@JarJarJedi's banner p

JarJarJedi


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


				

User ID: 1118

JarJarJedi


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

					

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


					

User ID: 1118

Does that mean I should say I support trans rights, or that I want to protect trans kids?

You should. They are not owners of your expression, and they have the same ownership claim on the language as you and every other person on the planet. You should recognize their relationships are not the only possible (despite them pretending it is the case), and their language use is not the only correct one, and support the usage that agrees with your beliefs. At the same time, you should not be blind to what is happening in the world around, and be aware that there are forces that work hard at usurping control over the language and make "protect the kids" mean only agreeing with their ideology. Recognizing such attempts and calling them out (even if only inside your own head) is part of maintaining the habit of independent thought and mental hygiene.

though maybe you could point me to someone actually espousing precisely this position.

Pretty much every "yeet the teets" doctor and their support teams. I've just last month read a number of stories where parents turned for help to doctors like that and were pressed into doing hard meds at the explicit threat of imminent suicide (and probably surgeries too, I just didn't read a specific example of it lately). In fact, this specific threat was just quoted in this same topic, I did not invent it at all (I wish that wasn't the case, but it is).

Please work harder to portray your outgroup's views in a way they would be likely to recognize and agree to

They are already agreeing to it. Moreover, they are already doing it. Moreover, they are already calling people that object to it hateful bigots. How far along it should be going before I'm allowed to notice it?

You try to understand it as an individual entity, it is a wrong way to treat it. It is part of the network of relationships, and in this network it has a symbolic meaning, and that's how most people see it - as a sigil that marks the place of this person in the network of cultural relationships. Signs often have relational meanings - i.e. the sign "A" has meaning within English language when it is combined with others, but by itself it's just a weird geometric shape, there's nothing inherent in it. Most people pick (and sometimes over-pick) the relational and contextual clues and use them all the time, though I know autistic people often have trouble with doing this automatically.

It'd be weird if Gwen Stacy was someone who followed orders blindly and this was portrayed as a good thing,

Would it be? Marvel is woke, Sony is woke, whoever they hired to do this is undoubtedly woke. Being woke is assumed to be an obviously right thing that is not up to reflection. A thing where you instinctively know on which side (the right side) you are. So, a Spider Woman (!), of course, is woke too, as as a woke, she would have all the appropriate attributes, including this kind of poster. It just confirms to you that yes, this is the right side. Just as a red flag with hammer and sickle would tell one communist that she's in the company of another fellow communist. You don't need to deeply reflect on what the sickle actually means for you personally - it's part of the package.

we saw Uncle Aaron turn into a monster because he did whatever his boss said.

But was his boss woke? Did he give him the right kind of orders? Probably not. I might now know the details (I am not deeply knowledgeable in Marvel universe anyway, and given the direction it all took, it waned almost completely) but in general the whole concept of something being morally right vs morally wrong in the woke world hinges of whether or not it serves the right agenda. Real world example: is segregation bad? It was bad when it served the KKK agenda. It is good now, when it serves the equity agenda. The goals justify the means. If you are told the right thing by the right people, it is right for you to accept it and put in on a poster.

What does this phrase mean?

That you are woke and not a deplorable thoughtcriminal and want everybody to know it. That you are fully in sync with the latest agenda updates, and will execute whatever instructions are going to be uploaded next.

The only activist movement I hear about that specifically relates to trans children is their supposed right to medically transition, but my friend says I'm being uncharitable if I assume that that's what is being referred to.

The current release (as far as I know) of the agenda specifies that any child that expresses any interest or ideation about himself being transgender, should be immediately medically, socially and surgically transitioned, parents have no legitimate way to react to it except fully supporting and enabling it, and in case they do anything else, they should be immediately and irreversibly striped of all parental rights. Failing to do this will inevitably and imminently be leading to the child in question killing himself, and it would be the fault of everyone who did not do enough to enable it. That's what "protect" operationally means right now. But for somebody who has such a poster, it usually doesn't mean they reflected on all of that, considered all advantages and costs of such approach, and their own personal opinion, after deep reflection, is that this is what must happen. More likely, it means they are signaling their non-dissent from the agenda and willingness to lend their support to whatever is declared to be the right thing.

True enough but Trump is not really helping this, viciously attacking people in his own party when they try to become his competition, and often even when they don't but he feels (justifiably or not) slighted by them. This helps his personal brand, but doesn't help neither the GOP nor the base which needs things done, not an idol to worship. Well, to be honest, some do need an idol to worship, but it's not healthy and not helpful to them. Ultimately, they want the win (or at least a win) in the culture war, not a tragic hero that whines on Truth Social about how everybody prevents him from achieving true greatness.

But it's clear DeSantis doesn't have Trump's vision for diagnosing the problem

How it is clear?

And also, the problem is already diagnosed. We know the problem. We have whole books upon books of diagnoses. We have the proofs, we have the receipts, we have the emails and the laptops. What we don't have is the treatment plan, and Trump doesn't seem to be in any rush to propose any. While DeSantis seems to have some experimental treatments successfully applied in Florida. So, maybe it is time to move from vision to action?

those same people seem to like DeSantis

I would bet if DeSantis becomes lead Republican candidate, those people would trip over themselves to declare him literally Hitler. Just as it happened to Romney and McCain and Bush and all others. For now, he's not a threat to them, so they "like" him. When he becomes one, they'll show how much that liking is worth.

Was it less 'build the wall' and more who the frontman for building the wall was?

It was both. Trump had a combination of being the man who actually talks about building the wall and who is crazy enough to actually try building the wall (or draining the swamp). Before him, almost 100% of the GOP candidates weren't. Now that Trump tried to build the wall, but largely failed to complete it (and has no significant successes in draining the swamp), the case for him becomes weaker. Is it weak enough for somebody to challenge him? I don't know, but I notice he spends a lot more time pissing on DeSantis than he does on explaining how this time is different than the last one and why this time he will actually drain the swamp, unlike the last time. Of course, the former is much easier, but I'm not sure it'd be enough anymore.

but he fought the culture war like a champ.

The "fought" here does a lot of work. If you understand it as "engaged", then yes, he engaged a lot. If you understand it as "won", then no, we aren't tired of winning the culture war, in fact we're not even close to it, and Trump didn't do much to stop the victorious march of wokeness through the social institutions. All the feeble attempts he made were instantaneously reversed once he was gone, except maybe for the SCOTUS which has and will deliver some important wins, but even there it's not assured, and also SCOTUS can't rule the country or the culture, it's not its function. So I am not sure he really deserves the title of "champ" here.

By that standard New York or Boston would have been legitimate targets if the Nazis or Japanese had gotten the bomb first.

If the Nazis did, these cities would be (see what they did to Britain). I don't see what "legitimate" does here - nothing Nazis did was "legitimate", it would be just another crime they committed, among many.

I said he was a figure that for most of western history would be considered a "Hero of his nation"

And you are the only one who did so - no actual nation ever proclaimed anything like that, so the responsibility for such proclamation is squarely on you. You are either committing libel, or engaging in wishful thinking. Neither of these options is good.

ask a Native American about Lincoln

Lincoln is not venerated for what he did to Native Americans. I am amused that you think such a simple trick is going to work.

One could add the reverence modern Romanians have for Vlad Tepest

It's Tepesh, if you want to transcribe, but here you're confusing a mythical cultural figure with historical prototype. Also, I must notice here how far back you have to reach to support your point even with most flimsy and fictitious examples. Hitler didn't live in 15th century.

and the vast majority of people on planet earth (south asians, Middle easterners, Latin Americans, Chinese) AFTER even 1945.

First - and most important - morality is not a majority vote. If a billion people think genocide is just fine, it doesn't make it fine. Second, you claimed Hitler would be a hero in Western civilization, not it India or China or Bangladesh.

Hell the Chinese and Russians actually still STILL have personality cults

So they do. I don't see how it makes your argument any better. It's like trying to acquit a murdered by pointing out there are other murderers. Yes, there are. So?

and reverence for Mao and Stalin!

Not sure about China - it's really hard to understand what's going on there with all censorship and without knowing the language - but in Russia not many revere Stalin, mostly old farts whose reverence to Stalin is best described by a Russian expression "in Stalin's times, my dick was hard" and young idiots in search of most idiotic figure to worship to show they are different.

As great national leaders who fought for Chinese or Russian nationality

Stalin never fought for "Russian nationality", whatever that could mean. In fact, under Stalin, for mentioning something like that you'd probably be shot (after being tortured for a week or two to name the names of those people who gave you these ideas and those you shared them with) - there was only one nationality under Stalin, "Soviet people". And he never fought for them, either - they fought (and died, in millions) for him. That's the only was it worked.

they both killed vastly more than Hitler, and their victims were disproportionately their own people.

Could very well be true, both Mao and Stalin were one of the evilest people ever born. I fail to see how it gets us closer to any point of yours, though. It's not even "tu quoque", it's "ille quoque" - what it is supposed to prove?

Hilter is not some exception. He's the rule.

Rule of what? That there are evil people? Sure. He is a representative of the rule evil people exist, and he is an exceptionally evil - though, possibly, not uniquely evil - example of it.

but still better than Stalin, Mao or Genghis Khan

Better for what?

It can't say "I don't know" because it actually doesn't "know" anything. I mean, it could return the string "I don't know" if somebody told it that in such and such situation, this is what it should answer. But it doesn't actually have an idea of what it "knows" or "doesn't know". Fine-tuning just makes real answers more likely, but for making fake answers unlikely you should somehow make all potential fake texts be less probable than "I don't know" - I'm not sure how it is possible to do that, given infinite possible fake texts and not having them in the training set? You could limit it to saying things which are already confirmed by some text saying exactly the same thing - but that I expect would severely limit the usability, basically a search engine already does something like that.

It's not bizarre. It's literally how GPT (and LLMs in general) work. Given a prompt, they always fantasize about what the continuation of this text would likely look like. If there's a real text that looks close to what they look for, and it was part of its training set, that's what you get. If there's no text, it'd produce a text. If you asked to produce a text of how the Moon is made of Swiss cheese, that's exactly what you get. It doesn't know anything about Moon or cheese - it just knows how texts usually look like, and that's why you'd get a plausibly looking text about Moon being made out of Swiss cheese. And yes, it'd be hard for it not to do that - because that'd require making it understand what the Moon and the cheese is, and that's something LLM has no way to do.

Hiroshima and Nagasaki weren't "purely civilian cities" - not likely any major cities in Japan were, they were completely mobilized for war. Hiroshima had army and naval headquarters, was key military supply depot, military assembly point and had extensive war industry (which, btw, used slave labour). Same for Nagasaki.

it takes really special pleading to argue the Nazis were uniquely evil

It really takes a special... I don't even know what, to jump from "Nazis were not unique, there were other evil people in history" to "Hitler is an example of a hero of Western civilization". Any word that I can fish out doesn't even start to cover how boneheaded this jump is.

Ukrainians today all see him as a great hero of history.

No they don't. It's utter bullshit. Yes, I know all the supposed "examples" of some Ukrainian decades ago used some symbols that triggered somebody because it looked like Nazi estetics. And there are probably Nazis (and idiots) in Ukraine, just as they are in any other place. But no, "Ukrainians" - in any sane meaning of generalizing this term - do not see Hitler as a great hero of anything. That's just plain lie.

By contrast the great communist leaders were plagues upon their own nations.

Just as Hitler as a plague to his. I took Germany from being the most civilized and admired culture of the Western world to the most despised, he caused it to be split up - just recently after uniting, he completely destroyed the economy of course, he made a huge way into destroying the scientific potential and supply his enemy with the best and brightest minds of Europe - who could be all working for him if he weren't such a complete moron, half of his country were under Communists for half a century due to him, he created the situation which made it impossible for Germans to have political freedoms even now, and he also murdered a lot of Germans, as any totalitarians regime does. If Chinese communists were a "plague" on their country, Hitler was ten plagues on his - combined with all the evils he inflicted on the rest of the world.

There is a very good reason in the Western Democratic nations where society and the majority are supposed to control and make the government subserviently to them,

If you think Western Democracy is just the rule of the majority, you understand very little about how Western Democracy is supposed to work. Majority is stupid. Majority is fickle. Majority is hateful and manipulable. All the work the founders of the US did, designing this complex system, was because they didn't want it to be just the majority.

who only killed tens of millions in wartime.

For a totalitarian dictatorship, it's always wartime. If it's not today, it's certainly will be tomorrow. And of course, the totalitarian dictatorship kills as much as they can, at any time, including their own citizens - which happened in Germany too. The willful historical ignorance - especially when we're not talking about the times where barely a handful of sources survived but about times where the witnesses are still alive or were alive recently, which are extensively documented - is astonishing. But I guess, not very surprising.

I can't get over how utterly obnoxious most writing for the New Yorker is

I used to subscribe to it. This is the reason I cancelled.

What the fuck is this supposed to convey?

I think the general idea is that being just trans is so passé, you need to acquire more identity labels to be trendy, and the app is leading the way, while the person in question follows.

What the fucking hell has any of this to do with a dating app for pretentious fartknockers?

Ritual abuse of the outgroup is an important part of communication for the target group of New Yorker, I think.

80% of drivers think they are above average. For sex, that's probably 98%.

Given that the Soviets perpetrated their own massive anti-Jewish campaign right after the war ended, emphasizing Jewish suffering at the hands of the Nazis while sending them to Siberia would not be productive for them. That only changed in the 1960s, with overall "thaw" liberalization, where atrocities like Babi Yar were allowed to be remembered and came into the public view. Even then it was instructed to not over-emphasize the suffering of the Jews over all other peoples of the Soviet Union, but at least the topic has been opened for discussion, though the concept of the Holocaust, as an historical event, I think still didn't exist in Soviet cultural space until the 1990s.

They chose to help those poor, poor migrants. I don't think they chose to have murder and rape and mayhem. I mean, the latter is the consequence of the former, but I don't think they realized it when making the choice.

He doesn't need to impress anyone.

I never felt a particular reason to impress anyone either (well, maybe outside the period where I was on the dating market, but that was decades ago...) but I still like nice things. If I had so much money that it wasn't a question of price, I'd certainly buy a house that looks nice (to me) - not to impress anyone but because it is pleasant to live in a nice house.

His fellow billionaires think it is beautiful

How do you know? I mean, I don't know a lot of billionaires, to be honest, but I met some rich people, and their tastes in general aren't that different from the rest of the population. They are not aliens. It's not about my approval of course, it's about my understanding of why he did it. I am curious. I do not seek the power to approve Gates' decisions, I seek the understanding.

Yes, many right on the beach or very close. I recommend Scenic Rd in particular, it's always nice to walk there. I have no idea where were they built (last time I was there, which was a couple years ago by now, some were still building, though I have no idea how they came out) - I could probably find out, but never bothered. Maybe it's a very expensive and arduous process to get anything approved there (most likely it is), but those people somehow (probably - lots of money and connections?) managed to get through it.

What prompts this entire rigamarole in the first place?

The government is supposed to be "doing something". Of course, they can not fix the problem - both for the ideological reasons (that'd require to recognize there are other issues in play than "systemic racism") and for practical ones (doing the police work that needs to be done requires resources that they'd rather spend elsewhere). But this is an excellent opportunity to distribute some of the taxpayers' money to a network of NGOs and other parasites created for this explicit purpose. I am sure this program will be a great success in what its true aim is - sucking millions out of the city budget and redistributing them to a myriad of grifters. It wouldn't do squat about shoplifting, of course, but that's only for the better - that means they can complain the current budget is not enough and ask to double it next year.

I liked that one. Of course, given that they had Odenkirk, it was expected. Again, Odenkirk being almost 60 (and to be honest, he didn't look that "youthful" way before that either) does not detract from the fun.

I saw pretty interesting houses, say, in Carmel. So California is not at fault here I think.