@Eetan's banner p

Eetan


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 2 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:19:45 UTC

				

User ID: 208

Eetan


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 2 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:19:45 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 208

I never watched Bridgerton, but I'm told it's about wanting to have a black noble family in the British upper class. I don't mind that in the least, and this book seems to be the same.

You missed nothing, it is ordinary regency romance, except set in alternate world where British empire was always racially diverse and completely color blind.

Because old European kingdoms and empires were awesome, and their only flaw was racism. If people of color were equally represented among European royalty and nobility, it would be true paradise on earth.

Very conservative and "trad" attitude, called "progressive" today.

Wouldn't 'supporting the current thing's go against his long term goal?

Every long term goal is composed of short term steps.

If he gave an inch by painting the rockets, wouldn't they ask for the mile?

Wouldn't they ask for affirmative action in his rocket engineering teams?

Easy. Rocket engineering teams announce their transition and discover their POC identity, helped by generous benefits offered to BIPOC LGBTQ+ employees.

The 'current year' people are apparently debating the ethics of who to put on a rocket.

This is thought experiment unconnected to anything real, such "lifeboat" scenarios were debated by science fiction nerds before our parents were born.

If we take this scenario literally, human race is doomed anyway (no way you can get viable population out of eight people).

If you want to argue that he should do at least the minimum X amount of signaling, then how do we know that this is not dooming the future either?

The minimum he could do would be do not alienate both woke people and deep state simultaneously. Just shut up, about both culture wars and Ukraine.

How many generations of rocket engineers do we hope to breed if we're signaling to this generation that rocket engineering is GAY?

Breeding? You can as well ask what model of ox driven wagon is best for trip to Mars. If organic humans ever get to space, they will be designed, not bred.

How can we expect honest engineering if the only competent people we want to hire have to spend a non-negligible amount of time and effort navigating dishonest mission statements, hiring practices, etc?

This is work for lawyers and PR people, not engineers.

In past times the only possibility go towards stars was through creating (useless, but cool) vengeance weapons for Greatest Leader of Aryan Race or (even more useless, but way cooler) cold war propaganda stunts for Freedom and Democracy.

Wernher von Braun understood it, and was willing to wear both Nazi uniform and American business suit to get closer to his dream. And he achieved it.

Surely Musk can wear dress and wig.

Face it: space is deeply hostile, if humanity wants to spread there it must transform. Transhumanism is the only way to the stars, and transgenderism is the only way to transhumanism in current conditions.

"Yes, I assembled world's top scientific talent and I am spending billions on researching human cloning and creating artificial wombs. Why? This is the only way to help trans people to fulfill their dreams to affirm their gender identity by having children of their own. Do you want to say they are not valid?"

"Yes, I am spending tens of billions on researching human brain, on genetic engineering, on growing organs and body parts of cell cultures. Why? Hundreds of millions of trans people all over the world are waiting for their gender affirming treatments. Do you want to deny them their rights?"

"You dare to call me Nazi? You dare to call me eugenicist? You dare to call me Frankenstein? Are you against trans health care? Are you a TRANSPHOBE?"

surely it's indisputable that the 2A would apply to actual 18th century weapons?

Yes it is very disputable.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knife_legislation#Constitutional_protection

There is no NSKA (National Sword and Knife Association) and as a result, in many places where gun carry is fully legal even small knife can get you in trouble. As always, CYL before you get in knife fight ;-)

Transition is a "fuck you, I quit" to the problems of gender.

Nope. Going full "aro ace" - aromantic asexual is the ultimate fuck you to all gender problems, the ultimate liberation.

Fly the sunset flag and be chill.

Has anyone here written about Musk Derangement Syndrome in detail?

No, no one here wrote how totally and completely deranged Elon Musk is.

What Elon wants? What are his goals?

According what he says, it is to get mankind to Mars and then onward to stars. Nothing else matters, either we make the universe our own or we all die on this dirty mud ball.

He had a good start on his goal, but it is all just first step on journey of ten thousand light years. There is so much to be done.

And what Elon does? He insists on sabotaging himself in the stupidest way possible - by going against all current things, by alienating all powerful and influential people, by messing with things (both culture war and world politics) no one, not even a centi billionaire shouldn't mess with.

Does he sees himself as invincible? Does he think he is irreplaceable part of MIC? Does he thinks he is uncancellable?

If I were Elon? I would paint all my rockets with rainbow and trans colors (+ Ukraine colors after Feb 2022), named them after murdered trans women of color, stood hard against racism and transphobia and followed (and lead) all current things. To preemptively silence all criticism, I would announce my transition at the most opportune time.

All hail Elonia, Queen of Mars!

edit: blue bird links just for illustration

The question is much bigger than that. You can ask it about literally anything in social sciences, and you'll never know the answer because you can't rerun an experiment under controlled conditions.

If education counts as "social science", yes you can run trials and experiments according to most rigorous scientific standards, and you can also completely disregard the results and drop the whole thing into memory hole.

Official line for introduction

Twitter thread following the crumbs into rabbit hole, with links to further resources

Icons are representative, not realistic. So you can (and should) adapt iconography to the ethnic and cultural makeup of the people using them in order to make them more relatable and less foreign. Hence you have black, white, Chinese, etc. icons of Jesus, Mary, and so on

This was overwhelming consensus of historical Christianity. No one had a problem painting ancient Israelite kings as contemporary rulers in appropriate royal dress and regalia, ancient Israelite warriors as contemporary armored knights, because they were kings and knights and should be recognized as ones.

"Realism" was not an issue.

These longterm WoW players easily know 45,000 pieces of distinct information. It’s crazy when you add it all up like that.

And it is ever crazier when you grok that all this knowledge belongs to mega corporation that can alter or delete it by one click of some minimum wage employee, mega corporation that can easily decide the game is no longer profitable and shut it down.

Imagine - you dedicated days and weeks and months and years to exploring Black Troll Land and mastering the lore. Suddenly someone sees how extremely problematic it is, and deletes all racist content.

You are screwed.

Building your life and your identity on something so fragile is like living on a quicksand. Do not do it.

Where are the hard men bringing good times to africa and all the other god-forsaken places?

They are bringing good times, OFC for themselves only. What would be otherwise the point of being "hard man"?

Luxury Homes in a Gated Community in Hargeisa, Somaliland

Well, the way Jewish religious law works, a lot of things are derived and not spelled out specifically and explicitly, that's just how the system works.

Yes, we all know how the system works - first profess to follow absurd and nonsensical law, and then find a smart reason why the law does not mean what it says. This is the reason why God gave Jews their stratospheric IQ.

There's also a significant disagreement about this question in the Talmud: https://shulchanaruchharav.com/halacha/castration-sterilization-to-humans-and-animals/ and the resolution for non-Jews seems to be along the lines of "unclear, but better to think it's prohibited just in case" (which is a common case in Jewish law in general to go this way if there's a possibility something might be prohibited but no clear resolution either way). For Jews, of course, it's a strong definite "no".

So, oxen are not kosher and Jewish peasants in old times before tractors were supposed to use bulls to plough their fields? As everyone with experience with cattle will tell you, castration of animals was invented for very good reason.

It seems to be just another impractical and unworkable law written by priests who had no idea about agriculture, law designed to be avoided by some clever roundabouts.

(Ouch! I let my gentile neighbor to borrow my pair of bulls, and he returned them without balls! What can I do? Let him borrow more bulls!)

See for example this. Jews are supposed to leave all land fallow every seventh year and live of locusts (Yes I know the lore - in bygone times when Jews were truely pious and observant, the sixth year harvest was double that usual, wouldn't rot or spoil and rats or mice wouldn't touch it). Nevertheless, Jews in Israel today find a way to get around this commandment.

I find it interesting that The Motte tends to treat Christianity with kid gloves that are not reserved for other belief systems.

As others said, these other belief systems are clear and present danger while Christianity is not.

The noughties are over, Bush of out of office, intelligent design is out of schools, it is just not a live issue any more. If Christians were here to agressively preach and proselytize, I am sure they would met with strong pushback.

Similar example: I presume most people here strongly condemn communism, but it is not discussed there often. If some hard core tankies arrived and started forcefully explaining how Stalin did nothing wrong, it would change quickly.

Do you understand the difference between "the Jews" and "one Jew"?

Do you understand the difference between "one Jew" and "one Jew, seen as the highest authority by half of the world's Jews?"

What? No.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ovadia_Yosef

Ovadia Yosef (Hebrew: עובדיה יוסף, romanized: Ovadya Yosef, Arabic: عبد الله يوسف, romanized: Abdullah Yusuf;[2] September 24, 1920 – October 7, 2013)[3] was an Iraqi-born Talmudic scholar, a posek, the Sephardi Chief Rabbi of Israel from 1973 to 1983, and a founder and long-time spiritual leader of Israel's ultra-Orthodox Shas party.[4][5] Yosef's responsa were highly regarded within Haredi circles, particularly among Mizrahi communities, among whom he was regarded as "the most important living halakhic authority".

So, what was his attitude towards non-Jewish people?

In a sermon he delivered in October 2010, Yosef was strongly condemned (including, among others, by the Anti-Defamation League and the American Jewish Committee)[81][82][61] after stating that "the sole purpose of non-Jews is to serve Jews".[61][62][83] In his sermon, he said:

"Goyim were born only to serve us. Without that, they have no place in the world – only to serve the People of Israel.[84]

In Israel, death has no dominion over them... With gentiles, it will be like any person – they need to die, but [God] will give them longevity. Why? Imagine that one’s donkey would die, they'd lose their money. This is his servant... That’s why he gets a long life, to work well for this Jew," Yosef said.

"Why are gentiles needed? They will work, they will plow, they will reap. We will sit like an effendi and eat.

That is why gentiles were created"[84]

This dog anecdote was just an illustration of peasant relationship to the divine and supernatural, untouched by any theological thought.

Yes, it is an anecdote, because we do not have any research or opinion polls from medieval villages.

We don't, but we have second best, classic anthropologic survey work of extremely trad Italian village (with very unPC name), as close we could in 20th century get to the medieval world.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Moral_Basis_of_a_Backward_Society

The Moral Basis of a Backward Society is a book by Edward C. Banfield, an American political scientist who visited Montegrano, Italy (Montegrano is the fictitious name used by Banfield to protect the original town of Chiaromonte, in the Southern Italian region of Basilicata) in 1955. He observed a self-interested, family-centric society, which sacrificed the public good for the sake of nepotism and the immediate family. As an American, Banfield was witnessing what was to become infamous as the Southern Italian Mafias and a self-centered clan-system promoting the well-being of their inner group at the expense of the other ones. Banfield postulated that the backwardness of such a society could be explained "largely but not entirely" by "the inability of the villagers to act together for their common good or, indeed, for any end transcending the immediate, material interest of the nuclear family."

So, after 1500 years of Christianity, how pious and devoted were the Montegranesi?

The Montegranesi get little religious instruction. A peasant grandmother tells her grandchildren the stories of miracles and sacred things which she heard from her grandmother. At six a child learns his catechism, a meagre list of questions and answers which is likely to be forgotten soon after the priest has given a simple test.

In school an hour a week is devoted to religion. In later life the individual, if he goes to church--and many do not--hears simple sermons: the priest says, for example, that to be a good Catholic one must love God, obey the laws of the church, and do right. On saints days speakers sometimes come from Naples and Potenza to tell about the saint whose holiday it is.

This is the extent of the ordinary person's religious training.

Those few who could read the Bible are not discouraged from doing so but they are not encouraged either. A few peasant women have prayer books or the gospels, but most homes contain no religious literature.

Every peasant has his children baptized but (according to a Montegrano priest) most of them--especially the men--do not take seriously the idea of life after death. They believe there may be some kind of an after-world but that, whatever its nature, it will be the same for all. The hope of heaven and the fear of hell do not move them.

For the typical peasant, God (or Christ, the terms are used interchangeably) is not a spirit of loving kindness or even of firm justice. He is a demanding and capricious overlord. He may not notice one at all. If He does, He may distribute bounty or catastrophe according to whim.

Many think of God as a hostile, aggressive force which must be propitiated. A young woman, very angry with her father for getting drunk and making it necessary for her to leave a festa to take him home, sobbed, "What do I have to do to satisfy Christ ? He never does any nice things for me, and He always does these bad things to me. I don't know what to do to satisfy Him."

Some Montegranesi pray more to the saints than to God. Candles are rarely left before the main altar; most people think it more economical to leave them before the statue of a saint or madonna.

These judgments are made on practical grounds: no one has heard of any noteworthy miracles performed recently by God; this or that saint, on the other hand, has shown himself to be able and willing to afford protection (it is always protection that is asked) in a special class of matters. Some peasants even believe that certain saints are more powerful than God.

Five Madonnas are honored in Montegrano, and for some people the connection between them and the mother of Christ is extremely vague. (When a Montegrano boy who had studied for the priesthood attempted to explain to an old woman that there is only one Madonna, she laughed at him. "You studied with the priests for eight years", she said, "and you haven't learned the differences between the Madonnas!"

OP meant most probably late Father Coughlin.

I don't know how the medium version of this hypothesis could possibly be verified. It must remain in the company of models like historical materialism that may be true, seem like they could be true, but who knows.

"Historical materialism" another of these terms people love to shit on, without knowing where it came from.

How hard core non-materialist conception of history looks like?

It looks like this:

(context: Australian and Californian discoveries of gold in mid 19th century)

https://archive.org/details/historyofeurope108alis/page/326/mode/2up

In February 1849, the population of Europeans in the State was 2000 ; in June 1852 it was already 182,000 ; and in 1856 it had risen to 560,000. Soon after this great discovery had been made, a similar vein of prosperity was opened in Australia.

Gold was there discovered in 1849, in the alluvial plains near Ballarat, and this led to a general search in the vicinity, and the precious article was soon found in great quantities. The effects were immediately the same as they had been in California. Population and wealth enormously increased ; the emigration to it in 1854 rose to 87,000 persons; the exports turned £14,000,000, being about £28 a-head; and the gold obtained amounted to the enormous value of £15,000,000.

The annual supply of gold and silver for the use of the globe was, by these discoveries, suddenly increased from an average of £10,000,000 to one of £35, 000, 000! The words of poetic genius were more than realised. Methinks, as I gaze around, I see the scheme of the All-beneficent Father disentangling itself clear through the troubled history of mankind.

How mysteriously, while Europe rears its populations and fulfils its civilising mission, these realms, which have been concealed from its eyes, divulged to us just as civilisation needs the solution to its problem ; a vent for feverish energies, baffled in the crowd, offering bread to the famished, hope to the desperate, in very truth ; enabling the new world to redress the balance of the old. Here the actual Aeneid passes before our eyes.

" A race from whence New Albion's sons shall come, And the long glories of a future Rome"

Most of all did Great Britain and Ireland experience the wonderful effects of this great addition to the circulating medium of our globe. That which, from the effects of the erroneous legislation of man, for five-and-twenty years had been awanting - a currency commensurate to the increased numbers and transactions of

the civilised world, was now supplied by the beneficent hand of Nature.

The era of a contracted currency, and consequent low prices and general misery, interrupted by passing gleams of prosperity, was at an end. Prices rapidly rose, and rose steadily ; wages advanced in a similar proportion ; exports and imports enormously increased, while crime and misery as rapidly diminished.

Yes. The Creator wisely arranged geological processes so gold deposits would accumulate in these remote lands, and then stood watch over them, smiting any dirty pagan or greasy papist who tried to touch them.

They were there since the day of creation waiting for good Anglo-Saxon protestants, coming exactly at the right time when British Empire needed increased supply of money. Awesome.

This was writted not by some obscure preacher, but by one of most esteemed historians of the time. His works, forgotten today, were frequently reprinted (Internet Archive is full of their various editions).

No one, not even the most devoted believers, could and would think and write like this today. We are all historical materialists now, Marx(PBUH) be praised. ;-)

At the very apex of Age of Faith, at the time when Saint Thomas wrote his Summa, how common peasant devotion and worship looked like?

It looked like this.

Yes. Veneration of dead dog as a saint. Absolute and unspeakable horror for anyone who ever skimmed Theology 101, SOP for average Christian peasant of the day.

This is what actual based trad popular religion of our ancestors looked like, and it had nothing in common with dreams of online trad bros.

The church was not amused.

The custom was regarded as harmful and superstitious by the church, which made efforts to eradicate it.

How successful it was?

the last known visit by someone to Saint Guinefort Wood to effect a cure for a sick child occurring around the 1940s.

Yea, only full fledged modernity of radio, cinema, TV, urbanization and medicine that actually works, managed to uproot age old superstitions.

Good question. What would cound as evidence proving existence of aliens beyond reasonable doubt?

Independently verified physical evidence. Word of government, any government of Earth, is not sufficient.

For example:

  • clearly intelligent signal from space, confirmed by radioastronomers from all over the world, from direction where is no Earthly space probe

  • clearly intelligently designed artifact somewhere in Solar System, observed by at least two space probes belonging to rival great powers

  • alien artifact or material declassified by Eartly government, studied by scientists from all over the world and confirmed as something that is beyond human ability to create

I sympathize with him for being socially shamed, assuming that the post is real.

Reddit is as real as Jerry Springer show, and serves the same purpose - light brainless entertainment and indulging your sense of superiority.

"Maybe I am an asshole loser, but I am not as big asshole and loser as THESE PEOPLE! Praise reason, logic and science!"

This is what Reddit is for, if you use it in other way you use it wrong.

The common Frenchman, I Imagine, would "just want to grill" and that is a significant part of what I think sets the classes apart.

What the common Frenchman really wanted at the time (I assume from context it is the time of Great French Unpleasantness).

We can actually tell rather well, not only from newspapers, pamphlets, letters and memoirs of the time, but also from this official "lists of complaints" composed by people of all three estates. These documents survived, were digitized and are accessible on https://gallica.bnf.fr

Cahiers de doléances

https://pages.uoregon.edu/dluebke/301ModernEurope/Cahiers.html

The nobility were especially keen on personal liberties and on the authority of the upcoming Estates General: the common theme here is a concern with the arbitrary power of the king and his officials, who had been nibbling away at traditional, local privileges. We can interpret this concern with the "liberty" and power of Estates as a traditional, noble complaint, expressed in the language of Enlightenment.

Like the nobility, city-dwellers are concerned with the authority of the Estates General, but are more concerned with barriers to the market: concerns about customs duties and taxes on legal acts, for example, pertain to the free flow of trade. Their concern with Estates General, moreover, reflects and eagerness to diminish noble privilege: voting by head in the Estates General, for example, would throw more power to non-nobles.

And the overwhelming mass of people at the time, the peasants?

Unlike the nobility and the city-dwellers, rural people are overwhelmingly concerned with the burden of state taxation: after "taxation in general," which they share with the other two orders, all but two of the rural "top ten" concern taxation. By contrast, concern with the voting rules for the Estates General are almost entirely absent from the rural "top ten."

Yes, ordinary Frenchmen were just like ordinary Americans, they wanted to grill untaxed meat seasoned with untaxed salt and wash it down with untaxed booze.

Or an alien AI singularity decided to park a bunch of drones under the ocean when the local monkeys started building cities. Pays to keep abreast of developing intelligences, lest they become a nuisance in a scant few thousand years.

Or alien equivalent of kids poking a bug with stick for fun (before they stomp on it). Because the gap between us and interstellar aliens would be like this.

This is why there is no point agonizing about aliens - it they are real, they understand us better than we understand ourselves and can do to us and with us anything they wish. The ball is in their court.

And aliens are not real, preponderance of evidence glows like New Year fireworks and points to long running psyop - more precisely, series of psyops since 1940's (plus all kinds of con men and crazies jumping on the bandwagon).

Yes it is based and ball pilled.

In the late unpleasantness in god fearing Yugoslavia, when thugs with guns wanted to find who are you, they forced you to cross yourself. If you did it the wrong way, you were fucked.

In today's Ukraine, a foodie place, it is Palianytsia. Do not know what it is, cannot pronounce it correctly? You doubly fucked.

In America, it is the ball. If you expect interesting times incoming, get prepared, learn all what you can about balls.

The vast majority of 'dating advice' young men are given (by the mainstream liberal feminist zeitgeist) is absoluting terrible and only land them in situations like this if they follow through with it.

What "dating advice" outside of porn movies tells young men to introduce themselves: "Hello sweetie. Wanna fuck?"

Time for some good old fashioned gender politics seethe

Good subreddit with lots of quality content.

The thread you posted is not the most catastrophic - OP will, at the worst, have to ask to get reassigned to different study group before everyone forgets about the incident and, in a few years, will be out of school and hopefully have good job and be on his way to fuck you money.

This is bad.

My husband became a robot and I don’t know how to help him

and this is real tragedy.

My (21M) girlfriend (21F) went on an anti Semitic rant after getting into an argument with someone. I’m Jewish...

Classic MEMRI meme coming to real life.

Historically, this is nothing exceptional. How many medieval illiterate village peasants (or barely literate town laborers) would answer this questionnaire correctly?