FiveHourMarathon
a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop
And every gimmick hungry yob
Digging gold from rock n roll
Grabs the mic to tell us
he'll die before he's sold
But I believe in this
And it's been tested by research
He who fucks nuns
Will later join the church
User ID: 195
I think you misunderstand my argument. Trump's unique personal bond with his voterbase would probably enable him to hold onto the vast majority of them, a larger than normal portion of them, regardless of his statements. While his pivot would cause Democrats to hurt themselves in their confusion. When Trump has gotten to the left of the Dems, the Dems get spooked and either go right and alienate their own voters (who mostly don't trust Democratic politicians anyway), or they go even farther left and alienate everyone else.
So Trump comes out for a ceasefire. Harris is in a Dilemma; if she tries to go further left and withdraw all support for Israel she alienates most normal Americans, if she tries to swing zionist and talk about our steadfast support for Israel she alienates a lot of voters she needs in November. Where does this cash out for votes?
I don't think Trump would follow through on it in office, or that it reflects his personal views. I think it would be a political masterstroke, forcing Harris onto the back foot, and likely tying her to any bad thing Israel does between now and November.
Whereas if Dems pivoted against Immigration, they would alienate a lot of their own voters, who don't trust them on immigration, and they wouldn't really win over any Republican voters, who don't trust them on immigration. What makes Trump unique is his charismatic personal bond with a lot of voters, who think he will do the right thing even when he has specifically said he won't.
Shapiro's gubernatorial campaign sometimes seemed aimed specifically at trying to get Dougie boy's supporters to call him a Jew.
I've been under the impression, in my own bubble, that Trump could roll up the Dems if he came out and said CEASEFIRE NOW. He's flirted with it, saying he'd fix it when he was in office and that's why Arabs would vote for him. But if he really came out saying he was against the war and calling Biden genocide Joe, the Democrats would be sent into such disarray that he'd win on a gimme putt.
Perhaps Harris and co have the opposite opinion, that Trump or a major enough surrogate can be baited into attacking Shapiro on anti Zionist, anti semitic, anti Israel grounds and this will be good for Harris.
I got another illegal fake anti-Harris attack text, pretending to attack her in ways that clearly benefit her with most voters.
Real Socialists see through Kamala: She's a fake progressive. Kamala supports Law and Order, Border Control and wants to FUND "community policing" across America. Harris can't be trusted to stand for REAL social justice and she should not lead our Democratic Party. stop to end
These seem to be faking attacks from people everyone hates as a qualification for Kamala. The last ones I got were absurd Christian extremist, these are absurd progressive socialists. Maybe this is a continuation of the strategy?
So wait, the IBA is still around even though it isn't recognized by the IOC because of accusations of corruption, right? Is the IBA giving money to all the medal winners even though it isn't involved?
I'm in favor of allowing mild test supplementation.
It's that I'd like both sides to rely less on their political assumptions and priors and actually watch the damn games.
In Track and Field we've been forced to watch dominant male-bodied athletes cruise past their competition and been told nothing to see here. Now we're seeing a mediocre competitor treated as "Prime Mike Tyson" by the anti-trans press, who simply refuse to actually watch the damn fight and examine what is happening. I'm sick of being told "Who are you going to trust, me or your lying eyes?" Sports questions require answers that come from examining the outcomes of the sport, not from internet shibboleths.
Damn. I've always just heard it as a legend.
She did not get TKO in any normal sense of the term, nor do we have any reliable information as to the status of the other boxer. She got tagged by one good punch and gave up.
if it’s not okay to criticize someone in her capacity as “woman” but okay to criticize someone in her capacity as “white + woman,” I’m going to apply some Occam’s razor here and say this has more to do with the “white” part of the equation than the “woman” part.
I'm not understanding where Occam's razor comes down that way.
All the things White Women are criticized for in woke spaces are things Women are criticized for in TRP spaces. I tend to hold the view that these are accurate stereotypes of women, generally, regardless, so the simplest explanation is that the use of the qualifier "white" is meaningless, it is used to provide cover.
Fair point!
Myself. If she'd refused to participate I'd respect the decision and my default is against male participation in combat sports, and athletics generally. I was very anti Caster Semenya, for example. But watching the brief fight it was clear that I was being told something that didn't make any sense.
It might have been so, but if so it was a mistake. She'd be much better off refusing to compete in principle, which has happened before. Walk into the ring and then announce it before the fight. Or see out the fight.
I'm convinced that 95+% of attacks on "white women" in progressive spaces are just laundering misogynistic attacks through a racial lens to let wokies say "Women cry to get their way" or "women are frivolous and stupid" without getting called out.
I'm not sure what my feelings on chromosomes are. My general default is that physical presentation (ie visible genitals) rule first along with organic social presentation (though this is less telling as trans ideology spreads), and any other medical testing for natural conditions is a little squicky. I suspect if we tested male competitors we would find higher than expected incidences of xyy syndromes, which lead to greater height and higher test levels. It would seem ridiculous to ban those men. I'm not sure how to translate it back.
Is there any proof of the old weight room legends about East German female weightlifters transitioning to male after their careers ended because they had shot so much test into their bodies that they were mostly there already?
I should also note that I have sparred with guys much bigger and stronger, I was a wimpy 16yo training with grown male amateurs. Which is where my point came from, cover up run away and survive to the bell if you can't hang.
Many were the times the round timer went off and I had to tell the guy "Hey look I think we're going too hard for me."
-
Basically everybody Lance competed against at the highest level was also doping.
-
It radically changes the debate to say the advantage is routinely surmounted. It also undermines Carini's testimony that "she's just too strong."
The proof of the pudding is in the eating. If she has overwhelming physical advantages, such that they are unfair to allow in competition, then it would show up in her fight with Broadhurst. It doesn't, Broadhurst bullies her around the ring. I've never heard of a hormone that doesn't work against the Irish. That's the most objective evidence we can have about unfairness in boxing: the boxing!
I guess I see your point that we could all refrain from any discussion on the topic absent personal knowledge, but the standard of proof has to place the onus somewhere, and there's significant moral hazard in a "believe all women accusers" standard. It seems morally obvious to me that the requirement should be on the party crying unfairness to offer evidence of unfairness. Given that the record in the ring is mixed at best and offers no clear support for disqualifying Khelif, additional evidence must be offered on that side.
What evidence am I supposed to have if we're not trusting institutions? Am I supposed to go grope her? The evidence I offered was the analysis of the fights she was in, if you want to dispute that evidence it is on you to offer evidence that she is intersex.
Homosexuality and gender transition are definitely illegal in Algeria. It's not an Iran situation where Persians are weirdly fine with transition as a solution to Homosexuality.
It's not technically impossible that it's a birth certificate identity fraud or Balls-at-twelve situation, but I'm pretty comfortable putting the onus on those looking to disqualify. The assumption should be that someone who was born as female is female.
None of which changes the outcome of the Carini fight.
Dammit! I already wasted time chasing it around!
You're just finding reasons to get cold feet.
A Carnival of Bad Sports Opinions
I'm sure by now everyone has seen the 43-second fight between Khelif and Carini. Full 43 seconds here and the money shot in slow-mo here.
What a ludicrous display. The bigoted opinion most supported by this farce of a fight isn't anything about Khelif's genital arrangement or chromosomes, it is that women's boxing shouldn't be in the olympics if this kind of crybaby shit is going down in there and no one is immediately calling it out. I spent some of my teen years being a weak, wimpy boxes (coincidentally at about that height and weight!) and this is just not how a fight goes when you realize that your opponent is much stronger than you and get scared when you realize you don't have a chance. You shell up and avoid leaving yourself open, you get on your bicycle and run away, you throw tentative tight jabs while keeping your hands up to keep them on the outside, if they get inside you immediately clinch to avoid further punishment. I was a teenager bad at boxing and working out with a lot of grown men much better than me, I was frequently in this position. What you don't do is what Carini did. You don't attack, extend yourself, drop your hands, get tagged, and tap out. I'm not an expert on Olympic boxing, but I've never in my life seen any male fighter, from the level of muay thai smokers up to the pros, surrender like that for no apparent reason. If a male fighter tried that, I would assume it was fixed.
Carini may have been outmatched, but she easily could have fought the round out defensively, run away, survived to the bell, and thrown in the towel between rounds. Minimal shame in that. I'd even be a little less judgmental if she truly took a dive and faked a "phantom punch" and just dropped to the ground to take a KO loss. But to give up not even halfway into the round after taking one punch, when she was clearly fully functional and unhurt? It makes a mockery of boxing. The majority of the felt force of that punch wasn't even relative to the strength of the boxer, it was the near perfect angle given by Carini with her hands low and her chin out.
One of Khelif's former opponents Irish boxer Amy Broadhurst has stepped up in her defense. In one of the funnier twitter exchanges I've ever seen, a random user asks Broadhurst how she would feel if she had to fight Khelif; Broadhurst has beaten Khelif in the ring multiple times in international competition. Here's footage of Khelif looking significantly less manly when someone has the guts to stand and bang. The mick keeps her hands up, gets inside, and punishes Khelif, who clearly gets gassed from the punishment taken from the stronger Broadhurst. This presumably settles the old North Jersey debate over whether Irish or Italians are tougher? Watching these fights I probably drop my opinion on women's boxing, Broadhurst is willing to tank a hit and get inside and go to the body hard, and wins the fight handily.
This is, in my mind, one of the great unsung tragedies of the rise of the trans movement. A woman, born female in a country where homosexuality and gender transition are illegal, raised as a woman, but born tall and with a face and body that is undeniably a bit masculine (especially by global and eurocentric standards), is now under constant suspicion of being secretly male. I have no idea what intersex condition Khelif might or might not have been born with, and no public statement has been made that confirms any testosterone testing. The presumption must be, absent testing, that a girl raised as a girl is a girl. There is probably an inappropriate level of testosterone at which a female competitor should be removed from competition or forced to suppress the level, but we still have yet to see evidence that Khelif is in that category. Further, there is a moral hazard created by normalizing edge cases, in that a competitor will accuse their opponent of gender-violations. Some of the more insane red-state laws allowed any parent of a competitor to require testing of any opponent, which I have to imagine would be abused constantly to try to demoralize one's competition by having a weird judge examine your vagina before the big game.
The takes on the "Defend Women's Sport" side of the debate have been degrading in quality, as TERFs like Rowling have risen in prominence. My problem with the pro-trans "there's no difference" side has long been that not one of them has any knowledge of or enthusiasm for sport. I feel like we're seeing more of that from the TERF side here, with the idea that Khelif is just SO MUCH STRONGER that Carini was forced to quit for her own safety being parotted across Twitter without any evidence. I'm embarrassed for my side of the debate, if this is made a serious test-case for trans bans it is going to harm the cause for reasonable restriction in sport.
At the end of the day, I don't really object to transwomen competing in women's sport, I object to them winning. If they lose, then clearly it was no big deal. It's only if they win that it presents a problem, we got the science wrong. Given that binary, it would benefit the trans movement if they avoided trans women in sport altogether. But alas, here we are, in the carnival of bad sports opinions.
ETA:
https://apnews.com/article/angela-carini-imane-khelif-boxing-63e9dbaa30f1e29196d4162c72c2babf
Poor girl. Doesn't deserve some fat asshole from Pennsylvania going off on her for something she says she regrets.
Yeah, I just think using minced oaths should be a bannable offense. If you want to say nigger say nigger, terms like "the n-word" should only be used when discussing how stupid it is for people to say "the n-word." It's juvenile, and either hopelessly cowardly or deeply mean-spirited.
Definitely, and honestly I'm not sure the Willie Brown story is going to end up getting anywhere as a result. They're not threading the needle so far, at least online, and if the misogynistic or anti-sex "tee hee blowjobs" version of the insult gets around the world before the vaguely me-too and corruption tinged "trading sex for career advancement" version, then it might inoculate a lot of people against it.
That being said...
[I]t seems like it'd be fairer to characteri[z]e her as having once been in a relationship with political benefits. Are wives in general trading BJs for financial security? On some level you can put it like that but it's reductive and says more about the attitudes of the person choosing that phrasing than it does about the wives.
It's become standard ethical practice to avoid any and all workplace romance. It's widely considered wrong to sleep with a subordinate, and if a supervisor sleeps with a subordinate and then promotes them, the presumption is quid pro quo. It seems obvious to me that there is a moral hazard involved in electing a woman who used such a quid pro quo to kickstart her career to the presidency. It sets an example for young girls. I can think of worse and less qualified presidents and presidential candidates, but not since LBJ have we had a president whose entire career was built on early acts of low moral character.
Where your comparison to wives falls apart is that my wife isn't just trading me blowjobs for financial security. We are also mutually exchanging love, care, companionship, mutual support, being nice to each other's parents, faking interest in each other's dumb hobbies. But if Willie Brown appointed Kamala to various political sinecures in exchange for love, care, companionship, mutual support et al; that would also be corrupt. Reducing it the gross, bodily aspect is obvious, it's a political attack not patticake. But "Blowjobs for political jobs" seems like a fair if slanted interpretation of "casually dated a politically powerful man 30 years her senior who appointed her to various sinecures which boosted her political profile." Because none of the relational aspects, wholesome or pornographic, should have anything to do with who Willie Brown appoints to those positions.

College crew was known for years as the Title IX destroyer. Our men's team didn't own any boats, we borrowed them from the women's team, who happened to own twice as many as they needed.
I should also note, I watch a decent amount of women's sports. I used to catch a lot of Roussey's championship bouts, and my mother and I watched a lot of Caitlin Clark's basketball games last year. It's perfectly possible to make an entertaining and profitable women's product, doing so just often goes against the ideology they're trying to promote. I actually think social media has had a salutary effect, hot Olympians can do the influencer thing, which encourages an emphasis on physical beauty, which makes it all more entertaining.
More options
Context Copy link