in which case the argument against immigration is a very clear and resounding 'not very good'.
Maybe in europe, but american immigration is still net economically positive by most quantifiable metrics. People on this forum make some combination of the "but it's not good for absolutely everyone" and the "but cultural diversity makes me feel bad" arguments. In response to the first argument, lazy rent-seekers can work harder instead of trying to interfere with my ability to do commerce with whoever I want. In response to the second argument-- shrug. Reducing immigration makes me feel bad and I don't see why they should get their way.
I'm not coming at this from an anti-russian angle, I'm coming at this from a pro-american angle. I'd like ukraine to be free-- but the most important thing is for america to be prosperous and safe. To that end, it's in our interest to contain our enemies with the least expenditure of american lives possible.
but most historians seem to think that Containment wasn't super effective.
It continually baffles me that historians say this because... where is the soviet union now? I think the domino theory was probably bullshit, but forcing your enemies to expend resources at an unfavorable rate forever just works™. The mistakes america made was with picking the wrong enemies-- we could have easily had that one vietnamese dude as an ally, and later Iraq proved to be a lesser evil than hardcore islamists like ISIS.
Option A - Stalemate and Attrition
I don't understand why people think this is a bad thing (for the united states of America). "Defending Ukraine" is just a useful fig leaf for what's actually important: degrading the ability of the Russian state to interfere with America's interests. Sure, a decisive victory for Ukraine would be good... but an indefinite war is even better. The war in Ukraine is essentially a pinning action for Russian state capacity. The longer we fix their attention on Ukraine, the better. Paying a few hundred billion dollars for the privilege is cheap. American lives are worth millions of dollars apiece-- getting to spend Ukrainian lives instead is an amazing deal. In the absolute best case, we turn ukraine into Russia's Vietnam-- a forever war that permanently saps their will to fight completely out of proportion with the actual military consequences of defeat. (And yes, Vietnam did that for America. Sure, we fought wars after, but with the major caveat of no longer having the draft.)
Morally, of course, I'm repulsed by the idea of intentionally extending the war... But that's my honest assessment when I take my "moralism" hat off and put my "realism" hat on.
Flopping is pretty silly. The women's league is known for having much less of it so it's probably possible to mitigate it just by telling the refs to behave differently. That being said, it's worth noting that some of the players notorious for flopping (ex. Brazil's Neymar) are also notorious for getting injured because the opposing team's offense hard-focuses them. So on net I'd want ref enforcement to encourage less flopping, but there's probably no good way to have zero flopping. Maybe some incidental change like automatic VAR review for big matches would help at the margins, but it's not something I think is particularly important to optimize for. The kinds of americans who love football and dislike soccer will continue to like football and not really like soccer even if flopping is removed-- and that's perfectly fine, people are allowed to have different values and therefore different preferences. But soccer is beloved for being the beautiful sport, not the most action-packed one. It appeals to a wide range of ages and demographics. It's the sort of thing a mother encourages their sons to play together without worrying that they'll get hurt. Football can't really say the same.
Congress still has the power to refuse confirmation with 51% majorities.
Nah, "interim" appointments just last forever now.
The president still faces the threat of legal action after their term if they violated the law.
Everything is an official act if the president wants it to be. Everything else gets done by underlings and receives pardons. The idea that presidents were liable to state law provided a check on that-- but now it's gone. I won't pretend like republicans are fully to blame for that-- I'm not a fan of biden's blanket pardons. But this is one more, massive, crack in the dam.
Do you have evidence for this?
Beyond gut instinct fermi estimates, no. But I should clarify that I'm speaking of the net effect of voting for politicians that promote particular anti-abortion policies. If I had to choose between two buttons labeled "end climate change" and "prevent abortions in the US for a hundred years" I would pick the second, but I don't think any sort of federal ban is actually enforceable. I'm suprised and impressed that republicans actually managed to overturn roe-v-wade, but most estimates of that claim that it only saves about ~30,000 lives a year. Compared to the marginal effect of preventing ISIS-style wars I'm unimpressed. I'm aware that the comparison is a little unfair because I'm imagining an intervention that could singlehandedly halt climate change at some degree thresholds-- but at the same time, I think it's likely that the most deleterious effects of climate change are liable to happen at the margins, where it might be possible to just hold the breaks long enough to get to a tipping point.
(Also, as a Catholic you should know it's not about the effect of paying for an abortion, it's about the remote material cooperation with evil. Being made complicit in the murder of a baby is the thing that really upsets us and Congress explicitly tried to protect us from.)
I'm concerned primarily with the net loss of life. But if we're speaking in terms of remote material cooperation with evil without considering numbers, preventing immigrants from making better lives for themselves also qualified.
What mechanism do you want? I vote in accordance with my conscience, and my conscious tells me I'm going to save more lives by voting for climate action than by voting for anti-abortion measures. I wish I could just concentrate my beliefs in a single party but unfortunately we don't live in a parliamentarian democracy.
The democrats are definitely the progressive party. Their policy is progressive. The mechanism they arrive at their progressivism doesn't really concern my argument. But if we agree then I don't care to dispute it.
I know we're arguing about definitions, which is the lowest form of argument, but I still think it's worth trying to get you to see my side. When you say, "the democrats are... the progressive party," you're taking a descriptive view of the ways the democrats behave. And it's accurate! But it's also missing the point. It's like calling a motorcycle gang a "motorcycle helmet wearing gang". Democrats adopt progressivism because it is useful to them-- because they have particular common needs the ideology serves. They would still be (mostly) bound together if they found a different way of addressing the same needs. That's why I call democrats the urban party-- because their needs and desires are fundamentally a result of what urbanites need and want. Yes, there are non-urbanist democrats, just like there are urbanist republicans, because not all urbanites share the same needs. But serving urban environments is still fundamentally the core of what the party is and wants.
What evidence is there that indicates that the US is headed towards organized political violence?
Uh, the fact that we're already here? Two trump assasins and luigi. Unless the economy skyrockets and things start getting immediately better now we're already going through what later historians will probably call "the american troubles" or something alike.
Progressivism is unpopular; a very tiny percentage of voters thought democrats were too far to the right.
I had this same mental model of the world, and then harris lost. Without changing how I personally feel about progressivism, I now have to concede that the left-populists were right about the electorate.
It's worth remembering that the last democrat with any sort of popular movement was Yang, and he's also strongly populist-progressive (though not so much left-progressive.)
I don't mind if we eat the rich too, I just think it's infeasible. Slave revolutions basically never work-- you have to have some sort of elite buy-in.
That was a typo lol. I mean, "easier to destroy than to create." Actually that plays into why I believe trump is stupid-- it's really easy to see how the bulk of his success is just the short-term gains from looting complex systems he lacks the intelligence to create. I won't dispute calling him "canny" because he really does have an exceptionally refined sort of animal cunning where he understands what people want on an emotional level... but I would define intelligence as either the general intelligence score or the capacity for abstract thought, and trump's mode of speech alone disproves him possessing those.
Then if you believe in election fraud anyways there's no point making the defense of "each state runs their own elections." In fact, you should probably accept that all elections are totally rigged, and take the sequence of events from 2016-2024 as evidence that the deep state was secretly on your side as part of a long-term plan to get trump in office.
In any case, the cumulative effect of this back-and-forth wrenching will not, I think, be a net increase in state capacity and control.
I think you're dramatically underestimating the bully power of a president with full regulatory authority over the corporations and therefore culture of the united states.
But oh well, at this point we're still discussing counterfactual. I wish I could just remindme! 8 years.
Unless-- do you have a manifold account? We could make some prediction markets to resolve this.
Maybe we can agree at this point to not delegate so much to the executive?
I agree on this point, and that's exactly why I liked that these agencies were independent. The senate could have killed the filibuster instead and started passing laws to deal with the administrative state if they wanted to-- but they didn't because presumably the ability to loot the government and install bureacrats via a patronage system is more convenient. Oh well.
What do you think it's been like to be a Conservative this whole time? Do you think we like not having the Comstock Act enforced and have our taxes go to killing babies in their mother's womb? What are you worried about that tops that?
Climate change. I'm a catholic, and therefore anti-abortion, but the net effect of stuff like "not funding abortions" is dramatically outweighed by the net increase in deaths caused by droughts, floods, famines, and famine-related-instability.
But oh well, at least this power is symmetric. I hope the next democratic president just straight-up regulates carbon intensive industries out of existence.
These are reasons that do not support your position that it is easier to create than to destroy, they support the position that it is easier to destroy than to create.
Uh, I just realized I stupidly mistyped this in the first comment and then didn't pick up on it later. It's harder to create than to destroy; we agree on this point.
Helping people with the government is a pretty core belief of progressivism. If the democrats abandon that position, then to what extent are they democrats anymore?
The democrats aren't the "progressive" party. They're the urban party. Progressivism is highly adaptive for urbanites, so urbanites adopt progressivism and demand democratic leaders. It's not the other way around, where progressive leaders convert urbanites.
And in any case, progressivism isn't about "helping people" in general, it's about helping specific people, who by some calculus deserve that help. All the democrats have to do is change the calculus... drop the expensive, economically useless, socially conservative old people, pull in the technocratic, culturally liberal tech bros. I'm not saying they will do that, but it wouldn't be a huge ideological stretch if they did.
A man that owns an acre in the urban core is just as much a property owner as a man who owns 100 acres in Nebraska. Whose land is worth more? Where do the rich reside? In the urban core. Who has greater security needs - the property owner in the urban core, or the property owner in Nebraska?
You're probably thinking in terms of burglars and murder statistics. Start thinking in terms of organized political violence instead.
"John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it!"
It's not about having a cult of personality-- it's about being able to reward favored underlings and protect them from retaliation. Basic feudal-contract type stuff. The more power a president has over their bureaucracy, the more loyalty they can engineer their bureaucracy to have.
The Democrats could also be described as making use of this tactic
Yes, to some extent-- both parties use a variety of electoral strategies, I'm just describing a tactic the democratic coalition relies on more.
One could argue, watching from another screen, that Manchin and Sinema were the last stalwarts keeping the Dem party from completely sabotaging itself and going full-lefty.
I can and did argue that. I'm a neoliberal, not a leftist. But 2024 proved me wrong-- evidently the democratic base really did want left-populists, and us "return to normalcy" folks were basically wrong.
Is the idea of "old = conservative" a given? I think a lot of your ideal vision rests a lot on this, among other things.
Yes. Not every old person is a religious conservative-- but old people are intrinsically more resistant to change. Culture isn't just what people think about the gays... it's how people want their cities laid out, how business owners treat their employees, and what segments of the population are given disproportionate amounts of respect. And over the total spectrum of subjects, the old people in my party are basically as bad as the old people outside of it-- they still want to drive cars, destroy the environment, prevent dense construction, and extract transfer payments from the young.
I won't claim that the democratic party will abandon old people. I just think they should.
We were staring down the barrel of it previously, and this was the best recourse we could find.
Republicans control all three branches of government. This was the best recourse you could find? Republicans could easily have looked for a solution that favored the power of the legislative branch (where they have a structural advantage) or the courts (where they'll soon have an incumbency advantage.) Instead, they gave the power to the presidency? Seriously?
The basic problem is that we can no longer agree on core values, on what the laws should be and how they should be enforced. Either someone has to win, or we have to have a divorce.
This part I agree with. That's why I'm so confused: why are the republicans giving the democrats the ammunition they need to win the divorce?
If the administrative state was unconstitutional the supreme court could have ruled it so.
But that's not really my point. I accept that no one gives a damn about the constitution. Rather, my point is that the cost of making a little more accountable is going to be an administrative state that is significantly more statist, and in the long-run probably more progressive and growth-stifling too. You can easily point at all the regulations you hate, but you're going to have much more trouble identifying all the bad regulations that never existed in the first place.
Now? well, it can take decades to grow a business... but only a few well-placed, well timed regulations and tarrifs to kill one. Making it easier to kill regulations by executive fiat is equivalent to making it easier to implement them. Trump is lubing up the levers of power, but one way or another, he's going to have to give up the stick.
I've read this article before and agree with it.
where is the constitutional scheme whereby an independent agency can write regulations.
and I answered "in the bit where it gave that power to congress, and then congress gave it to the independent agency (and NOT the president.)"
And I’ve been very anti administrative state for years and years.
Okay well I hope you're ready to change tactics and start railing against the monarchial-presidential state. All the government's power is still there... it's just more strongly concentrated into a single person.
By food i mean in general. Increased population leads to an increase in food demand, driving up prices.
The best nonviolent way to reduce global population is to get immigrants to move to countries with low-fertility norms.

I'm going to speak on this mostly from the American perspective because I think the calculus for Europeans is legitimately different. Anyways--
It's interesting that immigrants have only a marginal effect on population aging. That part of the article is well supported, contradicts my priors, and has forced me to update my beliefs.
Everything aside from that core point is worthless. The arguments about cultural and genetic threats are just silly-- but I won't harp on them too much. I think my culture is the best and my genetics are pretty darn good so I'm confident that through the graces of God and Darwin I'll prevail. I can see why people with inferior cultures and genetics would be afraid of immigration but that's not my problem, and anyways over the long run your doom is overdetermined.
But the economic argument is just ridiculous.
Let me start with the calculation that would actually convince me that that any specific immigrant is a net drain:
[Net Tax Income] + [Integral of (ΔGDP PPP + ΔAvg. Wages) over immigrant length of stay] - [Net Welfare Spending] - [Net Harm from Crime] < 0
... generalizing over any group of immigrants.
It's obvious and uncontroversial that that [Net Tax Income (immigrant)] < [Net Tax Income (natural-born citizens)]. And while I've never actually seen it proven, I wouldn't be too surprised if "Net Tax Income" (immigrant)/years in country < "Net Tax Income" (natural-born citizens)/years in country.
I understand that anti-immigrant activists believe that [ΔAvg. Wages] is negative. I disagree but respect that there are consistent a priori arguments in the other direction, and that the a posteriori argument I find convincing is founded on fuzzy, difficult to interpret data.
I understand that anti-immigrant activists believe that [Net Harm from Crime] is very large. I think they've been fooled by media sensationalism, they think I've been fooled by media censorship, we're just never going to agree on this.
I don't blame the article for not convincingly addressing the above points-- those arguments have been rehashed over and over again. But its failures are twofold:
First, it claims to show that [Net Welfare Spending (immigrant)] > [Net Welfare Spending (citizen)], but to do this it uses *blatant accounting chicanery. It treats, "percentage of households receiving welfare" as a proxy for "welfare spending," but that's an obviously terrible idea when not all welfare is created equal. SNAP is cheap, Medicaid paying for a nursing home is definitely not. And-- it treats the benefits received by the citizen children of immigrants as benefits received by immigrants. That's poor-faith sleight of hand. I don't just mean that in the philosophical sense that citizen children of immigrants aren't actually immigrants-- I mean that it double-counts welfare provided to immigrants, but then is careful to treat the results of that welfare-- the economic gains due to education, good childhood nutrition, etc. as being the result of citizens. That's completely unfair. It would be like me trying to argue that this CIS report showing how naturalized citizens receiving welfare at lower rates than American-born citizens is proof that we should naturalize every immigrant immediately-- when of course that report also reflects the fact that naturalization is a long process and by the time you've been in the US for over a decade you've probably become reached a prosperous middle age and become economically established.
(By the way, I got that CIS link from the article itself-- and it was including its numbers as more proof that citizens take less welfare than immigrants. Can you see the logical error here?)
I can envision an article about how inclusive of the cost of their childhood poverty, the children of immigrants have a greater net cost to the government than the children of natives (and therefore that we should discourage immigration for that reason.) But it would have to contend the fact that 2nd generation immigrants make MORE money than the native population-- and therefore also pay more in taxes.
And finally even more egregious than the accounting mistakes, the article doesn't even try to argue that ΔGDP PPP is negative, even though for pro-immigration activists it is our entire raison d'être. I like goods and services. Immigrants make goods and deliver services. Q.E.D. Yes, immigrants receive welfare-- but they also work in the hospitals that supply Medicaid-funded treatments and in the fields that supply SNAP-eligible foodstuffs. Immigrants contribute to the American project not just by paying taxes, but by giving us the things our taxes pay for. In a contrafactual world without immigrants or their children either the economy or inflation or both would have been much worse.
The best the article does is vaguely gesturing toward the direction that national IQs are correlated with GDP per capita, as if this should prove anything. Well to use a term mottists really enjoy, "One man's modus ponens is another man's modus tollens." I believe that immigration has raised and continues to raise America's GDP PPP per capita. Therefore, I must logically conclude that immigrants are on average smarter than the native-born population. And that's not much of a stretch! Even if I believed that differences in national IQs accurately measured differences in genetic predispositions toward intelligence (I don't, I think they're measuring differences in nutrition, disease rates, and stress-linked epigenetic expression) those differences are actually fairly small, in the grand scheme of things. If you compare the general population to groups self-selected for competence (think engineers, doctors, scientists, etcetera) you see a much larger, much more persistent difference. Immigrants are the ultimate self-selected group. Hell, that article I linked about 2nd generation immigrants making more money than they native population also includes that 2nd generation immigrants end up better educated than the native population. And education is correlated with IQ...
Yes, the article provides a study about national IQ changes... but its trivial to sketch out an argument for ignoring that study. A difference of <=2 points could be noise, could be due to flaws in the design in the PISA test, could be due to a non=representative sampling of students, could be due to differences in language proficiency, could be due to stress-linked epigenetic factors, could be due to any number of things besides an actual genetic difference pre-dispositioning immigrants to have lower IQ. I'm not making an actual counterargument, at this point-- but only because it would be a waste of time to discuss IQ when what actually matters is ΔGDP PPP and you can just measure that directly.
Now, that all ignores the admittedly rather compelling argument that aggregate economic benefit is not the same as personal economic benefit, and that specific individuals may suffer net losses from immigration for whatever reason. I wouldn't want to tell one of the people in the new years New Orleans Muslim terrorist attack that they net-benefited from immigration. But the article doesn't make that argument so I won't bother addressing it.
There is one concession I have to make to the anti-immigration argument, and that it is that asylum applicants/refugees are-- if not necessarily a net loss-- than less economically beneficial than either illegal immigrants or high-skilled immigrants. And that's a problem for Europe, because there are a lot of legitimate asylum applicants they are mandated by morality and international law to accept. But the fact that it's also a problem for America is completely ridiculous! Even if you accept (like I do) that we have a moral imperative to accept economic migrants... there's zero need to give them the support we give to actual refugees. They would happily take long-term work visas instead, with no obligation for America to let them stay here into retirement and pay for their expensive old-age healthcare (unless they upgrade to permanent residency through excellence and hard work.) If I got everything I wanted, we would have a LOT more immigration-- but immigrants would receive less welfare. Legal immigration is good but illegal immigration is WAY better. So the more illegal we can make our immigration-- the fewer responsibilities we require and the fewer the rights we extend-- the better.
More options
Context Copy link