@JarJarJedi's banner p

JarJarJedi


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


				

User ID: 1118

JarJarJedi


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

					

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


					

User ID: 1118

Two years is not that much, and it's one thing to occasionally make a mistake, and another to consistently use the wrong one while knowing it's wrong.

Well we have also the story of the priming work which was hyped to the high heavens and then turned out to be exaggerated, largely non-replicable and looking like Wikipedia's "list of research fallacies". That does not inspire too much confidence in similar approaches.

Probably one more of those studies whose conclusions are inflated way beyond their actual effects, and at the end they fail reproduction spectacularly, but not before there are 9000 books written about them and "everybody knows" they are true. I mean, it's possible it is not, but most likely it is.

This is also what was grating for me in Ancillary Justice - I get how the (ex)AI may be weak on the concept of gender, and how its (her?) default may be stuck on female. That's understandable. But a small child learns to grasp that concept - and how to use it - within rather short time. Breq is clearly aware (it was stated in the text, as I remember) that genders exist, and that gendered languages - including some she is using - exist, and that some of the people she is talking about are male (she may be unaware initially, but it's not after repeated encounters) and there is a proper way to address them in that language. Yet she keeps applying "she" to them as some kind of obsessive tick. That breaks the immersion. At least such a major flaw should be somehow addressed.

In general, the first part itself looked average for me. Some of the ideas and depiction of Raadch, its philosophy and the consequences of its multiple-personalities setup are well done, but the style and the pace didn't really work for me that well, and I couldn't really feel anything for the protagonist. Didn't try the other parts for this reason.

If aspiring writers of science fiction and fantasy can't make it without catering to woke sensibilities, then unfortunately the quality of the genre will drop drastically

I expect this is exactly what is going to happen. Likely already happening. Alas.

These guys may yet make Trump 2024 candidate, despite his own best efforts.

I feel in Europe it's a bitt different since there nobody gives a hoot about things like freedom of speech from the start, and there's no need to pretend. So you can just come out and say "we're going to control your speech for your own good, ordnung muss sein!" - and people will be ok with it. So maybe they can afford more principled approach since they are already in control. That said, given how they were pretty much silent over the era of censorship on Twitter 1.0, and started screaming immediately after Musk took over, I suspect they are also not as principled as they may say they are.

Too bad if it turns out the same genetic constellation also activates an unsatiable urge to steal suitcases in airports...

I interviewed at Facebook (years ago) and got an offer (didn't take it). Wasn't something any competent programmer couldn't pass, maybe with some preparation. I am pretty good, but not on "really really good" level probably (I know a lot of people better than me in many aspects). So it's not exactly easy, but probably doable for a significant number of people. Especially now, when they are so big - not everybody needs to work on optimizing compilers and quantum computing, some people would also write scripts to parse logs, etc. And it won't get you the top range $500k+ salary, but getting over $100k shouldn't be a problem.

I absolutely hate the fact that, due to the reactions that 90% of what Elon does now causes in the likes of this guy, they're starting to make me take his side. I don't like Elon!

Now you understand why some people voted for Trump, even though they didn't like him.

What I like most in this one is FBI dressing Twitter down for not giving them enough fodder for their narrative of foreign government constantly attacking the US democracy over social media and heroic efforts necessary to combat this imaginary onslaught. Even Roth is kinda taken aback - he thought less foreign meddling would be good? Looks like he still didn't get the game - it's not about achieving some end goal, it's about establishing control. Oceania has always been, and will always be, at war with Eastasia. Foreign governments has always meddled and will always meddle, and always require heroic censors to stand in their way. And if to prove that you need to mine 10-follower accounts for ancient jokes about Wednesday elections - then so be it.

It's the same in offline world btw - how many "plots" turned out to be constructed by the FBI out of the whole cloth recently? That's what happens when you corrupt the watchdogs.

Only that none of this was even unknown or outside the mainstream.

When it was first reported, it was "libelous accusations without any proof, we won't lower ourselves to discuss such baseless rumors". When the proofs started appearing later, it's "old news, everybody knew that, we already discussed it years ago, nothing to discuss here, move on already!". Simple trick, but surprisingly effective.

Usually acts that get impunity is like stealing billions of dollars and causing deaths of tens of thousands, but acts that get consequences is something like stealing a bag.

Well, at least he is not a complete idiot. Which should be normally a default for a MIT graduate but now you never know.

The real question is why studios continually favor hiring not just mercenaries but mercenaries with little experience

I suspect maybe because mercenaries with experience can't speak fluent woke, and mercenaries with little experience can. And studio executives feel that if they don't have enough woke credentials, the critics and twitter mob will rip them a new one, and they certainly don't want that to happen. So it's not like they choose poor producers, it's that their criteria for choosing weren't "who would make the best story", but, for example, "who would ensure best hype among people that matter". Even if the goal isn't explicitly to make a woke product, if you hire people that don't rub the woke the right way, there would be wailing, and gnashing of teeth, and nobody wants that trouble.

Actually, if you read "Whither Tartaria" and numerous articles on the same topic lately, there are indications that yes, at least some mansions are built this way too - i.e. that the choice had more to do with social currents than with the expected utility of the result. Not sure about yachts, I know nothing about that.

I've seen some pretty grotesque Tolkien adaptations. And in some of those the lack of craftsmanship (and budgets) was obvious. But here I think the problem wasn't that.

The writers of Rings of Power are unwilling to do any work.

And the reason for that I think was that they weren't in love with the world and the story. If you are, you'd put in your best work, billion dollars or not - just because that's what you dreamt of doing for ages. But that didn't seem to happen here. It's like the parts of the story for them were just tokens which can be combined in any way or form and as soon as it looks passable to them, it's good enough. I think it's not because the lack of skill - but because they though whatever they did is good enough and they don't need to do better.

I think there's a lot of reasons there, but the main reason is simpler. This is a thing made by people that aren't in love with Tolkien and his world. They are doing it for money, or for culture war reason, or for any other reason - but their primary goal seems to be something other than to cherish and enhance the Professor's legacy. This is the only way I can explain the decisions that were made and the approaches that were taken there. Dissecting the details can have its own fascination, but for me the main reason stays the same.

This is why, as a long-time (since the 80s, probably?) Tolkien fan, I am not even mad at them. As noted above, and I agree, it's just not Tolkien. It's using Tolkien for... whatever, I can't even care about it. Best thing that can be done about it is to file it to a dusty shelf of history where the weird curiosities are stored, and only take it out when we need to feel better by looking at something extremely cringe-worthy.

I never claimed anything like that. I claimed that if you weren't rich and then became rich, it's not "making your whole", it's much more than that. Your statement of "same harassment is more damaging to richer people" is indeed absurd, but I never claimed anything like it.

But focusing on whether it is a windfall is a red herring; the question is whether the amount of damages reflects the harm suffered

It looks like you taking only half of my argument. The whole argument is that the windfall is not reasonable exactly because the damage is not windfall-worthy, so to speak. I know that trying to establish order on suffering is always morally suspect and smells wrong, but if we're talking money compensation, there's no way around it. And once we get past that moral objection, I think, absent new information unknown to me, that $10M does not sound very reasonable against the angle of "make the plaintiffs whole".

But I feel like lately the veneer is peeling off more and the raw unadulterated tribalism is proudly paraded everywhere. We used to have people that are genuinely committed to things like freedom of speech, society control over government, limited government, due process, journalistic standards, etc. We used to have people that tried to at least maintain the facade of evenhandedness and principles. Some of them are still around - but virtually none of them are part of the "establishment", whatever that means in a particular area - they are either forced out or left, foreseeing being forced out. The rule of the day seems to be "2*2 depends on whether we are talking about something useful for my tribe, or something harmful". People openly and vigorously defend opposing viewpoints in the timeframe of months sometimes, and they are not flustered anymore when reminded they said the opposite only a short while ago - they just shrug it off as "enemy propaganda" and march on. I don't know, maybe I am just noticing more, but it seems like it not used to be that way 10 years ago or so.

Of course they do. In the middle of a culture war, you can't really expect it to be fought just by one side.

It does matter because compensation is meant to restore and repair the harm that was done to you. If you never were a multimillionaire, you can not honestly claim to restore harm done to you you should become one. When it's grievous bodily harm (say, you lose your hand, or get cancer) it may be different, because loss of life or quality of life is very hard to repair with money, and even to approach it one needs a lot of money. But here it's not the case, that's why I am questioning the reasonableness. And surely the percentile matters - otherwise how would you know if $10M is a lot or not? Money is a social thing, so to know how much money is $10M you need to look at the society. Maybe in some society even $1000 would be a huge sum of money, but in ours it's not a lot. To have this measure, we need to use percentiles.

Either the monetary compensation was commensurate with their damages, or it was not.

That's my point - I don't see how $10M is commensurate.

There are plenty of people, after all, who would refuse any amount of money to be subjected to what some of those parents were subjected to

That's not a good argument, since that implies infinite compensation for anything that I would never agree to do voluntarily. Let's say I hate you very much, and would never agree to give you my car for a ride, not even for a billion of dollars, I am very stubborn this way. You break into my house one day and take my car for a ride. No harm done to the house or the car, but I feel very bad about it. Does it entitle me to a compensation over a billion dollars? I don't think most people would agree to that as a reasonable approach.

At the very least, a tortfeasor who profits from his tort should be forced to disgorge those profits, which in this case might well exceed $10 million.

That's different from a compensation. Compensation is measured against damages, not profits. If you said the court should take all Jones' profits gained from his lies (let's imagine it is possible to figure it out) and distribute it equally between the victims - that would be a different thing, but that's not what you said.

I agree that wasn't exactly effortpost, but I disagree about weekmanning. My opinion is that ADL have turned completely political, and has converted from a principled institution fighting anti-semitism and bigotry to a partisan reputation laundering outlet that cynically cashes in on these sentiments for partisan reasons. Thus it is useless to mention it as a trustworthy arbiter in cases like this. This is not a random throwaway boo, this is a result of long (and rather painful, for me, as a Jewish person) observation of their (de-)evolution.

I think he'd take a couple of months to get up to date with the current party line, and then we'd get the same Biden. He'd be still occasionally say things like "poor kids are just as smart as white kids", or "you cannot go to a 7-Eleven or a Dunkin’ Donuts unless you have a slight Indian accent", or call his black party comrades "clean and articulate" when he wanted to compliment them.

  • Right-wing politicians, journalists and public personas suspended, banned and shadow-banned for years - "It's a private company, just don't be an asshole!"

  • Left-wing journos suspended for one day for doxing Musk - "It's fascism! Regulators, come and save us! It's free speech apocalypse!"

It is utterly fascinating how there's not a shred of even trying to apply fair standards here. Everything is completely motivated reasoning all the way down.

Why $10M is reasonable? I mean, spreading vile lies is without doubt despicable, but $10M is more than life earnings of most Americans, and that not taking into account future value discounts. Basically, it's a sum that moves you to a category of "never has to work again unless you want to" and maybe the same for their family (depending on the size). I could understand if that was presented as "reasonable punishment" - this is a ruinous amount for the liar, and if you want to ensure nobody lies in such manner ever, it's reasonable to use a huge fine to ensure that. However, as a compensation, I do not understand why it is reasonable that a person who was a victim of a lie (admittedly, a very vile and disgusting one, but still one lie), should instantly become top 1% rich just because of it? I mean, if they suffered huge economic or physical losses because of the lie, I'd understand this, but did they suffer losses like that?

Yeah I didn't know that when I wrote it, but now I know about that case and it definitely looks like something that could trigger a person. If somebody used some stupid twitter doxer service to attack my kid, I probably would be hugely pissed too, both at the attacker and at the service. It's not unprecedented for bad things to happen to rich/famous people's kids, even without political angle, and some antifa types have absolutely no limits nowdays, as it seems...