MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
To extend the Taylor Swift example, if her fans started physically threatening her exes while she kept composing pop melodies like "My Ex is a Dirtbag Who Totally Deserves to Die," I think her exes might have a legitimate civil case.
It would have to be a false statement of fact, whereas this is opinion, so no defamation liability. "My Ex kicks puppies and is a dirtbag who deserves to die" would potentially be actionable if Joe Alwyn does not, if fact, kick puppies. In the US, Swift might get away with "I was obviously joking", so not really a statement of fact, so no liability (Elon Musk successfully ran this defence after falsely accusing Vernon Unsworth of being a paedophile). But Alwyn is British and Swift's albums are published in the UK, so an English court would have jurisdiction and "I was obviously joking" is not a defence in the UK.
In a political compass model, the FDP was to the right of the CDU on economic issues and to their left on social issues. (The CSU is a Bavarian party which has caucused with the CDU since forever, but is the farthest right of all the respectable parties on both economic and social issues because Bavaria is the Texas of Germany).
The fact that it is easy to explain the difference between the FDP and CDU but hard to given an unambiguous answer to "which is more right-wing?" is itself evidence against the 1D left-right model.
The Netherlands were governed by "Purple coalitions" including the left-wing PvdA and the right-liberal VVD but excluding the Christian centrist CDA from 1994-2002 and 2012-2017. The 1994-2002 Purple coalition explicitly excluded the CDA becuase the VVD, PvdA and left-liberal D66 wanted them out of office. The coalition passed significant social-left legislation opposed by the CDA including the legalisation of prostitution, gay marriage and euthanasia. (The 2012-7 purple coalition is a less good example because the only reason the CDA and D66 were excluded was that the VVD and PvdA didn't need their votes.)
This one, of course, makes perfect sense under a political compass style model - the PvdA is economic left, social centre, the VVD is economic right, social centre, the D66 is economic centre, social left, and the CDA is economic centre, social right. So PvdA-VVD-D66 is a social centre-left coalition which is all over the place on economics.
If you want to go full horseshoe, there are two important examples of the Communist KPD co-operating with the far right in Weimar Germany - the KPD had been ordered by Moscow to oppose the centre-left SDP as a priority. The 1931 Prussian referendum was an attempt to recall the SPD-led State government in Prussia which was supported by the Stahlhelm (an anti-democratic right-wing veteran's organisation tied to the DNVP), the Nazis and the KPD. There was a transport strike in Berlin in November 1932 where Nazi and KPD goon squads worked together to protect strikers and intimidate scabs.
I also endorse the modern German examples downthread.
Per the most recent census, 59.3% of the population of London were born in the United Kingdom. The vast majority of these people are British, unless you are using "British" in some non-standard way which does not reflect the laws, customs, or practices of the United Kingdom.
British (as opposed to English, Welsh, Scottish or Irish) national identity was always civic and political from when it first became a thing in the 18th century. There is a reason why "I feel more British than English" is associated with left-establishment politics and "I feel more English than British" is associated with right-populist politics - it is the only question that predicted how people voted on Brexit better than age. (See https://ukandeu.ac.uk/brexit-and-english-identity/ for poll results)
Oops - edited.
There is a practical difference if gods are real and that the prayer for self-imposed punishment forming part of an oath is likely to be granted.
In a religious context, an oath is a statement about one's future intentions coupled with a prayer requesting divine punishment on yourself if you don't follow through. In the modern Christian context, the prayer and penalty are abbreviated as "so help me God". (The Oath of Office for the US President prescribed in the Constitution omits this, but this is exceptional and most Christian presidents added "so help me God" voluntarily. This was probably a drafting error because all the other oaths of office prescribed by the 1st Congress did include it). But in classical antiquity, or in dubiously Christian contexts like Masonic oaths, the penalties can get quite specific.
As usual, Brett Devereaux provides more detail.
But critically to this thread, the clerics who wrote the creeds (and, more importantly, the professions of faith and such like which form part of the Confirmation ritual, which is where you would have put an oath if you wanted one, and do in fact look more oath-like) could have made them oaths by adding "I swear" and "so help me God", and chose not to. So they are not oaths.
The creeds are pure statements of current belief, made in solemn form to encourage taking them seriously. There is (at least in mainstream Christianity) no suggestion that someone changes their mind and ceases to believe in the creed calls any special divine wrath on themselves beyond the general damnation of unbelievers.
I think it is more that Frankfurt is the commercial capital of Germany, whereas London and Paris are the commercial capitals as well as the political capitals. Rome is poorer than you expect (about 15% richer than Italy as a whole, but below the northern Italian average) for the same reason - Milan is the commercial capital. Greater DC (the District itself is notoriously dirt poor) being as rich as it is (about 20% above the US average) is the unusual thing by international standards.
Republicans are never willing to punish employers, despite these being the obvious targets for enforcement as they have names/addresses/Tax-ID where punishment can be executed.
I was pleasantly surprised to see mandatory e-Verify in HR2, but of course HR2 is mostly performative trolling designed to embarrass Biden and derail the Senate border deal. I do not know if even the current MAGA Republican party would put mandatory e-Verify into a bill they were expecting to pass.
The goal of asylum law was largely to protect specific individuals who had specific threats against their lives, like dissidents from Authoritarian regimes.
This is incorrect. The 1951 Refugee Convention (which national asylum laws implement) was designed around two paradigm scenarios:
- Regularising the status of people who had fled the fighting in WW2 and couldn't go home because their home country had ceased to exist or the political situation meant they were no longer welcome there. This affected millions of people, but people at the time assumed that it was a one-off.
- "Never again" the scenario where Jews trying to flee Nazi Germany couldn't because no country would take them.
In the Cold War era asylum was mostly used by political dissidents, but the system was originally designed around the needs of large groups of people fleeing war and/or democide. It is true that it specifically wasn't designed for people fleeing the kind of general chaos you see in places like pre-Bukele El Salvador.
In any case, the problem is that the system set up by the 1951 Convention has failed, and the sane anti-immigrant right (i.e. Meloni or Marine le Pen, not Trump or Marion Marechal) needs to (and probably will) start talking about what the replacement for it should look like. From my perspective it would be even better if the liberal centre outflanked them by having this conversation first. This is another item on my "effortpost needed when work calms down" list inspired by the UK election campaign.
I don't think this is something that Marx was wrong about in the simple and obvious way you are suggesting. Marx is vague about what "communism" (as opposed to the intermediate stage of "socialism") was supposed to be like, but most of the circumstantial evidence points towards Marx's uptopia being what the youth of today would call "fully automated luxury space communism" - a world in which the economy was so productive that all material needs were met and there was sufficiently little disagreeable work to do that the kind of gentle social pressure used to get roommates to do the washing up was sufficient to get it done.
Marx absolutely knew that even early C20 Britain or Germany was too poor for communism - part of the point of the socialist stage was to preside over the period of economic growth needed to get to the level of wealth where fully automated luxury steampunk communism was a material possibility. (Marx was wrong in believing that rational planning under socialism would generate faster economic growth than the chaos of market capitalism, but until the Soviet system started to fall apart under Brezhnev almost everyone made the same mistake).
The other thing that would have surprised Marx is just how high material standards of living can get before the average Joe is willing to give up toys in order to have more leisure time to play with them. Keynes famously thought that a society as productive as C21 America would have a 15-hour work week*. I think almost anyone from the 1970s or earlier who looked at modern America and saw people working extra hours in a not-fun job to afford an F250 instead of an F150 would have a WTF response, but this is the choice that modern blue-collar Americans fairly consistently make - including people who have enough control over their work hours that it clearly is a choice like self-employed tradesmen.
* Some of increased leisure Keynes predicted has happened, but in the form of shorter careers as a fraction of life expectancy rather than a shorter work week. Blue-collar workers in Keynes' day started full-time work at 14 and worked until they were no longer physically able to do so. Now they start working full-time at 18 (pace the Florida child labour bill allowing high schoolers to work full-time hours on top of their schooling) and expect to retire in their early 60's and enjoy a decade or so of being healthy enough to work but not required to do so.
Capitalism has been tried many times and even when executed with flaws has been a resounding success. If capitalists were in charge of the corporations instead of the PMC IYI - disney's experiments with putting a chick in and making it gay would have been cut way shorter.
If we are talking about the execrable Star Wars sequel trilogy, capitalism isn't telling Disney to knock it off. All three movies made money hand over fist, and The Farce Awakens set US box office records. Capitalism can create good art, but it usually doesn't. The best art appears to be created by priestly types who actually believe in their religion, like Bach or Michelangelo. Walt Disney himself is something of a weird case that in my view proves the rule - Disney was a for-profit company organised on capitalist principles, but based on his writings Walt saw himself as a priest of the American civic religion (that included capitalism) rather than a pure capitalist who made movies because it was more lucrative than soap, and left "running Disney like a business" to his brother Roy.
In my opinion, the greatest fault of Capitalism, and the real problem that is behind it, is that it is so productive that can share money to unproductive people, creating a new caste of Priestly Propagandist, that exists only because they receive money from society. A parasitical relationships between the producers of wealth, the managers and the oppressed/activist class, who can rearrange the chairs to receive more money, prestige and wealth.
Unproductive priestly castes, including unproductive priestly castes which fail to provide spiritual comfort and moral guidance to the 2nd and 3rd estates while also failing to live up to the tenets of their own religion, predate capitalism. In our own post-Protestant culture, the paradigm example is the Catholic Church immediately before the Reformation.
The expensively-educated 110-130 IQ white women who go into left-wing NGOery are working harder and earning less (when government benefits are included) than they would in the government, or in some suitable support role in the private sector like HR or in-house legal. So at least they have skin in the game in a way the Renaissance party Popes didn't*.
* Except Julius II, who had very literal skin in the game because he personally led the armies of the Papal States into battle.
I was responding to both of you - I wanted to explicitly agree with you that Labour's coalition makes them likely to get housing right.
Salaries in finance (including fintech) are only slightly lower in London compared to New York. For FAANG SWEs the difference is probably a factor of three between London and the Bay area.
NYC also has a PMC status competition thing going on which makes the perceived cost of living for upper-middle-class people high relative to the actual cost of living. "$250k in NYC is barely middle class given the cost of living" gets sympathetic nods. "£150k in London is barely middle class given house prices nowadays" gets you laughed at.
Labour have a public commitment to building more houses, a policy which will allow them to do it (namely removing protection from low-value land in greenbelts) that isn't motherhood and apple pie (the Conservatives are promising to protect greenbelts), a coalition that supports it (as @RegularlyExpressed points out) and a golden opportunity to do something that everyone knows is necessary but is unpopular with swing voters (a likely majority in the stratosphere).
If, like most people who are paying attention, you think that the housing shortage is the most pressing problem facing the UK, then things will get better, albeit slowly.
The other thing that is going to get better regardless of the election result is that the headline net migration number is going to drop (unless Ukraine collapses). Net migration in 2022 and 2023 is inflated by the Hong Kong and Ukraine resettlement schemes and by the post-COVID rebound in the stock of foreign students in the UK (which implies a temporarily high net inflow). An incoming Labour government will, of course, claim credit.
I have modest hopes that a Starmer government will be more competent on crime. Starmer was both competent and (given his other political views) surprisingly based as Director of Public Prosecutions (among other things, he was responsible for the decision to throw the book at the 2011 rioters, and issued guidance to reduce the number of people being prosecuted for offensive tweets). The pozzing of the Crown Prosecution Service happened under his successor Alison Saunders.
If you are a typical Motte-poster (i.e. under 50 and educated), the people you knew who voted Tory at the last election are likely to be highly atypical of the people across the country who voted Tory. The only person I know who falls into that category and is happy to discuss politics is my mother-in-law who is a more stereotypical Leave/Tory voter (non-graduate Boomer, self-identifies as working class despite enjoying an affluent retirement due to Boomer privilege). She is also voting Reform, but for the rather more straightforward reason that the Tories are a bunch of lying incompetent expletive deleteds who need to be thrown out.
The tl;dr version of any discussion of the issues in this election is the shockingly bad record of the current Conservative government that even the columnists at conservativehome.com are struggling to defend. Rishi Sunak's problem isn't that he is losing votes to Reform by being a closet Lib Dem or losing votes to the Lib Dems by being a closet Faragite, it is that he is so bad at governing that he hasn't delivered any agenda at all, and so bad at comms that the electorate can't tell if the agenda he failed to deliver is a Lib Dem one or a Faragite one.
Were Donald Trump Catholic, I suspect he would be more likely to be excommunicated for promising to launch a crusade and not doing so. My understanding of the precedents is that "Congress wouldn't support it" is not an excuse and "You should have taken by calls for war against the infidel seriously but not literally" certainly isn't.
But they did excommunicate the SSPX leadership after the Econe consecrations - schismatic consecrations are still one of the reliable ways of getting excommunicated - or technically given the law around latae sententiae, of excommunicating yourself in a way the Vatican will wish to publicise.
You will notice that most of the historical exommunications I mentioned didn't succeed in crushing anyone - the practice of unrepentant excommunicants thumbing their nose at the Papacy is as old as the practice of excommunicating people.
This is a recent pussification of the Church. The last Head of State to be excommunicated was Tito in 1946 (for ordering the show trial of a Catholic bishop) and the previous one was King Victor Emmanuel II of Italy in 1870 for invading Rome.
The last time "arguably the world's most powerful Catholic" was excommunicated was Napoleon in 1809 (also for invading Italy).
In the Middle Ages royal excommunications were commonplace, but if the criterion of "arguably the world's most powerful Catholic" is used then we have Holy Roman Emperors Otto IV in 1210 (invading Italy again), Frederick II (three times: for promising to go on Crusade and not doing so, for invading Italy, and for obstructing the Pope's attempt to lead Christian Europe's response to the Mongols), and Henry IV and Henry V (multiple times over the Investiture Controversy - in effect for claiming the authority to appoint bishops in the Holy Roman Empire in place of the Pope).
The short answer is that there is no "red tribe" in the UK (except for Northern Irish Unionists, who are mostly irrelevant to UK-wide politics) - the "red tribe" is anchored by the long-standing distinctive culture of the white South, which has no equivalent in the mainland UK. The UK culture war is generational, not tribal - see for example the age split in the Brexit referendum exit poll which is bigger than the racial gap and far bigger than the equivalent generation gap in the US.
This is also on my list of "things I would like to do an effortpost on if I didn't have a demanding job and two SEN kids"
What are his metaphysical/spiritual beliefs?
This is slightly complicated by the Great Awokening, which I understand as the replacement of MTD by Wokism as the dominant religious principle of the Blue Tribe, but Wokism doesn't have the metaphysical aspect that some people think is necessary for it to be an actual religion.
Another interesting point is that hard core blue tribers think that all major world religions, correctly understood, are skins on MTD, so anyone who believes in a religion other than MTD is doing their own religion wrong.
I don't disagree with you - I was just pointing out that we have to careful about who "we" is in this context.
Critically, the chip race isn't between China and the US. It is between China and the US-Netherlands (ASML)-Germany (Zeiss)-UK (ARM)-Taiwan coalition.
If the West allows China to defeat us in detail, China will probably succeed. But that would be a very stupid thing to do.

The sleazy behaviour of the President's son and brother been a top-3 Republican talking point for some years now. The possibility of John Podesta's brother being a paedophile was also a major right-wing talking point. There is as much evidence that Joe Biden delivered any of the bribe-service implicitly promised by Hunter and James' schemes as there is that Clarence Thomas participated in his wife's insurrectionary plotting or that Samuel Alito participated in the petty harassment of a left-wing neighbour - i.e. none whatsoever in the legal sense, and not much in the Bayesian sense beyond the normal assumption that families stick together.
Anything that is Bayesian evidence that a prominent government official is disloyal is legitimately newsworthy. And a close family member engaging in obviously disloyal behaviour is weak Bayesian evidence that the principle is disloyal because families do, in fact, stick together and more powerful family members do, in fact, have a degree of control over less powerful family members' behaviour. This isn't a legal point, but the court of public opinion isn't subject to legal rules of evidence. Nor is employer discipline - I work for a bank, and if my wife were to get caught trading stocks on my employer's watchlist I would lose my job. If I told my wife "Please don't trade this stock - you could get me fired." and she did it anyway, I would be in a shockingly dysfunctional marriage. So my employer's compliance department assumes that she is doing it with at least my tacit approval.
The Alito incident should be less newsworthy because flying a controversial flag to troll a neighbour (and we now have tapes which, if genuine, prove that this is what is going on) is not disloyal behaviour. I am not obliged to believe a conservative Christian who insists that he has no control over his wife's behaviour. I can (and do) conclude that Alito doesn't take the kind of behaviour his wife is engaging in seriously enough to ask her to knock it off. But that just means he is a cockwomble - it doesn't mean that he is disloyal or corrupt. Given that six/seven of the nine Supreme Court justices (I am excluding Thomas, Roberts and possibly Gorsuch here) are partisan hacks appointed to rule the way their party wants, arguing about whether they are cockwombles or not is unproductive. But critically, the fact that Martha Ann Alito was trolling a neighbour rather than expressing support for an insurrection wasn't known at the time.
More options
Context Copy link