@JarJarJedi's banner p

JarJarJedi


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


				

User ID: 1118

JarJarJedi


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

					

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


					

User ID: 1118

But to transfer these emotions from the army, from politicians, from specific criminals to gigantic groups of people consisting of millions of individuals is stupidity.

No it isn't, if the gigantic group of people is either willfully blind to the atrocities being committed by the army and the politicians, or are willingly supporting and encouraging them.

It's easily generalized - any advocacy for an idea X can be reframed as a dangerous call for violence against those who disagree with X. And if you doubt that, you can always find one or two idiots that would be willing to write on Twitter "if you disagree with X, you must die!". And if you find yourself in a rare idiot drought, you can always open an new twitter account and do it yourself... This form works absolutely regardless of the content, and thus can be applied against (or for) anything, provided you have the necessary power.

It never works this way. What is actually - and always - happening is there's a preferred narrative and there are in-groups and out-groups. It may not be stated explicitly, but it always happens one way or another. Comments dissenting from preferred narrative are deemed "misinformation". Comments offending the in-group are deemed "hate" - even if they are formulated in most polite and courteous terms possible (e.g.: there's no way to disagree with sexuality/gender theory and not be labeled "hateful" and "phobe", regardless of how polite and considerate you are). On the contrary, comments agreeing with the narrative would be deemed "truth" and "science", regardless of their agreement with the objective facts, and comments targeting an out-group would be deemed "vigorous discussion vital for our democracy", no matter how many f-bombs and calls for violence they contain.

What you are probably envisioning is some kind of clean space where everybody is polite and rational and are having thoughtful arguments, and you want that even at the cost of brutal repression. That is not what will happen however - the brutal repression would never be applied equally, and the space would be a paradise for whoever wants to "own" the other side, the side of the outgroup, and hell for whoever is on the other side.

So, does it mean if I injected somebody (non-allergic) with peanut butter extract mixed with an adjuvant (provided I find a safe way to do it without causing them harm) they'd get a peanut allergy?

Conversely, if somebody were vaccinated, e.g. against flu, and subjected constantly to low doses of flu virus - would they lose the immunity eventually? If not, again, why does it work with allergens and not with the flu virus?

I wonder if somebody from Sweden (with typical Scandinavian features) moves to Mexico, gets the citizenship, spends a while there and then moves to the US - would they be considered "from Mexico" and therefore "person of color"? What if their parents were from Sweden (i.e. same features, but born in Mexico, all papers are Mexican, etc)?

It's a common joke that Elon Musk is the richest African American, since he's actually from Africa - but I wonder, if he really were interested in declaring himself "person of color", could he do it?

I don't. I mean, I don't consider this question at all. But, since US society is insanely race-obsessed, I guess it'd depend on the purpose of the query. E.g. do you remember how George Zimmerman became "white" when what happened to him happened? I would bet in another context - e.g. if he was attacked by a member of Oath Keepers, say - he wouldn't be "white". Of course, sometimes it's hard to pull this trick - I personally look so white that nobody would believe I am not (even though KKK would vehemently object to including me in "white" - but they are on the dung heap of history now, so who cares). But in many other cases it depends a lot on the purpose. For me, putting Messi into "white" or "not white" box is absolutely useless - but if for you it is, then you have to start with what purpose these boxes of yours serve?

Potentially a stupid question based on misunderstanding, but it's really confusing to me now.

So, as far as I know, allergies are caused by immune system reacting to some substance, usually harmless to most people. One of the ways to treat allergies is to introduce small quantities of the allergen and try to get the immune system to stop treating it as a threat.

Then, the main function of the immune system is fighting infections - e.g. viruses or bacteria or whatever. Unfortunately, sometimes viruses and bacteria do their business so quickly that they overwhelm the system and it can not fight them off. To prevent that, we have vaccinations - where we introduce the small quantities of the antigen to the system and try to get the immune system to recognize it and fight them better when they come next time.

What is confusing to me is why in these two instances the same system is behaving in two opposite ways? In the first instance, if you introduce something it then makes the immune system to ignore it eventually, but in the second instance, if you introduce something, the immune system starts to react stronger to it? What am I missing?

Also, does this mean that if somebody didn't have a certain allergy, and I were their evil nemesis and wanted to give them one, I could do it by concocting a specific "vaccine" that would stimulate their immune system to react on the specific substance - just as regular vaccines do? Or somehow it works with one class of substances and not with the others, and if so - why?

I understand the full answer might be "get PhD in immunology and it'll all be clear to you" but maybe there's a shorter answer to this?

There are of course Gulag denialists in Russia, but they are not widely popular, for one crucial reason. Stalinists, who would be a natural audience for this, do not really think gulags were a bad thing. Surely, there were some excesses (перегибы), but in general it was a grandiose reform of the country, which always had and continues to have myriads of enemies, both outside and within - you can not do anything without somehow suppressing those enemies! Western inventions like freedom of speech, civil society with open political discussion, rule of law, etc. are not fit for Russia's special environment anyway, since Russia has its own destiny, and that destiny always included incarceration and/or otherwise removal of enemies of the people from the society. So there's nothing to deny really - except for rare instances of some particular person getting a bit over-zealous, but this is really small thing - there are criminals and bad cops everywhere, so are in Russia, nothing really to see there. It's not like USA doesn't have prisons - so Russia has prisons too, nothing special. So, nothing to deny.

I'm not sure it makes sense to draw conclusions for a single year of returns. Maybe they are geniuses. Maybe the found an exploit in the markets. Maybe they just bet on 15 black and it came out 15 black. How would you know from the dataset of 1?

Are you insinuating the results are fraudulent since no candidate had received 81M votes before

I would insinuate the results are fraudulent because a lot of evidence of irregularities has come up since then, but practically it is a useless discussion because the Republican establishment is not interested to rock the boat, and the rest have zero power to do anything about it. The sacred cow of "there's no electoral fraud" is not ready to be slaughtered yet. In any case, Republicans knew the rules of the game - including the fact that whatever cheating is going to happen, it's going to happen. They were either unable or unwilling to prepare and resist it - the buck for it, as for everything else, stops with Trump. Whether we should interpret it as "country rejecting Trump" or "Trump being bad at winning in the game of politics" is everybody's choice, the result is the same.

Somehow, some people still thinking that Trump supporters support Trump because he charmed them with some kind of magic spell and they listened to his MAGA siren song and became MAGA themselves. But this is the exact opposite of the truth - Trump got popular because he tapped in and became the focus point of unsatisfied need in the American politics. But then he departs from that point, his influence diminishes. When he is ineffective in serving those needs, his influence diminishes. I wouldn't go as far as proclaim he's beatable in 2024R, my personal opinion he is still going to win (and for DeSantis would be smart to sit this one out entirely). But his decline in popularity, I think, is in direct relation to his inability to efficiently govern and deliver on his promises. He has only two ways to go here: either invent some new way to deliver, that he haven't tried before, and somehow convince a lot of people that it's going to be different this time, or ride a slow decline of his popularity into an eventual political oblivion (or the position of a political commentator on TV).

Whatever Ray Epps' role was, it doesn't change the fact that it was just a spontaneous crowd gathered in naive beliefs, probably instigated by social media viral messaging.

Sure, but the question here is that there were some acts of violence and unlawful behavior. They are greatly exaggerated and overblown by the media (as expected) but who initiated them? Most people that are prosecuted are found guilty of the most mundane things akin to "walking where the government told you not to walk". However, we know some people did instigate the violence. Who were those people? We also know the FBI had informants there, and the FBI is not shy of using provocation tactics (see Whitmer "kidnapping" plot) - so were the FBI informants among those who instigated the violence, in order to turn a peaceful protest into something they could make a Congressional commission out of? If there were such people, we'd expect them to not be prosecuted, but instead to be used as vehicles for promoting such agenda.

And here we see a person who seemingly took part in instigating violence, was not prosecuted and is being used as a vehicle to promote the Dems agenda. If we learned he was working for the FBI (or any other part of the government apparatus) - it would confirm that the suspicions above are indeed true. Otherwise, we do not have a plausible explanation of why Epps was treated completely different from what we expect and see other protestors, often not guilty of anything more than walking through a space the government didn't like them to walk, are treated.

  • There was a person mentioned in Hunter Biden communications under the alias "the Big Guy" to which, as the communications allude, went part of the profits. It is widely assumed that it is Joe Biden, and he was a knowing partner in Hunter's dealings, but so far there's no direct proof of that AFAIK.

  • Ray Epps is a person who took active participation in the events of January 6, by his own admission "I orchestrated it", and was seen inciting certain violent actions, but who for reasons unknown is treated in a radically different way from all other protestors by Democrats, and not only his prosecution was dropped without any plausible explanation, but he was invited to testify in front of Jan 6 commission, and during that testimony the interrogators basically fed him (pun!) the answers. It is suggested by some that the reason for all that is that he is one of the many FBI informants that we know were present at the scene (and in general most right organizations, such as Oath Keepers or Proud Boys, are infested with FBI informants, which makes it plausible that there should be some at the scene on Jan 6) or an agent of some other governmental agency.

Yes, mostly marksmanship, target shooting.

Have a question on training and self-evaluation. I got some basic pistol courses and been practicing on the range from time to time for a while, and I think I am doing kinda OK, but I see various flaws in my shooting and I am not sure how to proceed to get better. Most of non-beginner trainings I've see around are for things like concealed carry and situations that arise from that, which I am currently less interested as I do not plan to carry, at least for now. I feel like just books and videos can only get me so far because they won't show me what I am in particular doing wrong or how I could fix my flaws. Any advice on this and how to improve? Am I thinking about it wrong or missing something?

we haven’t had a major war or civil unrest for decades

Who exactly is "we"? There's a shooting war almost a year old in the middle of Europe. There's several billions of damage from riots just recently, and some cities are more dangerous than war zones. Kids are graduated from schools being illiterate and unable to do basic math. War on poverty is going so well people are living on the streets permanently in virtually every major city and seeing people shitting on sidewalks became a routine occurrence. Oh yes, and we also are doing so great that record numbers of people kill themselves with hard drugs in prime of their life. I'm not sure it's as spectacular record as we'd like it to be.

Because it's getting too big to hide? Especially once full lockdown is removed, people start talking to each other and notice some people are missing. If the official statistics (arbitrary example) says there are 100 people dead in the whole China, and you know 20 people with dead relatives just in your city, it's impossible to believe. But if you add up a bit more, then it becomes more plausible.

I mean, I don't have any data now, right now it's just a suspicion, a theory and a gut feeling. We'll see.

I don't see why Biden needs cash less than Clintons, and Clintons took money from basically anybody.

I nominate these:

  1. Joe Biden is the Big Guy. I mean, everybody thinks that, but there's no proof. I expect it will show up eventually.

  2. There's something that covid vaccine does to athletic young males that makes it significantly riskier than presented (which was pretty much zero risk)

  3. Facebook and Google (YouTube) are as controlled by US government censors as Twitter was, and regularly and with minimal filtering execute governmental requests to suppress information and dissidents

  4. Ray Epps confirmed to have been working for US government

  5. We learn China has been lying about their covid stats and the real numbers of deaths are horrendous and all their zero-covid strategy was a colossal atrocity

The problem is not a single article. By itself it is indeed nothing. The problem is what gave raise to this article and what made it possible and normal and in some circles, laudable. Because it also made it possible to have racial quotas, people being fired for being of a wrong race, people being hired solely for being of a right race, mandatory racist trainings, "professors" calling whole races criminals and calling for their elimination, and, ultimately, people hearing those calls.

You seem to think it's all nothing, mere noise, because The Patriarchy is strong and never changes and since every white person is a member, there's nothing for any of them to worry about, however much hate and abuse is directed towards them. I think the situation is a bit different. Something like The Patriarchy does exist, but I am not a member and you are likely not a member either, and most people who are being called "white" aren't a members (tbh, most people that aren't being called "white" also aren't). And it absolutely does not care what you look like, if you're not a member - but willing to use how you look like to keep you under control, and if needed - to destroy you. And when people like the author of that article think by writing something like that they fight The Patriarchy, the do exactly the opposite - they spread the Approved Narrative because that's what was deemed useful. And if you happen to be fired, or denied opportunities, or not promoted, or plain old beaten up due to this narrative - it's all on you, because that's what the Narrative says.

One who is so sissified that he must constantly bark his head off at every perceived slight isn't an alpha, he's a chihuahua who needs to prove how threatening he is.

Have you actually tried to threaten an alpha? I don't think that's how actual alphas in hierarchical animal societies behave. I think if a lower ranking animal gets bold enough to challenge an alpha, there would be a fight. Or at least show of dominance that ensures the alpha is still an alpha.

I mean we as humans do not have to follow animalistic patterns, but if you bring that in - I don't think "true alpha is so secure in their power you can spit on him all day and he'd just smile" actually how it works. The point of chihuahua barking is to look threatening, yes. The point of Cane Corso not barking it already looks fucking terrifying. If you're sissified, you're not looking fucking terrifying. I don't think anybody can seriously claim that people in the US right now live in terror of white patriarchy. They certainly don't behave like it. I don't say they should be - but if it's not happening, you can not pretend it is and bring it as an argument.

I'm sure this guy appreciates that him being fired for being white is all on him. How dares he, indeed? Or this guy. Or this guy. Or this guy.

On the plus side, Harvard has finally, in 2022, achieved its long-term goal of getting the percentage of Jews getting in to no more than 10%. They have been working on it since 1920s. So if you happen to be young and smart and Jewish, and you didn't get into Harvard - it's totally on you. Maybe you can pretend to be 1/1024th Cherokee or something?

IIRC lower class black people were actually for more police intervention.

They are. And yet, they consistently vote for leaders who would oppose more police intervention and pressure the police to stay away from areas where these lower class black people live and institute training and policies which ensure the lower class black people can't rely on the police to protect them. And I don't mean like slight preference - I mean like 90%+ block voting for the same people that have been in power for decades and presided over things going downhill.

Some of it is open source, but open source does not prevent patents. I mean, patent holder would not likely hunt down small hobbyists, but at the moment it gets bigger and starts earning money, you get the lawyers on your doorstep.

And if the GOP can win elections they could always just pass laws getting rid of these patents.

The GOP is about three or four conceptual levels behind being able to to that. I would love to have the GOP that could understand problems like that and efficiently design strategies to handle them, but they are not even on the same continent with it. They still can't figure out how to make transparent and secure elections happen, something countries that use ink-stained fingers pull off successfully. If they can't figure out 19th century technology, how good would they be with 21th century technology? Especially when 99% of people who understands this technology also hates the GOP.

I don’t think society would like 3 megacorps controlling AI and 350 million Americans with no AI.

They probably wouldn't. But that doesn't mean that a) it wouldn't happen and b) the solution we'll arrive at wouldn't be worse than the initial problem. Remember the last big problem our system handled, aka the wu-flu? Are you impressed with how efficiently, sanely, competently, honestly and non-harmfully it was (is being?) handled? Now, western societies deal with infections for centuries. We at least have some experience how it works. How AI revolution would work - nobody has a slightest idea. Adjust your priors on how competently, efficiently and sanely any problems arising from it would be handled. I am not exactly optimistic there. At least it won't be boring I guess.

They need 17 or so people, I think there are more Dems that are entrenched enough that it'd be nigh impossible to primary them, at least not without the support from the top of the party. And if it's done under the orders from the top, then they'd be pretty safe.