JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
That remains to be established. I hope the answer is "no" because we have enough nicely looking ideological packages leading people into bad places, we don't need more. But my point is not that it's bad, my point is it's not "inert" - we need to watch out and evaluate whether it's bad or not, we can't just rely on the idea that "ideas are inert", because very often they aren't.
Not really. If we have some seemingly plausible argument that still constantly leads people to heinous actions then the good heuristics would be to reject this argument even if we can't conclusively prove that it is always false. Humans are flawed, and evaluating consequences and strength of each argument personally is hard work. I am not sure that sufficiently clever demagogue can't trick me into following something bad if I treat each argument as inert. However, if I put up some guardrails in dangerous places - like if adherents of this concept often turn out to be psychopathic conmen, or if adherents of that concept frequently end up committing genocide when they raise to power - I may be restricting myself a bit but at least I cut off a huge chunk of possibility space where I would be convinced to follow something very bad.
I think it's time to move on to a horse that has not shuffled its mortal coil and did not join the choir invisible. This is an ex-horse.
I'm 98.45730468302835030019% certain.
Maybe there are no Bond-villain type organizations? I mean, there are crime syndicates, but they do not need to retail their enforcement capabilities to any random Joe with a bitcoin. They want them for themselves, tightly controlled by their leadership. And those who would retail probably would end up taking an order from LEO and going to jail very soon. It's an inherent contradiction between having wide retail appeal and tight opsec.
Not only charities. There are aftershocks through all crypto-system, and a lot of people that aren't affected directly are re-evaluating their stance towards crypto, which may lead to affecting even more people (imagine a major bank planning to invest in crypto - but then deciding to stay away - that'd probably lead to some reallocation of resources, somebody not getting a promotion, somebody fired maybe...)
Examples: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-11-14/ftx-fiasco-sparks-billions-of-dollars-of-outflows-from-exchanges https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-11-15/ftx-latest-regulators-discuss-questioning-bankman-fried-in-us
It's way beyond just FTX customers and EA charities.
Well compared to the whole US government, sure, they are tiny. Assuming US government is still capable of consistent coordinated action and not wholly captured by a network of entities that are not going to allow to deploy its resources to any goal that contradicts their goals. Sure, US government has trillions. But how efficiently can it deploy those trillions towards a single goal? That's a question to which the answer is not clear to me at all.
But the US is not the only country. So "we solve" as in "US citizens solve". What about citizens of Brazil? or Pakistan? Or Nigeria? Or any smaller country? They'd like to have some solution for this too...
which are restricted from causing havoc by the 500 years of laws pertaining to corporations
But are they really? They have a huge part of writing most of these laws, and there's also such thing as "too big to fail"... And most of these laws were written after the harm was already caused, and only are able to prevent the past, not the future. I mean sure, they are somewhat restricted - if Musk or Soros would go on a rampage killing people in broad daylight, we probably know how to handle this. But that's not what we're talking about when we talk about alignment, right? We're worried the harm could be caused in ways we can not perceive or prevent before it's too late, and that's already true.
I don't agree this is "normal finance". It's a high risk game that is sometimes played in finance, but they committed fraud by the way they played this game and the way they presented it. My question was about whether EA/rat angle played any role in it. Initially, I thought the connection was purely coincidental, now reading more about it, I am not so sure - it looks there are some aspects of both a con aimed at EA/rat world and using EA/rat premises as justification for doing evil things, or at least to destroy all fencing that usually keeps one from doing evil things - which eventually inevitably led to doing evil things.
I think it's matching the environment. In Scott's environment, most people aren't highly skilled sociopath conmen, so trusting people makes sense. The reverse side of it is that once in a while there will be a highly skilled sociopath conman that will totally take advantage. I'm not sure I can really tell this way is better than be eternally suspicious and distrusting and live all your life on guard against the conmen - but I think both models have their tradeoffs and both are plausible.
I think the point there was not that no one wants to do that, but no one wants to assign a profound importance to banalities.
I didn't claim you invented abstract algebra (if you did, I'd probably just worship you quietly and wouldn't dare to contradict you) - I claim that ability of symbols to attach to any meaning and the fact that same symbols can be used to designate multiple entities with different qualities and properties is not some kind of deep revelation that leads people to profound insights (at least not by now - maybe when this fact has been first discovered, it would). It's more like a rhetorical gotcha trick that is meant to confuse people and give the trickster a false aura of profundity - "oh, he knows that 2+2 can mean so many different things, he must be so smart!", or even "aha! He said "I like giving gifts to children", but in German "gift" means poison, so he is actually is a child murderer and I won the internet by this clever trick!". It's not really that clever, that's what I am saying.
OK yes, I didn't realize whose messages those were, my mistake. It's more of a smoking gun than I realized, I'll probably need to research it deeper.
which is viewed as an unalloyed good
This is one wrong premise. Another wrong premise is having more ballots in the box is not necessarily means having more people voluntarily and willingly participating - there's no way to actually verify that part.
This is because participation is an important part of civic pride, helping to preempt unrest
Not helping, as we witnessed having a lot of unrest, including in places like Oregon that has mail voting for a long time.
Also, I don't see how making less effort to participate makes you more proud of it - usually it works the other way.
I was going to write up the case for mass voting, even by the uneducated, but I’ll sum it up as “safety valve for political pressure.”
This makes little sense. First of all, recent events demonstrated that if there's any safety valve, it does not work. Second, most people that resort to violence don't do it because it's hard for them to vote, it's because they think voting is useless. Letting them do useless thing easier, or have more people do the useless thing, is not going to change their opinions. Third, obviously, even if all the previous arguments are false, your premise is good only if we're talking about more individual voters voting being good, not higher numbers in "vote count" column being good. The whole premise of the parent comment is that mail voting allows to disconnect one from the other, which invalidates "voting is good" as an argument for it.
I don't think so. The EA work of FTX/SBF were rather incidental to the main scam activities, and I don't see much input from the EA/rat circles into the scam. They got some outputs from the scam, and maybe lent it a small measure of credibility, but I don't see any way they were an inherent part of the scamming and had any substantial input to the decisions FTX investors and clients took.
Looks like an exercise in sophistry. Of course with skillful redefinition of what '2' and '+' and '2' and '=' and '4' you can make it mean anything you like. It's not a very interesting thing, just as you could invent your own private language where the word "water" means "sun" and the word "dry" means "yellow" and then claim "water is dry!" and feel very smart about it. There's nothing to reconsider - it's not about something being true or not true, it's about confusing oneself on purpose.
I think you kinda underestimate how easy is to manipulate a grown adult outside of their area of expertise. Especially if the manipulation is towards the result that they want to achieve (which is how any skillful conman would do it). Especially if the target is commonly living in a low-threat environment where it's usually ok to trust people and most of people you encounter aren't actually out to get you. It's probably easier to manipulate a very smart professor than a very dumb prison inmate - because the latter won't just believe any word you say regardless of what you say, just on general principle that they don't know you.
Well, if these people vote in presidential, that means they know how to vote and are able to, but still choose not to. I think I shoudn't worry about them not participating - it's not like they were excluded - they specifically chose to abstain, that's as valid as any other vote.
I have mixed feelings about this - from one side, some people in rationalist circles made very inflated claims about how their methods of rationality give them almost superpowers and how they are way better than regular humans at things that regular humans are bad at. So, for a regular human it's both a bit of reassuring that those supposed gods have exactly the same failure modes as mere mortals, though on the other side it was nice to imagine there are gods walking among us, for a short time.
That said, I don't see how it really should hurt rationalism that much. I mean yeah, a bunch of rationalists got caught on a scam. Smart people getting caught on a scam is not that rare. Isaac Newton - an intellectual titan by any measure - lost lots of money on South Sea Company. There were numerous other cases. It's not good, it's ok to feel bad about it, in fact it's probably necessary to feel bad about it, but it's hardly some kind of huge global catastrophe for rationalism or EA, IMHO. Stand up, dust off, analyze and admit your errors, try to do better next time.
I'm not sure it'd be that different, actually. I mean if only 30% voted, these people wouldn't be some Martians - they'd be somebody's peers, friends, coworkers, relatives, etc. - so they'd be part of the same culture. If you're an academia and everybody around votes Democrat, and some of them would be too hang over to vote, the rest would still vote Democrat. If you're in rural Tennessee and everybody around votes Republican, and you just forget to vote - the rest would vote Republican anyway. Sure, some patterns may shift here and there, but I suspect it won't be that different even if much less people voted than do now.
So everybody around is now like "please vote, please vote". I'd like to challenge that. I'll start with the observation that while obviously not everybody votes who has the right to, we don't exactly have a crisis level of participation here, we have about 2/3 of voters turn out. Which isn't that bad, it's not like a tiny group of people are deciding for the whole country.
Now, if somebody is so disinterested in politics - or so lazy, or disappointed, or uninformed - that they don't want to vote, why should any effort be spent on convincing them? Their vote probably would not be well thought out, and they would probably fail to accurately appreciate the consequences of their choices. Best case they'd vote at random, worst case they'd follow the first demagogue or pretty face they encounter. I mean, if you work for your local neighborhood demagogue, it's exactly what you want I guess, but why anybody else would support such an effort? I'd rather say the exact opposite - please don't vote unless you understand what it is about and what are you voting for - in which case you probably don't need anybody else to tell you what to do anyway!
Religion does not have biological basis, but sex very much does. And not just a peripheral issue - like which garment I wear or such - but as one of the basic frameworks of huge spectrum of biological organisms. You can't just wave it away with "oh that looks stupid, just ignore that part" - no more than you can ignore other part of your biological reality and decide from tomorrow morning you are capable of FTL spaceflight.

The headline talks about rationalists, but the article actually talks a lot about people who aren't rationalists at all. Like journalists. Or Krugman. Which are very easy to dupe, because they want to be duped. They actively go out and look for people who can be used as props to launder their agenda through them, and in some cases if they fail, they manufacture it (somehow this is considered to be much worse behavior than cherry-picking props, while being essentially the same). This is an easy trap to fall into - and I am sure many people declaring themselves rationalist fell in it too, because they are human. If you build a trap skillfully and put tasty enough cheese inside (different cheese for different people), a lot of people will get caught. Some of them may be calling themselves "rationalists", some of them may even try and become less easy to get caught - but they are imperfect humans, so they'll get caught anyway. That is to be expected. Doubly so if they actually profit in one way or another from getting caught (like journalists or political activists - which are pretty much one and the same nowdays). For those, passing a good "boo outgroup" story is almost inhumanly hard, so here are most of your examples.
More options
Context Copy link