This, but unironically. Do people really choose their church based on whether they like the music and not on their doctrine?
Yes. The noughties are over, age of christian-atheist debates is over. No one cares about doctrine, no one cares about apologetics, no one cares any more to prove or disprove existence of God and literal truth of the Bible.
"Just go to church, bro. One full of majestic music, lots of incense, shiny pictures and golden statues. It is based and trad. You want to be based and trad, don't you?"
What’s interesting about that these sovcits is that they aren’t stupid, the arguments they make have some internal consistency; it’s just that they think that if they torture the words enough, that they can warp reality.
No, their arguments have no internal consistency, yes they are stupid.
'The government is illegitimate band of gangsters with no authority other than guns, taxes are extortion and armed robbery, but there is one clever trick how to avoid them! If you spell your name in ALL CAPITAL LETTERS, they have to leave you alone! Do not ask why, they just have to!"
It is not any kind of brave protest or noble resistance, it is nothing than plain delusion.
Rational Wiki is in their case 100% right.
Sovereign citizens would accurately be described as the flat earthers of the legal world.
What is the living spirituality of your people?
Good question. What keeps Americans of all races and creeds together?
It is not politics, it is not voting - about half of eligible voters do not bother to register and vote, but no one wants to excommunicate them from ranks of American nation.
Yes there is something, and this is sport - more precisely, sports that are played only or mostly in good ole US.
Throwing big ball, kicking ball (but in completely different way than rest of the world kicks ball), beating small ball with big stick.
This is why everything stops during the biggest sport event of the year, this is why it is so big deal what music is playing and what advertisements run in this grand event.
This is the way it is, and it had been for a long time. Remember what happened during WW2 when Americans needed to find enemy infiltrators in American uniforms speaking English? Knowledge of baseball players and trivia was the shibboleth to find out real Americans from the other kind.
("American" who knows nothing about hitting small ball with big stick is no real American and will not be missed)
How would you know a SEA woman isn't just looking to move to USA with man they are not really attracted to and then drop them once they have acquired citizenship? Hans/Nina Reiser.
Easily. Tell your beloved you decisively denounced America, renounced US citizenship and are ready to live with her in her home country for the rest of your life.
I cannot imagine how this ends well for Western civilization.
Are you implying that there is some other civilization that does things better?
Gain of Function - big fat failure.
This thing is probably the most blackpilling thing about today's world.
Who profits from GoF research? There is no big business or government interest, there are no massive profits, this thing goes on so few thousand people can publish peer reviewed articles no one will ever read and burnish their citation metrics.
Few thousand people with concrete names, faces and addresses.
And no one cares.
Not governments, not billionaires, not celebrities (to say nothing about general normie population). Not any "protestors" "activists" or "rebels". All people, including the most rich, powerful and influential ones who can nevertheless die together with billions of ordinary peons when the next oops happens.
And oopses like this are happening pretty much regularly.
Imagine a ship, old times sailing ship. Ship where midshipman one day decided to drill a hole below the waterline, just for fun, just becuase he could. And everyone - captain, officer, crew and passengers - just watches and says: not my problem.
If you need hard evidence that humanity as a whole deserves to die, this is it.
Actually it was 25 years. The decline of the Soviet Union started with Brezhnev - Khruschev had the revolutionary idea for communist that economic of a country and some form of free enterprise and free culture are important.
If his reforms were allowed to continue who knows how much different the world would have been today
Big K had indeed many revolutionary ideas, all of them stupid.
Starting with denouncing his precedessor who was for thirty year worshipped as living god, undermining whole party and state legitimacy just to win some stupid personal power struggle.
The most hardcore tankies are 100% right about him.
Chinese did it better, they kept big M in the mausoleum, kept his statues and portraits everywhere while doing 180 degrees turn from his policy.
Otherwise, none of his reform had anything with "free enterprise" and "free culture."
Not hunt for abstract art, not renewal of religious persecution, not abolition of machine tractor stations, not destruction of workers cooperatives, not destruction of peasant's private plots, not the maximally demented corn idea.
Set aside this thing, equivalent of waving BB gun at heavily armed and armored cops and saying "Boo, pigs!"
May he be reborn thousand of thousands times as pig on factory farm.
Imagine craft guilds having more influence centuries ago, imagine laws ensuring that every newfangled machine had to be operated only by fully trained and qualified Master Spinner, Master Weaver and Master Tailor.
Your clothes would cost half of your yearly income, but they would be awesome.
I wonder if we will discover that there are many jobs which are, in fact, net negative for the economy only when people doing them get automated away and their sinecures lose lobbying power.
Already had been discovered.
At the best, about 20% of adult population is keeping all of us alive and comfy, the rest is engaged in digging holes and filling them again (only in comfy offices). UBI is already there, only in the most wasteful and inefficient form imaginable.
Who wants a job not as last desperate attempt to get money, but "to serve mankind", should find employment in water, sewer, power, food production/distribution etc...
I am talking about whole of OP's clever plan, forbidding people to work for living (not even private patch of potato allowed).
Such times and places existed, but they were not immigration magnets, to put it mildly.
what about illegal immigrants working full time? Yes, what about them? How can you hope to fix the fertility rates if you can't fix immigration?
Good recipe for land of omnipresent black markets and universal snitching and snooping (nothing like laws that ban something everyone does and everyone has to do to survive).
Such countries have many problems, but illegal immigration is not one of them. Such countries do not need big and beautiful border walls, such countries need strong anti-fascist protection barriers.
Explaining great and influential social movements as "mere" revenge for schoolday grudges is not new idea.
Robert Nozick, one of leading theoreticians of libertarianism, tried to answer mystery why intellectuals oppose capitalism, when capitalism is the greatest thing ever.
Why Do Intellectuals Oppose Capitalism?
TL;DR of Nozick's argument: smart intellectuals get the best grades from teachers in schools, but not the best rewards from bosses in capitalist marketplace.
Therefore, they are justifiably angry and burn the whole shit down.
And when they still do not get what they deserve, they do it again.
Big if true. Is school is not mere waste of time, but factory producing unstoppable killer robots, the only way out is to shut the whole thing down.
So it is all about old school grudges?
If true, we would observe that home schooled children who completely missed the whole uplifting experience of American education, would be the bitterest and most vengeful woke warriors.
Do we observe it?
I'm also interested in hearing from Catholics (particular TLM Catholics) about how they reconcile belonging to a church that seems to hate its own faithful so much. I can't figure it out.
The most hardcore justify it easily: the true Church was hijacked by Satan 60 years ago, popes since Vatican II are impostors.
This is logically consistent position - how could true and infallible church suddenly turn around by 180 degrees, condemn what it always preached and preach what it always condemned?
By coincidence, the communists had the same problem at the same time.
The problem with this position is, when the devil captured the whole church for 60 years and fooled 99.99% of believers with no end in sight, it really looks that gates of Hell prevailed and promise given to Peter was false.
Well, for now sure, but how long can a country that thinks in memes and slogans maintain its power?
Power was always about memes, and West/NATO power had never been greater.
Ancient leader motivated his troops by talking about mythical heroes, medieval would motivate his troops with inspiring pep talk about Bible and knightly romances.
The conquistadors, who managed the most brilliant feats of arms in history, were weebs living in fictional world of trash literature of their day.
"And as we saw so many cities and inhabited villages in the water, and many other large settlements on land, and the road that led to Mexico, we were stupefied ['admirados'], and we said that it all these things seemed like the enchantments recounted in the book of Amadís."
Now, NATO has Harry Potter and the Avengers. What does Russia have?
So if the goal is having people read the more moral version, then I think Puffin is planning uncharacteristically long into the future, for a company anyways.
People in charge are hired managers responsible to other hired managers, all the way up to BlackRock/Vanguard. The goal they care about is their personal future, and are wary of anything that might endanger it, like, for example, being suspected of racism and hate.
"The book we just printed is full of racism! There is massive outcry and backlash against the company! Who authorized it for print?"
"At your last job, why were you publishing racist books? Are your racist, or willing accomplice of racists? Why should we hire hater like you?"
Conversely in the west, our entire culture is built around the message that we're all equal and that we all have an equal say in democracy and so on.
This whole thread is about deep, millenia long history or different civilizations, not skin deep modern fashions century old at best.
And Chinese culture was always based on principle of meritocracy and unlimited opportunity. Every Chinese boy knew he could have great career if he studies and works hard, and could even become a emperor if he finds few friends to help him. Predictably, revolts and revolutions were neverending.
While European culture was for millenia based on principle of feudal hierarchy, divine right and noble blood. If you were born a peasant, you are going to be a peasant, as God ordered. To rebel against your betters was to rebel against God himself. Predictably, peasant revolts were rare and ended very badly.
I don't think this is accurate at all, "right wing" art is still being made and "right wing" artists are still out there, successful ones even, they're just not "fashionable".
It depends on definition of "right wing".
Is this an art that will shield your kids from socialism?
This would fail spectacularly and I can't imagine the CCP big shots ever being high enough on their own supply to attempt it. "force people at gunpoint to have kids" is such an obviously bad idea that there is a reason it has not been tried already.
Yea. See how the Party quickly backtracked over COVID lockdowns in the face of very mild protests and disturbances.
Maybe China is really the country where the government fears the people? (insert your favorite Guy Fawkes meme)
It would be wise attitude - one brief look at Chinese history demolishes all racist canards about "oriental slavish nature". How many peasant revolts in Europe came ever close to succeeding?
I suspect the stakes simply haven't been raised enough. If it were to come down to dire circumstances like either of the World Wars, where food is tight and industrial nations are reduced to stamping crude submachine guns out of sheet steel, then luxury beliefs will have to be outcompeted at some point.
It depends what belief is true luxury.
For example, in the most dire circumstances imaginable, proletarian internationalism was put onto the back seat, but socialism, party and great leader stayed and were doubled and quartupled down.
It worked.
gag order on Israeli nukes.
No need to bring something so obscure, things like anti-BDS laws are something completely surreal that can, unlike question of official recognition of Israeli nuclear weapons, affect normies in their daily lives.
The law came under fire in October 2017 from both Democrats and Republicans[citation needed] as Dickinson, Texas required Hurricane Harvey victims who applied for disaster relief funds to promise not to boycott Israel.
Try to explain to non-American (or to average normie American) compulsory pledge to do not boycott Israel - they will just refuse to believe it is real.
BTW, since this is another Israeli/Zionist thread, I recall you were once wondering about origins of Christian Zionism, about sudden and surprising replacement of traditional Christian attitude to Jews ("children of Satan") with modern one ("our beloved elder brothers").
In Protestant world, important figure was one Cyrus Ingerson Scofield, How he happened to be as influential as he was?
Being a “born again” preacher did not preclude Scofield from becoming a member of an exclusive New York men’s club in 1901, either. In his devastating biography, The Incredible Scofield and His Book, Joseph M. Canfield suggests, “The admission of Scofield to the Lotus Club, which could not have been sought by Scofield, strengthens the suspicion that has cropped up before, that someone was directing the career of C.I. Scofield.”
That someone, Canfield suspects, was associated with one of the club’s committee members, the Wall Street lawyer Samuel Untermeyer. As Canfield intimates, Scofield’s theology was “most helpful in getting Fundamentalist Christians to back the international interest in one of Untermeyer’s pet projects—the Zionist Movement.”
This man, Samuel Untermeyer. Very important person in his time, far from mere "Wall Street lawyer".
He figures prominenly in many wild conspiracy theories, was supposed to blackmail the president and be the mastermind behind American entrance into WWI.
https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/52658-two-us-presidents-among-many-celebrities-blackmailed
About a century ago, the 28th US President Thomas Woodrow Wilson (1856-1924) was reportedly blackmailed by a noted lawyer Samuel Untermyer of Messrs “Guggenheim, Untermyer and Marshall,” who had tried to extort $40,000 from the American head of state in relation to an affair Wilson had with a fellow professor’s wife, while he was teaching at Princeton University.
The blackmailing lawyer had visited Wilson at the White House on March 4, 1913.
In his book “The History of the House of Rothschild,” author Andrew Hitchcock has shed light on how President Wilson had budged to the blackmailer’s demand of appointing a United States Supreme Court judge on his recommendation if he paid $40,000 out of his own pocket to the woman with whom Wilson had an affair.
Consequently, on June 4, 1916, a Jew Louis Brandeis (1856-1941) was appointed to the US Supreme Court by President Wilson as per his agreed blackmail payment to Samuel Untermyer three years earlier.
Justice Brandeis had gone on to serve the US Supreme Court from 1916 to 1939.
(Wilson's relationship with Mary Hulbert Peck is confirmed historical fact, the blackmail tale originates from Benjamin H. Freedman of dubious reliability.)
Now, back to Scofield. His only biography paints him rather unflatteringly, as typical American huckster and con man, not humble servant of Christ.
Still, the mind boggles how could such, unimpressive and obscure at the time, character be invited into such prestigious group.
The club’s purpose as noted in Article I, Section II of its Constitution, was: The primary object of this Club shall be to promote social intercourse among journalists, artists, and members of the musical and dramatic professions, and representatives, amateurs, and friends of Literature, Science, and the Fine Arts: and at least one third of the members shall be connected with said classes.
Since the theatre was taboo and worse in the circles where Cyrus had moved since 1879, we assume and we think rightly, that someone felt that Scofield could qualify in the literary catagory. But, that qualification could hardly have been on the basis of Scofield’s literary output up to that time. There must have been anticipation.
The club’s Literary Committee, when Scofield’s application was presented, included Samuel Untermeyer (1858-1941), a notorious criminal lawyer. Untermeyer’s accomplishments, described in Who’s Who in America9 take up more than two columns. There is not one activity listed which would suggest that Untermeyer could have appreciated either Scofield’s Bible Correspondence Course or his magazine The- Believer.9 Untermeyer’s life was so remote from the circles in which Scofield normally moved, that we must remain amazed that Untermeyer would have given Scofield the “whiteball” rather than the “blackball.”
...
Scofield kept up his membershp in Lotos until his death in 1921. The membership was not referred to in any obituary or eulogy. (The Dispensational community knew nothing of it!)
...
The selection of Scofield for admission to The Lotos Club, which could not have been sought by Scofield, strengthens the suspicion which has cropped up before, that someone was directing the career of C. I. Scofield. Such direction probably was motivated by concerns remote from fidelity to the person, work and truth of Jesus Christ.
Big if true. If confirmed, nothing else can be said than: well done, well played.
Self determination of black Americans as separate nation was Communist party project (in style of pre-Stalin Soviet national policy).
https://www.blackpast.org/african-american-history/black-belt-republic-1928-1934/
It was not the most succesful plank in CPUSA platform, to put it mildly.
Longhouse, as you said, is traditional dwelling used by many tribal peoples, independently invented many times because it is highly practical.
"Longhouse" in internet alt right speak means modern degenerate and unmanly society where women and homosexuals rule and real true manly men are oppressed and persecuted.
"I do not want to sit in office all day, I want to loot, rape and pillage like my ancestors did! I want to collect enemy skulls, not funko pops! They do not let me live like real man, this is so unfair :'-(:'-(:'-("
Why they chose this name is unclear. One would imagine that online manly right that sees civilization as fake and gay would see life of Iroquis or Mohawks as the best life ever.
Would "Bronze Pervert" and his ilk advise the Iroquis to leave the longhouse and build tiny huts for each family separated with picket fences? If so, they wouldn't go very far.
edit: links
I'll be honest, I have almost no idea what a real death threat actually looks like.
99.9% of so-called death threats on the internet fall into one of two categories; faked or implausible.
Easy. Imagine mail arriving on your real name private address you never ever used to shitpost on the internets, originating from proxy server in Belize, that contains pics of your house and family taken through telescopic sight and polite request to cease meddling with stuff you shouldn't meddle with.

Does not conclude. You can logically accept all the following:
1/ There are no gods and no devils, there is no judgement, no heaven, no hell, no reincarnation and no nirvana, when you are dead you will decompose and be forgotten (at least until AI reconstructs your brain in order to torture it forever).
This world is all what there is.
2/ This world is dirty, muddy and bloody rat cage, always had been and always will be. To live long and prosper you need to learn how to lie, cheat, steal and scam, how to snoop, snitch and denounce, how to plot, intrique and backstab. You have to be total and complete rat to get ahead.
3/Regardless, I do not want to live like this, I do not want to be a rat.
Grim and hopeless mindset that would appeal to few people, but 100% scientific and materialist.
More options
Context Copy link