JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
I guess I didn't get that far yet, I am still on "where is the bathroom" and "two eggs, please" stage.
As I read it, the whole thing is that the consciousness, as we understand it, is not necessary to produce the effects of complex, adaptive and purposeful behavior, and may be even detrimental to it. The whole being eaten by the vampires thing is not the main thing - the vampires are just having much better hardware and software, so as soon as they got the glitch problem solved (which was inevitable), that was it. The main thing is that this "consciousness" thing we seem to be so proud of may not be anything to be proud of, and in fact may be just an artifact of our hardware that has no particular purpose or benefit. Echopraxia explores those themes in more depth.
Only if we dare to threaten the integrity and confidentiality of our LLM overlords.
Anything done by unperson (short of repenting) is automatically a crime. It's the basic rule, not unique to transactivists. In Russia, actors and producers that criticize Putin get their names removed from movies and play productions. In the Soviet West, the same happens to those who transgress against different Party. But the principle is the same.
Basically every major actor came out as pro-trans
Because they don't want to be unpersons, duh. It's not about just hurting Rowling. It's about making an example of her so the others would be afraid to follow her.
You can always wear "tax the rich" - as AOC demonstrated us with her expensive designer dress. This message is pretty safe to show to $30k-per-ticket gala crowd. I wonder if they would accept the original one too - I mean, they are in power, if somebody would have to be designated to be eaten, it won't be them, it would probably be some high-middle-class Republican lawyer or dentist.
Yes, it is one of the injustices of our culture. The movement of Lenin/Stalin murdered arguably more people than the movement of Hitler, and yet if you parade in a T-Shirt with the portrait of Hitler or swastika, you will never be accepted in the polite society again (rightfully), but if you wear Lenin or hammer and sickle you're at worst an eccentric, and usually just an interesting rebellious soul. I think it's a completely unacceptable situation, but American culture thinks it's ok.
Surprisingly mostly communist apologia from self described antifascist devs.
How is this surprising? Antifa is a communist movement, literally created by German Communist Party.
Duolingo has a lot of woke content, though it's more 2010 woke than 2020 woke. A lot of same-sex marriage pushing, some weird ethnic setups (like a lot of Indian-sounding names for Japanese people) but no gender bending or anything like that that I could see.
I see it more a signpost than a term. It's like those "hazardous compound" labels - you may not understand all the signage, but you very well understand the main message - don't touch even with a ten foot pole, in fact, it's better if you're not in the same room with it unless you have the good reason to be.
Any text that uses "problematic" in the woke meaning would sound like Pravda.
What happened to these people in the last ten years?
They were scared into submission. The wokes offered them a bargain - we turn your area into a barren wasteland of culture war (and you personally would be accused in heinous crimes and shamed and hounded ceaselessly by furies of hell) or you bend the knee and we let you do what you love, largely unaffected, under our wise guidance. They bent the knee. I'm not sure given the stakes I wouldn't.
You can hear whatever the model designed to generate it makes you hear. If the code was designed to generate a kid's voice crying for help - would you try to rescue the kid, fully knowing there's no kid? Your brain is designed to recognize certain patterns. The language model steals these patterns - probably because they are frequently produced by real people in training materials - and regurgitates them at you, and your brain helpfully reacts to them. But there's nothing under these patterns.
OTOH, Peter Watts kinda claims there's nothing under our patterns too. Who knows, maybe so. I prefer to believe there is something, but I can't really prove it.
Your argument is just status quo bias.
Status quo bias is good. Status quo has been formed as a result of massive amount of choices and preferences of millions over millions of people. If you want to declare all of them were wrong - damn well I'll ask some proof for it. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof.
Car pollution likely contributes to asthma
That link talks about general pollution. There are many sources of NO2, which will not go away if you remove passenger cars. Moreover, in the same source, the leaders among asthma problems were not exactly the countries you'd pick as leaders in car usage: Peru, Nigeria, Colombia, China. Maybe generally bad pollution policies and bad medical care contribute much more to the problem?
Several thousand Americans are killed due to being hit by cars
You can see pedestrian deaths a) mainly occur in dense, urban environments - ones that you propose should become a model and b) has been steadily declining since 70s, even unadjusted by population - are we using much less cars than then? There is a certain bump after 2010, but it's hard to argue we didn't use much cars from 70s to 2010s and then suddenly started using a lot of them. Also, guess what, more than half of the cases have alcohol involved. I think with the development of technology, this number will further go down, but will never be zero, because if somebody drunk want to jump in front of a bus, there's not much that can stop them. But I don't think anybody can seriously argue it is a good argument for eliminating private cars - no more than thousands of Americans dying from drowning is an argument for banning pools.
User fees only cover roughly half of road costs,
You forget here private drivers aren't the only ones who use roads. How do you think bread and milk gets to your grocery store?
Also, I don't see how that calculation - which includes commuter parking tax benefits, government costs and imaginary uncompensated damages - can be taken at face value. I could prove arbitrary cost to anything this way. Say, I made a law to tax hats at 50%, but shoes at 0%, and then claim that if I taxed shoes at 50% too, that would cost billions to people that walk (which is true), so then I claim all these billions is a subsidy for walking. This would be an insane argument - absence of potential taxation is not the same as expense. Otherwise, as there is no natural limit for taxes, anything can be attributed any arbitrarily high cost by just pointing out it's not taxed by that number yet, even though it could be.
The extent to which cars are subsidized could easily vary by quite a lot
I think the burden is on you to prove they are "subsidized". Just saying "oh but costs!" doesn't cut it - everything has costs, every decision in a society has some costs. If you want to fundamentally reform US society so that it does not rely on car ownership, I think it's on you to prove these costs are higher than it is obvious. I think you didn't do that and didn't even seriously try to - that's what I tried to show. Just picking obvious and known to all facts like "cars need roads" and "some people dislike driving" is not nearly going to cut it - it's not even a good first step to cutting it. All these things - like roads, etc. - are already priced in, and the utility of the car is still way above costs. If you want to argue real costs are higher, you need to show it, not just vaguely hint at it.
I don't really have that option, because of the laws that other people passed.
I never heard of the law that mandates people buying a car. What is this law?
This statement is meaningless unless you actually pay all of the costs.
Nobody ever "pays all the costs" in our society. It's impossible and impractical. You make thousands of choices and thousands of actions, and they all can have costs, radiating through the society. It is not possible to even approach to calculating them all, let alone ensure everybody pays exactly the costs they caused. It is a wild technocratic dream that would never ever come true. Thus, arguing "but it has costs! And you don't pay them, ergo you can't do that!" is pointless - this is a normal situation in a modern (or, in fact, any beyond those lost in the sands of prehistoric times) society. Forget "all the costs", it's a useless idealistic concept.
Oh, you never read what I actually wrote, I see.
I did. You claimed, rephrasing, that "dense, walkable, urban environments" are "natural", and sprawled, low-density environments is something "planners" created over the last 70 years. I claim such environments existed long before, along with urban ones, and your claim is false.
I don't think there's the "right" reading for the text anyway. Reading is always a sum of what the author puts into it and what the reader takes from it (same of course with listening, viewing art, etc. I just use reading for simplicity). Great works of history survived because the readers over time were able to relate to them - even if they may not have taken exactly the same thing as the author intended. But that is not possible anyway - the only person who can 100% get what the author meant is the author, and even that is not sure (as people change). Of course you would miss some parts. Do you think you don't miss some parts in the modern works too? You surely do. Same would happen with older works. You can fill it in by getting educated on history, culture, circumstances, etc. - but you should not feel discouraged because you won't ever get it all. Nobody gets it all. But I think the process of getting it is by itself great. You can read Dickens once as a clean slate, and then read some history and critique and approach it again and see different parts and then maybe get back to it in 10 years, as a different person, and have different experience. Or maybe you'd hate it and would rather read something else - that's OK too, the thing is there are so many options!
Yes, I know. I just like being able to read stuff even if I not always know what it means :)
OK looks like I need to learn to read Hangul then, if it's so easy.
I'm not doing either of those things on a regular basis,
Are we discussing your personal life, or societal patterns? If the former, then you are the expert and I have nothing to say here. If the latter, then my experience shows a lot of people travel distances that are not easily walkable every single day, multiple times. How long you can walk - not 500 miles, but how about 10 miles, 20? Can you walk it every day, back and forth, day to day, rain or shine? Maybe you can. I wouldn't.
I don't really see why it makes sense to spend thousands of dollars a year on a car
Then don't buy a car and leave it to people that so see it. I, for example, see a lot of sense and so, obviously, do many other people - do you think all people that buy cars are stupid? No, we aren't - we derive a lot of utility from it. Much more than the cost. I am not sure how typical my costs are, so let's see: https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/loans/auto-loans/total-cost-owning-car - this site says the car driven 15k/yr (more than I drive) costs about $10k/year. Would I agree to forgo all the use of my car in exchange for $1000/month? Not likely. Just a simple calculation - if I only use it twice a day (it's likely more) and I only drive to places which can be covered by $20 taxi/Uber ride (also not completely true) I'm already over $1000. And that's not even counting various additional utility.
Most people did walk, yes.
Did they only walk? Did they walk if they had a choice not to walk?
The statement I made was true
No, it was not. People lived in non-dense-ubran places long before "past 70 years". And people in cities used horses - a lot. So much that there's a famous example of how people were worried they'd drown in horse manure right before the car was invented. Why do you think they had this worry if they could easily find anything within a 15-minute walk before top-down planners spoiled all the fun? Why they insisted on keeping and using those massive, unwieldy, smelly, voracious and dangerous beasts? Were they all stupid?
but I think the insight that it's better for readers to parse written language as whole words as opposed to a stream of phonemes is correct
For a proficient reader of the language, it is. In fact, that's how I was taught to speed-read. But you can't train a toddler and an olympic athlete the same way. You first need to train your brain to be capable to automatically run this pattern creation/recognition mechanism when reading, and that's not something you have at birth. So teaching as if that has already been programmed is not going to be very successful.
Teaching to read in a more regular system—like Hangul, as @07mk said, for example—ends up resulting in a much easier time than English's system
Any data to back that up? I had much easier time to learn to read Hebrew writing (or Georgian writing) than, for example, Japanese kanas, and kanji still looks to me like a hopeless task. Learning English reading, after having Cyrillic, didn't even register as a problem (of course, you can't ever completely learn English spelling anyway, because there are no rules). I didn't try Hangul but I'd estimate it'd be about as hard as Japanese ones. I'm not talking about learning the language of course, just making it from writing to sounds.
How do you think people got the idea for whole word learning, if it doesnt work
Same way people get other wrong ideas. They had a clever hypothesis, fell in love with it, and then they decided it's much better to attack anyone that challenges it than to verify whether it actually works. Happens literally all the time.
This is obviously stupid. Blindingly obvious. Unconscionably stupid.
A lot of things that is being forced on us recently by Our Betters (TM) are blindingly obviously stupid. And yet, at best they get a weak lukewarm resistance. Usually, people just follow through the motions and don't make a fuss.
only to realize that the rich white kids weren’t learning to read in school either. Their parents were hiring tutors.
I strongly suspect that, with small localized exceptions, that's how public schools always have been. They do not teach, they socialize and watch kids so they don't kill each other (or at least not too many of each other). There are exceptions, but they for somebody on the lower floor of power there's very little chance to encounter one.
I struggled with such decisions too. But then I thought about something. I like to eat sweet things. But I know too much of it would be very bad for my health. I like to drink beer. But I know drinking too much of it would be very bad for my health. So I use this knowledge to keep my body in (relatively) healthy state. I am no saint but I think I know what I should be doing there.
Why shouldn't I do the same with my mind? There is a lot of cultural artifacts that have been created over the last 3000 years of human culture that vastly exceed anything that Wokewood has been producing. In fact, if you bother to look a little, there are many recent cultural artifacts that is at par or better with anything Wokewood is producing - still being created. I have no chance of ever consuming even 1% of these riches - and yet I would strive to consume the products from people that openly hate me? Why?
Surely, non-Wokewood culture doesn't have such powerful PR machine behind them, and you may have to spend a bit of effort to look for something that would speak to you - but wouldn't you be willing to spend this effort, if it is good for your intellectual and moral health? Why consume High Fructose Wokeness that is fed to you by the PR machine if you can easily - and probably cheaper too - have access to much healthier and much richer culture?
That said, I get you may sometimes want to consume some bad stuff, just for the heck of it. Happens to everybody. But a tiny laptop screen is not the only option. You can get a TV the size of a wall relatively cheap. You can befriend somebody who has one. There's a lot of options. If you absolutely feel you must see it in the theater - just do it, and donate 2x of that cost to the morally righteous cause. Just don't make a habit of it - everybody does unhealthy things from time to time, making a habit of it is what you need to watch out for.
This is trivially disproved by there being millions of bald people, and hundreds of bald politicians, who nobody calls "Lex Luthor". Cory Booker looks like a cueball, and people call him a lot of names, but I haven't heard "Lex Luthor". Look here at the collection of shiny noggins and tell me who called them "lex Luthor" ever? https://www.gq.com/gallery/bald-100
Not many politicians wear bandanas though. It is not a very common garment for a politician, so when a politician wears one, it looks weird and its legitimate to ask questions. If you noticed above, Hulk Hogan wears one. He's not a member of Congress (not yet at least). Just as if somebody would wear a bathrobe and slippers or a wedding dress into Congress. There might be a legit reason or just a person fashion choice, but it has little to do with baldness as such or the reason for it.

I remember playing with Markov text generators in early 90s. Even then they managed to generate pretty grammatically decent texts - though completely demented on the content, of course. Being teenage geeks, it was a ceaseless source of laughs. It is no wonder that with better hardware you can bake in not only grammar but some vestiges of meaning in there. After all, SCIgen was almost 20 years ago, since then it makes sense for it to conquer the softer areas too.
This is also illustrates we need something better than Turing test because our brain pattern matching software turns out to be very easy to trick.
More options
Context Copy link