@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

...And I find that description absolutely absurd when it is applied to our modern world. Maybe it was true in Doyle's time and place. It certainly is not true now.

It is true now in first-world Asian cities. It is sufficiently true sufficiently much of the time in most European cities that the average European urbanite would find the discussion above bizarre.

America (apart from NYC) is bad at policing, in the sense that they can't convert dollars spent on policing into crime reduction efficiently. One upshot of this is that Americans keep trying to move to places that don't need policing. Others are that America is unusually tolerant of vigilantism, and that America tends to substitute harsh punishments for effective policing in the same way and for the same reasons that medieval societies did. Americans are sufficiently used to this that they don't seem to find it a problem - probably because they think it is a universal fact about what is possible - and assume that there must be some reason why Singapore doesn't need policing. Singapore does need policing, and is effectively policed. London and Paris also need policing, are less effectively policed, and while safe by American standards have levels of crime that Singaporeans would find intolerable.

Given the absence of any political faction that wants policing to be expensive and useless, I suspect the reasons for this (which are not well understood) are structural rather than being a policy choice. This excellent substack by a retired cop blames the Bill of Rights.

I do not think that the Deep State would have succeeded in removing Nixon if he had run his re-election campaign honestly, rather than hiring the former Plumbers to ratfuck McGovern. It is entirely possible that the Deep State would have failed to remove Nixon if he had used fewer bad words while on tape plotting the Watergate cover-up.

Apart from Spiro Agnew's conviction for tax evasion, essentially all the big Nixon-era political scandals relate to the activities of Liddy and Hunt. He didn't need them, and would have done better without them. A lot of the smaller scandals relate to the over-enthusiasm of John Dean in pursuing petty feuds. Given that Dean eventually ratted Nixon out over Watergate, he would have done much, much, better without Dean.

put your cards on the table

“Russia, if you’re listening, I hope you’re able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing, I think you will probably be rewarded mightily by our press,”

Said by Trump at a live press Conference on 27th July, 2016. 5 days previously, Wikileaks had published the results of the GRU hack of the DNC and DNCC servers. Based on the publicly-available information at the time, a Russian hack was the most likely explanation of how Wikileaks got the info (as it in fact turned out to be the case). Wikileaks had passed advance information on their plans to publish the data to the Trump campaign via Roger Stone, who was aware that the source was probably a Russian hack. So this wasn't an innocent joke. Nor did the GRU treat it as one - that night they launched another cyber-attack on Hilary Clinton's personal e-mail accounts.

That is collusion. Russia helped Trump, Trump asked for additional help, and Russia attempted to provide it. The collusion continues into October, but the evidence gets murkier. It is reasonably clear (but not proved to a criminal standard) that Roger Stone continued to act as a go-between between the Trump campaign, Wikileaks, and GRU-controlled internet persona Guccifer2.0. Does Trump condemn Roger Stone after he publically congratulates a GRU agent for hacking and leaking additional DNC e-mails? Of course not, because Stone was working for Trump.

[Source for all facts above is the bipartisan Senate report ]

It is also the case that Trump's campaign manager at the time (Manafort) was working without pay, and his primary source of income was a consultancy arrangement with pro-Putin oligarch Oleg Deripaska. Was Deripaska making an under-the-table donation to the Trump campaign? I don't know, but it's definitely a card I am happy to put on the table.

Was there an explicit quid pro quo - probably not. Trump had visited Russian on several occasions, both to seek Russian investors in his US projects and to discuss possible Trump-branded developments in Moscow. He had met various Russian elites who could have passed information on to Putin. I think Putin liked and respected Trump and thought (correctly) that they be able to work together as world leaders. In addition, Trump was the more NATO-sceptical of the two candidates, so there is a direct and obvious benefit to Russian foreign policy from a Trump victory.

So in my model we have Putin deciding that he benefits from a Trump victory, Putin helping Trump, Trump enthusiastically accepting the help, and Putin and Trump working together via plausibly deniable proxies to maximise the impact of the help. I call that collusion. It isn't a crime - in fact it is almost certainly all 1st amendment protected activity - but it should tell you something about Trump's patriotism and fitness for office.

What does a responsible, patriotic candidate do if a hostile foreign power wants to help their campaign with hacked opposition research. At a bare minimum, you performatively condemn the hack "whoever did it" and call for an investigation. Ideally you specifically say that you don't endorse the hack and are not working with the hacker (this isn't a big sacrifice in terms of election-winning chances - sympathetic media would have been all over the Wikileaks drops even if the campaign wasn't). But Trump wanted everyone to know he supported the Russians interfering on his behalf.

In addition, please explain why Peter Strzok said that "There's no there, there"

Strzok believed - correctly - that working on the Trump-Russia investigation would be bad for his career, and didn't want the job. If he was thinking of the investigation as a criminal investigation, then he also might have believed - correctly - that there were not any actual crimes to discover. If it wasn't for the good fortune that Cohen and Manafort turned out to have committed tax evasion and mortgage fraud - in Cohen's case entirely independent of any involvement with Trump-Russia - then the investigation would have come up with bullshit process crimes.

My favourite example of a British Tory doing this is Norman Tebbit, who was a key early ally of Margaret Thatcher and who would go on to be the main minister responsible for implementing her anti-union policies. Tebbit consistently maintained that the closed shop was a form of fascism, because it required workers to join a union they didn't want to in order to keep their jobs. In 1978, this eventually provoked Michael Foot (who was one of the leaders of the far-left faction within the then-ruling Labour party) to call him a "semi house-trained polecat".

Tebbit's wife was disabled by an IRA bomb in 1984, and he retired from front-line politics in order to care for her. As was then usual for senior politicians who retire while still young enough to contribute, he was made a Lord. This entitled him to a coat of arms - which led to the burning question of what does a heraldic polecat look like? Eventually the College of Arms decided that heraldic polecats were semi-mythical creatures similar to heraldic tygers, and could fly. So Lord Tebbit's shield is held up by winged polecats.

Per Wikipedia, the term referred to non-Southern white working-class voters who switched from D to R for culture-war issues, particularly (in the 1980's) crime. Obviously that group has continued to drift right since Reagan to the point where most of them voted for Trump, but it isn't really part of the Republican base the way rural voters, small business owners, or the white South are.

Counterreminder: Nixon knew what Liddy and Hunt were after they botched the burglary of Daniel Ellsberg's psychiatrist. He had ample room and opportunity to fire them, and chose not to - presumably because he wanted them to do something similar to Watergate. The fact that he didn't know about that particular burglary in advance is good mafia opsec, but it doesn't affect his culpability.

Trump doesn't need to offer red meat to his base. His base already love him so much that they are still supporting him even after he has been indicted twice for serious crimes of which he is obviously guilty (and once for some bullshit process crime in NY). His problem is that his base are not close to a majority of the electorate - they are barely a majority in a Republican primary.

Trump either needs to convince more NeverTrump Republicans to hold their noses and vote for the crook, not the Democrat, or to convince more Reagan Democrat types that trannies are more of a threat to their kids than Russians.

I think as a practical point, the "system" almost never punishes highups for "high crimes and misdemeanors" where the primary victim is foreign (or Black or Indian pre-civil rights era, which basically counted as foreign), but often does so when the scandal is purely domestic. For example, nobody ever suggested punishing Nixon for Laos etc. but was taken out over Watergate. During the Reagan administration, only one person was jailed for their role in Iran-Contra (and that was for tax evasion), but a double-figure number of people were jailed for their roles in relatively trivial contract-rigging scandals. And Clinton was impeached for lying to cover up his relationship with Monica Lewinsky, not for bombing a pharmaceutical factory in Khartoum to distract media attention from it.

I suppose Trump was long considered a failson by Trump Sr, although it’s hard to say any father would be disappointed in a son who ultimately became president.

Trump had four careers: as a GC in his father's real estate empire (where his success was recognised by Trump Sr who gave him early access to his inheritance), as a real estate developer in his own right (where he was a failure, but made money anyway due to the big run-up in NYC property prices), as a reality TV star, and as a politician. He was brilliantly successful in three of them, but I can see why his father might care most about the one he failed in.

I sometimes wonder if Saddam Hussein was aware there were no WMDs in Iraq - up to the point where resolution 1441 passes the UNSC, he acts like a man who has WMDs and expects to lose power if he gives them up.

I also think that W would have received a sufficient amount of stovepiped intelligence to convince anyone who doesn't start out with the prior that the entire US national security elite are lying liars that there were WMDs in Iraq. Apart from the fact that the national security establishment are lying liars who knew what the White House wanted to hear and were happy to provide it, Cheyney and Rumsfeld were exceptionally able DC power players, partially controlled the flow of intelligence to the Oval Office, and wanted the war even more than Bush.

In the preface to Speaker for the Dead Orson Scott Card writes about "adolescent" vs "adult" main characters. He doesn't deal with it in those terms, but in effect what he is saying is that the Campbellian hero can't be someone who is already playing a fully realised adult role in his community (in his worldview as well as mine, this is approximately synonymous with "married with kids") because the hero arc doesn't make sense. So to write a heroic story with "adult" main characters (OSC's goal in Speaker/Xenocide/Children of the Mind) you have to do something else.

In my view, OSC fails - but I still love the books for HFY/superversive type reasons. Speaker and Children are both carried off by "adolescent" heroes - the still-single Ender in Speaker with a number of pequinino "brother" pigs (who we later learn are literal adolescents when the pequinino life-cycle is revealed) as supporting characters; and young Peter, Si Wang-Mu and Jane-as-young-Val in Children. Xenocide is a relative stinker because it doesn't have this - the central plot conceit is that Ender's struggle to bring harmony to the Ribiera family as stepfather turns into a metaphor for the broader struggle to restore harmony on Lusitania and in the wider galaxy. It almost, but not quite, works.

As a separate point, in last week's thread we had the Barbie discourse which talked about the idea of the fundamental male (hero's journey) and female (abandon your demons and embrace your inner fabulousness) character development arcs as being about SMV increase. A happily married man who goes on a hero's journey is not going to develop into a man who gets the girl, he is going to develop into a man whose wife loves him less than the man she married. This works well as the apotheosis arc where the hero who we saw complete the journey and get the girl in series 1 is called away from "happily ever after" to perform one last act of heroism to pull out the good guys win in series 2, and normally gets himself killed in the process. (Think Tony Stark in *Avengers: Endgame). But it doesn't work well as a regular hero story.

Somehow I doubt they'd be saying the same thing about Russiagate, a conspiracy theory based on zero credible evidence. But putting that to one side, this makes discussion pointless:

Even the Durham report admits that there was credible evidence for Russiagate (namely that Donald Trump asked* Russia to hack and leak Hilary Clinton's e-mails, that Russia did in fact hack and leak John Podesta's e-mails, and that there was circumstantial evidence that the Trump campaign worked with the GRU and Wikileaks to maximise the political impact of the leaks). The core claim of the Durham report is that there was insufficient evidence that Donald Trump committed a crime** to justify the amount of resources devoted to the investigation.

* I am aware that Trump's supporters on this site say he was obviously joking. The GRU didn't take it as a joke, so I don't.

** Signal-boosting true-but-illegaly-obtained information is of course 1st-amendment protected. This just means that it isn't a crime, not that we can't take it into account when assessing the patriotism, integrity, professionalism, or lack of all of the above, of Donald Trump.

If you set them to only go off below a certain balance (which is the default behaviour for my bank), then in Aransentin's position they just... stop.

The plot of the basic male story is "Man is weak. Man works hard with clear goal. Man becomes strong". I think men feel this basic archetypal story much more strongly than women, so that even an otherwise horrible story can be entertaining if it hits that particular chord well enough, if the man is weak enough at the beginning, or the work especially hard.

I think an even more basic male story is "Man is already strong. Man uses strength to serve God/Tribe/Woman and is appropriately rewarded. All live happily ever after or at least until next week's episode". That one goes all the way back to Gilmagesh - his character development is that he acquires the wisdom to use the strength that is already manifest at the beginning, not that he acquires strength. The same applies to the Greek heroes and most modern superhero material. The earliest examples of Took a level in badass on TVTropes are around 1800, which is consistent with the origin of the Bildungsroman as a genre - I can't think of obvious earlier examples of the "Weak man becomes strong" plot, unless you count tragic antiheroes like Macbeth or Faust who become strong in a cheaty, corrupting way that sets them up for a fall.

The reported appeals don't say - possibly because it would be a State crime and not Federal and the FBI or AUSA didn't want to hand the case over to the local DA. Possibly because attempted murder is notoriously hard to prove (you have to prove beyond reasonable doubt that she knew the poison she was using would have been lethal if the stunt worked). But the only thing that hit the public record are the charges and the verdict.

The fact that neither Hacker (who is chasing headlines) nor Sir Humphrey (who is trying to protect the interests of the senior Civil Service) are actually trying to deliver on an agenda is critical to the way the show works. Giving Hacker recognisable political views would turn Yes Minister into The Thick of It - in the sense that the show would become about why Hacker is chasing headlines rather than doing what he went into politics to do.

Interestingly, there appears to be a real-world parallel - a lot of people (including Dominic Cummings) who have commented on the real-world applicability of Yes Minister have said that a minister who is actually trying to do something can normally find more junior civil servants who want to help them and work around Sir Humphrey, whereas a minister who is chasing headlines will not motivate civil servants to do anything other than chase promotion.

I think there is a very interesting analysis to be done linking Yes Minister, Moral Mazes (extended analysis thread), and The Gervais Principle as a kind of three-fold way of bureaucratic dysfunction.

Moral Mazes is about the middle-management hierarchy of large non-financial companies in the pre-shareholder-value era, but is generally considered to be a universally applicable account of the internal politics of unaccountable bureaucracies. Yes Minister is about how such bureaucracies resist reform-from-above. And The Gervais Principle is about how they conceal the full horror of the situation from the line workers who actually hold the thing together and therefore prevent revolution-from-below.

If we ignore the policy substance (i.e. the immigration culture war aspects of this), the federalism issues also have a long history as a culture war flashpoint.

The TLDR version of the two sides are:

  1. The Federal government should have the necessary power to ensure that the US complies with its treaty obligations even if individual States don't want to, otherwise the US is an unreliable treaty partner.
  2. The Federal government should not be able to use treaties as an end-run around the principle of enumerated powers (or the rights of the States more generally).

It is very clear from the text of the Constitution* as well as the arguments made during the ratification that what the framers intended was (1) - although the Anti-Federalist papers make the case for (2), so it was a live issue on day 1. But the issue is not particularly relevant for the first 150 years because the enumerated powers of the federal government cover most of the things that 19th century statesmen negotiated treaties over (namely war and international trade). So the first time it starts to matter is with environmental treaties. The key SCOTUS case is Missouri v Holland in 1920 which said that a treaty with the UK (really Canada, but Canada was only de facto independent in 1920, not de jure) protecting migratory birds overruled State game laws in Missouri - note that under the pre-New Deal jurisprudence the Feds absolutely would not have won an argument saying that shooting migratory birds was interstate commerce.

The culture war on this point hots up after WW2 with the campaign for the Bricker Amendment which among other things would have explicitly reversed Holland - as far as I can see this is driven by John Bircher-adjacent conservative Republicans in the Midwest who don't like the Federal government because it did the New Deal and is probably full of Communists, don't like the UN for the obvious reasons, and are concerned about the possibility of the UN interfering in US domestic affairs. It naturally attracts the support of the White South (because the Federal government and the UN are both threats to Jim Crow) and so becomes one of the early "movement conservative" culture war issues. The Bricker Amendment was popular, and Eisenhower and LBJ had to twist a lot of arms to stop it passing.

The issue loses salience during the Cold War when the American right is bigger on anti-Communism than isolationism.

After the cold war the issue comes back on the agenda - mostly pushed by the group of libertarian legal scholars around Randy Barnett (who favours a set of new federalism amendments including something similar to the Bricker amendment). The key SCOTUS case is Bond which has utterly hilarious facts which will now be recounted, so keep drinks away from your keyboard.

  • Catherine Bond worked in a lab as a microbiologist. Her husband cheated on her with her best friend and got the friend pregnant.
  • Bond tried to poison the friend by using stolen chemicals to manufacture an arsenic-based contact poison and smearing it on her doorknob.
  • She gets caught, and the friend is not injured. Naturally the authorities want to throw the book at her, but because nobody was injured a lot of the juicy charges are hard to prove.
  • It turns out that the poison she used is legally a chemical weapon under the 1993 treaty forbidding chemical weapons.
  • So the Feds prosecute her for illegally manufacturing chemical weapons (under the 1998 Federal law implementing the US's obligations under the treaty) - which unsurprisingly carries a hefty sentence if it sticks.
  • After two trips to SCOTUS (one on standing and one on the merits), Bond wins 9-0 and the chemical weapons charges are tossed. Bond serves 18 months for stealing mail. The interesting thing is the breakdown of votes on SCOTUS. 4 liberals, Roberts and Kennedy voted to punt by interpreting the law in the light of the treaty - basically they said that because the treaty didn't cover Jerry Springer level shit, Congress couldn't have intended the law implementing it to cover Bond's behaviour. Alito, Thomas and Scalia write concurrences saying that the law as written clearly does cover Jerry Springer level shit if the shit involves a chemical weapon, but that Holland was wrongly decided and the law is unconstitutional on federalism grounds.

Again this turns into a good issue to unite the right - Bond was supported by corpocons (who opposed the treaty because they didn't like the idea of UN weapons inspectors inspecting US factories making dual-use chemicals), neocons (who opposed the treaty because they thought the US should retain the right to make and use chemical weapons if they turned out to be needed), UN-haters (who broadly overlap with social conservatives), libertarians, and gun nuts (who saw the ban on private ownership of chemical weapons as the thin end of the wedge towards the UN neutering the 2nd amendment).

No Teletubby is a valid male role model.

The target audience for the Teletubbies was ages 1-4. At the time the original Teletubbies came out in 1997, it was the first TV show to explicitly target an audience under 3, and attracted heavy media coverage in the UK on this basis long before anyone cared about Tinky Winky's sexuality (which, to be fair, was never much of an issue in the UK anyway - the "gay panic is stupid" faction had already won decisively on our side of the pond). Both "Teletubbies is revolutionary because nobody had made TV which will hold the attention of a 1-year-old before" and "Teletubbies is evil because 1-year-olds shouldn't be looking at screens" were done to death in the media.

A Teletubby is a perfectly good role model for an 18-month-old baby aspiring to toddlerhood. When I was growing up, the preferred pronoun for babies that young was still "it" - they are not going to be picking up gay dogwhistles.

but still offered a uniquely higher level of protected liberties than other societies at the time or for centuries prior

As a slave society, antebellum America offered a lower level of protected liberties than non-slave societies, of which several existed in 1776. You can argue that Jefferson was a hypocrite who believed that "all men are created equal and endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights" while whipping niggers for fun and profit, and that America deserves the credit for his good intentions, but we know that most of the Southern elite from which Washington and Jefferson were drawn did in fact believe that some men were born with saddles on their backs and others with spurs to ride them, and were willing to say so explicitly. This is, of course, what the French revolutionaries and their enemies said they were fighting over (and I believe them), and what the Americans said they were fighting over in the 1860's (and I believe them too).

I have always assumed that one of the reasons America was spared the bloodshed of the French revolution and associated upheavals was that the Founding Fathers carefully fudged the question of whether all men really were created equal. As it turned out, the fudge only lasted 80 years and the bloodshed was postponed and not prevented.

In the UK, we put our fudge in place with the Restoration in 1660 and the Glorious Revolution in 1688, and somehow made it stick all the way to the present day when Charles III is crowned By Grace of God, King of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and his other Realms and Territories, Defender of the Faith and only spergs and left-idiotarians complain that this is incompatible with democracy. I assume part of the reason we were able to do this is that the English Civil War and the depradations of Cromwell's major-generals was a fair warning of what would happen if you actually tried to give a straight answer to the equality question.

Most LBO debt (which this is) is floating rate.

LBOs need to have optional principal payments because they don't know if the company will make enough free cash flow to make principal payments on the debt. Fixed rate debt with a prepayment option is a nightmare for banks to price and risk manage (see SVB passim, or the S&L crisis for an earlier example - LBO debt would be even worse than mortgages because there isn't the huge volume of historical prepayment data) so it tends to be expensive. And private equity firms have the necessary skills and market access to manage their own interest rate risk with derivatives. Most (but by no means all) LBO loan covenants require the borrower to buy an interest rate cap which protects itself (and thus indirectly the lenders) from big interest rate rise.

To be fair, Musk-owned Twitter is exactly the sort of organisation that would "forget" to buy the cap, and it turned out to be a working assumption among Musk-aligned right-wing VCs that they were bailout-eligible.

The fundamental issue that the EU had in England was that it lacked legitimacy.

This is dubious - there was a 2/3 supermajority for membership in the 1975 referendum, and zero sign of meaningful public support for changing this until UKIP get 16% of the vote on a 38% turnout in the 2004 European Parliament elections. Eurosceptic parties do embarassingly badly in Westminster elections until 2015, by which time UKIP have learned that they need to headline a populist domestic programme - Brexit is relegated to an appendix in their <a href = "https://d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net/ukipdev/pages/1103/attachments/original/1429295050/UKIPManifesto2015.pdf"manifesto.

Notably, pro EU people in England don't express themselves in favour of the EU, but against England.

This is simply false. It is true that "I see myself as more British than English" is the best predictor of remain-voting (better than age or education) and that the patriotic section of the pro-EU movement used British rather than English symbols. But the anti-patriotism wing of the British left is anti-British (mostly anti-Empire) at least as much as it is anti-English. The only people who are noisily anti-English in British politics are the SNP.

The main reason why pro-EU people in the UK are pro-EU is that we believe (correctly) that EU membership is in the national interest - Dominic Cummings' focus groups confirmed this. Our support for the EU is a fundamentally pro-British position. (And therefore, indirectly, pro-English). There is a minority of fanatical pro-Europeans who would support EU membership if it wasn't in the national interest - they express this support by waving the EU flag and singing the Ode to Joy, not through being anti-English (which, as I have said, would just make them look like angry Scots).

The driving force behind right-populism in the UK is (similarly to other countries) a combination of:

  • General Boomer nostalgia

  • Vibes-based beefs about the economy, which mostly appeal to a generation of pensioners who are nevertheless enjoying an unprecedented level of affluence in retirement.

  • Opposition to Muslim immigration, which has very little to do with the EU.

The fact that this expressed itself through opposition to the EU, rather than opposition to the UK domestic policies which caused the problems, is a mistake on the part of right-populist voters - the Brexit we are getting is, as promised by the Johnson wing of the Tories, leading to increases in non-EU legal migration and is also leading to increases in illegal migration. And the Brexit-supporting faction of the Conservative party that supported Johnson, although not Johnson himself, are committed to the "Thatcherite" domestic-policy agenda that is what the people beefing about the economy are beefing against. So the interesting question is why the nascent right-populist movement in the UK self-sabotaged by focussing on Brexit. The question of why right-populists in the rest of the EU are not making the same mistake is easy - because they can see what happened in the UK.

Some of this is bottom-up (the age group that is most susceptible to right-populism is also the cohort group that has always been the most anti-EU, going back to the 1975 referendum). But a lot of it is top-down:

  • Pre-Farage, Euroscepticism is mostly a libertarian-adjacent project which although deeply unpopular with the voters, is well-funded and backed to the hilt by powerful foreign-owned media. So the right-populist movement that looks most likely to deliver Brexit and then cuck (i.e. UKIP vs the BNP/EDL/English Democrats) is the one that gets the cash and favourable media coverage. And even the existence of this movement is somewhat contingent - if Margaret Thatcher's senile dementia progresses differently then the bizarre idea that the true Thatcherite position on the EU is the direct opposite of Margaret Thatcher's approach to the EEC as Prime Minister may not get off the ground.

  • Cameron promises the Brexit referendum because of internal Conservative party politics, not because of any public pressure for it. (Remember how pathetic UKIP are in Westminster elections). FWIW Cummings says that promising the referendum did not help the Tories in the 2015 election, mostly because the promise was not believed.

  • If you look at the leave campaign messaging, both Vote Leave (Cummings) and Leave.EU (Farage) made blaming the EU for Muslim immigration a core part of their campaign. Vote Leave mostly do this using the "Turkey is joining the EU" lie - which only sticks because Cameron personally supported Turkish EU membership back in the pre-Erdogan era when it was a live political issue. Farage focusses on the 2015 Mediterranean migrant crisis (which was technically Merkel's fault, not the EUs, but the politics didn't reflect this) - which is taking advantage of a piece of good luck. But critically, neither campaign makes migration of EU citizens a core issue, because opposing the immigration of hard-working law-abiding culturally-Christian immigrants was not a vote winner.

I’m not sure any of that it possible unless all of Europe does the same.

From the point of view of the European populist right, yeschad.jpg. The European Parliament effectively forces political movements to organise at a pan-EU level, and the populist right is getting better at it. The bottom-up movement to curtail Muslim immigration is inherently pan-EU.

Also, the problem as perceived by the marginal right-populist voter is irregular immigration, and a lot of work on that issue (border policing, asylum reform, doing deals with transit countries to push "refugees" back) can and should be done at EU level, and increasingly is. Contrary to the "woke EU" memes spread by the Brexit campaign, the EU institutions have proved themselves perfectly willing to actually do anti-immigrant things where the member states let them. The EU (largely under the influence of Eastern European conservatives) has produced

  • A public statement by the Commission President (effectively the head of the EU executive branch) that countries deliberately facilitating the transit of unwanted immigrants are engaged in a "hybrid attack" on the EU.

  • A uniformed EU border corps (Frontex). Frontex also has a coast guard that actually turn migrant boats round and send them back (see wokist wailing and gnashing of teeth), rather than acting as a water taxi service. This Samo Burja briefing (unfortunately behind an expensive paywall) provides confirmation that Frontex is for real from a non-establishment source.

  • The Dublin agreement to stop asylum shopping. (Leaving the Dublin agreement as a side effect of Brexit is why the UK now has a "small boat" immigration crisis that we didn't when we were in the EU)

  • A deal with Turkey to return Syrian refugees who settled in Turkey before illegally immigrating to Europe.

  • The only reason why the EU isn't funding border fences is tit-for-tat budget politics.

"If we want to keep the infidel out of Europe, we need to work together" has been a truism of European politics for almost 1000 years by now.

It is never 5D chess.

Whenever someone claims that n-dimensional chess is being played in the FSU, my go-to response is "Gary Kasparov has repeatedly said nobody in the FSU is playing n-dimensional chess and the cock-up theory of history applies the same there as everywhere else - are you claiming to know more about chess than him?"

the story of never again is really only propaganda

"Never again a Holocaust" is propaganda. "Never again a land war in Europe" is something that Europeans and Americans of the wartime generation took extremely seriously, and which Europeans and Blue Tribe Americans are still taking seriously in Ukraine as we speak.

Much as the globohomo elites liked to kvetch about the lack of Pride parades in Moscow, nobody seriously suggested actually doing anything about it, even something petty like boycotting the Sochi Winter Olympics. What brought the banhammer down - both the little banhammer in 2014 and the big banhammer in 2022 - was Russian troops crossing the internationally recognised borders of Ukraine with murderous intent.