JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
I myself is a huge fan of JRRT work since I read The Hobbit while in high school (that was quite some time ago). I own a lot of Tolkien and about-Tolkien books. I own a DVD set of the LOTR trilogy and regularly re-watch it. But, I can't find any reason for myself to watch the Amazon stuff. I know it's not Tolkien. I know it's not made by people who respect and cherish Tolkien's legacy - they said it themselves that they think Tolkien should be "updated" to fit their modern sensibilities. I'm fine with that, at some level - it's their billion dollars, and we're a free country. But I really don't see why I would watch any of that.
The bad thing is that this is probably the only adaptation of Tolkien we're going to get for a while now. The good thing is that this is probably the only adaptation of Tolkien we're going to get for a while now - and maybe the next one would be when the woke wave has receded and people would go back to put Tolkien's work on screen because of the love of the lore, and not because it's a Platform for The Message (TM) and also maybe we can make some money on the hype.
The chance of severe illness and death for a young person is very small. So it's like buying insurance against a being struck by lightning while being chased by a shark. Sure, it may be a reputable company (some may doubt that but let's assume they are) and they'll pay out if that happens in 97% of cases, but should you really bother?
Why not both? He's both insisting on being the part of every decision, and completely incapable of understanding what is going on and actually make complex decisions about complex problems, and also appreciate how much his capabilities have declined. That could explain a lot of the disfunction.
Authority of the office is a tricky thing. Trump's administration demonstrated us how easily the authority of the office could be denied even to the President if the bureaucracy is not afraid to confront him in an open conflict - formally, he had authority over a lot, including the DOJ and the FBI, factually, he was not running the show at all. Of course, with Biden situation is much different, and there's no open war - and no reason for it - between the White House and the bureaucracy. But the same mechanisms could be deployed to softly route around the President instead of openly defying him. Maybe even under the guise of "for his own benefit" - after all, the bureaucracy has been ruling the country "for their own benefit" for decades now anyway, extending the same approach to the President is only logical.
And also be reminded more frequently that their co-workers may be secretly hating them - and likely are, since there's no possible way for them not to, even if they genuinely think they don't, they still unconsciously are, there's no way for them to stop, since the whole culture is making them do it. And thus everybody should be vigilantly watching everybody else for the signs of that and scrutinize any communication or action (or inaction) for the signs of that. And if it looks like any communication - including one you're not the party in - raises your suspicion, you should immediately intervene and emphasize how much harm such hateful conduct is doing and how intolerable are the conditions that led to this outbreak of bigotry. Only the eternal vigilance can ensure the feeling of belonging.
Suicide usually means either being terminally ill or being severely depressed. I imagine when you're depressed, you don't have the capacity to think about going away in a spectacular way. And if you're terminally ill, you're probably too tired to care.
Audiobooks. Libraries have tons of them, for free, and there are audio courses too if you want your driving time to be educational. If you don't mind paying (or, alternatively, don't mind visiting certain sites of arrrgh persuasion) almost every book can be had in audio form. Not all books work this way - obviously, ones that need lots of illustration aren't a good match - but otherwise you can get many, many hours of content. And then there are podcasts, which can fill another lifetime.
P.S. I'm not a "young people" anymore, but still wanted to note the possibilities.
That means that despite the nearly $8B businesses typically spend each year on D&I training, nearly half of the employees still don’t feel like they belong.
Despite daily beatings, the morale has not improved yet! A mystery shrouded in enigma!
When the Brazilian soap operas were introduced into Soviet market in the late 80s - previously unfamiliar with them - the whole cities shut down when the regular installments were broadcast. You could walk into a store and not find anybody to serve you because everybody was watching (but anyway, what business did you have walking around when you're supposed to be watching too?). It was hugely popular, and Brazilian soap operas remain very popular among some categories of people to this day. It also introduced the Brazilian word fazenda into Russian - where it became to mean the same as dacha.
Racial representation is not everything but it might be the single largest factor going into why I will gravitate towards something
I can imagine your enjoyment of a cultural even is predicated on the participant's skin hue being as closely matched as possible to your own. I mean, everybody has their kinks. I don't have to understand yours. I just think it's very weird for this particular kink to become a culture-wide rule.
Slice of life-style dramas do need to be culturally familiar, again with race acting as a rough proxy.
That sucks for me, because now I have to stop watching everything from Agatha Cristies' detectives to American romcoms to Hong-Kong martial arts movies to Korean historic epics - nothing matches my cultural background as an Eastern European Jew. I could probably still enjoy Sholom Aleichem maybe... but he talks too much about living in the shtetl, and I grew up in an urban culture in 20th century, so no luck for me again. But wait, there's a respite - their skin tones still roughly match mine (even the Hong-Kong guys maybe close enough? please?), and that means that it's all the same culture, since there's only one culture per skin tone, so yay, I am saved.
Basically some other culture's/race's noir or rom-com is nowhere near as interesting as my own
I think you are voluntarily robbing yourself of a wealth of cultural experiences. I'd suggest to try to expand your horizons and you may discover people that are different from you may be also interesting. You don't have to, of course - it's just a choice that is available to you.
There's evidence of euthanasia being over-promoted by the same doctors who are supposed to be guardians of it, I posted it on this thread and so did others. So there's definitely not "the absence of actual evidence of institutional failures", quite the contrary.
If something does look wrong to someone, they can investigate.
Not really. Only if someone is a DA or similar person in power, and they have motivation to intervene for some reason. Otherwise, there won't be any investigation at all, let alone "reasonably thorough" one.
"Something looks wrong" is unfalsifiable.
We're not talking here about scientific paper and abstract scientific pursuits, where "we still don't know whether theory X is true or not" is an OK outcome and in general we're fine with waiting for conclusive evidence one way or another. When we're talking about killing people, "you can't scientifically prove there's something wrong here, therefore we're fine to assume it's ok and not knowing one way or another is completely OK too" shouldn't be the bar it has to clear. It should be much, much higher than that. If something looks wrong, there should be an overwhelming and obvious proof it's not, and "if something were wrong, somebody would investigate it" shouldn't cut it too. When we're talking about irreversible actions of this magnitude, we can't approach it in the same way as we manager parking tickets - "this officer has been issuing tickets for 20 years, so if you can't conclusively prove she was wrong, we assume it's ok". We have to erect a higher bar on this.
The opposite side of this coin is called "salami tactics".
but this argument can be directed at virtually every institution in existence.
And it should be. If you see something, say something. If something the institution does looks wrong for you, your responsibility, if you ever want to have good (or at least better) institutions, is not to say "well, they are the institutions, they know best" but apply scrutiny to what they do. That's the only way to make sure any institutions work at all for us, and not for their own sake. If you ignore all the evidence of institutional failures, contenting yourself with "well, they have years of experience, surely it's ok somehow in some way unknown to me, just trust the experts and everything will be ok" - nothing will be ok, because there's no motivation for the institutions to serve you - you abdicated all your claims on that.
it can't be positive to grow up watching superhero movies and none of them look like you.
This is assuming Arnold Schwarzenegger "looks like me" because his skin has a hue close to mine (if you really squint) and thus I can imagine myself being him, despite having nothing else at all in common, but if my skin were a couple of hues different, now I can't. That doesn't make a lot of sense. I mean for a racist, where everything you need to know about a person is their race and it defines everything - sure does, but for someone who didn't grow up in a race-obsessed culture, it just sounds extremely bizarre.
Also, billions and billions of people grew up without watching any "superhero movies" at all, and they came up just fine - or at least not worse that those that did see the magic pictures.
know better than the woman herself, a panel of doctors and a public prosecutor,
The woman has been, factually, mentally unwell, so it's not hard to understand why one may think they "know better". If we allow the idea that psychiatric illnesses exist, and some of them may move persons to an action which is not to their best interests, and it is possible to fix these conditions and they should be fixed - which is, admittedly, not an obvious proposition and is fraught with edge cases, but if we still allow it - then the reason for such thinking becomes clear. As for "a panel of doctors and a public prosecutor", unfortunately, many of us observed, some more recently than others, as public figures and medical professionals acted out of considerations other than the best of their patients and the pure factual truth, and there is no reason to assume it could not happen again. Of course, it's not easy to conclusively prove that's what happened in each particular case, but there's nothing outrageous in assuming it might have happened, and "the doctor knows best" not always works, and "government employee knows best" works even less frequently.
If we know how to treat it - surely. If the treatment is "put them on hard drugs to make them a functional vegetable" - maybe not. Some old fashioned solutions are out of fashion for a reason. I agree that we should try hard, but there should be a limit of how hard. I have a feeling in this case the limit hasn't been reached, but it should exist. There should be an exit, just not to be used outside of most dire circumstances.
I would be. I mean, some illnesses can be intolerable, and gender has nothing to do with it, but I still feel very hard to believe nothing could be done to fix it, given the circumstances as described (no physical injury, youth, etc.) and can't shake the feeling that somehow this outcome is too normalized for comfort. Maybe it wasn't fixable, and maybe there was really nothing to be done, but somehow the tone of all messages feels like it's some normal, maybe even good outcome and not a terrible failure. I don't think it should feel normal.
It seems like the medical establishment can't be trusted to restrict it to only the most extreme cases
I'm generally very supportive of a person's right to do what they want with themselves, including ending their own life. But when I see state-run medical establishment nonchalantly offering it left and right, or according to other reports even strongly suggesting it, it just doesn't feel right. It definitely doesn't feel like "only the most extreme cases".
Seeing happy couples where the man is at least by some definition "conservative" I doubt the assertion that "young women hate conservative men". It may be that the women who would otherwise look for their romantic match online might hate "conservative men" - but even that is not true, I know for a fact there are conservative men who met their spouse online (even though not on Thiel's app). So there might be some segment of women that "hate conservative men" but I am pretty sure it's significantly narrower than "all women".
Also, "no women" is a pretty common problem for online dating platforms, as I heard (not sure if true as I got married before most of currently popular platforms even existed, but I read many times such a problem exists). Also I am pretty sure the author of Jan 6 review is lying, and I suspect all of them may be lying - it's not uncommon for people to post fake reviews for resources whose owners they hate.
Does Russia just limp along after with less energy revenue as a client state of China until their population implodes
Most likely. Or until Putin dies and they get lucky to have somebody more sane next to the throne, which will give them another couple of decades of partial recovery, after which we're likely back to sq. 1
Does Russia disintegrate into 20 countries
Not very likely, for now - the only areas with strong nationalist movements are in Caucasus, and I get distinct impression they are getting enough money and freedom from Moscow to not really want to do it on their own, on the condition that those who do think of doing it on their own are promptly murdered. As long as Moscow has any money, it'd work. And the priority of this deal is pretty high - from what I heard, on prisoners' exchanges any members of Kadyrov's forces get the highest priority, for example. The other regions just don't have any basis to separate. Maybe they'd grow it eventually, but that takes decades.
Or turn into a repeat of the 1990’s but much weaker now.
That's essentially the "lucky" branch of the first option.
There’s an ideal world where Putin is replaced by a new west friendly guy but do we get that world?
I don't think there are any "west friendly" guys left anywhere near power in Russia, Putin made sure of it. And even if this guy existed, he's somehow has to take power and deal with the opposition. Even if they somehow magically had the means and the forces to do it (from where?) it'd be basically a civil war, but I don't think there are any movement to pull it off at all. Pro-western liberals in Russia are largely either in jail or in exile now, and their support on the ground is minuscule. Nobody likes to be drafted and sent to die in Ukraine, but from that to a strong capable movement is a huge distance, and pro-western forces were quite impotent at their best times, now they are virtually non-existent as a political movement outside twitter.
Ukraine is getting it now, why do they need to give anything to Russia for that?
If "far right" were used to mean "not socialist" by the media, then the media would call non-socialist parties "far right".
That would only be true if the media had to use only one single term to describe the whole spectrum of parties. Then this term would either be "far right" or not, and your claim would be correct. However, in reality it uses a variety of terms, and some of them are used without any accuracy, as general pejorative labels. That doesn't mean the media always wants to use general perjoratives when talking about every party, of course.
what's (in my personal perspective) happened to The Motte
I am flattered to be elected (by a single vote, but apparently it's enough) a representative of the whole forum, but I think your lament is rather misguided and driven by misunderstanding more than anything. You may consider that if somebody tells you they didn't mean what you say they mean, then maybe they didn't mean what you say they mean.
If Ukrainians would believe any "offer" from Russia of that nature, they'd be idiots. I don't think they are.
Well of course the offer hasn't been made - because Russian needs Donetsk and Luhansk like they need a hole in the head. These regions never been that great, but now they're thoroughly ruined and would require billions to bring to even semblance of normal life. And there's not much anything useful to Russia there. The whole point of holding them has been to gain a beachhead for the ultimate move - subjugating and "reuniting" Ukraine with Russia. That was always a part of the plan. Crimea may be different as there's certain mythical status in the culture to owning Crimea, but nobody really wants the NRs that bad. It's just part of the ongoing conquest. There's no point of offering security guarantees for keeping the NRs because neither Russia ever intended to stop at them nor Ukraine ever will believe they intended so. If Ukrainians were desperate and on their last leg, they could accept a temporary piece to gain a respite - but that's what we had since 2014 essentially. There's no reason for Ukraine to end up in that situation again, especially now that they have the initiative and are liberating their territories, and there's no reason to assume Russia is capable of giving any "security guarantees" or is willing to do so. And how such guarantees would be enforced anyway - if Russia reneges, then what?
From what I understand, the guy is a billionaire. And I don't mean a puny $1.00001 billion, he has multiple of them. I don't think whether he sells more clothes is what primarily bothers him now. I mean yeah, some of these billions are linked to successfully selling clothes, but I don't think he raises and goes to bed with the thought about how today's sales were. I think he's in it for the cultural/political impact.

No they couldn't. If they could, they wouldn't need to vandalize others. If you can create your own universes, you just do that. If you can't - well, you either learn to code, or do sequels, reboots, derivatives and stuff like that.
More options
Context Copy link