JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
GoatGuns look kinda cool and I've considered getting one to fidget around with but probably won't.
I got one. It works great as an ornamental piece. Of course it doesn't have all the detail (that would be awesome but I doubt you can pull such thing off for 50 bucks). I do not regret getting it. It kinda sounds silly - what a tiny gun that doesn't work is useful for? - but turns out sometimes having some silly things around is enjoyable. I have no idea where I heard first about it though... theoretically could be an ad, I just don't remember.
Fair enough, would you change mind when it's not a politician? 60 Minutes, WSJ
No, because I am still not a high ranking politician. Deep personal scrutiny of high ranking politicians is an absolutely normal, moreover -necessary thing. With great power comes great responsibility. This responsibility, and attached scrutiny, is voluntarily accepted when the person wants to achieve the position of power. I do not hold a position of power and thus do not welcome scrutiny. If and when I will be (never!), then I would change my mind, and only then.
But I do think that it shouldn't be politically motivated either.
That's baloney - of course friends would not investigate friends, and if the politicians can't be scrutinized when the other party is in power, where that leaves us? Who would scrutinize them, and when? We can investigate Democrat criminals only if Obama personally approves, otherwise it's "politically motivated"? Nonsense. Part of the politics is keeping it clean (ok, clean-er) by attacking opposition politics who are dirty - because their own party definitely wouldn't attack them. This is A GOOD THING! That's the only way get at least some of the corrupt politicians down - the competition between politicians would make them use the dirt to attack those who are dirty, and thus hopefully push them out of the field and diminish the amount of dirt. This is how the competitive politics is supposed to work! It's not some dirty trick that we must condemn. It's the only thing standing between us and permanent oligarchy that usurps totalitarian power and never lets it go.
What would change your mind that is intimidation mostly?
Not sure I understand the question. Criminals being intimidated is a good thing. Honest people being intimidated is not a good thing. If you don't want to be subject to intimidation, maybe not committing mortgage fraud is a good starting point? It's not that hard, a lot of people manage it - but somehow, for prominent Demorcrats it's even harder than understanding why socialism doesn't work.
Trump knew or kinda knew about Epstein's proclivities during the 80s and 90s
That may be plausible, Trump is not exactly a saint himself, and being in business, you have to deal with all kinds of sleazy people, so until it didn't affect him personally, he might have at least heard the rumors and didn't care much while it stayed on the level of vague sleaziness. When Epstein started to mess with Trump's own grounds, he was promptly banned. It's unlikely Trump ever was involved in Epstein's shady business (as far as I understand, he didn't need anybody's help in that aspect of life anyway) but it's not unlikely he had some common dealings early on. But the note implies the level of intimacy that Trump has never demonstrated to anybody, and frankly is a harsh mismatch with anything he has ever done and how he behaved in public. It's something Hunter might do (I don't say he did, but his character - artistic pretense, etc. - would fit much better) but Trump wouldn't. If the allegation were he knew Epstein - nothing do deny, he did. Even that they for a while were friendly is true - so if somebody implied Trump sent a congratulatory note to Epstein on one of his birthdays, nothing to deny here either, he very well might have. But not this particular note, it's just not him.
Most of the speakers though come to say their thing - usually as well-structured, well-oiled, often repeated presentation, maybe answer a couple of questions, and move on. They usually don't come to engage in debate, and they do not set it up specifically as "I am here to debate you, come and argue with me, if you want, that's what I am here for". Maybe some do, I don't know, but most of the guest speakers I've seen expect mostly one-sided engagement. So if there are exceptions, that's what I want.
And yes, I realize that if we're talking about colleges, they are leftist sanctuaries. But even leftists occasionally disagree about something, not? And there might be other spaces where one could find and debate non-leftists, not?
We have a benchmark - Charlie Kirk himself. Compare to what he's been doing. If you need more, I'd be fine with any reasonably argued definition, but I'd define "open" as accessible to everyone, within reason (you can come to open mike, subject to physical availability, ask a question and get an answer from the debater, and be able to challenge the answer and at least briefly engage in discussion), and is explicitly advertised as such. And "debate" as a discussion of a topic where the sides perform a public two-directional dialogue where both sides are equally engaged. For the purposes of this question, this dialogue has to be synchronous.
I don't think you can really equate the two things.
Which two things? I'm not sure what is the second thing.
No, it won't be OK because I am not a high ranking politician. But if I run for a position with significant power and responsibility, yes, then it would not only be OK, it would be completely expected and is routinely happening. That is not the reason I do not commit fraud, but if I did commit fraud, I would expect this to be revealed if I try to get into the position of power. In fact, I want this happening as much as possible, so I could be reasonable sure people who are in the position of power and don't have any crime discovered about them are actually not criminal. The idea that if somebody is a politician then they are above scrutiny and any crime revealed about them must be dismissed because it's just "dirt" is the exact opposite of what I want to happen, and the exact opposite of what should be happening in a normally functioning democracy.
This can not be used as an example of Trump intimidating his enemies into silence - because it only applies to those of his enemies who are criminals (or at least can be reasonably argued to be criminals) and it's a direct responsibility of the executive branch to prosecute criminals. I do not think that the majority of Trump's opponents are criminals, so those of them who are not criminals would not have any fear of being accused in mortgage fraud - and to confirm, I don't know of anybody who had been baselessly accused of mortgage fraud as means of intimidation. True, being an active opponent may raise the chances of scrutiny and thus the chances of the crime being revealed, but the primary cause there is the crime, not intimidation. I want the criminals to be intimidated, and I do not want them to escape unpunished, whatever political persuasion they are.
I'd say I'm about 70% on it being real.
You need to adjust your bearings then. It's clearly your feelings about Trump cloud your judgement. It sounds absolutely nothing like him, and Trump is one person who had a very peculiar style and is not changing it for anybody. Not to mention it is made explicitly so that it would be impossible to attribute. Even Dan Rather's Killian letter hoax was better made. It's separately hilarious how all the Left has switched on a dime from "all Epstein theories are Q-anon stupid inventions, shut up already about it" to "everything about Epstein is real and it's the most important thing ever and Trump is surely in the middle of it!". And then right in the middle of it this thing shows up. I mean, how gullible you must be? Of course, TDS makes people believe anything. I thought "hookers peeing on Obama's bed" or whatever it was was dumb enough to instantly be seen as ridiculous - and I was wrong. This one is even dumber.
For one thing I feel like Trump and his camp are not convincingly behaving like it is not.
That's a very silly reason to make conclusions. Trump's camp have seen dozens if not hundreds of hoaxes over the years, and this one is so ridiculous it's hardly worth attention. And "oh, you deny it not strongly enough so it must be true!" is extremely dumb way to decide if anything is true. And the worst of it - it's the ONLY reason. There's no evidence of Trump doing something similar ever to anybody, there's no evidence of Trump ever writing in this style, there's no evidence of Trump even writing any other notes to Epstein. It's completely out of character, out of pattern and unsupported by anything. It's like you said you have a gangsta rap track personally recorded by late Queen of England - and despite it not being in her voice, her never doing anything like that and having zero evidence it's hers - you believe it for the sole reason the British government is "not behaving convincingly enough" to deny it (they deny it all right, but it doesn't convince you because - wait for it! - it's "not convincing!"). Come on, man!
Prosecuting crimes - even committed by Democrats, gasp! - is not "violence". Not to mention it's 1/10 of what the Democrats did to Trump and his allies when they were in power. And it's so easy to avoid - just don't lie on your mortgage applications (super-hard for Democrats, sorry)! I did several mortgage applications and never had to lie, why can't they do the same?
Security clearance is not some "human right", and removing it - from people who literally committed multiple frauds and lied for years in a plot to try and unseat the elected President - is certainly not "violence". Security clearance means the state trusts you with its secrets, and there's zero reason to trust those people with any secrets. As for Musk, it literally was just rants, nothing happened to Musk contracts. And even if it did, it certainly wouldn't be "violence". The lefties have very peculiar definition of "violence" - anything they don't like is "violence" except for, you know, actual violence that they do, up to and including murder - that's anything but.
Qatar was kind of friendly to Israel before
Welcome to our universe, stranger from far away realms! No, not in our universe, Qatar has never been friendly to Israel. Qatar was a major sponsor and enabler of Hamas instead. Qatar has been playing a game where they try to make themselves useful by serving as a middleman to Hamas, but there never was anything friendly in it.
and in the US pocket.
That's another part of the game. They try to be useful, in a hope that this excludes them from the consequences of their actions - such as hosting and supporting Hamas, which is engaged in active warfare with Israel. Turns out they aren't useful enough.
Greta flotilla drone attack
Which as I remember was actually some of theirs mishandling a flare (I suspect fun substances were involved because come on, we know who we're dealing with here).
Trump Epstein birthday card
This hoax is much older than last week, Snopes reported on it in July: https://www.snopes.com/news/2025/07/18/trump-epstein-birthday-card-drawing/ which is about when I remember it happening but maybe even earlier.
I've seen a tweet:
Note: there's not one prominent Leftist anywhere in the West doing what Charlie Kirk did, i.e. issuing an open debate challenge to all comers and saying "Here's my view, I invite you to try and prove me wrong". None of them are willing to subject their views to that scrutiny.
So my question is - is this true? Does anybody know a leftist that does what Kirk has been doing? I know some leftist bloggers - obviously Scott among them - that can argue their points with decent (in all senses) argument and manner. But it's still preaching, a blog is not an equal debate. Are there any debaters around?
That means that a) either there are some secret repositories of content which a lot of people can access, but somehow nobody ever can publish anything from there and everybody who has access is bound by an unbreakable vow to deny their existence; or b) literally everybody discussing this does it without actually doing the basic thing like watching the content they are discussing. Which is extremely sad.
What's the point? If you can't find multiple sources with a casual search, then clearly it's not something that had been important about him, either as a person or as a public figure. Most likely he didn't say it, and somebody just invented it or perverted what he actually said to mean the opposite. Maybe he did in a stupid moment and deleted it, who knows. It doesn't matter. This only is relevant if you subscribe to the idiotic "inner demon" theory - which most of the social media peoples do, of course, because it's stupid - where nearly everybody is actually a vile demon, but you can't exorcise the demon unless you have "proof", and when they finally say something that you can attribute to a vile demon, that "reveals" their inner true nature and this is the only thing that matters about them now and forever, and you can ignore everything else, and proceed to the exorcism. You just need to be on the lookout when the demon reveals itself.
Tyler Robinson trial probably not a lot - what matters for him is what relates to the murder, and the motive is easy to establish based on his own words alone, no need to dig deeper. However if the feds decide to go after his lover as an accomplice, there all kinds of weird shit may show up. Maybe even defense will bring it up - "you see, this guy is getting off looking at pandas, clearly he's bonkers and can't be expected to make a reasonable judgement".
If it's just general retarded talk then indeed the internets are full of it and the feds aren't going to bother with it. But if it's specific talk like mentioning specific plan, specific weapons and specific discussion, like where to hide the rifle and which way it's better to run away, then participation in such chat may be trouble. Probably not for "never talk to me about this again", unless the feds have a particular reason to haunt this person, because the likelihood of making a case on such basis is very small. But from what I read his pals may have been a bit more supportive than that... If that's true, they may have some unlpeasant time ahead of them.
From - not really because in general I would never buy anything based on ads alone. But I am using VPN that also had sponsored some youtube channels which I watched. I didn't decide to buy it because of that, but I can't say it didn't influence me in some way - it does have some alternatives which are also acceptable, and maybe if I've seen their ads I'd decide otherwise, hard to know. I.e. in general I'd never buy something I didn't previously know or research just because of ads, but I admit an ad can make me aware of something (which after research may prove worthy of buying, or not) or influence my choice between equally good alternatives. Didn't happen to me a lot but I have one example.
This is the most depressing part for me. I classify myself as a libertarian, and I disagree with the left way, way more than I do with the right, but I'd completely fine living aside them - including communists, despite my ancestors suffering a lot from the communist regime and me hating all that relates to that - I am willing to set that aside for the sake of having a pleasant, peaceful society. If only the Left agreed to play by a simple set of rules - no violence, no destroying the country, no destroying the culture. I am willing to only "destroy" them like Charlie Kirk and Ben Shapiro did - by showing, with fact and argument, again and again, how utterly ridiculous their views are and how disastrous the consequences of them - including for them themselves - they are. But there's no way I can have this. Every time they feel they are losing the power, they become violent. I don't see how this violence can be dealt with in a peaceful framework.
Should they have been killed? Probably not
Probably? That's how you know your moral compass is malfunctioning. When you ask yourself "how do I feel about brutally murdering a person that said something offensive to me?" and the answer is not "fuck no, not murder!" but "well, maybe no, maybe yes, he was really annoying so kinda murder sounds right but those people around me say murder is bad... so hard to figure this out... should I err on the safe side? Should I hedge more? It's really a tough conundrum!".
And, of course, you should only talk about punching other people's faces in if you're willing to have your own punched in for your opinions. Yes, I know yours doesn't smell. But that's how it works. I wouldn't accept this deal, I'd rather have a deal where nobody's face getting punched in, but maybe some people enjoy their faces being punched in?
There's a wide gap between "illegal" and "detrimental to the society", and it is not closeable in any reasonably organized society that allows any freedoms to its members. You have conflicting interests here - the consumers of healthcare want to have maximum care for minimum cost, the providers have limited resources which will never be enough to provide it, and the middlemen want to extract profits. There's not really an optimal arrangement that you could legislate. Even if you make a totalitarian dictatorship fully dedicated to regulating and distributing healthcare, you still will have people who think they don't get enough care, and some of them will blame the providers for it. Sure, you could legislate against some of the toxic behaviors, but you'd get a set of others in response, and another set of people being mad about it. US is not in a great spot here, for various reasons, but there will always be something to complain about.
Why the selective embracing/rebuking?
Cost/benefit. You can sell that healthcare CEO is a supervillain that deserves death, and some normies could buy it, because US healthcare system sucks, and a lot of people hate it. Selling that the guy whose only thing was to debate anybody who would talk to him was a supervillain is much harder.
"Unarmed leftist protesters" are prone to physically attacking people, just ask Andy Ngo. And "unarmed" is such a weasel word - if somebody bashes you skull in with a brick, was he "unarmed"? What about metal bike lock? Skateboard? Plain old glass bottle? Or the same filled with petrol and set on fire? Given how easy it is to conceal a knife, is there even a way to know somebody is "unarmed"? Especially when you facing a mob dressed in a way that is specifically designed to make them intimidating? In some situations, where people are clearly behaving aggressively, it's only prudent to assume they may escalate - and take measures to deter then from doing that.
And have you heard about the group named NFAC? Using the initials only to make it SFW. To be clear, I support the right of these guys to own arms as much as any other person, but what they are doing with their legally owned arms is nothing but intimidation. And Black Panthers are know for posting uniformed big guys "unarmed" with clubs at polling places - just to make coming there more fun and welcoming, I am sure. So when discussing intimidation, let's remember that.
But the most important thing is this: if those conservatives would want to intimidate you, they'd say "stay away from me, or else". What the left is saying is different - "shut up and cease to spread your message, or else". And "or else", in this case, is clearly demonstrated as being murder. And the lower ranks of the left explicitly and enthusiastically endorse it. They don't say "how horrible it is that it come to that", they say "what a joyous day, let's murder Musk and Trump next!".
This is just what the whole 2A/tree of liberty stuff is about.
No it is not. 2A is not for shooting people who try to debate us. 2A is for shooting people that try to shoot us. Or apply other form of explicit, organized and widespread violence. Kirk tried to talk to people, that's what he was shot for. It's the opposite of what 2A is about.
Of course it's political. We have a party that had been calling all the opponents "Nazis", "enemies of democracy", "worse than Hitler", and thousand more variants, and it had led to a number of murders and attempted murders already (anybody remembers James Hodgkinson?). It's not like it's some kind of random occurrence, a meteor strike out of the blue, a random victim of senseless violence outburst. It's a predictable result of a coordinated and deliberate campaign of hate. Yes, not literally everybody on the left participates in this campaign - but all observable leftist spaces are ripe with it, there are hundreds of examples, and there is no meaningful pushback on it. We know how hard the left can push to drive out an unpopular opinion. This obviously is not one of those opinions. No prominent leftist figure - except for Sen. Fetterman, who is an exception in many cases concerning the left nowdays - had done anything more than rote "oh noes, we don't endorse violence, please keep on keeping on" kind of condemnation. And many of those who is doing rote condemnations now had been participating in the hate campaign days or weeks before. People on the lower rungs of the ladder don't even bother with that - the leftist press if basically "well, he spoke things we didn't like, what do you expect would happen?!" and the masses on social media are like "good job, let's have a celebratory drink, who's next?" Yes, not literally everybody, but enough to see where the dominating vector is pointing to.
So yes, this is a political thing and it's totally appropriate to discuss it as a political thing. It's a political murder.
It's not Reddit that is a problem. Reddit allows the demons to reveal themselves, but it didn't create them. It's schools, academia, press, Hollywood and other cultural conduits that had normalized violence for years. Look how many teachers are publicly endorsing the murder. They all think it's completely fine, and encouraging more of it. And it's not like it's new - same happened after Trump assassinations and after Thompson murder. It's a deeply sick culture, whose sickness had been cultivated and endorsed for years, Reddit and bluesky just lay it bare for everybody to see.

Oh my, is it the "games make people commit terrorism" season again?
More options
Context Copy link