FiveHourMarathon
a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop
And every gimmick hungry yob
Digging gold from rock n roll
Grabs the mic to tell us
he'll die before he's sold
But I believe in this
And it's been tested by research
He who fucks nuns
Will later join the church
User ID: 195
You're missing the weasel words. They're separately going to double urm representation and increase minority representation. The former group is tiny, blacks and Hispanics, the latter is Asians and gays and probably Jews and Armenians if they need them.
Any recommendations for good YouTube posts of full college lecture courses?
In the past I've enjoyed YaleCourses posts of Philosophy of Mind with Searle; Dante in translation with Mizzota; introduction to the old testament with Hayes; Marx's Capital with Harvey.
I'd be interested in anything in the literature, especially classical antiquity or 20th century anglophone; economics; history, especially Islamic or Chinese on a broad scale.
Half an ounce could really go either way. You're underestimating how much weed dealing is really, really petty nonsense.
-- We perceive the world at the level of our baseline skill. Is there any way to specifically develop skill at intuition, or is it only possible to develop skills which will then provide you with intuitions as they integrate into your brain? Can I learn to diagnose an engine problem by sound/feel, or is that just the residue of a thorough knowledge of engine repair in general? How does this apply to personal interactions, which we generally don't think of as a teachable skill but as purely intuitive? ((I'm perpetually amazed at my mechanic's ability to just "know" what is wrong with a car from how it feels))
-- Phantom vibrations seem to relate to the brain misinterpreting stimuli that are typically meaningless as meaningful due to the presence of a new stimulus in the form of phone vibrations. In what other ways have new stimuli short-circuited our intuition? Or have we formed new intuitions? ((I definitely run into phantom vibrations, or a constant desire to check emails, during certain work periods))
-- How much can we intuit about a person through text based communication? How much can we read between the lines of text messages, letters, forum posts in subtle ways beyond the implications of normal writing? Is this skill more or less present in those who use these formats more often? ((I recently formed a fairly profound connection with someone via text, and my intuitions about them proved right, and I've been wondering this ever since, luck or unknown skill?))
-- Blood Harmony is a degree of musical harmony that is traditional in country/bluegrass/gospel music; supposedly siblings can achieve degrees of harmony impossible for others. Is this a real phenomenon? Is it applicable to other fields than music? Does consanguinity create the harmony, or being raised together? Both, neither?
Sure, the state intervenes, but not easily. There's thousands of lawyers around the country who work at getting Social Security Disability Benefits for their clients. I've worked on those kinds of cases before. It is not as easy as you think to just reach out your hand and get a handout. There's a whole corpus of law and expertise devoted to determining what jobs a person is able to hold, and whether those jobs can make the necessary adjustments to allow the individual to work there, and if those jobs are available. Can this individual carry 50lbs? 15lbs? 5lbs? Can they walk a mile, a thousand yards, a hundred yards? How long can they sit/stand/walk before needing a break? How many days a week would they be unable to work? The government can dig into every aspect of your life at a hearing to determine if you'll get anything out of them, and half the time a lawsuit results. If there is any job you can do, you aren't getting disability benefits. If you lose your arm and can't work as a welder, you don't get money, you get told to go get a job manning the booth at a parking garage.
Which brings us back to our friends the incels. This is the debate we have over Incel vs Volcel, whether most incels could get laid if they wanted to fuck ugly women, or if they washed their hair, or whatever. The government, or society, has every right to interrogate if you are doing enough before giving you help.
I wrote a prior comment in an SSS here. In general, just read all the comments on here, and think of all the different activities we put under the heading "homosexuality" and figure that maybe the act of men having sex with men might have multiple causes. Dudes might fuck dudes for different reasons at different times in different places. Trying to come up with a single cause of all those things is like conflating wage theft, embezzlement of corporate funds, armed robbery, burglary, running a ponzi scheme, shoplifting at self checkout, lying on your tax return, and creating a false will for a relative, and selling used cars with bullshit "warranties" that don't cover anything; and then looking for a "theft" gene that unites all those disparate kinds of thieves.
I'm happy to give you something more concrete as an assignment if it would help you, I always like reading your thoughts, and I certainly have a few clear topics that would be interesting to hear about from someone else.
I wanted to define it broadly to allow anyone to enter anything that was percolating in their head but hadn't yet been committed to text.
But why are the "basement dwelling gamur incels" among the most reviled subgroups in the culture war? Is it simply because they spew the most bile against every 'vulnerable' demographic (women, minorities, LGBTs) online?
The single oldest work of Western Literature is The Epic of Gilgamesh, "He Who Surpassed All Other Kings," "He Who Looked into the Abyss." Spoiler Alert! The wild man Enkidu is sent by the gods to chasten Gilgamesh for his overbearing ways, a fellow great hero to limit Gilgamesh and to be his companion. But Enkidu is wild and uncivilized after his creation, he uproots traps and robs farms. The Priestess Shamtat goes to Enkidu, and they make love for seven days and seven nights, and after that Enkidu is ready for civilization, he is alienated from his old friends among the beasts and the birds and must become a civilized man and go into town. Or it might take two weeks, depending on the tablets translated from
In a nutshell, the differences between the two episodes reflect different stages of Enkidu's transition from an animal to a human being. The discovery allows us to study this transition in more detail: What does it mean to become human? What steps lead from a life among the animals to a full human consciousness? What did humanity entail for the ancient Babylonians?
The first time Shamhat invites Enkidu to come to Uruk she describes Gilgamesh as superb in strength and horned like a bull. Enkidu readily accepts her invitation, saying that he will come to Uruk – but only to challenge Gilgamesh and usurp his power. “I shall change the order of things”, he declares. “The one born in the wild is mighty, he has strength.” Though Enkidu has learned to plan and speak like a human being, his way of thinking is still very much that of a wild animal: he immediately sees Gilgamesh as an alpha male, a rival bull to be defeated. The only thing that matters to him at this point is strength and domination.
But the second time Shamhat invites him to Uruk, after they have had sex for yet another week, he sees things differently. Shamhat says that she will lead him to the temple, home of Anu, the god of heaven. Rather than change the order of things, Enkidu is to find a place for himself in society: “Where men are engaged in labours of skill, you, too, like a true man, will make a place for yourself.” Enkidu, now wiser after a second bout of civilizing sex, is ready to accept this invitation. “He heard her words, he consented to what she said: a woman's counsel struck home in his heart.” He has understood the value of urban life, accepting the fact that human society is not all about domination and strength, but also about cooperation and skill. Each human being is part of a larger social fabric, where everyone must find their own place.
The incel is both threat and symbol of society's failure to civilize its men. Without a Shamtat, a sacred prostitute, to civilize them, men will run wild, they will remain with the wild playmates of their youth. Shamtat, of course, is ordered to take on this task, while she is typically portrayed as doing so voluntarily she does not do so of her own agency. Of course, other than the hair and the dirt, the reader also probably pictures Enkidu as being pretty hot, a muscled wild-man of the mountains, does the sacrificial task of Shamtat take on a different erotic charge if Enkidu is pasty and obese? It's a strange contradiction in terms, caused by a confusion in the discourse around incels which is the natural result of the terminology being unclear.
Cribbed from my own prior Reddit comment:
Taking the plain meaning "involuntarily celibate" is more like "unemployed" than it is like "disabled." Unemployed is defined as "someone who doesn't have a job but is seeking one," while disabled is defined (per social security) as "a person with a disability must have a severe disability (or combination of disabilities) that has lasted, or is expected to last, at least 12 months or result in death, and which prevents working at a substantial gainful activity." Many/most people are unemployed at some periods in their lives, few people are disabled at some point in their lives (leaving aside childhood and old age, when everyone is disabled from getting a job and no one can/should get laid).
We could distinguish there, between the "unemployed" incel and the "disabled" incel. Almost every man goes through periods when he is looking for sex and can't get it, very few young men are permanently physically incapable of getting laid. We could further distinguish among the unemployed incels the three general types of unemployment in Econ 101: Frictional, Cyclical, Structural. Virtually every man has periods of Frictional celibacy, between girlfriends or hook ups or busy at work or on a long term sojourn somewhere not amenable to casual sex. Obviously there's not a "business cycle" to sex, but we could substitute that for the lifecycle of the man himself, almost all men are ready and willing to have sex long before they are able to obtain it, and most are willing to have sex long after they are too old to interest most women. Those two categories are unimportant to us, they may participate in incel discourse for a time but ultimately they'll get their "fair share" of sex over a lifetime. It's the third group, Structural Incels, we should worry about. The Structurally Unemployed are those whose skills have been made redundant by industrial changes and reorganizations. Your coal miners or carriage makers. People who will never get laid with the skills they have. The solution to that is always training and help changing careers. Some people don't want to train and they don't want to change careers, well tough luck then. Sitting around whining you should have a bigger paycheck because you are the best carriage maker in ten counties, and failing to acknowledge that no one buys carriages!, is a bridge to nowhere.
I think we tend to conflate a bunch of different phenomena under the same incel heading. Some of this is rhetorical, politically active incels themselves conflate themselves with the disabled constantly when we'd probably label a lot of them somewhere in the unemployed category. But we all know somebody who can't get laid, and it is easy to be scared that they are or aren't on the slide into inceldom, permanent exile from civilization.
because I'm not sure I could satisfy her.
You absolutely can, and will, if you decide to. The standards for heterosexual men are barely above the floor, you have to limbo under that bar or trip over it to fail. While I hardly have perfect information, I'm perpetually shocked when I hear about what women out there tolerate. While I think your first time can be written off as a loss, and hell I tell any new partner going in that the first time together will probably be mid at best, you are not incapable of being a good lover in all likelihood.
As a comment in the main thread, as a standalone post, or as a comment in any other post. Basically anywhere we typically post on themotte.
Absolutely, that pipeline is already set up and easy to use. All you need to do is win, my man.
It's an interesting theory, but I have to question how many gay men you know and thought hard about in the process of writing this. Or rather, probably, how many hot, upper class gay men who live in urban centers. Homosexuality is not experienced as fleeing from competition, but as a constant state of competition. If one becomes gay to escape heterosexual competition, it is out of the frying pan and into the grindr. Anecdotally and stereotypically, it is gay men who put more effort into their appearance, gay men who are in better shape and less likely to be obese, gay men who are more likely to choose hobbies that partners might like over vagina-drying hobbies like vidya games or arguing on obscure internet forums.
I would also point out that entertainment fields that gay men dominate, fashion and theater, are as or more competitive than fields straight men dominate, athletics and video games. The win conditions may seem less legible to you, but that makes them no less real to those participating. But materially, economically, there is only so much room at the top, and the bottom gets nothing out of it in fashion.
But more importantly, sexually, the vast majority of heterosexual men are monogamists, while gay men are much more likely to be open see also, all studies put it at 4-5% in straight couples and 30-50% in gay male couples. Moreover, two thirds of men are married, while only one out of every ten homosexuals jumped the broom. Monogamy is sexual socialism, polygamy is sexual capitalism. In a monogamous relationship, competition may be fierce initially to get a partner, but after that you have a secure long term partner. If you let yourself go, if you stop romancing your spouse, if you form unattractive habits; then social shame and government policies act to keep the couple together, or at least to make it inconvenient to exit. In a polygamous relationship, you are an at-will employee. You never stop competing, if you ever lose your edge, you'll lose your spot to a fresh applicant. The rewards scale differently. In a monogamous relationship, however hot I get the reward is the same. In a polygamous relationship, the hotter I am the more sexual partners I can have.
So I guess I just don't see it, in terms of how gay and straight men actually live their lives and fuck. As I get older and I interact with more people I actually find that homosexuality confuses me more and more. When I was a kid and it was just a political issue, and I knew perhaps a half dozen gay men, it was easy to buy into simple explanations like genetics or "helper-in-the-nest" or hormone wash (or, for that matter, sin). Now, with experience, no explanation on offer really satisfies me. The epicycles-type mental explanation I'm working through is that what we bunch under the heading "homosexuality" is actually a big pile of different phenomena from diverse causes, but that's probably just a lack of understanding rather than a sophisticated understanding.
Is a lack of confidence just being conflated with virginity here?
Yes. Or more specifically, not a lack of confidence per se, but the feeling that you are not where you want to be, you are not doing what you want to do, and you are not getting what you want out of life. What most attracts us to people is the feeling that they're doing exactly what they want to do, that they're in flow, slicing reality at the joints. Almost all nonreligious men in our society, and most religious men too unfortunately, want to get laid all the time with any available woman. So if one is a virgin, one is almost certainly not getting what one wants.
That's why sometimes virginity is perceived as a wildly unattractive feature. If you're doing it for religious reasons, then you're getting what you want, that's attractive. If you're doing it for non-religious reasons, no one will ever believe you anyway. You'll probably get a better reception among religious folk, which is where you ought to be looking for a similarly situated virgin bride anyway. {You'll probably have a lot of problems finding a true virgin among the religious anyway unless you're comfortable dating a younger woman.}
I just don't know any virgin women over age 25 who aren't religious, hideously ugly, or deeply unhealthy. Often multiple of those. If you're not looking for a religious woman, and a younger one at that, I don't see a path forward.
If you're not looking for a similarly situated virgin bride who will likely be a virgin for religious reasons, then I think you do have to question what the path looks like to being with the person you love.
I'm an awful degenerate. I don't think I could have seduced my wife if it wasn't for the yeo(wo)man's work other girls put in to to teach me what was what. The first time we were together was electric, and it's all flowed from there, we've been together ever since. Maybe love conquers all and it would have worked out even if I had been rather underwhelming in bed that first time, but maybe not. So when I look at how happy I am with my life and my wife, I think i should send a couple girls thank you cards.
-
The two words have entirely different etymologies. Chad the western name comes from Ceadda, Chad the country comes from T'Chad.
-
Chad the country would still be feminine. Ain't no one dying for a country with he/him/his pronouns. Sometimes countries are personified as male (Fatherland, John Bull, Uncle Sam) but they're always sung of as she. Like a ship.
On a related note, I wish we had a 21st century American Songbook. I want to hear more great covers! I want to hear every new metal band play their spin on Painkiller and Twilight of the Thunder God. I want to hear Jay Z or Snoop do a retrospective album in their middle age, where they rap their friend's songs, hear their renditions of Heaven for a G and Country Grammar.
Thanks for summarizing the article for me. I tried reading it, but it was just so Godawful long that I couldn't get through it once he started lionizing the little known foreign thinker, while criticizing the well known Anglophone for taking drugs, while engaging in endless low-grade sneering about people dancing or committing minor crimes for fun. Sometimes I get halfway through a new substack, and I just want to know the time and circumstances of the writer's last orgasm with another person.
For a while circa late 2019 to early 2020 the astrology app The Pattern was a fad among my friends. You punched in your data and it gave you a daily horoscope. Nothing deep, just a little fortune-cookie wisdom every day. I joked that this was an untapped market for Mike Bloomberg to purchase ads in! What if, close to primary days in key states, he paid The Pattern to just tell people in that state to vote for him. Or maybe more subtle, "The position of Uranus relative to Mercury indicates that you will fair better over the next four years under political leaders with real world business experience, and should avoid leaders who got where they are through political game-playing." Not too subtle, these are astrology fans we're talking to.
I think the far more dangerous use of TikTok would be similar. Think of The Mule, the greatest threat that the Foundation ever faced. His psychic powers didn't kill, they didn't cripple, they simply demoralized. They slightly depressed the enemy fighters, they took away that last 5% that wins or loses games.
Can TikTok do the same? Can it just turn down the dials on a soldier, make him less effective? I don't know. But I'm sure people are trying to figure that out right now, and I doubt any of them have my best interests at heart. Can we pitch people's moods up or down by throwing them certain pieces of content and avoiding others? It seems plausible. I can be put in a better mood by one piece of media, and in a worse mood by another. People seem to get implausibly angry and frustrated by certain meme arguments online about politics and culture war shit; could TikTok just turn all that up to 11 and cause chaos?
I'm not so sure, I kind of doubt Social Media's broader impact on the conversation, because the testimony to it always seems one sided. "Your opinions are impacted in ways you barely understand, His opinions are entirely astroturfed; come read my substack to get the real dope." Rarely have I ever seen anyone say "ACAB, but the George Floyd riots were driven by a social media mind virus." It's always the bad things that other people want that are fake and gay hailcorporate astroturf; your own causes are pure, you arrived at them through the application of pure reason in a vacuum under a Bodhi tree. The instant writer has no doubt that only a degeneracy-inducing Chinese superweapon could get people to enjoy dancing or watching pretty girls make funny drinks. Yet he doesn't stop to wonder why he is the 10 millionth fucking guy this week {including most of my own TikTok feed} to give an introductory lecture on Stoicism.
More beautiful Cowboys facts:
"Jalen Hurts wasn't born the last time the Cowboys made the conference championship game. That means Hurts' parents had sex, gave birth, raised him, he learned how to play football, went to 'Bama, transferred to OU, got drafted, sat behind Wentz, and then lead his team through a soft-rebuild to the NFC Championship game before Dallas got back." -- David Akers
Dallas Goedert was literally named for the Dallas Cowboys, and he's going to play in the NFC Championship Game before the Cowboys get back to it.
As an Eagles fan, I had about the best weekend possible.
On Saturday night the Eagles beat the Giants in a performance so dominant that they pulled their starters by the end of the game. Hurts' and his receivers had anemic stat lines, it simply wasn't necessary to try very hard to dismantle the Giants. On a podcast afterward, former Eagle Tra Thomas said you could watch the Giants' players collectively decide it was time to "piss on the campfire" and just get out of the game and into the off-season unhurt, by about the middle of the second quarter. That was great.
But Sunday night was even better. The Dallas Cowboys and their overrated Quarterback Dakota* Prescott managed to completely blow a playoff game against unheralded rookie-back up Brock Purdy and the 49ers. Ending it on one of the most bizarre Hospital Ball plays you will ever see. Instant meme. Let's get our running back fucking murdered, then throw the ball into traffic ten yards in anyway. It was beautiful.
So today, I indulged in one of my many vices. I went through and downloaded a series of Dallas Cowboys fan podcasts. I love listening to other teams' pain. Probably even more than I love listening to Eagles' podcasts gloat after a big win. It's beautiful to listen as Blogging the Boys or About Them Cowboys, and just hear the pain. Hear the bewilderment as to how their massively highly paid quarterback and running back blew the game; how the team just can't seem to execute under pressure; how Brock Purdy now has as many playoff wins as Dak Prescott or Tony Romo; how the same thing seems to happen every year with the Cowboys managing to blow it late in the season; how just last season they blew a playoff game against the Niners in similar fashion.
I love the schadenfreude. The NFL is my outlet for Tribalism. The human mind has an inbuilt capacity for discriminating against and punishing the out-group. This works for any out-group, no matter how tendentious. We must hate someone, it's a required field to fill out on the form. Try to hate no one, you'll just claim you hate those who hate someone. The best way to hack hatred, is to pick an inconsequential hatred to burn it out on. This is ancient knowledge, the Romans had Red-White-Blue-Green Chariot factions. RetVrn! Bread and Circuses generally has a negative connotation, but it worked for a long, long, long time. Rome wasn't built in a day, and it didn't fall in a century. Bread and Circuses kept the plebs in line for centuries in much of the Roman world. By directing their hatreds towards inconsequential things, political rage was blunted, drained of vitality.
I hope to maintain a clear mind on topics that matter. Are there people, groups, factions I dislike? Yes, but I don't want to do so irrationally. My ideal is intellectual Jeet Kune Do, taking the good from everyone and the bad from no one. I don't want to irrationally hate Donald Trump or Joe Biden, I want to understand why they are powerful, absorb what they have right and critique what they have wrong. But the brain wants to hate, wants to hate irrationally, wants to hate viciously, wants to admit nothing positive about anyone wearing the wrong colors. I sate that beast, I feed it the Dallas Cowboys. While my Id is busy hurling batteries at Ezekiel Elliott and joking about the 90s, my rational Superego is free to consider politics and philosophy and religion.
*Men should not be named Dakota. Place names are female; and anyway English shares so much in common with the romance languages that we should stick to their gender rules and name boys DakotO.
Answers:
-
Yes.
-
As @Stefferi states, they would probably have predicted that society would collapse more or less instantly upon the achievement of several prior levels of degeneracy. If they're wrong on every sub prediction, it might be fair to ignore or soften their future predictions.
-
Try to rank the Roman Emperors. The Biblical Jewish kings. Hell, American Presidents. All of them. The first few slots are bitterly contested, who was a better king Solomon or David? What order do Diocletian, Augustus, Hadrian go on the list? Andrew Jackson and Abraham Lincoln are quite easily seen as GOAT or goat, depending on who is doing the rankings. Do leaders over bigger territories get extra credit over those who lead diminished geographies? But pretty quickly, you realize that none of those lists contains a preponderance of good leaders. Despite three very different polities, choosing their leaders by very different methods, the net result is similar: there are a handful of really great leaders, historically important geniuses who set their country's path for decades, sometimes centuries, to come; who are succeeded by mediocrities and losers, who fritter that momentum away over time. But it takes many mediocrities to lose the path, "There's a lot of ruin in a nation." Rome spent most of its history in "decline." The Old Testament is mostly just a series of kings turning away from the true faith, the modern Jews essentially are still running off the software created by a handful of great leaders between Moses and Solomon. This might just be a result of historiography, but it seems to me that decline and degeneracy are the normal state rather than an exceptional one; collapse comes much, much, much later than degeneracy can first be identified.
It's at core not a social media platform. This makes comparisons to Twitter/Reddit and their clones/subgroups somewhat tendentious. There is no really convenient way for a substack post or comment to "go viral" on the platform in the way a tweet or Reddit post will. As of yet, we also haven't seen substacks/comment sections that will rally the troops for raids on other substacks, which is generally the dynamic that leads to witch-covens becoming an issue.
It's just a different animal.
You can still volunteer to knock on doors as a grown up with no intention of going pro. Signature periods open up for 2023 local elections in many states soon, get in touch with your local party and you too can get in the game.
Maybe that doesn't mean much today, but a few hours every year and you might start having phone numbers that will be useful to you, or being someone local candidates will court.
If colleges are going to start requiring some diversity BS elective, maybe this knocks it out as an AP class in high school, saving students later time and money?
At which point the blame lies upstream. But just looking at my own bookshelf, I could teach a state college freshman elective (how I'd rate an AP class) on African American Thought from Doughlass through Du Bois to Baldwin and McWhorter Next Week. The idea that there "isn't enough material" is absurd, and meant to say something else.
Seconded. They really serve no purpose. They don't shrink, there's no purpose.
The little voice says, just stop, pass away and perhaps you'll roll again and be more fortunate.
Yeah, idk. Depending on how you figure the rolls are weighted, it seems extraordinarily unlikely you'll do better. This statement kind of fascinates me because it is making me think: what would the re-rolling process look like, and how would you weight it? What are the range of possibilities? All humans? All sentient life? All life? Are we throwing in +∞ and -∞ possibilities for monotheistic heavens and hells? How do we weight the possibility of nonexistence? What about time periods: are reincarnations time-progressing such that from here I will wait 90 days and come back, or what if they are time-independent? It's a hell of a Rawlsian Veil of Ignorance to worry about piercing.

I suspect it has less to do with the age or calculating libido than with the "good new content." It's classic Coolidge Effect.
More options
Context Copy link