@FtttG's banner p

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/


				

User ID: 1175

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

					
				

				

				

					

User ID: 1175

Just FYI, that was a literal hypothetical question. I'm not personally aware of any strong evidence that the majority of medically transitioned trans people eventually regret their decision, although the increase in subscriptions to /r/detrans over time suggests that the rejection rate is higher than the most outspoken trans activists would have me believe.

If 50% regret it, I think I'd have to spend a few days seriously reconsidering my world view.

It takes a great deal of intellectual integrity to acknowledge that and I commend you for doing so.

Okay, well now it seems like you're just flipping between definitions according to the needs of the moment. This time yesterday you said "a woman is someone with a vagina" (or neovagina). Now you're saying a woman is someone you refer to as she/her, even if you know for a fact that that person doesn't have a vagina (or neovagina). I find this inconsistent. Maybe the idea is that the word can have multiple meanings, e.g. a woman is anyone who has a vagina, or anyone who has a neovagina, or anyone who has expressed a desire to be referred to with female pronouns.

But now we're right back to circular definitions! A woman is anyone who has expressed a desire to be referred to with female pronouns. What are female pronouns? The pronouns we use to refer to women and girls.

If Samantha goes on a rant about how people are transphobic for not dating her, just because she has a penis, I will think she's full of shit and making the rest of us look bad.

Well I'm glad to know we agree on that much at least.

The basic idea behind trans ideology is that sometimes you get a person, a trans woman, who is born as a guy. Despite this, they feel a strong desire to modify their body to have breasts and a vagina. When they modify their body in this way, they become much happier - it is one of the most successful medical interventions, on that axis.

I note that this is an empirical statement, not a normative one (like "adults have the right to modify their body however they please, and it's none of your damn business whether you think it's a good idea or not"). Hypothetically, if you were presented with persuasive evidence that the majority of trans women who fully medically transition later come to regret their decision, feel markedly less happy afterwards (according to, for example, a PHQ-9 or HAM-D survey), or feel that their quality of life has declined as a result of their transition - would that persuade you that trans ideology is a bad thing on net?

So I've heard. It's pretty funny that Tartt hated it so much that she fired her agent.

The basic idea behind trans ideology is that sometimes you get a person, a trans woman, who is born as a guy. Despite this, they feel a strong desire to modify their body to have breasts and a vagina. When they modify their body in this way, they become much happier - it is one of the most successful medical interventions, on that axis.

So, a woman is someone who prefers to have a vagina rather than a penis, and vice-versa. But of course "prefers" is really hard to confirm, so let us instead say: a woman is someone with a vagina.

Tada! Nothing circular, and nothing referring to any sort of immutable biology.

If "trans woman" was defined as "a male person who has undergone a surgery to change their penis into a neovagina", I think that's a definition I could get on board with: it's straightforward, non-circular and trivial to verify. Perhaps we could be even a little bit more generous and define it as "a male person who has undergone a surgery to change their penis into a neovagina, or is actively seeking one (has applied to the relevant medical practitioners etc.)".

I'd just like to gently point out that such a definition excludes almost everyone who identifies as a trans woman: only 5-13% of trans women have undergone genital surgery. Even if we allow that for every trans woman who has undergone genital surgery, there's another trans woman who has applied for it but is stuck on a waiting list (or even two such women), your definition still excludes anywhere from 61% to 90% of males who consider themselves trans women.

This is not intended as a "gotcha", it's a completely sincere question (echoing @Amadan, I'm genuinely grateful to get the input of someone with "skin in the game", so to speak). You're a trans woman who has medically transitioned. Supposing you're having a conversation with a visibly male person who has told you that her name is Samantha and her preferred pronouns are she/her. During the course of the conversation, the topic of medical transition comes up, you start talking about your own experiences, and Samantha mentions that she hasn't undergone bottom surgery. She also mentions that she has no interest in undergoing it and is perfectly happy with the configuration of her genitals as they stand.

Once she's made this clear to you, do you continue referring to her as a woman? Or no?

Thanks a lot!

Recommendations for a nice analogue men's watch under €200?

Amazon's Man in the High Castle was supposed to be anti-Nazi but it made Nazism look cool.

I had the same thought about Wolfenstein: The New Order, weirdly enough. Nazi-controlled London in that game looked substantially grander than the real London ever did.

This sounds like CCP-style state capitalism (which, for all its faults, is at least tremendously efficient) rather than communism either as historically practised or as envisioned by Marx and Engels.

My standard explanation is "in school or college, were you ever assigned at random to a group which had to complete a group assignment, and there was one person in the group who didn't lift a finger but got the same grade as you? Communism is that, but scaled up to an entire nation."

The obvious disadvantage of this approach is that some people might truthfully answer "no" to this question - because they were the freeloader. Not coincidentally, such people are disproportionately likely to endorse communism as a philosophy.

Where and when did I say any of these things

I actually had a Costanza "Jerk Store" moment

The French call it "l'esprit d'escalier".

  • A kebab, chips and Coke from the kebab shop around the corner, which for my money is the best kebab shop in the city.

Allow me to illustrate why I don't think it's appropriate to refer to your neovagina as a vagina.

The vagina is a sexually reproductive organ. Its purpose is to be used for procreation, and all of its key functions (sexual intercourse, delivering children and, indirectly, menstruation) serve that end. Our default assumption is that any nubile woman's vagina has the full range of functions outlined above. There are rare instances in which post-pubescent women are unable to get pregnant or menstruate, but these are properly considered as disorders in which the body is not functioning as intended for one reason or another. There are also menopausal women who once could get pregnant and menstruate but no longer can, but this is a normal part of the aging process as the body begins to break down over time. Finally, there are prepubescent girls who cannot yet get pregnant or menstruate, but we assume that they will if they have a normal development.

A post-op trans woman has a neovagina. This organ cannot be used for procreation, and this is by design. Unlike vaginas which never menstruated and which could not be used for conceiving a child at any point in their life cycle (which are a tiny minority of all vaginas), 100% of neovaginas don't menstruate or could even in principle be used for conceiving a child. Thus the purpose that a neovagina is meant to serve is entirely different from the purpose a vagina is meant to serve. The fact that they are in two entirely different categories of organ is plainly demonstrated by the fact that the failure states for the two organs are entirely different: if a trans woman's neovagina was bleeding for five days straight, that would be cause for concern and the person in question would be strongly advised to seek medical attention. If a cis woman's vagina is bleeding for five days straight (i.e. if she was menstruating), we would consider that "working as intended". When "working as intended" for one organ looks like "malfunctioning" for another organ, I think it's plain to say we are talking about two different categories of organ. (By way of analogy, a cyclist must expend energy and calories to make their bicycle move: that's how a bicycle works. If a motorcyclist has to expend calories making their motorcycle move, it means something has gone wrong with it. You're not supposed to have to physically push your motorcycle to make it move - that's what the engine's for.)

In fact, if you believe that an orifice which can be used for receptive penetrative sex but which can't be used for procreation ought to be included in the set of "vaginas" (because a small minority of women can't get pregnant or menstruate), then I would argue that you already had a vagina from birth. Most of us would call it your anus, but if we're being this expansive about categories and the definitions of words, why not? You get a vagina, you get a vagina, everyone has a vagina! (Is this what the most terminally horny trans activists are getting at when they demand people to stop using the word "vagina" and use the word "bonus hole" instead?)

"That's totally different, faeces come out of my rectum." About that. Do you see how annoying and pointless this line of reasoning is, how it proves too much? A minority of women don't menstruate or can't have babies; ergo, all neovaginas (none of which can be used for menstruation or procreation) are vaginas. By the same token, a minority of women experience stool in the vagina; ergo, all rectums are vaginas.

If you assume everyone is bipedal and able-bodied, why all these requirements for elevators, and curb ramps for wheelchairs?

Jesus Christ, you know exactly what I'm getting at, stop playing dumb. I'm not saying "assume that everyone you meet is bipedal and able-bodied (and deny the existence of people who don't meet that description)"; I'm saying "assume that any given individual is bipedal and able-bodied, unless you have strong evidence suggesting they aren't". And likewise with a person's sex. What is so complicated about this?

Bathrooms are probably the part of trans activism I find least objectionable, so I personally am not going to get terribly bent out of shape about an emasculated male who looks passably female going into the ladies' bathroom or locker room. A few gender-critical people presented me with sources suggesting that abolishing sex segregation in bathrooms in a particular jurisdiction caused a spike in women being sexually assaulted, but I didn't look into it too deeply.

There's plenty of biological women in that category, so it doesn't really seem relevant

100% of neovaginas never undergo menstruation. Something like 3-5% of female people experience secondary amennorhea (i.e. they have gotten their period by the age of 16, but it's stopped for one reason or another). Somewhere in the region of 0.1% of female people never get their period. All menopausal women and prepubescent girls do not menstruate by definition, but once did or will in the future (a distinction I've made exhaustively clear). Moreover, amennorhea in pubescent or post-pubescent females is evidence of something going wrong with their bodies, and they are urged to seek out medical care; neovaginas not undergoing menstruation is them working as intended. It baffles me how you can pretend not to understand this.

Like, menstruation and child-bearing are pretty much defining features of vaginas - that's what they're for. I point out that literally zero people with neovaginas have ever borne a child or had a period, and all you can say in retort is "well a tiny minority of women can't have their periods either, so it's no big deal".

To return to an earlier analogy, surely you understand the difference between "a motorcycle which runs", "a motorcycle which was once running but which no longer runs because of damage to the cylinder" and "a bicycle which has been modded to superficially resemble a motorcycle, but does not actually have an engine attached (and anyway the wheels have been removed)".

"dilation must continue regularly for at least one year postoperatively." I would hardly call that "the rest of their life."

"The frequency required to use [a dilator] decreases over time, however remains obligatory lifelong." (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vaginoplasty)

Not to mention that vaginal stenosis is potentially congenital: https://www.nationwidechildrens.org/conditions/vaginal-stenosis

So, again, all trans women are required to use a dilator for a significant period (possibly indefinitely) after undergoing bottom surgery. A minority of female people (possibly as few as 1%, according to Wikipedia) are required to use a dilator in order to treat a specific medical condition (which can often be treated by methods other than dilation). Ergo, there's nothing strange about including males in the category of "women". Okay.

Sorry, but when you're telling me that my definitions of the words "woman" and "female" are wrong and I should be using your definitions instead (and our definitions are mutually exclusive), I am absolutely going to pull you up on it when you start using words in a fashion which is not remotely consistent with the definition you yourself are advocating for. That's not pedantry, that's just consistency.

If you simply want to chide me for a minor slip in language... okay, fine. I'll go edit it since it's so incredibly important to you

I have never and will never be persuaded by passive-aggressive whining of this sort. It has no place here.

Ok, buddy, every old Oxbridge family just has superior genetics.

Definitely true in the UK, definitely not true in Ireland.

Finally finished The Goldfinch this evening. 6/10. Ending dragged on interminably which probably knocked a whole point off the score.

Granted, cutting off your dick and undergoing bottom surgery are meaningfully different concepts, but referring to the latter as "turning your penis into a vagina" might be putting things a bit generously. A more accurate description might be "turning your penis into a decidedly crude approximation of what a vagina looks and feels like, and which is markedly different from real natal vaginas in numerous ways - most notably in that a) it never undergoes menstruation and b) the immune system will treat it as an open wound, so it must be continually dilated for several hours every day, for the rest of the recipient's life, to prevent it from closing up".

All excellent points which I hadn't fully considered at the time of writing.

At least in the US, the male:female rape rate is somewhere near 1:1, maybe 2:1.

I have zero interest in addressing this until a source is provided. (Though I must say, I find it interesting that you're recycling manosphere/MRA talking points from a decade ago.)

It's a bit difficult to take gendered claims seriously, when you've cheated and used a definition that explicitly excludes female offenders.

I thought "female" just meant "anyone who looks like a woman, or who gets addressed as ma'am"? A definition which would include many trans women who haven't undergone bottom surgery, and who are hence perfectly capable of raping people? Sounds like you know exactly what "female" really means when it suits you.

And if you assume everyone is bipedal, you'll be even more "accurate"! You might get extremely confused by people in wheelchairs, but hey, what are 80 million categorization errors between friends?

(Because, you do realize, 1% of the population is... 80 million people?)

You're putting words in my mouth, trying to act as if "assume that everyone you meet possesses this trait unless given good reason to believe otherwise" and "deny the existence of people who don't possess this trait" are synonymous and interchangeable. It's obnoxious, tiresome and you should know better.

In point of fact, we do already assume that everyone we meet is bipedal and able-bodied: that's why when (for example when making a job application) many employers will ask if you require any special accomodations because of your disability status. The default assumption (borne out by statistics) is that the standard job applicant is bipedal, able-bodied, sighted, able to hear etc. The reason these accomodations are "special" is because, by definition, most people don't need them.

If we didn't assume that almost everyone is bipedal and able-bodied, when building new houses and office blocks, why would we bother building stairs as part of the new construction?

why are we going around checking for uteruses and gametes?

We check uteruses and gametes only when we are presented with strong evidence to suggest that a specific person who looks female or claims to be female may not in fact be a typical member of the female sex (or may not be a member at all). If a couple wants to have a baby, they just start trying to get pregnant right away: they don't go to the hospital first to get an MRI to confirm that the female partner has a full complement of functioning reproductive organs. They only go to a fertility doctor if they are facing difficulties getting pregnant i.e. once they are presented with evidence that might point to at least one partner in the couple not possessing a full complement of fully functioning reproductive organs. The tests to determine whether or not this is true are intended to provide more information than can be gleaned from the naked eye (e.g. you can't just glance at someone and determine that they have an irregularity in one of their fallopian tubes), but are subject to false negatives and false positives just like any other medical test. And yes, I absolutely would believe that the rate of false results (categorisation errors) associated with these tests is higher than the rate associated with the informal heuristic in which we assume that anyone who looks female has a full set of reproductive organs.

In fact, now that I think about it, this is just extremely basic Bayesian reasoning. Employers assume that all applicants are bipedal, able-bodied, sighted etc. unless given relevant information (walks with a cane; disabled sticker on their car) which suggests otherwise, at which point they update their priors. The medical establishment assumes that a given female-looking person of a certain age has a full complement of functioning reproductive organs, unless given relevant information (has been trying to get pregnant for a year without success; looks female, but in fact has a penis) which suggests otherwise, at which point they update their priors.

Trans, intersex, extremely androgynous people and people lacking in reproductive organs are such small minorities that if you meet someone and they look like a female person (meaning they have ovaries, a uterus etc.), you will be correct 90+% of the time. It's an extremely reliable heuristic, more reliable than any medical protocol ever designed. I acknowledge that this heuristic may not be quite as reliable in the specific subcultures and circles in which you move, but across the human race as a whole, 90+% sounds about right.

Are trans women more dangerous than cis women?

Yes.

Post-op trans women are 18 times more likely to be convicted of a violent crime (including rape and sexual assault) than cis women.