JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
The idea of the piece is that they're right and honest about most things, not that they're right and honest about every thing.
Sorry, not buying it. That's like the Gell-Mann amnesia squared. We know they purposely and knowingly lied in many topics, but we're supposed to assume that in topics we haven't caught them yet they wouldn't lie to us, and not only that, but praise them for it as the best truth-spreading vehicle humanity can offer? That's like telling a battered woman "well, he doesn't beat you all the time, right? Only occasionally, maybe once or twice a day? So he's actually a great guy, what is to complain about?!"
Anything not having explicit purpose to gaslight me is a good alternative. Hanania's claim that "it is one of the most honest, decent, and fair institutions designed for producing and spreading truth in human history" is absolutely laughable. Well, no, I correct myself - in "media not lying" sense it is absolutely true. It was designed for this exact purpose. Except it has absolutely abandoned its purpose and went all in for partisan propaganda and agenda-building.
OK, maybe the "most" doing all the work here? I mean, what institution designed to spread the truth is actually keeping with its mission? Academia? Gimme a break. We have whole areas of research banned and we have absolute cretins rampaging on campuses seeking - and often succeeding - to expel anyone who dissents from the woke dogma. If any truth-seeking still happens underneath it, it's hard to say academia is institutionally aimed at it anymore. At worst it allows it to happen if it's not too bothersome. Arts and entertainment? You know, writers, poets, playwrights that guide and enrich and elevate the society morally? Nope, can't remember any recently. Libraries and schools? Too busy organizing drag shows for kids and counting pronouns. Religion? They certainly would claim they spread the Truth, but given how many of them there are, hard to rely on their words here. Maybe courts and legal system? Too laughable to even consider, they don't even try to pretend "truth" has anything to do with any of it. So yeah, maybe it's more like "John is the most honest person among this set of 20 pathological liars" kind of statement.
Even then I am struggling to award this humblest of prizes to the media. These are people who repeatedly and consistently tried to deceive and gaslight me into thinking things that not only were absolutely not true - that they themselves knew or must have known if they had any professional integrity are not true. They repeatedly buried stories that contradicted their agenda and invented stories that support it. They are actively and constantly trying to harm me by distorting my model of the world and trying to manipulate me for their own purposes.
Rebel News may have it flaws, but at least they aren't part of the giant machine that tries to eat my brain and convert it to an obedient mush. I mean, if he argued "the press is full of shit, but there are nuggets of truth in there from time to time, and also they publish the sports scores" I could find some sympathy to that, but "most honest, decent, and fair"? nope.
Trump was given every opportunity to return the materials he "accidentally archived"
It doesn't look like this is what happened. See here: https://www.factcheck.org/2022/08/timeline-of-fbi-investigation-of-trumps-handling-of-highly-classified-documents/
Trump's team repeatedly complied with the requests, and provided documents and access to the property, but every time DOJ came back and asked for more, and for some of the documents, Trump team alleged it's either not classified or privileged, while DOJ disagreed. Despite all the times they were given access, they got a warrant and conducted the search, grabbing everything and the kitchen sink (including Trump's passports, for example).
With Biden, we have DOJ warn them upfront before issuing a warrant:
https://www.cnn.com/2023/01/25/politics/justice-department-biden-home-search
And I don't see any Biden passports being taken, either. I think the process here was conducted in a much more amicable manner. And I don't see Biden team disagreeing that the documents found were actually classified documents.
As a side note, CNN absolutely does not know what the word "unprecedented" means.
This collusion, if still present, would change the future.
It already changed the present, and by that of course it changed the future, but that already happened. You can not just choose an arbitrary point in time and say "no, disregard what happened before that, I want future changed only from here forward". The future changing already happened, we live in that future that has been changed.
The question is not whether schröder worked for gazprom, he clearly did, but whether german policy is meaningfully impacted by such things.
OK, so we agree they were friends with Russia, but you think them being friends with Russia did not influence their decision process at all. That's a very implausible belief, but then how do you explain them, including current minister of defense, arguing for removing sanctions from Russia? How do you explain their constant delays - for a year now - in sending heavy armaments, including blocking other countries from doing it? If you hold a powerful position, you have a friend and you consistently act in a way that benefits this friend - how many people would conclude your friendship affected your decisions, and how many would pretend there's no way to know that because somebody said something on some internet page about "paying dividends"? I sense an attempt to confuse the issue here.
Your belief now is that there is collusion. This should be a falsifiable belief.
In theory, yes. In practice - how do you falsify a belief that the coin toss came out heads? Maybe if somebody proves you that you suffer from hallucinations that make you see a coin that comes out tails as heads, but we both know it's a very far reaching scenario. In practice, if you saw it come out heads, you'd be convinced it's heads, and pretty much nothing practical would falsify it. So blind obsession with falsification is misleading here - you do not owe anybody to construct some imaginary constructs to mock-falsify in the future things that you already know to be true.
has failed to give accurate predictions of germany’s policy on ukraine, months ago, and a few hours ago
That's exact opposite of the truth. My belief predicted German would be dragging their feet with providing necessary amounts of help - and they have been dragging their feet for a year now. My belief predicted affected people would argue for pro-Russian moves - and they had argued for pro-Russian moves, including removal of sanctions. The fact that they finally, after years of affecting German policy (remember, the war started in 2014) start to lose their influence, does not mean the past predictions were inaccurate - my belief does not claim they will be in power forever, nobody is in power forever.
is used to explain behaviour that is unremarkable compared to other countries
It is remarkable compared to other countries like Britain, Poland, Estonia, and even the US. It is unremarkable compared to countries like Spain or Japan, but comparing to those is not exactly comparing the same situations.
will be maintained no matter what happens
I do not see a reason to change beliefs on the past unless the past changes. If the documents come out from, e.g. Putin, and there would be reason to believe they are not lying (don't know how, but let's assume it) where he says "we tried our darnedest to corrupt Germans and influence them, even hired Shroeder for Gazprom and gave him and others tons of money, but they have proven absolutely incorruptible, and refused to ever do anything for us at all, these people are saints and not men, we just can not corrupt them!" - yes, I will have to amend my beliefs about the past, as the model of the past changes. Since no such revelations were made, the model of the past stays as it is, and my beliefs about the past do not change, for there's no reason for them to change.
Yes, sorry, typo.
I think this concept works fine for specific set of beliefs - about what is going to happen, but works very poorly for many other sets of beliefs, such as about what already happened and what was the cause of it happening. Obviously, if Germans weren't in bed with Russians, the world would look very different - Schroeder wouldn't work for Gazprom, for one, and Germany would have already supplied (and enabled others to supply) tanks to Russia Ukraine. This did not happen. But asking "what should happen to invalidate this belief" now is silly - it already happened, so nothing in the future would invalidate it, because it has been already validated in the past. It's like telling me to disbelieve the coin I just tossed came out heads, because I seen it come out heads, so regardless of how many times I toss it again, the result of this toss remains "heads". So you declare this belief as "not paying rent" - since it doesn't change anything in the future, and so, by your logic, I should forget it's "heads" and claim ignorance on that. That makes zero sense.
you obviously can't display a certain amount of ingroup favoritism for certain groups without that favoritism being framed as bellicose towards the groups not being favored
Does it work in all directions? I.e. is "promoting women in $thing" obvious sign for hatred of all males? Is NAACP a racist hate organization? Does any affirmative action program have the racial hatred of white people at its core? Is a scholarship available only to women, or only to persons of Native American descent, an obvious mark for hatred of men or all persons who aren't Native Americans? I mean, that's a consistent position, I just want to make sure whether or not it is your position.
Welcome to the feminism Rowling supports
Did Rowling actually say any man who is not actively working for a feminist movement is doing harm to women?
Well I think that's the difference. When the outgoing President or Senator takes a bit more that he should have (which seems to be routine occurrence) usually what happens is lawyers write other lawyers and there's a bureaucratic tug of war until one of the sides gives up or somebody higher up yells at them and appoints one side as the winner. No press involved. Nobody outside deep bureaucracy knows it is happening.
With Trump, it was a huge FBI raid taking everything and the kitchen sink, and the press clowning around for weeks telling us Trump was about to sell nuclear codes to Russians. It definitely looks like a drastic change of pace. And how everybody is discussing old secret documents as the most important thing (while multi-trillion-dollar bills pass with little notice, as it seems).
https://obamamessiah.blogspot.com/
https://www.newsbusters.org/blogs/nb/kyle-drennen/2009/06/05/newsweeks-evan-thomas-obama-sort-god
And so on, I could give you a hundred, but I think you get the idea.
Are you working on or have a degree?
Yes, but I don't think "academic" means that. I have a degree because learning for my craft is done (or has been done when I learned it, things changed a bit now) in institutions that give you a degree when you're done learning. That's pretty much all the use I ever had of me having a degree.
Are you an Atheist?
Nope.
Do you believe that there is a "right" and a "wrong" side of history to be on?
Err... maybe? But probably not in a way you mean it. I believe there's good and evil, if that's what you mean (which is kind of mandated by the previous answer I guess?) so I guess somebody that does a lot of evil and not a lot of good can be defined as "wrong side of history", but I do not believe the history has a goal or is moving towards any definable goal, or that there is a political movement that is always correct and infallible.
I'd say the description is accurate given your prior responses here.
I guess I have to submit to your authority. A guy who knows me from a handful of random posts on the internet is definitely a better expert on me than me.
I'm just against the excesses of the modern black activist movement.
Why would that require creating a homeless shelter for white people only? Black people likely suffer much more from these excesses (and the following actions, like destruction of police effectiveness) than white people. If we lived in a world where major cause of white people's homelessness would be black people - then in that world, having such shelter might make sense, but we're not living in such world.
If they are choosing to not lend it to trans women they are doing harm to them.
That's like saying if you have money and you don't give it to me, as much as I want and when I want, then you are doing harm to me and I am justified in attacking you.
I suspect the practices of handling some documents marked classified by top politicians has been very lax forever (maybe not raiding SCIF but not turning in some stuff that should be turned it, for sure). Outgoing Senators and Presidents probably kept some documents they technically shouldn't be keeping, and nobody made a fuss about it. Just as with many other things (e.g. FARA or Logan Act, etc.), everybody knew and nobody cared. Until it became necessary to use it to get Trump - because everything must be used to get Trump. Now there's a silly dance of trying to explain why our guy doing the same as their guy is totally different. I wonder if they dare to inspect the Lightbringer's archives - I bet there are classified docs there too, though nobody would dare to have FBI raid his residence, of course.
I think that's the first time somebody called me a "secular progressive blue-tribe academic". Over my many years on the internets (and before internets) I've been called many things, but not that. Funny thing that every single word in this description is wrong :)
No, they are sending their own tanks. These powers of collusion are that weak
I haven't seen any actually sent yet. When they arrive, that would be the conclusion, but until they did - they are premature. Over the last year, I have heard "they are sending" a lot of times and at the end, nothing was sent in many cases. So I prefer to see results on the ground.
Again, and in real time, your belief in german-russian collusion has failed to pay dividends.
I am not sure which dividends I should expect from this belief. I think the facts establish the presence of German-Russia ties pretty conclusively, and the facts also establish so far many German promises were delayed or subverted. Not all of them, true, but many were. You are free to believe these are just coincidences, I do not.
In other words, I was trying to find a hypothetical that would falsify your belief.
If you prove me that I have been living in a simulation for the last 10 years, and multiple facts establishing German-Russian ties were not part of actual reality but a fabrication of the authors of this simulation, and did not exist in reality - that would indeed falsify my belief it happened. Short of that, I can not see how pro-Ukrainian faction of German politics overcoming pro-Russian one in the future would falsify existence of the latter in the past.
True information should always pay rent,
I have absolutely no idea what this is supposed to mean.
Are you arguing that what he writes is false?
I'm actually not arguing at all, since I am not sure his arguments raise above "boo outgroup" level, at which level it is useless to argue - since the point of the argument is to mock and denigrate the target, not to identify areas for improvement. The author considers "The Motte" dead (hence the "postmortem"). People here, obviously, do not (unless we are a den of necrophiliacs?) I am not sure which argument could change that perception. Yes, of course there are right-wing postings here. Why not?
Are you confused by that, is your theory refuted?
I am not confused by that at all. State politics is not a one-bit switch. It is a complex combination of thousands of complex interests. There are powerful interests in Germany against intervening in Ukraine, and less powerful in the US (coming more from isolationist place than anything else, unlike Germany) but still existing. There are also pressure from the other side to help Ukraine, aided by the revelations of more and more war crimes committed by Russians. The outcome of this interplay of interests can change over time, there's nothing confusing here and nothing refuting the existence of these interests. The pro-Russia fraction was powerful in Germany, but its power is not infinite and gets eroded as the war goes on - now to the point that they are too weak to prevent Polish tanks to be sent to Ukraine. One day, hopefully, they'd be so weak they couldn't prevent the same for German tanks. It does not refute their existence at all.
Germans could be fighting russians in kiev in 2 years,
Unlikely, for several reasons. First, if Russians get as far as going into Kiev, the EU would decide the war is lost for Ukraine and would cut the losses. One of the reasons they are increasing the help now because they are seeing their help can do something and not just increase the losses. Second, I do not see Germany committing any number of troops to fight Russia anywhere. Poland - maybe. Estonia or Latvia - maybe. US - very, very unlikely but there's a tiny chance. Germany? No way. Third, German army is right now not exactly in the fighting condition, as I read. They have a lot of iron and so on, but they suffer from long neglect and disarray. I don't think they want to fight anybody.
we must not forget their entire political class has been bought by russian money. Ex-Bundeskanzler Schröder...... etc
Obviously, we must not. Why would we forget the fact, which is true? I don't think removing true information from consideration makes any model better.
If 1000 gets sent to Ukraine, the war will end pretty soon after. But right now we're not even near that level of commitment, good thing if they manage 10% of that. So far I understand it's more like 1%: https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidaxe/2023/01/22/germany-okays-a-dozen-polish-tanks-for-ukraine-hundreds-more-could-follow
But I don't see how it's "a lot of lost contracts for Germans" - if these tanks are already bought, the contracts are already paid for. Now imagine they all get sent to Ukraine and stay there (either somehow destroyed, or hanging around keeping the peace after the victory). I imagine they would need eventually to be replaced. Since the rest 2600 are Leopards, and having similar tanks is easier than having different ones, for obvious reasons, that mean the same Europeans now come to the Germans and say "give us more of those Leopards, we need to replace those we sent to Ukraine". I'm not sure I understand - how is this a loss for Germany in your book? Of course, if somehow Americans had a Jedi trick that would make the owners of those 2600 to replenish the missing 1000 with Abrams, that would be a lost opportunity for Germans - but I don't see how it would suddenly happen. As far as I know, militaries don't just jump to an entirely different supplier on a dime. If they planned to replace L2 with Abrams, that decision wouldn't be caused by giving tanks to Ukraine - it'd be taken independently, and there would not be additional loss to Germans to allow the tanks to be given to Ukraine - if country X intends to no longer buy Leopards, it'd not buy regardless of what happens to existing Leopards, whether they go to Ukraine now or sold to Saudi Arabia in 5 years.
the galapagos islands have vastly more biodiversity than north America
Is that actually true? And in which terms "more biodiversity" - more species in general, starting from Archaea and viruses up to primates? More species per square inch? Did somebody really conduct such a research? How did they count the species and what was the result?
Well, having a full copy of your DL may allow an identity thief to impersonate you against many financial institutions that do KYC using it (they used only to ask for SSN, but by now pretty much everybody's SSNs are stolen already) and maybe also register for voting in your stead if you weren't registered. But I agree that most of this info is already stolen, except maybe the picture of your ID itself.
Well, when people are horny and want to see porn, they're not exactly thinking with their upper head. That's not something that one can ever change, I think - at least for some people. Of course, one can always question whether people electing politicians that do such things to them aren't worse idiots themselves, and that'd be a valid question too.
Fascinating. I wonder if the insult counts if the target can't even understand what the insulter is talking about.
US does not want to get involved in a war in Europe. Or at least some part of the US doesn't. That's the same story since WW1. If you ask why US wants to be involved in Libya or Iraq or Somali, but not in Europe - I don't have a good answer for you, it is what it is.
As for the rest of them, its a combination of Russian ties (Germany was leading the way, but Russian money and Russian energy dependency is all over Europe, it's not unique to Germany at all, though France has much less energy dependence due to the developed nuclear production - I always was fascinated how unexpectedly sane French approach in this area has been) and again, reluctance to get involved in a far away conflict that they feel they don't have much stake in.
I don't think the price of a dozen (or even several dozens) tanks plays a significant role in the trillion-dollar budgets/GDPs here. It's sounds like a B-movie plot rather than something that actually happens. The US is trying for a long time to get Europe to do 2% of military expenses that they agreed to, and I think it still didn't happen, Germany barely getting to 1.5. With this level of spending, I don't thing fucking the economy is a big concern.
Also, from what I understand, the manufacturer of these tanks said that they can't make too many more than they do now anyway, at least soon, so I am not sure who is being fucked by replacing them with Abrams, if that indeed might happen. Also, according to the Wiki, Germans plan to replace them anyway by 2030, which again makes the plan of fucking the German economy by temporarily replacing some tanks not a viable plot.
Also, Germans until this point objected to Poland sending L2s to Ukraine too, which does not have any potential to affect German economy at all, except maybe Poland buying more modern tanks to replace the old ones (where Leopards would be the first choice since they already have everything set up for them) - again, nothing fucking German economy here. And now Netherlands wants to buy some L2s from Germany to give it to Ukraine - again, no fucking the German economy I can detect here. I am not sure whether the Germans would agree - but I think it'd be a good deal for them, unless there are some non-economic reasons not to do that.
Learned a new word - "wordcel". Still not sure what it actually means, but it ends in "cel" so it must be something bad.

They probably would also spend a lot of time on how it is caused by global warming (and maybe racism), and how some Republican is at fault for it.
More options
Context Copy link