@FtttG's banner p

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/


				

User ID: 1175

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

					
				

				

				

					

User ID: 1175

For years, I believed the trans-inclusive narrative that trans women were "women born in the wrong bodies" i.e. if one were to conduct an MRI or CT scan of a trans woman's brain, it would more closely resemble a typical female brain than a typical male brain. I subsequently learned that this claim (breathlessly signal-boosted by many trans activists) originates from a single Dutch study from the 90s which compared brain tissue from deceased trans women and found that it more closely resembled female brains than male. However, this study was hopelessly confounded by the fact that all of the trans women in question had been taking female hormones for years, meaning we have no way of knowing if their brains looked like that from birth or only as an effect of taking hormones. The study has never been replicated, and even some prominent trans activists have admitted that it doesn't really tell us anything one way or the other. I assume if more persuasive evidence had come along since, I would have heard about it. Until that day comes, I'm defaulting to the null hypothesis that trans women's brains look exactly like what you'd expect a male brain to look like (or perhaps what you'd expect a male autistic brain to look like).

When I was an undergrad, I believed the standard feminist line that male and female brains were essentially the same; all observable differences in behaviour, interests, habits of mind etc. were solely attributable to socialisation; and the belief that there might be real natal differences between the typical male and typical female brain amounted to "neurosexism".

I believe that in her prime she’s arguably the most beautiful woman to have ever lived

Apparently a demon in the sack as well.

Until a few years ago, I was operating under the misconception that the total number of non-Jews (homosexuals, the disabled, Slavs etc.) murdered in the Holocaust was somewhere in the region of 5 million. I subsequently learned that this figure was invented from whole cloth for propaganda purposes, and the real figure is significantly lower, perhaps by as much as an order of magnitude.

(Not interested into getting into a debate about what this misconception of mine might imply about the accuracy of other Holocaust-related figures - you know who you are.)

During Covid, I believed that many of the more authoritarian measures imposed on the Irish populace with the ostensible goal of slowing the spread of the virus (in particular, vaccine passes, without which one couldn't gain access to a pub or restaurant) were the first step in the government's rollout of a police state modelled on the CCP or the US's PATRIOT ACT.

All of these measures have since been abolished and no one has had to present proof of vaccination against Covid for any reason in years. I still think these measures were a legitimate cause for concern at the time of writing, and the current sitting government make little secret of their post-Covid authoritarian aspirations (e.g. the incredibly sweeping "hate speech" bill, comparably restrictive as the recent piece of Scottish legislation, which would make it a criminal offense to have an "offensive" meme saved on your phone even if somebody else sent it to you, and which passed in the lower house but has been languishing in the upper house for over a year). But my specific prediction that the vaccine passes would remain in place indefinitely, and their role slowly expanded until they functioned like an EU-wide ID card, turned out to be untrue.

Oh sorry for the confusion, I was referring to the stealth mechanic in In Sound Mind, not XCOM 2.

In vanilla XCOM 2, I agreed with Zero Punctuation that it's annoying that breaking concealment instantly makes every enemy on the map aware of your location until the end of the mission. It would have been nice if killing one group of enemies before another group arrives on the scene restored concealment.

including one that made timers freeze until stealth is broken

Agreed, this is one aspect of the base game that makes absolutely no sense and is blatantly a contrivance for gameplay's sake. That being said, it's hardly the only such aspect.

I don't entirely agree with this for reasons I can't fully articulate, but I'm nominating it for an AAQC anyway.

I got In Sound Mind as a free giveaway from Epic Games ages ago. I was hesitant about playing it because I was concerned it was one of these games that markets itself as a survival horror but is really just a walking simulator with periodic jump scares. The other night I started playing it around 11-11:30 and found it so absorbing that it was 1:30 before I stopped. Pleased to find it's emphatically not a walking simulator, but a real game with real mechanics. The pleasingly goofy premise is you play as a therapist who has sessions with his disturbed patients, and in order to resolve their traumas (and get to the bottom of the mysterious conspiracy at their root) you enter into surreal dreamscapes and defeat a boss. A bit like Psychonauts crossed with Silent Hill (or perhaps Alan Wake).

After spending several months trying to beat X-COM 2 on Classic difficulty, this is just the kind of game I'm in the mood for: enough of a challenge to be satisfying but forgiving enough not to be tense or stressful; spookily atmospheric but rarely actually "scary" (I've completed three dungeons and only the first one ever made me feel any degree of fright); puzzles which I don't require a walkthrough to solve 90% of the time; story which is well-written enough to be entertaining but which doesn't seem to take itself terribly seriously, like a 2000s psychological thriller (Secret Window, Identity) which is sort of aware of how silly its conceit is without fully lapsing into self-parody. The only criticisms I have of In Sound Mind so far are that the dungeons seem a bit padded with samey areas it's too easy to get lost in, and the inclusion of a stealth mechanic seems a bit half-baked and largely useless.

A question on voting. Ireland, where I live, uses the "single transferable vote" system. Irish people often favourably contrast it with the "first past the post" used in the UK. I was trying to explain the differences between the two to my girlfriend and illustrate the weaknesses of first past the post relative to STV. One weakness that jumps out even at a casual inspection is that first past the post massively incentivises tactical voting, which by extension likely gives a home advantage to incumbents. Are there any other significant weaknesses to first past the post? Conversely, are there any weaknesses to STV that make first past the post preferable?

A medical question. I've often heard it said that one is far more likely to contract HIV as a result of gay sex than straight sex. Is this statement true purely as a result of the incidence of HIV infections in the gay male community (i.e. the proportion of gay men who have HIV is vastly higher than the proportion of straight people) - or is there also a mechanical component that makes the virus more likely to spread via certain sexual activities than others? That is to say, supposing Alice and Bob both have HIV, and they've both had it for the same duration, neither are taking PReP. Is Carl more likely to contract HIV as a result of having anal sex with Bob than as a result of having vaginal sex with Alice? Moreover, if Carl had anal sex with Alice, would he have the same risk of contracting HIV as he would if he had anal sex with Bob? Lastly, does it make a difference who the receptive partner is - is Carl more or less likely to contract HIV from Bob if he's the bottom than if he's the top, or does it make a difference?

While I was nowhere near as big a fan of Hlynka as many of you were, he once wrote "Never write anything down which you wouldn't want to have read out at your funeral" which strikes me as remarkably good and universal advice.

Meanwhile, in the land of 'you got a loicence for that?' kids are required to have a car seat until they're 12!

Is this true? That's insanity. By the time I was 12 I was quickly gaining on my own mother in height.

Okay, rude.

It would be pretty funny if he got more write-ins than Kamala.

I think this checks out but someone else will need to check for me.

Before you are three closed, identical boxes. The first box contains two silver coins and nothing else. The second box contains two gold coins and nothing else. The third box contains two coins (one gold and one silver) and nothing else. You have no idea which box is which, you cannot see inside the boxes, and they are mounted to the wall so you cannot lift them to estimate their weight.

You reach your hand into one of the boxes and withdraw a gold coin. If you reach into the same box to withdraw the second coin, what is the probability that that coin is also gold?

It's 66%. You know that the box you withdrew the first coin from can't be the box with two silver coins in it, so it must be one of the other two boxes. There are exactly three coins remaining in these two boxes combined, one of which is silver and the others gold. Ergo the odds of you withdrawing a second gold coin are 2/3.

This puzzle was shared on a Facebook meme page I follow. I'm not trying to flex or anything, but I solved it instantly and the solution seems incredibly obvious to me. I was very surprised to see the comments full of people asserting that the answer is 50%. There's even a Wikipedia article about it, and it's referred to as a "paradox". One of my pet peeves is when the word "paradox" is used to refer to mathematical problems with counterintuitive solutions, or counterintuitive findings from the sciences - as opposed to contradictions in logic. Russell's paradox is a legitimate paradox: there is no good answer to the question "if a barber only shaves men who do not shave themselves, does he shave himself?" The "twin paradox" in general relativity isn't actually a paradox, but I can see how it runs counter to our human intuition of how things work in Mediocristan. But in this case, I don't think this particular puzzle even rises to the level of "mathematical problem with a counterintuitive solution": the solution seems incredibly obvious and straightforward. The word "paradox" gets used far too freely.

Likewise!

around the “fertility crisis”

Why the scare quotes?

Still waiting for the day he comes out onstage and launches into a spirited rendition of "Weird McDonald's Rap".

Okay, thanks for clarifying, I see where you're coming from. I apologise if I came off as hard-headed or combative, that wasn't my intention and people tell me that's how I tend to come off when discussing all sorts of topics, not just politics.

A quick Google returns a dozen articles like "Republicans suggest that testosterone may have made Hale more violent - here's why they're wrong" (followed by a begrudging acknowledgement in paragraph 15 that testosterone does in fact make more people more aggressive - in other news, water is wet). I'm unable to locate any hard evidence on whether the shooter was taking it though.

Has it been confirmed that Hale was on testosterone? Many trans men (and cis men, for that matter) have reported a major spike in aggression and hostility after taking it (as was the subject of an AAQC from last month). It certainly seems like the most obvious explanation for why Hale went down this route, rather than acting out her despair and frustration in a more typically feminine way (anorexia, self-harm, suicide attempts).

At the time, I thought that even samples of Hale's handwriting gave the game away that he was really a woman.

But credit where credit is due: he seems to have nailed the Rodgerian "sexually frustrated narcissistic incel with delusions of grandeur" mindset with aplomb. "Chicks only want to date dongoloids with huge cocks, unlike Nice Guys like me with average-sized dicks - it's not FAIR!!!" ingeniously substituted with "chicks only want to date Chads with cocks, unlike a Nice Guy like me who doesn't even have a cock - it's not FAIR!!!" Hats off.

Frankly, I think the two definitions of "woman" you're using (one commonsense and straightforward, the other postmodern and controversial) amount to a motte-and-bailey fallacy, and I don't like motte-and-bailey fallacies on general principle.

If you said "a woman is anyone who identifies as a woman", I would think that definition was incoherent and circular - but at least I'd know exactly what you meant when you used the term "woman" in conversation. If you said "a woman is a person with female reproductive organs", I would likewise know exactly what you meant whenever you used that term.

But if the single word means both of those things, then that gives you a blank cheque to jump back and forth between the definitions on a whim according to the needs of the moment, depending on who you're trying to persuade and what rhetorical point you're trying to make.

It also makes the basic act of communicating a nightmare, because if I want to communicate honestly without misleading anyone, I have to laboriously explain exactly which definition of "woman" I'm using whenever I make a statement like "women cannot impregnate people" (true according to the second definition, false according to the first), "all women should undergo regular breast cancer screenings from the age of X onwards" (true according to the second definition, except for the minority of women who have already undergone a mastectomy; a complete waste of time and medical resources for many people if we're using the first), "in post-pubescent pre-menopausal women, amennorhea is a cause for medical concern" (true according to the second definition; false according to the first, as that set includes many perfectly healthy members who are physically incapable of menstruating), "women are dramatically less physically strong than the strongest men" (true according to the second definition; if using the first definition it would be false, because that set includes many members who would be competitive in tests of strength against men, by virtue of being male). And if someone were to insist that both definitions are equally valid, but refused to specify which definition they were using at any particular moment, I think it would be reasonable to conclude that, at best, they hadn't really considered the implications of using a single word with two such radically different definitions (as the examples above illustrate); at worst, that they had considered this and were knowingly trying to sneak something past me.

Compare with some of Scott's examples when he popularised the concept: does "God" refer to a specific Abrahamic deity, or is it just another word for the order and beauty in the universe? Is "racism" just an unconscious bias which can't be fully controlled and which everyone is guilty of to one extent or another; or is it prejudice + power (ergo anyone who's not white conveniently can't be guilty of it, except Asians for some reason)? I dunno, maybe for all of the above examples you'd say "it means both of those things", but at some point I think you'd have to acknowledge that there's something a bit underhanded about the whole rhetorical technique, regardless of to what end it is aimed.

The Goldfinch came out in 2013, she's already overdue!