JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
That's my point - for a mildly liberal normie, who still doesn't want their kids life to be sacrificed on the altar of Trans, there's no support system. There are a lot of people like that, in fact majority of the people I know would likely qualify.
There's a difference between evaluating risk for oneself and being pressured to do allow procedure on a kid. People are usually much more vulnerable to manipulation via the kids than via their own fears (think of the children!).
If you think that puberty blockers don't actually reduce the risk of suicide
I have no idea what the statistic is. We're not talking about averages and populations here. Bludgeoning parents with the suicide threat on the first sign of child being confused about his identity is not something that a honest specialist would do. If there was substantial risk of suicide, and the parents would ask about it, then the specialist should provide options to reduce it. Using it as a bludgeon is despicable.
Not tell their parents about it?
Tell it when such risk is relevant. "Complicated" is not an universal excuse - consent may be complicated, not using underhanded tactics to force it - is not.
It's possible to explain, but an average parent probably would need a specialist support. Only there are no specialists that can support them now - there's woke transing disassembly line on one side, and I guess there's some conservative Christian support options which one probably wouldn't even consider if you aren't already a conservative Christian, and of which I know next to nothing, and so probably the average parent. And in modern Western world, where most people don't have the ingrained reflex of "the system is not your friend, it will hurt you and all you love" - this becomes an easy trap to fall into.
They especially and annoyingly split hairs in that they admit the doctors said trans teens kill themselves without treatment, but the doctors never said they would specifically. See, totally no longer pressuring the parent!
Ah yes, the regulators don't let us to tell you your kid will kill himself if not put on puberty blockers, but since we can't tell you your kid will kill himself we can tell you other kids, who are totally not your kid, kill themselves all the time, but we're not talking about your kid, because the regulators would not allow us that. So, no pressure, totally your decision whether you want your kid to kill himself or not, we have no idea what'd happen, or at least we're not allowed to tell you what's happen, only that all other kids who are completely not your kid, did kill themselves, so you can choose anything you like. Also please sign here that we totally didn't pressure you about anything like telling you your kid would kill himself.
Been reading an article about the child "transgender" story and something really caught my attention. The quote first:
Casey expressed no discomfort with his sex as a child, but when he turned 13, he said, he discovered through friends and online that “transgenderism was a thing.” He started researching this and felt, “Holy crap! You can do that?” Soon he declared he was “gender fluid.” Casey explains, “This means that my gender changed based on the day. Then it got to the point where I was never feeling masculine or like a boy.” After about six months of being gender fluid, Casey says, “I decided that I was a fully transgender girl. Like I wanted to present as a girl and I wanted people to see me as a girl. So, I started to socially transition. I was going by a different name and using she/her pronouns.”
That lasted for a few more months until, he says, “I started to lean more kind of in-between. I didn't identify as a girl as much. But I did not see myself as a boy, so I identified as non-binary, which is what I am today.” He explains being non-binary means he is neither sex, and to go along with this he changed his name again—to something as gender neutral as “Casey”—and began using they/them pronouns.
So there I realized even though I am very far from woke, the propaganda has warped my understanding of the issue too. I was thinking what happens in such cases is some child suddenly starts very strongly feeling that they are the opposite gender, and then the system gets involved and "affirms" them in their delusion. But what is happening here is nothing of the sort. It's more like childish fascination with the unknown and unexplored and cool, which gets turned into much bigger thing that it should be by both the parents who are completely unable to provide the child the necessary structure ("just be what you are", wtf is that, that's not a kind of help the confused child lost in a confusing world needs) and the system which actively problematizes and medicalizes any case it can get the hold on.
The result is predictable - the system deploys the tactical nuke of "if you won't transition now, you child will surely kill himself and it'll be your fault", the parents fold like wet paper, child gets put on puberty blockers, develops severe mental problems, has to take five medications at the same time, becomes suicidal, the system reacts "see, we told you! if we didn't rescue them in time, them'd be dead already!" and refuses to budge. The parents finally see what a huge fuckup they did and start running around, screaming and writing articles.
The article worth a full read, but this was the part that struck me the most. It was how easy it was to get from a childish curiosity about "you can do that weird thing? really? let me try it on!" to being pulled into the machine and turned into a case and somebody whose life would forever be dependent on the medical system (and, of course, forever "oppressed"). I thought it's more like "X has a severe problem and it's hard to solve it and looks like the system doesn't always do the right thing the right way" but it's more of "X has been playing and waded too far into the woods, and the ideological ogres captured him and made his life into a problem with which he'll now have to live forever". Which is quite infuriating to me in its pure evilness.
It's a continuation of the norm-breaking that led to electing Trump. Or, in other words, the supposed "norms" have been norms only to one side, but not the other - and the indictment is added to the long list of these one-sided norms, where Democrats are routinely doing things they claim shouldn't be done because of the "norms". It's not the new complaint, it's the same complaint over and over and over and over.
Falsely claiming that a major party candidate is ineligible is an attack on American democracy
Oh come on, tone down the drama. Such claims existed long before. Exhibit 1: https://www.sethkaller.com/item/1415-23425-Claims-that-First-Republican-Presidential-Candidate-is-Foreign-Born-&-Ineligible&from=12
Important! to the Public ... The Republican Candidate for the Presidency, John C. Fremont, of Foreign Birth
That's 1856. Somehow, the American Democracy (R) (TM) has survived this attack, which can't be called the worse since Pearl Harbor or the Civil War only because it predates both.
Fundamentally, the scary thing about Trump is that he behaves as if American elections are kayfabe on top of an underlying system of raw power politics
So, he behaves as if what significant part of his electorate believes and observes is true - is true? What a scoundrel! The norm for a candidate is to pretend he cares about his electorate, and then once elected, wear a nice tuxedo or dress, show up at gala receptions, get the appropriate pork allocations from taxpayer's money and otherwise not rock the boat.
which any wrestling promoter knows can destroy the franchise
Now you're starting to get it. This franchise is no longer serving the people that are supposedly their clients (an apt metaphor, because most entertainment franchises, such as ones of Hollywood, also moved on from serving the people to serving a tiny sliver of increasingly bizarre elite critics) - so it's time to break some things.
The question is not whether Trump is personally corrupt - to be honest, nobody cares much if he took or given a bribe or two. The reason he was elected is not because he's a saint personally, it is to try and break the whole corrupt system - where the problem is not personal corruption, which can be dealt with by replacing the corrupt individual, but systemic perversion of the whole power structure. So, for those who elected him, Trump defecting is exactly why they elected him - because cooperating hasn't been working for them for decades now, and they feel like the other side is already been defecting for a long while, and it's time to respond in kind.
violate democratic norms, such as by calling on Russia to release hacked emails or stating that both the 2016 and 2020 election results were rigged
These are good examples, because neither of them actually violates any democratic norms. It does violate the norms of behavior that the elite political class has set up - mostly not for themselves but for others - but that's, again, why Trump is there in the first place. Whining about elections being rigged is the staple of American politics - but when the Left has been doing it about Bush, that was par for the course. Asking KGB's Andropov to help with fighting Reagan was par for the course. Arranging with Medvedev to be "more flexible after the elections" is par for the course. Getting millions from Russian banks and oligarchs for "charity purposes" is par for the course. It's when the Right is suspected of doing a tiny bit of something similar by themselves - then it's a norm violation, they're not supposed to do it to us, we're supposed to do it to them! That's exactly the norms that the deplorables wanted to be violated.
why the norm of "presidents gracefully concede elections and don't challenge the results" exists
But does it really? Maybe the Democrat President did not have to personally challenge the results - he had hundreds of lieutenants to do it for him. The deplorables do not have the army of lieutenants that the systemic president, chosen by the system, has. So they can not rely on a network of proxies to do the job, if anything can lead this on the deplorable side, it's Trump. But the norm of "elections are never questioned" does not exist - it's all pretend. Bush results were questioned all the time, Stacy Abrams still claims her election was stolen and she is not seen as norm violator - I know her title as The President of Earth may not qualify, but she is still quite prominent to illustrate that this supposed "norm" is fake - it works only towards one side and not the other. Such are almost all "norms" that Trump has "violated".
To me, it sounds a bit like those people that tell us AGW will kill us in the next 10 years, since early 1980s. Oh, interesting thought, maybe if in 6 months we'll all be doomed due to AGI, we can stop being worried about being doomed due to AGW?
In the ragged parlance of the youth: "human government has been tested and found wanting time and again" is not the own you think it is.
I don't think it's the "own". I think if you say "it will kill us all because X would happen" and I say "X is already happening and we are not dead yet" then it's pretty good argument that the direct casual link between X and killing us all is not established.
doesn't mean you shouldn't be worried about something even more distant and ineffable making your existence look like a burden on the universe
I am worried about a lot of things. Death, disease, government turning fascist, that kind of thing. If AI ever reaches the level of being worry-worthy, sure, I'd worry about that part too. I am just not seeing the "my child won't survive to adulthood" part.
The AI has a more plausible shot at Total World Domination than the slapdash great power competition that we've been under for a few centuries.
That needs to be established. High IQ nerds think being able to do some tasks fast means total power, but somehow I don't see too many high IQ nerds in power. Even among people having Tons of Money not everyone at all is high IQ nerds, and the percentage of billionaires among high IQ nerds is not as large as they'd likely wish. So even imagining they'd build an electronic super-high-IQ nerd - which so far isn't proven at all, though seems more plausible than before - I am not sure it is established this means Total World Domination.
Do you consider punishing any form of providing fake election information to be going to far?
This is an absolutist statement that tries to paint it as binary option - either nothing at all related to the elections is prosecuted, or anything can be prosecuted if only it could be attached to the election somehow. Of course, neither is the case. Some things - like destroying equipment, physically preventing voters from coming in, intimidating voters, etc. - can be prosecuted (though often aren't, see Black Panters ). Others - like publishing jokes and memes - shouldn't. When there is prosecution, the actual occurrence of the crime - i.e. specific people prevented from voting in a manner that violates their rights (i.e., for example, not convinced to not vote) should be proven beyond reasonable doubt.
OK so trademark infringement and wire fraud are present here, if they were present in my example, no?
That'd require using the actual official insignia, and as far as I know, it didn't happen.
Do you have the trial transcripts or any reporting from the courtroom?
No, but I have reporting that clearly indicates there was no proof of any case of not voting as a result of that and the prosecution relied on messages to the number alone. Of course, as we all know, reporting can be false - and if you provide reliable reporting to the contrary, I will re-evaluate my opinion. So far it didn't happen.
I think it's important to distinguish lies that attempt to influence voters from lies that attempt to inhibit voters
Sure. If you blow up a polling station, or ruin the road leading to one, or sabotage people's cars so they can't come to the election - or all your voting machines have mysterious malfunction all over the district and voters can't vote for many hours - there could be grounds for prosecution. At least if Democrats don't win there could be. But just putting a meme (clearly a ridiculous one) out there on the internet doesn't do any of that.
The case here was about an attempt to prevent people from voting by deceiving them into believing they had successfully voted when they had not.
That needs to be proven, and it wasn't.
The right you have as a citizen is to cast your ballot. Interfering with that right
Nobody interfered with that right. The assumption that some idiot didn't vote - which is not proven even in a single case! - is not interfering with the right, they very well could vote if they wanted to. If I convince you not to go to vote, because it's useless and the system is rigged - would I be convicted for "interfering with the rights"? After all, as we all know, "the system is rigged" is a lie, or at least the government knows that, which is enough - and here you go. Then if I try to convince people that they shouldn't vote for a certain candidate who is running unopposed, because he's a piece of shit - that also would be interfering with elections. Then there's almost no space left between that and jailing me for advocating any electoral position - after all, if I convince you to vote certain way, I also convinced you not to vote some other way, and we already agreed convincing you not to vote is a crime.
Being called "fascist" by most of the media at once is a given, comes with being a Republican candidate, and has been so since "fascist" has been a thing (really, it's amazing how fast this word came into use in US politics - even before WW2!) - so, since there were Republicans elected since then, it's possible to deal with it successfully.
I'm not claiming all children are going to be murdered in less than 20 years.
Well, you personally aren't, but Yudkowski is. Or at least this is implied since there's no special reason to select his child from others to be murdered, one can reasonably conclude whatever applies to his child also applies to all other children.
I'm saying we're probably giving up what little control we had over the future of human civilization
I don't think so. At least not anything we have. I am also not sure who is in control "over the future of human civilization" right now, because so far whoever they are, they're not doing spectacular job. I mean, 18-th century war in the middle of Europe? Dudes, you were supposed to be so past that. Our only response to a threat like pandemic seems to be "let's try fascism, whatever will happen it'd be better with fascism, right?" Our solution to raising energy needs seems to be "let's try to shut down our most effective ways of getting energy and then invest heavily into ways that we know for a fact wouldn't satisfy our needs, and then let's shame each other for having needs. Oh, and destroying classical cultural artifacts on the way doesn't hurt too, just for fun". I'm not feeling there's any entity or entities that do anything that can be reasonably called "in control", but if they are - I certainly have no input into that and no reasonable way to ever get any close to having any input into that. So tell me again what I should be afraid of losing?
Once we start, we'll never be able to stop.
We're not able to stop writing, or using electricity, or modern medicine. But that doesn't mean any of those lead us to catastrophic consequences.
Something else I just thought about. We know about dozens of people who knowingly distributed false information connected to elections - namely, the lie that Biden's laptop has been a foreign intelligence fake. We know that it significantly influenced the elections. We know there wasn't not only a single conviction but even a single attempt to open investigation into the matter. I think this should bury the idea that anybody is interested in prosecuting "election interference" that is committed by lying. Not that I would call for it - on the contrary, such a prosecution would be as big a spit in the face of the First Amendment as this one is, but it doesn't happen. Which clearly establishes the zeal for truth, even misguided, is not why this prosecution happened. What was the real motive I leave as the exercise for the reader.
If I copy the exact logos and formatting of my county board of elections and mail out postcards to registered Republicans telling them their polling place is moved, should that be a crime?
It'd likely be several crimes - using official insignia without permission, probably some kind of trademark violation, likely mail fraud, etc. The content of the envelope wouldn't really add much. None of this happened in this case. This is like somebody being prosecuted for peacefully protesting against a politician and you'd say "there should be a line somewhere - if he murdered him, dismembered the body, liquified it in acid, and set his house on fire - that should be a crime, right?" Yes, it should be. Nothing like that happened though.
In this case, there is concrete evidence that a large number of people were likely deceived
No there isn't. There's evidence they contacted the number. That's not proving any crime, and definitely not the one that was insinuated. It used to be that the crimes have to be proved. Not "well, he did something that we could imply that might be connected to something else", but the actual deed that is criminal.There was no proof for that. Even if there was, it'd be very questionable it is a crime - at least there should be a proof of criminal intent, if I just tell you "you know they cancelled elections?" and you believe it, it's not a crime. But they didn't do even the minimal thing. Because they didn't need to - finding a friendly jury which will convict anybody who is politically opposed to them is, apparently, much easier.
it seems extremely likely at least some of them would have actually voted but for the conduct undertaken.
You saying "would have" as if it were established they didn't. There's no single case where it was proven any of those people din't vote the normal way. You just assumed that - because it couldn't be The Powers screwed up that badly, could it? Yes, it could.
I genuinely don't know if enough evidence was presented to reach the threshold of actually causing a large harm to identifiable specific people
No, there wasn't, and they didn't even try that hard to do it. Probably because they counted on people assuming what they had is enough - and indeed, as we see, it was. Don't complain when you get a friendly local policeman show up at your door for a joke on twitter - after all, somebody could take it seriously - you see, 3 people liked it! - and that could mislead him into voting for a wrong person (not Democrat), and that's election interference. Hope you like them bananas.
You forgot about "the process is the punishment" part. How much do you think preparing a case for Supreme Court costs? In case the Court wants to bother with it, which is not even guaranteed - so you could spend all this money to prepare the petition and then don't even get a hearing. Would the perspective of undergoing multi-year and ruinously expensive process deter you from criticizing certain politicians (remember, comrade: nobody ever gets prosecuted for memes about Trump!) or wouldn't it?
That's BS - I have seen dozens of such jokes, from both sides, close to every election previously. And nobody ever on the Trump side complained about it as an evidence of fraud. While we are seeing here that the Biden side is not just complaining - but prosecuting a person for it. But still somehow it's Trump's fault, amazingly.
Of course, 4900 unique numbers might not mean 4900 people whose votes were prevented, who knows.
It used to be, in non-banana-republic countries, the prosecution had to prove such things. As far as I know, they didn't prove a single case of anyone being prevented from voting. Of course, now "it could happen, who knows" is proof enough to convict a person.
Wasn't the whole thing in the Larry Flint defamation case that the speech he was accused of was blatantly untrue to the point of being ridiculous?
In any case, this seems to be building grounds for prosecuting people for "misinformation" - which, as we know, is anything the government doesn't want to be said. If the government can prosecute any speech it declares false, and the only barrier is finding a jury with correct political inclinations, then the 1st amendment provides no protection about government prosecution anymore.
Well, the banana republic stuff seems to be picking up. It used to be the case that at least you can't be prosecuted by the state for speech in the US. That wall has fallen too now.
And it's not like Republicans didn't try exactly the same strategy before. There was Romney. There was McCain. Both were duly declared literally Hitlers and both lost. But of course, true pandering to socialists has never been tried yet.
I don't have anything to rely on but my previous experience. My and humankind's previous experience tell me: a) totalitarians killed literally millions of people, all in service of the goals that they considered noble and existentially important and b) so far, every time we were told something would surely kill everybody it didn't, and not for the lack of such predictions. Of course, it could very well happen that this time it's different and it will kill everybody. But I see no way to establish that, and the bar for resorting to measures that are already known to kill millions is very, very high, and merely proclaiming "yes, those guys all were wrong and false prohpets, but it's different with me, I am the real prophet" - it's just not enough. I understand that it could be very frustrating for a real prophet, but it doesn't mean I would abandon my reason.

On the other hand, some people Bought Large Mansions, and I imagine otherwise benefitted from millions poured into the myriad of BLM-affiliated NGOs. So it's not a total waste, a lot of people got worse off, but a small number of people got much better. That's called "politics". Or "community organizing"? Not sure about the proper terminology here.
More options
Context Copy link