JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
Depending on how big the "+" part is... I am reasonably fluent in 3 languages (meaning, can maintain a conversation, read a newspaper, would likely understand about any book not specifically written to be incomprehensible, etc.) and can easily understand another one though not speak fluently, for the lack of practice. Not a genius by any measure. So I'd imagine if somebody had real skills and worked on it... I don't see why achieving something like 8-10 would be impossible. I mean, once you got once Romance language, a reasonable effort would probably give you about 5 of them. Add German and English, you're already at 7. Then you can add Dutch and Norwegian and Swedish, since you already familiar with Germanics, and you've got 10. And we didn't even have to leave Europe!
Seeing this I gained a lot of respect for Magnus (not that I didn't respect him before, but I respect him even more now). Having a talent can happen to anybody. Developing a talent takes a lot of hard work and dedication. But not letting this talent alone take over your life and subsume all of you, being the ultimate master of your life while keeping the talent - this is a sign of greatness.
Why isn’t he playing in the world chess championship right now?
Because he doesn't want to? He has proven to himself what he wanted to prove. He doesn't owe anything to anybody.
How did chess of all things become about hanging out with chicks?
Maybe some chess club somewhere prayed extra extra extra hard?
although I disagree that it is easy
I never said it's easy. I deal with security professionally from time to time (though mode code security than people security) and I would never use the word "easy" when it comes to security. Yes, it requires effort, thought, careful application and the most important, as you very correctly noted - "organisation that actually cares". Of these, the US military has plenty of resources and access to plenty of smart people, more than capable to solve such problems - but as I suspect, it is just not that kind of organization. They say they care, but in the immortal words of Forrest Gump, careless is as careless does.
every colonel has given his keys to the janitor at some point
I have no doubts fuckups happened and will happen, now and forever on. Most of all in the military. What I am more interested in is what happens after. Does the colonel lose their chance to become general and gains eternal shame, demotion to managing the least important storage of old socks in the nation, and derision of all his peers - or he keeps failing upwards until one day he may become Chief of Staff? Is there some push to make it happen less often, on the usual SNAFU response?
I think this is also not very important who exactly is defined as "Marxist". It's just a word, if we use another word to define the same set of folks, sharing roughly the same ideology and occupying now most of the academic space, the outcome would be the same. "Marxist" is a convenient word because it gives a good estimate what this ideology is about and where its roots come from, and I think it is not a bad estimate. But if the word is the problem one can use any other word, that's not the point and there's no use to get bogged down in trying to refine the precise definition if we already know what we're talking about.
Exactly. We now have a couple of generations of "subversive conformism" - where the culture behaves as if it still were 1960s and there were some "establishment" they are fighting, but they are not fighting any establishment actually, because they have been the establishment for decades now and has (mostly successfully) suppressed everybody who dissented from them. That's why they need constructs like "systemic racism" and "patriarchy" to maintain the image of rebelling against an overwhelming force, while actually being one.
What's "correct social, political or religious beliefs"?
Anyway, let's imagine a fantastical situation. A group of Nazi scientists (and I mean hardcore Nazis with all accompanying beliefs) from parallel universe gets into today's America and by some means (e.g. by temporarily hiding their beliefs) manages to take over a small Higher Education institution (still bearing the title of University because it's good for PR) in some state. They proceed with a program to find smart youth of proper Aryan background and indoctrinate them and educate them in sciences (let's assume they are really good scientists) and thus make sure only devoted Aryan scientists fully on board with Nazi ideology can be professors in this establishment. They teach all the usual scientific stuff, but with a Nazi bent, and also have a variety of more specific courses, like how Jews are evil, how homosexuality is ruinous for civilization, how to scientifically figure out people's worth depending on their genetics, which genetical defects can be cured and which should be exterminated, maybe the history of Aryan races and Aryan culture, maybe even a course on Nitzche and Wagner (with some appropriate bent of course), etc.
Now, let's say they are not particularly hiding it, and the citizens of the state discover they have a full blown Nazi University in the middle of the state, supported by their tax dollars, participating in career fairs, inviting their schoolchildren to campus tours, publishing their own newspaper (with appropriate graphics of course), holding their big celebration on April 20 each year, and so on, you get the picture. Do you think the good people of this state would say "well, it's a University, and they are technically not doing anything against the law - sure, the stuff they are teaching sounds vile to us, but we can't subject them to governmental sanitization, that wouldn't be University anymore!" Or, do you think they'd grab torches and pitchforks and would demand to raze it all to the ground, and would destroy any politician that would object to that? Or would they do something in between - like find any legal means, however tortured and far-reaching, to destroy this outlet without technically violating the law and committing outright violence, maybe?
And if you think people would not tolerate a Nazi University - what set of principles would you propose that would be consistent with that, but also with your ideal of a University as something completely and utterly independent and subject to no outside control whatsoever?
I think the university should be a hothouse of strange and controversial ideas.
That would be nice, but that's not how it worked now for decades. Instead, how it works is that it is a hothouse of ideas that are strange and controversial to an ordinary man on the street, but all these ideas are completely mainstream and mandatory inside the hothouse. You're getting whole institutions where there's no single professor or administrator to the right of Bernie Sanders, and if one, by some strange accident, shows up and starts stirring controversy, they are silenced - and usually, expelled from the hothouse - very quickly. Some may tolerate one or two tokens, held around to show - here we have freedom, we keep this whole one moderately-right-wing professor out of 250! So what we actually have is a monocultural hothouse, which looks strange from the outside, but does not allow any substantial dissent on the inside. Academic freedom is a nice concept, except it hasn't functionally existed on most of the American campuses for a long time - you are free to only lean to the left, as far as you want, but never to the right.
Even worse, they are still trading on the image of "intellectual powerhouse" and pretend that this monoculture is the result of superiority of their ideas to any others, and unfortunately this still carries a large cultural and political merit. Something like "a study from Big University has shown that" can make or bury a law, a social program and sometimes even a career of a politician, despite it being known that Big University has not had a single non-Marxist professor in relevant field since 1960s and multiple examples of studies from the same University being shoddily made, non-reproducible and ultimately completely debunked on every replication attempt.
So, do you have to wonder why the Right politicians finally make their first timid steps to take control of this political and cultural weapons platform that has been used by the Left for decades now to completely devastate the opposition?
I still think it's important that we have at least one institution that acts as a countervailing force to utilitarian profit-maximizing techbroism
There are many institutions that can act as such. But, you may consider that most of the utilitarian profit-maximizing techbros are actually products of the very system you present as an alternative to them. How comes?
But if the choice is between the university we have now, or nothing, I'll stick with the university.
It's never nothing. If we won't have the current Marxist indoctrination camps plus spectator sports empires plus adult daycare for chatterati class younglings, we'll have something else. And maybe even better, who knows.
A far bigger deal is that large organisations don't want to lose data to a forgotten password - where the organisation can, of course, also "forget" a password by virtue of the person who knows it ragequitting or falling under a bus.
This is all solvable - and largely solved - problems. There are multi-key schemes where you could store passwords in a place that can be unlocked, for example, by using any two (or any other numbers) keys out of N - so each top officer on the base gets one of those master keys, and then if such situation happens, they call two or three of them together and unlock that password. One of the ways to do it, another just make multi-key encryption to the data itself (it's practically the same thing as nobody uses passwords now to directly encrypt data, there are usually intermediate keys anyway).
Even if you use some kind of off-the-shelf commercial product that does not support easy password recovery, because of course as an US Army with trillion dollar budget and its own research branch that invented the freaking internet, you are not able to use state-of-art technologies, there are still off-the-shelf products that offer password management and recovery. It's not something that nobody else heard of, it's a known problem with known solutions.
the (generally relatively junior) IT guy who handles password recovery can steal your data
Only if you design your security poorly. Day-to-day password recovery should require something that the legit user has and IT guy doesn't (phone, card, device, name of the dog, whatever - there are dozens of ways). Hit-by-a-bus password recovery should require participation of higher level key holders - and they should bear the responsibility for the misuse (aka you give your colonel's keys to the janitor - you may get early retirement and never make a general, etc.) There are a lot of schemas that allows to handle it without giving access to IT janitor to every single bit of top secret data.
Of course if somebody in the government does something we don't understand, it always because they have their ineffable ways, which can not be understood by mere mortals. Never attribute to inefficiency and rigidity of humongous bureaucracy what you could attribute to ineffability and unknowable reasons.
There's two ways to handle it - one is to prove not all government funded media is the same (one may start by not using deceptive tricks like the graph described above) and another is to scream "how dare you publish true information about us" and ragequit. CBC chose the latter, because the former is probably too hard for them.
So in other words, he would pass a background check. As indeed we know he did.
You keep saying it as if it means something. That's a cargo cult behavior - insisting that if some formal criteria is satisfied, then the actual problem, which this formal criteria was supposed to answer (but does not) is actually solved, by virtue of satisfying the formalities, and the evidence that it is very much not solved is just noise, as long as we look back at the formal criteria, all is fine.
How would you know?
I can't know for sure, but it seems highly implausible that anybody - let alone a low-level 21 year old recruit - could have a job that required him to access this breadth and depth of information. Of course, theoretically it is possible that this Air National Guard airbase is exactly the place where Ukrainian counter-offensive strategy is forged, despite National Guard and US Air Force having nothing to do with it, and this is exactly the place where also intelligence information about Israel and South Korea is concentrated, again for some reason as this has nothing to do with National Guard or Air Force, and at the same place the reports about intelligence collected from Russians is sent, and also this is the place which is responsible to reacting to hacker attacks on Canadian energy infrastructure - and in the center of all this sits the master spy, the indispensable man, the nerve center of US intelligence community - 21-year-old super-mega-ultra-agent Texeira, which rules all this spying kingdom. I leave it to you to decide what is more plausible - this scenario or that security compartmentalization and audit practices in US Army are bad, and you are just arguing for the sake of arguing.
Certainly he has a background; he's 21 years old, not a newborn.
He's not Brett Kavanaugh, so what he did in high school hardly matters. If he did something that does matter, like having a criminal record, he probably wouldn't be nowhere near that position anyway, in fact probably wouldn't be in the National Guard to begin with.
Texeira didn't have access to the US government's entire classified output either, of course.
He had much more access than his work needed him to, that's the point.
the audit trail would let them trace forward to find and question those who could have leaked them.
You're saying like existence of that trail is an established fact, but it's not. I strongly suspect it in fact does not exist.
Who has been through the background check process and gotten a security clearance.
He has no "background" to speak of, so background check is useless. Justifying the failure by "but look, here's the checklist we designed, and all the checks are checked! We even used the fully approved pen and the font is in full accordance with regulations!" is a very clear example of turning it into a cargo cult.
did you not get access to all sorts of company confidential documents right away?
Nope, I did not. I now have 30 years experience and an impressive sounding title, and I still don't have access to a lot of company documents or permissions, and I am glad I do not.
because your job required working with those documents
Texeira's job did not require working with those documents. That's the point. Nothing in Texeira's job required knowing how the Ukrainian counter-offensive preparations are going and what Russians think about it. In fact, I don't think I'd be too wrong if I assume there probably no more than one or two persons on that whole base, and maybe none, who needed to know anything about that.
Who said the access wasn't audited?
It's obvious from the fact that they didn't know where it came from and for how long it was allowed to continue unchecked. If there were audit, it'd discover who accessed those docs and the general pattern of accessing docs he has no business accessing very quickly.
People in classified environments aren't working in a panopticon with their superiors suspecting them all the time
They should be. Somehow the rest of us living in a panopticon gets much less pushback than people working with "top secret" documents being supervised while reviewing those documents. If anybody deserved the panopticon, it's them.
The audit trail is useful after the fact once it's known the documents had been leaked.
And yet, that's not how Texeira has been found out - instead, open-source researchers and journalists talking to his game buddies got to the target first.
I mean, I agree, but this seems like a fully general argument against planning for the future.
No, you missed half of it. What it should have been is "you know who else called to sacrifice present morality in service of the bright future? Hitler!". Yes, I am ready to stand behind this comparison.
Obama's "well spoken" and, i guess, reasonably competent speeches were often praised as moving, compelling, causing goosebumps or tears!
I am not sure it's a good example, as Obama is practically a religious figure to many, they'd be in tears if he read the yellow pages. The question is, in a hundred years, which of Obama speeches would they study in high school as an example of rhetoric brilliance? I'd go for "none of them".
but I'm not sure why you think it was somehow obvious before the fact that he wasn't.
You don't just give 21 yo who you've just hired recently (obviously, you couldn't have hired him while he's in high school) the keys to the castle with zero supervision. No matter if he looks super trustworthy, it is not how it should work. In fact, I see no reason why non-audited access to the documents should be given to anyone, and why anyone should be accessing this level of documents without leaving the audit trail and probably raising some alerts as to why these documents are accessed by a person who has no tasks assigned related to these documents. Like, you don't have to initiate full-scale FBI investigation immediately, but if his supervisor got an alert that the guy who is supposed to be a technician is accessing the docs about Ukraine and Israel and what not, which he has no business with - and if he's a competent manager - he'd call him and ask him what is going on, and all this charade may have not gotten out of hand as it did.
I think most of democratic societies depend on that - you can not have civil rights and have a system that does not depend on the vast majority of people being good faith. As defection becomes the norm and is celebrated, people that liked it as it were before start demanding on heavier enforcement. China leads the way, but social score will probably happen in the US too, at least if they find a way to make it compatible with DIE ideology and explain to the AIs how to make it racist in the right way without making it racist in the wrong way. On the other side, as more and more people feel the system is obviously not working for them, the drive to defect would become stronger. Why be good and work hard if lazy and evil people prosper in front of your very eyes? Traditional moral systems (like Christianity, but not exclusively of course, there are many more) had an answer to that, but they are domestic terrorists now. And the new civic religions pretty much declare the modern Western civilization the root of all evils, so they can't really be relied on to counter the decline and destruction.
Unfortunately, to some degree, that was Texeira.
Somebody appointed him to that position. Somebody supervised him. It's not like US Air Force command structure is Biden - Charles Q. Brown Jr. (had to look him up) - Texeira. There's probably some layers in between, and people in those layers have direct responsibility for hiring and supervising their subordinates. Which means, whoever led to the situation where Texeira had full and unsupervised access to secret documents he had no business accessing - failed at their duty. What I am interested in is who these people were and did they suffer (or will suffer) any consequences, commensurate with the degree of their failure.
I don't have much of a horse in this fight as I don't think I ever drunk a can of Bud Light and never intend to unless I'll be dying from thirst and Bud Light would be the only source of liquids on the whole planet. That was true before they set their brand on fire. So not much changed for me. Except that they make a very convenient target to make an example of them, and if it will successfully be made, it would be a good victory in the culture war - something that very rarely happens on the right.
One thing I find interesting to discuss though - how comes Don Jr. came into defense of Bud Light? https://www.foxnews.com/politics/donald-trump-jr-opposes-bud-light-boycott-citing-company-donations-republicans I mean yeah, they gave some sweet $$$ to Republicans, but come on, read the room, dude. Why the fuck would we need money given to Republican politicians if they refuse to help us not to be completely destroyed in the culture war? How much money they give to him to shoot himself in the foot like that?
I may also note every movement that murdered millions of people in 20th century was doing it for the sake of the future. Maybe it suggests some pattern here? Some general rule, like "if you see somebody calling for suspension of moral inhibitions today, for the sake of the bright future, you may be looking at somebody, killing whom by time travelers would be a common topic in future science fiction works". Or at least I'd be very, very cautions with such claims, just on the strength of the prior experience.
When I was a kid and my father taught me how to play chess, the most useful lesson was this: "remember, in chess there are turns - after each of your turns, the opponent gets to do his. If you have a plan which only accounts for your side, it's going to survive for about one turn". I am quite mediocre chess player, but most of what I can play, I owe mostly to this lesson. Somehow, when developing Galaxy-brain size plans, people completely forget they are not the only actors and think everybody else is an NPC that would sit and wait until activated by their plan, and then act exactly in a way their plan needs them to. It is not so.
Making compute platforms a very rare and insanely prized resource would create an opportunity to profit by producing them. Of course, the bootleg ones would be of inferior quality, unreliable and extremely expensive. But if it would mean for India getting advantage over Pakistan - or vice versa - and not just some small advantage, but superpower-sized advantage - they'd do it, whatever it costs. They'd bribe whoever needs to be bribed, steal whatever needs to be stolen and spend as much as will need to be spent (and murder if somebody would need to be murdered, have no doubt about it). When we're in cooperation mode, of course it's much easier and cheaper to buy this stuff. But this leads to a dangerous illusion where you think that since everybody is buying the stuff from you, you're in control of everything. This is a common mistake, most recently made by one Vladimir Putin, for example.
In truth, if cooperation breaks down, there are always alternatives. Inferior, more expensive, less pleasant - but they exist, and they will be used if the preferred venue is no longer available. If the US would go to war with the world over AI, the world would learn to live without the US, and the AI will still be created - assuming, of course, current road indeed leads to AI creation. Maybe 20 years later, and maybe it will speak Chinese or Hindi - not sure how it's better - but saying "everybody will bend to my will because I have this MacGuffin" rarely works. People will find a way around, if the incentive is large enough - and if the claims of the alarmists are true, the incentive here is nearly infinite.
Why is it necessary to give someone permission to read the contents of a file in the course of network maintenance, support, and upgrades?
It is not. However, working with encrypted files is harder than with plaintext ones, e.g. something like search is much harder (though with recent advanced in homomorphic cryptography may be finally possible). On top of that, from what experience I have hard with government systems, they are often old, technologically backwards and poorly maintained. And the Higher Powers usually do not understand how the systems work and what is the conditions there, until it's too late (i.e. seeing the article in WaPo about a security leak).
someone needs to do janitor duty in the closed area
True, but the secret documents don't have to be laying around, ready to be photographed, when they do it. There are such things as safes.
literal janitors are going to be granted top secret clearances
Don't see how it follows. Getting physical access to where the safe stands and getting inside the safe is two different things. That's kinda the whole point of the concept of the safe.

I think it's possible. It just requires indoctrinating them into the culture which The Experts (TM) currently consider "white supremacist". And this is not something that will be done, especially as making black kids perform better would mean also making them and their kid middle class, with middle class voting patterns. And who needs that trouble? Certainly not people who are now in power in places where there are a lot of black kids. They already have the votes locked in, thankyouverymuch, and they don't need to mess with a working system.
More options
Context Copy link