern carrier groups that don't really have a role in a NATO-Russia conflict?
The US Army doesn't exactly have a key role in a Taiwan conflict, and the European navies even less so.
A year ago I'd probably have said "this is surely an accident and Russia is going to make that very clear very quickly, possibly with generous payments to next-of-kin." Today? I just don't know.
That's never been the Russian way under Putin. Malaysian Airlines Flight 12 is probably the best example here.
Indeed. It appears the fighting retreat was what was happening the last few weeks. And egg on my face for not raising that possibility either, despite some (admittedly contradictory) reports of partial withdrawals. It remains to be see how much was/was not withdrawn- there seems to be indications that some conscripts brought in to buffer the more experienced elements were left behind and told to basically do whatever, with many of them donning civilians and trying to go to ground in the city, but the consolidation of the west bank seems to be going on quickly. It remains to be seen how much was left behind, but... well, we shall see.
It's important to emphasize that the Dems didn't force Republicans to do anything. All they did was dangle the candidate's Republican bona fides with "oh no it sure would be terrible if this person that loves Trump and still thinks the election was stolen ends up being the nominee oh no" and voters agreed with them. Given how much of a resounding success this was for the Dems, I anticipate we'll see it again in the future.
I agree that we'll see it again, but strongly disagree that 'all they did' was dangle. Active interference with the internal workings of the opposition party isn't a bad idea in a functioning democracy because it 'forces' the opposition to do anything- it's because the purpose of such an intervention is to prevent the opposition from doing anything by keeping them out of power. The distinction is like claiming an induced convulsion doesn't prevent your muscles from working, and so isn't the same effect as induced paralysis. Steering crowds towards known allergens in a buffet and then deliberately making the alternatives look worse doesn't change a dynamic of food tampering just because someone could have chosen a different item. The actions taken were intended for an effect, and the moral onus of the effect lies with the person who instigated the action with the intent to cause that effect.
The fact that it works is not new. The reasons why it shouldn't be done are not new either. Even 'minimal' active interference in the internal workings of the opposition is a bad idea because it's the precedent/catalyst for more and other forms of active interference, the consistent success of which builds upon itself turns an opposition party into a state-managed (as opposed to state-run) opposition.
This is generally understood in other contexts to be a pretty banal means for authoritarians to degrade and defang democratic opposition parties.
If so, can the GOP do anything to immunize itself from this effort? Should it even try to?
The answer to the first is yes. You can immunize yourself to foreign influences by ruthlessly purging people associated with the influence vectors and, as possible, actively targetting the sources of influence until they can not or will not attempt further influence efforts along those lines. Since it is quite profitable for them to do so, targetting will be need to be highly coercive, and involve some mix of targeted violence, intimidation, and other forms of retaliation against not only the organizers, but their associates and friends and allies, until such people are isolated even within their own alliance networks and unable to execute and no one will want to be seen as emulating them. Such a campaign will need to sustained, actively circumvent efforts of the state dominated by the opposing party to prevent it, and generate popular momentum to continue targetting these people who happen to be fellow citizens of the country.
The answer to the second is that obviously many people, and not just those positively inclined towards the ruling party, would rather the opposition party not do that.
That's a pretty big bar. It's the single best explanation for this combination of maneuver and publicity.
I caution against the strength of this assessment. What we're seeing is compatible with this assessment, and it's not an unreasonable assessment, but it's also compatible with Russia having learned an important lesson from the retreat at Izyum, where they lost control of the narrative and received much more damage from an obviously pending issue because no one official could say what was obvious in the social media space, that the position was untenable. This combination of maneuver and publicity is absolutely taking control of the narrative in a way the Russians consistently try to influence, without the making-it-up-as-they-go-along that was a large part of what made Izyum a catastrophe.
A point to be made is that even if Kherson wasn't about to fall immediately but in the coming months, its nature of it as an untenable position has been generally recognized for some time. If even Putin can be made to recognize that- and implicitly this is a shared assumption in the negotiation hypothesis or else Putin wouldn't have a need to make a deal there- then even in the lack of an agreement, there would need to be maneuver and publicity to exit in as good order and with as much damage control as possible.
My guess is that it's part of initial secret diplomacy. The best evidence will be the ferocity (or lack thereof) of the Ukrainian attack now. If they smash the bridges and run six divisions into Kherson, capturing/killing large numbers of Russians, I'm wrong. If the fighting is light, but the Ukrainians make steady progress, then it's more likely talks.
The issue with this test is that smashing and running six divicisions into Kherson may not be within their capability. The Ukrainians weren't exactly days or maybe even weeks from breaking into Kherson before this announcement, and have been trying to smash the bridges for months with mixed effects at best.
There is also a domestic Ukrainian political consideration to consider. Kherson has been a significant meat-grinder for some time, and while the Ukrainians have made it work (as obvious output is now obvious), there's always a balance between pure military optimization (destroy as many Russians as fast as possible), and military-political strategy (not lose political support, by politicians or public, increasing the casualties of an already 'won' engagement that won't end the war). If the Ukrainians ran six divisions at Kherson, and got a bloody nose for the trouble but no appreciable change to the strategic balance of power, that would be both an internal liability, but also an external diplomatic liability.
And this is without the third level of meta-strategy on how to deal with the people who do want to try and leverage this into talks/peace settlements. Regardless of whether this evacuation is part of a deal, there are significant parts of the Western governments backing Ukraine who will seek to make it the basis of a deal and compel an armistice. This goes into a rabbit hole of competing theories/counter-theories and distinction of positions, but a point here is that if you are a Ukrainian maximalist, the key to success in the longer war isn't destroying the Russian forces located in Kherson now, but to sustain Western support long enough for a long war, and so operational maximalism is in tension with strategic optimization.
I’m inclined to think narrative control doesn’t really explain the outcomes.
To clarify, I don't think narrative control explains the outcomes, but rather narrative control explains the health of the political machine aparatus, which works to leverage other factors to explain the outcomes. It's not an allegation of direct control, but rather that it helped keep the party together.
Not fraud per see, but in the bag of (dirty?) tricks, I'll throw in 'supporting the primary candidates you plan to call a threat to democracy.'
This is pure strategy, though, and not election-day fraud. I view it as highly troublesome, as any sort of managed opposition strategy by incumbants is by definition state-meddling in opposition parties, but this is a broader tension between political parties in zero-sum competition than what you're referring to.
Washington Examiner article on Democratic influence in Republican primaries-
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/campaigns/democratic-meddling-republican-primaries-effective
Of course this means that the new defensive line is harder to crack, but really, at some point, you'd imagine sheer morale questions would make it hard for Russians to proceed, at least. Where will the Ukrainians push next?
Kherson, because bar any un-announced agreement between the Russians and Ukrains over the terms of withdrawal, this will be a fighting retreat. It remains in the Ukrainian interest to force the Russians to retreat under fire rather than in relatively good order. Some of the main crossings are within 10km from being in 'normal' artillery range, which would greatly increase the pain to the Russian retreat.
But for the rest of this winter? I wouldn't be terribly surprised if it's much lower tempo/scale meant to make the Russian conscripts miserable rather than make a major breakthrough. Winter is well and here, and while it's not been the worst winter, the Ukrainians have been having as much trouble as anyone else in the relatively favorable southern terrain. There's also plenty of media of the Ukrainians having shot through their artillery barrels from over-use, they have indeed taken significant attrition in the units that were committed to Kherson that will need to be reorganized/reset/retrained, and so on. Plus, it's November. I wouldn't say it will be a quiet winter, but I wouldn't be surprised if the Ukrainians take an operational pause of about a month just to reset from Kherson, and then they'll face the decision of starting something in the middle of winter before Christmas, and of course the potential season of mud.
Given the timelines, and the ongoing western training/equipping pipelines, I wouldn't be surprised for a major offensive after the season of mud (which is not the same across the country, and would support an earlier offensive in the south than the north).
More interesting to me is the Russian side of this.
For one, Putin actually capitulated to his leadership advocating the retreat. This was probably the influence of General Sergei Surovikin, the former commander of Russian forces in Syria and who had (or retained) a good reputation with Putin and was brought in to take over last month. Surovikin succeeding where the Defense Ministry had failed for some time, but also overcoming the hardliners who had insisted escalation (which had included conscription) were needed to avoid the appearance of future defeats, is revealing.
For a second, just as the Ukrainians have reason for an overall pause, so do the Russians. The Russians have put conscripts around the fronts already, but many have also been put into training regimines as the Russians try to re-build their training organization infrastructure. A few months of relative lull can get the Russians from the embarassment of totally untrained conscripts to a maybe minimally trained, and have basic defenses prepared through the winter, etc.
Third and finally, an operational lull is likely the last/best chance Putin will have to force an armistice/truce/peace and turn this into a frozen conflict along post-Kherson lines. The Russians have been targetting Ukrainian energy infrastructure and are likely to continue, which hasn't yet caused a grid collapse but eventually would/could if they keep throwing enough drones at it. While the European energy card has failed to meet the pre-war expectations of what a cutoff would entail, being a major pain instead of a catastrophe, breaking the Ukrainian energy grid and leveraging that with other options might be seen as a way to compel the unicorn of European forcing a pro-Russia settlement at a point when Russia probably has the most relevant territory it has going forward.
This is a window, however, and I admit to being bear-ish on its prospects, because as the Europeans bring more energy and energy import infrastructure online in the coming months, the Russian leverage drops.
Or, in the case of Israel, the capacity for its neighbors to never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity due to internal political dynamics that are in no small part driven by geographic and geological features that were old when homo sapiens were young.
I won't be surprised if Republican states and legislatures start pushing more and more similar measures through in the next two years.
Fraud implies malicious intent, not mere incompetence or bad luck.
The thing about this framing, however, is that malicious fraud would always try to present itself as incompetence if caught, while only incompetent fraud would fail to do so, thus demonstrating it's incompetence.
From a systemic rigging perspective, incompetence itself can be the method by which a malicious actor might operate. If you are politically biased human resource allocator, sending your most competent, capable, and credible vote-facilitators to your partisan base to gather and protect the votes, but sending the lazy, the incompetent, and all-round worst mailman who leaves the back of the truck unlocked to go collect from the enemy neighborhood is... well, not fraud, by definition, but it's a definition that proves too much. 'I'm not facilitating fraud, I'm just bad at election security' is a distinction without a difference.
Now, there's no clear line that covers the premise of election shinanigans that fraud overlaps with- or at least, I don't have one that's broadly agreed upon- but that's what makes it such a useful (or hated) motte-and-bailey. Fraud is whatever the person making the argument needs it to mean at the time, from both directions.

There are other formatting issues on the pages- RAND doesn't usually put their symbol, or date and (mis-)classification on the Executive Summary page- but I will note that the roman numerals itself isn't off.
RAND regularly has a numbering divide between the main-body of a report, and the pre-body pages that include the copyright page, the agenda, but also the executive summary. Pre-main body material will be in roman numerals, with main body reports in arabic characters. The 'missing' pages would likely have been the Agenda and the Methodology pages... but the implication they were only a page each, on an executive summary this length, is itself a red flag.
More options
Context Copy link