FtttG
Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.
User ID: 1175
Yes, I'm familiar with the phenomenon you're describing, and the fact that at least some white people in certain industries think their careers would stand to benefit by attempting to pass themselves off as non-white people shows how far the pendulum has swung in the opposite direction. More recently, Philip Roth wrote a novel about a black man whose career in academia can be at least partly attributed to successfully passing himself off as Jewish, which was widely (and apparently erroneously) believed to have been inspired by Anatole Broyard, a mixed-race writer and critic who died in 1990 and who passed himself off as white.
I'm curious if the phenomenon still exists in the "non-white -> white" direction, as opposed to its modern incarnation of "white -> non-white". Given the online circles in which I move, I hear about just about every example of a white academic or activist who gets exposed for pretending to be non-white, or a white teenager who "identifies as" trans-Korean or similar. It's possible that the reverse case may be equally common, but I just haven't heard of it because I'm in an echo chamber.
Now that's a blast from the past.
So far as I'm aware, every prominent recent example of a person openly identifying as transracial or being exposed as a racial charlatan (in the sense of trying to pass themselves off as a member of an ethnic group they're not, by subterfuge) has been a white person. The canonical example is of a white female academic, activist or politician who presents herself as Latina, Native American or more rarely black, in order to secure a job which is explicitly or implicitly ringfenced for members of such groups. But they don't seem to be doing this cynically, as an expression of their contempt for subaltern ethnic groups. In essentially all cases of note, the person in question seems so socially progressive and steeped in post-colonial theory that they almost seem to wish they really were members of these ethnic groups, and so they're playing an elaborate game of Butlerian performative declaration (clap your hands if you believe): announcing that they are members of these ethnic groups makes them so.
Is there a corresponding trend, for non-white people to identify as white, or try to deceitfully pass themselves off as such? And I'm not talking about implicitly (e.g. Indian women using skin-lightening creams), but explicitly the way white progressives do.
See this Quillette article on how the symptoms of "long Covid" are so variegated that people who claim(ed) to have been suffering from it may have simply been using a topical buzzword to describe the ordinary ennui, malaise, tedium and frustration attendant to modern life. It has not escaped my notice that the demographics most likely to claim to suffer from long Covid are the same demographics most likely to
- claim to suffer from all manner of contested illnesses
- earnestly support "self-diagnosis" as a concept
- claim to suffer from vague mental illnesses such as anxiety, depression and/or "trauma"
Moreover, he notes that a survey produced by Body Politic Covid-19 Support Group, a prominent driver of the Long COVID idea, indicates that “many of the survey respondents who attributed their symptoms to the aftermath of a COVID-19 infection likely never had the virus in the first place. Of those who self-identified as having persistent symptoms attributed to COVID and responded to the first survey, not even a quarter had tested positive for the virus. Nearly half (47.8%) never had testing and 27.5% tested negative for COVID-19. Body Politic publicized the results of a larger, second survey in December 2020. Of the 3,762 respondents, a mere 600, or 15.9%, had tested positive for the virus at any time.”
I'm being a bit cheeky here, because on both occasions I had Covid, I uncontroversially had long Covid symptoms: in the first instance a persistent sore throat, in the second instance an extremely phlegmy cough, both of which persisted for months after the acute symptoms went away. But the key differences are a) my initial dose of Covid (and I think also my second) was confirmed via antigen test; b) the symptoms I was reporting were extremely specific (as opposed to impossibly vague constructions like "fatigue") and c) the second instance of long Covid went away after a GP prescribed me an inhaler and a course of antibiotics.
Perhaps related, the NHS reports that the two demographics most likely to present with Munchausen's syndrome are women aged 20-40 (often with a background in healthcare) and unmarried men aged 30-50: https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/conditions/munchausen-syndrome/overview/
WebMD reports that it's more common in men than women, but doesn't provide a source: https://www.webmd.com/mental-health/munchausen-syndrome
An interesting journal article about malingering, Munchausen's syndrome, Munchausen's by proxy and Munchausen's by internet: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3510683/
I wonder if this has anything to do with slave morality as described by Scott: https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/matt-yglesias-considered-as-the-nietzschean
If Scott is correct that slave morality ultimately derives from Christianity, then perhaps the phenomena you're describing (pathological guilt, scrupulosity, fetishization of victimhood) are common to any culture in which Christianity is or was the dominant ideology for some sufficiently long period of time. This would have predictable effects: maybe if we compare countries which were forcibly converted to Christianity within the last two hundred years vs. countries which have been Christian for over five hundred years, we would see higher support for antinatalism, higher support for radical environmentalism, higher incidence of "contested illnesses" like Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, chronic fatigue syndrome, chronic Lyme disease and similar.
From a cursory inspection, most of the countries in which literal self-flagellation is still practised seem to be in Asia, regardless of whether the practitioners are Christian or Muslim. This suggests that local factors (i.e. culture-bound syndromes) might play a larger role than religion.
I'm afraid I can't say much that would be of use to a third party. I don't really know how I became more disciplined, I just know that I did.
But I think a big component was setting myself long-term goals which I'd publicly pre-committed to by setting them for myself as part of a group. During Covid I got into running, and a couple I know suggested that the three of us sign up for a marathon. I decided to do it. I think the fact that it was a group activity made a big difference: if I'd just privately signed up to do it myself I wouldn't have lost face if I'd decided to back out after a few weeks of training.
First Reformed was brilliant.
Saturday was November 30th, the last day of NaNoWriMo. I made it, 50k words in the bank.
I am both very surprised and quite proud I didn't give up partway through: I've become a far more disciplined person than I used to be. While it was a busy month, I was pleased to find that it wasn't a gruelling chore throughout: while there absolutely were days when it felt like pulling teeth, even quite late in the game there were plenty of passages which I found quite fun to write.
Sunday was a well-earned Sabbath day. As I mentioned, I realised quite early on that the story I'd envisioned would not fit inside 50,000 words, and right now I'm feeling like a first draft will be as long as 80k, or even 90. My plan is to write at least 1,000 words a day during the week and take the weekends off (unless inspiration strikes). At that rate I should have a first draft by the middle of January, or the end of the month at the latest.
Every time Trump has been accused of nepotism (e.g. the Jared Kushner appointment) or of abusing the power of Presidential pardons for nepotistic reasons (Kushner's father), Democrats are implicitly appealing to said agreement.
You said that a President pardoning someone isn't hitting a defect button.
If two teams have agreed not to use the power of Presidential pardons for illegitimate purposes, then if one team goes ahead and uses them for that purpose, that team is defecting.
What did Jim do?
If you haven't already read it, I think you will enjoy this article: https://www.firstthings.com/article/2023/10/we-are-repaganizing
I'm sure what you're saying is true, but do you have a source?
It's incredible. Even his father didn't have nearly as much hair at that age.
But I think it's fair to say that it's highly questionable for the President to use that power to prevent his loved ones from facing legal repercussions for misconduct. If the presumption that it's illegitimate for a Republican President to do such a thing, but legitimate for a Democrat President to do it, that is a defection.
Ah, correct on both counts: probably the main reason that so many tech companies (Google, Meta etc.) have their EU headquarters in Dublin (along with the English-speaking populace). Interesting.
He considers Ireland's market reforms a model and wants to go even farther, so that Argentina's the freeest country in the world.
This is fascinating, did he mention which specific reforms he was referring to?
What's yours?
Obviously the Kennedys held the mantle during the period in which they were the preeminent political family in the states, and probably the Clintons as well.
The story above, coupled with:
-
Trump's weird habit of openly lusting over his own daughter
-
Trump's ex-wife accusing him of rape
-
Trump's second wife almost certainly being unfaithful to him
-
Trump's current wife's obvious distaste for him
-
Trump paying a porn star to have sex with him, along with his numerous other extra-marital affairs during at least two of his marriages
-
Trump Jr. getting embroiled in a messy divorce and custody battle
He shouldn’t have said he wouldn’t pardon him but that’s not actually what he said, was it
The president's decision to pardon his son is a sharp reversal from months of vows from the White House and Biden himself that he would not use the power of his office to benefit his family. After his son was convicted in his gun case, the president said he would "abide by the jury decision. I will do that and I will not pardon him.”
"Spite" may be an appropriate emotional reaction in certain situations, in the sense that it was what we would expect the average person to reasonably feel in that situation. That's quite a ways from saying it's the virtuous emotional reaction. The whole point of virtue as a concept lies in recognising that many times our instinctual emotional reactions to situations are both morally wrong and often counterproductive.
Not only is being spiteful not virtuous almost by definition, in many cases it's counterproductive from the perspective of pure pragmatism - hence the phrase "cut your nose to spite your face". It's an ugly and irrational emotion.
To give a simple example, if a criminal is breaking into your house uninvited in the middle of the night, then the virtuous thing to do is certainly to respond with malice.
Hard disagree. The virtuous thing to do in that situation is to defend yourself from home invasion using no more force than is strictly necessary (which, yes, can escalate into lethal force depending on the specifics of the situation). In the hypothetical situation in which you can point a gun at the criminal, force him to surrender and wait for the police to take him away, what do you stand to gain by using additional force beyond that?
The malicious thing to do would be to maim the criminal breaking into your house and then sadistically torture him for hours on end. Your immediate response to hearing someone breaking into your house in the middle of the night should be concern for your and your family's welfare, not "oh goody, now I have a blank cheque to be as vicious and cruel as I please!"
"Bullshit - if someone breaks into my house, beating the shit out of him is a totally understandable, even reasonable response." No argument here. We're not discussing what's understandable - we're discussing what's virtuous. The standards are higher, by design. I can't even truthfully say that this is a standard of behaviour I would succeed in meeting in the heat of the moment - but this is a failing on my part, not a failing of the moral standard I've set myself.

I don't think there's anything remotely unique, novel or threatening about long Covid. Sequelae for the flu were known to be a thing for decades before Covid. It's just a rhetorical tool pro-lockdowners only invoke while moving the goalposts when the more relevant metrics aren't producing the desired results.
It's one thing that really annoyed me when arguing with people who were in favour of prolonging lockdowns indefinitely. When Covid death rates started to decline, pro-lockdowners would inevitably resort to "but what about muh long Covid???"
Having gone through it twice now, my response to that is "yeah, it's a bit annoying. Is preventing it worth shutting down the entire country and throwing thousands of people out of work indefinitely? No, obviously not." (Even assuming that NPIs which throw thousands of people out of work indefinitely are even effective at preventing it.)
More options
Context Copy link