FtttG
Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.
User ID: 1175
Danny Boyle's Steve Jobs, penned by Aaron Sorkin, was a transparent attempt to recapture the magic of The Social Network, Sorkin's earlier film about a brilliant tech entrepreneur whose arrogance and single-mindedness ends up compromising his relationships with his loved ones. It was slated on release, but I thought it was actually quite good, with an interesting narrative structure, great performances all around and some clever cinematography to reflect the passage of time. What was lacking compared to the earlier film was the propulsive force of Nine Inch Nails's score and a strong narrative through-line: Steve Jobs just ended up feeling too episodic for the audience to feel consistently engaged throughout. Each of the three "acts" could have been broadcast as an instalment of a three-part miniseries without compromising the emotional effect one iota.
LA Confidential might be in my top ten movies of all time (definitely in terms of the number of times I've watched it). But I've always considered Training Day a terribly overrated film. Denzel deserved his Oscar, but I don't know that the film has much else going for it.
Ireland's presidential election is this Friday. The Irish president (Uachtarán na hÉireann) is a ceremonial role which wields no actual power, but the incumbent is expected to serve as the ambassador for the nation. The office is currently occupied by Michael D. Higgins, who became something of an icon both nationally and abroad owing to his short stature and white hair, lending him an elfin/leprechaun appearance. (My mother thinks he's a closeted homosexual in a lavender marriage.) Higgins is coming to the end of his second term, for which the term limit applies.
This election cycle has been something of a shambles. Lack of coordination at the nomination stage has resulted in a meagre ballot of three candidates, half as many as the last election in 2018:
- Heather Humphries, Fine Gael
- Jim Gavin, Fianna Fáil
- Catherine Connolly, independent
After several presidential debates, Gavin unexpectedly dropped out of the race, but with too little notice to have his name taken off the ballot. It'll be interesting to see what happens if he secures a majority. It's rather surreal seeing the election posters for a candidate who's already taken his hat out of the ring dotted around the city.
I know very little about any of the candidates beyond their party affiliation. Connolly is apparently intensely proud of the fact that she's fluent in the Irish language and has made it a major plank of her campaign. My opinion of her instantly soured when she argued the reason the Irish electorate rejected the "durable relationships" referendum was because they didn't understand it. There are few things I find more insulting than condescension: people understood it perfectly well, which is why they rejected it. [EDIT: mea culpa, it was actually Humphries who said this, not Connolly.]
The poor showing of candidates and controversy over the nomination procedure (particularly concerning Maria Steen, a conservative activist who sought the nomination) has resulted in many voters announcing their plan to deliberately spoil their ballots in protest, with a recent poll suggesting as many as 6% will do so.
As for me, I'm mainly just breathing a sigh of relief that the name "McGregor, Conor" doesn't appear on the ballot.
Met police drop all charges against Graham Linehan's tweets on trans issues.
On the one hand, good. On the other hand, this was sort of inevitable, and the process was probably intended as punishment: if they can cow him into silence without formally charging him with anything, that's cheaper and more efficient for them.
More interesting is that this article also claims that the Met police will stop investigating NCHIs (non-crime hate incidents) because they are too subjective and ambiguous. Kind of amazing that a Western police service is openly announcing "we will stop investigating things that even we ourselves do not consider crimes and return to only investigating crimes", but here we are, I suppose.
Linehan is planning to sue the police for wrongful arrest, and more power to him.
I'll be sure to send you a DM.
Last night I rewatched one of my favourite psychological horror films, The Mothman Prophecies, with which I developed something of an obsession during Covid. Still holds up, even on probably my ~fifteenth watch. I've ordered the book on which it was based, curious to see how it compares.
Okay, I know I said I wouldn't change a thing, and yet I did bristle a little at the culture war aspects.
But for all that, it didn't sully the emotional impact of the book for me one iota.
it was the worst book I've read in the past.... 10 years?
Try reading the aforementioned Doxology and come back to me.
The Japan analogy doesn't work, because there is no active anti-Japan resistance due to Japan having already made amends and settled the conflicts those crimes took place in.
Lies. Japan denies culpability for its assorted war crimes in the second world war to this day.
but I did actually go out and protest against the Iraq war which 9/11 was used to justify.
It's amazing to me that you consider this a relevant analogy. The entire reason the invasion of Iraq wasn't justified was because the Iraqis weren't responsible for 9/11. It was a ginned-up casus belli. The Palestinians were responsible for October 7th. Do you really not understand how these two situations are incomparable, or are you just pretending not to?
Hell, right now the Israeli government is proudly bragging about how they tortured Greta Thunberg
Dying to see a source on this one.
Wow, what heartening news! Thanks for the pick-me up.
So you claim that your preferred solution is for a single-state solution in which Israel is renamed to Palestine. And yet, it cheers you up to learn that lots of people want the Israelis to pack up and move elsewhere. Why would that be the case, if it isn't your preferred solution? Dare I say you're not being entirely truthful about what your preferred solution is?
You may as well ask jews in the 1940s if Nazi Germany has a right to exist.
Of all the obnoxious rhetorical strategies pro-Palestine activists use, Holocaust appropriation must be the most distasteful. Other Arabs are a far bigger threat to Arabs than Israel has ever been.
But even leaving aside the relative death tolls, the reason this analogy doesn't work is because, prior to the Nazis, relations between Jews and Germans were fairly cordial, as evidenced by the fact that there were hundreds of thousands of Jews living inside Germany at the time. But Arabs hate Israelis now, and also hated them in 1948, before Israel had even been founded (back when they were just called "Jews"). You claim that Arabs hate Israelis as an inevitable consequence of decades of mistreatment, but they already hated them before any of this mistreatment. Am I supposed to pretend that this is just a coincidence? As ever, I find myself irresistibly drawn to the conclusion that this is an ethno-religious conflict dressed up as an anti-colonial one.
Some time ago I read an article talking about how literary publishing is experiencing something of an extreme Pareto distribution: every year, one book becomes the literary book that everyone is reading, to the point that its sales completely dwarf the sales of every other literary book published that year. In 2022, that book was Gabrielle Zevin's Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow, which a family member (I think my sister) gave to me some years ago and which I started reading earlier this week.
I'm as surprised as anyone to find that the hype is entirely warranted.
Seriously — of the 27 books I've read from start to finish this year, this is the best I've read so far and it's not even close. (I was only about a third of the way through it when I started to think it might achieve this accolade.) The last time I remember being so affected by a book was when I read Kazuo Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go in February of 2023. When I woke up this morning I was on page 236, and when I picked it up this afternoon, I found that I simply couldn't put it down, tearing through the remaining 242 pages in three sittings and finishing it all of ten minutes ago.
It concerns two childhood friends who reconnect as Harvard undergrads in the mid-nineties and, with the help of one of their dorm-mates, decide to design a video game together. As a gamer it was of particular interest to me, but even my family members who don't game enjoyed it, so don't let that put you off.
Tender, moving, perceptive, topical, gorgeous. The three main characters are so vividly drawn, I feel like I know them personally. I don't think I'd change a thing. I will be thinking about this book for quite some time.
Funnily enough, about a decade ago I attended a talk by Brenda Romero, an American game designer. (You might have heard of a certain project her husband John designed.) She was talking about a board game she'd designed as an art installation called Train. One of the characters in Tomorrow... designs a video game with a broadly similar premise, to the point that Romero publicly accused Zevin of plagiarism. I can certainly see the parallels, but it seems possible that it was a coincidence: even when Romero was describing the premise of Train I thought it sounded a bit trite. Creative works using the "actually it was the Holocaust all along" twist often come off as cheap and manipulative, and that's coming from someone who used exactly that twist in a short story he wrote (come to think of it, I was about the same age when I wrote it as the character is when she designs her video game).
Working much better today.
Thank you for all your tireless work Zorba, you really are the unsung hero of this space.
Watched Les Diaboliques from 1955, having heard it described as a psychological horror.
If it was made today, it would be called a psychological thriller, not a psychological horror. Well shot, well acted, well edited, but alas I called the twist ending in every detail about an hour in, meaning the remaining ~forty-five minutes were just an exercise in killing time. Check it out if you're less genre savvy than I am.
Interesting, I've never heard someone refer to it as their favourite of his films before. For me, there are definitely parts of it that work, while other parts felt like a slog.
Hanania has a response in which he argues that, while female-dominated institutions may not be sufficiently devoted to truth and consistency, neither are male-dominated ones.
Last night I rewatched Lost Highway, having not seen it for years and having recently heard it described as a psychological horror movie (which is certainly not how I remembered it). Having watched it a second (third?) time, my thoughts on it are largely unchanged and pretty much the same as everyone else's:
- The first forty minutes or so, before Balthazar Getty's character is introduced, are as atmospheric and chilling as anything else in Lynch's filmography (especially the first scene with Robert Blake), to the point that they overshadow the rest of the movie. This section is the only part of the movie that can be described as "horror": everything after that is a noir pastiche or a psychological thriller.
- Robert Loggia steals every scene he's in. They should show the tailgating scene in driver's ed, it would get a great laugh.
- Lynch was attempting something big and ambitious here, and didn't quite pull it off. He attempted something similar in his follow-up Mulholland Drive and had more luck there (I might even put that movie in my top ten). It's hard to put my finger on why Mulholland Drive is so much more effective than Lost Highway. It might be because all of the silly slapstick scenes in Mulholland Drive are near the beginning, whereas in Lost Highway they're in the middle, after forty minutes of steadily escalating tension and paranoia, which is tonally jarring. Both films involve
characters transforming into other people , but in Mulholland Drive Naomi Watts is the leading woman throughout: havingBill Pullman suddenly become Balthazar Getty without explanation robs us of the sense of psychological continuity we'd have if it had beentwo characters portrayed by one actor. And four years later, Lynch had learned that the only thing worse than using a Rammstein song at the dramatic climax of the movie is using the same Rammstein song twice.
My main takeaway from this movie is that, in her youth, Patricia Arquette was fucking gorgeous. She has several nude scenes in this movie, but even just in close-ups of her talking while fully dressed, I was utterly transfixed. Normally when a movie introduces a female character that we're supposed to find beautiful by lingering on them in slomo, I'm underwhelmed (particularly if they're played by, like, Drew Barrymore). In this case I had no trouble understanding why Getty's character would risk it all for her, even knowing that she's a violent gangster's moll.
Yes, and often getting 504 errors.
I saw this silly meme (/images/17607111449663641.webp) attributing lyrics to Taylor Swift that she didn't write.
By coincidence, my brother sent me the actual song the lyrics came from and it's even worse than "Y'All Cowards Don't Even Smoke Crack".
I wouldn't be terribly surprised if the authorities just didn't want to get involved because, as the old saying goes, "just put all of them in a sack and randomly swing a bat at it, you'll always hit the right one". Not to mean that they all really did what was alleged, but that the extreme level of dysfunction in the general community made the accusations so plausible that most just didn't want to get involved in the mess.
When writing Chinatown, Robert Towne said he was partly inspired by a conversation he'd had with a Hungarian vice cop, who claimed that there were so many competing ethnic groups and dialects in Chinatown that the police had no way of knowing whether their interventions were helping or hurting the exploited — so their policy was to do "as little as possible".
Interestingly in real life, the trans woman who was murdered (in the film exclusively referred to by their "deadname" Barry) had previously been in a sexual relationship with one of their killers. They shot a scene for the film making this explicit, but it was cut.
It's now Spooky Season, for which I will be using these threads as an opportunity to write about scary movies I've (re)-watched over the next two weeks. If you've watched some good (or bad) horror movies lately, feel free to reply to this comment with your thoughts.
Last night I watched Snowtown, a dramatisation of a series of vicious murders which took place in Salisbury North (a suburb in the greater Adelaide area in South Australia) between 1992-9. Going in I was expecting a horror film: what I got instead was a social realist crime drama in the vein of Shane Meadows, which is more interested in kitchen-sink scenes of people smoking in grotty tract housing than the mechanics of murder and body disposal. The violence, on the rare occasions it's shown onscreen, is excruciating, but like Meadows, most of the film's copious discomfort comes from the implied threat of violence, when the ringleader John Bunting seems superficially friendly and yet there's a constant lurking sensation that he might blow his top at the slightest provocation.
Recently, notorious child rapist and former rock frontman Ian Watkins was murdered in prison. I'm not unhappy he was killed, and yet some of the crowing over his death and how he got what was coming to him makes me uncomfortable for some reason I found it hard to put my finger on. Perhaps the most provocative scenes in Snowtown depict John Bunting and his neighbours sitting around a kitchen table discussing their frustration with the authorities' refusal to properly deal with sex offenders and child molesters in the area, and how they ought to take the law into their own hands. And indeed, many of Bunting and co.'s victims were people he claimed were paedophiles and child molesters (also homosexuals and at least one trans woman, though the film doesn't dwell on this quite as much), often on the basis of extremely flimsy evidence or baseless hearsay. The obvious implication is that Bunting had extremely violent urges which he rationalised away by claiming that he was channelling them into pro-social ends, but that when the demand for "paedos" exceeded the supply, he simply invented new ones. Paedophiles, homosexuals, trans people and junkies were seen as deserving targets in the social milieu in which he lived, so he targeted them: raised in another environment, he would've targeted communists, apostates, witches, whatever.
The less obvious implication (and I have no idea whether the historical record would bear this out) is that one reason Bunting and his gang evaded capture for so long is not because they managed to intimidate anyone aware of their crimes into silence, but because they managed to persuade them that all of their murders were really vigilantism, meting out "justice" to those deserving.
I've long had a soft spot for Rockstar Games' controversial stealth/survival horror title Manhunt from 2003. The premise of the game sounds like it was tailor-made to get Jack Thompson's knickers in a twist (to the point that even some of Rockstar's own staff found it objectionable1). You play as an inmate on death row called James Earl Cash who has his execution faked by a mysterious benefactor, who then forces Cash through a gauntlet of urban environments patrolled by violent gangs actively hunting for him. Cash is hopelessly outnumbered, so must resort to the game's core mechanic of "executions": he can sneak up behind gang members and stealth-kill them with a melee weapon, whereupon the camera shifts to a grainy pseudo-VHS perspective. For, you see, Cash's benefactor directs snuff films (for which purpose he's installed CCTV cameras all around the city), and wants Cash to be his "leading man". And these films aren't just a way of making ends meet, but very much a "passion project" for the director: if Cash murders a gang member in a particularly gruesome fashion, he will commend Cash in his earpiece, or even moan orgasmically. (The fact that the director is portrayed by the wonderful Brian Cox lends him a great deal of seedy charisma.) And in spite of the PS2-era graphics, many of these executions remain positively revolting to watch, aided by the game's impeccable sound design.
It's a tremendously fun game that makes you feel tense and anxious while playing it, then dirty and ashamed afterwards, aided by the game's meta, self-referential qualities (the player character is being "controlled" by an overweight creep sitting in the dark in front of a computer monitor, who orders him to viciously murder people for no better reason than his own sick amusement — no prizes for guessing who he's meant to represent). I've played it several times before, but always on the normal (or "Fetish") difficulty, for which the UI includes a circular "radar" which shows the position of gang members in your vicinity, which way they're facing and how alert they are. I'd read that this radar is disabled on hard ("Hardcore") mode, which I assumed would make the game practically impossible (even "Fetish" is plenty challenging). I recently completed my first playthrough on "Hardcore" mode, and I quickly realised that it's the purest way to play the game. It's not a "deconstruction" of stealth-based games, but it's clearly aiming for a more grounded, down-to-earth approach to the genre than is typical (and it still feels refreshing to play a survival horror game with no fantastical or speculative elements whatsoever). Cash isn't a Sam Fisher or Solid Snake with an array of hi-tech gizmos at his disposal: he's just an ordinary guy thrust into a situation beyond his understanding, with nothing to guide him but his wits and whatever weapons he can get his hands on (you kill your first enemy by smothering him with a plastic bag, and even in the late game shards of broken glass are invaluable tools). Without the radar, you have to proceed cautiously and play close attention to the direction the enemy chatter is coming from, just as Cash would. It's a very effective means of putting the player in his shoes, and makes an already tense and stressful game positively nerve-wracking. Highly recommended if you've never played it before, and a suitable game for spooky season. But if you're trying to persuade your loved ones that video games are more than disgusting exploitative "murder simulators" — well, maybe don't show them this one.
1 "It may sound surprising, but there was almost a mutiny at the company over that game. It was Rockstar North's [the Scottish branch of the company] pet project — most of us at Rockstar Games wanted no part of it. We'd already weathered plenty of controversy over GTA3 and Vice City — we were no strangers to it — but Manhunt felt different. With GTA, we always had the excuse that the gameplay was untethered — you never had to hurt anybody that wasn't a "bad guy" in one of the missions. You could play completely ethically if you wanted, and the game was parody anyway, so lighten up," Williams writes.
"Manhunt, though, just made us all feel icky. It was all about the violence, and it was realistic violence. We all knew there was no way we could explain away that game. There was no way to rationalize it. We were crossing a line."
I had heard of it before, but using "watermelon" in reference to pro-Palestine types seems overwhelmingly more likely.
Actually, you appear to have misinterpreted me
No, I know what you meant. But I think the way you phrased it was telling in a way you perhaps didn't consciously intend.
Are you going to sit here and claim that Israel has never committed any war crimes prior to October 7th?
No, of course not.
The USA has also committed lots of war crimes. If, the morning after 9/11, a bunch of people staged protests against the US, it wouldn't be untrue for them to defend the decision to do so on the grounds that, while the US may have been the victim of a horrendous terror attack the day before, that doesn't negate the fact that they have committed war crimes in the past. And yet, I can't help but feel that the kinds of people who would protest against a country the morning after it has suffered a terrorist attack are motivated more by hatred of that country (and support for the people committing terror attacks against it) than by a desire to raise awareness of war crimes.
If this particular analogy doesn't achieve the desired effect - supposing the morning after the tsunami in Japan in 2011 in which thousands of Japanese people were killed, I immediately staged a protest against Japan in which I made repeated calls to "globalise the anti-Japan resistance". Somebody points out to me that this is a bit tasteless considering that this country has suffered a horrendous tragedy literally the day before. I defend myself by pointing out that Japan has committed war crimes in the past. This is unassailably true (Nanjing, Unit 731). And yet, wouldn't the timing rather suggest to you that I'm motivated more by hatred of Japanese people than by an innocent desire to raise awareness of Japanese atrocities?
There are a fair few people who protest against the fact that Israel exists at all, but those are usually the ultra orthodox jews who believe that the creation of the Israeli state is in violation of the Torah.
I don't believe that the majority of people opposed to the very existence of Israel are Orthodox Jews. Moreover, I don't believe that you believe it either.
For example, an outright majority of young Britons think Israel should not exist. A different poll of the same age group found twenty-one percent say it does not have the right to exist. A majority of young Americans believe that Israel should be "ended" and given to the Palestinians. Combining half of young Britons and half of young Americans gives you 18 million people, which is already significantly more than the total population of Jews in the entire world (never mind the subset of those who are Orthodox). And that's just the young people in two countries. Do you really think that if I surveyed literally any Arab country "does Israel have a right to exist?", a majority of respondents would say yes?
If you're as committed an anti-Zionist as you say and you've been to as many of these protests as you claim, I'm extremely confident that you're familiar with the saying "Israel does not have a right to exist", or descriptions of Israel as an illegitimate "made-up" state and so on. I'm equally confident that when you heard people making such proclamations, 100% of the people who did so were not Orthodox Jews. I don't believe that you believe what you're claiming.
I'd make sure that whatever I did, there wouldn't be gigantic protest movements against my country all over the world.
Your phrasing is very telling. Whatever I did. Because I really do get the distinct impression that whatever Israel does, people will be condemning it.
The gigantic protest movements against the country in question had begun in earnest less than a week after October 7th, well before Israel even had the opportunity to commit any war crimes. In New York, there were protests and calls to "globalise the intifada" literally the day after. (The less said about the people at these protests chanting "Allahu akbar" and "gas the Jews", the better.)
Call me crazy, but it kind of seems like at least a significant proportion of these protests have nothing to do with how Israel's military conducts itself, and more to do with the fact that Israel exists at all.
I'd honestly love to be proven wrong and learn that the Hind Rajab and Mohamaed Bhar stories were just a bad dream
The fact that individual civilians were killed in a conflict does not prove that said conflict was a genocide. Even the fact that individual soldiers committed war crimes during a conflict doesn't prove that said conflict was a genocide. Pro-Palestine activists think they're helping their case by claiming that every civilian death is evidence of genocidal intent on Israel's part. But because civilian deaths are a feature of every war (especially wars in densely populated urban centres; especially especially wars in densely populated urban centres in which belligerents deliberately hide among the civilian populace), all you're doing is collapsing the distinction between "genocide" and "urban conflict" by carelessly conflating the two. Twenty years ago, the word "racist" was a potent one indeed and people would react to the accusation with indignation: after a generation of woke people abusing it to refer to any behaviour they don't like (no matter how innocuous), there are now plenty of people who react to the word "racist" as if you'd called them a meany doo-doo head. Do you really think it's a sensible idea to do the same thing to the word "genocide"? Because that's the way it's headed. Do you want more genocide? Because that's how you get more genocide.
But all that's almost beside the point. I don't think you looked at the facts on the ground of the current conflict and dispassionately concluded that Israel is conducting a genocide. I strongly suspect that if I'd asked you the same question on October 6th 2023, I would've got much the same answer. You're citing examples of Israel killing civilians in the current conflict, not because they support your argument, but simply because of the availability heuristic. Israel was being accused of "genocide" from the morning of October 8th, 2023, before the war had even begun in earnest; a bunch of Hollywood celebrities signed an open letter condemning Israel's military action in Gaza as genocide in 2014; I'm sure I can go back to the 2000s, the 1990s, even further and see the same accusation lobbed against them time and time again. (The first sentence of the Wikipedia article on the topic bluntly states that Israel has faced this accusation without reprieve literally from the day of its founding.) You explicitly compared Israel to the Nazis and demanded the state be "denazified", but the difference is that the Holocaust actually saw a meaningful (and steep) decline in the global Jewish populace. Strange, isn't it, how the Israelis have been accused of genociding the Palestinians for the better part of a century, and yet the Palestinian population only ever increases over time? It's the Shepard tone of genocides — which is to say, not a genocide at all. How many genocides can you name in which the genocidaires came to a dead stop as soon as the people they were genociding agreed to release hostages?
You apparently expect me to simultaneously believe that the vastly technologically superior, limitlessly bloodthirsty and nuke-equipped Israel isn't pulling its punches and is in fact doing everything in its power to exterminate every last Palestinian from the face of the earth — and yet are somehow so incompetent that they've failed to wipe out a technologically inferior opponent who almost entirely reside right on its doorstep? I'm sorry, but I cannot believe both of these things. It is beyond me.

To slate:
More options
Context Copy link