@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

2S is two-spirit. It is one of those words like BAME and BIPOC that wokists use to lump together disparate groups based on an imagined political alliance, much to the irritation of the people affected. In this case it lumps together all gender roles recognised in a Native American tribal religion that are vaguely related to the white-people concept of transgenderism.

The white South didn't accept their defeat and try to live an honourable peace. They launched an insurgency (the 1st Klan), and when that failed they waited out the presence of federal troops in the South and then staged a series of coups against the Reconstruction-era State governments (elected by multi-racial electorates) in order to introduce Jim Crow. The North, to their shame, tolerated this due to exhaustion during the Gilded Age, and enthusiastically embraced it due to political corruption in the New Deal era.

Jim Crow was a dishonourable peace, and the Civil Rights movement was right to seek to overturn it.

Lee was regarded as a true Southern gentleman

And Rommel was regarded as a true German gentleman. But if a statue of Rommel stood in a place of honour in central Stuttgart as part of the pantheon of military heroes of Baden-Wurttemberg, and it was melted down at the request of the local synagogue, we wouldn't be complaining about "teabagging the outgroup". In fact, part of the "Reconstruction" process in post-WW2 Germany was the removal of Nazi monuments.

You don't have to, but "all men are created equal and endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights" is a core part of the American civic religion, as is the absence of a hereditary nobility. So not accepting the premise is un-American. Indeed, it is so un-American that it led otherwise honourable gentlemen like Robert E Lee into committing treason against America.

We can argue about the wisdom of forming a more-or-less official Committee on Un-American Activities to punish people who engage in legal but un-American political activity with public humiliation, disemployment etc. (I for one think it is a very, very, bad idea). But the idea definitely isn't new.

Indeed, it's a humiliation ritual. Again, I cannot even name one statue of Stalin or Lenin that suffered the same fate.

Neither Stalin nor Lenin betrayed their country. This kind of ritual humiliation was SOP for traitors, which Lee was - or at least an unsuccessful rebel, which counts as a traitor under the traditional rules. You can argue that Lenin was a traitor to the Kerensky government, but he was a successful rebel so it doesn't count.

In the same vein - Given that Confederates were enacting the inherent right of an armed people to seek justice against an oppressive government, we could add the symbol of people's justice (i.e. a noose) to the statues? Given that Confederates were resisting Northern tyranny in the name of God-ordained right, could we perhaps add a symbol of divine justice as well, in the form of brimstone candles around the base of the statue?

I get where you are coming from, but the difference between 2000 years and 150 years is significant. I doubt that more than a tiny handful of black people 2000 years from now will care at all about statues of Confederate figures, if there are even still any around by then. Not that I think most black people even today care much about them, but I think 2000 years vs 150 years is part of the difference between "only a tiny handful care" and "maybe 5% or 10% of the population care".

It isn't even 150 years. The Southern resistance to the Civil Rights movement made heavy use of Confederate imagery, including the Battle Flag, and a second round of monument-building. You can argue when that resistance ceased to matter (the last unrepentant segregationist in Congress was Trent Lott who retired in 2007), but certainly within living memory. In so far as white supremacist dead-enders are a thing, they of course still use the Battle Flag for the same purpose.

If Italian anti-Semites started conducting pogroms while waving Arch of Titus flags and Mossad responded by blowing the arch up, I think a lot of pro-Israel motteposters would be sympathetic.

No. I am applying the morals of his own time. Lee knew that slavery was evil, and fought to defend it anyway out of a misguided sense of patriotism. Given the many positive aspects of his character, I hope he gets to spend eternity slightly further away from the Fire than, say, Jeffrey Epstein.

From the point of view of the part of the modern left that generally favours secessionist movements, a big part of the answer is that they favour secessionist movements that appear to enjoy supermajority support among the inhabitants the seceding territory, or actually do enjoy a bare majority confirmed in a referendum. The progressive position on Scottish, Catalan, or Quebecois succession is that it is an appropriate matter for a referendum in Scotland/Catalunya/Quebec. In general, the view of progressives outside those places is that a "yes" vote is not per se a progressive cause, although holding a referendum that the British/Spanish/Canadian government doesn't want is one. In the case of secession of the West Bank and Gaza from being de facto part of Israel (i.e. a two-State solution), no such referendum is necessary because the result would be obvious.

"From the river to the sea" is a claim that the Israeli Jews are settler colonialists and not part of the "legitimate" population of the territory and that therefore a referendum that included them would be illegitimate - pre-GFA Sinn Fein took the same view about the Protestants in Northern Ireland, and supporters of Ukraine have made the argument about Russians who moved to Crimea post-invasion. This viewpoint used to be fashionable when the left was more sympathetic to ethno-nationalism, but in the current year nobody claims to support a United Ireland without a referendum, and the people chanting "from the river to the sea" are either confused about what this means or rabid anti-Semites.

Under this framework, the Confederate secession was illegitimate because the democratic consent of the inhabitants of the seceding territory was never secured. 40% of the Confederate population (including majorities in LA/MS/SC) were slaves or disenfranchised free blacks. And white support for secession was never close-enough to unanimous to argue that a 40% minority didn't need to be consulted.

Note that the democratic theory of secession is mostly relevant to cases where there are not large numbers of human beings being mistreated. The strongest argument for the existence of a Palestinian state is of the same type as the argument for the existence of Israel - that there are several million people whose fundamental rights will not be respected if they are ruled by people who hate them. The strongest argument against Confederate secession is the same as well - that the practical impact of the secession would be to violate the rights of human beings by enslaving them.

Jamaican x Irish is common in my neighbourhood of south-east London - 3 kids in my older son's primary school class. It also provides evidence that you can indeed have a black redhead - at least on the American definition where any mixed-race person with visible black in the mix counts as "Black".

So probably not a unicorn. If Ginnie Thomas has Irish ancestry (likely as she is PMC and Catholic, and Thomas isn't an Italian name) then Clarence and Ginnie Thomas are probably the most famous example of African-American x Irish.

genocide

The word is so overused (mostly, it must be said, by the left) that I now treat it as a fnord. I realise I managed to read the OP without noticing it, and had to go back to check that it was there after reading your post.

FWIW, my own opinion is that melting down the statue is a good start, but I would prefer if it was publically blown up on the 4th July with red, white and blue pyrotechnics while a military band played Battle Hymn of the Republic. But I'm not American, so it doesn't matter.

Even if people did trust the system, I don't think it would work. The Thatcher-era UK had a health service that enjoyed near-universal public confidence, police who enjoyed universal confidence among the subset of the public who were likely to be legal gun owners, and a gun culture that supported strong gun control. Even so, we couldn't keep guns out of the hands of mentally ill people who weren't supposed to have them. After two spree killings in 10 years (both using handguns, which was the norm for spree killers pre-Columbine), both by people who had gun licenses but should not have done, we banned private handgun ownership and banned private ownership of firearms other than shotguns designed for sporting or agricultural use.

I do not think you can have a system where any given type of gun is generally available to law-abiding citizens but does not end up in the hands of crazies.

People seeking sexual reassignment surgery goes back to the 1950's. Probably the first normie-famous case was Renee Richards who transitioned in the 1970's and played women's tennis as a transwoman. I'm not sure about the legal history in the US, but in the UK the classical legal case was Corbett vs Corbett in 1970 which held that a marriage between a man and an MtF transsexual was invalid on the grounds that she was legally male. So trans people existed at the time KSR was writing, and someone who was familiar with the weirder fringes of progressive politics (as I think KSR was) would have known about them. But even among people who were all-in on the 1990's PC wave, they were not an important left-wing cause. In UK student unions, the "T" got added to "LGBT" around 2000.

This thread has been hugely educational about how non-idiots see race relations in America. Thank you to KMC and rallycar-jepsen for having an incredibly polite conversation about an incredibly fraught topic, and to everyone on the Motte for creating a community where they feel safe to have it.

I agree, but wokestupid insanity is fractal.

The background to the Fram ban was that the WMF were proposing to change their ToS to incorporate the usual vaguely worded Code of Conduct that people expect to be selectively enforced against conservatives but is actually selectively enforced against spergy men who are more focussed on improving the product than playing politics. And as part of the ToS to use the server, this would be enforced by the WMF and not the community. There were the usual complaints by the WMF that the sex ratio in the community (which is male-dominated for the obvious reasons) must be due to Deplorable behaviour chasing women away.

Most of the evidence in the case is not public, but it looks like a woman who was friends with the WMF CEO was adding articles on Spanish Paralympians that were sufficiently badly translated that the community thought they were making the encyclopedia worse. Fram tried to make her stop, and she tattled on him.

What is public is that when the MSM picked up the story, the WMF leadership briefed that Fram was banned for being mean to female contributors and that the row was about the WMF trying to crack down on endemic sexism in the editor community.

There are a lot of proud Commies who really are sexist (the sex scandals in the UK Socialist Workers' Party were hilarious), and even more who are victims of bad-faith allegations of sexism by the establishment left. The "Berniebro" meme is the canonical example.

The Clinton-Gingrich welfare reform is the canonical example. I agree that is going to slip out of "last 30 years" soon.

The dealmaking around the 2013 sequestration got the Republicans 5 years of below-inflation discretionary spending growth and most of the Bush tax cuts made permanent - that was a better deal for Republicans than either constant law (and full expiration of the Bush tax cuts),constant policy (red ink as far as the eye can see), or implementation of the sequester as originally agreed (which would have cut defence more and other discretionary spending less).

I don't even know if MAGA conservatives want to cut Social Security and Medicare, so I don't think their failure to do so reflects bad dealmaking.

Jeff Bezos was at DE Shaw before he founded Amazon, and was successful there. DE Shaw are like Jane Street in that they recruit primarily for raw IQ and can afford to be extremely selective on it. 146 IQ (top 0.1%) doesn't cut it. 155 IQ (top 0.01%) probably does. Top 0.01% is also around the level where other smart people start using the word "genius" to describe you.

175 IQ is 1 in 3 million, and even the people who care about ultra-high IQs think that the distinction between very smart and very, very smart ceases to matter around the 1 in 1 million point. Re. the various comments on high SAT scores, the Prometheus Society considers 1560 on the old SAT to be 1 in 30,000 which corresponds to a 160 IQ on the current standard scale. There are no longer any publically available IQ tests which are accurate at that level.

SBF was above-average IQ for Jane Street, which also qualifies him as a legit genius.

If we treat "implausible polymathic success in a wide range of IQ-loaded fields" as a sign of genius-level IQ, then Benjamin Franklin and Napoleon are probably the smartest world leaders in history.

For me personally, "Paedo guy" and "Funding secured" were enough to push me from "Hooray for the eccentric genius" to "This guy may be smart, but he is not a fit and proper person to be CEO of a strategically important company". That applies for different reasons whether he was on drugs at the time or not.

At the time, this combined with the obviously dishonest SolarCity deal and the rapid turnover of Tesla CFO's to make me suspect that Tesla was the next Enron. I'm happy to admit that I was wrong there.

It doesn't help that Musk has actually got stupider as he got more famous. Everyone who worked with him at early-stage Tesla or SpaceX said he was scary because he understood the technical aspects of your job better than you did. But since he was normie-famous he has mostly been signal-boosting right-coded midwit conventional wisdom.

You can tell this by looking at what experts in his fields think of him. The car and rocket people all had the initial reaction of "This is a longshot, but it could work, and I want it to work." People who know anything about civil engineering's reaction to Hyperloop and The Boring Company was "Musk doesn't even understand why the last N people who tried this failed, so he is going to repeat those mistakes." And people who know about AI tend to think that Tesla is well behind Waymo and Cruze in autonomous driving.

My guess is that the underlying cause is some combination of drug abuse, long-term effects of lack of sleep, and no longer feeling the need to do his homework before running his mouth.

Most people using wikipedia are not looking for high-profile political topics. As Encyclopedia Dramatica famously put it when launching a vandalism campaign, you can't have a free-to-edit encyclopedia without editors who are willing to periodically check in on the article on fourth-order Runge-Kutta numerical integration to make sure it hasn't succumbed to vandalism, linkrot, or onward progress in computer languages used to implement the algorithm. What ED learned was that Wikipedia does, in fact, have editors willing to do that.

Vox Day thought that gamergaters and puppies would give him the basis of editors he needed to do this on Infogalactic. It didn't. It didn't help that he was dividing his time between too many projects at the time.

Wikipedia depends on the editor community to keep the encyclopedia current (and the Pareto distribution of editor activity means that the part of the community that matters is quite small) - the community increasingly see the WMF as a parasite using their encyclopedia to raise donations under false pretenses. The Wikimedia software and the text of the encyclopedia are open source - the only thing that the WMF actually controls is the IP and domain names (which would use value fast if they pointed to an "encyclopedia" that was full of rubbish).

The Fram ban incident was the point at which the community and the WMF became actively hostile - and the community won by getting Fram's ban overturned and an in-principle agreement from the WMF that wikis with active communities would remain primarily responsible for policing their own users. But the community now know that the self-perpetuating woke oligarchy that control the WMF think of them as unwashed white male neanderthals who are only one step removed from gamergaters, or something like that. My read was that both the WMF and the community realised that either side could destroy the social value of the encyclopedia, and neither wanted to do so.

When Jimbo (who had much more goodwill in the editor community than the current WMF leadership) launched the for-profit Wikia in 2004, the threat of an editor revolt meant that he had to keep it entirely separate from Wikipedia. If the WMF tried the same thing, there would be an editor strike.

Very possibly - I wasn't around.

It looks like that big area of SA is about 8000 people if you add back the two enclaves which are small towns with independent municipalities. Still scary. The most remote place I have been is a tossup between the drive to the Grand Canyon North Rim and the drive through the Scottish Highlands from Fort William to Skye Bridge. In both cases you go about 30 miles between settlements, and the settlements have populations in the low three figures.

Are the jobs that the missing people used to do (presumably, mostly running sheep stations) being automated away so that the agricultural productivity of the Outback is holding up, or are they just not being done any more?

The underlying phenomenon driving the More than my Hometown/23 vibe (that rural-to-urban migration is now a mostly-female phenomenon except where strong patriarchy prevents this, and that one of the drivers is that women do not want to end up as farmers' wives) is global - Fred Pearce's Peoplequake is where I read about it, but is now probably out of date. But that ground truth hasn't changed over the timescale you are looking at with the change in the vibes of Country lyrics, so the vibe shift you are looking at is probably driven by something else. Someone more familiar than I am with fine-grained US economic data could probably confirm if it is the same rise in economic anxiety in rural and small-town America that drove the rise of Trump - the dates superficially match up.

  • Ladies Love Country Boys strongly implies that the male lead got off the farm and met the Yankee chick while they were both undergraduates at one of the SEC party schools.
  • In Save a Horse, Ride a Cowboy the male lead is mostly attractive because he is rich, with the source of funds never specified.
  • Cowboy and the Lady is about a "cowboy" so far from the ranch that he is wearing a rhinestone-studded suit and cowboy boots in an airport business class lounge (and is also wearing a hat indoors, which would be a faux pas for an actual cowboy-with-a-hint-of-class).
  • If I were a Carpenter shouldn't really be on the list - the Carpenter is asking the question to the Lady with no particular expectation of getting the answer "Yes".

That leaves Thinks my Tractor's Sexy and Pickup Man as songs that portray rural lower-middle class men as sexy. And Thinks my Tractor's Sexy is very definitely about a country boy attracting the attention of a country girl - it isn't claiming that a "lady" would find the tractor sexy.

So the Country-is-sexy vibe was about the aesthetic of Country being the sexy icing on a cake which consists of money and status. All the Pretty Girls is getting at something similar, but without the cake - the pretty girls find the country boys superficially attractive and want to have some illicit sex with them before heading off to pursue lives elsewhere, and the country boys know that illicit sex is the only kind on offer so they sneak past the cops to get it. And of course this is in the general context of a genre which disdains outlawry and has lots of songs about people and their families ruined by breaking the law and ignoring basic sexual morality - so by the rules of Country music this is an account of systemic failure, not a "we cucked the white-shoe boys" brag.

FWIW (my exposure to Country is limited to what I hear at the house of a relative whose gateway drug was Dolly Parton), I think Hlynka is right and it was the swagger that was aberrational, not the maudlin.

Young men, of course, you can tell them to think seriously of joining the military or learning a trade

I am about as far from the target audience of the messaging as possible, but my impression is that (apart from the specific appeal to the Violent Class discussed by JTarrou, which only the USMC really features in its messaging) the "join the military" message is a combination of:

  • Enlist in the military as a career with prospects, and chase NCO promotions which (although they don't tell you this) will de facto require you to pick up a degree via distance learning to get the promotion points you need.
  • Enlist in the military in order to get GI Bill money to pursue a degree after you get out.

So I don't think the military (apart from USMC grunt) is sold as an alternative pathway to getting a degree, more as a better route to a degree for less-bookish more-masculine men compared to going to a 4-year college straight out of HS.