@FtttG's banner p

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/


				

User ID: 1175

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

					
				

				

				

					

User ID: 1175

Aren't Trans- of both kinds- murdered at lower rates than the general population

In the west, trans people are murdered at a lower rate than cis males.

In 2022 from a population of 1.6 million trans people in the US, there were 41 murders, broken down into 37 trans women and 4 trans men - 2.56 murders/100k of population.

In 2022 (the last year for which data on the victims' sex are known), there were 12,747 male murder victims in the US, from a population of 166.6 million. If we assume that that figure includes the 37 murders in the paragraph above, that comes down to 12,710. That works out at 7.63 murders/100k of population.

Anyone who tells you there's an epidemic of violence against trans people in the US is misinformed or lying.

Furry fandom is benign.

Midwest FurFest had to shut down their free HIV testing clinic early, because demand was higher than expected.

I don't think I've seen LGBT activists fabricate incidents

"Fabricate" is the wrong word, but the Obama administration passed a law against anti-LGBT hate crimes which was widely referred to as the Matthew Shepard Act. Matthew Shepard was a drug dealer who was murdered by a couple of rival dealers, and there is zero evidence that homophobia played any role in his death (he'd had sex with one of the men who murdered him).

Last year I designed a piece of cover art for a single. I fed (I think) Stable Diffusion a bunch of prompts (generally "[scene] in the style of [artist]") and downloaded the images as JPEGs. I used a different tool (no idea which one, sorry) to upscale the images. Ideally I wanted the finished product to be big enough that you could print it as a vinyl cover at 300 dpi if need be, so the entire image had to be 3,712 px square. I then imported all of the upscaled images into Photoshop and edited and composited them together. There was a lot of work involved: some of the figures created by Stable Diffusion had completely white skin rather than realistic skin tone, and one had six fingers on a hand. I was pretty happy with the finished product.

I agreed with the general thrust of your post, but I note that you're essentially taking it for granted that the DoD ran these campaigns, the campaigns were effective in persuading many Filipinos not to take Sinovac, and many Filipinos died needlessly as a result.

Data point 1: the Philippines reported negative excess mortality during the pandemic. It also reported fewer Covid deaths than many of its neighbours per capita.

Country Covid deaths Population Covid deaths per 100k
Indonesia 162,063 279,798,049 57.92
Malaysia 37,348 34,671,895 107.72
Philippines 66,864 119,106,224 56.14
Taiwan 19,005 23,950,214 79.35
Thailand 34,586 71,885,799 48.11
Vietnam 43,206 99,497,680 43.42

Figures above are from Worldometers.

Data point 2: by March 2023, 79.2 million Filipinos were fully vaccinated, or about 70% of the country. This is about on par with the global average, and higher than several of its neighbours including Thailand and Indonesia (but lower than Malaysia and Vietnam).

One could certainly argue that the DoD are morally implicated by these social media campaigns. If you took actions which you fully intended/expected to result in thousands of needless deaths, the fact that your actions didn't have the desired outcome does nothing to exculpate you (as I recently argued, in the rather different context of Hamas launching rockets at Israel which miss or are shot down). But it seems worthwhile to recognise that even if the DoD undertook certain actions with malicious intent, these actions were ineffective at their apparent goals.

I'm not saying "Hanson said this, therefore he should be cancelled". I'm saying that it's reasonable to characterise that specific belief as misogynistic.

Robin Hanson is apparently misogynistic

Hanson once wrote that a woman cheating on a man is as bad as (or worse than) a man raping a woman provided he does it in a "gentle, silent" way. No idea if he still endorses that opinion but it's a majorly sus thing to say.

I don't really see the inverse of this, there isn't a large contingent of men bashing on femcels.

Hard disagree, just think of all the subreddits dedicated to making fun of fat people which got banned over the years.

#3 is difficult to take seriously, to be honest.

Agreed, calling yourself a lesbian when you date men as well as women (maybe only date men) is stupid. Nonetheless, if the lesbian demographic includes many women who've been in (or currently are in) romantic relationships with men, that could potentially bias survey results in such a way to give a misleading impression of how common women-on-women domestic abuse is. The person conducting the survey might well assume that a person who identifies as a lesbian and claims to have experienced domestic abuse at the hands of a romantic partner has been victimised by a woman - indeed, this is a completely reasonable assumption given the standard definitions of the words "lesbian" and "woman". But just because that assumption is reasonable, doesn't mean there aren't people using those words in a nonstandard way which will bias the results. (Blood donor clinics and other medical practitioners already do this to route around the men who will give very different answers to the questions "are you gay?" and "have you had anal sex with a man in the past year?")

What you'd ideally want to do is design surveys in such a way that the results can't possibly be misinterpreted, like:

Q: In the past five years, have you been in one or more romantic relationships with:

  1. Male people only
  2. Female people only
  3. Male and female people
  4. No one

Q: In the past five years, have you experienced domestic abuse by

  1. At least one male partner?
  2. At least one female partner?
  3. At least one male and at least one female partner?
  4. No one

Of course, inevitably you would get people failing to report domestic abuse because the perpetrator was non-binary, or inflated numbers for female perpetrators of domestic violence because some respondents were victimised by trans women and interpreted male/female to mean "gender" rather than "sex". It's turtles all the way down.

insecurities over their own hobbies (current or when they were younger)

Who drew that comic, it's hilarious

Of course not, but on the narrow metrics of "desirability over time" and "fertility over time" I think it's fair to say men have it better than women and thus "women get shafted by nature" is a reasonable characterisation.

  1. If she was abused by a male relative, flatmate or housemate.
  2. If she was in a relationship with a man who abused her during a period of her life in which she identified as straight or bi, but now identifies as a lesbian.
  3. If she's a "lesbian" who only dates men.

Have you ever dated, seriously, a woman who you felt was objectively smarter than you were?

I once dated a woman meeting that description. I thought she was smarter than me even in spite of the fact that she was into astrology. Like really into it.

Now that I think of it, I also went on two dates with a doctor who I thought was more intelligent than me.

Not exactly the same, but I personally know one guy who said he was worried about the fact that his then girlfriend would soon be making more money than him.

As opposed to men, whose desirability to the opposite sex tends to increase between their early twenties and early forties, and who are able to conceive a child for a far longer proportion of their lifespan.

as far as I know, the opposite is in fact true on average

I've heard incredibly conflicting takes on this. I once heard that lesbian relationships reported the highest rates of domestic violence compared to gay or straight relationships. But then I heard someone else say that this statistic had been widely misrepresented: it was that lesbians were most likely to report having experienced domestic violence, without disambiguating the sex of the aggressor i.e. many lesbians reported having been victims of domestic violence at the hands of a male aggressor. If it's really the former situation, do you have any stats?

I'd love to see that effort post. Love the username by the way.

A few years ago I read an article on Quillette called "My Misspent Years of Conspiracism", in which the author describes how he was taken in by Oliver Stone's 1991 film JFK which alleges a conspiracy to assassinate John F. Kennedy, and how he subsequently came around to the idea that the Warren Commission's conclusions were accurate: JFK was killed by two rounds fired from the Texas school book depository by Lee Harvey Oswald, who acted alone. He explained the turning point in disabusing him of his misconceptions about the assassination was the TV documentary The Kennedy Assassination: Beyond Conspiracy. Not being especially well-versed in the various conspiracies surrounding the JFK assassination, I was persuaded by this article, and by its assertion that pretty much everything in the film JFK (which I haven't seen) is nonsense.

Today I've been reading some of the Wikipedia articles about the assassination, including the master article and the article about the assorted conspiracy theories (there's also one about the Dictabelt recording and the single-bullet theory, which I haven't gotten to yet). I'm currently watching the Beyond Conspiracy documentary mentioned in the article and it's fascinating (available here, but you need a Vimeo account). I was intrigued by this paragraph from the master article:

All remaining assassination-related records were scheduled to be released by October 2017, with the exception of documents certified for continued postponement by succeeding presidents due to "identifiable harm... to the military, defense, intelligence operations, law enforcement, or conduct of foreign relations... of such gravity that it outweighs the public interest in disclosure." President Donald Trump said in October 2017 that he would not block the release of documents, but in April 2018—the deadline he set to release all JFK records—Trump blocked the release of some records until October 2021. President Joe Biden, citing the COVID-19 pandemic, delayed the release further, before releasing 13,173 unredacted documents in 2022. A second group of files were unsealed in June 2023, at which point 99 percent of documents had been made public.

Two questions:

  1. Did the documents released since 2017 contain any bombshells? Have any conspiracies (or any components of conspiracies) been vindicated by the release of these documents?
  2. Even if the film JFK is a load of tripe, is it entertaining enough to be worth a watch? Or can you only get any enjoyment out of it if you're a true believer? Speaking as someone with decidedly mixed feelings on Stone as both a director and a screenwriter: Platoon was okay, Wall Street is trash, Alexander dragged on for bloody years, Natural Born Killers was eh (although I was probably about twelve years old when I saw it and perhaps too young to really get it), Midnight Express was somewhat entertaining but also the most unabashedly racist Hollywood film I've ever seen - come to think of it, the only film in which Stone had any involvement which I can say I love without qualification is Scarface.

Of all sad words,

Of tongue and pen,

The saddest are these:

"/pol/ was right again."

This evening, I learned that there's a Wikipedia article dedicated to /pol/.

Reading it was a real walk down memory lane. Anyone remember #SuperStraight?

The higher level of analysis, however, is; should police departments be setup for this? I'd actually argue they should not.

I think about this sketch a lot.

As highlighted by Freddie deBoer, there's so much inconsistency in the standard progressive narrative about what the police are for and what they should do. Cops don't do enough to protect black people, but it's also bad that police allocate disproportionate amount of resources to high-crime (i.e. black and Hispanic) neighbourhoods. Cops don't do enough to protect female victims of crime. Therefore we should defund the police while criticising the police for not doing enough with their already limited budgets.

So much of the debate seems stymied by the availability heuristic. Consumers of true crime content focus on fascinating cases which happened to relatable victims: in other words, bizarre unsolved murders in which the victim was an (A)WF(L)*. Consumers of this content are then bound to come away with the misconception that it's exceedingly common for a man to murder a strange woman and get away with it, which is wrong in almost every way: the overwhelming majority of murder victims are men, most murder victims are killed by someone known to them (although admittedly the American murder clearance rate has plummeted in recent decades, although I suspect that most of the unsolved murders in recent decades were gang violence rather than Ted Bundy copycats). True crime consumers then apply this misconception to their expectations for a functional police force, clamouring for police to Do More to solve murder cases with female victims (but without increasing police budgets in any way, of course).

And sure, maybe if we raised police budgets by 10% every year we might improve the marginal return on murder clearance, solving that 1% of murder cases every year which don't neatly fall into a) gang violence b) domestic violence or c) drunken bar fight. Whereupon the narrative will shift on a dime: "$State spent $10 million sending this Black man with learning disabilities and an underprivileged upbringing who raped and murdered three women to the electric chair! Imagine if that money had been spent on education so that children from similar backgrounds don't follow him down that path." There's no winning.

I think I agree with you that I'm satisfied with a police force that can solve most of the banal murders in a timely fashion, accepting that a small number of really weird cases will go unsolved every year as the price of a free society. I'm not persuaded that increasing police budgets by 10% to catch these weird cases passes a cost-benefit analysis, much like it would be a misallocation of resources to invest millions trying to find a treatment for a disease which only kills 100 people a year.

*"Affluent" and "liberal" are preferred but optional.

Jordan Jensen is a comedian I discovered on Instagram. I think she's one of the most consistently funny comedians going and I would love to see her perform live.

Then this happened today, and I'm wondering how long it'll be before she has to issue a groveling desaturated apology video. (Personally, I don't think she has anything to apologise for.)

One thing I find funny is when people say things like "I can't believe you said this during Pride month!" The implication being that jokes of this kind would be well-received by the trans community at any other time of the year, but are beyond the pale during June. Like, right.

The elections for the European parliament are running from yesterday until Sunday. I'm on my way to vote.

Thoughts on J. Robert Oppenheimer?

Playing tennis in a 3-piece suit is just about the most insane thing I've ever heard.