FirmWeird
Randomly Generated Reddit Username
No bio...
User ID: 757
How would ordering the FBI to break into your opponent’s office to steal information to help your campaign fall within the official duties of the president?
When this happened in 2016, the excuse given was that it was for reasons of national security. You just conjure up a foreign adversary with information you know is fake, use it to get a rubber-stamped warrant from the FISA court on some minor figure in the opponent's campaign and then use that justification to suck up all of your opponent's communications.
I mean, he voluntarily undertook the search for documents, and they found a couple at an old office of his as well. To me, that seems fairly organic.
The problem here is that I don't actually have any faith that the people doing the searching and investigation are doing so with a desire to actually find the truth. While I can't actually prove that Biden's case was soft-walked, there's a comparable case that happened just recently - the Hunter Biden laptop. Given your level of knowledge I'm going to assume you're familiar with the details of the case, but they paint a picture of an FBI that's thoroughly unwilling to go after Biden despite impeccably documented evidence of serious crimes. While they did eventually prosecute Hunter after it became a major issue and was leaked to the press, this only happened as a result of serious public pressure and attention. The FBI actually had his laptop for quite some time before the contents were leaked to Giuliani, and they didn't do anything about it. We know from the contents of the laptop that there were several unarguable and undeniable crimes (the doing crack part at the least) as well as traces of what seemed like an obvious influence-selling case... but the government did absolutely nothing with it, only intervening when the contents of the laptop started showing up in the media. Furthermore, there were multiple figures in the intelligence community who came out to knowingly lie about the origination of the laptop in order to help Biden's election chances. At the same time, we know that the government has actually been reprimanded in court for fucking with and manipulating evidence in the Trump documents case. The two sides are very clearly not being treated equally.
I freely admit that there's no direct evidence of serious wrongdoing here, but the last time the FBI came out and said that a Biden hadn't really done anything worth being charged for they were lying through their teeth and were only forced to recant once the evidence became public. That they were forced to actually admit something happened at all is enough to make me extremely suspicious - but I don't know what they could really do to assuage my doubts. Politicisation is a hell of a drug, and it means that I don't really have any trust or faith that they're telling the truth THIS time, when a lie would be perfectly in character and advance their political goals (for the record I believe these goals are anti-Trump rather than anti-Republican).
I said that he has a dedicated core of supporters who are very loyal but not very bright or discerning,
I actually agree with this, but I think that this is true of any large political movement. There are plenty of people in the democrat base who are utterly thoughtless and pick their vote/political allegiance based purely on tribal instinct as well - this isn't something unique to Trump. though his personal charisma likely means he has a larger number of these people than other politicians.
Much of it boils down to saying "liberals don't like conservatives and say mean things about them." Conservatives don't like liberals either and say mean things about them, so I'm not sure what I'm supposed to take away from that, other than that maybe conservatives care more about what liberals think of them than vice versa.
I disagree with this reading of the article - you don't seem to have grasped the point actually being made, which is that Trump has been using this tendency on the part of the left to ingratiate himself with his base. He knew that he'd be able to get the talking heads to talk shit about him in ways that would make people who dislike those talking heads support him as a result, and so he went out of his way to get the media to attack him. This is stated explicitly in the article so I'm not sure if repeating it here will do any good, but that's what you're meant to take away from that particular section.
The difference is that Greer thinks they are basically justified on grounds of economic neglect while I think the economic anxiety narrative is bullshit and they are attracted to Trump because he promises to vicariously remediate their sense of humiliation.
You think the economic anxiety narrative is bullshit? Do you have any kind of argument against the claims he makes?
In 1966 an American family with one breadwinner working full time at an hourly wage could count on having a home, a car, three square meals a day, and the other ordinary necessities of life, with some left over for the occasional luxury. In 2016, an American family with one breadwinner working full time at an hourly wage is as likely as not to end up living on the street, and a vast number of people who would happily work full time even under those conditions can find only part-time or temporary work when they can find any jobs at all. The catastrophic impoverishment and immiseration of the American wage class is one of the most massive political facts of our time—and it’s also one of the most unmentionable. Next to nobody is willing to talk about it, or even admit that it happened.
Where's the bullshit here? Are you living in another America that doesn't have a massive fentanyl crisis and didn't outsource huge swathes of productive industry to China? I (and Greer, based on the quote) can understand not wanting to talk about it or admit that it happened, but there's a substantial amount of fire beneath the smoke of economic anxiety. Is there an element of vicarious remediation of humiliation? Absolutely! But to pretend that's the only motivating factor strikes me as absurd.
I don't think Biden's mishandling rises to Trump's level because though there certainly was some lack of care, it didn't seem to be super deliberate and there didn't seem to be the same kind of lying going on.
I'm actually not so sure on this one - I don't think it'd be possible to get a really clear view of how bad his case was without exploring the Hunter corruption issue. Biden lies all the time, and I don't think we have a real picture of exactly what went on there. We know that classified documents were being stored in an insecure manner, but we don't actually know how serious it was because it all got brushed under the rug so quickly. It might be a big deal for the big guy, but it might also just be Biden's failing mental state. All that is ultimately an academic concern, however - the partisan disparity is so great as to eclipse any other concerns.
Though with all that said I don't feel terribly bad about classified documents being leaked - I'm a big supporter of Julian Assange, Ed Snowden, Binney, Drake, etc. I like it when classified documents are mishandled and leaked, in part because those leaked documents usually reveal some kind of malicious or nefarious government behaviour. As far as I'm concerned, it was a good thing when details of PRISM got leaked, and likewise when Collateral Murder was leaked, so it feels kind of hollow for me to say I'm looking forward to prosecution for document mishandling.
In any event, would you praise the Sackler family for at least trying to flood the market with pharmaceutical drugs (whether they succeeded in this endeavor or not, would you praise the endeavor)?
Absolutely not - I come at this from the "smelly hippy" angle rather than the libertarian one, and I think that what they did was actually monstrous. I'm a proponent of drug legalisation, but I think that legalisation should be accompanied with responsible education and policies with regards to addiction and the like. The Sacklers were ultimately responsible for and made substantial profits from a legal and corporate structure that heavily encouraged and even induced addiction in cases where it wasn't necessary. I absolutely think that drugs should be legal, but I think that part of that liberalisation should include responsible management of them. Encouraging addiction because those ruined lives are extremely profitable is the part of what the Sacklers did that I object to, not so much the distribution of the drugs themselves.
I have yet to see a single proponent of drug legalization (with the underlying reasoning being that if drugs were legal and produced to pharmaceutical standards, then no one would ever use them dangerously)
I am a proponent of drug legalization, but that underlying reasoning is garbage and I cannot think of a single person I know who holds the position I do based on that reasoning.
You have to simultaneously tear Trump down as a weakling and present yourself as a better vessel for their inchoate rage.
The Trump base might not be the most articulate but there are absolutely smart people in their orbit who understand their grievances and why they're so angry. You can win them over to someone who isn't Trump - but you need to understand why they went for him in the first place, and if you're going to claim that was because of vulgar social dominance you're going to fail each and every time. If you're interested in a good article that explains what attracted those voters to him, I recommend https://www.resilience.org/stories/2016-01-21/donald-trump-and-the-politics-of-resentment/
Worth noting that personally, I think he should be imprisoned, and for about one year, because he literally did do exactly what they are saying he did, with full knowledge that it was bad. Would be, I think, a great inspiration for holding people in power accountable for their actions.
As someone who is on the record as being relatively pro Trump, I could get behind this as long as it was the cherry on top of a series of good-faith prosecutions of political officials who mishandled classified documents in order of severity... which means that Trump would be coming well after HRC, Biden and a few other people. You'd also have to get the FBI agents who fucked around with the classified documents in question to boot. But absent that actual prosecution of people who did far worse than Trump (there was SAP material on the Clinton email server!), you're not going to get the red tribe to agree to this.
how shallow the Dem bench has become.
My favourite conspiratorial explanation for this is that the HRC team knew that she was such an unlikeable and unpopular candidate they went and kneecapped all her prospective challengers to make sure she'd have an easy time getting the nomination.
I've said multiple times on here and the old site that "democracy" is best understood as rule by the managerial elite - if Trump won with a majority of the popular vote, then got disqualified and replaced with the Clinton caretaker government by the CIA, that would count as a victory for democracy as the term is used.
Again, Donald Trump is a stationary target highlighted in high contrast paint. The Democrats have perfect data on windage and distance, and have the ability to sight in with lasers and use a bench rest to take their shot.
The problem with this is that the Dems are also held hostage by a galaxy of personal interests and corruption - the uniparty policies that Trump makes vast amounts of noise about taking down (his actual effectiveness at doing so has been mixed, of course). Sure, the democrats COULD change things around and run a real candidate who can stand up to Trump both in terms of personality and policy... but they won't, in the same sense that I COULD spontaneously type in the private key to some random BTC wallet and transfer myself a vast sum of money.
Those aren't the only people taking drugs - cocaine is rather famously a rich person's drug extremely popular with people in finance who absolutely abuse whatever drugs they can get for performance enhancement.
Second, we’re already bleeding hardware and equipment to Ukraine. This limits our options in other areas at least until we stop doing that.
Don't forget that the US is also going to be bleeding hardware, equipment and troops to Israel and the Middle East in short order as well.
China has a pretty strong military, and decent equipment. It’s probably a multi year war
Actually, I think the war would be pretty quick - if China and the USA go to war what actually happens is that the entire world burns in nuclear fire and then we have a really tough winter while the survivors try and put civilization back together.
Is it? I can see that when you're looking at the issue from within the media landscape of the US, but I don't see how you can draw that conclusion when you're able to access a variety of sources and see what the other side is actually saying.
CIA lost their entire network in China a few years back when they told them to use some stupid webpage and Chinese spooks figured it out.
They actually figured this out? I was under the impression it was from Clinton's email server, I hadn't heard of any actual confirmation for this one.
The activities of the Internet Research Agency are now public knowledge
I'd already mentioned this - I don't think their posting a bunch of BLM memes was enough to have any kind of measurable impact on the results of the election. I'll take concerns about Russian influence on American elections seriously when they get to the point of having a 10th of the impact that the Israelis have.
Campaign staffers such as Papadopoulos met with RU intelligence agents to arrange for embarrassing email leaks from people like Podesta, lied about it several times, and was sentenced to prison.
This ties in to the corrupt origination of crossfire hurricane - like the Carter Page warrant and Alexander Downer's involvement etc. If you want to talk about this incredibly complicated and opaque topic it will take an entire thread to hash out all the details and points of agreement.
Many other individuals such as his campaign manager(!) had suspicious links to Russia, and there has been plenty of additional evidence that Russia was trying to influence the election.
Wikipedia is worse than useless for this and the page you've linked even debunks some of the claims made in the article. The DNC and Podesta leaks were almost definitely not the result of Russian action, for instance. The US intelligence community can't actually be trusted on this topic - we know they were actively lying to deceive both when they made the Carter Page warrant application, and when they released the letter condemning the Hunter Biden laptop.
Russia has been interfering in US elections since the Cold War, and history has shown how much friendlier Trump has been to Putin compared to Biden or Hillary.
No? Hillary was literally buying fake kompromat from the Russians in order to attack Trump, and I can't see any indication that he was acting in Russian interests except coincidentally - there's some undeniable overlap in the policies that both Trump's base and the Russians support (like ending the forever wars and not purposefully starting a proxy war against Russia) but that isn't really a meaningful argument.
feel like a lot of people really needed that article by Eric Turkheimer on why race science is objectionable.
This article sucks. As a congenital leftist who doesn't like racism per se but has been convinced as to the validity of HBD, I was expecting something worth reading rather than "These beliefs are offensive because... you know, they just are, there's no point examining this further." This article isn't an attempt at explaining why race science is objectionable, it just assumes that it is and then proceeds from there. Yes, I know that answering these questions might make some people feel bad. That's not actually a reason to continually lie about it and engage in efforts at restorative justice that are doomed to fail because they're based on motivated thinking rather than a look at the evidence. If my car is refusing to start, should I simply ignore the fuel gauge showing empty because I don't want to believe that I'm out of gas and spend tons of money taking my car to mechanics to figure out the problem?
If the question of African IQ is a matter of empirical science, exactly what piece of evidence are we waiting for? What would finally convince the racialists that they are wrong?
There's actually a lot of evidence that could settle this! The problem isn't that no scientific evidence proving Tabula Rasa is accepted, but that every single time you actually do the experiment you end up with evidence proving the opposite or a paper that doesn't replicate. What even is the point of raising this as a hypothetical when in other places in the article he flat out admits that his own side should ignore evidence in favour of ethical concerns? He's also destroyed his own ability to prevent that evidence - why exactly should I trust an article written by someone who says that on this particular topic it is a moral imperative to lie if the facts don't match up to his ideology?
Watson is a legitimately respected and famous person on the basis of his great scientific accomplishments and the awards they have won for him, but those accomplishments don’t have very much to do with racial differences in intelligence, except that both domains involve the concept of “genes” in a very general way. It is safe to say that he does not know anything more about the subject than anyone writing here.
No, it isn't fucking safe to say that! Watson would absolutely know more about genetics and evolution than Eric Turkheimer, or me, or most of the people on the motte. Hell, I will flat out say that I know more about genetics than Turkheimer despite his years of study, because in this article he doesn't even seem to know how genes work (see his section on how the legacy of slavery is why African americans do worse on IQ tests). Of course, I think there's a decent chance that he is aware and is simply lying about it - after all, the position he takes is that this is a matter of morality rather than evidence, so it doesn't matter what the facts say.
I'll remind you that the vast majority of the actual escalation has come from Republicans.
This is extremely incorrect - the vast majority of the actual escalation has come from the intelligence community. It wasn't the Republicans who set up crossfire hurricane or ginned up the fraudulent Carter Page warrant. Those were the actual attempts at "democracy-proofing our institutions" and they began before Trump even took office.
EDIT:
To avoid duplicating reply chains, I saw you make this comment later on.
The origin of the Trump-Russia investigation is shrouded in bias, just like the investigation into Biden's son was. But in both cases it was clear that there were actual problems there. Not problems that reached up to the highest level, but problems nonetheless.
No, it wasn't! There was no real or serious attempts by the Russians to get Manchurian candidate Trump into office. The only role played by the Russians in that election (apart from posting a few BLM memes on facebook) was to provide the HRC campaign with a bunch of fake dirt they could use (via the Steele dossier) to have the Trump campaign spied on.
That's a lot of words but I think I may not have been sufficiently clear when making my point because this reply doesn't get at the core of my objection, which doesn't have anything to do with the distribution of the score. I'm aware that height doesn't follow the same distribution curves as IQ, but the point of using height was to make the concept of a threshold or minimum requirement more obvious.
AFAIK as IQ is deliberately intended to be normalized, the gap is exactly the same 85 to 100 as 100 to 115, and if you think that those two aren't the same, you are also inherently saying that IQ is the wrong tool for the job.
The point being made by your interlocutor is not that the 15 points of IQ between 100 and 115 matter more than the 15 between 85 and 100, but that it can be harder to tell the difference externally. To wit:
A fifteen point gap at the higher end of the distribution isn't likely to be noticeable in everyday casual interaction, but at the lower end it can be the difference between someone who can at least tell you their own name and a total potato.
A single casual conversation can give you enough information to determine whether or not someone meets a certain low threshold for IQ, in much the same way that a sign in front of a rollercoaster with a single black line at the height threshold can tell you if someone meets the minimum requirement or not. The fact that the single threshold of the sign gives you a bit of information about the height of people who compare themselves to it but is unable to give you more information about the distribution of heights among people who pass does not mean that a centimetre is measured differently above or below the threshold.
The simple, self-evident fact that IQ is fit to a normal curve and you yourself don't seem to believe that a symmetric 15 point gap is equal across the domain is in and of itself a tacit admission that IQ is the wrong tool
Imagine two groups of children go to a themepark and want to hop onto a rollercoaster, which has a minimum height requirement of 105cm. One group of children has heights that range from 110cm to 150cm, and the other group has heights that range from 70cm to 110cm. The symmetric 40cm gap would not be equal across the domain - is this a tacit admission that height is the wrong measuring tool for the job? A simple 15cm boost would have a different effect on each group's ability to ride the rollercoaster, so how can you say that 1cm is equal to 1cm between the two groups?
Is this fear of Ukranaian Nazis genuine, or just an attempt to sap anti-Russian energy in the West by associating Ukraine with one of the past century's great villains?
Speaking for myself as someone who doesn't really consider themselves pro Russian (but would likely be considered as such by others) there's no real genuine fear of Azov - they're just shown as an example of the hypocrisy of western governments. Nazis are the worst ever and need to be punched in order for democracy to survive... but these nazis are actually heroes, and your tax dollars need to be used to support them. The reason people bring up the fact that western governments are actually extremely pro-Nazi in the Ukraine is to damage the illusion that Western governments are motivated by ethical values("defending democracy" etc) rather than pure realpolitik.
There is potential concern that after Ukraine's defeat the remnants of the Azovites will become a far-right paramilitary organisation with a bone to pick with Europe, but nobody really cares - the far right are probably ok with an armed neonazi terrorist remnant fighting for their side and bombing synagogues, while the people who support the Ukraine war are doubtless extremely happy for there to be another reason for European tax dollars to get funnelled to arms/"security" companies once the war is over.
It's hardly clear that Trump would be materially better on this front.
He probably wouldn't, but that's actually an argument supporting the second claim - which I agree with. Voting for Biden because he would be indistinguishable from Trump in every way that they care about would just be a way to guarantee that the issues they care about are never addressed.
Do they actually have any kind of choice? I don't believe that Israel would be terribly accepting of an official Hamas Military outpost showing up anywhere in Gaza.
organization happy to putting their children in the kind of danger that produces fresh horrific images.
Are you claiming that Palestinians moved to Palestine just to make sure their children could die in order to win propaganda victories? The Palestinians didn't actually migrate to Palestine or Gaza just recently in order to make Israel look bad - they've been in the region for quite a while.

Actually, both sides of politics got involved trying to do this in Florida in 2000.
More options
Context Copy link