@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

The sentiment / revealed consensus of TheMotte is a valid topic of discussion for TheMotte, and past comments can serve as important data for many conversations.

If you want to reply to a particular comment, reply to it directly and keep that thread going. Don't start a whole new argument trying to take the high ground looking down on them. Upvote analysis doesn't show revealed preferences accurately, it mostly shows the attention economy, a lot of which has to do with timing.

I want to register my distaste for quoting and upvote-analyzing prior discussions, and for ChatGPT summaries of articles. Idk that it's worth reporting, but it feels like something that shouldn't be done often. If you can't be arsed to summarize it yourself and the readers can't be arsed to read it, maybe just let it go.

The debate on this just reminds me that there are approximately seven principled libertarians, and everyone else is just using libertarian arguments when convenient. This goes at least back to the States Rights arguments around slavery that lead to the American Civil War, which flipped completely in regional and political valence the moment Abe Lincoln got elected. The slave states were pro-federal-power to enforce the fugitive slave acts, right up until they saw that power likely to be turned against slavery.

I don't know if you know all this or not, so my apologies if this is repeating the obvious.

You have the basic concept right. A lot of stuff in Project 2025 is the kind of stuff that's been in every Republican Party Platform at the national convention, on every Republican Presidential Candidate website, in lots of Heritage Foundation white papers, etc. The actual stuff they want to do is neither particularly surprising nor frightening.

What does make it a game changer is the creation of lists of state-level experts willing to serve in a Republican administration and pursue these goals, along with a plan to expand the spoils system such that a huge number of government functionaries will be fired

Republicans/Conservatives have been hamstrung for decades by the dynamics of government work. In many ways from the New Deal onward, but certainly accelerating since Reagan, growing worse under Bush II, and critical under Trump. The people who go into Government aren't Republicans by attitude, and people who are Republicans by attitude don't go into government work. In the same way cops are mostly Republicans because young Democrats don't tend to become cops, EPA staffers are mostly Democrats because young Republicans mostly don't want to work for the EPA. As a result, even when an R admin takes over in the White House, they can appoint a new Republican department head, but that department head can only direct a vast number of Democrats. /u/Tracingwoodgrains has provided a recent overview of how this works in the legal field, where the Federalist society has created what amounts to a list of Republican leaning law students, who are maneuvered into clerking for Republican leaning judges, who then move on to become Republican leaning judges. They've been able to keep the courts relatively split and the conservative bench well stocked, even as it's increasingly hard to find a Republican at HYS tier law schools.

Project 2025 will promise to do the same, but for the EPA and OSHA and HUD.

That is a reasonable thing for Democrats to fear. The destruction of one of their major structural advantages would be a cataclysm. The reclassification of a vast number of jobs as political appointees would also absolutely cripple government for decades, because Democrats would be forced to in turn fire and hire a vast number of people every four to eight years. The resulting chaos would make government slower, even when Democrats win. Rather than having career bureaucrats who have a home field advantage in the bureaucracy, you'll have guys who just heard of this regulation for the very first time. Combined with the recent changes to Chevron, bureaucrats will be on a much more even footing with citizens going up against them. Republicans will say this is making government more responsive to voters and rooting out the administrative state's antidemocratic self-preservation instinct; Democrats will say it is disarming the army and then saying well the army can't protect us so we better surrender. Both, to some degree, have a point.

A side note being, while high-level career bureaucrats have long been political appointees flowing in and out of power with admin changes, there has been an ecosystem on both sides of think-tanks and academia and corporate sinecures to absorb those folks when they are out of power. But what will they do with more low-level staff being swung in and out? What will happen to the entire city of DC when a huge portion of its workforce is being hired and fired constantly?

One "I wish he'd gone for Biden and it landed, then we'd have a better candidate!"

We got another candidate!

I thought COVID was a convenient excuse. It's got the advantage of being a medical diagnosis that can vary in severity, and also something you can get over. If he dropped because of Dementia or Alzheimer's, he can never get away from that. And in his remaining 6-10 years, he can't really give speeches at Harvard as a former president if he's known to be cracked mentally. But he can recover from COVID, and be treated as an ex president in good standing. Sure, he'll be visibly slower, but it doesn't really matter because he has no obligations.

It's a very similar vibe to when a rival sports team gets a great young player.

They have a weird amount of negative sway over my mother, who is online enough to see the collected lolcow posts reposted and laundered through Democratic party mouthpieces, but not online enough to run into it in the wild. So she's saying stuff to me like what's with the Nazi frog?

Perfect triangulation points.

So what are examples of names/events that MADE the cut? So we can place Trump in the hierarchy.

What have your personal public conversations about the Trump shooting looked like?

I feel like everyone around me has barely mentioned it outside immediate family and friends. It's like everyone just backed off, left wingers and right wingers are giving fewer zingers. The closest I've gotten to having a real conversation about it was at a gun store, explaining why I wanted something in stock with a reference to "you know, everything going on..." Which he nodded to acknowledge and said something like yeah it's crazy.

Big Sam is the model. You need a guy who can keep a bad team from getting played off the field.

Afraid of what?

I've been trying to find the right sports metaphor for dropping Biden for a while now and I've finally got it:

The new candidate is Big Sam Allardyce, getting brought in to save the democrats from relegation.

There's a big difference between sex to get ahead and sex once you get ahead.

Harris is accused of using sex to get her first job in politics. Trump is accused of using his wealth/Fame/position to get sex.

This is mostly a gendered dynamic, but it's also more elemental than that. Consider: if instead of fucking Willie Brown to get ahead for politics, Kamala had used her position as Senator or VP to sleep with AJ Brown the eagles wide receiver for pleasure. Totally different dynamic, different accusations would be hurled towards her.

Sure but they're not a Trump card that ends a conversation. They're a research bureau. A lot of times if you read the whole article, even the despised deboonkers know what is going on. It's the use of headlines I object to. Mostly true, mostly false. No you need to get into the nuance of it!

It's really just a model nomenclature, a 3er with a 3.0 liter engine and x drive used to be 330xi.

Now a car with x drive isn't in the model name, and the number is just ordinal 20<30<40 in power but not related directly to size.

It's still a 3er with appropriate power and all wheel drive, which is the core concept.

No? I think my nomenclature was off though, it's 330i with xdrive, it used to be xi instead. The 30 stopped meaning a 3.0 a while ago though, it's 2.0 liter turbo mild hybrid.

For those of your following along at home, I never wound up buying myself a car. Originally I wanted to buy a new car for my wife, but she initially didn't really like the things she wanted to replace her Lexus Rx with, and wanted to keep it, so I considered buying myself a car to add something to the family fleet that wasn't approaching old age. But then her parents wanted her car, and we wanted to give it to them, so I bought her a car instead. After looking at things like the Subaru Outback, Crosstrek, Toyota Crown, etc she ultimately fell in love with the BMW 330xi. Which actually gets great marks on ConsumerReports for major reliability, and we were able to get a very low mileage lease return at the local dealer, a couple years old but in perfect condition. It's a tremendously fun car to drive for how practical it is, gets 40mpg on highway trips, and my wife loves it which is the most important thing. It's so easy to get a lot out of it, that it's turning her into more of a car enthusiast, which I love, she's taking backroads home to get to whip it around corners a bit.

And personally, I like the car a lot too, so if inshallah in a few years our kid situation is such that she wants to move to something bigger, I would have no objection whatever to driving it daily, it has a future in the family even if she moves on. Which is why i was looking at buying a car to begin with, to have one in the bank in case EVs get weird for a few years. I wish it was manual and had less complex computerization, but the paddles have come a long way so I'll live with it.

Anatomy of a Deboonking: Why Debunking Stories So Often Fail to Persuade

So I'm looking at the Motortrend website looking for reviews as I'm shopping for a car for my wife. And I see this article purporting to independently test a "rigged" matchup used in Tesla marketing. Tesla posted this video claiming to show a Cybertruck Beast, towing a Porsche 911, defeating a Porsche 911 in a drag race. Right off the headline, where they state it isn't "rigged" this time, the implication is that Tesla (and that rascal Elon) lied to you! But upon actually reading the article, I'm left kinda cold. It seems to me like their effort to debunk the race just proved to me that the race was plausible!

Right off the bat, Motortrend admits:

At just 2.5 seconds to 60 mph in MotorTrend testing, Tesla’s three-motor electric truck beats every Corvette, every McLaren, and all but one Lamborghini that we’ve ever tested in the industry-benchmark acceleration test. That’s without a trailer, of course.

That's crazy numbers. It's insane to build a pickup truck, or even some kind of weird SUV thingamajig since it's only kind-of a truck, that can do Corvette and McLaren numbers on a drag strip! That's a category destroyer! It also tells us that, unloaded, the four passenger plus mucho-cargo Cybertruck will stomp on a two passenger and a duffel bag 911 in most cases. That's a big advantage. But ok, that isn't winning while towing a 911, so let's test it. Motortrend says that...

We approached our drag race with a scientific sense of curiosity. Regardless of which vehicle won, we wanted to understand how it nabbed the victory. We also gave the Cybertruck every possible advantage—within reason—since we assume Tesla also did the same.

At core, this meant that they picked a lightweight trailer, a lightweight 911 model to tow and removed all reasonable weight from the 911 being towed, the slowest 911 model to race against. Resulting in...

All in, our race pitted 11,268 pounds worth of stainless steel, aluminum, lithium, and bristling muscle propelled by 845 horsepower against 3,488 pounds of aluminum, carbon-spewing flat-six, and dad bod powered by 379 horsepower. The only thing left to do was race.

And the results come in and are instantly treated as conclusive!

Here’s What Tesla Didn’t Show You We ran six quarter-mile drag races, and each one had the same outcome: The Porsche 911 Carrera T wins and the Tesla Cybertruck Beast loses. In the world of drag racing, it’s not a particularly close race, either.

Notice the implication that Tesla lied, "Here's what they didn't show you." The implication of deception is used throughout, that this video amounted to a deceitful lie, that Tesla was taking advantage of you, the gullible potential customer. And the conclusiveness: it wasn't particularly close, by drag racing conventions.

We then go into a series of potential alterations to the format. Does it matter if we put the Tesla's best run against the 911s worst? No. Actually, Tesla only ran an 1/8th mile rather than a quarter mile, does that change the result? No, it doesn't. There is just no honest way to get the Cybertruck in front for more than about ten feet. And at the end of the article, Motortrend, that pinnacle of journalistic excellence, comes down hard editorializing against Tesla:

No matter how you slice it, present it, or asterisk the claim, Tesla and Elon Musk’s big brag doesn’t hold up. There’s no scenario where the Tesla Cybertruck Beast pulls a fully functional Porsche 911 Carrera T across the quarter mile before the Porsche 911 Carrera T gets to the finish line. Even if Tesla had originally disclosed it only staged an eighth-mile race, the video seen by customers, fans, and curious observers is highly misleading. ...it was reckless for a corporation worth billions of dollars to make an unsubstantiated claim to millions of people...Here’s the truth: A Tesla Cybertruck cannot tow a Porsche 911 Carrera T over a quarter mile quicker than the 911 Carrera T alone can run the race. Add it to the long list of broken Tesla promises. [Emphasis Added]

The moralizing tone and catastrophizing language is kinda overwrought here, n'est pas? Tesla may have theoretically deceived "millions" of viewers, but they only shipped 12,000 Cybertrucks in 2024 as of July, while Porsche only sells around 1,000 911s a month. The people whose buying choices may be actually impacted by the comparison are negligible. And, at any rate, someone who can afford a $125k 911 or a $100k Cybertruck is (hopefully) likely to be a sophisticated consumer who will do more research than just watching a Youtube video about an irrelevant occurrence and making their decision based on that advertising video. No one is being seriously impacted by that rascal Musk's awful DECEIT and FAKE NEWS. So why treat it that way?

And in any case, I came away from the article, despite Motortrend's laudable efforts at technical rigor, thinking that Tesla's claim was more true than it was false anyway! It was maybe not literally true under laboratory conditions, but those very conditions explain why it would likely be true in day to day life for the average fuckboi who blows six figures on a Cybertruck. Right at the beginning of the article they admit:

From the moment the words came out of Musk’s mouth, we were skeptical of Tesla’s towing/drag race video. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and while Tesla did show the full, unedited race from four angles, that wouldn’t stop the Porsche 911 driver—presumably a Tesla employee—from ensuring the Cybertruck won. If the race was as close as Tesla’s video suggested, a soft launch, a slow shift, or a slight lift of the accelerator in the Porsche could be the difference between a Tesla loss and a victory.

Motortrend, of course, uses their own drivers. Who are presumably pretty fuckin' good at driving, pretty well educated in drag strip technique, and doing their damndest. Later in the article they note, when reviewing technical reasons for the result:

The manual-transmission Carrera T has a 3,500-rpm limiter at standstill, and on a sticky, prepped drag strip, launching quickly requires getting off the line without letting the revs fall. Drop the clutch too fast, and the engine will bog, falling out of its powerband. It takes a slow, carefully modulated clutch release to get the perfect launch, which keeps the engine on boil and extracts a small amount of slip from the tires.

The vast majority of Mottizens, who by and large are smart and technically educated people who (should, by rights) eventually be in the market for something like this, might understand all those words, but haven't engaged in the practical activity of doing that activity. I've driven some bitchin' cars, but I've never clutch dropped a race-prepped 911! While in my imagination I'd like to think the average 911 driver has a greater degree of technical knowhow, I'm not even sure they'd pass the pop quiz of telling me exactly what all those words meant, and certainly wouldn't be able to execute it perfectly under pressure in a repeatable way. Even with a seasoned pro behind the wheel:

Over the next few runs, as the Porsche driver honed his launch, the 911 trimmed 0.3 second off the time. The Cybertruck only posted one quicker run, which amounted to a trivial 0.02-second improvement.

His first try wasn't ideal, his technique improved over time. While for the Tesla driver, it's plug and play:

The Cybertruck launch, in contrast, is as simple as it gets. Put it in Beast mode, step on both pedals, wait a few seconds for the truck to squat on its air springs, then release the brake. With no turbo to reach full boost, no intake manifold to pressurize, no clutch to modulate, and a big, fat torque curve available from the jump, the Beast yanks hard even with 4,228 pounds hitched to its bumper.

So you put two randos off the street, or even two average purchasers, behind the wheel and there's a good chance the Cybertruck is able to get back that .2 seconds! All Tesla would have to do to "fake" the result is alter the skill level of the driver in the Porsche. No movie magic, no editing, not even having the guy pull his punches, just use a guy who isn't a seasoned drag strip driver experienced in getting the most out of a Porsche. Which is the average situation on the street!

What this tells me is that in the absurd, American Graffiti ass hypo that I was driving my Cybertruck towing my 911 to a racetrack, and a real-life 911 with a real-life guy who bought a Porsche behind the wheel pulled up next to me at a stoplight and we locked eyes and decided to race, there's a pretty good chance the Cybertruck would win unless the guy happened to be a top 1% talent. Most 911 owners are merely rich, and not talented drag racers. That's good odds! So it seems odd to me to say Tesla lied, more likely they just tested under conditions closer to reality. .2 seconds is a world on a dragstrip, but it's nothing in real life among real drivers.

But of course, why ask any of those questions when you have an opportunity to take a shot at public pinata Elon Musk?

The debunking industry so often follows this same track. Ideologically motivated, the definition of "true" and "false" are slippery, and determined more by political advantage than by reasonable interpretation. And here, as so often, if you dig into what the Deboonkers say they did, you come away from a "false" claim with more respect for the false claim than the one anointed true! I came away from this saying, the Cybertruck really is as fast or faster than a 911, even with a lot of cargo. And honestly, as I see more of them in real life, the Cybertruck is awesome. Idk that it's a practical choice, or that all the features are fully realized, or that I'd ever consider actually buying one. But fuck if they aren't distinctive, special, and as it turns out, nearly as fast as a 911 even when they're towing a 911. That's a much truthier point, in the Colbertian sense, than it is to say ELON LIED TO YOU.

I leave it as an exercise to the reader to consider whether this is politics infecting car magazines, and how this dynamic impacts much thornier debunks that are so common in the liberal press.

What are the great Duels in Russian Literature?

I'm working my way through The Brothers Karamazov for the second time, and I got to the life of the Elder Zosima, and his pivotal duel. And it got me thinking of reread of War and Peace earlier and how the duel there was a clear parallel to Evgeny Onegin, subverting the outcomes.

So you have Onegin sort of accidentally tragically killing his best friend. (Pushkin of course died in a duel). You have Pierre grievously wounding Dolohov for a perfectly valid reason, then instantly regretting it. You have Zosima letting his opponent shoot then, then throwing away his own gun and begging forgiveness. All playing with each other's themes.

Then by Anna Karenina Vronsky and Karenin never duel although Karenin considers it, to what extent was that a matter of technology? Firearms were better by that setting, death more likely and more related to skill. And in Notes from Underground the Underground Man fantasizes about Duels that never occur because he's not cool enough to be noticed, a kind of school shooter psychology. The stakes of these literary teases are created by the predecessors.

Then of course somewhere in there is Lermontov originating Russian Roulette in A Hero of our Times, betting on whether a pistol will go off.

So literati and Russophiles of the motte, which other examples are there?

Different world. Trump wasn't supposed to win and the Republicans were supposed to lose Congress in 2016. There were reconciliation noises at first, but Trump quickly proved pretty bad at the job (largely due to lack of bureaucratically inclined assistants and resulting chaos).

This time it's looking like he's got a better set of plans, is likely to win, and at least control the Senate.

It's amazing watching the real time decline of an heuristic catchphrase.

To be clear I don't think any of those three belong. I say this as someone who had a Derek Jeter poster on my wall as a kid and read and reread his autobiography. Jeter has a reputation entirely built on the 1997-2000 run, take that away as this list purports to do and he's merely a very good shortstop. Jeter absolutely belongs on a list for the last thirty years, but not the last 25.

Ortiz was a career DH and simply didn't do enough to make it, he's all personality and no stats. Beltre arguably has the stats, but lacks the impact or personality.

In my mind greatest athlete is about impact on the game, statistical achievements, accomplishments (ie championships etc), and impact on culture. Not necessarily in that order, but you need at least a dose of all three to make it into the list.

The baseball picks were largely weird. Adrian Beltre and Derek Jeter and David Ortiz?

My American problem with European football leagues is that the national level season is so boring to me. What's the point of a league where only four teams have won a championship this century?

La Liga trophies literally count, to me, in a comparative ranking like this somewhere between Brady's AFC east division wins and Lebron's Eastern conference wins. It's just not really a competitive league outside of Barca and Real.

Serena is gonna get a ton of shit on here because she's the best example on the list, Lewis Hamilton being the other, of everyone chasing the Jackie Robinson high. But there was only one 42. You can't just pretend it happened that way.