JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
You made a baseless assumption "what if everything you know as reality is wrong", without producing any argument as to why, and when I refused to accept it, you try to mock me as if I represented myself as Truthbearer. I am not bearer of anything, I have eyes and ears to witness the reality, and that's enough. If you want to challenge that, you are welcome, but you need something more than bare assumption of "what if everything you know is wrong". That's not "disagreement", not in any useful sense, it's just baselessly refusing to agree for the sake of contradicting. To have disagreement, you need to have some contrary argument or evidence, not just bare declaration of "nonsense".
Unfortunately, looks like you don't have any more. I agree, this position can not be enjoyable for you. Good luck next time.
If you optimize for kindness then it is self-evident that you will have to sacrifice truth at some point.
I don't think it is self-evident. It would be only self-evident if you were forced to express opinion on every subject where expressing a truthful opinion in a kind manner is impossible. But I suspect a number of such subjects is not that large. Also, experience teaches me that at least some people who claim they are rude because they optimize for truth if fact are just optimizing for rudeness because they feel it makes them look cool or powerful truth fighters, not some weaklings that have to be polite. I'm not saying this applies to you, but one needs to be aware of this frequent failure mode.
A few days ago I saw a top-level comment wondering why prostitutes don't like being called whores and sluts, since "that's what they are."
Sigh. Out of whole mountain of content - and I don't claim it's pure gold, but there's certainly a wide range of topics discussed and post effort levels and seriousness of approach - this is the single example of things actually discussed in the whole post. I am not sure how I can make myself take it seriously.
So Putin just says that instead his shtick about Nazis.
What exactly is "that"? If Putin said "we must spend 200 thousand lives to invade Ukraine because having a democratic state next to us makes me look bad" - then I'm not sure the society would collapse, but pretty sure the war effort would. The society there has more than one lie, so removing just one is not really enough.
What if the now truth-telling western elites let it slip that what you're saying is nonsense?
What if the Sun were made of Gauda cheese, the quarks are unicorn farts, and the Earth is a giant corn tortilla glued to the back of an enormous turtle? I have no idea. It's a counter-factual hypothetical for which I have no answer and in which I have no interest. In reality, this happened: https://youtube.com/watch?v=N0IWe11RWOM This is not some random talking head. This is the guy who was US President for 8 years, and called "Lightbringer", "Miracle Worker" and "kind of god" by the same elites.
Ukraine wants to become more democratic, cut ties with Russia,
Ukraine never wanted to cut ties with Russia until 2014. It had very active political parties that pushed for more pro-Russian approach, and deep economic ties. What it wanted was a relationship of independent neighbors, not master-thrall one Putin was looking for (and is getting in Belarus, for example). Of course, the situation soured when Russia invaded, but let's at least not rewrite history at which we were actually present.
Putin cannot abide a free prosperous society at his doorstep" is the pro-Ukrainian narrative.
It also happens to be a pro-truth narrative. I think between truth and appearance of not choosing sides, one should choose the truth. Even if it - gasp! - means that somebody is actually bad and somebody else is not. You don't always have to split it in the middle.
The fact is the "Western threat" has been entirely the product of Russia acting as a local bully (that has been the pattern long before 2014 - see Georgia, etc.) and the West ignoring it for the longest time, but finally it got too far, and when the West started objecting, Putin's propaganda of course cried "You see! We warned you they always hated us, and that's why we had to always behave as a bullies! Otherwise the West would have conquered and enslaved us!" Of course, nobody is interested in enslaving them, and nobody was interested in their affairs at all until they started invading neighboring countries, and for some time after that too. It's just you can only go so long with invading neighbors in Europe until people start noticing.
They were always enemies to some extent,
Nobody was interested in being Russia's enemy, neither Ukraine nor the West. Russia though was very interested in having enemies in the West, and subordinate thralls in Ukraine. And to achieve the latter, it created the former.
The same still applies.
although you seem to think they're all vile subhuman orcs
No, I think they are vile humans, who behave like a bunch of orcs. And the web of lies they live in enables and helps them to behave that way. To be sure, not everybody in Russia is like that - but enough to form a stable majority on which dictators like Putin can thrive.
"they're getting a bit too close to the west, if we're going to stop them, it's now or never"
No, if he didn't lie, he'd say "we've got too many problems in Russia, mostly caused by me and my people being a bunch of thieving criminals who are quite bad at managing a country, and we need something to make you idiots stop asking questions and look at me like your savior. Or at least enough of you so I could brutally suppress the rest without a risk of being hanged on a lamppost. So that's what we'd do - I'll take some half million of you and send to murder people into the neighboring country. Most of you will be killed or wounded. You will get absolutely nothing for it but death, pain, suffering and hate of people all around the globe. But I and a bunch of my henchmen would be secure in our positions for another decade. Good deal, isn't it?"
All these tales about how Russia is oh so much threatened by the West is just another bunch of lies. Nobody in the West had seen Russia as an enemy mere 15 years ago (remember "the 80's called and they want their foreign policy back"? Sick burn, eh? Oh, how did they laugh on those stupid neanderthals still seeing Russia as an enemy! Next thing they'd fight George III!) All that narrative was manufactured exactly so that people would buy into it - and to Putin's delight, not only Russians but a lot of Americans swallowed it hook, line and sinker.
If you had different names on the doors of Russian offices, it would probably be on par the US,
That's the whole point, it wouldn't. Not in the Russia as it is today. It's not 140 millions of people under the magic spell of a single Volde-Putin. It's a country whose moral fiber is by now profoundly rotten and corrupt. That's what allows Putin and his henchmen to thrive. Changing the names wouldn't help anymore (maybe if it happened 20 years ago, it could, but not today).
I don't subscribe to the view of the existence of "evil"
Unfortunately (for you, also) evil exists whether you believe in it or not. Moral relativism is just a tactics to avoid responsibility to see its existence, because realizing the existence of evil puts a lot of complicated questions before us. But moral relativism allows avoiding any questions - everybody is good, everybody is bad, no reason for anybody to do anything. Unfortunately, as I said, ignoring evil usually leads to there being more evil.
Him being a tyrant has zero to do with the reasons for the war,
This is false, it has a lot to do with the reason for the war (unless of course you subscribe to the idiotic notion that US just wanted to steal Iraqi's precious bodily fluids oil). It wasn't the only reason for the war - being a tyrant merely kept Saddam in the running for the top villain, his numerous other actions brought him over the top. It's not a single traits that defines it. But it's a big factor. That's what you keep missing - you can not isolate single factor and claim that since other had this factor too, it has zero influence on the reasons for war. It does not work as a single factor, but as a combination and strength of multiple ones, and the opportunity factors too (some dictators are evil enough and their actions are evil enough, but the US does not have the power to do much about it - e.g. see Putin).
Yes.
I mean, surely there would be consequences, as names on the doors change and money stops to flow in the hands of one set of grifters and inevitably starts to flow into another, and so on. Instead of Common Core, we'd have Educational Excellency, and affirmative action university attendees would go back to sportsman's scholarships or something other designed for the same purpose (of getting that sweet federal loan money without actually trying hard to educate someone). That wouldn't change the overall political system. Withdrawing governmental meddling with education - both by prescribing standards and providing a torrent of tax money - would lead to some significant changes, but that is not based on lies. Everybody knows the government meddles, and everybody (about 98% of voters at least) wants it to meddle, the only difference is how exactly it meddles and who benefits from it. The system is not a secret, there's no lie there and everybody agrees with it - the only contention is who gets the profits and who is left holding the externalities.
I do not know if there was such an intent, though the terms were decidedly punitive. But I do not see how anything that happened 100 years ago in Versailles could change anything that is happening now. There's ample evidence, provided by Russian propaganda materials, Russian officials words and Russia's effective actions, that the intent is the destruction of Ukraine existence as an independent nation. Russians have never hidden their disdain for Ukraine, considering it a "fake" nation, whose language is nothing but broken Russian, whose territories have always been the rightful part of the Russian empire, and whose national existence being nothing but a fantom, created by the West to spite Russians. They are fully intent on fixing that mistake and subsuming the "brotherly nation" back into the Great Russia's fold. I.e. perpetrating a cultural genocide - and if needed, a little of physical genocide too, as we saw in places which Russians managed to capture but turned out Ukrainians are less brotherly than they expected. Nothing that happened in Versailles can change that reality, so any references to that is nothing but word games trying to paint over the reality.
The war crimes that were committed by Americans - like Abu Ghraib incident - were also condemned, including by Americans.
the propaganda side of this is that you learn about certain atrocities and not about others.
We know about American atrocities and we call them that. But when it comes to Russian atrocities, somehow there's always somebody explaining that it's still America's fault because if only we gave them more people to enslave they'd finally stop. Somehow there's always justification for any foreign atrocity, as if America being imperfect justifies that.
Saddam being a tyrant doesn't change that.
It kinda does. Not about the atrocities, but about the war. War against a brutal dictator, ruthlessly oppressing local population, openly supporting international terrorists, developing and deploying weapons of mass destruction (even though not exactly in a way the ironically named "intelligence" services presented) and invading foreign countries - yes, it is morally different from a war against a democratic country which poses no threat to anybody but just looks too inviting not to invade. I'm not saying US should intervene into any case of brutal dictatorship - I am saying the moral calculus does differ, and Saddam being a tyrant does change it.
I'm pretty sure if Ukraine willingly gave the rest of the donbass, made public statements about becoming neutral towards the russian culture and interests, including allowing russian to be taught again in schools, russia would make peace.
No they wouldn't. Why would they if they can take the whole thing in three days (as they were sure at the start)?
Also, guess what, Ukraine did all that. Almost all.
Donbass was occupied by Russia since 2014 (so were Crimea, which somehow the Russian propagandists always ignore) and Ukraine de-facto accepted this situation, due to inability of changing it. It obviously was just a stepping stone for Russians which only encouraged their appetites and showed them Ukraine is weak and the West is indifferent, so why not finish the job?
Ukraine has never been any threat to Russian culture - majority of Ukrainians speak Russian at least as the second language, for majority in large cities, especially in the East and the South, it is the primary language at home, huge number of Ukrainians worked in Russia, etc. Before Russia started its war with Ukraine in 2014, Russian was taught in schools freely and there was no restrictions - they came after 3 years of war, in 2017.
As for "interests", given that the official position of Russia is that Ukraine should not exist as a nation and should be owned by Russia instead, since "we are the same people" and Ukraine is "an artifact of Western meddling", it is impossible for Ukraine to both exist and "become neutral towards Russian interests" - you can not be neutral in the question of your own existence.
The issue with the dehumanization of the orcs and with the tribal manicheanization of russian interests that the western media and people parrot is that despite having some elements of truths
Like 100% of those elements. When somebody fires a stream of rockets each containing a ton of explosives into a densely populated city, pretending they do it because they don't teach enough Russian in the same city, and not allow 80% of the population that speaks Russian there to speak Russian more freely, and that's why they all have to be murdered by Russian rockets - I have no trouble figuring out which side is evil here. And no fancy words like "manicheanization" will change that. Whoever fired the rockets dehumanized themselves by their own actions.
Again, you are confusing two things. Let me give you an example. We know US government orchestrated the suppression of the Hunter laptop story. We know there was a lot of lying involved. Did it impact the policies? Hugely. Imagine they wouldn't be able to do that. What would be different? Would we have a different name on the door of the Oval Office? Sure. (yes, I know there's not the actual name, I am speaking metaphorically). Would the Federal Government look differently, US political system work differently, Congress work differently, SCOTUS work differently? Not substantially. The political decisions certainly would differ, but the system would remain mostly the same. Same about climate change. Right now we waste trillions of dollars and sacrifice quality of life and sometimes lives on the altar of the Angry Gaia cult. If we stopped to do that, would those dollars and lives be saved? Sure. Would America work differently? Not much, it'd work the same, but better. Sure, a bunch of old hippies and young idiots would be pissed off (which they are permanently even now, tbh) but it'd be the same country with the same political system, it's not a fundamental systemic change.
To be fair, it does not. American government could do most of its business (excluding some spy matters, etc.) without lying, and it wouldn't break anything much. Of course, it doesn't matter American government does not lie - unfortunately, especially recently, it lies a lot, but these lies are more aimed at subverting the government to use it for private or partisan needs than a foundational necessity of governing. As it exists in Russia now, the lies are foundational for the government there. If American politicians stopped lying, we'd have a bit less rich politicians, and maybe some shuffling of the names on the doors, but the government would be largely the same. If Russian politicians stopped lying, Russia would descend into chaos.
Why single out the Kursk incident specifically? The Soviet/Russian way of handling of any problem is always the same: lie, hide it as long as possible, until it becomes so bad it can not be hidden anymore, sacrifice lives in heroic efforts to un-bungle the mess they made, fail at it due to the inadequacy of means and inability to organize anything in time, lie again about how it is going, blame the victims, bury the evidence, lie a bit more, then promote and award medals to people that presided over the whole mess and blame the West for everything.
They didn't care if they'd bungle it. Because the lives of rank-and-file Russians are always expendable, and do not even come into the equation as a factor. The pride of some Russian general/admiral, who would feel bad if he'd have to ask the hated foreigners for help, does though - in fact, it is the whole equation.
And I don't think the logic of Ukrainian men at the front line is "We defend our land with all our hearts!"
You think wrong. Probably too much reading of bad translations of Russian war propaganda, that is popular in certain right-wing circles, which think if it is not American government propaganda, then it must be the holy truth.
Because they don't want to be Putin's slaves?
Russian demands currently include destroying Ukrainian nation, and they aren't exactly shy of proclaiming it. It's not a matter of "pride", it is a matter of survival - both national, political and for millions of Ukrainians, physical - since Russians are not exactly shy of just murdering whoever dares to oppose them or look at them in a wrong way, or just looks suspicious enough, in places which they are occupying.
Everybody knows and always knew that Russian state power always lies. People are fine with it. I mean, they of course object when the lies concern something personally important to them (though it almost never has any consequences) but in general everybody accepts and endorses constant and endless stream of lies. In fact, it makes them more content - without the lies, realizing the harsh picture of reality in Russia and what is happening there would be psychologically crushing for many, because most people aren't inherently evil. However, when they have the crutch of government lies, they can believe - or at least pretend to believe, they know it's lies, but they don't care - everything is going fine, Russia is a mighty empire which the rest of the world is in envy of, they are fighting nazis, and they are winning, due to overwhelming power of Russian advanced weapons and strength of its military, etc etc. Lies is what is holding Russia together and allows the war to continue. If somehow Russian government could no longer lie, there wouldn't be any war - or any Russian government as it is now, for that matter.
Even people not being Ukrainians can condemn war crimes and atrocities committed by Russians. Just as you don't have to be a Jew to condemn the Holocaust, or Armenian to condemn the Armenian genocide, or a Tutsi to condemn Rwandan genocide. Recoiling before the sights of inumane atrocity is not "war propaganda", it is a natural effect of learning about the atrocity and being horrified by it.
I don't think this is the case in any war. But in those where it was the case - yes.
Are Americans as a group to blame for war in Iraq and should be hated for it because majority of them once supported it?
Hated by whom? By Saddam Hussein? Probably. But why would I care what Saddam Hussein would think, if he wasn't hanged and dead?
And I don't think that majority of Russians will support SMO in the next 10 years.
So all we need is to wait 10 more years or terror, murders, war crimes and atrocities, and then it all be ok. Or at least some guy on the internet says so. That really makes one confident, thanks.

I disagree. I think it works because it exploits values most people have - like compassion, justice, kindness, sense of belonging, desire to protect the weak - and weaponizes it to goals completely alien to these values. Most people do not have innate immunity for that, at least not yet. It's like the virus getting into the cell - it uses its own resources for the goals that have nothing to do with the goals the cell is for. Most non-tribers and red-tribers do not know what to do if somebody attacks them with "here's some oppressed people and either you do exactly what I say or you're the oppressor" - and most people do not want to be the oppressors. That's where the crybullying gets its power - from the desire of people to be good and fear of people to fail to be good, which is successfully weaponized.
Because Red Tribe's values make for them very hard to weaponize compassion. The tribe that values individual strength, individual responsibility, individual merit and individual freedom would find it hard to convincingly pretend to be a helpless victim of circumstances and evil conspiracies. It's hard for them to pretend to be an innocent victim convincingly enough for the feelings of sympathy to overwhelm logical defenses. They are not ambush predators by nature. So copying a strategy that was not designed for them is not going to work very well. You can't have a spider and a hawk to hunt the same way.
More options
Context Copy link