JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
The character is Jewish and Jewish identity (and anti-Semitism) is still Very Important in 2083 - okay, I'll buy it
Well, Jews have history much longer than 60 years, and for a lot of these years the questions of identity and anti-Semitism were pretty important. It'd be strange if that suddenly stopped right now.
At the end of this speech, one of the aliens comes out as nonbinary
Wait, so they're saying even in alien civilizations, among the stars, on the endless expanses of the Universe, being a "nonbinary" is so controversial and unusual that you need a special "coming out" act to recognize that? It's not some stupid quirk of a patriarchal Western culture, it's actually a universal law of the Universe itself?
Your Betters decided it. Just follow the latest twitter hashtags, and you'd know what you should resist this week.
For the wokes, it's not even nearly the same level. The Pride flag expresses best hopes and feelings of millions, is a symbol of all that is best in our nation and quite possibly is a sacred object, while the National Anthem is a symbol of systemically racist oppressive society and constant reminder of suffering and oppression every person who became a multi-millionaire for playing a game is subject to. There can't be any comparison.
For any recent literary work, encountering "subverts" in a friendly review for me would be a huge red flag. That usually means a derivative work concentrated on pushing a point while using somebody's else creation as a prop. Very few people can do anything decent with this as a toolkit. Even less among those capable of it would want to - if you are that powerful, you do your own thing, not mock somebody else's. If you are a Creator, you make elves. If you are not, you make orcs out of somebody else's elves.
I'm not sure what's to justify there. Kaepernick has protested for Good Thing (TM), thus protest is good and exercise of freedom. Reimer has protested for Bad Thing (TM) thus protest is bad and should be suppressed. If you try to dig up any deeper principle behind this - there isn't any. If we're winning it's good, if they're winning, it's bad. Them's the rules and there are no others. All talk about same standards and one playing field and all that is racist anyway, I'm sure one could find a dozen of quotes from Berkley professors on that.
It's not the lack of self-awareness. They know how it looks - and they are fine with it. It's an exercise of power - yes, there are different rules for Good Thing and Bad Thing, and yes, we will claim diametrically opposing arguments to support those - what you're going to do? What you can do? Point out the hypocrisy and inconsistency? They don't care, it works for them just fine. Your next move?
I've never seen the same kind of outrage about others among the nerds
I've been seeing it everywhere since 2016. The nerds, who imagined themselves philosopher-kings by proxy, were completely shocked and outraged that their obvious choice - which, on their opinion, wasn't really a choice at all, just confirming the obvious - hasn't been implemented. They have been determined ever since to not let it be repeated - and explicitly said so, many times on many occasions. To achieve it, extreme intolerance to anybody who does not align themselves with the party line, is necessary, thus the outrage directed at those who dare to break the ranks. Musk didn't just slightly broke the ranks - he captured one of their major platforms, and let his hordes rampage through it. The hate is fully expected.
They are still fantasizing about Twitter going down, and you even see media outlets constantly writing about Twitter's "problems" since Musk too over.
Remember that they murdered Parler (1.0) and tried to murder Gab. And, as you can witness looking at the address bar of your browser, cleansed Reddit of thoughtcriminals. And they destroyed a number of smaller platforms. Of course they want Twitter to go down - it's captured by the enemy! They want every single no-woke site to go down. And of course the media will savor any problem with Twitter - it's the problem that the enemy has, it should be highlighted to confirm that the enemy is stupid and evil.
What's interesting is that Musk haters is not just the woke, you'll find even libertarians and conservatives in the mix.
Well, any celebrity has base amount of haters (sometimes deservedly, nobody is perfect and being a celebrity highlights the faults). Musk just has that plus all the wokes hate him by default.
"Believe" feels like a wrong word there. If it's an argument, I'd definitely be more inclined to follow succinct and clear argument more than a complex and windy and obscure one. If it's just a statement, then I guess a simple one would make it easier for me to evaluate, but for something like "The Moon is made of swiss cheese" isn't not going to make me more likely to accept it as the truth.
More jobs at AI startups, especially for people that can make Python code run faster? Of course, that depends a lot on whether the fed will continue printing money (likely so, you all see what happens if they try to stop).
Now if you asked 30 years... that may be a harder question.
I've known people that did sex change, but not very closely - more like professional relationship. Wasn't really impacted by the sex change - in my line of work, the sex bits aren't very relevant anyway.
Not that I have seen, but so far Musk is getting pretty standard treatment for any celebrity figure that dares to be publicly not woke. Peterson, Thiel, etc. Of course, the fact that he owns Tesla and wokes love Teslas adds some spice to the mix, but otherwise nothing out of the routine thoughtcriminal bashing.
How many books do you read from before 1920?
The older I get, the more I see how the books from before 1920 are very relevant today. I understand that may be survivor bias - the ones that were not worthy just perished, and the one I find are those that withstood the test of time - but I am very willing to benefit from this process. In fact, almost all of the fiction that I read currently is pre-2000, though some of it is post-1920.
I think you overestimate the value of negotiating. Things like chemical weapons weren't largely phased out because they were effective but high-minded people managed to convince the generals not to use them. They were phased out because generals discovered dumping explosives on the enemy is much more efficient, and the fact that for some reason high-minded people hate them less for it is just a pleasant bonus. So if the generals find out AI-controlled drone swarms are effective, they start using it, and no negotiation will help any, because the defectors would just smash the opposition with their hordes of AI-controlled drones and laugh at all the signed treaties. Negotiations hold when the BATNA is bad. If you have a functioning army of AI-controlled drones, and your opponents don't, you BATNA doesn't look that bad.
The only alternative is that some superpower for some reason would threaten to smash anyone who uses the drones by other, no less effective, means and nobody would be able to withstand their might, but for some reason that superpower is reluctant to use AI-powered drones. That requires single pre-established superpower that has near-religious superstitions against the AI. It could happen that the US (or, if US keeps electing nonagenarians and obsessing about pronouns in the military, China) would take on itself such a role, but so far I don't see any signs of it happening. The US is not nearly powerful enough to pull off such things, and doesn't seem to want to be - half of the US wants to sit on their backyard and grill, and another half wants to destroy the Western civilization to atone for the sins of centuries past.
Giving up Taiwan would certainly prove once and for all that US is not that power. And would eliminate any reason to negotiate with the US - if we don't, what they'd do? Put a hashtag out on Twitter? Which would put the pressure on the US to develop their own drone swarms, because clearly all the bad guys aren't afraid of anything anymore and they are doing it, so we must too, or our grilling would be threatened, and that's unacceptable. Summarily, I don't see any scenario where US giving up does not raise the probability of any arms race. I can't think of any example where unilateral disarmament made the opponent more peaceful and less willing to develop and deploy new weaponry.
Or its not even charged in the first place because the cops just picked up a bunch of people fleeing a crime scene and don't have the time to bother.
That very well may be the case, but in this case I don't think we have much basis for the claim that all of them were violent dealers? I mean, just fleeing doesn't really give us enough data to make such a conclusion, does it?
Russia's bureaucrats have always been notoriously corrupt
All totalitarian bureaucrats are notoriously corrupt. At least ones that are members of any sufficiently large state. It's impossible to find enough fanatics, and the temptation of unchecked power is just too great.
were incredibly effective
The Economist slightly disagrees: https://www.economist.com/china/2019/03/21/chinas-strong-arm-approach-to-drug-addiction-does-not-work
It may be that as many other "incredible effective" totalitarian policies, they are only reported as effective because it was reported so. I am admittedly no expert at all on China drug policies, but if you need to put 320K people per year into camps, I don't think you have solved the problem in an "incredible effective" manner. Same if you need to execute thousands of people per year - I mean surely the CCP sees zero problem with that, but in my opinion, if you still have thousands to execute every year, declaring the problem "ended" is a bit premature.
We are vey far from skynets now, and there seems to be no desire from the military to grab it and run with it (if anything, US military is more occupied by getting woke than by anything else). Even if China somehow makes breakthrough and develops a skynet, not sure how it'd help them in taking Taiwan - they don't lack anything for it that would be helped by having a skynet. So I don't see how gifting Taiwan to China changes anything - if Chinese have the capability to develop a skynet (which I don't think they do), and would think it would be beneficial to them, then they would develop it anyway. I think unless you deny agency to every nation in the world besides the US - which some people who are automatically attribute all problems in the world to "US meddling" clearly do - there's no scenario in which "China + Taiwan" is less dangerous than just China. Especially given that controlling Taiwan means controlling large amount of electronic manufacturing - which, guess what, would be necessary for making a skynet. Unless, of course, the end goal of the scenario is crippling US AI capabilities, as the only nation capable of developing a skynet, and assuming no other nation would be able to do it.
For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong.
That's not what I'm saying. Harshness of the solution is not the issue. We don't need public executions of weed smokers. At least it won't fix public space decay problems. What is likely to fix it is consistent enforcement of quality-of-life crimes. It won't fix the drug abuse - but it would prevent it from messing up the lives of ordinary citizens not participating in it. However, the society took the conscious decision that the welfare of drug addicts is more important than the quality of life of the rest of the society.
In practice, there are open smoking areas in every city for marijuana.
Because when you fighting something for 50 years and there's no sight of winning, at some point the third generation into it stops taking it seriously. I mean, if it's ok for The President to smoke it (and yes, he inhaled) why it's not ok for anybody else?
The people actually incarcerated for drugs are almost universally dealers
"Dealers" is a very flexible term. In fact, it's not a legal term at all - IIRC the legal description is "possession with intent to distribute". From what I understand, "intent to distribute" may be as much as having a couple of bags of weed in your pocket while being in area where drugs are routinely sold (how else would you get those into your pocket - it's not like you can have Uber deliver it to you, at least not in prohibition places). And since like 95% of cases never see the trial, how many of those "dealers" were actual dealers and how many were just druggies caught with their weekly stash - anybody's guess?
The non-violent imprisoned drug dealer is so rare as to be a rounding error.
this: https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/dofp12.pdf says 52% of inmates are in for drug offenses and only 4.8% for violent offenses. If everybody who is in jail for drugs were convicted of violent crimes, I don't think there would be 10x difference. In fact, 44% of marijuana convicts and 48% of cocaine convicts have no previous criminal history.
Similarly, the vast majority of women who sell sex in the US are not like Aella they are like the street walkers you'll find in the shitty parts of any city. These women tend to be addicts, tend to have a fraught relationship with "consent" (is it really consent if their pimps beat them for not making enough money?)
Is this based on any data? I've heard claims of diametrically opposing nature (from "nobody is ever forced to do sex work nowadays, it's completely voluntary because it's the easiest job ever, you're literally born with everything you need for it" to "vast majority of sex workers are forced into it and trafficked and nobody talks about it") but I have no way to verify it. I've read self-reports from several Aella-type sex workers but I imagine I wouldn't have access to the opposite stories as opposite cases probably won't be very active on the internet, and I have no independent means to research this. So how would one know if it's true or not?
but many studies have shown legalization increases human trafficking
Prostitution is legal in Nevada, though with limitations. How much did that increase the human trafficking in Nevada compared to, say, Oregon and California? I read Las Vegas does have issues with underage prostitution, but ironically prostitution is not legal in Las Vegas at all.
Part of this does fall on the left which has a weird sort of allergy to rules, no matter how well meaning.
They do? The same people who write humongous lists of micro-agressions, lengthy manuals about how to ask somebody for their gender without offending them, institute Rules of Conduct, Diversity Statements and Bias Incident Reporting Policies? The same that regularly rewrite books and change old TV shows to remove anything not matching the current directives of the Party? I think they are plenty fine with rules - as long as it is their rules, that they have developed and have all the power of enforcement over them. Replace violent smelly drug addict on a train with a clean-shaven white supremacist calling other people n-word, and see how fast the rules enforcement will be called in. They are just fine with you being harassed by a violent druggie because you are the oppressor and the druggie is the oppressed, so you get what you deserve.
If a ticket (assuming enforcement of having a ticket) were $10 or more,
Who cares, they'd jump the gate or just break it. If there's no police around, who'd stop them?
isolate themselves from the effects of luxury beliefs like "we should prioritize the feelings and welfare of criminals over having orderly public places"
This makes a lot of sense, but I know a number of residents of SF, Oakland and other places like that, who aren't in any way rich enough to avoid the effects of the luxury beliefs, and they still largely support the policies that led to them. I mean, they're certainly not happy about people pooping on the streets or open drug markets, not to mention unending car breakins and other criminality, but somehow they never make the conclusion the policies they support are responsible for it. They just think it's "wrong Socialism" and as soon as they figure out how to make "true Socialism, that has never been tried" - which is right around the corner, we only need to tweak a couple of things and spend a couple of billions more - and it all will be fixed.
Indeed local government is currently involved in a fight with the metro because the metro makes homeless people get off its trains at the end of the line, annoying residents of Long Beach and Santa Monica who want to force them to let the homeless stay on the trains overnight(!) so they don't enter the wider city. That the homeless problem could be solved rather than forced upon someone else is seemingly uninteresting.
I have never been to Addis-Abeba, but I have a suspicion that if a homeless person tries to camp in metro there, the police would come, take him out immediately, and if he persists, would apply some kinetic persuasion to convince him it's not a good idea. What they wouldn't do is to have a wokefest about "safe spaces" and "holistic solutions" and have 25 NGOs with billion-sized budgets write white papers about the problem, while prohibiting the police from addressing it on the ground. I am not advocating that AA approach is better - and it's certainly less humane towards the homeless - but it is certainly different. It's not that the solution is a total mystery - it's that LA (and others) decided, as a society, that they don't like that solution, and so far they were unable to find any other one. Obviously, the money is not the barrier here - if you don't know what to do, no amount of money would help you.
Lock the addicts up, slaughter the dealers, forget about the problem
I have an idea. We should have some catchy name to this approach. I propose "War on Drugs". If we could pull off something like that, I imagine in a couple of years we'd be done. If only somebody would have such an idea sometime earlier, let's say about 1971... We'd never even know such a problem existed at all. Too bad we only got to this now.
I'd argue US drug policy is not "woke" at all - in fact, this is one of the rarest case where I'd like it to be closer to what the wokes think. I mean, we still have marijuana as Schedule I federally. There's no substantial distinction between highly addictive and non-addictive drugs. The whole policy is a mishmash of nonsensical historical baggage and moral panic. And the population is largely OK with it because they don't care - they aren't drug users (unless they're ill and need strong painkillers, in which case sucks to be you) and drug users look ugly, so just put the boot on their faces and be done with it.
As for the idea that totalitarianism can stop drugs - I'd propose you a question - did USSR have drug addicts? If you research this question, you may find that your faith in the effectiveness of totalitarian regimes in suppressing problems like drug abuse would be substantially eroded.
none of that outright comes out and says that castration is forbidden
Well, the way Jewish religious law works, a lot of things are derived and not spelled out specifically and explicitly, that's just how the system works. Of course, for non-Jew there are much smaller number of requirements (and they probably care much less about what Jewish law says about them anyway). There's also a significant disagreement about this question in the Talmud: https://shulchanaruchharav.com/halacha/castration-sterilization-to-humans-and-animals/ and the resolution for non-Jews seems to be along the lines of "unclear, but better to think it's prohibited just in case" (which is a common case in Jewish law in general to go this way if there's a possibility something might be prohibited but no clear resolution either way). For Jews, of course, it's a strong definite "no". Would be interesting to see what Christian religious law says about it, but I have to idea even where to look. But I imagine they didn't stop at the literal text of the Bible either and have their own thoughts on the matter.

Never heard of anti-snoring pillow - what's the mechanism? Would be glad to hear any reports too.
More options
Context Copy link