FiveHourMarathon
a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop
And every gimmick hungry yob
Digging gold from rock n roll
Grabs the mic to tell us
he'll die before he's sold
But I believe in this
And it's been tested by research
He who fucks nuns
Will later join the church
User ID: 195
It doesn't really matter as long as the raw number of people who will throw a tantrum and refuse to vote for the D candidate is large enough that you'll lose.
If a sufficient percentage of people, see this insane person (aside to @2rafa, this is the straw-donor plaintiff for a future lawsuit against the Biden campaign for passing funds to a new candidate illegally), will only vote for Biden and not for a new candidate for reasons that might be absurd; then it doesn't matter if the group of people who won't vote for a senile candidate is larger or smaller. The Democrats can't afford to lose any part of the party, or they lose the election. They're going to try very hard to thread the needle and get everyone on board before they give up and make the Sophie's Choice of whether to lose by a lot or a little.
I do think that's an interesting angle on why Affirmative Action is such a crime against society, it takes the talented tenth and pulls them out of general life for most people. Harvard is, as it were, hoarding all the smart Black Friends.
I didn't get into this in the prior post for that reason, no one will get anything out of the discussion.
The Biden nomination relies merely on Democratic indecision and cowardice which... Seems like a generally good bet. For the most part good strategy is to turtle, run out the round, and be saved by the bell. For the most part I agree that it might be too late to win the presidency, and every week that passes it's later.
In particular Biden just needs Democrats to collectively hesitate out of a sense of MAD, which can be achieved by empasizing that some voters would only vote for Joe. There apparently exist people like that. I can't comprehend it. But showing enough of them makes Biden unremovable. If removing him costs 5% of the vote, it's pointless to try.
It's the classic John Sedgwick joke.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Sedgwick?wprov=sfti1
His command to his soldiers to stand up may have been perfectly reasonable, it nonetheless is remembered as a very funny joke.
I suspect hiding him away is doing more bad than good - egoist politicians like Biden draw strength from rallies, not from being sequestered with aides and drilled.
I see this argument all over the place, and it seems to be classic WFAN caller "the coach is stupid, why doesn't he just play the good players?" I generally despise everyone I know who moved to DC and went into politics, but don't doubt that the consultants that surround him know that he should be doing rallies, that rallies would be good for him, less than a coach knows that he has to score more points than the other team. He's not doing rallies because he can't do rallies. This is a case of running a projection model that doesn't take injuries into account.
On paper, as you say, there is not much room for improvement, but that's not how people feel and that could change.
It's not just that there's no room for improvement on paper, it's that any improvement on paper probably leads to increased inflation. We're running near frictional unemployment, and the stock market is hitting record highs. Any increase in employment or wages is going to push prices higher, which upsets people. The only way prices are going to decrease is a recession, which will upset people. Biden's best hope is that everything stays the same for another few months. But running your game hoping that suddenly Americans will realize what's been going on around them for years is insanity, and hoping that Biden suddenly improves his salesmanship while in the state he's in is insanity.
But Biden's biggest problem is that the narrative is running against him that he's senile. Every slip up or routine action will be taken as a sign of senility. I was joking with my wife that, under a microscope and facing an assumption of senility, you'd find ample evidence in my life. Just yesterday, we had the septic tank pumped at one of our rental properties, which must be done every three years by township ordinance. I last worried about this three years ago, and I vaguely thought the tank lid might be out back somewhere. The guy pumping it remembered precisely where it was, on the side of the house, off the top of his head, because he did a repair on it seven years ago. Oh my God my memory is terrible!
Wally, did we eat the onion here?
Legal tolerance breaks. I like it.
First things first: this is an unspeakable tragedy, I feel terrible for this person's friends and family, and anyone cracking jokes about "their pronouns were was/were" is disgusting and should be ashamed of themselves.
No, it's not an unspeakable tragedy. It's a murder. Gruesome surely, tragic for those close to her. But people have been making light of murder for, well, probably forever. Do kids still sing about Lizzie Borden giving her father 40 whacks? We did. If stabbings are unspeakable tragedies what do we make of Louis Armstrong doing Mack the Knife? Because that's an American songbook classic.
Making light of the macabre is a normal human response. It's not disgusting or evil. R/HermanCainAward? Good content. Was/were? That joke would honestly kill if it were told at a drag show. The gulag and the purges were unspeakable tragedies, yet the scene in Death of Stalin where periodic gunshots are heard in the NKVD hallway was hilarious.
A holocaust survivor dies of old age and goes to heaven. When he gets there he meets God and tells him a holocaust joke.
God says, “That’s not funny.”
And the man says, “I guess you had to be there. “
As for the PR possibilities of the murder, it'll probably just be sorted into a pile of "trans murders" and used in statistics. The reality based community will continue to note that trans women have a murder rate higher than natal women but well below that of the general male population; they will not succeed in persuading anyone.
I don't think any of those paths are plausible. The economy doesn't have much room to improve without overheating. The things that cause negative economic perceptions are mostly structural issues that will take decades to fix. Trump's trials are too manifold and confusing to really go that badly, if there were just one it might work, but every Negress prosecutor on the east coast filed a weak case and the scandals cross each other up. And there's no reason to believe Biden will get younger in time for the second debate.
Don't we see that? Throughout history rich people tend to be taller, stronger and more attractive than comparably selected poor people.
I have to be honest, I don't know what sister Souljah means.
I don’t think Clavell saw it that way himself. He was a fan of Ayn Rand.
It's hard for me to interpret the brilliant scene at the end, where the parachutist liberating the camp looks at the arch-capitalist trader King, and asks why he is well dressed well fed and clean when everyone else is in rags and starved. It's the classic dorm-room smoke session idea of how if an angel or an alien came down, they wouldn't get why some people are rich and some people are poor, man, and how would you explain why one person is rich and another person is starving to them? It's heavy handed!
I don't think he comes down against Capitalism, necessarily. Marlowe, the Clavell self-insert in the best Hemingway tradition, struggles to explain why the King wasn't bad, struggles to explain his glory, after the liberation. And glorious he was! He managed to save Marlowe's arm, and maybe his life! And he could only do that because of his power, which he only had because of his hustle. And to a certain extent, Clavell also simply thinks it right and proper for a man to live by his wits at the expense of others, to risk it all and to dominate or to fail.
It's a very deep and complex critique of capitalism. In many ways, every Clavell novel kind of follows the same plot, with a young Englishman joining a foreign culture and learning its ways. Shogun does this with Japan, Whirlwind with Iran, Tai-Pan with the Hong Kong training colony. King Rat does this, but the culture that Marlowe is indoctrinated into was King Rat's American Capitalism. The King hustles around, yelling things like "Time is money!" and "There's Always an Angle!" and he has a buddy named Tex. He couldn't be more of an American stereotype if he had an Eagle and a Flag tattooed on his arm.
OT, not having read Les Mis: is Javert nearly as well written as Grey?
So it's a tough comparison because they are in very different genres, in addition to simply being very different lengths. Characters are drawn differently in punchy 300 page adventure novels that take place over maybe six months, versus 1600 page monstrosities that cover generations with massive asides about the battle of Waterloo and the French Sewers. But in my mind, I liked Javert better as a character, Grey was just a bit too much of a butt monkey for me. Javert is defined by his dedication to rules; Grey is driven primarily by his deep envy and jealousy of the King and of Marlowe.
I bask in your praise.
I really do recommend the book. I read it with a friend from Singapore, and we both expected it to be in large part about the cruelty of the Japanese and the struggle for survival against them. Instead the cruel Japanese are largely a far-group fact about the universe, the primary struggle is within and among the PoWs. The book started and presents as an adventure yarn, but becomes a withering critique of capitalism.
Counterargument: we are much less risk-averse on average than historical peoples, and as a result the people who throw it all up and risk everything are less extraordinary. Back in the day, when the average risk aversion may have been a 2/10, someone who played at a 5/10 or a 7/10 was extraordinary, and there was money on the table to be gained. Now, most people might be at a 5/10, and as a result playing at a 7/10 isn't that noticeable, and even a 9/10 doesn't pick up that much reward.
Historically, the vast majority of people lived in one place and died there, took the jobs in their town, more or less the same ones their parents held, attended the church their parents attended, married a local girl for life and had kids like their parents did. People died within miles of where they were born. Think of Sam Gamgee, early in Fellowship, stopping on their journey upon the realization that one more step would be the furthest from home he'd ever been, two days into their walkabout! Taking risks was completely foreign to historical commoners.
Today it is very common for ordinary people to move cross country, thousands of miles, to places where they know no one. Few people go into their father's profession, few take over the family land or the family business. I'm an extreme outlier in my PMC peer group for living on the street I grew up in without a drug addiction or a failed marriage holding me back. People are constantly changing careers or homes or marriages. Taking up a new career, moving far from family support networks, borrowing multiples of your net worth to start a business or go to college, leaving your current partner to look for a new one, these are all huge risks that no responsible peasant would countenance, which are routine parts of a middle class American life story.
As a result, taking really big risks doesn't deliver as much value. The great explorers and traders and settlers and entrepreneurs of the past became heroes and gods. and kings, because there was money just laying about waiting for someone to pick it up. If you were willing to throw your life up and move, you were instantly extraordinary, one in a million. Today, you're one of a million, just another guy.
I went to see a local production of The Merry Wives of Windsor last week, twice. After the first time, I immediately knew I wanted to go back and watch it again, so my wife and I got tickets for another show and took my mother two days later! It was truly fantastic, a wonderful production, with actors who absolutely exuded charisma and interpretations of the setting that were beautiful and brilliant, life and joy affirming comedy. They did a mid-century modern setting: Falstaff was a down-on-his-luck fat-Elvis, his band were a bunch of greasers, Fenton was a jock, Slender a preppy doofus, Slender's uncle a southern sheriff. And it got me thinking:
Has every Shakespeare play more or less remained in production within a generation, such that we are watching an unbroken chain of transmission from producer-to-producer, or have some of them gone moribund and been revived from scratch?
Obviously, the producers and directors of this play had seen it before, if not in person in some filmed version. The stage directions, the character interpretations, the delivery of the lines, are partly derivative, surely, of other productions. When the Welsh preacher talks about pretty Anne Parson's "great gifts" and gestures to indicate breasts, or he and the uncle ask Slender whether he can please the girl and make lascivious motions to indicate sex, that is a particular interpretation of the language, not natural necessarily to the text, and I found myself wondering if that kind of thing is mostly passed down, or invented whole cloth at some later. Particularly for the canonical English writer in Shakespeare.
Are we watching a interpretation of the play that is based on productions earlier this century which have been recorded, which themselves were influenced by earlier productions, in a direct line more or less to the Globe? Or to when? Surely, even before recordings, most times some individual at the theatrical company would have seen an earlier production of Wives and been able to offer that experience as a basis for interpretation, and in that earlier production someone would have seen an even earlier production, how far back do we think that went? To Victorian times? To Shakespeare himself?
It strikes me as a Bad Move on his part, though I will confess that Donald is a significantly better political mind than me, possessed as Asimov put it of a tremendous instinctual understanding of psychohistory.
Attempting to distance himself from it will reduce or blunt Democratic attacks on him precisely zero, any more than Conservatives are less apt to attack Biden about the 2020 riots because of his public denouncements of defunding the police. He won't succeed in persuading anyone who has heard of Project 2025 and can process what it is that he isn't tied to it, he's more likely to succeed in convincing people who like the Heritage Foundation that he isn't a reliable executive for that purpose.
Trump has been an incredible maverick about that kind of thing up to this point. He's notable/notorious for his refusal to full-throatedly denounce some really out-of-the-mainstream support he gets. This is a guy who had Kanye West and Nick Fuentes over for dinner, he's not afraid to charm people who are way outside the norm, he doesn't tack to the middle the way most politicians have, to the chagrin of media blobs and to great electoral success. Appealing to the extremes has gone well for him!
It strikes me as odd, because I've had the conversation with my wife, far more liberal than I am, and we both found the liberal obsession with Project 2025 groan-inducing. It's a very inside-baseball, extremely-online liberal attack, similar to the ever-idiotic analysis of party-platform positions. We're seeing the Trump campaign neuter the party platform too.
Maybe he's smarter than me, but I always think of this kind of stuff as more editorial page nonsense than having a real impact.
For example, "Birthing Parent's Day" is mostly a GC meme. Trans activists are, to the best of my knowledge, not particularly interested in renaming Mother's and Father's day, because they still see "Mother" and "Father" as totally valid terms as long as they're used in a manner consistent with self-ID and not with biological sex.
This strikes me as kinda sanewashing or bad-faith. It's tough not to tie the effort to technically rename mothers as "Birthing Parents" to broader, largely left-coded, efforts to expand Mother's day to include non-mothers, or to avoid offending non-mothers. The NYT and such regularly run mother's day op-ed articles about how X was like a mother to me, or that mother's day was depressing to me because I didn't have a mother, or how just because I'm not a mother people should still honor my professional accomplishments and not reduce women to wombs, and really we should include aunts and mentors and whatever else. There's a definite effort to downgrade motherhood afoot, even if not every individual in every case agrees with every aspect of it.
I read the first, autobiographical/Hemingway worship novel by James Clavell (Of Shogun fame), a fictionalized version of his experience in a Japanese PoW camp in Singapore during WWII, King Rat earlier this year. I highly recommend the book, but one character is pretty much this: Sean.
Sean is an RAF pilot who turns into a woman during the time in Changi. He's presented as the "Queen" of the camp, a parallel to the titular King of Camp. He is the only soldier given a private room, and private time to bathe. He's showered in attention and gifts, and in the regular theatrical performances he is the star attraction. It's implied he acts a bottom sexually, but it is never really the point: he traipses about in fine women's clothing, shaves his legs every day, showered in gifts and love and affection and service and praise for his beauty from other soldiers. He has immense privileges over every other inmate, far above his natural position in the hierarchy of the camp, second only to the King who runs the economy as a capitalist and above the commanding officers who have official power, simply as the star attraction in the theatrical productions. Far above the privileges given to the directors and producers of the shows! Clavell's self insert Marlowe knew Sean before the camp, and nearly killed him upon learning of his change in identity, but regrets it and considers it his own sin to fail to accept Sean, though he denies his own attraction to fSean. It is implied that Sean first takes on the female role because he was drafted to play a female role in a play, and that the attention lavished on him caused the change. That he couldn't turn down all the praise, and leaned more and more into the character until the mask became the face.
Don't you put that evil on me, nybs. If we have to hear about a THIRD disgusting love affair in the process of these cases...
Several responses:
One of my favorite interview quotes of all time, and one I live by, from boxer Tex Cobb:
After I dropped out of college, I started traveling around the country. I was 19 years old and I decided to find me something that worked, like being cool. Being cool worked, it got you out of trouble and you got a lot of good things happening for you but I never had more than maybe a C- in cool. Being smart worked for you. It got you out of a lot of trouble and got you a lot of good things and although I was actually pretty quick, I didn’t count it for much ‘cause it came real easy to me. I could memorize large sections of data and regurgitate it back to you but it didn’t bring me any happiness. But believe me, being smart isn’t nearly as good as being wise. Then there was having money, it got you out of a lot of trouble and got you a lot of good things and I never had two nickels.. . but there was being bad . . . and being bad applied across the board. Because you could take a rich, cool, smart guy and you could have him doing anything you could possibly conceive of because you were bad. So I thought, hey I found me the secret of the temple, I’ll go out and get me a Pass Master in bad, and I did. And there ain’t nobody bad believe me, I looked. I fought for world titles in boxing, karate, I fought bar wars, street corners, most everything living and half the stuff dead and darling it don’t matter there ain’t nobody bad, I know, I looked . . . just God.”
I could rephrase that last line personally. I thought intelligence was everything. And I've argued with college professors and with wall street CEOs, I've debated with Senators, Congressman, drunk philosophers and internet impersonators, gamblers on commodities and on blackjack, rationalists and bishops, ivy league lawyers and both elected and appointed judges, most everything living and half the stuff dead, and ain't nobody smart, I know, I looked...just God.
Don't get overly into the idea that there is such a thing as generalizable intelligence. I know many brilliant people who are into religious or philosophical concepts so stupid I can't imagine sitting through them, let alone making them part of my week. I consider transition a primarily religious belief, having to do with a metaphysical gender-soul which exists separate from any physical evidence thereof, and a philosophical requirement that one live in conformance with it. If I tried to believe in every religious belief that someone brilliant I know believed in, I'd have a set of contradictory and useless beliefs, some of them so stupid I can't even reckon with them.
That said, I broadly agree with your vibe. When I interact with trans people, I don't generally find them either dangerous or disturbing, and I do my best to respect their choices personally, but that doesn't mean I philosophically agree with them, nor does it require that I buy into the metaphysical framework they live under, and least of all does it require of me any political position. I simply find them to be fine enough people and don't make a big show of hurting them. I suspect most people who hold "transphobic" positions online are probably similar. I recall a tweet that went something like: if instead of asking yes/no polling questions, one interviewed Americans about their opinions on trans people, the actual answers would converge towards something both intensely bigoted and basically accepting in ways that neither political party would find acceptable. Most people go along to get along, and I believe that if you respect Mark broadly then you reasonably ought to give his religious beliefs respect in conversation.
There was a bait post on here some weeks ago asking what evidence it would take to change your opinion on HBD, iirc in some annoying fake math that I didn't feel like messing with. But my first thought about it was, well you'd have to somehow prove to me that my black friends, professors, coworkers, etc were hallucinations, that they weren't really there or weren't really what they seemed. Until then, I'm not going to buy into a strong framework that predicts that those people would be so much rarer than they seemed to me to be. Whatever is going on in the graphs, it can't change my actual experience, and that's going to predominate in how I see the world.
Reality is under no constraint to be philosophically consistent for us.
It's too confusing anymore. People I talk to literally think the SCOTUS overturned his conviction because the prosecutor was fucking the judge.
Weirdly his obsession with Nato spending is my single favorite policy position of his.
...Huh? What Establishment Republicans are you talking about who are very good at getting candidates who don't help them win elections off the ticket? The same ones who kicked Trump out, along with Oz, Mastriaono, Masters, and every other nincompoop that threw away a winnable seat in 2022?
I was kinda shocked when Trump felt the need to distance himself from it publicly. Really bizarre behavior. From what I saw, he distanced himself from Project 2025 harder than he distanced himself from a lot of much worse things.

Republicans can do anything and survive politically. We've seen it fifteen times in the last ten years.
More options
Context Copy link