@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

I think the entire view isn't focusing enough on minority, plurality, and majority viewpoints. To wit, my own theory: Cancel Culture is when too many people all exercise their Freedom of Association in the same way at the same time. You can't know if any example of what you are doing is good or bad without considering the way the rest of the world will act. This applies regardless of the topic.

An extended analogy to dating to demonstrate what I mean. Romance, we can agree for the sake of the discussion, is an area where FoA is, and of right ought to be, absolutely sacrosanct. No one can force you to date or be attracted to someone you aren't attracted to or don't want to date. And no problems arise from this, provided that everyone's preferences are kaleidoscopically unique and match up with the diversity of options available. This is the utopian vision of FoA: a lid for every pot.

Imagine a Midwestern high school, with a student body that is more or less entirely varieties of mixed up European white mutt, with no particular dominant strain. Within this student body, some boys prefer sunny blondes, others sultry brunettes, and a few happen to really have a thing for redheads. On the flip side those same groups of boys find the other girls outside their preference less attractive, the blondes too dumb, the brunettes too boring, the redheads too pasty, respectively. This is fine, terrific even, certainly not a problem, provided that the rate of boys with those preferences lines up close enough to the rate of girls with those hair colors that everyone has a reasonable chance to get a date. If 40% of guys prefer blondes, 40% love brunettes, and 20% worship redheads; and 40% of girls are blonde, 40% are brunette, and 20% are readheads, then we win. FoA is great, we all get to date a girl we find really pretty, or be courted by a boy who finds us really pretty, respectively. On the flip side, if 90% of the boys are crazy about blondes, the remaining 10% prefer brunettes, and no one will touch a redhead, but we keep the percentages from above; then we get a distorted market. FoA is good, is sacrosanct in dating, but it has lead to negative outcomes: the blondes are besieged with fetishizing fawning attention, the brunettes are left competing desperately for the attention of just a few men, and the redheads are out in the cold.

Without violating strict FoA and forcing anyone to do anything, in the first scenario where everyone's preferences match up with availability, there's nothing wrong with allowing or even encouraging hair-color fetishism. Men, refuse to date any girl that doesn't have your preferred hair! But in the latter case, it would make sense to push the opposite message, hair color doesn't really matter that much, as such a message will make everyone happier.

We can play with this pet example in a million ways, with ranked rather than strict preferences, with touchy subjects like skin color or height instead of low stakes examples like hair color. But in all cases, I root for the less common preferences, and decry the more common. I love to see a girl cheat on her tall husband with a short king! Because I know girls who are 5'2" who won't date a guy under 6', that market is deeply distorted, so I love to see the opposite preference in action!

The problems don't occur from any one individual having preferences and exercising their freedom of association to enact them, they come from too many people having the same preferences and enacting their freedom of association together.

Back to Cancel Culture. FoA, and Freedom of Speech, require that no one is forced to hang out with anyone else, listen to anyone else, publish speech they don't agree with. And that is fine inasmuch as everyone else doesn't happen to have the same opinions, such that people get unpersoned. This is the basic American values of freedom we were taught growing up. If we all choose to freely associate in the same way at the same time, it becomes freedom-limiting rather than freedom exercising. This is the Christian virtue of reaching out to the oppressed and the outcast, visiting the sick and the imprisoned. There is virtue in eating lunch at school with the kid sitting by himself, even when you don't really want to.

McCarthyism was bad, according to this teaching, not because there weren't any Communists, and not because the Communists were right or weren't bad. It was bad because it lead to people being driven out of society, forced out of their professions. It ultimately failed because there were enough people who didn't really care all that much, and were willing to hire blacklisted workers, but for the brief moments when everyone did care, the results were tragic, with people totally shunned and unable to earn a living. Communists were wrong, but a man has a right to earn a living. I don't particularly object to any individual employer saying something like, my favorite uncle died in Budapest in '56, I'll never hire anyone who breathes a positive word about Lenin. But if everyone decides that no one who has ever breathed a positive word about Lenin can work for them, then we've got a problem.

Boycotts are the same. The Bud Light boycott is a good thing, regardless of your level of agreement with the motivation and rhetoric, because it represented a group that wasn't being heard in the discourse, and it inflicted pain for ignoring their demands. Companies hewed closer to mainstream views, and avoided strong stances. Bud Light was good because you can still be a libtard beer company, but you know what you will lose if you do. But you can also be a conservative beer company. Let a thousand flowers bloom! Cancel culture is bad when you can't be something, not when being something causes you to lose 30% of your sales. A moderate range of consequences isn't Cancel Culture, a total loss of ability to associate is.

If you want to avoid engaging in cancel culture, avoid being in the majority. Always be skeptical of the crowd, the mob, the herd. Refuse to be bullied into what is popular. Since anything worth doing is worth doing with fake numbers, the moment more than 20% of people agree with you, reassess your views and see if they will be harmful if everyone holds them. If you see something, don't just complain, reach out. Support places, like our very own Motte, where any voice can be heard. I started using Twitter after the Musk takeover for that reason, I wanted to support a free speech positive platform, even if it has had its problems since.

Any tax on assets becomes a new and relentless goad to optimization of assets.

A tax on income taxes doing things, earning money. A VAT taxes purchasing things, going out and getting things. A tax on property taxes you even if you do nothing at all.

And what this means is that you constantly have to be putting your property to its optimal use, your property has to be earning its keep.

A land-tax has the effect, if it is assessed on the hypothetical rather than current improvements as Georgists would argue for vacant land in cities, forces the owner to put his property to its greatest value. I can't decide I just like my sprawling old Victorian home, I have to turn it into a shopping center. I can't decide that I like my economically unviable small farm in the middle of a suburb, I have to subdivide it and build townhouses. Because Georgists want to tax it as though it were already townhouses, as that is the value of the underlying land.*

Taxing unrealized gains on companies will mean that people who own large shares in companies will have to put that property to its optimal use. I don't think we'll see founders selling off their shares and losing control, particularly where in IPOs it has been accepted that different classes of shares give founders control even with tiny holdings. Rather, we'll see companies being pushed towards paying dividends and returning capital, both to help defray tax bills and to reduce unrealized capital gains. Where once it made sense to hold a company and develop it into something ever bigger and try weird things in hope of producing even higher share prices; now it will make sense to have your shares in the company maintain their value while paying you a dividend. Money that might have been invested into moonshot R&D programs or skunk works will go back to owners of capital.

My guess is we'll see less of things like AWS because if you had a company like Amazon, it would make sense to have your successful online store paying you a 4% dividend rather than get hit with an unrealized gain tax if you hit blackjack on the next business. And we won't see vanity-project boondoggles like the Cybertruck, in favor of Tesla focusing on profitability and paying money back to Musk. But on the bright side, we might be spared another round of Metaverse hype?

The value of either of these propositions is debatable. Arguably it is better for publicly traded companies to pay dividends than to seek moonshot growth at all costs. Arguably it is better for me to build townhouses on my economically unviable farm rather than let it sit. But the flip side is that relentless optimization leads to less randomness, less adventure. A car company laser focused on maintaining a 5% dividend would never build something like the Cybertruck, judge for yourself the value.

*There are various workarounds to this in place already for property taxes in most states, which we can consider both proof that this is recognized as a problem with property taxes, and as a problem with Georgist moves towards property only taxation as using exceptions like that will get increasingly sticky.

Personally, I believe that the dose makes the poison and that people are different, and it's telling that the medical literature on the topic is clearly searching for downsides out of a puritan sense that they must exist while not having clear examples of any.

But, I'd imagine that they wouldn't be great for your teeth/gums, especially if you used a lot of them a day. And I'm pretty sure nicotine is addictive, though I've seen zero sign of it personally.

I tend to use a Zyn more or less exclusively when I'm on a long drive, or I need a pick-me-up on a boring workday and don't want to drink another coffee. Two to three times a week at most. I don't notice any craving for nicotine on days I don't, and I've sustained that pace since Easter more or less. They're very pleasant, in that it gives me a bit of a nicotine buzz and a little bit of energy, along with a little pop of flavor and a sense of "something going on" that on a long drive or boring doc review I might otherwise fill with a snack.

That's where knowing yourself comes in: while I've never really used hard drugs, I don't tend towards addiction to the soft ones I have used. I notice the pattern of behaviors in other people's descriptions of their relationship with weed or alcohol or nicotine, and I don't identify them at all. My relationship with alcohol, weed, kratom, modafinil, nicotine has mostly been one of having a vague idea of trying it or "getting into" it, then ignoring it entirely and forgetting about it in my cupboard. While my wife, who is by no means a person "with a problem," will tell me a couple times a year that I need to hide the weed from her. My friends, who I don't think are alkies, will talk about fighting the urge to have a drink as soon as they get home from work. I don't feel any of that.

A solid red Congress has zero chance of passing national ID legislation that enforces punishing employers for employing illegal immigrants.

Clown world when every department at HP has been thoroughly gutted except their wet work team, and every corporate maneuver they've attempted has failed except their assassination plots.

... Do you genuinely think that either of those policies has a snowball's chance in hell in Congress?

Not really. A large percentage of illegals come over legally then overstay a visa. To say nothing of those already present. Blocking one route increases the value of a different route.

The twin axioms of immigration seem to be:

Elite human capital immigrants entering the country is good.

Low human capital immigrants entering the country is bad.

I'd offer additional axioms which different groups of Americans hold on the topic of immigration:

  1. Importing labor is valuable to help utilize capital and reduce costs for farm goods and labor, particularly for seasonal labor.

  2. Current residents should be allowed to reunite with family.

  3. The efforts necessary to secure the border and to police the presence of illegal immigrants in the country now would require abrogations of civil liberties that would be totally unacceptable.

Buy-In Visas will not get the fruit picked and the turkeys slaughtered. And they don't solve the problem of how to enforce immigration law. I'd be all for them as an addition on top of whatever the current policy is.

I am however, all for putting a Jizya on all non-citizens, a flat tax somewhere between 2-10% of income. Set it at the profit maximizing point, to get the most out of the surplus immigrants obtain from the USA.

Has anyone run the numbers on what percentage of male-line preferred monarchs/rulers in history failed to produce a son?

By male-line preferred I mean to include not just pure primogeniture inheritance, but also cases like Imperial Rome where a son wasn't necessarily the heir, and one could have an heir without having a son, but if possible a son was preferred. In both cases one imagines that such a ruler tried very hard to produce a son.

Historic tradition has given birth to the superstition among the French farmers that a man named Napoleon would restore to them all manner of glory. Now, then, an individual turns up, who gives himself out as that man because, obedient to the “Code Napoleon,” which provides that “La recherche de la paternite est interdite,” [#5 The inquiry into paternity is forbidden.] he carries the name of Napoleon. [#6 L. N. Bonaparte is said to have been an illegitimate son.] After a vagabondage of twenty years, and a series of grotesque adventures, the myth is verified, and that man becomes the Emperor of the French. The rooted thought of the Nephew becomes a reality because it coincided with the rooted thought of the most numerous class among the French.

Read Marx's Eighteenth Brumaire.

Now imagine if Trump had turned a little to the right and been shot through the temple on live TV. Then the GOP nominates some ghoul, who betrays the MAGA cause, betrays the MAGA faithful.

Baron Trump would in that moment, if he chose, be your parallel institution. Monarchy isn't about institutions, it's about sacred blood. About devotion to an individual and a bloodline as superior. That's the kind of drama needed.

Which would produce vast electoral college and house of representatives implications!

Sure, but I have friends who rent who could afford land in another location.

Don't kid yourself that suddenly the government would get better at tracing things than they are now.

I'd be so fascinated to see landowner suffrage, in the sense of how the West would look. How would we chop up Wyoming if you needed acreage to vote?

Going braless is one of those things that goes in and out of fashion every fifteen to twenty years. Watch old episodes of Charmed, tons of visible nipples under shirts. Was very in fashion in the early 70s as well.

In every case there's an ideological superstructure of justification built around it, but it's mostly barber pole fashion theory. Much like the baggy-tight-baggy cycle of jeans, and the skinny-wide-skinny procession of ties. People will write essays about the ideological undercurrents lying within the choice to pursue a fashion, but it's post hoc.

At some point it gets complicated and we can split hairs. Are unit prices elastic to cost or primarily to demand? For the most part low end home buyers aren't actually checking things like electrical wiring, they're paying for ft^2 and location.

But the cost of putting conduit in a wall or under a parking lot is negligible. In any house I've renovated, I always run conduit between the major parts of the house, so as to at least be able to run a wire most of the way without cutting open any walls. Panel to the garage, panel to the attic, panel to the basement.

And how much capacity is there to enforce code requirements? The Gestapo isn't keeping track of all this, so you end up with people doing things without permits if doing them with permits costs too much money.

Like I said, the devil is in the details. What constitutes "readiness?" I'm all for conduit and panel space, very much against ripping out existing anything.

Tons of the ticky tacky national builders give their customers panels that are already completely maxed out, such that in order to add an outlet without breaking code requirements you have to redo the entire box. It's smart to avoid that. Running heavy conduit up to the roof and out to the garage before you close the walls is trivial, after it's major surgery. That's smart policy. Putting thousands of dollars in wiring in is a mistake.

Codes and code enforcement have always be and will always be instruments of politics. The devil is always in the details. That said:

While I probably wouldn't want it to be mandatory, in that I'd like very little to be mandatory, I've been yelling at every meeting for every project I work on that we're idiots if we don't plan for EVs. If you put in a parking lot today without running conduit under it for future chargers, you're a fool who will later be ripping up a parking lot. The cost of planning for the future should be minimal, requiring that commercial and residential buildings leave breaker space and place conduit before the building is closed up is smart. It avoids costly and often messy retrofitting later. Requiring them to actually put in the wiring and devices I would oppose.

Assuming that a critical mass of residents in an inspection state hated inspections, they'd get rid of it. There's at least some people who support inspections or it wouldn't exist.

Have any states gone from an inspection regime to a non-inspection regime?

I actually didn't recognize who they were supposed to be. It's not really "them" in any way the porn parodies of 2004 weren't "them" only without the actress informing us who she is.

Ok accepting this logic ad argumentum, why would we stop prohibition short of alcohol? Why does the line run precisely between Marijuana and Whiskey?

It seems incredibly likely that after the cease and desist goes out later this week, Grok is neutered, but in the meantime everyone has heard about Grok.

I think it's more of a Russell Conjugation, where actions that benefit the Democratic party are positive, while those that benefit the Republican party are sinister.

I remind my husband about all the bad things about Trump. He berates his wife about how terrible the libs are. I emphasize to my partner that if he really loves me, as a woman, he won't vote to take away my rights. He threatens to leave his girlfriend if she doesn't vote how he wants. I fortify my husband's resolve to vote against Trump when he gets tempted by bad arguments. He bullies his wife into voting against her own interests.

I'm not going to say I've never in my life seen a woman say something innocuous only to be snapped at by her husband who brusquely informs her that "we" don't believe that. But the idea that it is a crisis is just silly.

More women vote than men, so logically if anyone is convincing anyone to vote it would go that direction.

Anecdotally, Trump would benefit massively from removing spousal pressure on voting. This morning my dad joked to me that he'd like to vote for Trump to save me money on estate tax, but so much of my inheritance would be wasted in the resulting divorce that it wouldn't be worth it.

Far more women refuse to vote for tromp on moral grounds than men offended by Harris.