@FtttG's banner p

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/


				

User ID: 1175

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

					
				

				

				

					

User ID: 1175

Maybe this is just the availability heuristic, but it does seem to anyone else that the two major political families in American politics (the Trumps and Bidens) are two of the most uniquely toxic and dysfunctional families in the US? This would sound contrived if it happened in a soap opera.

This was intended to be a lengthier comment but my phone posted it before I could finish it. I replied to you with a full comment.

Hunter is known to have fathered at least five children. The first three of these he fathered with his first wife, the youngest of whom was born in 2001. The fourth he fathered illegitimately in 2018 with a former stripper, denying paternity until a paternity test proved otherwise, followed by a court ruling. The fifth child he fathered in 2020 with his current wife.

I have a hard time imagining that Hunter is terribly present in the life of the girl whose father he denied being and whose mother had to sue him for paternity (as noted elsewhere in the thread, said daughter was pointedly not invited to Biden family events), so if he'd gone to prison I can't imagine said daughter would've noticed. I agree that his youngest daughter with his current wife probably would have felt his absence. But as upsetting as it is for a young child to have a father behind bars - is it so much more upsetting than having a father who's addicted to crack cocaine and unexpectedly disappears for weeks at a time to go on crack binges and have sex with prostitutes? Sort of sounds like much of a muchness to me, to be honest. There's even the possibility that a short spell in an environment in which crack cocaine is markedly harder to come by than outside might have straightened him out by forcing him to go cold turkey.

Finally there's the point about Hunter providing for his children financially, to which my only response is a high trill of gay laughter. Whether Hunter had gone to prison or not, I think we all know that, either way, his children would have been financially provided for by their grandfather, not their father. Hunter has been a wastrel for his entire adult life, and I don't think even he would dispute that whatever gainful employment he's had (e.g. his seat on the Burisma board) came about purely as a result of his family connections.

But even in the counterfactual world where Hunter had his shit together and was capable of providing for his minor children on his own merit and was a positive role model for all of them - either his crimes are serious enough to warrant jail time, or they aren't. This seems like "one death is a tragedy, a million is a statistic" - why is the welfare of Hunter's children being elevated to being a point of material concern in whether or not he should serve jail time, and not the welfare of the children of all the other people who've been convicted under the same laws he's deemed to have violated?

Hunter has three children from his first marriage, the youngest of whom was born in 2001. He has two young children, one from his current marriage and the illegitimate child he fathered with a former sex worker. This comment got posted prematurely, the full comment is here.

ensure his family has a future

I'm curious what you mean by this. Pardoning Hunter ensures his family will have a future?

Why should a father not protect his son when he is able to?

A father should protect his son when he is able to - when the son is a child. Even if Hunter was in his early twenties, it'd be a lot more understandable if Joe pardoned him - sowing your wild oats is what youth is for. But Hunter is 54 years old and has been a fuckup and prodigal son for essentially his entire adult life. Tough love has to come into effect at some point.

especially for a crime as minor as tax fraud

One of the crimes Hunter was indicted on was providing false information when purchasing a firearm, namely lying when asked if he was a drug user. "Crack cocaine addicts should not be carrying guns" seems like a rare gun control policy proposal that I could imagine a lot of 2A diehards getting onboard with. Given Joe's outspoken support for gun control (e.g. his support for the federal assault weapons ban of 1993; his longstanding support for universal background checks; the Bipartisan Safer Communities Act, which he signed into law two years ago), this makes his leniency all the more hypocritical.

There's something heartwarming about the party that has recently been so obsessed with procedural norms and maintaining the moral high ground learning that there are, in fact, situations where a strict literal interpretation of the norms should be suspended. This may be more of a tactical consideration than a purely ethical one, because it helps Republicans illustrate how absurd the prosecution of Trump has been.

I see nothing heartwarming about this naked hypocrisy and corruption. Espectially seeing as, contrary to your interpretation, I have zero confidence that this pardon will prompt reflection among Democrats and they'll realise "you know, maybe it's more about the spirit of the law than the letter, perhaps we should be more forgiving when the Republicans overstep in future". No - the takeaway from this will be, as always, "it's okay when we do it".

It's an appropriate parting "fuck you" to a political establishment that conspired to replace him without his consent in the 2024 election.

It's weird that I specifically asked you why you think this action was "virtuous", and part of your answer is, in essence, that was a wonderfully spiteful act of malicious revenge. Which is quite far from what I typically think of when I hear the word "virtuous".

Steven (nominative determinism) Gallant, a convicted murderer who, while on day-release, fought against the jihadi who carried out the London Bridge attack in 2019

How have I never heard this story before? This is incredible. What a redemption arc.

This was the virtuous thing to do.

Why?

The world needs more humans, and fewer bots who are governed by algorithms (even, and perhaps especially, when that algorithm is the algorithm for “justice”).

What a bizarre way of saying "there's no point in having rules or laws of any kind".

Would TheMotte really be here condemning Trump if he pardoned Don Jr. in a tax fraud case?

I would.

A tweet from June 6th:

Riddle me this MAGA: how has Biden weaponised the Justice Department if his own son is on trial and he's saying he will not pardon him if convicted? Your whole argument kinda crumbles, doesn't it? Embarassing.

A reply to this tweet, today:

Oh.

Sure enough, in his final month in office, Joe has pardoned Hunter, after repeatedly promising not to do exactly that. No less than the Guardian and the BBC are calling Joe Biden a hypocrite and saying that this latest action legitimises some of the criticisms Trump has lobbed at Biden.

A few weeks ago there was a discussion here on what Biden might do with his final few weeks in office to ensure his legacy, knowing that he'll never hold public office again. Negotiate a last-minute but inevitable peace deal in Ukraine, to snatch that opportunity from Trump's grubby claws? Recognise the Armenian genocide at last? Pass a bill mandating the creation of a new national park? Step down so that Kamala can legitimately claim to be the first female POTUS, if only for ten minutes?

I guess we have our answer as to what he'll do with his legacy: piss all over it, exposing himself as no less of a corrupt nepotist than Erdoğan.

This is fundamentally what men are doing with each other when they bond like this: they're accentuating the intimacy they feel for each other by demonstrating that they're so close and their bond is so tight, they can insult each other and engage in dominance behavior without any real threat.

Late to the party, but Scott refers to the phenomenon you're describing as "countersignalling". Essentially, "I trust you enough that I can insult you, knowing that you'll understand no real malice is intended and you'll take it in good humour". Zizek argues that ribald jokes of this kind are vital for defusing tensions between members of warring ethnic groups.

it would seem less than conducive to a healthy working environment to know that your colleagues consider you naturally predisposed to neurotic behaviour, by virtue of being a woman.

Any woman in the workplace already knows that her male (and female) colleagues believe this about her.

It's tangentially related, but I'd like to take this opportunity to share one of my favourite bits of linguistic trivia.

The Irish word for "President" is Uachtarán*. (The President is a largely ceremonial role: the leader of the country is the Taoiseach, the Irish equivalent of the Prime Minister in the UK and other countries with a Westminster-style parliament.) The word uachtarán was originally used for the chief of a tribe or village in pre-colonial Ireland. The President's official residence is called Áras an Uachtaráin.

When we had to learn Irish in school, we learned the words for cream (uachtar***) and ice cream (uachtar reoite**** - literally "frozen cream"). I always wondered about the connection between uachtar and uachtaráin, as they're obviously from the same root, but I only found out last year. Can you guess?

Uachtar literally translates as "top". It is used to refer to "cream" because the cream floats to the top of the milk. By extension, the uachtarán is the person at the top of the tribe/village/country.

*Pronounced "OOK-tar-awn".

** Pronounced "TEE-shuck".

*** Pronounced "OOK-tar".

**** Pronounced "OOK-tar ROW-it-cha".

hugbox incoming

I just want to say: I appreciate you guys. I spend so much time in this place that I sometimes forget what an aberration it is compared to the rest of the internet, by virtue of being a space which encourages honest good-faith discussion and penalises juvenile name-calling and consensus-building. Occasionally I'll step out into the wider world and be reminded of how unusual the Motte is in this regard. I got into an argument about JK Rowling on Facebook this evening with some dude I don't know, and after a couple of backs-and-forth he announced that, from that point on, any additional comment I posted would result in his estimation of my IQ decreasing by 5 points. I made a few additional points, and to each one he responded with the same comment - just "-5", over and over again.

"-5"

"-5"

"-5"

Such a bizarre way to behave. The NPC/Soyjak meme didn't come out of nowhere - people like that really exist. As good a reason as any to redouble my efforts not to get into arguments with strangers on the Internet, or at least not with strangers incapable of comporting themselves like adults. As bad as some people might find this place (particularly people whose opinions go against the local norms), I find it impossible to imagine someone here refusing to engage and simply taunting their opponent by robotically posting "-5" ad nauseum. And not even because the mods would put a stop to such immature conduct pretty quickly - I just think it wouldn't happen, full stop.

Yes. So? Both pop music (created by an ethnically diverse range of musicians) and hip hop (traditionally a black genre; black musicians still create the preponderance of music in the style) are extremely popular among white audiences.

In any case I’d imagine the most popular music among urban whites is generic pop music.

Much of which is performed by ethnic minorities (The Weeknd, Bruno Mars, Olivia Rodrigo, Rihanna, Shakira, Usher).

Obviously there's a strong correlation between one or more of an artist's various identity markers and the style of music they perform or its lyrical themes, but I don't think that implies that audiences are more likely to enjoy music created by people with whom they share identity markers. Jazz is a niche genre, but probably more popular among white audiences than black despite being a historically black genre; hip hop has been more popular among white urban audiences than country music for as long as hip hop has existed, and this was true even when hip hop was pretty much exclusively a black genre; K-pop is enormously popular among white girls and women; numerous gay musicians have found large followings among straight people and in some cases are even more popular among straight men than straight women (e.g. Elton John, Freddie Mercury of Queen, George Michael, Morrissey of The Smiths, Rob Halford of Judas Priest, Sam Smith, Boy George, Ricky Martin).

I bought a Fiio X3 about seven years ago, specifically because you can put an SD card into it and have effectively unlimited storage. If you're an audiophile, you can have thousands of FLAC files instead of MP3s. Not only does the audio player still work, its battery life barely seems to have declined at all and I still use it occasionally. (The main reason I don't use it as often as I used to is just because I don't listen to music as much as I used to.)

Depending on your preferred genres, most artists will upload their music to Bandcamp as well as streaming platforms. There's no subscription fee for Bandcamp, you just pay when you want to buy a release from a specific artist. If you buy a release, you can listen to it as often as you like via the Bandcamp app, OR you can download the release in your preferred file format (MP3 at a range of bitrates, FLAC, even WAV if you're feeling nuts) and upload it to your personal audio player.

I've never had a Spotify subscription and never intend to get one, firstly because as previously mentioned I don't listen to music very much anymore, secondly because I loathe SaaS on general principle, and thirdly, because for all the talk of it being a "great way to discover new music", everything I've read about it indicates that its suggestion algorithms work the same way as every other such algorithm: it shows you "new" artists which sound extremely similar to the artists you already like. Just because I like listening to Weezer doesn't mean I want to listen to Weezer knockoffs every day.

Plummeting fertility rates.

Day 27 of NaNoWriMo. Passed the 40k mark on Sunday, we're in the home stretch now, and all going smoothly I'll have 45k in the bank by the time I go to bed tonight. As ever it's a high-variance project: some days getting the words out feels like pulling teeth, other days it's a smooth and flowing process. Monday evening was probably the most fun I've had since the start of the month, I wrote a sequence which (in my view) was equal parts funny and sad.

I'm not sure if I understand the question.

Maybe your idea of "political material" is a vicious coke-addled rapist, with such a short temper that he has been convicted for physically assaulting a fifty-year-old man for the crime of refusing a glass of whiskey he offered him. It is not mine.

which implies he's part of some sort of organisation, which is definitely not progressive.

It's called a "gang".

But that would mean not watching Tár, which is perfect.

...

  • -10

I've read several of his, and yet my favourite is still the first one I read, which is also his normie basic bitch black sheep hit: Norwegian Wood, also a leading candidate for my favourite novel ever.

To quote the Wikipedia article on Blanchard's typology (which is generally sceptical of the concept, if not outright hostile to it):

Studying patients who had felt like women at all times for at least a year, Blanchard classified them according to whether they were attracted to men, women, both, or neither.[3]: 444  He then compared these four groups regarding how many in each group reported a history of sexual arousal together with cross-dressing. 73% of the gynephilic, asexual, and bisexual groups said they did experience such feelings, but only 15% of the androphilic group did.[8]: 10  He concluded that asexual, bisexual, and gynephilic transsexuals were motivated by erotic arousal to the thought or image of themself as a woman, and he coined the term autogynephilia to describe this.

From an interview with Blanchard himself in 2019:

When I looked at the relative numbers of autogynephilic and androphilic gender-dysphoric males back in 1987, the autogynephilic cases were already a majority, approaching 60 percent. The proportion had reached 75 percent by 2010, and it might be even higher now.

...

Examples I have collected include: sexual fantasies of menstruation and masturbatory rituals that simulate menstruation; giving oneself an enema, while imagining the anus is a vagina and the enema is a vaginal douche; helping the maid clean the house; sitting in a girls’ class at school; knitting in the company of other women; and riding a girls’ bicycle. These examples argue that autogynephilic sexual fantasies have a fetishistic flavor that makes them qualitatively different from any superficially similar ideation in natal females.

There is also the telling phenomenon of autogynephiles who are involuntarily aroused by cross-dressing or cross-gender ideation, and who complain about difficulties changing into women’s attire without triggering erection or ejaculation. It seems likely that few natal women would give the analogous reports that they wish that they could put on their clothes without triggering vaginal lubrication or orgasm.

Self-identified autogynephiliac trans woman Anne Lawrence, who has medically transitioned, wrote a book about autogynephilia called Men Trapped in Men's Bodies, in which she solicited the perspectives of autogynephiliac males and affirmed Blanchard's typology:

"I would simply like to state for the record that, based on my clinical experience and my reading of the scientific literature, I am firmly convinced that the overwhelming majority — probably 98% or more — of cases of severe gender dysphoria in men arise in connection with either effeminate homosexuality or autogynephilia; most of the rare exceptions probably arise in connection with conditions such as schizophrenia and certain personality disorders. The idea that substantial numbers of MtF transsexuals belong to a putative “third type” that is neither homosexual nor autogynephilic is inconsistent with my clinical experience and is, in my opinion, inconsistent with the best available empirical evidence..."

Scott's survey of his users found significantly higher rates of autogynephilia among trans women than among other groups. When asked the question "Picture a very beautiful woman. How sexually arousing would you find it to imagine being her [on a scale of 1-5]?", the mean response among self-identified trans woman was 3.2.

The highest rates of autogenderphilia were found in bi cis men (autoandrophilia), gay cis men (autoandrophilia), bi trans women (autogynephilia), and lesbian trans women (autogynephilia).

(Scott goes on at length about what it would mean to be a male person who is sexually excited by the thought of oneself as an exceedingly handsome male person, or vice versa. I will freely admit I still have no idea what this entails in practice.)