MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
The last I heard was that the Democrats were willing to amend the rules to make Patrick McHenry (the interim speaker nominated by McCarthy) de facto speaker, at least for long enough to deal with the backlog of must-pass legislation with bipartisan support. That isn't an offer to vote to make him regular speaker, but I would say he is now the Schelling point for a bipartisan speaker if that is what the Dems and RINOs decide they want.
The visa-selling scandal is particularly bad because PiS is facing two other right-wing blocs - Civic Coalition (Tusk's lot) are right-liberals and Third Way are a bit of a grab-bag but the largest party in the bloc are old-school agrarian populists. A right-wing party facing no serious right-wing opposition that fails to deliver on a right-wing agenda due to incompetence or corruption can survive for a very long time because their voters don't have anywhere to go. (Whether this applies to the GOP is left as an exercise for the reader).
Given how well Third Way did, I think a lot of social conservative voters switched from PiS to the Third Way parties in disgust at the visa-selling. They are still voting for a party in the populist quadrant of the political compass, but this time one that doesn't sell visas.
Precisely - the whole point of a party caucus is that everyone is expected to vote in line with the majority of the caucus, at least on important procedural votes like Speaker elections. You accept a degree of party discipline in order to get the benefits of being the majority. The details are different in Parliamentary systems, but the principle that anyone who votes against their party on a confidence motion (or who fails to show up for the vote without a good excuse) is kicked out of the caucus ("has the whip withdrawn") is utterly mundane. The last time this happened in the UK was to pro-European rebels against Johnson, and the time before that was to Eurosceptic rebels in the Major era. In both cases rebels were kicked out even though it left the government without a majority.
Right now there is no majority caucus in the House, because the Republicans lack the party discipline to be a real caucus, and neither the mainstream nor the MAGA factions are anywhere close to 218. The reason why this has become a clown show is that the Republicans are still acting like they are in the majority, even though they are not.
There is a very important general point here, which is that if asset markets are telling you to adopt a particular investment strategy, and you do not have a good personal reason not to, then you should do what the markets are telling you.
Low interest rates (strictly speaking, low real interest rates) are asset markets telling you to invest in real assets (equity of non-financial companies, real estate, your own business) and avoid financial assets (bonds, cash, arguably bank equity, at the margin even paying down debt). The market is telling you to invest in real assets because not enough other people are, so if you follow the market's advice both you and society should benefit.
Debating this elsewhere, some reactions were "Oh, but the Arabs wouldn't accept the partition plan", but why should they, why does the UN have the right to just impose that on them?
The UN didn't. The British did, both as the internationally recognised rulers of Mandate Palestine, and by virtue of having (if we could be bothered, which in the post-WW2 environment we couldn't) sufficient men, ships and guns to determine the outcome. The legal status of the 1947 partition plan was that it was non-binding advice (it was a General Assembly resolution, and only the Security Council can issue binding resolutions and only under specific circumstances) to the British. When Israel's Arab neighbours (most of which were nominally British allies) rejected the plan, the British government declined to enforce it and we basically bugged out and let the Jews and Arabs fight.
Are Israelis kvetching at Germans any more? My impression was that in the current year most of the people kvetching to Germans about the Holocaust are Jewish-American lawyers looking for a payoff.
By stereotype when I was growing up in London in the 1990's, the Irish were more likely to be anti-Semitic than the British. Overt anti-Semitism was sufficiently rare that I couldn't gauge the truth of the stereotype. On the far left there was an element of IRA-PLO solidarity, but most Irish people in both the mainland UK and Republic of Ireland despised the IRA by this point, so that can't have been the main thing. Some of it went back to the 19th century, when Disraeli opposed devolution to Ireland and Irish Catholic politicians responded by wheeling out all the usual anti-Semitic tropes. (Even in the 1860's, Disraeli's Jewish ancestry was not an issue in mainstream British politics). The piece de resistance was a speech by Daniel O'Connell comparing Disraeli to the unrepentant robber crucified alongside Jesus and speculating about their family resemblance.
This is statistics 101. In a world where there are a lot more Irish-Americans than there are anti-Semitic Americans, a sufficiently strong positive correlation between the two pretty much guarantees that both of the following apply:
- Most anti-Semites are Irish
- Most Irish are not anti-Semites.
I don't think so. Keith's perspective is missing and most of the anti-Zionism in the West is typically very leftist.
Anti-Zionism is (in the US, at least), profoundly anti-establishment. The anti-establishment right didn't have a megaphone until Trump walked down the escalator in 2016, and this is the first time since then that Israel-Palestine has been the current thing. But "why can Israel oppose immigration but the US can't" and "why can Israel play to win with the Palestinians when the US has its hands tied in Iraq" where both fairly common memes on the anti-establishment right back in the noughties. (Practically every commentator on the Unz review plus Moldbug)
Unlike the anti-establishment left, the anti-establishment right isn't consistently anti-Zionist, because it includes rabid Islamophobes who support Israel on enemy-of-my-enemy grounds, and wackjob Christians who support Israel in order to immanentize the escheaton. But the natural position of the anti-establishment right is that Israel is just another country and the US should not spend money defending them for the same reasons as Ukraine.
"Several decades" would mean that $cientology, Hare Krishnas, and arguably Moonies have made the transition from "cult" to "religion" by now. Certainly in the UK, the anti-cult crowd think that Scientology and Moonies are the most dangerous religious cults.
From the point of view of the western left and centre-left, Israel is also just a really right-wing country in a way which makes it less sympathetic. The only reason why the current (until the formation of the national unity war government) "National Camp" coalition between the right, the far right and the religious right doesn't have a permanent majority is that Naftali Bennett is outraged by Bibi's corruption - if Likud dumped him for a non-crooked leader then there would be a solid 55% of the vote for aligned right-wing parties. And the principal opposition comes from the liberal centre-right (Yesh Atid) and a bunch of retired generals (what is left of Blue & White).
I am definitely seeing pro-Ukrainian forces trying to spin up a Russia/Iran/NK/Hamas axis of evil meme. This has the advantage relative to the Bush-era axis of evil that the countries in the alleged axis are actually allies, whereas the Bush-era axis of evil, while evil, was about as far from being an axis as it is possible to be.
That was coming from the pro-establishment left much more than the right.
The Madrid bombings were an order of magnitude less destructive than the Hamas raid on Israel, in a country an order of magnitude larger. They also didn't involve sexual humiliation of Spanish women.
It probably doesn't matter, but any attempt to unite the country was blown by the Aznar government telling the ridiculously obvious lie that the bombings had been carried out by ETA.
Also of note, mild dissidence isn't resulting in massive condemnation, it's approval of Hamas that's getting that retort.
Some of the Squad have tried both-sidesism, and the Biden administration called them disgraceful and repugnant.
I think the US domestic politics of this is going to be totally blown up now Trump has called Hezbollah "smart". I assume it was a gaffe, but Trump being Trump he isn't going to walk it back. Absent the Trump gaffe, it would have been an obvious good partisan move for the right to keep pointing at suitable targets at the left and complaining they hadn't denounced Hamas loudly enough (whether or not it was true).
If the union in question is SEIU, then "calculated dick move" is a racing certainty. If any other union, I would take the over on "maggot extremists on the paid staff acting without meaningful membership supervision".
I'm not seeing a real vibe shift here. The pro-establishment left in the US has always been pro-Israel (anti-Israel views are the only left-wing views people were ever cancelled for in establishment institutions, with Steven Salaita the most famous example) and the anti-establishment left has always been anti-Israel, and often rabidly so. The pro-establishment left have always despised the anti-establishment left with the same level of vitriol and for the same reasons that the pro-establishment right despise the MAGA right, and anti-anti-Semitism is used to enforce the left edge of the Overton window in the same way that anti-racism is used to enforce the right edge. It's just that they kept quiet about it for a while after the George Floyd asphyxiation because they were afraid of being called racist.
"The left are cheering Hamas" on your social media dashboard because the people you follow are signal-boosting a small number of idiots, some of whom are tenured academics or leaders of usual-suspects lefty student groups, but most of whom are randos. This is the usual suspects coming out in force - anyone on the pro-establishment left who are surprised by this is an idiot, and I suspect most of the pro-establishment lefties claiming to be surprised are faking it.
The number of Democratic office-holders, university administrators at Dean/Deputy Provost level or above, NYT journalists, or woke corporate executives who are saying these things is negligible. I'm sure that Jewish-American elites don't like the fact that the Squad have called for de-escalation and said that the US should not fund Israeli war crimes in Gaza, but this is the kind of milquetoast stuff that anti-establishment figures who are testing the edges of the Overton window say, not "The left are cheering Hamas". Rashida Tlaib has gone further than the rest because she is Palestinian - again the fact that she is rabidly anti-Israel should surprise zero people who are paying attention.
Another interesting side of the discourse is what will happen in Europe
In Western Europe, normies ran out of sympathy for both sides of the Arab-Israeli conflict decades ago. Everyone except the usual suspects on the anti-establishment left is lining up to condemn the latest round of Hamas atrocities because they are unusually barbaric, but in a month's time we are going to be back to "Hundreds dead in Middle East. Bear shat in woods. Football scores to follow." I can't tell Arabs from Europeans in the dark, but the pro-Hamas protest outside the Israeli embassy in London looked like it was majority south Asian Muslim.
Somalia is surely a better example?
As well as significantly higher taxes than Somalia, Singapore has compulsory retirement savings managed by a State-owned asset manager, a majority of the citizen population living in public housing, extensive prohibition of industries deemed to have negative externalities (as well as the usual suspects like narcotics and unlicensed housebuilding, this includes unlicensed newspapers and chewing gum), restrictions on private car ownership that The_Nybbler would consider totalitarian oppression, military conscription, and State ownership (through Temasek) of strategic stakes in Singapore's largest companies.
To be fair, I don't think the original Star Wars or Star Trek are rightist. More the later fits more with the left.
Trek was always openly and notoriously leftist. Original Trilogy Star Wars was non-leftist in a way which makes it an "old book" for the purposes we are talking about here. The snarky way of explaining this is at the level of aesthetics - the Empire was (according to Lucas, explicitly) modelled on the Soviet Union and the scene in A New Hope that is notoriously plagiarised from Triumph of the Will was the final scene where Leia gives Luke a medal while LARPing as the lawful government of the Galactic Republic. The First Order is modelled on Nazi Germany and all the scenes in The Farce Awakens which are redolent of Triumph of the Will are all First Order rallies. Meanwhile the goodies call themselves "The Resistance" and LARP as a real resistance even though they appear to be irregular forces of an actually-extant, non-LARP restored Galactic Republic. The serious way requires a level of expertise in media criticism that I don't possess. The best statement of the argument original trilogy (and prequel) Star Wars is right wing is the one made by David Brin, who thinks this is a bad thing.
I note that this can be done, because the Mormons have done it. When I was in SLC I attended a taping of Music and the Spoken Word with the Tabernacle Choir, and the modern Mormon sacred music made me think “This is what the culture that produced Bach and Haydn would be putting out if it had drifted since 1900 instead of actively self-destructing.” The Mormon Conference Center is very visibly built with the same desire to glorify God as the great European cathedrals, and is the only modern building I have seen built by people who hoped it would still be standing in 1000 years.
You don’t. Every society has had a leisure class of gentry.
Obviously we can’t have 40% of the population be in it.
Part of the problem is that economic policy in the West is based on the idea that 20+% of the population should be leisure-class gentry - namely middle-class retirees. The core premise of Boomercon thought is that an amount of wealth that could be accumulated relatively painlessly over 40 years of median-income work (30 for blue-collar union workers in legacy manufacturing or the public sector) should endow 20 years of comfortable, active retirement (including the massive healthcare expenditure needed to support it) through some combination of asset ownership, earned workplace benefits, and earned government benefits. The extreme and malignant form of Boomerconnery (and the dominant one in the UK) is that it should do this without touching the capital value of the family home you continue to occupy as empty nesters. In Continental Europe this is seen as an entitlement that should be guaranteed by the State, in the Anglosphere it is only seen as a default expectation that should be facilitated by the State. But in either case it is a huge constituency of people who are objectively rentiers and do, in fact, vote like rentiers.
The underlying confusion is conflating "class" as in inherited SES with "class" as in ones relationship to the means of production. In 1900 this didn't matter much - almost all rentiers and most entrepreneurs had higher inherited SES than almost all wage-workers. But in the modern day almost everyone is a wage-worker in their youth (it isn't socially acceptable for upper-middle class families to subsidise failsons to live a playboy lifestyle - notice that a huge part of Joe Biden's legal-but-sleazy scheming is trying to create opportunities for James and Hunter Biden to pretend they are earning the money) and everyone hopes to be a rentier in retirement, but in a way which means they can say that their ability to eat while others work is a right and not a privilege. So the generational divide in British (and, to a lesser extent, American) politics is exactly what orthodox Marxism would predict - wage-workers vote left, asset owners vote right.
This is an important point. There are two (possibly three) very different views of the owning class lifestyle. FatFIRE is selling the idea that you can live like a retired Boomer starting in your late twenties - plentiful toys, no responsibilities, and no constraints. But people who do that end up living a life of permanent luxury travel in low cost of living countries for a reason - it isn't socially acceptable to live with no responsibilities unless you are an actual retired Boomer or an attractive woman ("socialite" or "trophy wife"), so if you actually end up settling down somewhere you find yourself universally hated. It is also a lifestyle which lends itself to family court litigation, which is the fastest destroyer of dynastic wealth short of wars and revolutions.
The other view is that rather than allowing you to remove yourself from community, being independently wealthy either raises your status in your own community (the "gentry" model) or allows you to join a higher-status community of people who are as rich as you (the "aristocracy" model).
I know that. But what he wrote was "We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal" People who teach American civics using the texts of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution (which is the natural and obvious way to do it) don't need to push anything for schoolchildren to think that it might be a self-evident truth that all men are created equal.

I don't see why this is any more perverse than any other example of "you can be unjustly fucked if a court makes an erroneous factual ruling against you"
"Is this apparently unreadable hard drive encrypted under a key controlled by the defendant?" is the same type of question as "Did she say yes?" - it is in principle a question of fact, not opinion, with a single correct answer, but the practicalities of determining it are that the jury will be making a subjective determination based on multiple pieces of circumstantial evidence. Courts decide these types of questions all the time, and need to. And an innocent person can be totally fucked if the court gets it wrong.
A world in which nobody could be criminally convicted based on circumstantial evidence is a world in which a lot of crimes are effectively decriminalised.
More options
Context Copy link