FiveHourMarathon
a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop
And every gimmick hungry yob
Digging gold from rock n roll
Grabs the mic to tell us
he'll die before he's sold
But I believe in this
And it's been tested by research
He who fucks nuns
Will later join the church
User ID: 195
Probably not. I would probably, though not strongly, feel worse about hearing that a nepalese kid died than that a species of fly in the Amazon died out. Though, at this point, we're talking about very very very very minor degrees of caring to begin with.
On the other hand, I'm clearly going to feel more upset at the news that 1,000 rhinos were poached than at the news that 1,000 Bangladeshis died somehow or other.
I'm not sure what the equation looks like exactly. I could probably be persuaded by an ecologist that some species I don't care about now is actually really interesting/necessary/unique/whatever such that I value it above the dead foreigner.
I'm just rejecting the idea that every single human life is more valuable than every single animal life. I don't think that is the case, either intrinsically or by intuitive feeling or by revealed preferences of people. Even an ethos argument built around the depravity of individuals, I'm not sure I get there: I'd probably think someone who poached bald eagles was a worse person than the median murderer.
Now I'd probably sign on for the idea that every single human being is allowed to value their own or their loved ones lives above every single animal life as a general rule. But globally, I don't value them that way, and no one else does either.
Are there school-shooting-nutjobs and CEO-assassinating-nutjobs, or else are there mass-shooting-on-any-target-nutjobs?
I think there are murder-suicide oriented nutjobs, across all cultures and all time periods, and the particular expression their death-urge takes is socially mediated.
A man with the overactive murder-suicide gene born in the Arab world has an obvious path for it: he joins a jihadist group. In medieval Norway, he would go a-viking, while in Russia he would go off and become a Cossack, in the old west he would go off and fight injuns. In virtually every European country for virtually every male before 1945, at some point in his youth he'd have the opportunity to join an army and fight in a war, and if he went off to war with much desire to kill and little desire to return, he probably wouldn't make it back.
The school shooter is one of Tyler Durden's "middle children of history," with no great war or great depression he lashes out at random. He is offered no socially acceptable way to get himself killed and noticed, and picks the worst one possible. I'm a big believer that the best way to prevent school shootings is to give them another way to get themselves killed.
Furries remain something that I can't, quite, accept that they exist.
He said he stopped liking it in 2016, he stopped using it when he got banned "a few" years back, which I'd normally read as 2-3, giving at minimum double the amount of time of using Reddit as having left Reddit.
Given that it takes five years of residency to be ready to apply to become a US citizen, I'd say leaving for 2 or 3 years isn't enough to shed it. Certainly if one lived in the United States for 20 years, leaving for ten isn't enough to stop being American, you probably never quite stop being American at that point.
I'm curious what the linguistic or philosophical category is for a statement where I would say that someone can't claim something as a positive status, but can't argue against it as a negative status. Like if a teen boy has only received a handjob, one is probably precluded from claiming to be a virgin in the positive sense of being chaste, but probably can't brag to his buddies about having lost his virginity. Or a corporate lawyer who does some pro-bono work for woke causes; he can't claim the positive status of being in public interest because he's a corporate sellout, but neither can he avoid the negative accusation of working for the woke blob.
So the question is, is being a redditor (or an American) more like building a bridge, or fucking a goat?
Huh, interesting. I mostly hear weebs made fun of by Asian girls who want to complain about fetishes.
...What were the furry wars?
Likewise, the "scifi jurassic park stuff" isn't really scifi anymore, we're already doing it in a limited capacity.
Has this actually been done? I'm aware of people talking about it, but not of it actually happening.
But sure, I'll cop to both of us using extreme examples: you're thinking of "endangered species" that are slightly different varieties of Vole, which yes I probably don't much care about; while I'm thinking of things like megafauna and butterflies and stuff I would care about. I don't really care about every kind of crawfish; I do care about the rhinoceros.
Maybe in general, but not in my case. A few years back, after a long downward pattern of less & less use, I copped a permanent ban on absurd grounds, and had my appeal rejected.
Claims not be a redditor. Used reddit from somewhere prior to 2016 until a couple years ago. Appealed the ban to try to keep using reddit.
Yeah, dude, you're a redditor. Albeit maybe an exiled one. One wouldn't say that an American living abroad has ceased to be an American, and a Catholic who stops going to communion is always just a lapsed Catholic.
Redditor is a unique designation, in that hating redditors tells me instantly that you are, in fact, a redditor. I'm not aware of any similar grouping of humans. Chris Rock might rail about the difference between "Black people and Niggers" but he clearly understands himself to be in the former category. Jews might mock their own foibles, but so does everyone else. Only Redditors complain about Redditors.
This is remarkably unresponsive to my comment. I didn't say, at any point, that extinction of any species was of infinite value. I said that an increased chance of extinction of certain species was more valuable than one human life in some cases, which is the contra to @hydroacetalyne who stated that
I don’t care if harambe or dumbo or shamu are as smart as a child they don’t have the moral worth of one, it’s a qualitative difference not quantitative.
I don't think you value every human life at a higher value than you place every animal life, and I don't think most people do.
You might not value the life of a rare Rhinoceros infinitely, but I'm fairly certain based on my knowledge of you, South, that you do value it more highly than you value the life of a random 3rd worlder.
To my way of thinking elephants are rarer than rats and so killing one should be a much higher bar to clear, but there isn’t a moral problem with shooting a depredating elephant from a helicopter in the same way that there isn’t a moral problem with setting a rat trap.
I think I disagree. There's a point of rarity, or even just majesty, at which I'm more upset by the death of an animal than the death of a human.
I'd consider it worse to kill a critically endangered species than to kill a random human. Because killing the endangered species gets closer to robbing and harming every human forever (leaving aside scifi Jurassic park stuff) while the death of any individual human probably doesn't.
Where exactly I draw that line, I'm not sure. Definitely when a critically endangered species population is almost unviable, every kill is one step closer to extinction.
But examining my feelings, I'd probably also be more upset by a dead bald eagle than a dead person, depending on the person, for purely symbolic patriotic reasons.
The most locally concerning precedent being set in immigration cases is the requirement that all social media be set to "public". This is essentially leaning towards the abolition of internet anonymity.
I don't see how one classifies "social media" in a way that doesn't include a place like Reddit, TheMotte, or MetalArchives, or my comments on BleedingGreenNation about Nick Sirianni, or the comments from Carolinian politicians on NudeAfrica. No more usernames, everything must be posted publicly.
And while they might only be talking about Facebook or instagram or Twitter initially, and during the visa process they probably won't be extensively cross-referencing non-public information to figure out your anonymous usernames, let alone utilizing stylistic analysis or correlating personal information to doxx you, the catch-22 is potentially really bad: if you lie on your visa application, you have now committed a crime.
And if they want to get rid of you, all they have to do is utilize the various methods available to a government to doxx you, find the comments you made on BloggingTheBoys about how Jerry Jones needs to get his head out of his ass, and boom, they have you.
No. This is Frederick Forsyth novel stuff.
The most likely outcome from doing so would be that the weird letter would be reported to the police/fbi/whoever.
Didn't the Puritans marry pretty young?
I can believe that you can keep a boy virginal to 16 reliably with good parenting, 18 or 20 less reliably but still often enough to make it worthwhile, but probably never to 25 unless the boy is sort of a fuck up. Like if a boy loses his virginity before 16 it says something bad about the parents, of a boy still has his v card at 26 it says something concerning about him. He might lack the libido to have a quality marriage later, or the power of will to get what he wants.
I'll note that I haven't watched every single video or read every tweet. But, it's weird to me that few of the reactions seem to be seeing it as the obvious homage to the Brooke Shields Calvin Klein ad campaign*. Calvin Klein was the peak of designer jeans at the time, and Brooke Shields was one of the sexiest stars on the planet, and they had this long advertisement of her slinking into her jeans while talking about the genetic science of evolution and mating. It's a direct homage
The whole thing seems so odd to me, so telling on yourself, to complain about the ad, rather than demand a parallel ad with a genetically blessed black girl, and so on and so forth. In a completely non-racial way, Sydney Sweeney has great genes. In the same way that Saquon Barkley has great genes, that Barack Obama has great genes, that Fedor has great genes, that Lucy Liu has great genes. Great genetics aren't inherently a racial question.
*To be fair, I'm only aware of this because my wife wanted to watch that documentary that weekend, so I wouldn't have gotten it either last week.
Who knows, but old heads still talk about them so they must have worked.
Very
-
I can with a great degree of safety (90%? 95%?) avoid questionable girls right off the bat by sight.
-
I can avoid places where underage girls hang out pretty easily and costlessly
-
No one actually checks their dates ID.
I can't avoid places "people who didn't take or can't pass the sex test" hang out. I can't read it at a glance. I'd HAVE to actually check.
So... Instead of the sloppy but intuitive test of "does she look old enough" one would now have to literally ask if she has a license?
The world made a rule that ethnic cleansing was never justified under any circumstances.
A much more basic way to frame this moral precept would be:
All people who live within your borders are, and of right ought to be, citizens of your state, and the government of your state has equal responsibilities to them as to any other citizen. You can exclude people from entering your country, you can expel parts of your country (Malaysia/Singapore, India/Pakistan), but you can't treat certain people living in your country as non-citizens.
Israel has tried to find its way around this by creating two Palestinian bantustans and keeping them split, the non-viable non-contiguous territories providing a shred of cover that those living there will never have to be integrated into Israel's population, despite Israel's permanent control of the external policy of each enclave.
My point being that Israel has another path: re-educating and reconciling with the Palestinian civilian population such that they no longer support Hamas (or whoever).
Hamas doesn't get to do its permanent-war bit on its own. It requires mass support among Arabs, undermine that and there's no more Hamas.
I'm not really interested in horse-trading and baby-splitting about what you think constitutes a war displacement and what constitutes a genocide, how many need to die before it constitutes a genocide rather than "ethnic cleansing with the hallmarks of genocide" as Poland's parliament termed the massacre of over 100,000 Polish civilians in Volhynia during the end stages of WWII by Ukrainian nationalists who wanted to make sure that those areas would be part of the "correct" country at the end of the war.*
But I'm not sure what the point of this argument you're making is. What is the upshot here of the Holocaust being different? What impact does it have on the world today, in terms of how people should or do act?
I don't even think Jews, generally speaking, are any more likely to maintain multiple passports or loyalties than anyone else in America, curving for differences in social class, education, urban/rural split. It's a common affectation.
As an aside, accusations of hypocrisy against Jews regarding Israel/Palestine are often misplaced. Highly detailed demographic breakdowns on the NYC mayoral primary show that Zohran Mamdani won a plurality of all Jewish voters in the primary, and 67% of Jewish voters under 45 (he finished second among Jews over 45). The astroturf campaign trying to paint Mamdani as anti-semitic is mostly driven by and targeted at non-Jews.
*Learning about this really changed my view of the Nazis, in the sense that I'm still confused by the idea that the Nazis didn't actually have that tight of control over the interior of the Ukraine, that the Ukrainian Insurgent Army could still have weapons and congresses and stuff.
And also that the Ukrainian Insurgent Army would have weapons and use them on the Polish rather than on the Germans OR the Soviets! On the one hand, it's almost a kind of grimly admirable focus, there's a sort of cold-blooded truth to it: their actions did change the borders of Poland and Ukraine on a permanent basis. But it's just unimaginable to me, I'm American, I consider all racism not based on US census categories to be so junior varsity as to be pointless. Don't they realize they're all just non-hispanic whites?
Does Hamas control anything at this point, in the sense that I could go to an office and talk to my local boss to get something?
And if my aunt had balls she'd be my uncle.
I understand what you're saying, I don't really see it as a different category of problem. Germans and Poles and Russians and Ukrainians have all experienced living in places for centuries only to find that the government of that place suddenly no longer considered them citizens. So did Russian aristocracy, Cambodian bourgeoisie, East African indians, hell millions of Americans have arguments around this.
This seems like another special pleading case where the Holocaust is considered particularly exceptional and gives the designated descendants of the victims a gold card to break norms that everyone else is expected to observe.
Either way the argument that the Holocaust justifies paranoia doesn't really absolve anyone of anything. If I'm dating a girl and she refuses to commit because "she's been hurt before," I'm not obligated to tolerate it and consider her a loyal girlfriend despite her disloyal behavior. Commitment is commitment, and mixed loyalty is mixed loyalty, even if it is justified paranoia rather than pure avarice.
That's because they have a country that isn't going to suddenly decide they don't belong there.
Except, you know, that millions of eastern Europeans literally did find themselves in that situation at various times between the end of WWI and 2022.
I get what you're trying to say but altered borders so that Russians find themselves outside Russia, or Poles outside Poland, has been a pretty constant problem.

You have no idea how happy it makes me that someone got the joke.
More options
Context Copy link