FirmWeird
Randomly Generated Reddit Username
No bio...
User ID: 757
It demonstrates complete and utter scofflawism.
This was the entire point. The video footage all the cameras on that island recorded would have been titillating but not really worth anything if there was no criminal element. "I have a video of you having sex with a barely legal woman" is nowhere near as compelling a blackmail tool as "I have a video of you having illegal, criminal sex with a child".
If you're interested in an article exploring similar themes, I recommend https://www.resilience.org/stories/2012-11-21/in-the-twilight-of-empires/
You're not the first person to notice the similarities between Outremer and Israel. In fact, the last discussion I had on this topic on here can be found at https://www.themotte.org/post/753/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/158402?context=8#context
Specifically regarding EROI, this makes it sounds like you're calling for continuing to use fossil fuels.
Actually, the opposite - continuing to use fossil fuels is impossible, because there's a finite amount of them and you eventually run out. But worse, because humans tend to extract the easiest, best resources first, the energy return and economic viability of them will go down well before we actually run out.
And if fossil fuels are the only energy source capable of powering modern civilisations, then when you remove that energy source without replacing it with something better/equivalent you end up without modern civilisations - there's no inherent law of the universe which says that modern western lifestyles are a permanent fixture of reality. You don't end up in Mad Max land (we had civilisation before we had fossil fuels after all) but you do end up with a society very different to the one we have now.
As I said, it has recently improved and some of the first new reactors since the 1970's have finally started to come online.
I will believe that this problem has been solved when those reactors are functioning and supplying us with electricity - but people have been saying similar things for the past decade, and nothing has happened. Again, these advanced reactors have been on the verge of solving the energy crisis for the last 50 years, so I'm not exactly holding my breath.
Curious what you think the energy problems we are facing actually are.
Climate change is going to cause vast amounts of economic damage as extreme weather events increase and climate belts slowly head north. These changes are going to encourage much more energy usage precisely at a time when that energy usage makes the problem worse - and the source of that energy is starting to run dry. The transition from fossil fuels to a new mixture of energy is going to cause lots and lots of economic pain on top of having to deal with massive amounts of pollution and changes due to global warming. There are going to be climate refugees as water systems change location, good farming land moves around (Siberians are probably going to be pretty happy though) and some places simply become unliveable. We need to find a viable alternative to fossil fuels, and in order to have a gentle transition to a society that uses that alternative we need to find it several years ago - which means that we aren't going to have a gentle transition even if we do manage to find something.
I said that I support some leftist policies, not that I actually am left-wing. The specific issues you listed are ones that I don't actually care about - trans issues are just not something I think are particularly relevant, but I support gun rights and I'm also against immigration (because it damages labour and the environment both). So you're essentially asking me to agree to a bunch of policies I actually support - in which case the answer is hell yes.
Climate change is urgent when it comes to "you have to give up something" but is suddenly not so urgent when it comes to "we have to give up something".
This is actually one of the main reasons that the climate change movement failed - people saw that a lot of the most prominent activists wanted to preserve their own carbon consumption habits while shoving the costs onto others (especially people in the wage class). I personally walk my talk and do my best to minimise my own carbon footprint, and there's no way I could look someone in the eyes and tell them it was important if I wasn't willing to make my own sacrifices.
If you consider human-caused climate change an imminent existential threat,
I'm not going to go into the rest of your post, but as an environmentalist I don't think climate change is an imminent existential threat. First of all, there's nothing imminent about it - the process has already started. 2023 is the hottest year on record, and the previous holder of that esteemed title was 2022. Climate change is not some threat that could appear off in the distance, but a present reality. Coral reefs are bleaching, currents in the oceans and atmosphere are changing, ice is melting and the sea-level is rising. All of this is happening right now and if you live in the right places you can just go stick your head out of the window and see it.
At the same time, it isn't really that existential of a threat - if you're talking about humanity as a whole. If you want a good article which explains what I think is the most realistic evaluation of climate change outcomes, I recommend https://www.ecosophia.net/riding-the-climate-toboggan/
Compared to what?
Compared to the energy needs of continuing current western lifestyles and patterns of consumption into the future, which is the only comparison that actually matters. Current nuclear technology, even with rosy assumptions, isn't capable of doing it. I would love to be proven wrong, with an example of a profitable nuclear power system with an EROEI that can support a modern first world economy, but I don't think that can happen. The reason I bring up profitability and cost is that they are ultimately a reflection of viability, and probably our most accurate one (which is why France's cheap uranium is relevant). I'll also freely grant that nuclear power does have some use-cases - it is fantastic for submarines and aircraft carriers for one, but it has yet to be demonstrated that it can be a viable energy base for a modern first-world economy. I can believe that regulatory burdens contribute to making nuclear power less productive, but I think at least some of those regulatory burdens are actually good (your nuclear plant should not be dumping radioactive waste in the local primary school playground etc), and I don't believe they are enough of a burden that removing them would make nuclear that much better of an option.
That has started to change and in addition to the small modular reactors that are nearing market availability, serious followup to the molten salt reactor research that was done in the 1960's may finally be moving forward.
I'll believe it when I see it. This is explicitly what I was talking about when I mentioned hypothetical reactors. They have been "nearing" market availability for several decades now, and I can remember being excited for those liquid molten salt reactors ten years ago myself. Maybe you're right and this time is different, but I'll need a bit more evidence than the same claims of imminent cheap and sustainable energy that have been made for longer than I have been alive. That said, if you're right and those future nuclear reactors actually do just solve all the energy problems we're facing then I'll be extremely happy and update my flair on here to reflect that I was wrong (and keep it that way forever).
I'm going to have a tough time naming public figures because the forces (in the non-conspiratorial sense) that make figures public aren't actually big fans of people who are talking seriously about these issues - public cognitive bandwidth is reserved for more important figures like Baby Gronk, The Rizzler and the Hawk Tuah girl. I've seen a lot of environmentalists and green activists support things like hydro, geothermal and wind as well - but those power sources have limits which mean they can't be scaled up to the level required to support modern first world lifestyles. There's nothing wrong with hydropower per se, but there are only so many places you can actually build a dam and get a decent return on your investment. Geothermal, if appropriately developed, might even be able to supply 10% of our energy needs in the future - which is great, but not an actual answer to the dilemma we're facing.
But that said, you have several large obstacles in the way of convincing environmentalists to support nuclear. Nuclear power as it is currently available to us does not provide enough energy returned on energy invested for it to be a viable option even without the costs of dealing with waste. France's nuclear power system was only viable because they bought Uranium at a 97% discount due to their exploitation of Africa, and even their system has had to be nationalised due to going bankrupt. Hypothetical nuclear reactors which generate electricity too cheap to meter have been 20 years in the future since the 1960s, but are still yet to materialise. When they do appear and generate enough electricity to pay for their own creation without a galaxy of government subsidies, I will be extremely happy and advocate building them all over the globe as soon as possible - but they haven't appeared, despite people promising that they will for half a century.
If you disagree with me, name some counterexamples
Sure - me. I support some left wing policies but my stance on climate activism has little to do with those, and I'm not a communist (I'm open about my political ideology - distributism). Though in the interests of full disclosure, I think that many of the current sources of climate pollution are terrible for everyone involved and should be stopped, but for some of those cases concerns about the climate aren't the only factor. The Iraq War had a massive carbon footprint, but I'm not going to lie and claim that my opposition to it revolved around environmental concerns.
If that's not good enough, there's a local political party which takes the climate seriously and isn't interested in simply applying left-wing policies (notably being against massive amounts of immigration) - the Sustainable Australia party. I'd throw John Michael Greer onto the list as a conservative, but he isn't really a climate change activist - he thinks that it is already baked into the cake and the only thing that people can really do is make better and more sustainable choices in their personal lives.
I don't think you're completely wrong here, but I feel like pointing out that climate change is actually happening and taking place. It is a real and serious problem, and if you have lived in a coastal area long enough to see the changes they're not really deniable anymore. There really is something happening and it really is causing big problems for the environment and the future. The idea that we can simply make one intervention and "fix" the climate without any second-order consequences strikes me as a bit short-sighted to boot.
That doesn't mean there aren't an army of scammers and grifters out to use that problem for their own advantage - Goldman Sachs is not being selfless when they advocate for a complicated carbon credit scheme which would let them make millions of dollars for no work at all. Plenty of prominent climate "activists" have the carbon footprint of entire cities in the third world (private air travel being one of the biggest contributors) and do nothing except make the position they're advocating less credible. But the fact that people are using the situation to grift and profiteer doesn't mean the problem isn't real. A snake-oil salesman selling you a miracle cure isn't providing an actual treatment for your condition, but the fact that a snake oil salesman is trying to sell to you isn't an argument against your condition existing.
On the weekend, I hand fed an actual quokka and gave it a bunch of pats. They're actually pretty cute and friendly in real life (although a bit lazy), and they actually grab your hands with theirs when you feed them to make sure you don't take away the food. That had me thinking about the motte, and then I saw an advertisement on the way back home telling me that the mainstream news was going to be presented by a Mr. Overton. Nothing particularly relevant, but it was enough of a synchronicity I felt like posting it here.
are also happily controlling their own reproduction instead of just jumping into babies as quickly as possible.
How does this even rise to the level of an argument against the idea that women inherently want babies? I have an inherent need to eat, but I don't scarf down the first bit of food that I can see as quickly as possible. I make conscious decisions like "I'm going to cook pasta for dinner tonight" and happily control my own consumption of food and I don't see any contradictions between those two positions.
I don't have a problem with kids being able to take on some work or go get experience in the real world. Hell, I think that's a great idea - but the way that it is presented here has real problems and that's what I zeroed in on. Sure, your dad was a top performer and got scouted out super quick... but if he's super talented then he's by definition not part of the super below average cohort, who are the actual biggest problem with this proposal. Some people are just net negatives, and as someone who has been both an employer and an employee, I would violently detest whatever system decided to use my business as a daycare for some special needs kid whose interests are jacking off in public and physical violence. Of course, the other end of the bell curve has issues as well - if you discover the next Terence Tao, they should be studying advanced maths rather than cleaning out the deep fryer.
Ultimately I don't think the idea of having kids in school go out to join the workplace is a bad idea - I just think making it mandatory and forcing even the super-below average kids to go do humiliating jobs in service positions they can't even perform adequately is bad for everyone involved.
I don't care whether they're actually "productive" at it though, the point would be to gently guide them into the workforce,
Actual employers and people who do productive work will violently hate and oppose this idea. Putting someone who needs constant supervision into a potentially dangerous workplace, or even one with a modicum of complication, is a massive burden that would require ruinous compensation. That super below-average kid who can't understand conditionals and violently assaults people for taking his nintendo switch away would be a net negative for any business saddled with his care. The very below-average kids aren't just unproductive, they're actively destructive in any kind of task that's worth doing. Even as a customer I don't actually want the super below-average forced into humiliating service positions they have no hope of ever performing adequately - hell, I don't want to have to see that as a human being.
I'll admit that's a tough one I don't have an answer to besides the fact that continuing this zombie-statist-capitalism will eventually lead to national bankruptcy along with a Defense Industrial Base that literally cannot keep pace with a peer actor (China).
I have some bad news for you - this won't eventually lead to national bankruptcy and a defence industrial base that cannot keep pace with China. You're already there! China has 232 times the shipbuilding capacity of the USA, and their manufacturing capacity in just about every other industry is leagues ahead of the US as well. In wartime, civilian manufacturing capacity can be switched over to defence/military work - but building entirely new facilities and staffing/training them is substantially more expensive, difficult and time consuming. While the problem isn't as bad (but absolutely still present - https://www.defenseone.com/defense-systems/2024/06/mixed-results-us-military-efforts-reduce-dependence-china/397368/) in military manufacturing, there's enough Chinese penetration into both to render them extremely vulnerable to disruption in the event of serious conflict with China. Keep pace with China? The defence industrial base isn't just failing to keep pace with China, it isn't even capable of standing on its own without their assistance!
Think about what an actual military conflict with China would entail - the removal of Chinese manufacturing capacity (or worse the subversion of critical US military infrastructure due to Chinese manufactured backdoors etc) would cause the US supply chain to fall apart, creating countless problems that would need resources diverted to fix them precisely when those resources would be needed to recreate a manufacturing base. Fixing it is going to be really complicated as well. First of all, the people who made the decisions to cut costs and sell US manufacturing to China are in many cases still in power and still profiting from those decisions. Second, actually seriously investing in domestic manufacturing and military manufacturing would greatly strengthen the domestic political enemies of those in power. This is actually one of the reasons the CHIPS act failed - the various left-wing political sinecures and set-asides put into the bill to make sure that they were on the right side of history were so odious that they held up progress on the proposed plant.
I don't think this approach would work on a broader scale at all. If you have the kind of happy family and upbringing where there children would do this themselves without the law, you don't need it to be mandatory. On the other hand, if a child would actually need the forceful hand of the state to make them support their parents, there's a decent chance they won't be able to really support them - and if they could, there's a decent chance that they would refuse to for reasons that could be entirely legitimate. A child being forced to pay a portion of their income to the father that raped them or the mother who prostituted them for drugs would, in my opinion, be justified in refusing to work if it meant that they would be supporting those people. At the same time, it isn't like sharp and serious political disagreements between parents and children don't happen either.
The graft and bloat isn't good, just inevitable.
There's nothing inevitable about it. Every single one of these instances of corruption is the result of purposeful, deliberate actions - this is something that is done on purpose and not by some inevitable law of nature. Each instance of corruption strengthens the corrupt aspects of the MIC and makes the problem as a whole worse to boot, as people profiting from that corruption can reinvest in their own "business" and help it grow. While I think there's some validity to the claim that they'd just do it elsewhere without Israel, I think all those other laundering operations should be shut down as well - so the claim that it would be them if it wasn't Israel is just a non-starter.
both of which we would want done anyway even if Israel wasn't the one doing it.
Claiming that Israel is doing a good thing by helping the military industrial complex get stronger and suck up more government funding is just bizarre to me. The fact that more and more tax money gets spent on incredibly corrupt military procurement bodies is something I find sad to think about - the opportunity cost on all that money and the good it could have done for the world is just immense. Is that actually something you think is a positive?
While I don't agree with your overall point, I think you had a valuable insight here.
Lasting ceasefires hinge on some combination of a belief in the other party's intentions, and an evaluation of their capabilities. Due to Putin's lack of credibility, a ceasefire acceptable to the Ukrainians and Europeans will be built on Russia's loss of long-term capabilities vis-a-vis the Europeans, who both want Russia to lose the Soviet inheritance and to build their own military production capability so that post-war Russia can't out-arm them.
There's not going to be a ceasefire because neither side's bare minimum terms are acceptable to the others - there's no way Putin can offer a deal that the west would accept without being immediately couped by someone under him. At the same time, the west can't make any deals either - their credibility also isn't that great, and there's nothing they can offer which would be worth the continued existence of a hostile and belligerent Ukraine on Russia's border.
likely also responsible for the US not being pro-Hamas.
I think this is much better attributed to AIPAC than Biden.
The idea that if I make a film about how bad Hillary Clinton is, it's my right, but if I get together with a bunch of other people and make a better film about how bad Hillary Clinton is, that can be censored, makes no sense.
There's a lot more to being a corporation than just working together. Incorporating provides considerable legal and financial protections which you wouldn't get on the basis of just working together with others. So in the proposed schema there's actually nothing stopping you from getting together with your collaborators and making the anti-HRC film of your dreams - but if you accidentally flood an entire town with sewage while recreating the tour bus moment you won't have the legal protections that a corporation would. If you're going to donate vast amounts of money to a political party/candidate or otherwise get seriously involved in politics, I don't think there's anything unreasonable about requiring you to give up the protections of corporate personhood to do so.
I agree that looks matter, but I think Trump also gets to coast on past glories. He was a big deal in the past, and while his appeal didn't manage to reach me, he was apparently attractive enough to spawn a flood of erotic dreams (https://www.yahoo.com/news/heres-why-always-sex-dreams-160500781.html).
Bush's lead was already shrinking before Trump came down the escalator. He had an early lead because he started with more name recognition, but he was not a strong candidate along any dimension except that vague sense of competency that came from having done a good job in Florida, which he failed parlay into actual success on the campaign trail.
Bush was a terrible candidate, but so was everyone else in the running. What Jeb had on his side was the GOP establishment, and none of his competitors in the non-Trump world had the charisma or popularity among the republican base to overcome that advantage.
Immigration was already an issue prior to 2016.
The GOP did not actually care about immigration - they made noise about it because their base cared, but whenever they were in power they did everything they could to make sure more and more illegal immigrants entered the country. The GOP's wealthy donors wanted to make sure that they could continue to drive up the price of real estate while putting downward pressure on wages. While they made noises about it, Trump was the only person to actually try and do anything about it because he wasn't beholden to those same donors.
The whole reason the autopsy had happened after 2012
Autopsy? I'm not sure what you're referring to here.
but he already had the reputation and had already made it a important plank of his platform.
Had he? Maybe I'm remembering things wrong but I don't recall Cruz talking seriously about immigration until Trump brought it up. I think in the non-Trump world Cruz just has the same positions on immigration as the GOP consensus and accepts a minor portfolio position in the stillborn Jeb! administration.
Bush's lead had disappeared by the time Trump started taking off.
I was under the impression that this was in no small part due to Trump's attacks on Jeb. Without Trump there's no differentiation among the republican candidates at all, and that means Jeb's structural advantages deliver him the nomination (so he can lose to HRC). As for Cruz, we absolutely knew he was a weak vessel in 2016 - though I'm not sure that becomes as obvious with Trump out of the picture. At the same time, I don't think Cruz would even adopt the positions he did without Trump establishing them as primary-winners first.
I know this secretary in a big company, she would produce and present documents for the (somewhat dumb) CEO to sign and she was revolted that he wouldn’t understand, or even read, most of what he was signing.
If I got frustrated in a position like that and my concerns got knocked back, the next documents the CEO would be presented to sign would be requests for an increase in how much I was being paid.

Uh, no? There's no need for those leaders to alter the calculus or think any more about personal safety than they already do. They were already thinking of their own personal safety and have for an incredibly long time - it isn't like Soleimani was the first leader to get whacked. What it will actually do is force them to take a long, hard look at their supply chains and how they actually procure electronics. The biggest change I can see coming from this is a market opportunity for Chinese/Russian pager manufacturers.
More options
Context Copy link