@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

Oher stated in his 2011 book that he entered into the conservatorship as a substitute for adoption. While the book was probably ghostwritten, he presumably read it, and would have been aware of it at that time. It's possible he didn't know that it hadn't been legally wrapped up.

What strikes me as most likely is that the family wanted to take care of him, but not to adopt him, because adoption presumably includes family inheritance on equal footing with the other kids. That's...a lot for a rich family to do, emotionally. That's not just the parents decision, at some level, it's also asking your kids to share their inheritance with the new adult son.

This wouldn't relate to the creation of the conservatorship, but instead to why Oher would not receive proceeds from the film (which came out in 2009) based on the book (which came out in 2006). Oher remained NCAA eligible to my knowledge until 2008, and would not have been able to sign any contract to profit from his name image or life story without losing eligibility. The other family members were under no such constraints.

You are correct, that makes a lot of sense. More familiarity with the process as well. But I'd think the most important thing is having two producers (directors, studios, whatever and etc.) interested in the work. One guy wants to make a movie of your book, you get what's "fair;" two guys want to compete to make a movie of your book you have a bidding war.

Michael Lewis also spoke at my sister's graduation, so I've followed his writing pretty closely, but less so the movies. I never recall hearing anything about the book prior to the movie, where Moneyball and Liar's Poker and The Big Short were huge successes and cultural landmarks prior to their respective films. The Blind Side was sort of an also ran as a book.

Possibly relevant: on another forum someone mentioned that Oher was in college when the book was written/published. NCAA rules would have prohibited him from benefitting from the book during that time. This may have impacted the later distribution of rights based on the book. So because Oher probably didn't/couldn't get revenue from the book, he would not have gotten part of the book rights, his rights in the film would have had to be a more general "life rights" agreement. But the filmmakers may not have pursued that, given that they had the rights to the book in hand. Maybe a sufficiently zealous advocate manages to carve out some money for Oher, but that seems like a tiny slight to sue over.

Huh. You're right. The Moneyball movie came later, but the book was written before The Blind Side.

Moneyball is the much more relevant comparison fwiw.

Slightly different topic but I tend to think the people who make it to play pro sports are significantly above group level IQ. Like Oher being 100 IQ. I just can’t see a 70-80 IQ functioning well enough to understand pro-sports concepts or being capable of training themselves to get there.

People like the idea of human beings as like character creation in DnD, you put too many points in Str and you don't have any left for Int! It feels just, it feels fair, it allows for humans to see a role for themselves in an Eigen Plot, even if they're not the big strong hero they still have a role.

The reality is human traits aren't distributed fairly. [John Urschel](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Urschel#::text=John%20Cameron%20Urschel%20(born%20June,of%20the%202014%20NFL%20Draft.) and Frank Ryan are guys who played in the NFL while obtaining and holding PhDs in mathematics from MIT and Rice respectively. Some people are just better than others. The idea of the dumb jock, and of the nebbish nerd, are copes designed to help people feel better about their own lacks.

I've never actually seen the movie, or read the book, it didn't seem like a plot that would interest me. But consider that as many as 80% of NFL players declare bankruptcy within three years of retirement [ETA: This number is probably wildly inflated, but it points to the general concept that a non-HoF level NFL player typically goes from making millions to making almost nothing in a year when they retire]. It is very common for players to think the money will never stop, to spend themselves into game-day paycheck to game-day paycheck, for their career to run out earlier than they thought, and next thing you know they're broke. It is quite likely that Oher is looking for alternative sources of revenue.

Simultaneously, he will never ever escape the movie. Even if he had been a truly great NFL player, he would always be "that guy from The Blind Side." As the poem goes, O-Line isn't a famous position for anyone other than Jason Kelce:

You'll note the life of Dick Szymanski

Is not all roses and romanski.

He centers the ball, he hears a roar-

Is it a fumble or a score?

He accomplishes amazing feats.

And what gets photographed? His cleats.

Ultimately, he quickly became a top 1000 O-Line player in the world, a fringe guy hanging around the edges of the NFL, rather than a top 150 player in the world who starts for an NFL team. For virtually any NFL player, they have defined their life by football for a decade or more. In high school he's the best player on their team, in college he's royalty. The end of their career becomes a crisis of self-definition, who am I if I'm not a football player? The lucky ones become coaches or commentators, the rest have no good answer to the question. Oher faces the additional obstacle towards his identity, he faces the Oscar-Winning film, he's stuck. In every room he enters he is "that dumb kid from the movie" before he is even "Super Bowl Winning Baltimore Raven." Even the sympathetic articles introduce him primarily by the movie, rather than as a starter in two Super Bowls. Viewed in this light, I suspect this is more of a tragic personal lashing-out played on a national gossip circuit. It's sad to me, and even worse that race is going to get dragged into it.

In general, when I see a celeb complaining about the contracts they signed early in their career, my prior is that they hit their sell-by date and can't understand what happened and they are lashing out. From Tab Hunter to Ke$ha, products of systems think they did it all themselves and wonder why the system claims so much of their money.

To my knowledge every study has concluded that women in the same age group are more likely to be sexually assaulted if they aren't in college.

Siddhartha is equally ridiculous in seeing the Four Sights, the pampering is often taken to comical extents in retellings of the story. It's the idea of someone so pampered seeing our world for the first time, with eyes uncallused, that they see things we accept and are horrified by them, as perhaps we ourselves should be horrified.

It's just an odd complaint on realism to me because it is, at core, a frequency argument. I don't think anyone is arguing that getting your ass smacked by a stranger is unrealistic. I'd go so far as to say it's a normal experience, for most men and women, at some point in their lives.

So the argument isn't that the occurrence itself is unrealistic, it's that the occurrence happens too fast to be realistic. That it portrays harassment as something that happens to every woman every day, when it's probably more like a couple incidents in there course of a lifetime.

That's gonna seem really nitpicky. It's meant to portray all of real life on an accelerated timeline. The movie doesn't have months to noodle about between interesting occurrences. So it comes out sounding like no woman ever gets her ass smacked, and that's just a silly point.

Great call! Next up: Pull up bar, kettlebell between 35 and 53 pounds, big exercise bands (Not a TON of value but they are cheap).

I sort of saw that as the Barbie equivalent of Buddha leaving home for the first time and seeing the Four Sights. But rather than disease old age death and asceticism; she sees ogling/catcalling, sexual assault, and old age, capped by defiance from the old lady.

I'm not sure where a discussion of realism fits into a film that features both tiny girls replaying the 2001 monolith scene and multiple extended musical numbers.

Excellent post, but I think Goggins is a spectacularly bad example.

First of all, he was an Airforce TACP at 20, then got obese after leaving the Air Force and working a dead end job, before working his way all the way back to the SEALs. The SEALs are obviously more famous/prestigious and arguably more difficult, but it's hardly too big a change of genre from TACP. Reaching the SEALs, and then going on to do various crazy things with ultramarathons and pull up records and whatnot, was arguably a return to form for him moreso than a change in lifestyle.

Second, he is insane. I don't mean that negatively or judgmentally, he's awesome and I enjoy his podcast appearances and I love his challenge heavy gut-it-out approach to fitness. But he's very different from most people. The experiences he's had have carved deep grooves in his psyche, among them is a recognizable insecurity and fear of going back to where he was. I've noticed that among the handful of people I know who have lost similar amounts of weight or made those kinds of fitness changes. One of my best friends throughout my life, we were both skinny teenagers, then he for various reasons (graduating high school and no longer playing soccer, leaving home and eating too much McDonald's) ballooned to 260 lbs. He since has lost a ton of weight, through a tremendous effort of cutting almost all carbs out of his diet for over a year, and while he's no Goggins he went from getting physically carried through a Spartan Sprint to running multiple Spartan Trifectas a year and placing top-10. But the scars remain: I have a very different relationship to food than he does, despite being the same weight today. He has a fear of food that I don't have, because he's seen what it can do to him. Goggins, similarly, is going to have a different mentality than someone who spent their whole life on one track from High School Cross Country star to Ultramarathoner. That difference is visible when you listen to him talk.

As for the prophets, I do think it means something that, for example, Sidhartha Guatama came from a Kshatriya warrior family, not from a Brahmin family of fellow sages or a Shudra family that was pissed on. A sermon I heard many years ago talked about the legends of Buddha meditating under the Bodhi tree, and demons appeared and threatened him with armies and tempted him with pleasures. The sermon talked about how depending on the translation, it's not clear that he was threatened with the armies, but perhaps was tempted by them. "Come on, let's go conquer and fight and rape and pillage like warriors should! It'll be a good time, we'll war and win and bleed." Buddha understood both the temptations of ease and of leisure, and the temptations of strife and of struggle. Both Type I and Type II fun are desires that must be extinguished.

Personally, I think that human identity is based primarily on hierarchy. The question of one's identity is the result of trying to differentiate oneself from others. One isn't a jock because one is big and strong, one is a jock because one is (or perceives oneself as) bigger and stronger than others, and defines oneself by that. One isn't a nerd because one is smart, but because one defines oneself by being smarter than others. As a result, one of my goals is to make sure that I raise my children by exposing them to as many different hierarchies where they will fit in differently and discover and develop different sides of themselves.

@2rafa 's argument can I think charitably be phrased as "The grooves in your psyche are carved by the time you are 12 or so and it's impossible to recapture that time."

But I suspect you have different definitions of identity and different definitions of nerd and jock here.

Far from merely entitled, if you work at any local warehouse to me they offer incentives for you to bring in additional workers from your friends and family. Stopping just shy of letting you recruit your own regiment civil war style.

I just finished Plutarch. That was a slog at times but I loved it.

I'm midway through The Dawn of Everything

For something lighter I'm picking up Nightbitch which my wife recommended.

I found Caro to be one of the greatest non fiction authors of all time, but I'm midway through The Years of Lyndon Johnson and the one thing that really frustrates me is his authorial Gell-Mann amnesia. In the middle of writing a 1600 page book on how Robert Moses/LBJ was a fraud and everything you heard about him was a lie forwarded intentionally to perpetuate a myth he'll pause to outline another character and give out some real whoppers. Al Smith working in fish markets, Sam Rayburn honest as sunshine, Coke Stevenson studying law by campfire. Watching Caro demolish LBJ one hears about Coke Stevenson accidentally getting into politics and one thinks "What a load of baloney, he made that up himself."

Congratulations!

I've been on a real cut for the first time in my life, and I'm below 200 again for the first time in like 10 months. New appreciation for how difficult it can be.

Huh, never thought I'd see the Woke-Wignat crossover game include "New, technical definition of Racism that excludes most historical and colloquial uses of the word, including most of the uses that made it popular."

I was more addressing @functor 's point here.

Protestant Irishman and Catholic Irishman can't get along, neither can two peoples who I would have honestly just labeled as Russian, so therefore I as an American descendant of Austrians and Hungarians must ally with Sicilians to keep Spaniards out. Just following the science.

It would, but partner hiring gives them a shot at some academics they wouldn't otherwise have a chance in hell with. Advantages to that kind of thing.

He'll never see a dime of the money, but those people will also be forced to live quite limited lives.

Or, you know, any of the dozens of other times and places where racial and ethnic hatred have resulted in death and destruction from Rwanda to Kosovo twenty years ago and from Syria to Donetsk in the past decade.

That America has gotten lucky and mostly avoided communal violence for a spell of 50 years seems like a silly prior to update.

((Also @2rafa)) If you have irrelevant questions about my personal life, please direct them to me and not to an antagonistic troll.

It's an account called Throwaway with five comments to their name who references minor sub users histories, so it's most likely a banned regular or someone who means the motte ill.

Another great example!

Who cares? People with an attenuated sense of fairness, who I mostly picture as people giving some pissant version of the Brando "I coulda been a contenda" speech centered around legacies/affirmative action/Nepo babies/racism/sexism/fatphobia.