JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
This approach seems different from how the law works in other areas. If you steal something and you are caught, the law doesn't say "it's enough that we took back what you have stolen and also everybody knows you're a thief". It you forge a check - the law doesn't say "enough that bank detected it and didn't pay out anything". Usually restitution and reversing the immediate consequences of a crime is only a small part of what happens, and there's a punitive aspect which is aimed to deter people from defecting. Usually the argument is because otherwise there's no deterrent for me to not commit the crime - i.e. if I lie on the stand, worst thing they catch me and I lose the case. But if I tell the truth, I'll lose the case anyway, so there's no downside for me not to lie - absent the punitive deterrent. Why doesn't it apply in the case of perjury?
How do we know that they didn't just misremember, or that they were mistaken, or that they were misled? Etc. Getting slam dunk evidence otherwise is very rare.
But 95% of criminal convictions don't even see the trial - why nobody tries to at least get some guilty pleas on perjury?
As for knowledge - in the specific case Miller testified that the messages that she was part of don't exist. I think unless she proves she was struck by a bout of very convenient amnesia, it is pretty clear she knew the messages in fact existed. I mean, if somebody actually wanted to do it.
That presumes OWS has "threatened things" in any noticeable manner, which is an extremely implausible assumption. OWS was half trust fund kids in search for a noble cause and half anarchists looking for shit to stir up. The latter moved on to antifa (which eventually aligned itself with idpol because why not, as good excuse to set shit on fire as any) and the former I imagine moved to the position of VP DIE or similar because that's exactly a position I'd expect somebody with a lot of energy, best credentials parents' money can buy, absolute conviction in one's moral superiority and absolutely no useful skills to occupy.
I am a firm proponent of legalization, but I'd say this makes some sense. I am personally much more upset about the consequences of the drug bans (and the horrible "War on Drugs") and the theoretical loss of freedom aspect of it than by actual hardships involved in being personally unable to consume drugs (which for marijuana in the US is none anyway, you can get it practically anywhere easily, even if it's not legal there), especially since I never had any desire to consume any (besides alcohol). This does not apply to medical marijuana though - the fact that marijuana is still officially considered by Federal government as Schedule I - i.e. having zero medical uses - is a colossal idiocy. Everybody knows it's a lie and it harms a lot of people, and still this persists. But for recreational purposes - yes, I'd say the direct effect of such a ban on me is pretty much zero. I still oppose it on the other grounds, but probably I'd feel much less upset than about something that involved personally infringing my freedom and making my personal life worse. Such as COVID lockdowns, for example, which did insane, totally infuriating amount of harm.
Curious about something that I didn't find answer for in all SVB-adjacent reporting. If FDIC takes over a bank, as I understand they'd eventually sell all the assets, return all the deposits, pay off all the creditors, as much as possible, etc. However, there could be the case that the ultimate value of the assets is over the value of liabilities (I guess not a common case for a failed bank, but it could happen). What happens with the rest of the money then? Does FDIC take it for itself? Is it distributed to former shareholders? Something else happens?
But perjury is a criminal matter, is it not? So there shouldn't be the need to demonstrate anybody specifically harmed by it, at least in theory? In practice, of course, cops routinely get away with crimes much more heinous than perjury. I wonder though why there's no interest in prosecuting perjury at all and why we are still pretending testimony is worth anything if lying under oath has almost no consequences.
Just had Ticketmaster suggest GvF to me, literally an hour ago, I kid you not. What a coincidence. I guess now I have to check them out?
Qualified immunity is absolute travesty, but I understand it protects from civil lawsuit in situations where it is not clearly established the government official was acting unlawfully. Here it is a clear case of perjury, which as far as I know is a criminal matter, and I think it is pretty clear to a law enforcement officer testifying in court that outright lying is not lawful? I don't think there's any principle that justify this, it's just how it happens that there's no consequences for government officials.
Most of the trans culture wars have nothing to do with sex. The question of whether a person featuring a penis should be allowed to school girls locking room is not about sex (at least I hope it isn't for the majority of the audience?). The question whether a person having male body structure should be allowed to beat women to a pulp or leave them far back in the dust on the sports arena has nothing to do with sex. The question whether a person convicted for raping a woman using his penis should be jailed together with other women because he suddenly felt he's a women once convicted - is not about sex (at least not about consensual sex, anyway). The question whether female esthetician should be forced to handle somebody's cock and balls because they feel female this morning is not about sex. The question whether a person should have a power to control the speech of everybody on this planet if they think they must use certain words when speaking about that person is not about sex. The question whether we can be allowed to talk about women having babies and men having erections or it is a crime which has to be prosecuted with full force of governmental repression is not about sex. The question whether a grotesque parody of a woman should be presented to kindergarten aged kids as the best possible role model for their future socialization is not about sex. The question whether a kid having doubts about their sexual development should have their genitals cut off as soon as possible without any input from the parents is not about sex. The question whether a person should be deprived of their rights and means to earn sustenance and forced to spend the rest of the days as an outcast to the society because they dared to have an opinion on any of the previous questions that diverged from the one prescribed by the Official Dogma is not about sex.
There are grocery stores with better, cheaper and more variety of food than US supermarkets everywhere
I've never been to Kyoto (maybe one day), but I severely doubt it about Chelyabinsk. I haven't been there either, but I have been to many many other Soviet city, and central planned system does not allow too much variety. So the way it works in Soviet cities (I am talking about 20th century of course, post-Soviet period is a bit different - the places are the same but the patterns shifted a bit) is that you have one bigger store (compared to US supermarket like Safeway) per micro-district and a bunch of smaller specialized stores (basically, bread, milk, eggs, basic veggies, you're done). The smaller stores are within ~10 mins walk from your dwelling usually. The bigger one would be about 20 minutes walk (on average, you could happen to live right next to it - or have to walk more, but probably no more than 30 minutes). No public transportation whatsoever within the micro-district whatsoever, if you can't walk for 20 minutes loaded with all the groceries that you need, you are so much screwed. Find someone who can, or subsist on the basic choices available in the mini-stores. The choice in the larger store would be about as good as in a below average US supermarket, with corrections for local conditions of course. The situation is a bit different if you live in the center of the city (majority of people don't since it'd be a) very expensive and b) there's just not that much residential space in the center) or in the places which are not part of the system of the micro-districts for reasons of remoteness or history. In the former, you'd probably have access to closer stores, in the latter you'd have to go farther.
The situation has changed a bit in post-Soviet times due to several factors: 1. people got access to personal transportation (of course nobody planned the parking nearly enough to cover the needs, so the parking situation usually would be not ideal) 2. There's now informal public transportation networks supplementing official transportation and 3. There are private markets and mini-stores popping up everywhere, which are usually hideously ugly, but significantly improve access to goods and groceries.
Tolkien in general spoke numerous times agains explicit ham-fisted allegories. He preferred to work in much more subtle manner and let the reader derive conclusions from the whole story in it's full richness rather than do primitive pattern-matching. E.g.:
"I cordially dislike allegory in all its manifestations, and always have done so since I grew old and wary enough to detect its presence. I much prefer history – true or feigned– with its varied applicability to the thought and experience of readers. I think that many confuse applicability with allegory, but the one resides in the freedom of the reader, and the other in the purposed domination of the author."
I wouldn't be surprised if they did. I am not Christian, but if I were, and there would be a choice between a church where I feel nice and welcome, but whose official doctrine is slightly different than mine (not to the point where visiting this church would be religiously forbidden for me, if that's even a thing) and one that matches my views exactly but doesn't work very well for me socially - I'd rather go to the former. Reducing it to just "music" is probably too narrow, but I think social aspect in general should not be underestimated.
I also heard numerous cases of Christians changing denominations for reasons like moving, marriage, etc. I don't think their thoughts about God and the ways to worship Him changed instantly with that, and they still seem to be ok. So I imagine there's some flexibility in there?
Ed Gainey
Early on in his career, Gainey spent six years as a legislative aide to Pennsylvania State Representative Joseph Preston Jr.[6] Gainey's early career also included a period as a special projects manager under Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy.[6] During this period, Gainey worked to promote economic development in East Liberty. Gainey and Preston's relationship later soured, and Gainey first posed a primary challenge to Preston in 2004.[6] In 2006, Gainey challenged Preston for the second time, losing by 94 votes.[7]
Gainey later took a position with the City of Pittsburgh under Mayor Luke Ravenstahl in a community development role.[3][8] In 2010, he became chairman of the city's Democratic Party committee.[3][8]
I know Wikipedia should be taken with a grain of salt, but this is not exactly what I think of when I say "outsider".
She's another state rep, a DSA member
DSA is an outsider to Dem party like Sanders is an "Independent" senator - formally it's true, but we all know what they'd be voting for. If they are "outside" it's the part of "outside" that the mainstream body can't venture to go without risk losing the independents, but not the part which they disagree with.
a Republican who loves AOC and tweets against Trump's immigration policy winning a GOP primary
Not sure about AOC, but there are plenty of Republicans tweeting against Trump's anything, from his hair color to his politices, real or imagined. That said, if I would discover that there's a Republican Machine in, say, Wyoming, I wouldn't be exactly shocked. I'm not saying there necessary is, just saying it wouldn't be a huge surprise for me if there were.
This is good effort post, but it sounds to me a bit like proving that communist USSR didn't exist, because look how dysfunctional the ruling system was, how many dissidents were there, how if you look at any particular party functionary, they were regularly removed from their posts and assigned to random places or even just sent into retirement (or sometimes worse). I mean, if the communist dictatorship was as real as the conspiracy theorists claim, would it not be able to function much more efficiently and would something like removal of Khrushchev (who was supposed to be an all-powerful communist dictator, following right into the footsteps of the mythical uber-tyrant Joseph Stalin figure!) ever happen? Clearly, the supposed "dictatorship" and "totalitarian society" there is nothing but a conspiratorial fakery, and not even a well done one.
Of course The Machine would be full of infighting for who exactly controls the levers and who gets to be in the driver seat. Of course you can be the Chief Machinist one day and cast out by a coup on another. Of course mafia bosses would order hits on each other and sometimes even rat out each other to the feds. That doesn't mean the Machine or the mafia does not exist. A better test would be - can an outsider - or, horrible dictu, even a deplorable - ever get to the levers at all? What challenges would they encounter - besides the obvious "convince the voters" ones?
What do you mean Anne Boleyn wasn't Afro-Caribbean? 😂
I would love to live in a society where that actually would work - i.e. we don't fret about eye color or foot size of the actor not matching the same of the role. Maybe one day all the race stuff would be so trivialized that it would sound like complaining "we know from this obscure portrait that Anne had green eyes but this actor has brown eyes!" - but we're very far from it right now, unfortunately. Moreover, we're so far from it that the mere access to this idea is now gated by the wokes - you can only do race switches in a particular woke-approved manner with an explicitly stated woke goals, otherwise it's "blackface" or "whitewashing" or some other thoughtcrime.
A seemingly harmless trade to avoid immediate calamity in the short term might well prove disastrous long-term.
Except that it isn't even "seemingly harmless" - we already know, both on historical examples and current analysis, that there will be huge downsides and costs. We're just postponing dealing with those costs until later - and somehow hope it'll be ok, because we want to avoid immediate costs. I'm not sure my definition of "rational" includes such behavior, unless we somehow are restricted to a very short time horizon - like we know for sure The Sweet Meteor Of Death is coming in five years, so we want at least live out these years calmly and happily.
Which btw reminds me that we're probably not doing ourselves a very good service electing 80-year old people to be our leaders...
If you're nazi, and you have a relationship with a person that thinks being a nazi is a deal breaker, then your relationship is doomed. It's not like some tiny flaw you can ignore. And tbh, this is not the way to live your life - you can't be a proper nazi (any time you march with a tiki torch you risk your SO finding out, where's the fun in that?) and you can't rely on your SO to support you, so what is left? Why would you want to be in such relationship - just for sex? That's not going to work on any significant term. I'd expect if someone is a nazi, their SO would be at least OK with them being a nazi, if not also one.
The opposition to Christians reasoning is likely post-dated. The tradition of wearing head covering goes back a while and likely if not predates Christianity then at least contemporary with very early years of it: https://judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/751/kippa-in-torah
Most middle class blue tribe Jews aren't super knowledgeable about Judaism, unfortunately, and Rabbis are well aware of it. So when you'd have to do something, you'll be told. And if you don't do it exactly right, it's no big deal either. Otherwise, just general stuff appropriate for the occasion - modest somber dress, head covering for males (if you forget one, there's a chance the Rabbi will have some spares), common sense behavior. I don't think there would be any other expectations from you.
Hiding your views from your SO is probably not a good base for a relationship, at least not in the long term. I mean, if you just have somebody to chat and occasionally tumble under the sheets, who cares, but if you are building life together, at least in terms of years, it's not gonna work. OpSec may be good to not share accounts, have separate computers, etc., maybe not even show up at the same forums if they are of a variety where participation can lead to bad consequences - but there's difference between OpSec and hiding your views.
I think the show's strength was that it simply assumed it's audience was on board with the modern liberal package, and so didn't have to convert them.
Most preachy shows also assume that - otherwise they wouldn't count on the audience to shell out dollars for watching woke tropes - but still preach like crazy. I think the difference is not that. There's two ways of promoting certain ideas in cinema. One is to have human attractive characters to act in accordance with these ideas and make the audience draw their own conclusions. So, if you wanted to promote racial integration, you just feature a diverse cast (hopefully avoiding blunders like casting a black person to play Bjorn Ironside) and make them act like it's normal, without mentioning it. The audience gets the message "racial integration is the normal thing". The other way is to draw attention to this fact constantly, lampshade it mercilessly and have the characters to pronounce wooden monologues about how happy they are that they have racial integration and how it's long about time they had it and how eager they are to have more of it, because nothing could be better than more racial integration. The audience gets the message "they really want to push racial integration on me, at the cost of sacrificing everything that makes movies fun". The Community manages to do the former, while most woke content past about 2016 do the latter with gusto.
I'll also start by answering the question first: it seems to me like it might be most rational for the US to concede Taiwan to China
Only if by "rational" you mean "optimizing utility on the shortest timeframe possible". I don't think people failing the marshmallow test are considered irrational, but I think it's commonly understood they are less successful at achieving their goals in the long run, and lose competitively to people that pass the test. On the shortest timeframe, it always "rational" to surrender, because surrendering ensures short-term survival, while fighting is inherently risky. On the longer timeframe, always choosing surrender leads to being a lowest-rank individual, which provides poor access to resources and opportunities, and ultimately leads to extinction of the associated gene line.
Also, considering public opinion is not "irrational". The public opinion mechanisms (treating it expansively, not just as responding to the polls) is why people form societies and not just live in a landscape of wild roaming sub-Dunbar bands. Dismissing it means dismissing a key mechanism driving the whole societies. Even a totalitarian society has to account for the existence of public opinion (even though it exists in significantly different form than in a democracy) but it a democratic society, not accounting for it is plain silly.
At least, this seems rational in a situation where one expects China not to themselves be willing to cede Taiwan
If you just proven it's rational to let Taiwan be taken rather than go to war and break profitable economic ties - why China shouldn't be expected to be rational too and arrive to the same conclusion? Yet, you seem to expect the opposite to happen, and treat is as an obviously the only possible conclusion. Do you think China is inherently irrational, or somehow same things are rational for China but not for other countries?
Don't think so, mostly because she doesn't care - where exactly I go to argue on the internet is not something that would have any interest to her I think. If she asked, I'd tell her but tbh I'd be surprised she cares about this.
I certainly see where you're going there - overhopping is a thing, and even I, who actually loves bitter beers, need to watch out. But many places helpfully publish IBUs, and for those that don't there are the wonders of Internet (like Untappd) and even when I do regular shopping between Costco, Whole Foods and couple of smaller local stores, I can pick up something decent that doesn't go over the deep end. And it become common for restaurants to have actual beer menu where the choice isn't just "Guinness or lager?" - so while the phenomena you mention are real, it's possible to avoid them and still have a good choice in beer.
I didn't think QAnon is a geographically localized phenomenon. Also, Moscow ID is a college town, in 2020 the majority voted for Biden, while Idaho went 2x to Trump. So I'd rather expect to find BlueAnon than QAnon there.

If you are talking about Jewish Bible, there are mentions:
https://www.chabad.org/library/bible_cdo/aid/9987/jewish/Chapter-23.htm
[A man] with injured testicles or whose member is cut, may not enter the assembly of the Lord.
https://www.chabad.org/library/bible_cdo/aid/9923
24[Any animal whose testicles were] squashed, crushed, pulled out, or severed, you shall not offer up to the Lord, and in your land, you shall not do [it]
From this, the tradition derives prohibition of castration and even vasectomy: https://judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/15555/halachic-permissibility-of-a-vasectomy
The issue with injuries or illnesses leading to deficiencies in that area is more complex, if you're interested, on the same site above there's a number of questions discussing this topic. It has been extensively covered in the literature (as pretty much any other topic, those guys had 3 millenia to work, they covered a lot of ground). Of course, I know much less of Christian tradition in question, so not sure what's the status of the matter there.
More options
Context Copy link