@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

On the "hereditary oppression" theory of what is wrong with Black America, ADOS experienced slavery until the 1860's, Jim Crow until the 1960's, and life under hostile white majority rule ever since. The British Caribbean abolished slavery in 1833 (de jure) or 1838-1840 (de facto) - by which point they had already repealed Jim Crow-style restrictions on free blacks, stopped trying to maintain a plantation economy by the 1860's, and brought in near-universal suffrage (and therefore black majority rule within the powers of the local elected assemblies) in 1944. Most Jamaicans in America emigrated after independence in 1962. So although sugar plantation slavery was more lethal than cotton plantation slavery, there is a pretty easy case that the descendants of the survivors suffered more hereditary oppression in the US.

Interesting. I would interpret “put him up against the wall” as a reference to unofficial political violence - the same context as “first against the wall when the revolution comes”

What are the conditions for obtaining the elderly pass vs the youth pass? In the US some make a similar argument with regards to a firearms permit vs a student ID, and it turns out that, I think, even non-citizens can obtain the latter. But I am certain the former has more checks.

Both can be obtained easily by non-citizens who meet the other requirements (as can a driving license, which is the most commonly used form of acceptable ID) - this is specifically an identity check and not a citizenship check. British citizenship law is such a mess that requiring proof of citizenship to vote would effectively disenfranchise everyone who hadn't already proved their citizenship to apply for a passport (admittedly, 86.5% of UK adults do have passports). The official reason given was that the checks made when issuing elderly passes are more stringent but it isn't clear why - in particular there is no attempt to verify the photo if you apply for an elderly pass by post, whereas the photo on a student pass is cross-checked against the photo on your student ID.

I'm sorry - I wasn't intending to call for Gaiman's murder - I was trying to say that I favoured, in full knowledge of what it meant, a society where quid-pro-quo sexual harassment of employees was treated as a serious crime on a similar level to rape.

I suspect I have fallen foul of a difference between the cultural significance of hanging and nooses in American and British society - in the UK a noose is a symbol of excessively harsh laws, not vigilantism.

In the specific case of Neil Gaiman, "don't fuck the nanny" is both a well-known social rule, and the law of the land (as workplace sexual harassment). It isn't a difficult case.

because he somehow knows that she'll feel bad after, is rank paternalism.

The actual social conservative response to this is yeschad.jpg. The idea that a resource as socially valuable as access to prime-age pussy should be under the absolute control of people as irresponsible as teenage girls is obviously silly if you start from the basic moral perspective of pre-liberal conservatism. Under herder* culture patriarchy, fooling around with a girl in a way which leaves her as damaged goods is treated as a property crime against her father or husband (which might be forgiven if the perp was sufficiently high-status relative to the victim). Under Christian patriarchy, it is treated as spoiliation of a community resource and (in times and places where the system of Church-led community justice worked as intended) the remedy was making the man clear up the mess through some or all of shotgun-marrying the girl, paying her "dowry" to bribe the village herb into marrying her, or acknowledging and supporting the bastards.

Feminists, like tradcons, are clear-eyed that a functioning society needs to stop lotharios manipulating silly girls into relationships which, while good for the lothario, are net-negative for society. They just have to take some extra steps in order to obfuscate the hate-fact that most prime dating-age women are silly girls.

* The mods have asked me not to call it goatfucker patriarchy, so I won't.

The 25th has to be invoked voluntarily by Joe Biden, or by Kamala Harris and a majority of the Cabinet. As long as Biden is physically able to sign documents and read prepared speeches off a teleprompter, Cabinet secretaries' jobs are more fun with no boss than working for Harris.

I don't know why the names of charismatic megafauna are learnt so early, but both my kids knew lion, camel, rhino, elephant, dinosaur etc. well before their second birthdays.

This was reinforced by available media - picture books, toys, Youtube Kids etc.

I agree that its weird, but I would be very surprised if a cognitively normal three-year old in WEIRD culture struggled to name those animals.

Ah yes, the continuity SDP, the most pathetic political party in the UK. By my account they got fewer votes than the Official Monster Raving Loony Party in both seats where both parties were on the ballot (Brighton Pavilion and Louth and Horncastle), and the only reason why they didn't lose to more Loonies is that most of the declared Loony candidates didn't manage to file their nomination papers on time. They should have stayed disbanded after losing to a Loony in the 1990 Bootle by-election.

This is the first UK general election where voter ID was required, having previously been trialled for local elections. Unlike in the US, this is considered by most to be a sensible technocratic fix rather than a sinister plot to disenfranchise anyone (although a few UK lefties seem to have imbibed US memes enough to see it as such).

It is well-known that voter ID was, in fact, a plot to disenfranchise young people. The main tell was that discounted public transport passes given to pensioners were eligible ID, but discounted public transport passes given to students and apprentices were not. Jacob Rees Mogg admitted this at the 2023 National Conservatism conference.

It is also well-known that the type of voter fraud that voter ID prevents (i.e. voting in person in the name of someone else) is not a problem in the mainland UK (it was a problem in Northern Ireland during the Troubles, so Northern Ireland has always had voter ID). The most corrupt election in recent British history was the 2014 mayoral election in Tower Hamlets, and the Election Court judgement convicts or at least credibly accuses Luftur Rahman of basically every form of electoral fraud or malpractice under the sun except that one. The in-person voter fraud Rahman committee involved Rahman supporters outside Tower Hamlets voting in their own name after registering at false addresses.

The difference between the US and UK voter ID debates is that there is no legal process where crying "waa waa it's racist" can invalidate a law, so the British left had no reason to do so. The Labour party did put out leaflets in student-heavy areas saying "the Tories are trying to use voter ID to disenfranchise you, here's how to stop them."

I really do believe an adult woman should and does have the agency to refuse that last kind of ultimatum.

Empirically, they don't. I employ nannies, and I have had young women working in my house who would not have been able to say no to a well-executed "question expecting the answer yes". As well as the threat to employment (and housing for a live-in nanny) and the possibility of a bad reference (references are essential for childcare employment for obvious reasons), it is easy to add a plausibly-deniable implicit threat of violence. Plus 19-year-old girls just don't have as much agency as adult men.

Even if she did have the agency to say no, having to do so would be expensive in financial and reputational terms - particularly for a nanny who relocated to take a live-in role (as Gaiman's did, and so did some of mine). In general, managing the risk of shitty behaviour by a counterparty sometimes requires people to avoid trades that would be mutually beneficial. (This is why high-trust societies are richer than low-trust ones).

If it was common for men in my position to engage in quid-pro-quo sexual harassment of nannies, I wouldn't be able to hire nannies, and my wife would have to give up her freelance business, with a knock-on impact her clients' businesses. (She is one of <10 skilled technical writers in a niche subspecialism). Empirically, where quid-pro-quo sexual harassment is tolerated, it is common. So, with the greatest possible respect, Gaiman should FOAD. If the events happened as described, regardless of whether it was formally consensual, I would cheerfully hang him myself.

However, it got quickly rendered obsolete by stories such as this, where a reknown cancer researcher was Canceled for grooming a 29 year-old researcher and seasoned carousel rider*:

She was a junior employee in the department where he was a lab head, and the Whithead Institute had an explicit policy prohibiting consensual sex between lab heads and junior employees. He wasn't cancelled for grooming anyone, he was cancelled for violating a black-letter rule. You may think it is a bad rule - I, personally think it is a good one. But there is a big difference between "sex between old men and younger women is inherently abusive" and "sex between powerful men and women whose careers they have a high degree of control over is inherently abusive."

a matter of retroactively revoked consent a decade later.

She was his employee. I have a policy of not reading salacious details beyond what is necessary to form judgement, but my wife tells me that the specific sex acts involved were such that the prior on "my boss made me do it" is higher than "I thought it was a good idea at the time". I don't think the sex was euvoluntary in the first place.

he's not doing anything illegal

I suspect it qualifies as workplace sexual harassment - which while not criminal is definitely illegal. The details of sexual harassment law differ by jurisdiction, but convincing your employee that her continued employment depended on saying "yes" qualifies almost everywhere.

(if he makes a habit of this as it seems like he has been then he's almost certainly given alcohol to a twenty year old)

If this happened in the UK, the drinking age in private homes is 5.

Even without Presidential immunity, it is an interesting question whether the speech would be protected by the Speech and Debate clause. The Speech and Debate clause is written to only protect Representatives and Senators, but given that it has penumbras and emanations that protect members' and committee staffers, it seems like it could reasonably be extended to protect the President giving the SOTU.

If the speech was protected by the S&D clause, the President could still be impeached for it (because that is a proceeding in Congress) but not prosecuted (even after impeachment, because S&D protection can't be waived).

The British parties actually have a system for telling MPs (and Lords) just how unacceptable a rebellion would be. The party whips produce a roughly weekly newsletter for their MPs (also called "The Whip") giving warning of forthcoming votes and telling them which way to vote. The preferred vote is underlined once for an important vote where MPs are expected to show up, twice for a vote where MPs are required to show up (unless "paired" with an absent opposition MP) but only habitual offenders will actually be punished for not showing, and three times for a vote where MPs are required to show up and unauthorised absence will be punished by default. Rebelling against a three-line whip will, in theory, get you kicked out of the party caucus (in British terminology, "having the Whip withdrawn" because caucus membership is de facto defined by the circulation of the newsletter) but in practice only happens where there is safety in numbers such that the Party leadership can't afford to kick all the rebels out.

Crossing the floor - voting against your own party

As an interesting piece of political terminology geekery, in most Commonwealth countries "crossing the floor" means an elected office-holder leaving their party to join another party - a far more drastic step than just voting against your party on a single vote. In British parlance, voting against your party on a whipped vote is called "rebelling".

The public interest in preventing harassing lawfare against private citizens (including ex-Presidents) is a lot weaker than the public interest in preventing harassing lawfare against a sitting President.

The constant filing of trivial and/or frivolous ethics complaints is what drove Sarah Palin out of the Governor’s office in Alaska

Given that those were not criminal prosecutions with the risk of jail time, that is much closer to Jones vs Clinton (where SCOTUS ruled that lawfare against a sitting President was just fine) than United States vs Trump.

but the plan was to have Pence reject some of the electoral slates, and force a debate within the house over the merits of the fraud claims.

If the election is thrown into the House because neither side gets a majority in the Electoral College, that is the opposite of "forcing a debate over the merits of the fraud claims". The process for forcing a debate over the fraud claims is an objection to a State certificate under the rules set out in the Electoral Count Act. Such objections were made, in the cases of AZ and PA debated, and rejected in Congress on January 6/7 2021. (It was during the AZ debate that the rioters entered the Capitol building and forced an adjournment.)

The contingent election that Eastman was trying to use isn't a procedure for debating who won the Electoral College vote - it is an alternative procedure specified by the Constitution for use when it is clear that no-one won the Electoral College vote. Consistently with most of Trump's strategy, it isn't an attempt to litigate the counting of the votes cast in November, it is an attempt to throw them all out and decide the election without reference to them. (In this case, a party-line House vote with unequal weighting of votes). In fact, the simple, obvious reading of the Constitution is that it doesn't even allow a debate - the Constitution says that the House should vote "immediately".

How many "double haters" would voluntarily show up for a no-cameras focus group?

There is a reason why focus group participants are paid. How many double haters would explain just how much they hate both candidates in front of a sympathetic audience for $100? Quite a lot.

The point of a focus group isn't to get a large enough sample for statistically meaningful results - it is to listen to what people say. You only need 5-15 people to hear all the common opinions, so you can afford to pay them.

Surely the economic way out for Biden is that the economic vibes continue to drift in the direction of the actual state of the economy. Unemployment doesn't need to drop further in PA, voters just need to realise that it is at 3.4%

The election is close in a world where the median voter thinks the economy sucks. If the median voter realises that the economy does not, in fact, suck, then Biden wins on fundamentals.

A nitpick, but 2004 was no cruise. It wasn't as close as 2000, and CNNs attempt to claim that Ohio was still too close to call as of Wednesday morning was cope, but it really was the case that both ex ante (based on polls and fundamentals) and ex post (based on winning by a single state, where the result was 51-49) the election was unusually close.

Most incumbent Presidents who don't wreck the economy cruise to a second term. W held on by the skin of his teeth.

He actually is a good golfer, even if he lies about his scores.

When was the last time Trump played a round of golf where his score was verified by someone other than a MAGA ally or a subordinate? His best scores all seem to come at his own golf courses.

You can't estimate the ground truth by adjusting the words of a lying liar.

What do we mean by "pro-war" here?

Neither party favours America fighting the war in Ukraine. America has various other levers that they can use to influence the result - Biden thinks that America should use them to work towards a Ukrainian victory, Trump that America should use them to work towards a Russian victory (his policy only makes sense if he is planning to jawbone Ukraine into surrendering). I don't see why an aggressor winning is an "anti-war" outcome.