FiveHourMarathon
a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop
And every gimmick hungry yob
Digging gold from rock n roll
Grabs the mic to tell us
he'll die before he's sold
But I believe in this
And it's been tested by research
He who fucks nuns
Will later join the church
User ID: 195
Simple line to draw: non competes can't be enforced unless the employees total average compensation over two of the preceding 3 years (or the entirety of the employment period if less) is greater than 10x the federal poverty line for a household of two. That puts it for 2024 at 200k. Beyond that simply enforcing existing common law restrictions on geographic and temporal scope will be sufficient.
I don't really have a problem with non competes for executives, managers, major salesmen, top engineers. Make them spend six months or a year on vacation, no big deal.
But I once took what amounted to a retail job and they wanted me to sign an unlimited non compete. For a job where I made $50k! That's awful. No working man should face that kind of restriction on earning a livelihood.
What would be the rules around use of personal information? People here frequently cite personal experiences, would the mods be piercing the veil and assigning discipline to accounts that lie?
It's worse. I have to estimate it long before anything goes wrong.
And my modal case is something like coming into contact with a person of interest. Or it's personal, your former coworker with an axe to grind or your ex boyfriend or your new girlfriend's ex boyfriend with a grudge, happens to have access to that kind of thing in some way or another.
That probability is impossible to estimate in advance. When I went skeet shooting in 2017, I could not have known that multiple people I shot with would be indicted in federal court on "insurrection" charges. I've seen friends stalk romantic partners, perspective and current and former, all across the internet including misusing work tools to do so. I have no method of assessing the people I interact with for whether they materially increase that risk.
privacy concerns are often the result of human intuition about our evolved environment rather than about our modern one. Thinking of data collectors as just algorithmic and disinterested in you personally doesn't come intuitively to most people.
We're looking at more of an intuitive statistical gap in understanding small percentage chances. There is clearly a greater chance that if my private information is stored at police headquarters that some sequence of events will lead to someone at police headquarters using that information against me in some way, than if that information is not stored at police headquarters. Most people aren't capable of actually calculating the expected value of that probability, so they either round it up too high or too low.
I anticipate significant unintended consequences from such a decision.
I've followed the story very shallowly, I read Carroll's original short story (it's very engaging) and I browsed articles in the WSJ and NYT in between since.
Maybe what trump said is worse than I think? But my impression is that while he has put his finger into the fan blade over and over, it hasn't crossed the line as I would draw it. Unfortunately I don't get to draw those lines.
This is perceptive. I plead guilty: I criticize the consent-only sexual ethic without really having a credible substitute to replace it.
Do you think that's still improper, that if the matter of fact which the defamation centers on is outside SoL, the court shouldn't be allowed to say whether or not recent statements were defamatory?
I addressed this in my initial comment, but I'll work it out a bit further here.
-
Statements of personal innocence, and defending your friends' innocence, should never be punishable in and of themselves. "I did not rape her" should not be construed as defamation.
-
Statements that impugn someone's character unnecessarily can probably still be defamatory, but because truth is an absolute defense to libel and the truth of the matter is somewhat impossible to prove, it should probably be limited to cases where the defamation is extreme.
-
Given that civil courts have a lower evidentiary burden to begin with, I don't think this naturally follows.
I disagree, and find the civil vs criminal distinction cold comfort. The civil courts ultimately have power of discovery to upend your life, the verdicts will be enforced by the courts and ultimately by men with guns, they create "facts" that can't be contradicted later.
For the present case, on balance I don't think Trump should face any liability for defamation in this case. It does meet the legal standards involved and procedures were followed, and he could easily escape liability by simply...cutting it out with the nonsense. But it is inappropriate to punish someone for protesting their innocence.
Thanks! Very helpful.
This article just gets funnier every year, and yet it has been over a decade since it was written.
The Bush-Obama era designation of entire nations as free-fire zones where international law does not apply is turning out to be a disaster for the world at large.
The left thinks systemically and the right thinks individually or on a personal level.
Not really. Everyone thinks systemically about other people and individually about themselves/their immediate friends. The right thinks systemically when it comes to HBD, the left thinks individually. The left thinks systemically about privilege, the right thinks individually about privilege. If you define "the right" as people who think individually, you are drawing a line that excludes a lot of people who both self-define as "right wing" and would be identified as such by a vast majority of people.
Calling it jealousy creates a straw man argument in my opinion, because much of the left-wing side that you likely don't hear about rests on very different arguments.
I apologize if my argument seemed to be talking about "the left" in a complete sense, I was focused on the people who make privilege arguments. Who are a tiny section of people. Who I do think exist largely in a state of jealousy.
Do you have a link to that anywhere? I wasn't aware he had tried, I can't find that noted in the articles I'm looking at (though obviously it is possible it was left out intentionally).
Okay, that's tangential to the question I am asking, and I should have left it out.
I'm curious what's tangential.
The Motte, as reasonably intelligent and sane persons, think that either/both/neither account is credible and second, you'd convict on that alone?
I repeat: Neither claim is provably true in a way that should lead to legal consequences for the accused. But neither is it provably untrue in a way that should lead to legal consequences for the women involved.
The entire concept of a "conviction" (or any kind of verdict, as we're talking about civil not criminal trials here) on the basis of one person's testimony to behavior that happened decades ago is obscene. It is contrary to the idea of civil liberties and limited government. Full stop. If in the jury box I'd be a vote against, regardless of the law involved.
Trying to adjudicate who had sex with whom and how into it they were decades ago is a morass. Trying to do so is obscene, and should not be a part of our politics. Full stop. That was my position on Brett Kavanaugh, on Tara Reade, on Trump's various women, it'll be my position on the next one too.
(for what it's worth, the more I hear about the Carroll case the more I'm shifting towards "she's lying" but that's not helping me decide if the bare account of the accusation, with no witnesses to back it up, sounds credible to others).
It's extremely likely that she is lying, or simply wrong, about multiple details of any quick moving event that happened decades ago. Trump, in turn, denied ever knowing her and said she was so ugly he'd never fuck her anyway; when confronted under oath with photos of their meeting, Trump misidentified Carroll as his then-mistress/later-second-wife Maples. Humans aren't actually so good at this stuff.
Trump could absolutely have chosen to sue her for defamation for her claim. There is no legal double standard in that, beyond claims of "the rules don't matter."
Trump can also call her a liar without committing defamation, he has repeatedly chosen not to. The framework for the non-apology apology is so well known at this point that it's practically available as a template on EForms next to promissory notes and ground leases.
That he's failed to do so is a matter of temperament.
Finally listened to MacBeth and the associated lecture from the "Late Works of Shakespeare" course I was working my way through. It was the last one, but I couldn't do the Scottish accents in the audio collection on youtube i was working off of. I've imbibed Macbeth in written form in high school, and three separate live performances (including a table read done entirely in the voices of Simpsons characters. I picked up on so many new things this time around. There's a reason the classics are the classics.
I'm still working my way through The Good Soldier Svejk. I'm finding it very relaxing.
You could try watching 3 Kingdoms from 2010 or other adaptations? Putting a unique face, costume and demeanor to a character helped me a lot.
A Chinese friend of mine recommended the graphic novels she read in Singapore in the 90s as the best english adaptation.
Both allege it happened in a secluded area. Why does Carroll get an $83 million payout for Trump saying she's a liar while Reade - doesn't?
I have to stop you there, Trump's alleged defamation was not a flat "I did not have sexual relations with that woman" or "It was consensual." The initial verdict was much, much lower; Trump manages to keep escalating it by continuing to deny the court's verdict in his inimitable manner. Trump will always strike me as an unlikely candidate to be railroaded simply because he could, so easily, avoid the railroading by simply choosing not to do the things he does. "I was acquainted with Ms. Carroll and thought we had a friendly relationship. It is unfortunate that she does not remember it the same way. I will continue to appeal the verdict." There goes your $83,000,000. Trump is trapped in a whirligig of his own creation.
That said, I weakly believe that both claims are more-likely-than-not true in a Rashomon sense of true: they reflect the internal experience of the women who made the claims. I strongly believe that neither claim ought to be justiciable, both because they are old and ought to be out of the SoL, and because as my evidence prof put it "Either Rape law is wrong or evidence law is wrong, but they can't both be correct." The standard of evidence demanded in rape law is so far below the standard demanded in virtually every other felony that the result is absurd, and we've already seen it used tyrannically against regime opponents.
Neither claim is provably true in a way that should lead to legal consequences for the accused. But neither is it provably untrue in a way that should lead to legal consequences for the women involved.
That said, I think you're going to end up just picking a fight here with the theory that:
Try, as far as you can, to put the background and any opinions you have on X versus Y out of your mind. Just go by the statements of what was accused and alleged and no interpretation "well of course A is the type to do this so B is telling the truth but C is not the type so D is lying".
Because now people are going to conceal that phase of their thinking. Or not. More likely, it seems that virtually everyone in a position of power (except Al Gore and his wife) are liable to become aggressive sexual deviants.
Declined, happy: Dodged a bullet
The medieval church neither spoke Latin(Latin was a liturgical/scholastic language and not spoken) nor was more parasitic than the nobles were.
Latin was certainly capable of being used in communication between educated Europeans. Which was parasitic, in the sense that it was unnatural. There was no native population of latin speakers who grew up speaking latin because it is what they heard at home, everyone who learned latin had to be taught latin as a second language.
I tried Dopa Mucuna a couple times. It seemed to up energy and motivation a little bit, but gave me a headache, so it sits in my medicine cabinet waiting for me to try it again for idk reasons.
Correct on the class games. What you're looking at is the remnant of linguistic layers in England: a Celtic native population conquered by Anglo Saxon Germanics who mostly achieved linguistic unity before being bulldozed by a French speaking upper class (whose descendants still disproportionately horde wealth and power today), with a parasite population of Latin speakers with significant influence.
One of the flaws of our culture, oft noted, is the lack of self confidence of the elites. One of the ways this manifests is that no one claims elite status, everyone is jealous and oppressed. No one is the Blonde Beast, everyone is the nebbish loser who doesn't fit in.
Not just the 1% but the 1, Elon Musk is jealous, perceives others as getting things he deserves, as having unfairly easy lives. Throughout the tippy top upper classes: Trump, Ackman, Adelson. Nowhere do we find the easy self assurance of the aristocrat. We find grievance.
Our culture is in disarray because the trads are rebellious and the rebellious are defending tradition.
I agree with this, largely. The most important thing is activities with an unknown outcome. This is why some of the classic fun activities are things like going out to party to try to meet women, or to get into a fight, or gambling.
Getting drunk or high on a night out is fun to a point because the more fucked up you get the less predictable the outcome of the evening. Drinking and getting high by yourself, of course, has the opposite effect.
I'm reminding you to write this, because my wife has sat me through two separate Hugh Hefner/Playboy docuseries in the past week, one pro and one con, and I have an extensive comment to add to your comment on Playboy.

Lie might be the wrong word. I don't care if they're true, but it seems like a violation for them to inconsistent but concealed in a way that can't be called out.
Like if I put on anon mode and started doing some "As A Woman" bit, that should be bannable.
More options
Context Copy link