JeSuisCharlie
Sumner, Hebdo, Kirk
Formerly "SandwichWarrior" and "The Upright Man", may or may not be feral, is most certainly quixotic.
User ID: 4009
I believe that the conflict between people with "skin in the game" and people without will be the defining conflict of this generation. I believe that a lot of the drama surrounding MAGA and the various European populists movements (EG. Marine Le Pen in France) can be explained in the context of this conflict. Finally I do not expect this conflict it to go well for a lot of posters here as IMO statements like "meritocracy is pointless" are luxury beliefs afforded to people who are not being tested on a regular basis.
Vivek's problem is that his whole persona is designed to appeal to edge-lords on twitter, when edge-lords on twitter are a overwhelmingly Democratic Party constituency. Meanwhile the MAGA crowd having taken his statements at face value have concluded that he must be either a beltway grifter or a progressive Trojan Horse.
This just makes the university appear less competent than they already did. IF the university was aware of the political pressure they would've presumably passed that down to their TAs and/or kept their TAs on a shorter leash which they clearly did not.
Whether OU is a tier 1 research institution or a tier 9 is not relevant to the matter at hand.
What’s your theory on how they sustained a high trust society given this kind of defection?
The obvious reply is that they did not sustain it, see @RoyGBivensAction's reply below
You beat me to the reference.
They weren't "stupid" they were "trusting". As @hydroacetylene observes, the defining trait of a "high trust society" is that you can just say shit and people will believe you, or at a minimum give you the benefit of the doubt.
Some stuff is cheaper, some stuff is more expensive; if the more expensive stuff is essentials, but the cheaper stuff is everything else, people can feel squeezed by the economy without actually being squeezed.
For what it's worth I feel like this is the opposite of what is happening, and I think this may explain much of the disconnect between how different demographics view the economy. I Imagine that for a single urban professional living in the city the current economy kind of sucks, housing is at a premium and consumer goods (especially imported consumer goods) have gone up in price. In the meantime, if you are a married couple with 2.5+ kids and a dog living in the 'burbs, two of your biggest expenses, food and transportation, have not only stabilized after climbing steadily for 4 years but in some areas are starting to trend downwards so naturally those people are feeling more optimistic about their situation than they were a year ago.
I find this comment to be in especially bad taste.
What do you do?
If you're asking me, personally (as opposed to the state) I say "Fuck it we ball".
If your partner is infertile, that is unfortunate, but miracles do happen. Things like adoption as well as integrating yourself into the lives of your nieces and nephews, or becoming a godparent to the children of your friends are also options you could pursue. Heck, you could even coach little league.
I do not want to come across as dismissing your fears out of hand but I am going to dismiss them. My early life was not as rough as yours, but it was also not without it's trauma and drama. I was a bit of a delinquent in my youth, and I know all too well the "joys" of sharing a family with addicts, alcoholics, and paranoid schizophrenics. Much of my adult life has been shaped by a desire to prove that I am not like them, and that I could turn things around. The fact that you are scared is a sign of a healthy outlook. You know who isn't worried about fucking up her kids? Your fucked up sister.
My first was an accident, completely unplanned, and I was scared shitless when I found out. I shared many of your concerns and your uncertainty. However, with the benefit of hindsight I also recognize that if my partner and I had waited till we were "ready" it would have never happened. Our first is now in middle school and has since been joined by multiple siblings, the youngest of whom we welcomed into the world just a few weeks ago. I'm still scared shitless but I'm also used to it now. What I've learned is do not let fear stop you from doing things that need to be done.
To echo @BreakerofHorsesandMen, for better or ill, the choices that will define your old age are on you. It is OK to be afraid, but do not let fear stop you from making those choices.
My understanding is that 0.38 Special is roughly equivalent to 9x19mm Parabellum in terms of terminal ballistics with 9mm ultimately winning out on the basis of being more compact, that that 0.45 and 9mm have killed a roughly equal number of people over the years, but I hadn't considered the 0.357 mag side of things. I may owe @hydroacetylene an apology.
"Lone wolves" that enjoyed a broad base of moral and material support from both the wider left, and ostensibly neutral parties such as yourself.
I chose to create this account and "rejoin" the motte after a year+ of mostly lurking as a reaction to Charlie Kirk's murder, or more specifically as a reaction to the reaction. I see the fact that a lot of people celebrated it, and that a fair number of users here are trying to dismiss and down play it as a serious problem because what you are doing is actively working to normalize sectarian violence in the US.
As I have said in prior posts on the subject I don't think it was Charles Sumner (the man in my profile pic) being beaten half to death on the floor of the senate that killed the existing norms against political violence and made Civil War inevitable. It was the fact that the Democrats along with the "Moderates" from Sumner's own party (the Whigs) chose to defend his attackers. In a world where Preston Brooks and Laurence Keitt are immediately arrested and face clear bi-partisan condemnation, a radical like Lincoln never gets elected.
When is this alleged shift supposed to have occurred? 9x19 Parabellum and 0.45 ACP have been the dominant cartridges in police and civilian use since the 1930s, and the two runners up 0.22 Long rifle and the "modern" 12 Gauge Shotgun cartridge both date back to the 1880s.
Yes 5.56 NATO is a relatively new cartridge that only saw wide-spread civilian adoption in the aftermath of the cold-war but that's a rifle cartridge and rifles represent a relatively small percentage of recorded homicides in the US. Approx. 2,700 out of 81,000 if the FBI's crime data explorer is to be believed. Even if we assume that 100% of homicides committed with an unrecorded type were committed with a 5.56 Rifle that's still not much more than the number of people killed with conventional handguns.
If you want to "speak softly" you need a big stick.
I don't know what he was like before coming to the US but my understanding is that he's a normal establishment progressive by the standards of Europe which puts him well into "far left" territory by the standards of US Politics.
I first became aware of him during the the 2012 election while he was at CNN where he described Mitt Romney as a dangerous far right authoritarian and claimed that the republicans were going end women's suffrage if they won. He was a outspoken supporter of woke cancel mobs and social media censorship through Obama's second and Trump's first terms, and nothing I've seen from him to date has made me think that he doesn't still hew to those views.
It's like watching someone sink tons of three pointers but can't even dribble.
Which in turn feeds the narrative regarding Fuentes being a "Fed"/"Trojan Horse"/"Controlled Opposition" that you'll see in more conservative aligned spaces. The fact that this interview is coming from a nakedly progressive partisan like Piers Morgan only fans those flames.
There is no objective truth, there are no facts. Particularly on Reddit, facts are distorted to promote a narrative.
This is not just on reddit, this is everywhere including here. The absence of a clear truth (objective or otherwise) is a core feature of online discourse.
On the Internet, nobody knows you're a dog.
Would a full-blown attack on GPS satellites not cross the nuclear threshold for the US?
30 years ago? Probably not. However I can imagine a scenario where someone in the decision loop interprets it as an attempt disable American early warning and missile defense assets in preparation for a more general nuclear strike, and then makes that case to the President.
Today? Absolutely not. The huge expansion of civilian space infrastructure along with massive improvements in the fidelity of both space and earth-based sensors means that we are no longer dependent as we once were on a small number of strategic satellites that could easily be knocked out by an adversary. And with the US representing a super-majority of world's total space lift capacity I think the more likely outcome in the event of such an attack would be a bunch of Chinese Satellites suffering sudden unexplained failures or falling out of the sky for no reason while the US Space Force conspicuously refuses to confirm nor deny playing any role in the matter.
I don't find it difficult to understand at all. They're starting from the position that Mangione should not be punished, and then formulating their arguments accordingly.
Take your troops home like Soviets did
The US has proposed doing just that on multiple occasions (most recently in March/April of this year) and the response from both the German and UK establishment has always been overwhelming opposition.
I feel like this is bait, because there are quite a few Americans who this denunciation would apply to today.
Yes, that is a large component of what makes Trump and the MAGA movement so divisive.
A society that looks like church #1 sounds like a dystopian nightmare to me. Something like the society in Ayn Rand's book Anthem.
It is funny, on one hand church #1 sounds really nice to me, on the other I also kind of hate both the Randian Dystopia and the Randian Protagonist. I'm curious to hear why it triggers that reactions because I feel like it might tell us both something meaningful about ourselves.
Piers' and the general Conservative, boomer, narrow loyalty to certain propositions, legal documents, and historical institutions is a thinly veiled expression of loyalty to socially dominant Memes...
First; Peirs Morgan has never been a "conservative", in fact much of his career has been defined by his opposition to both Conservate and American hegemony. He's one of the central examples of an advocate for enlightened neo-liberal technocracy.
Second; As I said in a earlier post Something I don't think you or a lot have users here have really grasped is that Trump and a core contingent the MAGA crowd are playing Teddy Roosevelt's bit about "Hyphenated Americans" absolutely straight,. Racially-oriented thinking is not "taboo", so much as it is viewed as weak, degenerate, and anti-American. To quote Teddy...
The one absolutely certain way of bringing this nation to ruin, of preventing all possibility of its continuing to be a nation at all, would be to permit it to become a tangle of squabbling nationalities, an intricate knot of German-Americans, Irish-Americans, English-Americans, French-Americans, Scandinavian-Americans, or Italian-Americans, each preserving its separate nationality, each at heart feeling more sympathy with Europeans of that nationality than with the other citizens of the American Republic...
...The man who calls himself an American citizen and who yet shows by his actions that he is primarily the citizen of a foreign land, plays a thoroughly mischievous part in the life of our body politic. He has no place here; and the sooner he returns to the land to which he feels his real heart-allegiance, the better it will be for every good American
There was a release of the first season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer in widescreen where they not only didn't remove crew at the edge of shots, they also forgot to darken the night scenes and tint them blue.
I had completely forgotten about the "Day Walker Edition" of BtVS when I wrote my own post, but yes. I would wager that this is exactly what happened.
My read was not that everyone suddenly began acting like idiots once they touched down, it's that the Cardinal was an idiot from the start but was insulated from the consequences of his idiocy by a combination of luck and people who where more careful than he was. Two resources that ran out quickly once he was on his own.

One of these days I will have to write my oral history of the Republican civil war, but today is not that day.
In any case that is not how I remember things going down.
What Trump did was accurately identify key fault lines that cut across large swaths of both the conservative and corporate sides of the Republican electorate as well as former Democrats who'd been alienated by the national party's embrace of things like open borders, decarceration, drag queens in pre-schools, and men in women's sports. IE "it's the economy stupid", bread and butter issues are what win elections. This should not have been such a novel insight but this is where the whole "skin in the game" element comes into play.
By the spring of 2016 it was already clear that the upcoming election would be a fight between the beltway establishment and some variant of the Tea-Party with Hillary Clinton representing the establishment. A vote for Hillary was a vote for more of the same, and for a large swath of the population who viewed the foreign, financial, and domestic policies of the last decade as just one massive fuck-up after another "more of the same" was not a compelling sales pitch. @faceh's rant about rewarding failure reflects much of the sentiment I heard from voters at the time. As such it seemed clear to me that despite being the favorites of the national party neither Jeb Bush nor Chris Christie ever really stood a chance. If a voter wanted business as usual, what did either of those two have to offer over Hillary? Accordingly the 2016 Republican primary looked like it was Ted Cruz's to lose. However, Cruz's campaign was hampered by the fact that he was a career politician with no real accomplishments to his name aside of being able to climb the party ladder. As such there was a lot of discussion at the state committee level about whether Cruz had the balls to fight the beast or would he become just another beltway stooge if elected.
something I don't think that a lot of our more liberal posters here really grasp is that despite their surface level similarities the internal organization and power structures of the Republican and Democratic parties are radically different. Republican state and municipal committees are more like independent chapters than wholly-owned subsidiaries. State and municipal reps wield real power and a national party endorsement doesn't carry the same weight in funding or in raw primary votes that it would in the Democratic Party. The Florida RNC backed Trump over Jeb Bush despite Bush being the governor of Florida at the time, and there wasn't anything the national committee could do about it because Florida was a net contributor to the national fund.
Enter Trump, Trump doesn't have Cruz's problem, he's not a career politician, he has a portfolio of accomplishments he can point to, and for all the sneering from establishment liberals about him not being a proper gentlemen, there is no question in anyone's mind about whether he has the balls or stomach for a fight. By adopting the most popular planks of the Tea-Party platform he immediately made himself the front runner. Cruz and Trump would fight it out to the end, but the choice was only ever going to be between Tea-Party original recipe (Cruz and Rubio), and Tea-Party extra crispy (MAGA). When Rubio threw his lot in with Trump, that put an end to the debate.
Trump isn't "wearing the Republican party like skinsuit" so much as he is the brick that the electorate has chosen to throw through the establishment's window. You and others keep throwing around words like "destruction", "chaos" and "weaponized incompetence" like this wasn't the plan from the start. It's only "incompetence" if you define "competence" as supporting a top-down liberal order.
More options
Context Copy link