Dean
Flairless
Variously accused of being a hilarious insufferable reactionary post-modernist fascist neo-conservative neo-liberal conservative classical liberal critical theorist Nazi Zionist imperialist hypernationalist NATO-consensus warmongering isolationist Jewish-Polish-Slavic-Anglo race-traitor masculine-feminine bitch-man idiosyncratic party-line Fox News boomer. No one yet has guessed a scholar, or multiple people. Add to our list of pejoratives today!
User ID: 430
Ambivalent emotions about the American election watching from abroad. Figured I'd just note them here.
I am less surprised than underwhelmed. From a distance/superficial level, the results don't seem to match what I was vaguely tracking as the polling trends, which is to say I was expecting the Republicans to do better in general, but in various places I'm not surprised they didn't since local variance and some such, and really they only needed to underperform in a few places to change the swing. Some reports that suggest the Democrats overperformed expectations makes me more inclined to think political polling is generally bad, but I am curious on what the data will show- and where the anamolous surprises are. I guess I'm trying to say I'm more surprised that Fetterman won than Oz lost, if that makes sense.
I'm not particularly curious or interested in any current allegations of -insert shenanigans here-, as much as sighing that ballot control measures appear to have been as bad as ever and so people will conflate an inability to detect with a lack of detection. Undated mail-in ballot saga in PA is probably one of those two-screens divides on whether you take fraud-control seriously. But- on the assumption that the results are legitimate I'm pegging three main reasons the Democrats only lost badly and not terribly.
(Yes, I consider losing the house meaning the Democrats lost, which it looks likely to happen even if Senate control doesn't. I mention framing below.)
1: The summer information campaign and early voting synergized
Post-Roe emotional highs and the friendly media coverage over Ukraine and summer were enough to draw in Democratic engagement were sustained long enough to translate into early voting, before the loss of narrative control let the economy dominate sentiment in the last weeks. Even if voter engagement was only in the form of 'fill out ballot now, mail-in later', engaging people outside of the final media cycles would have engaged them on much more favorable information terrain. We'll probably never know the party distribution of ballots based on time, but I'd be surprised if Democrats didn't do significantly better earlier than later.
A trade-off of this, however, is that I think this is non-repeatable/reliable per see. The denial phase of the economy is over, and I think that was far more important for enabling summer high-energy than the Democratic culture war issues themselves. Affirmative action will be unlikely to have the same kick, and have longer to dissapate. That said, people like to say COVID broke people's brains, and I'll not be surprised if the 'because of COVID I'll only do mail-in voting' demographic becomes a campaign reality, as the sort of people who would use COVID as a reason for absentee ballots at this point are probably atypical media consumers and atypical for the time they commit their votes.
2: The Democrat finger on the Trump primary candidates worked well enough (or was just lucky)
Infamously, Hillary tried to boost Trump because she thought it would support him. From various pieces I saw over the primary season, some efforts were made at that this go around, usually in trying to ease the way for them. I'm not particularly certain it was ever decisive per see as much as a finger on the scales that may not have been necessary, but the 'hope the outrageous candidate wins the primary (and maybe give them an aid),' a classic strategy, worked well enough often enough. As I said, I'm not surprised someone like Oz lost, and it only takes/took a few candidates failing to create a significant swing in the senate.
Edit after- a Washington Examiner article on 9NOV, "Democratic midterm meddling in Republican primaries worked but not perfectly" is a recount of various examples. While the editorial position is hardly lauding, it raises the point of how elevating weak candidates is an accepted strategy.
Since I still not not see a link embed button on this forum, link below
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/campaigns/democratic-meddling-republican-primaries-effective
3: Media framing helped set a stage the encouraged donor/base engagement early, and changed what would be considered serious defeat
I raised above I feel the summer friendly media environment- when there was a lot less cynicism about the economy, and more rally about Ukraine/abortion/etc/ helped juice the early voter turnout via mail-in, but it also supported expectation management in ways that helped boost the Democratic prospects. I no longer have exactly when it was, but there was a point in the summer where a number of the Democratic-aligned major media pre-emptively approached the election with a winner mentality rather than what was building as a doomer mentality. I'm not in a state to really expound, except that by creating even false motivation, they were able to keep the party system working together long enough to suffice for real motivation, which kept the donor checks coming and the activits engaged instead of depressed and inactive. Losing optimism/motivation is one of the death-spirals of a campaign movement, and just delaying that would help pad the war chest, which enabled significant spending.
But, even when the narrative flipped to the more doomer perspective of a Red Wave, I think it flipped to the other extreme, such that by not being the the worst-case scenario, even a poor performance could look good by contrast to the expectation, and thus a win. At this time of writing, the sentate is still up in the air... but somehow, losing the House but keeping the Senate is framing in some areas as 'Republicans lost.' There is, indeed, an argument to be made 'you should have won this'... but I dispute that the Red Wave 'should' have been expected as a matter of course. Red Wave wasn't the 'should' from 12, 8, or even 5 months ago. The numbers bandied about a year ago that I remember were... within two-to-three senate races. We are now... within two-to-three senate races. We'll see the final numbers, and the specific reasons why where, but assuming the conclusions is still a flaw even when in false-modesty. 'We should have lost worse, but we didn't, so really we won' is a cope that's assisted by a media inclined to inaccurate extremes.
Or, to reframe- early on, a supportive media environment kept the party machine churning better than it would have with early despair. Later on, catastrophic reframing allowed a non-catastrophic defeat to be portrayed as victory.
All of this may be too early, or turn out to be wrong in hindsight, but what's a musing if not to put a prediction to look back on?
Now, I am interested- and curious- what the final demographic totals are. Various points of change in recent polling suggested white women, hispanics, and even blacks going more towards the Republicans than expected in recent weeks. If those are trends, and more importantly trends that continue, reasons that apply above may easily not be sufficient next time... especially if it is literally Biden on the ballot, rather than a lot of local-man-versus-trump-proxy.
Or maybe Trump will be on the ballot. Who knows.
The Maricopa County shitshow: the alt-right and conspiracy boards were lighting up about Dominion vote tabulators not accepting ballots in a big Republican section of Arizona.
Detroit voters were stunned to be told they’d already voted absentee.
Some Pennsylvania voters whose mail-in ballots were rejected for errors were notified in time to cast an in-person ballot, some weren’t notified, and some were told they couldn’t cast a provisional ballot to replace it.
All in all, “red wave barely a ripple, Trumpism refuted, cope and seethe more” will once again be met with “y’all cheated, just give us a year to figure out how.”
Would any of these be conceded as voter fraud even if they are proven true?
Over the last couple of years, there was more than one appeal to semantics on what was / was not fraud, to dismiss irregularities/concerns as not fraud, and thus accusations of fraud baseless.
The jokes almost write themselves at that point.
Ironically, you would think that Catholics would not lump these two together, given how often they get accused of idolatry towards saints and icons of saints.
Isn't how often they get accused of idolatry increasing the likelihood of other forms of idolatry in other forms?
Of course, it's a perfectly valid meta-level take... assuming it rests on some substance, such as there having been some earlier interaction when sources one can reasonably deem high-quality had been presented; and that's a big assumption which does not match my recollection of this discourse. That said –
you can find the link yourself, thank you kindly, and if you can't then this goes back to competence rather than faith
My recollection is probably retarded anyway.
Not that specific link, but for some of what was being referenced to in the thread chain were same-day postings by
motteposting
anti-dan had some relevant sources
There are some other posters there who are referring to then-contemporary news or events.
Further, that was a post chain that started from a position of explicitly referring to multiple prior exchanges. Reminder that this was 31May thread, so about 5 and 1/2 months after 6Jan, with nearly a third of a year of information degredation on the reporting contemporary to 6Jan itself, and over half a year since the election, with even more about the reporting (and prior culture war threads) about that.
And since navigating that chain is a nightmare, but since I may apparently need it in the future, the root-thread- including higher-level exchanges before what ymeskhout likes to link to but which cover the lead-up that was summarized- is here
Thanks to you and @Dean both for lessons in Advanced English.
My loquaciousness in english is proportional to my state of mind.
Okay, you get some slack because of our unofficial, unwritten policy of being more lenient with people giving mods shit than non-mods (even when they are arguing with a mod who is speaking in a non-mod capacity) but directly calling someone a liar is always going to cross the line unless you can unambiguously prove that the person you're accusing is in fact lying. From my perspective, what you have here is a failure to communicate. I don't doubt you genuinely believe that @ymeskhout is a liar. However, I do doubt that @ymeskhout believes he is a liar.
The reason I call him lying now, but not before, is specifically because he specifically (and has repeatedly) quotes a post (the May21 post and thread) that says why I no longer provide him with sources, and then claims I provide him no reason, but also that my reason is something else. This is not the first time he's pulled this particular phrasing (not my job to educate you) either, or the first time it's been clarified that, no, the reason is in what he is quoting. He then repeats the same claim, and the same wonderment, at the next opportunity.
The first time could be a misinterpretation (hence why it was initially described as a flaw), the second time a miscommunication, the third even a sloppy strawman, but after the fourth or fifth exchange of a saved post being re-raised in the right way it ceases to be credible that it's accidental. Consistent misrepresentation of text and position, especially after multiple clarification, indicates will.
The charge of lying, to be clear, is specially for how he uses the May 21 quote chain he keeps on hand. I do not consider his flaw of conflating different conversations into a single narrative to be a lie, just a flaw, except when it engages in willful misrepresentation of the specified quoting.
I am not going to dig through all of your back-and-forths line by line to extract the exact phrase that you contend was a willful mistatement of the truth (and for which I would then have to dig through probably two years of previous conversations in order to render judgment on whether it is in fact a lie).
No need, since the lie accusation specific to this week, but I understand (and agree with) the premise behind this decision. I, too, would prefer (/expect/respect) focusing on behavioral trends rather than re-litigate past months of packed weeks of material.
Which is ironically relevant to this dispute, since demands to relitigate past months of culture war exchanges was one of the points that led to the assessment he cites.
Here's a very simple rule which we have always enforced: don't make personal attacks. You are certainly verbally adroit enough to get your point across without calling someone a liar, and if that sounds like "You can say you don't think someone is being honest as long as you don't outright call them a liar," that's correct. Attack the position, attack the words, point out what you perceive to be the contradictions. That leaves the ball in the other person's court, and they can then either rebut, clarify, or say nothing and let the audience be the judge.
I understand and accept this chastisement in the spirit it is intended.
I also note that the exchange that started this exchange this week was a response to boo-outgroup remarks that would be personal attacks were the people who'd stopped engaging him still around. (This is where we get the evaporative cooling point from in the separate thread this week, which was not a response as I walked away.)
But your hostility has ticked past the "slightly heated" phase and seems to be entering "personal grudge" territory, so cool it.
I will try, but it would probably help if the mod in question stopped trying to pull saved-quote-jutsu to misrepresent the same saved quote.
I didn't trust them long before this. They have given me no reason to trust them. The media's credibility has nosedived since 2015 when Trump became a threat , but even before it was bad.
My own personal... awakening? endarkening?- to American political media was a period in the early 2000s where CNN and such has a partisan distinction in how they reported political scandals on the talking head segment headers and intros. Generally, if a politician scandal was about a Republican, it would front-end 'Republican' or Name(R), where the party was obvious and in the framing. If it was a Democrat, however, the party affiliation was often buried into the body and not on the TV text, so things like 'Congressman in scandal' or 'Senator Name'.
There was also a (less consistent) trend of order of affiliation when bipartisan good or bad news occurred. If it was good news, Democrats and Republicans. Bad news was more often Republicans and Democrats. Democrats offered reforms, Republicans cuts or changes, etc.
Hello everyone, I continue to have no idea what Dean is talking about, either in the post above or in the many responses to me (ex. most recently here). I know that Dean does not like it when I talk about 2020 election fraud theories, but I have no idea exactly why. This is a saga that has been going on for almost two years now, and I keep linking to this exchange in May 2021 as illustrative.
Indeed it is, and as said before I maintain it is more condemning of you than defending. To quote from the May 21 you link to-
It was a reflection of your reoccuring flaw on this topic, which is to conflate far too diverse circumstances and contexts into a nominal narrative that ignores or dismisses people's actual positions/concerns while presenting a viewpoint they don't hold as the undisputed reality.
I maintain this is the case, because you are continuing to do this in your attempt to defend against it.
For example, Dean accused me of being selective with what theories I cover. When I asked which ones I should pay attention to, his responses were: "I'm not particularly interested in trying to feed you sources to be judged by you on your standards on credibility to consistency standards you impose that helpfully weed out things other people might care about and could even be true." and "I am uninterested in providing you sources on other people's positions given your conduct on this topic."
I don't know if I'm off-base here, but this reads to me as "It's not my job to educate you" which does not strike me as helpful or productive. Does anyone disagree with my interpretation?
Yes, and claims of ignorance like this is why I doubt your good faith.
I have, by your own link that you keep referring to, stated that I am uninterested in providing you sources on other people's positions given your conduct on the topic. What is my allegation of your conduct on the topic? My characterization of your conduct is- per the May 21 link- your reoccuring flaw to conflate far too diverse circumstances and contexts into a nominal narrative that ignores or dismisses people's actual positions/concerns while presenting a viewpoint they don't hold as the undisputed reality.
Your very response is to conflate different circumstances (quotations, in this case) to ignore a stated position, and assign a position I do not hold.
In this very citation paragraph you engage in this. The very reason of why I do not provide you sources is in your link, because of your conduct. Which you conflate with... 'it is not my job to educate you.'
My position is not that it is not my job to educate you. Stop lying about the position not only given to you, but that you cite.
I still continued trying to figure exactly what I should do differently. When I asked if focusing on Trump's theories was valid, Dean claimed accused me of incompetence and bad faith because "you are supposed to know that a lot of what Trump says is nonsense no matter what he talks about"
Oh, hey, conflating past conversations for a unified narrative. I'm sure that the actual context had no meddlesome distinctions from any other discussion, such as the literal versus serious dynamic that was relevant around Trump, or specific Trump messages in the context they were provided.
and then I'm accused of lying about something (no idea what exactly): "In two sentences you have given what could be called lies about other peoples positions already given to you. This faux ignorance of other people's posts made just hours or minutes ago, and significant mis-representation of what has already been given to you, robs an exchange of sources or justifications of any value."
Clearly a sentence that internally references other posts made at the time is has no missing context that is being ommitted for the sake of a narrative here and now.
I've confessed that I don't know what I'm supposed to do differently. I mean, besides adopting Dean's preferred conclusions of course. Short of that, can ANYBODY provide ANY insight into the specific concerns and what EXACTLY I should do differently? I love feedback! Especially when I can understand it.
Sure. Stop lying.
Stop lying about other people's positions are when they give it to you. Stop lying about people having never given you other arguments in the past. Stop lying that you haven't been provided insight into the specific concerns.
If you can't understand what someone says, confess incapability. If you can't remember what someone said, or find where it was, confess the failures of memory or recordkeeping. If you can't accept what other people say as valid, you won't be able to confess that sort of failing by its nature, but lack of selfawareness is no reason to lie about not being given reasons in the past.
To stop doing the flaw you have been described as having, stop conflating far too diverse circumstances and contexts into a nominal narrative that ignores or dismisses people's actual positions/concerns while presenting a viewpoint they don't hold.
Now, I have no expectation of you doing such, and fully expect you to pull out the May 21 link the next go around to go 'why has she never told me', instead of this, but that's only because this is, what, the fourth exchange on this subject where you ask the same questions about why you've never been given an answer?
I would caution against making this a rule. People often don't think highly of their opponents, and motivated reasoning is easy (its's not that my arguments are terrible, it's just that nothing will change his mind!) Sometimes the better the opponent's arguments are, the more that people react like this--bad arguments can be shrugged off, but good arguments from your opponent are infuriating.
If you're going to do it, at least be able to point to a place where the argument has been addressed before.
In general respects, I would agree, but as a more general rule, I don't keep lists of previous arguments for citation purposes, as that way lays madness, and weird portfolio lists. Knowing why you disagree enough to disengage, but then letting out of sight and out of mind, is better practice. This is especially so in not-archive-friendly thread chains, like reddit threads.
Like Iconochasm, I didn't read the commenting as suggesting you do that, as much as that you could.
Now, I am not the person you were asking, have no personal sense of your practices, and so can't speak to your habbits, but if you were serious about seeking general suggestions...
'Be less aggressive' is probably the best advice if you raise it for yourself. That doesn't mean not having your position, but don't burn bridges for random encounters, and express a intellectual humilitary that acknowledges how you could be wrong, especially if it leaves a way for the other person to maybe be partially right.
For most/more casual people, overkill is worse than just enough. Providing context- rather than a direct challenge- is far less intimidating, and it doesn't need to be patronizing either. 'You might be interested in reading X, Y, Z' is a much more engaging way than 'You obviously hadn't read X, Y, Z.' A summation of points is better than filibustering and gish-galloping. Not addressing every point- and just being clear you're only addressing a few points for Reasons- makes an engagement more of a redirection (had you considered this/this isn't supported by other things) than a full body tackle (let me tell you how each and every one of your points is wrong). There are absolutely some people you should engage more for public audience perception than individual persuasion (ie, bad faith actors), but if you just think someone is wrong, it's rarely worth it to rub their nose in it. Unless, again, you're very explicit and deliberately deciding to write off future engagement with them.
Similarly, being generous with your own limited understanding- not in a 'I can't see how reasonable people could see that', but 'my own difficulties are in the nuances of X, Y, and Z'- can be a good salve, especially if it just-so-happens overlays with someone's interest/point. 'I believe you're wrong about much of what you say, but this is one area you may be right and I wrong' is a good way to offer a face saving exit to the other person, while presenting two tokens of respect to them. First, you recognize what they do right, not just disagree about what they do wrong. Second, you offer the respect of acknowledging your own limits, and that you might have something to learn from... if not them, then someone they might have read from, or respect in turn. This builds a different sort of dynamic, of senior-junior rather than master-novice, with a far less domineering tone. To pick a personal example, there are many cases when international politics come around that US-skeptic/anti-US people will do what I see as jumping to a conclusion that the US is to blame for [incident X]. Even if I disagree, I'm often willing to concede 'well, I wouldn't be surprised' in the mix of 'but all these other points really don't work.'
For the timing of your hobby horse, it's probably good to not jump into every thread/discussion on it- at least not to argue- but really just not being a one trick animal. Throw in a little variety in there- an effort post about something else, a piece of reflection not about your hobby, even some pop culture or something funny- just to prove you have other interests, and aren't obsessed about this One Thing.
Which- to reiterate- I don't think you are, because I don't have enough of an opinion on you to have an opinion. (Other than I read your ask as sincere, which I respect, as opposed to false-humility, which I don't.)
Bot? No insight, but I'd be surprised if TheMotte didn't track on someone's social-media target board. There's following the news, but then there's also following a party line as it changes in response to the news, and that can be much more insightful. Once you can identify what an organization's line is, tracking how fast people map to it (ie, hours as opposed to days) can be an indication of whether they're following a change in conversation, or trying to lead it in conjunction with other controlled actors.
If it seems surprising that anyone would try to propagandize the Motte, don't be. Not only has the motte been a place of organized troll efforts, but as a descendant of Scott Alexander's blog- one in which national-visiblity figures used to post under their own name or were known to have read- it's not exactly a 'nobody who would ever influence anything would ever come here' environment.
What is going on with how colonialism worked in its heyday versus how difficult it seems to be to conquer and control other countries nowadays?
Back in the heyday, tiny little England controlled something like a quarter of the world, off and on during various periods, including such areas as all of India, most of the Middle East, the original American 13 colonies, Canada, Australia, sometimes hunks of China, various large hunks of Africa, etc. The somewhat larger France controlled other hunks of North America, a bunch of Caribbean islands, large chunks of Africa, and the Middle East, etc. Even tinier Belgium, with a modern-day population of only 11 million, had some pretty big colonies in Africa that they controlled. At the time, they (mostly) seemed to have little trouble controlling these colonies for centuries, sometimes with mostly peaceful means and sometimes with quite brutal violence.
Meanwhile nowadays, mighty continent-striding America can barely keep Iraq and Afghanistan under control for a decade or two. Russia had little better luck in Afghanistan and mostly hasn't done too well in controlling areas other than tiny regions on their borders already at least partially populated with Russians. China doesn't seem to be doing much better. All of the former colonial superpowers can now barely dream of controlling a single hostile city overseas. The British stretched themselves to the limit trying to take the Falklands back, and managed to hold I think it was a city or a small region in Iraq with a lot of help from America. I think France intervened briefly in Mali a decade or so ago, with only limited success.
What were they faced with today as opposed to three hundred years ago?
A blunt point is that while the colonized parts of the world were not devoid of people, much of the parts that were colonized first and fastest were devoid of strong governments. The Americas endured a nigh-apocalyptic plague of new world diseases after Cortez brought them over, crippling much of the western hemisphere. Sub-saharan africa has a variety of 'it is hard to build major civilization' here factors- from river distribution to tropic diseases to rainfall inconsistency. Asia certainly had more established governments- but these were also the last to fall vis-a-vis the 'weaker' areas. Later colonization periods of Asia were about breaking apart the Chinese tributary system, and even in the middle of the colonial era a large part of colonization was playing local powers off each other for the outsider's interest. IE, a disunited political resistance, many of which would only adopt nationalistic collective identities later.
But the means of resistance also changed. Cortez, who had advanced (for the era) meta armor and guns, was leading a rebellion against a state with arrows and bludgeons. European guns and armor were often facing natives with arrows and less armor, who could only hope to gets guns... from the Europeans. By comparison, in the 2000s Iraq, Americans were facing routine use explosives that once could have been used to siege castles walls, small arms that could easily pierce the armors of Cortez's age, rocket-propelled grenades that would eviscerate the sort of mass-disciplined formations of the colonizer eras, which themselves were better than less-massed, less-disciplined formations of the less-organized governments.
The single biggest point of change, aside from the change in ideas as nationalist-independence movements began to spread in the face of European weakness after WW1, was the rise of the Soviet Union, and it's flood of support for nationalist-rebel communist groups. In colonized parts of the globes, nationalist movements and communist movements had significant overlap in opposing colonial empires. With the Soviet Union being a functionally untouchable, peer technological base, the colonial empires weren't facing tribal confederations with worse weapons and no industrial base- they were facing groups with access to contemporary-quality weapon systems and par with conventional military weapons. The Soviets were far from alone in this, of course, but once all the major powers are providing 'modern' weapons, the capabilities of any resistance group go up significantly.
While the Soviet era weapons are now considered 'old' by contemporary standards, that just means 'not as capable,' not 'incapable.' An RPG-7 can still blow up a lightly armored vehicle, or a modern helicopter, if it hits. A heavy machine gun needs serious armor to resist, and that sort of protection is uneconomical to place everywhere. 'Old' doesn't mean 'won't kill you,' but the colonial era's ability to conquer and hold key areas was predicated on their ability to not-be-killed at economical rates that made colonization profitable.
In a contaminated media environment filled not only with not only bad-faith actors, but poor-capability ones? Heavens no.
To pick one recent example of how sub-par framing distorts discussion-
To the extent that I think that the picture ymeskhout is presenting is false, the proper response is to put together a detailed argument, backed by the best supporting evidence I can dig up, on exactly how and why he's unambiguously wrong.
I am no stranger to arguing with bad-faith bullshit. This is not what bad-faith bullshit looks like. This is, near as I can tell, what being wrong looks like. The proper response to that is to admit it and take your lumps like a grownup. The proper response to that is to admit it and take your lumps like a grownup. If you can't do that, if you don't actually value seeing misconceptions corrected, you're acting like a jackass, and ymeskhout is doing this place a tremendous service to make that fact as obvious as possible, with bonus points for style.
Here's what I've seen so far in the recent Jan 6th threads:
The single word in the third section that undermines all the rest is the qualifier 'recent.' Recent does not negate the iterative game-nature of people's engagement of a topic, and basing an argument only on the most recent action is less an isolated demand for rigor, as much as a demand for isolated rigor.
Just as any analysis of the Jan 6th legitimacy is fatally flawed if separated from the nature of election-law changes and documented coordination between partisan activists, government officials, and media groups to support that party before the election (and admitted afterwards- you can find the link yourself, thank you kindly, and if you can't then this goes back to competence rather than faith), a discussion on motte posting dynamics in the present is missing something very significant if it doesn't address that this isn't just a 'recent' exchange, it's someone who brought their pet hobby horse into the themotte.org after an established history, and pattern, of the same. A pattern that- as you say- did increasingly little to change minds, and the number of people who maintained engagement with said individual gradually declined. They did not stop doing so because exhaustive links to specific incidents or contexts of concern were disproven and overturned by the power of logic, they did so because over time they realized there was no point in engaging in such a way. The people whose minds could be shifted were already shifted; the people who could not were not going to be.
This is not what being wrong looks like. This is what evaporative cooling looks like, when the only people remaining to make effort-posts are the most-motivated. You may as well ask why Julius's Motte opposing arguments decreased in quality, when by the end he was probably the source of more warnings and kickings than meaningful counter-arguments.
Which, actually, is a better substitute-person for your argument, since it's clear where your sympathies are on this context but your broader point- if it's to be valid- needs to be valid for not just the people you think are in the right, but also wrong. Just as a justice system isn't for the people we sympathize for, a critique of the quality of engagement on the motte needs to address what engagement expectations realistically are.
One of the issues Julius B-something, or highschool-is-slavery McGee, or whatever his various alts were- wasn't simply that he was a bad faith actor, it was that he was just bad, as in incompetent, in both communication and scholarly skills, but he was only ever open to changing one of those. (The writing part, to be clear- so that he could be a better sophist in selling his point.) The people who were more familiar with the scholarship did not, in fact, respond to every Julius post with yet another immaculate sourced response decisively proving he was wrong... after the first few times. They gradually stopped replying at all, leaving him unchallenged except for the likes of less-scholared (and more prone to banning) people, for the sheer fact that he just kept posting. Once people knew what he was posting, and what he was going to continue posting regardless of what was said, and that saying so would make no difference...
By your framework, the point that after a year or so Julius B-whatever ended up with opponents like BestIrishGirl Ame who got in more trouble for opposing him rudely and who weren't able to really engage on a evidence level was a failure point of the community. With only a modicrum of twsting, Julius was providing a community service even, for exposing the jackasses, and overcoming them with style. (And endurance.)
I must dissent. And not simply because who is the asshole, or who has the style, is a subjectivity that does more to reflect the evaluator's preferences than the subject. Or that low-quality responses still serve a valid role in challenging motte-and-bailey arguments that would otherwise go uncontested for lack of engagement of at all, but be expected to continue indefinitely and shape the expectations of the forum as a whole if completely unchallenged.
I must dissent because recognizing when [insert actor here] has [pet topic x] for which they are sufficiently fixed in their views to negate the value of engagement, not engaging with their argument is the appropriate way to deal with [insert actor here]. Engagement on their preferred passion project really is a waste of time for all involved, it is an invitation for angry rebuttals and accusations of bad faith more likely to draw censor themselves than the actual person of bad-faith-but-is-polite-about-it, and it's not apparently changing the minds of anyone involved. By not engaging [pet topic x] directly, you can instead address other topics of possible mutual engagement (Julius's poor writing skills), or provide general signalling to the broader audience of what, and why, the risk of engaging the person is so that they are aware of the dynamics and risks at play.
I don't think I'm alone in this either- you're doing a similar dynamic, in this particular post, whether you intended to or not. You're speaking broadly, generally, and non-specifically about unnamed posters, and without source citations or evidence to boot. You're not calling out individuals, or confronting them in long exchanges. You're doing a relatively limited, relatively polite, dismissal of their arguments without engaging them directly, and doing so with a broader intent to shape the broader discourse, but no real expectation of affecting the individual(s) in question.
(And how could they? Many may not even realize you're referring to them.)
Per any model where conclusively proving your opponents are wrong every time is the right way, this is the wrong way. But as a model for engaging- or rather, not-engaging- with individuals for whom not-engaging is not only the path chosen, but attempting to marginalize through rhetoric rather than counter-evidence is the way, this is fine. You can call people jackasses or losers without being in violation of the Motte's rules if you're sufficiently vague, and that's fine. (It'd be pretty unenforcable otherwise.) Far be it for me to tell you otherwise.
But to do this, you had to make a decision on whether the person or group of persons was a good-enough actor (faith, competence, whatever) to pursue engagement going forward, or so bad that you instead began a general effort of isolating the sort of individuals in the community, so that they do not remain as unchallenged in their bailey as in an otherwise pleasant motte. Yes, this accelerates the process of evaporative cooling, where eventually only the assholes or the obsessives engage. But evaporative cooling around a poster is not the problem, it is product of the mitigation process, and more importantly the mitigation process is itself the consequence of prior patterns and past history.
Which comes back to not just what is recent, but what previous trends established the pattern of treating people like infohazards, or possibly Julius B-somethings.
Kronan Da Kunnin has interesting things about the implications of loot distribution matricies in a teef-based economy.
Perun seems to have taken off by doing just that. Though maybe less autistic, and more defense-economist-turned-strategy-game-youtuber-turned-defense-economist-youtuber.
But the overlap between build-strategy and force generation strategy is actually pretty strong.
If compact districts favoured Republicans as much as you think they do, then Republican legislatures would draw maps with compact districts. The fact that Republicans are drawing salamander-shaped districts suggests that the bias inherent in compact districts (which is real) isn't enough to satisfy them.
...or that there are other considerations in play, such as that it's been illegal for them to do so for some time, in large part because of the Voting Rights Act of 1965, which mandated racial demographic consideration (a requirement for gerrymander) and federal approval of changes (an obstacle to breaking it). Federal preclearance was only voided for a number of Republican-controlled states in 2013. There has literally only been 1 census cycle, and one congressional district reorientation, since then.
At which point you not only have the specter of (already ongoing) lawfare, but the secondary implications of working from the inertia of already-existing political subdivisions, like state counties, which themselves are often the anchoring points of congressional districts, and the political power structures that exist within and amongst these that interacts with what the legislatures can do. Even if an entire legislature was held by the Republicans, just the nature of the patronage network disruption and individual self-interests would make it a fratricide-heavy environment to pick the winners and choosers.
Surely it makes a difference that "some dude" is a person in an official position whose job is, at least in part, to dispense accurate information about this. If anyone did anything wrong here it's them.
And yet, that doesn't absolve you from following the law.
If an undercover cop tells you to commit a crime, it's still a crime.
If a military officer gives an illegal order, it's still an illegal order.
If a bureaucrat gives you the wrong application form, it's still the wrong application form.
Legitimacy doesn't derives from the government authority, nor does government authority alone absolve one from following the legitimate rules of society.
I guess the disagreement is largely about what kind of mens rea requirement should hold here. I don't see why voting illegally should be a strict liability thing like you apparently do, especially if the underlying goal is to prevent *intentional *voter fraud (though such votes should not be counted, if there's a way to enforce that without de-anonymizing them). Doing it with conscious intent, sure.
If claiming ignorance was a shield from all other laws, this might hold water, but without it it's a selective appeal for magic words. If you operate a law that only those who know the law perfectly beforehand can be penalized for, then it's not a law, it's a legal cludgeon for selective application of when 'should' applies to 'should have known.'
But I did, in the same post above you're replying to. If DeSantis was serious about actual voter fraud, I don't have an explanation for why he'd choose to make a public spectacle of people who were misled by his administration and dragging them to jail.
This would be credibility-boosting confession of failure, were it not intended to pretend to humility.
Given your past ruts on this topic with similar tendencies of not acknowledging contrary evidence...
We've been over this so so many times by now, and this exchange from May 2021 remains the most illustrative. I ask questions and your response is along the lines that it's not your job to educate me.
Oh, hey, look- linking to an argument that charged you with conflating information sets to dismiss the grounding of other people's prior arguments as non-existent...
You either have specific arguments to make or you don't.
...to conflate information sets to dismiss the grounding of other people's prior arguments as non-existent.
When the charge is you dismiss previous arguments and treat them as having never existed, dismissing previous arguments to treat them as having never existed is certainly illustrative, but also demonstrative.
I get that you don't like it when I talk about the 2020 election fraud theories, you've made that abundantly clear! What I don't get is why you keep wasting time on this beat.
Raising attention to your poor conduct and worse competencies on this topic is not time wasted.
Your projecting your opinions onto other people's evaluations is one of your consistent analytic flaws that deserves noting to warn others not already familiar with your tendencies.
If you don't have any, or you just refuse to make them out of principle, vaguely complaining is not going to accomplish anything. I'm not a mind reader, and you can't expect me to respond to arguments you choose to keep cloistered in your head.
Based on your past- and still present- conduct, I don't expect you to respond to arguments in good faith at all, and I consider it sound reminder to newer members of the community to be aware of this for the same reason the best advice to give anyone during the Julius saga was to warn those unfamiliar to move on.
given your frequent shills for your private substack and the financial interests in catering to your desired target audience I would submit you are not impartial
Well, you caught me. The dozens of subscribers paying $0 a month pose a grave liability to my impartiality. I hope my reputation can someday recover.
This, too, would be credibility-boosting confession of failure, were it not intended to pretend to humility.
Also, you're a lawyer.
I mean, the motivation behind forming this agency was as a response to completely delusional claims of voter fraud that are unfortunately held by a significant portion of the electorate.
Objection! Low effort consensus building which you have not only failed to demonstrate, but you have failed to uphold in this very day's update regarding Desantis's domestic political context, in which multiple contemporary contexts of conspiracy to commit voter fraud, potential evidence of fraudulant voting, and systemic weakness for fraud have been noted without sufficient rebuttal. That you, and even a significant portion of the American electorate, insist that claims of voter fraud are completely delusional and dismiss other people's reasons and perspectives does not, in fact, make those other people unreasonable or completely delusional.
Given your past ruts on this topic with similar tendencies of not acknowledging contrary evidence, I would submit you are not objective on this topic, given your frequent shills for your private substack and the financial interests in catering to your desired target audience I would submit you are not impartial, and given some of your past clunkers on understanding other people's viewpoints even when described to you, I would submit you lack the credibility to be a trustworthy evaluator of the motivations of your outgroup, especially on topics in which you have both past bad history and current financial incentives to defend dumping on your outgroup.
Playing aggressively isn't always a losing strategy just because you actually lost.
Playing aggressively is, however, a generally losing strategy in iterative social games where you're the weaker party more susceptible to catastrophic defeats undercutting future goals compared to the richer, stronger, bigger club whose main limitation is consensus. Underdog aggressors have to be successful every time, in order to catch up with accumulated power, but by the same respect every failure- or reversal- costs them more. Given that Putin and Russian narratives have repeatedly framed this not in terms of Russia-vs-Ukraine, where Russia is the overdog, but in Russia-vs-the-US/West/NATO, where Russia very much is the underdog, an aggressive under-dog strategy is high-risk, without corresponding high-rewards.
Putin is the worst of both worlds as a strategist, as he's an aggressive player who historically goes for low-risk options. In iterative strategy games, this is a bad option that gets worse over time, because it greatly increases the reputational costs that drive other people's decision-making against you, even as the low-risks that generally entail low-stakes mean that the gains are marginal. The reputational damage that Russia got in, say, Georgia in 2008 far outweighs the benefits of South Ossetia as a Russian-backed unrecognized state, and didn't exactly deter other post-Soviet countries from seeking closer ties to NATO/European countries, but it absolutely validated and strengthened the Russia-skeptic factions in other governments, who would get further empowered by further Russian opportunistic actions.
As a result of such past actions, there were no low-cost options in Ukraine, no matter how aggressive Russia chose to be. Aggression itself was the wrong play, as either Russia was going to find itself in an insurgency, or a (surprise surprise) conventional conflict, neither of which it was prepared to execute in a way where the cost-benefit would reward aggression.
It seems to me more likely that Putin took a gamble, a good gamble, which had positive expected value, and came up absolutely snake eyes on the heroism of a relative handful of Ukrainians. It’s wildly unfair to blame Putin for not expecting this guy would start acting like a Slavic Churchhill, when one could have expected a performance more akin to Ghani or at best like Tsikhanouskaya.
Ukraine wasn't a disaster because of Zelensky. Ukraine was going to be a disaster because a critical mass of the Ukrainians were plainly and already primed towards an insurgency that was going to be a disaster where instead of stay-behind actors doing rear-area spotting for artillery strikes behind the front lines in a conventional conflict, the flood of MANPADs and ATGMs going into the region from NATO were going to make Iraq look quaint. The cause of this sentiment isn't because Zelensky is popular, but because Russia was already hated by so many, and only going to get hated more when they moved in and started executing their pre-planned targetting lists of anti-Russian/pro-western actors. The same sort of people who manned territorial defense units will to go out and launch attacks on Russian armored columns are also the sort of people who would be ambushing Russian counter-insurgency columns.
Zelensky isn't the guy who made it cool to oppose the Russians, he's the guy who kept the Ukrainian government together, keeping a conventional war going instead of an insurgency war. Cratering the Ukrainian government was a clear Russian intention, but Putin's initial invasion force wasn't any better set up to deal with an insurgency than it was serious conventional resistance. Remember, one of the 'war isn't going to happen' arguments pre-invasion was that Putin's buildup was too small to do a meaningful occupation of the country.
Putin's fundamental mistake is that he discounted the relevant of the Ukrainian public's views, not because he didn't foresee Slavic Churchuill. Not taking into account the viewpoints of the nation you are invading is kind of the opposite of a good basis for a gamble.
Firstly, it doesn't matter even if they did blow up the pipeline with another method. I explicitly said that was possible in my first post.
'I don't know or care how they did it, but they totally did it since they were in the geographic neighborhood' has been a good part of why your theory hasn't been taken as seriously as you'd like.
So when winter comes and the Germans realise they really do need more gas and public opinion shifts in favor of Nordstream,
Substituting your theorizing and opinions on what's reasonable for other people's viewpoints and assuming their views accordingly is why you're not going to understand. I believe I raised this before.
the US should blow the pipeline then? When it's even more obvious (if that's possible) that it's the US behind it?
If it's not going to make a difference in attribution, then obviously yes, since doing it before it's needed pre-empts all the other measures and options to prevent paying a lesser political cost.
In your argument of if the US being responsible, the US is presumed from the start to be willing to be obviously responsible for blowing up the pipeline if it judges it necessary. This would support doing it when necessary, but would not justify doing it before it's necessary, or doing it before other actions that might be less attributable. Like, say, a cyberattack.
In my argument of if the US is responsible, the US waits the maximum amount of time until it pays an unavoidable cost, while attempting other efforts across the elements of national power to prevent the activation without having to pay the cost of such an overt action. The American concept of government power pretty clear- Diplomatic, Information, Military, and Economic measures are all means of national power to affect others, and as one of the more expensive for the US military is not the first resort against allies, especially those who are already doing the desired action.
Accepting a cost only when necessary is not silly. Incurring an unnecessary cost earlier than necessary when other elements of the state paradigm of national power are working is silly. If sillyness is to be minimized...
The Russian strategic goal is to get Europeans using THEIR energy. If they favour renewables, it's because it means gas is needed for reliability, gas that they supply. If they attack nuclear, it's to ensure there's a market for their fossil fuels. If they attack fracking... it's so they export more and Euros are less self-sufficient. Notably, they do not attack their own gas infrastructure! This does not create revenue or achieve leverage.
Substituting your theorizing and opinions on what's reasonable for other people's viewpoints is why you're not going to understand other people's viewpoints of other people's viewpoints.
If you're doing minesweeping exercises, you have to lay some mines. Fake mines, but mines nonetheless.
Aside from that you actually don't, are you even aware of how mines are laid in practice versus how they would have to be laid for your theory to work?
We have loitering munitions in the world of aviation, why not underwater too?
Repeat 'I don't know how they did it, but they totally did it!'
The question is not capability. The capability is not hard, even if you prefer to insist that it's beyond the scope of the Russians.
Wouldn't defending against Russian loitering munitions make a lot of sense as part of your official mine-warfare tests?
I graciously accept your concession of Russian capability to deploy loitering munitions that could cause this incident by your standards of capability.
I wouldn't trust the Russian navy to do anything correctly, let alone detect stealthy underwater UUVs and divine their mission.
Since your trust is irrelevant to their capability, this falls back under projecting your own presumptions of what other people perceive as reasonable.
Well, yes. Two actually happened, establishing a pattern of spiteful strategic incompetence, and the third is an accusation you've expressed confusion about why people won't accept as true without evidence.
No. The third is YOUR accusation, that Russia blew up its own pipeline.
I am not accusing Russia of blowing up the pipeline.
I accuse Russia, and Putin in particular, of the sort of strategic shortsightedness and malice that has repeatedly led them to do self-destructive stupid decisions in the recent past, to the point that blowing up their own (inactive, defunct, politically un-activatable, not-meeting-it's-strategic-function) pipeline for various reasons many would consider unreasonable is not a disqualifier for considering them in the slightest. But I am not accusing them, or anyone, as I wait for facts to emerge.
You have not provided any new facts, even weeks later, and continue to regress from anything resembling a falsifiable claim for a charge that would be very atypical of how the Americans normally go about resolving disputes with allies.
This is obviously contrary to its own interests!
It's not obviously contrary to their own interests. You reject other alternative frameworks of the prioritization of relevant interests where it's rational, but this is why your opening post here was 'I can't understand,' and I agreed, that, indeed, you will not understand.
This is your limitation, self-confessed even. As long as you retain this inadequacy, you will continue to not understand and resort to silly justifications instead.
You can be cruel, thuggish, corrupt and misinformed but still recognise your own strategic interests and not blow up your own pipelines that you built and paid for, that provide you with leverage on other countries, that you control! How is this so hard to understand?
From your perspective, likely very, but that's the demonstration of how you're struggling, and not the reason why. Among other analytic failures, this specific analytic model objection rests on the model's assumption that the Nordstream pipeline was actually giving Putin the leverage he wanted.
Your presumption that it did is, again, projecting your own beliefs onto others.
Given the course turn of the German government from before and after the war, and Putin's many repeated failures for the last half-decade to try and insert Nord Stream approval/activation as a solution to a variety of situations (including post-2014 Ukraine, the Belarus migration crisis, 2021 'offramp' negotiations, and more), it would be quite reasonable for people-who-are-not-you to come to the conclusion that no, Nord Stream was not providing Russia sufficient leverage over Germany to advance Putin's prioritized interests. German not only did not embrace neutrality on Ukraine, but continued to provide significant financial and even some military support despite Russian pressure attempts, german lobbying efforts, and not-very-subtle demonstration energy cutoffs. In fact, with the 2022 turning point and massive, deliberate shift of energy import strategy to gas import terminals despite the higher cost, the relevant time window for the leverage argument was rapidly shifting, as once the Germans did complete gas infrastructure much of the economic logic of bucking the EU and NATO would dissolve once the German capital investments were complete.
If a pipeline that is not supplying gas, is not providing the demanded geopolitical leverage (German neutrality on Ukraine), has a very visible shelf-life of geopolitical relevance (use-it-or-lose-it), and is not providing the effect of dividing the Germans from their NATO allies... well, by golly, it sure is lucky for Russia that some NATO ally decided to obviously blow it up before the Germans completed their import infrastructure! That sort of direct sabotage and attack might actually get the Germans to oppose supporting Ukraine, and break with Europeans out of righteous anger and look to reactivate the pipelines that can be reactivated! Including those non-bombed parts of the previously dead assets!
...no Russian President with a history of strategic shortsightedness would ever entertain the thought of when trying to grasp at straws to turn around a losing war he thinks he can win if he breaks European support for Ukraine.
Once you take away the assumption that it was actually providing geopolitical leverage, the rest of your 'it couldn't happen because it makes no sense' argument starts to fall apart. That money was spent to build and pay for is irrelevant- that applies to the military as well, and the state of the Russian economy as a whole which Putin's oligarchy consistently loots via corruption, and the economics of Nordstream itself from the start. If money were the goal, the Russians wouldn't have been selling the Germans cheap gas in the first place, but market-value gas for more money, nor would they have done pretextual shutdowns.
Saddam Hussein spitefully burned Kuwaiti oilfields to temporarily disrupt them, denying them to the West as his forces retreated from Kuwait. He did not start blowing up Iraqi oilfields or Iraqi infrastructure.
Because the Americans were very clearly not following him, and they were still of use for him. When the Americans did follow him, and it was of no further use, he absolutely did start trying to blow up Iraqi infrastructure.
This comes back to the assumption that the Nord Stream pipeline sections bombed were providing more use to Putin as they were at the time (inactive, not generating concessions, losing value over time) compared to, say, some other option that might deliver strategic benefits.
I'm not sure anyone with thematic sense should have been expecting Eren to not go into a bad place. The way it gets there is weirder than the resolution that a super-angry kid who turns into a race of cannibals goes to a bad place when worldviews are shattered.
Western young adult literature it was never going to be.
It wasn't making money. That was rather the a point of why it didn't affect gas prices mechanically as much as emotionally.
The pipelines destroyed were filled (pre-pressurized), but not active, and had been inactive so long that they were likely due for a long and expensive maintenance period before they could be activated anyway.
Nor has not-making good money exactly stopped Putin's pipeline strategy, given the rather implausible maintenance shutdowns and refusal to accept claimed required maintenance parts. Putin's strategy is to hurt the Europeans, not make the most money for himself.

This is what I mean by reframing defeat. 'Better than expected' isn't the same as 'good', and it's not a metric of success. You can do better than expected but still fail. You can do better than expected, but your expectations were horribly based in the first place. It's neither proof of good performance, or good evaluation.
More options
Context Copy link