FiveHourMarathon
a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop
And every gimmick hungry yob
Digging gold from rock n roll
Grabs the mic to tell us
he'll die before he's sold
But I believe in this
And it's been tested by research
He who fucks nuns
Will later join the church
User ID: 195
I'll take this opportunity to point out the outlines, as of yesterday, of a real 3d chess solution from Trump and his people. I don't know where, if anywhere, this sits after the breakdown in talks in the white house today.
Reading between the lines of the proposed Minerals Deal, this is the first legitimate proposal for peace that I have seen that matches in quality my tongue in cheek proposal to put Harry and Meghan on the throne in Kiev.
Trump wants a "minerals" deal in which US companies would receive concessions to mine rare earths in Ukraine. Articles covering the deal have pointed out that many of the mineral reserves considered in that deal are in parts of Ukraine that are currently occupied by Russia. Mean spirited turbolib snickering about Trump being unable to read a map aside, I don't think that is what is going on.
European armies are mooting the idea of placing a tripwire force as "peacekeepers in Ukraine" to keep the conflict from flaring back up. The European troops, somewhere between 30,000-100,000 soldiers on the ground, would not be expected to fight the Russians so much as to provide an easy target for the Russians to force a broader WWIII scenario. Similar to the US forces on the DMZ in South Korea, or the troops in Berlin during the cold war. Prevent a Russian invasion without an unacceptable risk of triggering WWIII. In classic game theory Chicken, this is the equivalent of putting a bar in your steering wheel that prevents you from turning away, forcing your opponent to take the last clear chance to get away from the accident, pre-committing.
Trump, when asked about this proposal, replied that the minerals deal was the guarantee.
This is more intelligent and bigger than anyone realizes. To quote from my own prior comment:
The government of Ukraine cannot end the war with Russia in a position where Russia could renew the war in the future. As the permanent neutering of Russia is impossible or inadvisable, most commentators want to provide Ukraine with some kind of security guarantee from the USA/NATO/PRC that will prevent future Russian aggression, but negotiated in some unspecified way that it isn't just adding Ukraine to NATO, which it is basically assumed Russia wouldn't accept unless, as above, Russia was permanently neutered, which, as above, is impossible or inadvisable. Another problem being that Ukraine tried that shit once already, with all nuclear powers guaranteeing the integrity of Ukraine's borders, and we've seen how much that was worth when the bullets started flying. Given that Ukraine had non-alliance security guarantees in 2014 and in 2021, it does not seem like they would successfully repel Russian aggression. So how do we tie Ukraine to the NATO powers in a way that is genuinely credible and will be viewed by Ukrainians as a binding guarantee, but isn't article 5?
Trump's minerals deal eloquently cuts the Gordian Knot here. Russia doesn't have to agree to Western troops on their border, and it doesn't have to agree to NATO status, and it doesn't even have to allow for Security Guarantees. Instead, a big American mining concession in the Donbass, right on the border, acts as the tripwire. It doesn't look like enemy troops, but it serves a similar function. Russia isn't embarrassed, and Ukraine is protected, and Trump wets his beak. Brilliant.
Obviously the screaming match today seems to point in the opposite direction. But, we can pray. I hope that the conflict today was stage managed, keep in mind that both Zelensky and Trump are television stars by trade, with a mutual goal of ending the conflict on a just and lasting peace built around using American economic concessions in Ukraine to tie the US to Ukraine's security from Russia.
As someone who prays for peace each night, I hope we're seeing some deep, strategic diplomacy from the Trump administration to secure peace all without ruffling Russia's feathers, and allowing Putin to have peace with honor so as not to induce chaos. If Trump pulls it off, whatever else he does will be worth it. A very stable genius.
Curses, foiled again. Shouldn't have tried to reply from my phone.
All junk food outside the home. Fast food, sweets, baked goods, chip局的, ice cream,everything in that range. Wish me luck.
I've tried to do the alternative "do something" lents and they just end up weird, and last year I was sober but it was too easy and kind of against my current life goals.
I finished Sandman. I see why people loved it, but it's interesting reading a commercial serial with literary pretensions, you can see the plots become more interesting and long running as Gaiman had more leash to play from his audience and publisher. I started it as a result of the all the Neil Gaiman furor, people kept saying he was a genius and I thought gee let me check it out. Reading between the lines, one very clearly sees Gaiman's sexuality spelled out in the pages.
I'm wrapping up Where Men Win Glory, Jon Krakauer's bio of Pat Tillman, which I'd started last fall and then forgotten at my parents' house. It is a favorable biography, just short of hagiography, but I nonetheless find myself disliking Tillman. I should like him: he was an athlete, a reader, a striver. But I find myself so frustrated with Tillman! Krakauer writes off his high school assault charge, which Tillman maneuvered with his lawyer to get out of by cleverly hiding it from the colleges he was recruited by to get a scholarship offer, then present to the judge that he had a scholarship and if the judge didn't have mercy he would lose the scholarship. Krakauer never grapples with how to square this with Tillman's emphasis on honesty with regards to personal values and straightforwardness in relationships. Tillman gets credited with turning down a massive contract to change teams so he could stick with the Cardinals, who proceeded to bench him; Krakauer presents this as an unconcern with money, I see it as annoying stupidity and weakness, letting the billionaire's take advantage of you. Tillman joining the Rangers was admirable, as was his written opposition to the conduct of the wars, but I'm once again frustrated by him. His decision to join as a grunt instead of an officer mirrors, exactly, the decision made by one of my best friends to join the Marines. Tillman was, of course, killed by friendly fire, my childhood friend was permanently traumatized after being caught in a "friendly" artillery barrage for hours. Knowing my friend, I always wondered if he would have wound up so fucked up if he had gone in as an officer, because he was such a brilliant competent guy. But he wanted to, like Tillman, go in as a grunt, go in to fight, and as a result they lost everything. It's a similar dynamic to turning down money to change teams, self-victimizing out of a misguided sense of honor. I'm getting to the end of the book, which is clearly going to be a second-by-second breakdown of the day Pat died, followed by the fallout. I'm curious to see if I get anything out of it all.
It's interesting realizing that Krakauer's assumptions are a little different, in 2009, than ours are today. He wrote just after Obama's first election, when there was still a feeling that the GWOT and its accoutrements were reversible. It turned out that they weren't, or at least that no one was much interested in doing so. Obama would disappoint his anti-war supporters, and constant overseas deployments in semi-legal wars and police actions are now a fact of American life, accepted by everyone to varying degrees.
Appreciate the thoughts and prayers. I'm telling myself this is the worst part, in that I'm no longer totally lost so just surviving isn't doing it for me, but I'm not actually winning much. My hope that a bunch of even newer guys would sign up for new year's resolutions was frustrated, most the classes I show up for I'm just on the bad end of a game of smear the queer when we get to rolling. But every now and then I catch one, so I'm getting better.
The severe, abused-victorian-orphan bruising has mostly stopped, so now my wife is more of a fan of what it's doing to my body,
Don't let falling behind on the plan discourage you! I've literally never perfectly completed a workout plan, I'm always too ambitious, but when I get to the end I'm stronger than I would be if I quit.
I'm assuming you're saying without special unique credentials, not without any credentials or ordinary education.
The answer is to work for government or other very large organizations and be willing to work below your true talent level. If you're a lawyer with a hypothetical true talent level of $400k/yr, and you're willing to take a secure job making $130k/yr that only requires half as much effort, those jobs are available. Ditto engineers, etc at different price points.
Great example from a field I'm not knowledgable in.
SCRIPT DRAFT: EAGLES TEAM PSA FOR EMPLOYMENT DISCRIMINATION
((Emotional, compassionate, deep voiced announcer))
Have you ever felt ignored? Felt invisible? Felt like people wouldn't give you a chance? [Images of rejection emails from jobs flash across screen]
Because you don't have any experience? [Montage of action photos of Jordan Mailata]
Because you had to change jobs? [Montage of action photos of Zach Baun]
Because you have a tough personality? [Montage of action photos of AJ Brown]
Because you were let go by your prior employer? [Montage of action photos of Mekhi Becton]
Because you were the wrong color? [Montage of action photos of Cooper Dejean and Reed Blankenship]
Because you had a criminal record? [Montage of action photos of Jalen Carter]
Because everyone else in your industry hates you? [Montage of action photos of CJGJ]
Give people a chance. Be a champion. Don't discriminate when you're hiring.
https://www.themotte.org/post/1146/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/256318?context=8#context
Evil Peak vs Evil Career Counting Stats
200 in a set is fucking monstrous. Good luck.
1-5 0
Special case: Generally $1 per drink, for coffee or alcohol, regardless of drinking it in or out of the location
6 20-25% for places I like, which is most places I go
7 $5-10
https://www.axios.com/2025/01/09/tesla-clean-credits-trump
It's less of their revenue than I thought, only around 5% anymore, but still makes up 43% of their profits for 2024, which is much higher than I'd think. We're talking about $2bn in 2024 and ~$10bn to date. It's not a small amount of money.
ETA: Probably the sentence would be more accurate as "derives much revenue" than "derives much of their revenue"
"Just remember the right one" isn't really advice 😂
I just never use either as a verb. Not worth the mental effort.
I'm never confident in this one, and just end up using impact instead.
This is one of those times when people's ignorance of history is actually important rather than a meme. Palestinians will never trust that displacement isn't permanent, that's sort of their whole thing. No Palestinian who gets herded into a camp in Egypt or Jordan would really expect a Right of Return, and they'd be stupid to expect it.
-
Much of their revenue and until recently all of their profit is based off of various government regulatory schemes for selling pollution credits to other automakers. Elon seems... Unlikely... To remove those particular government boondoggles.
-
They are genuinely amazing, class leading, genre destroying pieces of machinery.
-
People just think of it as investing in Musk. His stock is up, I'd imagine.
It's not so much never Trump Republicans as it is that the majority in the House is narrower than the number of total wingnutz who won't reliably agree to anything at all in the Republican caucus.
I loved this book. Gabo was a genius.
I think it would be easier to respond if you used concrete examples.
My basic response is that I don't like or dislike people primarily because of their politics, nor am I arrogant enough to think that the virtues I do rate people on inevitably lead to one political conclusion or another.
The Philadelphia Eagles will play the maximum four playoff games this year, and every single one of them has essentially the same analysis going into the game:
The Eagles are better at every positional grouping except QB and Coaching, and maybe some special teams positions. Analytically the Eagles should win, but you hesitate to have faith that the Eagles and Jalen Hurts will execute on gameday.
The Chiefs matchup in the Super Bowl is the mother of all versions of this matchup. The Eagles are better in every other position grouping except maybe D-Line and Tight End where it is a push but you might give the edge to the Chiefs based on playoff experience. But the Chiefs have the edge at Quarterback, and they have all-timers at Head Coach and DC, and they execute.
The Eagles have better Wide Receivers, possibly the greatest running back of all time, the best O-Line in the league, the number one defense in the league behind two DROY candidates in the secondary, a DPOY finalist at linebacker, and a gamewrecker in the middle of their D-Line in Jalen Carter. And it all might not be enough.
If you aren't sure who to root for, here's my rooting guide, pro for the Eagles and Con for the Chiefs:
Why you should root for the Philadelphia Eagles
Pro: No one wants to see the Chiefs win again. Every right-thinking NFL fan wants to see the Chiefs taken down a peg. In the long run, it will even be better for the Chiefs themselves: if they threepeat, there will be no mountain left to climb, we'll just hear about them as inevitable or whining about the refs; while if they lose, Mahomes and Reid will come back with a vengeance next year. While if the Eagles win, or if they lose, they won't win the division next year. Let's see some variety.
Con: We Are All Witnesses. We have the chance to see historic greatness, maybe the best to ever do it, in Pat Mahomes and Andy Reid and Travis Kelce and Jones and all the rest. You only get to see this kind of thing so often.
Pro: The Eagles are incredibly likable. Saquon ran across the field to congratulate his backup on scoring. They fight through injuries for each other. The next man up will always come in and play.
Con: The Chiefs might be annoying because of the incessant advertising, but as the new GOAT, they'd be replacing Tom Brady and Bill Belichek's Pats, who were just ontologically evil. So it's an upgrade in the record books.
Pro: An Eagles win is likely to be a more exciting game. The Chiefs are going to score 24-30 points, it is inevitable. So an Eagles win will likely mean each team scoring five or six times. While a Chiefs win will likely be the same nonsense of Pat Mahomes pulling some nonsense out of his ass and winning by two points. I got so bored of every Chiefs game this season, it felt like one of those Marvel schlockfests where the hero faces down a vast army of enemies, but you know he's going to win so there's no dramatic tension. Let's see something different. The Eagles represent a different way of building a team: where most teams are built from the QB out in recent years, the 2024 Eagles are built around a superstar O-Line and a great running back. Let's see teams pursue more running backs, and fewer teams tanking for QBs.
Con: But people like Marvel movies. People like watching Quarterbacks play hero ball. You're going to see a Chiefs win in which Mahomes does something crazy no human being should be able to do. When Jalen Carter tries to pick him up, Mahomes is going to throw the ball thirty yards for a touchdown to Travis Kelce. Give the people what they want. Then we're going to spend the off-season debating when the play should have been dead.
Pro: If you like Eagles fans, you'll get to watch them go nuts. If you don't like Eagles fans, there will be fewer of them after the celebration.
Con: Chiefs fans are genuinely midwest nice.
Pro: E-A-G-L-E-S EAGLES
Con: Huh?
Does Believing in Big Conspiracies Cause Small Conspiracy Theories, or Do Small Conspiracy Theories Cause People to Believe in Big Conspiracies?
Or: Why the Fuck is Luka a Laker?
I’ve always thought that one of the primary philosophical values of athletics is that it is a direct connection to capital R reality, in a way that is otherwise possible to avoid for many people. When I was in law school was when I got really serious about weightlifting, for the same reason that a lot of my friends got very into drinking: 1L year is a hell of feeling unmoored from any evidence of how you are doing. Traditionally, as my school did things, you have no feedback until finals. You are working all day every day studying, but you only really ever get tested on it in a cold call, which more depends on your professor’s mood and style for how it goes than it does on how good you actually are. And you might only get cold called ten times a semester anyway across all your classes. You’re working constantly and you have no real idea how you’re doing. But, as Henry Rollins put it, The Iron Doesn’t Lie to You. You can lift the weight, or you can’t. So I got really into the Olympic lifts. The Snatch, the Clean and Jerk, the Clean and Press (I’m old school). The numbers went up, or they didn’t, every day in my notebook. And if they went up I could feel good about myself, regardless of the fact that I was sure I was going to fail CivPro (I didn’t). Lifting weights, or running, or biking, gives you instant feedback on where you stand. You have a number you can pin your ego to, a baseline reality. You can lie about it, you can cheat, but you’re only cheating yourself: you know you’re a fake. In law school I needed that anchor to reality to keep me sane, to keep me from getting lost in my anxieties about things that I could not have knowledge of or control over.
Competition of course, is the ultimate reality check. I’ll confess to having become a bit of a hermit in my workout habits over the years. I have a very extensive home gym setup, the only time I worked out socially was the occasional climbing trip. Switching to BJJ has gotten me obsessed with fitness in a way I haven’t been in years, in that every time I go to the gym I’m getting my ego crushed. I’m getting dominated, submitted, and that’s reality: there was nothing I could have done to stop it. But, the victories are as real as the defeats. I can feel myself improving, and when I get a minor win, it means nothing it’s just a casual roll in a suburban strip mall in Eastern Pennsylvania, no one gives a shit. But it’s real, it happened.
And I think that athletics are necessary for that reason: they provide a tie to reality. There’s a reason that the study of decision making in economics has come to be known as Game Theory: you create a circumscribed ruleset for competition and use it to model greater decision making. This has value both in personal practice of athletics, and in the greater world of spectator sports and athletics. Moneyball taught more people about statistical analysis and strategy than any textbook. Sports are the one real thing on TV, you watch it and something happens, or it doesn’t. Your team wins, your team loses. This is important in that it keeps people grounded, it tells people things about reality. It teaches kids growing up to accept defeat, that sometimes the breaks beat the boys, that sometimes bad things happen. Sport was so important to national and ethnic pride, to civil rights movements, over the years, because sporting success is an inevitable fact. Jesse Owens and Jackie Robinson and Jack Johnson were, and remain, so important because he went on the field and did it. When they went in against whites and won, the lie that no black man could do that was untenable. There was no denying that reality. Trans competitors in girls' sports has been such a controversy, not because anyone gives a damn about the purity of high school girl's track, it's because it is undeniable. Contact with reality. Black and white.
Unless, of course, the product on the field is fake. The ultimate crime against the public, as Fitzgerald put it:
"Fixed the World Series?” [] The idea staggered me. I remembered, of course, that the World Series had been fixed in 1919, but if I had thought of it at all I would have thought of it as something that merely happened, the end of an inevitable chain. It never occurred to me that one man could start to play with the faith of fifty million people--with the singlemindedness of a burglar blowing a safe.
Then sport becomes just another case of one’s emotions being manipulated by some power on high.
I bring all this up in reference to the recent blockbuster NBA trade that came out of nowhere over the weekend. In the middle of the night on Saturday, the Dallas Mavericks chose to trade Luka Doncic to the Los Angeles Lakers for Anthony Davis and a 2029 First Round Pick, plus some spare change going around. This trade is so off the wall that many people assumed that the reporter who first put it out had been hacked. It simply makes no sense by standard NBA strategy: normally a team will never part with a top-5 player in their prime like Luka under any circumstances. If they did choose to trade a guy like that, then the team would accept that their current project was torpedoed and sell everything for future value, young players and draft picks to build the next great team. The Mavericks did neither: they got older and worse switching from Luka to AD, without acquiring any high end draft capital to help them build in the future. They lost a potential all-time talent, a face of the franchise and the NBA, a player who had just lead them to the NBA Finals as a number one option last year; and in exchange they got a slightly worse player several years older. It makes no sense. Writers call it The Dumbest Move I’ve Ever Seen. The Lakers have a player who virtually guarantees them a competitive team for the next ten years, and for it they gave up an aging star who was a key piece on a championship team five years ago, but didn’t look likely to win one this year.
And inexplicably, Mav’s GM Nico Harrison didn’t try to shop his player around at all. The players involved heard at the same time everyone else did, from a twitter account they thought had been hacked. Luka bought a house in Dallas less than a month ago. Players around the league reacted with shock. Fans are apoplectic. Had Luka been shopped, it is likely that Dallas could have stocked their team with bright young players and future picks to build a juggernaut years from now. A package vastly better than AD and change. They chose this very specifically. Leading many fans to ask why?
Conspiracy theories popped up immediately. From the mundane, Luka is injured or Luka is about to be MeToo’d or Luka fucked the owner/GM’s wife. To the more baroque: the Mavs chose to make this trade at the behest of TPTB within the NBA, who wanted their marquee franchise in LA to get a fresh star with the LeBron era winding down. Send the best young player in the league, and certainly the best looking most photogenic and charismatic player in the top ten, to the traditional top franchise in the league. The Mavs perfidious new owners, the (((Adelsons))) went along with this because they want to move the team from Dallas (a small market I guess?) to Las Vegas, and they needed to destroy the franchise and its fanbase Major League style in order to do it.
And that made me wander: do conspiracy theories filter up or trickle down? Does one start with a conspiratorial worldview and paranoid style and jaded cynicism because Epstein Didn’t Kill Himself and then decide the NBA is probably fixed too; or does one start with thinking the NBA is fixed and it shakes your faith in everything else? I’ve noticed the conspiracy theorists I know tend to be into personal conspiracy theories too. The same guy that’s telling me the Marines just raided a FEMA data center in Iceland to get the files about the 2020 election will tell me that the mechanic slit the rubber on his CV boot so that the mechanic could charge him to fix it. I wander, if one polled /r/nba fans, what would the correlation be between believing that the Luka trade was fixed and believing in RussiaGate?
Now we reach another question where Sports is a low-stakes microcosm of life: assume that the uproar was so severe that it actually threatened the legitimacy of the league. That so many fans were so convinced that the Luka trade was fixed by the NBA, that it threatened to ruin the NBA’s ratings and destroy the fanbase. Assume also, that it isn’t true, that Nico Harrison really just thought he was that much smarter than everyone. You are the NBA commissioner. Do you exercise your power to rescind the trade, in order to preserve the appearance of fairness, or do you allow it to go through, knowing that it will create the appearance of unfairness?
I love cats and grew up with them hanging around the barn, raising stray kittens and giving them away. My only solution to mice is getting a cat. I don't think having a cat is inherently feminine.
But working breed dogs and ones relationship with them are inherently and classically masculine.
Moreover, Israel is reliant for its suffrage on a moral system that such actions would undermine. Israel exists and is tolerated in large part because of Western guilt over antisemitism and the Holocaust, a belief in the idea of self determination for ethnic minorities. The moment those beliefs disappear in the USA and the west, so does Israel.

End Orwellian Langauge: It's the Department of WAR Not Defense
Niall Ferguson writing in WSJ this Weekend posits "Ferguson's Law" (conveniently named for another Ferguson) which states that:
Or more concretely, as to debt level:
Ferguson is concerned that the USA has recently crossed this threshhold:
He goes on to offer historical parallels: Habsburg Spain, Great Britain in the twentieth century, Bourbon France. All countries that, according to Ferguson, failed to keep their defense spending high enough
Leaving aside the wishy-washy verb "risks" (isn't any Great Power at risk of ceasing to be a great power 100% of the time always? Give me a quantifiable degree of increase in the risk!), what really stuck in my craw, as I read the essay, was the term "defense."
As used by Ferguson, it seems to refer to military spending, broadly defined to include things like intelligence and infrastructure. The problem is that referring to Charles V and Phillip II's series of misadventures in Habsburg Spain as "defense spending" is insane, or so deeply credits the viewpoints of the early modern Habsburgs that it amounts to insanity.
Charles V's wars were fought against France, against Muslims and Turks, against various Dutch, German, Protestant, and Spanish/Catalan rebels, and of course in his name wars of conquest were fought from what is now Latin America to the Pacific. His heir Phillip II would continue to fight all those foes, and add England to the list in a series of disastrous attempts to reconquista the newly Protestant island of his one-time erstwhile Tudor betrothed. Ditto the wars of les rois Louis XIV-XVI, the scheme of Richelieu and the wars of empire against England across the globe, that produced the debts that brought down the Bourbons. These were wars fought over trade, over succession crises on foreign thrones, over complex webs of alliances, over religious affiliations.
To be fair, I do hold the theory that virtually all wars we perceive as naked acquisitive wars of conquest in human history were, in first person view of the conquerors, justified in some way by religious or moral precepts. Rome "conquered the world in self defense;" Age of Exploration Europeans perceived themselves as spreading Christianity; Alexander justified attacking Persia by pointing to Persian invasions of Greece. Even Genghis seems to have justified his conquests with references to insults given to Mongol caravans and embassies or to ideas of sacred horses and sky gods granting universal sovereignty to the great Khan. The line between "self-defense" and "acquisitive conquest" is thin and faint and difficult to locate in the moment.
But we as historians, as economists, as political theorists, as assholes arguing on an internet chatroom, are not constrained by the first person interpretation of events through propaganda. We can interpret things as they are, and not as we imagine them to be. We need to distinguish between the act of self defense and wars of choice. Which turns into the game of determining each nation's proper aspirations, a trap of impossible proportion. But surely in theory we can agree there is some line between defense and aggression.
Which brings us to Ferguson's present case: the United States of America in the 21st century. The problem of confusing wars of choice with defense spending makes Ferguson's Law a rule that can be invoked in favor of anything a policy maker wants. My question for Ferguson: did the Iraq and Afghan wars bring the USA closer to or further away from compliance with Ferguson's Law? On the one hand they represent increased military spending, on the other they increased debt load. But looking closer, they had nothing to do with defense, and decades later we can see that they advanced no policy goals of the United States. So would Ferguson say that we should do more military adventuring abroad to increase defense spending, or less to reduce debt load? Is aid to Ukraine salutary, in that it is a relatively cheap way to achieve global military goals? Would a new Pacific navy be positive or negative?
The core problem here is the conflation of Defense with War, a problem created in 1947 when Congress changed the sensibly named Department of War and Department of the Navy into the Department of Defense. The Founders, in their wisdom, created those departments, intuiting that the Army would fight on the continent and the Navy would handle overseas foreign policy, primarily the protection of trade ("the shores of Tripoli"). The Department of War is logically named: it deals with war. The Department of Defense is obfuscatory: it assumes that wars are defensive, not offensive. It frames the question wrong, and obscures the reality of what the Army is for and what it is doing.
It reminds me, rhetorically, of the joking debates in my BJJ gym. The professor frequently talks about the "self defense" implications of different jiu jitsu moves, and in general we all kind of giggle about it, because the culture of the gym just isn't guys who get into a lot of fights. One of the other guys at the gym, when told to avoid shooting for a single leg on concrete, noted that his favorite "self defense" move was to either run away or to draw a gun. Robert Drysdale in a recent podcast appearance discussed how there were in his view four types of BJJ ability: Gi, NoGi, MMA, and Self Defense, in a discussion of who were the best competitors of all time. The host joked that it was difficult for anyone to be "the best" at self defense, as "the best" self defense would obviously be to avoid fights altogether. So they settle on "street fighting" or something like that as a better definition, but Drysdale points out that there's something artificial about a lot of the classic Brazilian fight videos that the Gracies built their reputation on: everyone sort of formed a circle, and the fight was one-on-one with no one interfering. Both combatants were constrained by customary agreements, by threats from law enforcement, by the goodwill of the spectators. So it's less "no rules" and more its own customary set of rule for fistfights, which might or might not hold in any given time and place you get into a fight. To say nothing of how a guy who is an expert in "self defense" may use it as license to behave aggressively, knowing they can't be held to account.
All of which is to say, we need to RETVRN to tradition and make it the Department of War again. We need to think clearly about what it means to defend this country, and whether the pursuit of imperial hegemony aids that defense or undermines it, both fiscally and materially.
More options
Context Copy link