@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

Zero. If he eschews striking in favor of lunging, she'd just run away, while peppering him with jabs for his trouble. He's not going to catch her. She's faster, especially within the context of moving while keeping cover on an opponent. If he just sprints at her, she's going to change direction faster than he can, while hitting him in the face, which may not immediately knock him out but he's not going to like it.

I'll cede that a man, even a relatively old man, who is in reasonably robust condition could probably win a hockey fight where they grab each other's sweaters and wail on each other with no room to escape, strategize, or dodge. But now we're sort of building a series of increasingly absurd hypotheticals that don't tell us much about olympic boxing at all at all.

Ilona Maher is actually a pretty dead on ringer for me in height and weight, while I have the advantage of being male and she has the advantage of being an elite athlete. She posted workouts that I think I could do trivially, but not without effort, like hitting a 235# front squat for three reps and multiple sets. ((My wife joked that I should have married her, we could share clothes and spot each other on squats.)) Do you think that every random untrained man can hit a 235# front squat for a clean triple? Idk. Probably within six months to a year of training I would expect a reasonably fit man to hit two plates, but I have friends who work out for whom it would be non-trivial. Certainly if we had a motte-up I would expect to see a few mottizens drop the bar onto the safeties if we made everyone do 235x3 below parallel.

I don't think the strength difference is big enough to make the difference, unless we start playing with absurd hypos: he's a 70 year old but he's a track athlete, and we shoved a neuralink up his ass so we're playing him with an xbox controller and he isn't going to feel fear or pain he's just going to go for it no matter what, and he's 70 and has spent his whole life training but has no nagging injuries or health issues, no bum knees or blood thinners that mean he bleeds like a stuck pig, he's never fought in the ring before and is totally untrained but he's got a perfect head for strategy and ideal sangfroid, etc.

I'm not sure "cuts weight and loses, puts on a bunch of muscle and starts kicking ass" is exactly an argument

A man is going to have an easier time cutting weight, less of the female bodyfat that is more or less uncuttable.

It's extremely and unequivocally pro-trans rhetoric to say that some women, who are born with female genitalia, have an invisible issue they are born with that adjudicates that they are actually male and should live as men.

So are we assuming that your 70 year old is a top 1% athlete for his age group? That obviously changes the calculus significantly!

I'm picturing a robust 70 year old man, of which I know several. Many are still very strong, more than capable of deadlifting a decent number or helping you move a couch. But age brings limitations: most are not going to be tremendously good at keeping up physical activity for extended periods. Mile times slow by about 33% between peak and 70. An untrained 70 year old is going to do a mile in around 10-12 minutes, a girls high school track runner of mediocre ability will do it under 7, and I'm going to very much bet an olympian will be equivalent to a high schooler in miles run per week. And I don't even think we need to question who will recover more easily from the effort of the mile.

The thing is, assuming we've removed the Marquess of Quensbury rules, we've also removed round timers, rest period, and the 10-point-must system of judging. So our female olympic boxer is under no obligation to limit the fight on time, or to attack at a pace necessary to avoid losing points. The 10-point-must system is the only thing protecting the old man from defeat here, take it away and I think he's hosed.

The standard outline strategy for a lighter, weaker fighter who is trying to win by finesse and speed is to stay on the outside, hit and run striking your opponent quickly and getting away before they can hit back, counterpunching when they try to come in on you and then retreating before they can close the distance, feint and then dodge and retreat, wasting your opponent's energy. As he gets tired, go in for the kill, increase the attacks as he slows down and gets worse at catching you.

An untrained guy, especially one trying to "mog" you with power, is going to be throwing big wind up haymakers. He can't produce power while remaining compact, that's a technical skill that is very difficult to teach and takes practice. His arm punches will not be threatening, only his haymakers. You'll be able to see it from a mile away if you're an olympic level boxer. There's almost no chance of "catching" her in open field, it's only going to happen if she chooses to close. In a standard match, you can't just retreat constantly because you're handing the round to your opponent. Without judges' scoring or rounds or point deductions or DQs for not being aggressive enough, you can just choose to retreat and only do the absolute bare minimum to force him to keep expending energy pursuing you (ie to keep him from being able to rest with his hands at his sides for extended periods). This is where cardio goes in: no average 70 year old can keep up intense physical activity for half an hour with no break. Every olympic boxer can. After running in circles and swinging at air for thirty or forty minutes straight, if he doesn't die of a heart attack on his own, he'll be wheezing and his hands will be down and it will be easy to knock him off.

This should be fairly doable for a female fighter unless we're going with a really big weight class and height difference, Amy Broadhurst is 5'8" and I think she could fight a 5'10" 175lb geezer without too much trouble on reach.

I give it a 5% chance one of his haymakers connects early, but not much more than that. You'd lose a LOT of money.

The main thing a professional female fighter would have against an untrained male is cardio. Especially assuming we get rid of round breaks.

And, gee, the stock market is not looking great this morning.

Fights between really strong unskilled fighters and really skilled but weak fighters (under marquess of Queensbury) look more like the skilled fighter dancing on the outside, trying to sneak in jabs and counterpunch while avoiding taking big hits. A woman defeating a man would look more like going the distance without taking many punches, than it would like getting a quick ko.

The Olympics are built for TikTok, and then whatever the Facebook version is. You get a huge sporting event where I'm not watching most of it live, and you just pour out highlights and lowlights and controversies. Toss in that the sporting public is even worse informed than usual, and you have a recipe for arguments. ((I am once again begging people to watch the events we're arguing about))

TikTok came out in 2016 after the Olympics were over, and Tokyo was a weird one with COVID and no crowds and a lot of athletes having been thrown off in their training. This is the first real Olympics with TikTok.

They were linked! You can also just Google insane Khelif v Broadhurst!

Those are all important possibilities, but Khelif doesn't even fight like a stronger physical fighter. She mostly fights like a tall, lanky, weak fighter. Seriously, I don't understand what the argument that she's a man is, precisely because a man would just get in there and physically dominate! Why didn't she up until just the fight with Carini?

Nah he makes a baseball glove for when you don't know what position you'll be playing until you get to the field.

Sometimes you write a thoughtful essay combining fresh interpretations of classical literature and current events and get crickets, sometimes you use the term cunt hair and spark a vibrant discussion.

Did you watch fights from 2-3 years ago to establish whether there's any difference in technique? I didn't see it in the OP.

Yes, I linked and summarized her fight against Broadhurst, unless that tape was taken down as well. I watched a few others, but that felt like too much linking for shit that it is readily apparent that no one watched, or possibly even read the summary of. Her fight with Broadhurst is representative, in that she is clearly the weaker fighter physically, getting bodied around the ring by Broadhurst.

Have you ever had a woman hit you as hard as she can? IANAB, (and to be fair neither was she), but it's an absolute nothing IME; like, we could do this all day. Going from that to even an untrained male punch would be a shock to the system I figure.

I've only ever sparred with women, never gone full speed. But I agree with you: a man obviously punches much, much harder than a woman. ((I will say training has a big impact on how hard women hit pads, but that is of limited value)) Which is why it is obvious that Imane Khelif is not a man: Hermano Khelif would have been muscling her opponents around, battering their defenses with a brutal level of strength. If one watches boxing at the amateur level one can see the pattern of how a fight between a physically dominant but less skilled fighter goes with a more skilled boxer. It doesn't look like Khelif v Broadhurst.

Give it time. We still have time for Chicago to be an historic disaster, for Kamala to do something foolish, for Netanyahu to do something disgusting leading to terrible Biden admin press, for Ukraine to collapse, for the stock market to crash, for like six more Boeing planes to crash.

After the shooting, I thought Trump had it in a walk. He's since managed to make it interesting. But that should be a reminder that anything can happen.

Thanks. Not a word I use frequently.

I still remember how heartbroken my neighbor felt. He is a bicycle enthusiast who survived cancer, Lance was his idol!

I laugh every time someone claims X wouldn't do steroids he's too good a guy. Everyone would, love. If they wouldn't, they wouldn't be here.

I've seen a lot of "confirming" he was a groyper, but I generally disbelieve that anything so convenient can happen to the worst people in the world.

...I did watch the fights and offered analysis in OP...

I truly can't underrated why everyone is going off priors and theories and medical studies when we have the real thing right in front of us to be observed. It's like imagining German generals in 1916 still talking about the Schlieffen plan and the concentration of men/meter to carry on vigorous attacks.

While we're discussing this: any news on motives? I'm amazed that no one has doxxed the guy on Reddit/chan/whatever by now, no friends have come forward.

At what point would these guys actually draw a line in the sand?

Ironically, I think more of them might cowboy up if they actually thought Trump had a permanent movement in place to maintain power over time. Right now Trump is strong enough that you can't control a winning GOP without controlling MAGA, but there's no MAGA bench behind him. Desantis, Rubio, Cruz, Kemp all think that Trump is going to disappear. Maybe in November 2024, maybe in January 2028, maybe at any given moment if the bullet had been aimed a cunt hair to the right or if a glob of Wendy's-induced-cholesterol gets stuck in the wrong tube. And when Trump shuffles off the scene, the Never-Trumpers will not inherit the party. No matter how he goes, Nikki Haley's career is over, she gambled on Trump getting sent to prison and lost. They're all angling to pick up the pieces and unite the party after Trump leaves, Kemp and Cruz think they just need to endure Trump for a few years then they'll be freed.

If only there were some way to figure this out like watching the fights.

I'd love to see him get trolled on the debate stage about that.

No the IBA recognition was yanked years ago as a result of totally unrelated accusations of corruption related to their relationship with Gazprom.

The IBA is just getting involved in this to troll the IOC. Which, hey, great opportunity.

But Shapiro has previously claimed this as a thing he did and valued as an experience.

.... What are you talking about?

Would you accept that argument for a school project that benefitted the IRGC or the PLA?