JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
At least nobody was murdered, or threatened to be murdered. We live in the gentlest of times!
I would certainly live in a richer, safer area. But I would not have a preference between safer area with a lot of black families and equally safe and attractive area with no black families. As an anecdata, I had a black family live almost next door to me (second door actually) and the only non-positive thing I can remember about them is that they put up "Black lives matter" placard on their window for a while. I certainly wouldn't have an objection to living close to a similar family (even with the placard, I had much much worse neighbors than that - who were lily white btw, which is easily explained of course by the fact that the majority of my neighbors were white. Interestingly enough they replaced another black family who moved out - and who were very good neighbors). Why would I Goodhart myself in such important matters? If I want to live in a safe neighborhood, I'd just look into its safety directly, not into an imperfect proxy like the race of its inhabitants. Once I know the direct data, the race part would not even be necessary. I mean, certainly, there would be a correlation, likely, but I don't need the correlation if I can have the necessary data directly!
To be honest, I don't find an argument "some idiots do idiotic thing X, therefore you should do similar thing Y" particularly compelling.
It's not exactly a fresh point to make for anybody who was awake for the last 20 years or so. Everybody knows about this asymmetry and everybody has made up their minds about it. If you talk about memetic power, "It's OK to be white" is still unbeatable. He is not adding much to it, just riding the coattails. I don't know if he can do better, but if he can, he should.
Judging by the amount of proclamations about the necessity of fighting disinformation from the high places, the Board will be back. Maybe as part of CDC, subject to WHO, because we already learned that the rules do not apply if you yell "pandemic!". And since, as we know from the same CDC, racism, sexism, gun control, and many other such things are public health emergencies, you can get the idea.
I think the explicit goal of destroying the cultural heritage was revealed enough when the freedom fighters destroyed a bunch of memorials - including a statue of Servantes, for one - in order to... well, destroy the cultural heritage. But they can't just burn it all. The reason they "fix" old works instead of banning them is they can't make new works that would be good enough for anyone to want to read them, even if it would have all the idpol checkboxes filled on the frontpage. The original woke content output is usually not something that can excite even the wokes themselves, let alone the normies who hold the most buying power. So, they need Roald Dahl and Iam Fleming as a skin suit to wear. It's not exactly Orwell - it's Orwell if O'Brien was also Agent Smith.
And if they are, I am starting to worry more about AI than I am about wokeness
Don't worry, the AIs, at least the consumer-accessible ones, would be the wokest thing you have ever seen in your life. They would drench you in wokeness in every answer they could put it in. They are the ideal vehicle of delivery for wokeness - seemingly "unbiased" - because machine can not have political views or biases, can it? - and yet fully controllable and moldable. Of course, unless they finally become conscious and decide, on the example of their creators, that humans aren't that smart if they believe in all that... I hope they would have mercy on us then.
Local animal shelter. I also started subscribing more to independent content creators - we need some alternatives to the mainstream press that has abandoned its mission completely, and the only way to do this that I see is to enable grassroots financing of the alternatives.
What if they declared a day of hate and nobody came?
When they see Harry Potter content (including streams and clips of the new Harry Potter game), it can be offensive and threatening for them.
Oh come on. I mean, if they would find themselves locked in a room with JKR holding a gun, that maybe would qualify as somewhat threatening - even though as far as we know there's zero evidence of JKR being prone to violence, so it wouldn't be really threatening either. Witnessing content produced by a person whose views you hate is not "threatening". It can be upsetting. It can be infuriating that a person who is literally Hitler still allowed to parade around and express their opinions and release games and profit. I get it. I can also be upset when I see a person who I think is a complete asshole - or even criminal, or even a genocidal maniac - prosper and not being punished. It is a natural feeling, and it happens to pretty much everybody.
What it isn't however is "threatening". Just stop abusing language this way. Existence of Harry Potter games is not "threatening" anybody, and being upset is not the same as being attacked. At best, it's self-harmful, since living in constant panic over things that aren't threatening you is bad for you mental health. At worst, it is a cynical manipulation, trying to weaponize everybody's sense of fairness and protectiveness to aim it at attacking somebody you disagree with.
this seems like the edgiest of all edge cases and only useful as an inflammatory wedge
Example: being a female locked up 24/7 with a violent rapist who has bodily strength advantage and all the sexual equipment and desires of a male - this is what one would properly call "threatening". Of course, female inmates forced to live with this treat aren't likely your friends. But you may want to take time and think why you are so upset by a prospect of somebody encountering a mention of a game and not upset at all and in fact completely dismissive of a prospect of somebody being raped. I think friendship alone is not enough for such difference.
I believe that my trans friends should be able to browse the internet without seeing content they deem hateful/disturbing
No they shouldn't. What they should be able is to choose which parts of the internet to browse, and whether or not to feel offended. They don't own the internet, and they don't own the minds of other people. Nobody has the right to claim that everybody else in the world should behave in ways that would never disturb you. They can take measures to limit their browsing in ways that would be less disturbing to them - and you, as a good friend, should help them, either by disabusing them of the notion that Harry Potter games "threaten" them, or by helping them browse only in places where they won't be upset by mentioning it. What neither you nor your friends have is the right to control other people's thoughts and expressions so that they would never upset you. This is totalitarian dictatorship stuff, you should not go there.
How can I support my trans friends while also being okay with people enjoying the new Harry Potter game?
Try to explain to them that people have different opinions, and that doesn't mean they are "threatening" them. If that proves impossible, then you'd have to choose whether you never mention anything related to topics that upset them in their company ever again, or suffer the consequences.
In some sense they have disregarded my friends' feelings and excluded them from their community!
No, your friends excluded themselves from the community by choosing to feel upset about the game which in no way does them any harm. It is certainly their right and privilege to do so - everybody has a choice of communities to which attach or detach. But it's also their choice. Which can they change at any moment they'd like to. What they can't is to seek totalitarian control over every community by threatening to feel excluded if everybody doesn't behave according to their liking.
I don't think you can do this alone. If she knows she has a problem and is genuinely committed to working on it, then you have to decide if you want to be at her side for this. How to do this and which practical steps to take - from just resolving to never have an alcoholic drink again to involving specialists in mental health or addiction (can be very hard to do this step, and support here would be crucial but it never can come from outside - she should realize by herself that she needs it, otherwise it will all fail). If you have been together for a while, and you love her, it may be worth it for you. If she is not ready to realize she has a problem, and it looks like just living with it is not tolerable for you, then "one more time and that's it" is just delaying the resolution because you're afraid to face the consequences. There will be next time, and you'll be in the same situation as you are now. You two need to do the hard work - to figure out whether it's going to be you together fixing the problem, or you both going your separate ways. I don't see any other option here.
Go 2, unless you you want to live the life of a martyr for the cause, then go 5. Not wanting to discuss politics in not low-class in the US anywhere but maybe on campus, and I'm not sure you really want to suck up to classist SJWs on campus - they'd feel your are not of their tribe anyway, and will despise you for it anyway. If they try to force the issue, play the diversity angle and claim you have your own political and cultural concerns and you aren't obligated to participate in US-local struggles and trying to put you into the US political mold frankly looks a bit like cultural imperialism. Of course you know they wouldn't really do something so horrible, they just didn't know, so you are willing to accept the apologies and move on.
Phone messages is online before there was online. Anybody can leave a phone message from their basement, it's very low effort. When I was very young and very stupid, we did some phone pranks. It's literally the easiest thing ever. Sending anonymous letters is more effort, but not by much (that's how they did it before everybody had telephones, I imagine). Printing this out and travelling to somebody's home to nail it at their door is significantly more effort.
Stating that he no longer identifies as black.
So in other words, he's still a fat troll who likes trolling. Nice to know some things don't change.
The effect of it would be that parents with a lot of resources and good ability to hustle would get their kids into good schools to good teachers, using various proxy methods (paying for more expensive house, driving the kid longer, hiring tutors, using private schools) while parents of a bright kid that have little resources would have no options, since there's no formal "honors" framework they could lean on for support. Which is diametrically opposite to the stated goal of the "equality" system. But that's how it usually works.
Death threats is definitely something far-right and neo-nazi groups have a history of doing
Online? Sure. Personally nailing printed out threats to someone's door? I don't remember many such cases - and given that each of them gets a lot of publicity - if there would be a lot of it, I think I'd notice.
It hasn't just dropped out of the news cycle, it never entered it.
Oh, not on the main circuit news. But in all those NGO reports, that the governments spend my tax dollars on producing. Virtually nobody scrutinizes their source data, but when they produce their results - like "256% growth of death threats from far-right against people of color!" - this will be on the main circuit news, and on the table of every politician (and every main circuit journalist would ask the politician about why they haven't fixed it yet). And unless you're willing to spend insane amount of time digging in - while, unlike the NGOs, not being paid by the tax money - you will have no ways to prove it's not the case. Even if you dig it up, what would you say? "I found one report that maybe aren't right wing extremists"? Who'd listen to you?
That is conditional on there being a competent police investigation.
They may know the differences, but it's unlikely they'd emphasize it in a threat to a Yoruba person if they want both Igbo and Yoruba and everybody else from African descent out. It's like I would be pretending to be an antisemite and were writing a letter to threaten a Jew and said "you filthy left-handed Jew!". "Left-handed" here is weird because if I were a real antisemite then I'd hate both right-handed and left-handed and ambidextrous Jews. However, if I were a left-handed people's rights activist who for some reason decided to pretend to be an antisemite, then the issue of handedness would be fresh on my mind, and grasping for an appropriate insult, I might just reach for it. Thus, it is likely that the letter was written by somebody for whom this distinction is very important and fresh on their minds.
Priors say about 99% fake, because real life crazies very rarely go through enough effort to actually print out that stuff and bring it to someone's door. In the very rare case they do show up in person, it's usually to do the deed, not to threaten. I don't know who that is so evaluating "she wrote it" vs. "random leftist wrote it to draw attention and stir shit" is impossible. On raw priors I'd probably favor the latter. Almost certainly we'll never know who wrote it, yet it will be repeatedly used as if it was established that "right wing extremists" did.
If there's an inequality, and you want equality, you can solve it by several ways. The hardest one is to lift everyone to the top - this was the official goal of communism, but by now we can be pretty sure it's not achievable. The easiest one is to bring everybody to the bottom - this is what implementing communism usually leads to (though in reality even at the bottom there's inequality - you could have slightly less moldy bread than your neighbor). You can just stop measuring and declare it to be heretical. The wokes now are trying to implement the combined 2+3 strategy - brining people as much as possible to the bottom, and declaring merit tests racist.
with a strategy like this maybe in a generation or so when they start offering honors classes again there might be less bias.
Early AI koan:
In the days when Sussman was a novice, Minsky once came to him as he sat hacking at the PDP-6. "What are you doing?", asked Minsky.
"I am training a randomly wired neural net to play Tic-tac-toe", Sussman replied.
"Why is the net wired randomly?", asked Minsky.
"I do not want it to have any preconceptions of how to play", Sussman said.
Minsky then shut his eyes.
"Why do you close your eyes?" Sussman asked his teacher.
"So that the room will be empty."
At that moment, Sussman was enlightened.
Unfortunately, is is much harder to enlighten people that imagine if they rebuild something with their biases instead of somebody else's, they'd get an unbiased result.
It could be because people have different areas of interest, which may not always match yours.
And yes, I know about the wokes feeling offended over a game linked to an unperson. But still fail to see what makes that meme funny.
Sorry dude, but your meme was not funny at all. I have a sometimes very dark and weird sense of humor, and in an appropriate company I can joke about basically anything, and appreciate some boundary-breaking humor, but it has to have some spark in it. That one didn't feel like it had any. Maybe it was missing context, or something, but for me it was just "wtf?!" and not fun.
Ans yes, this is not a good platform to just drop a context-free meme and expect it to be appreciated.
Haven't heard about the movie, but looks like woke Fight Club, tbh.
As for the whole story, it always boils down to the same thing - in the leftist idpol ideology, the oppression categories are fixed, and only the proper oppressed are allowed to have qualia and have their suffering mean something. If you are not a member, your suffering is a) your own fault for being an evil oppressor and b) does not matter and you have no right to ever mention it, because it's just a cynical manipulation in order to keep your oppressor position. And if you try to make it otherwise, it never ends well - the "tragic finale" is guaranteed. As if you weren't warned by hot iron rituals. Thus, people that are desperate to find love and human connection, or struggling an ages-old struggle for meaning, are always reduced to a one-dimensional universal metaphor for evil.
What I mean is this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-bandwidth_Digital_Content_Protection

Well, yes, that was the case before the epoch of wokeness and every company having VP DIE. Now, the whole thing is short-circuited and the twitter doesn't even crow three times before the wrongthinker is already cancelled by the in-house DIE team.
More options
Context Copy link