@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

the dead schoolchildren who, but for recent immigration from Africa, would likely still be alive.

Speak plainly.

This is true only in some trivial butterfly effect sense that is beneath notice, if you mean some deeper theory about it say it out loud.

The median private American view on trans issues is deeply philosophically inconsistent, combining both a level of acceptance that would make Ron Desantis cry with a level of bigotry that would be totally unacceptable to HR guidelines.

In all honesty, 90% of it comes down to what you picture a hypothetical trans girl looking like.

Are Republicans shamelessly sexually-humiliating their opponents enough to win this election?

Yes.

  1. I continue to favor Trump in the election at this point, because I believe that things will keep happening, and that there are many things that can harm Harris and few things that can harm Trump. Any economic downturn, any personal scandal, any international crimes by armies equipped by the Biden Administration. [Oh look, Netanyahu just bombed a hospital and even Reuters is inching towards the active voice. Oh look, Ukraine just invaded Russian territory, hope they behave themselves (and Putin isn't ballsy enough to pretend that they didn't even if they do). And stocks closed down again. A lot of people, myself included, emotionally thought the race was over after the shooting. Now people suddenly think Kamala is inevitable. I maintain the opinion that Kamala is shithousing, playing dirty for a draw. She's trying to win one news cycle at a time, keep her base invested in the process, and at least keep the national popular vote and the House in the D column. She's not trying to forward an overall plan, or make advances on policy, because that's not her goal. As long as Trump doesn't somehow manage to implode, he's still got this.

  2. Reading the replies, I'm realizing anew that so much of the online right consists of right wingers stranded in left wing professions and social circles. To wit: I see tons of content sexually shaming Kamala, from online to T shirts and signs walking around to bumper stickers in traffic. The attacks have been constant, including the sexual shaming of men who would vote for Kamala or of Walz for working with her, all previously discussed on this forum. I've encountered way more "Kamala is a whore" memes than I have "JD Vance fucked a couch" memes in real life. They haven't carried much weight outside of a slur for people who already hate her, because despite the obvious advantage of actually happening, they haven't been that effectively spread outside of existing right wing spaces because they aren't all that interesting, but they're all over the place.

  3. The couch jokes have spread so effectively precisely because they are so low stakes. Virtually every guy has a weird masturbation story, and they're a staple of the "coming of age memoir" genre, from Tim Allen to Angela's Ashes to Lena Dunham to David Sedaris. Interrogated Socratically, nobody would really say it mattered. It's not that damaging, the couch jokes are just an expression of dislike in a generalized sort of way. The only way the story can become serious is if Vance replies in a self-serious way. Here Vance replies to a question about what makes him happy by venting his rage about being asked stupid questions. I continue to rate Vance higher than the crowd, but if he fumbles the couch question similarly, it will be ten times as effective as it is now. The worst thing you can do is show that they're getting under your skin.

  4. The "Weird" attack is similarly effective because of the responses produced. The bizarre disconnect between the political elites and the average voter is one of those ongoing crises, like illegal immigration or gun crime, that can have attention drawn to them by the media at any time and made into a Big Deal. Your average American doesn't have well thought out consistent philosophical opinions, and the simple fact of having them on a large range of topics makes one weird. The attack can equally be turned on lefties, with similar results. Righties on Twitter have replied to accusations of weirdness by: calling it "feminine behavior," going off about trans people, talking about how they watch a lot of police bodycam footage and actually that's a new usage of "weird" among black youths, this is exactly how all the popular kids bullied me in school. In other words, in weird ways. Please, I'm begging everyone here, don't respond to this idea outside of the motte by talking about how masculine sexuality is shamed. It's not a good look.

  5. The only Republican that can effectively respond is Usha Vance, joking in an interview that "I might be the first political wife to have to sit her husband down and ask him, 'did you really make love to a couch?' Because I don't want to end up like Hillary Clinton, or Huma Abedin, or John Edwards' wife, where I'm denying it and then it turns out to be true!"

I stated all that in OP.

What I'm getting at is that the idea that people, regardless of their race, are obligated to vote for her based on her race is incoherent if the concept of race and the terms of that obligation aren't really defined.

This lacks context. Biden got Trump to agree to absurd debate conditions that Kamala wanted to hang onto.

I'll powerlift against @practicalromantic anytime anywhere, if @Walterodim wants a foot race I'll ask for conditions.

I'm thinking about it more, Republicans should compliance jurisdiction. Give the senior justices more options to hear cases, say cases about constitutional rights, or to vote on cases when it's 5-4. That would at the very least preserve the R majority until 2030, and might turn the whole project into an argument.

I have no credible anything. I've heard vague insinuations that the ranch was actually a brothel. But mostly, it was his death absent any apparent weakening or illness, out of nowhere, and his importance to the court.

It's pure shithousery, trying to play ugly and get a close draw or maybe sneak a win. Kamala is playing one news cycle at a time, tragically, and hoping to get a fast break late and win it.

I'm still negative on Kamala's chances, but I do think we're much more likely to see a Popular/Electoral split decision and a Democratic House than we were with Biden.

Excommunication.

The fear of being too pro Israel isn't so much about votes as a first order effect, it's fear of protestors>>>confrontations>>>viral video of riot cops pepper spraying teenagers>>>losing votes.

Not that many Democrats are truly pro Palestine from the River to the Sea, though I think the Israelis have overshot just how much margin for brutality they have. But Democrats naturally identify with young antiwar protestors at an emotional level, in the same way Republicans identify with churchgoers or families. Protestors, even ones they don't approve of, getting pepper sprayed or beaten or shot with rubber bullets is going to cause problems for Harris.

I don't think the policy has much to do with it beyond a mild justification. The nickname has more to do with calling him a tampon as (supposedly) an effeminate submissive man who exists to "support" a woman.

The deeper policy debate if there is one isn't going to be another round of trans bathroom bingo. It's going to be about casual misogyny, treating female bodily functions as disgusting, etc. Which could make either side look weird.

You don't need her to take positions. Attack the Biden admin, force her to defend Biden, join in the attacks and split her party, or admit she has no power in the admin and her job is fake and gay.

She's vice president. She can't disavow the admin policies. Differences will be around the margins and mostly stylistic.

Even accepting that, bad things can happen to Dems. Economic news can only be bad. Lurid crime stories. Netanyahu attacks a hospital and we get full 4k footage of a child literally being shredded. Zelensky takes some brand new American hardware and commits a cheeky war crime with it. A scandal comes out that we didn't even know about yet, who had "RFK hid the bear cub in the park in 2014" on their bingo cards? Biden can still suddenly decline in a way that makes things awkward.

Kamala was invited to the NABJ and turned it down. Most likely fearing questions about Palestine.

Kerry got absolutely soaked in 2004. The amount of credibility given to Swift Boat Veterans for Truth was ASTOUNDING!

Did Scott Adams ever accept that the last election wasn't stolen? I don't get why you'd expect a different result on the second try.

I like this.

It's not clear that the Robed Nine would win in a direct contest of wills with the federal government. If Harris says, we aren't going to listen to any decisions made by an improperly constituted Court, and will ignore them, then what happens? What seems most likely to me there is that Judicial Review is removed from American government going forward, the death of the SCOTUS, with original jurisdiction cases remaining a marginal lacuna to be dealt with in time. Is the alternative a gamble on violent outcomes, or governmental breakdown? I have trouble picturing John Roberts and Brett Kavanaugh signing up for that, though governments have broken over less.

The fun possibility: we might get a SCOTUS Avignon papacy, with two SCOTUSes sitting separately ruling each other illegal, with neither side being determined enough to take violent kinetic action, but simply ignoring each other for decades, with the result being legal chaos until we get a reunification of the belts (presumably) when Republicans win enough elections to claim a majority on the 18-year court or Democrats win enough and Republican justices die enough to get a majority on the lifetime court, at which point the conflict will conclude.

ETA: Thinking about it more, it seems like the decisive vote would shift over time in the current nine. It requires six to sit. Assuming simplistically that the Ds are pro-term limits and the Rs are against, the third term limit appointee would give the term limit court a quorum once the OG Ds show up as well. You could have a situation where first the OG SCOTUS excludes the term limit appointees, and then once the majority shifts the term limit SCOTUS convenes and the remaining OG justices can choose to caucus with them or not.

This is all starting to remind me of the periods in Ottoman history when independent rulers in North Africa paid nominal allegiance but were not under any concrete control.

Steelmanning the Strawman: Trump Has A Point About Kamala

OR

Bill DeBlasio is Blacker than Kamala Harris

TLDR: Trump’s attacks against Kamala, while characteristically garbling a more logical point, get at a deeper truth: why should black Americans (or anyone else) vote for Kamala as a Black Candidate when her experience of blackness (inasmuch as such a thing exists) is atypical? This demonstrates how progressive racialists lack a cohesive philosophy of why diversity is good, and who qualifies for diversity points and why.

Trump’s instantly infamous remarks* at the NABJ conference have been universally decried and only sporadically defended. As is typical, Trump has made a mush of a very incisive argument: when progressives tell us that Kamala Harris is an historic candidate for being a black woman, what does that mean? When they say, or at least imply, that Kamala Harris’ Blackness gives us a reason to vote for her, what are those reasons and why should we care about them?

To be clear, Kamala Harris is of course, literally half black and has never hidden that fact or pretended otherwise to my knowledge. She had a Jamaican black father, an Indian mother, attended Howard University (the premier Historically Black College), where she joined a black sorority. We can’t rule out that she lied about her race in some small way at some small point, perhaps lied to somebody in high school, or misreported her race on some official documents where she thought it might benefit her. But let’s compare her to another Democratic politician who traded on a questionable claim to blackness, one who I think was very briefly her competitor in the 2020 presidential primary:

Bill Deblasio is Blacker than Kamala

Kamala starts the comparison with a significant lead, on DNA and her Howard degree and whatnot. But let’s consider some other metrics! Bill has more black kids than Kamala does. Bill has more black spouses than Kamala does. Bill’s immediate family (prior to his divorce anyway, but we’ll ignore that for the exercise) had more black people in it than Kamala’s. Kamala hasn’t had a close relationship with her black father in decades, leaving only her sister; Bill had a black wife and black kids. Even if we expand a bit to give Kamala credit for her brother in law and nieces and nephews, Bill pulls away further: his wife had three siblings who probably also had some kids. Bill DeBlasio had more black loved ones than Kamala has now.

That may seem meaningless, but think about how black advocacy groups construct the idea of a leader being “one of [us]” as an important factor. Barack Obama said Trayvon Martin would have looked like his son. Bill DeBlasio could say that. Kamala Harris can’t. In all honesty, many of my friends have talked to me about “the talk” that their parents had with them, that cops would not treat them well and shouldn’t be trusted. Bill had that talk with his son, Kamala never has. When you hear about hate crimes on the news (let’s assume they’re a real fear ad argumentum) Bill would be worried about his wife and his kids, Kamala wouldn’t be worried about the Emhoffs or her mother.

So if DEI, in the sense that its important to put Black Women in charge, is about experiences, then DeBlasio should get more points than Kamala in some ways. But clearly he doesn’t, and no one would say he does. So what does it mean? It’s not in the blood, because no one would say that Harris or Obama before her are less black than Clarence Thomas. So it’s a minimum blood quantum, the one drop rule, but then after that nothing else matters. Which is either a silly way to insist that I make judgments about our country’s leadership, or an offensive one. Silly, because there’s no logical connection between the one drop rule and leadership if we don’t consider anything else, not experiences or percentages. If it's a DNA trait, we should see some who have more and some who have less. Offensive, because if the theory is that leadership is tied to non-Yakubian blood, then they should say that out loud, that this is a racial hierarchy. This dilemma becomes immediately apparent once we strip away the idea of questioning one’s experiences.

The question that Donald Trump is brave enough to ask, even if everyone else is too PC, isn’t “Is Kamala Harris Black?” It is, why should we care? If diversity is good, we should be able to measure its effects, and when it appears and when it doesn’t. I don’t know that Kamala ever lied about her heritage or altered her history. But she has certainly chosen to emphasize one aspect of her heritage where it offered her political advantages dating back quite a while. I’ve heard a hundred times that she grew up in Oakland, never that she spent a lot of time in Canada growing up. I’ve heard a lot about how she identifies with her distant father, little about the mother that raised her. And that just strikes me as, for lack of a better word, corny. I don’t like being told who to vote for based on race, but if you’re going to do it, then it becomes a political question that can be discussed, and it isn’t offensive to bring it up.

If only we could be having that discussion instead of a birther rehash.

*For what it’s worth, here’s how I would script an answer the question asked:

Republicans didn’t give Kamala Harris the label DEI candidate, Democrats did. Republicans value Americans as Americans, Democrats value people by the color of their skin. Republicans choose the most qualified person for the job, Democrats choose by the right skin color. So when Democrats say they’re going to make DEI picks, that they’re going to pick people by the color of their skin, then their picks are going to face that accusation. What Joe Biden did to Justice Jackson! Ketanji Brown Jackson, I might have some disagreements with her politics and how she decides cases, but she is a very smart very accomplished very qualified woman. And what Joe Biden did to her, he went out and he said he would appoint a Black Woman. And he did that for himself, he did that to try to buy votes, he did that so people would think he was a good guy. But when he did that, he helped himself, but he gave Justice Jackson an asterisk she’s going to carry around for the rest of her life. She will always have to deal with that comment that Joe Biden made to benefit himself, that she was only chosen for her race and her gender. If Joe Biden hadn’t said that, if he had chosen her and said she was the most qualified, she wouldn’t have to deal with that. So you have to ask, when Joe Biden talks about DEI, is he trying to help you, or is he trying to help himself?

Idk, just playing Sorkin, I’m sure Trump is better at this than me.

Excellent comment outlining the threat, but what is the response? Where is our Switch in Time That Saves Nine?

For those not versed in SCOTUS lore, FDR at the height of his New Deal power was repeatedly thwarted by the SCOTUS, which was conservative in the sense of operating under constitutional understandings that existed before FDR. FDR planned to pack the court, nominating enough new justices to dilute the conservative majority, and introduced a bill to do so. At the last moment, SCOTUS changed course in West Coast Hotel Co. v. Parrish, allowing the federal government vastly more of the powers that FDR wanted. The court packing plan died, and we have stuck with nine judges ever since.*

So this is the opening salvo by the Dems, as of yet merely a warning shot. Besides, as @ulyssesword put it "win[ing] every election forever" how can Republicans prevent this? What is the potential compromise, or amendment to the structural changes to the court, that can deflate the desire of the Democrats to do this? How can our present Justice Roberts imitate his illustrious predecessor Justice Owen Roberts and make a switch to maintain the peace?

We can talk all we want about sacred institutions, about precedent, about the constitutional order, but if the majority of Americans don't believe in those institutions enough to accept their authority, they are already moribund and just waiting for amputation. How can Republicans in Congress and on SCOTUS currently act to reach a new compromise, or to otherwise restructure the Court in a way that will make the plan either less deadly or less necessary? A compromise, a surrender, a poison pill?

If you believe that, as Vladimir Ilych Liberal wrote, Nothing is to be Done; that the Democratic party is so hell bent on complete tyranny that no compromise is possible, then there's no point bemoaning it, the court is dead. The Republicans will not win every election forever. Swallow the black pill.

But politics is about persuasion, and there aren't going to be a lot of people that need to be persuaded. Leaving aside a solution like "make the institutionalist case more effectively" which seems unlikely. What actions can be taken? I'm not sure I can think of any.

*Additional discussion of the Switch in Time: Arguably at the time, the nine member court was only sixty years old, more recent to them than FDR is to us. That precedent has grown significantly more ancient as a result of FDR's success in changing the direction of the court without packing it. So it was a bit less norm breaking. There is significant dispute as to whether the Switch was motivated by a desire to avoid the court packing plan, whether the Switch lead to the failure of the court packing plan or if it would have failed anyway, and a lot of other aspects of the history around this. I'm providing a thumbnail sketch of the classic story, we can argue about it more if anyone is interested.

**Post Script: I'm not inherently opposed to term limits. They would have multiple salutary effects. I don't think it's good for "death" to be a positive political outcome for anyone, and we should build institutions to avoid it. ((I'll always think there was more to Scalia's death)) It would reduce randomness: it's silly that HW, who won one election before I was born, still has a dead hand on the Court while Clinton, who won the next two, has none. It's a strange system that gives a voice to 1988, but not to 1996. Or that Obama and Biden's combined twelve years in office produced as many justices as Trump's four. It would also halt the race to the bottom on young justices, and allow the appointment of a brilliant jurist with health issues. Currently, the best qualifications aren't brilliant legal theory and talent, they are ideological reliability and a 50 resting heart rate. Increasingly, most justices are chosen with the bare minimum qualifications to pass muster in the Senate (which are themselves declining!) and the youngest age possible. Forget affirmative action, a president is a fool to nominate anyone other than an Asian American Woman, when you nominate a man you're leaving years on the table! The biggest problem with term limits is that introducing them randomly produces a particular set of elections as determinative, the RRRDDRRRD structure means that we know when majorities would turn, and we're stuck with that forever.

And, if we're doing SCOTUS reforms, what I want to see isn't term limits, it is PAGE LIMITS. Old decisions were just a few pages, now we get novels, and the longer they are the worse they are, near universally. The deeper the cuts they need to resort to, the more likely they're pulling a fast one. If you can't justify it in fifteen pages, you can't justify it. If you can't explain it in fifteen pages, you're probably legislating from the bench. Fifteen pages for the majority opinion, five for dissents, three for concurrences.

If you think he's worth keeping around, do you think you can actually defend his argument?

I could steelman it, but I don't particularly agree with it so I'm not sure I particularly want to at length. It's a meaner variant of the Great Sort hypothesis offered by a Murray or a Lee Kuan Yew in the past. That first worlders have been "sorted" successfully into the smart and the dumb by various mechanisms, such that those "still" poor are the absolute worst, the hard cases, the genetic dregs. LKY talks about this when discussing the professionalization of union organizers in Singapore: in the early days there were many smart workers in the union, but today any intelligent Singaporeans end up in white collar jobs, so if you continued to draw union chiefs from the shop floor you would get people too dumb to function as good union chiefs.

My problem with banning him has less to do with people I like vs people I dislike as with wanting to avoid calcifying the userbase of the motte. Near as I can tell, this is being banned for jimmy-rustling, rather than for any content problems. Certainly we see similar posts about groups that are primarily out-groups to mottizens, the "bioleninists." A similarly structured argument about Palestinians, negroes, women, gays, illegal immigrants, etc would be skated by. ((Though I will note again that those posters who get obsessed with that kind of posting do tend to eventually catch bans anyway)) I'm positing that if we label it banworthy to offend the userbase of the motte, then at that moment we set the userbase in stone and preclude any changes in the future, because anyone who wants to join will find offensive material targeted at them to be common, and that turnabout is not fair play. That is akin to announcing official forum positions: one can, but is not required, to believe that blacks or arabs are inferior; one cannot believe that working class whites are inferior.

Those whose jimmies have been rustled can simply choose not to participate.

I should note that I recently complained about the Count in another comment, for his use of a minced oath, which I find to be annoying behavior.

I don't think it's that readers are bored of it, it's that writers are. It's been done before. Writers, good writers anyway, are setting out to create something. Burroughs and Howard already exist, so the only things you get like them are either twists in some way or they're thinly veiled fanfiction.

+1. While there's an obvious element of trolling for reactions from the crowd, a lot of stuff would slide right by if it didn't get reactions from the crowd. Target this level of vitriol at a group that isn't here or that the denizens don't identify with and it's a normal day ((though most of those posters don't hang around))

That's exactly the problem though. Recognizing the motte and Bailey doesn't lead naturally to therefore attack the motte harder. Instead you recognize and you keep the fight in the bailey, you endeavor to cut off the motte so they can't support the bailey.

Here, I fear that those concerned about trans participation in women's sport are setting themselves up for a fall. Everyone from JK to DJT have publicly attacked Khelif, who is going to leave Paris with a medal around her neck. Perfectly timed for a TV special on CBS Sunday morning, where the crew takes a look at her life growing up, her training, how she never knew about her DSD diagnosis, talking head from the IOC comes in to say it's fair, the "attacks" she suffered, and then gets some talking head with an MD to come on and say "Intersex disorders are very common and gender is really complicated!"

Conflating rare invisible intersex disorders, or just having (eurocentric) masculine features, with being trans is what the TRAs want. They want terfs to make themselves look bad attacking sympathetic targets.

Male pro at 5'10 135

Extra test gets you extra muscle. A male minimum health body fat is 8-10%, while for women it's closer to 16-20%.

Also, on wikipedia she's listed at 5'10". Assuming she cuts some weight, probably walking around at 150-160. Which is roughly the height and weight I was when I started rowing in college.