MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
You didn't just have to mix with them, you had to lead them into battle. With the rise of gunpowder and the demise of the knight in shining armour as a practical battlefield weapon, the role of nobles (and gentlemen below them) on the battlefield became as officers, and officering the army became the de facto function of the nobility. And the other ranks tended towards the worst kind of oik. As Wellington said:
I don't know what effect these men will have upon the enemy, but, by God, they frighten me.
If I look at my own family history (I am from a multi-generational upper-middle class family), all my (male) ancestors had a job early in their career where they had to give in-person orders to their social inferiors. My father's first graduate job was as a shift manager in a factory, and the previous three generations were military officers. The only people I have ever had to give orders to (apart from servants - one of the advantages of the UMC mindset vs. the PMC one is that you can save money by hiring servants directly rather than going through a corporate intermediary) are juniors in the office who are basically younger versions of myself. And that is typical of my generation - the only person in my undergraduate social circle who expected ever to be giving orders to social inferiors was the lady who spent her whole gap year working at McDonalds and got promoted to floor manager half way through. (Quite a few people from UMC backgrounds had worked on the line in shitty jobs like McDonalds as student summer jobs etc. - but that is temporarily slumming it with the proles, not leading them, and thus a very different experience).
What would "fighting back" involve? Are you suggesting that you know something Nixon's advisors didn't, and that he had a way of avoiding Senate conviction? Or are you suggesting that he stage a coup to remain in office despite the Senate voting to remove him? (SecDef Schlesinger and NSA Kissinger had already taken steps to prevent orders to stage a Latin America style coup reaching the military)
We now know that Woodward and Bernstein were stenographers and that Mark Felt (aka "Deep Throat") was a swamp insider trying to remove Nixon for swampy reasons. But that doesn't matter as a matter of law or politics - in 1974 the Republican caucus in the Senate wasn't prepared to support a President who swore like a sailor while plotting the cover up of an outrageous piece of ratfucking in an election he would have won anyway. If you are caught red-handed committing a crime, attacking the motives of the prosecutor is not convincing to anyone who wasn't supporting you anyway.
Nixon did find a way of turning a vast electoral victory into a way to lose - but that was staging the Watergate burglary in the first place. That is what I don't understand - why did he do it? With McGovern as the Democratic candidate, the 1972 election was basically in the bag without the information he was hoping to get from the bug tape. The trifecta of committing a serious crime, getting caught, and having powerful enemies is not usually recoverable, and I don't see how it would have been for Nixon.
???
Are you saying that sending classified information over unsecure e-mail is equivalent to putting it on the open Internet? I suppose it might be in terms of possible harm (although in the case of Hillary Clinton's e-mails this would be mitigated by the fact that they were probably never routed outside the US), but in terms of legal culpability it definitely isn't.
Nixon didn't resign out of decency. His advisors had told him that the Senate would vote to convict, and he didn't have the kind of grassroots Republican support that Trump did that would allow him to seek revenge on the Republican senators that voted against him - the hard-core Republican primary voters already preferred Reagan to Nixon by this point.
To be precise, the crime is intentionally falsely recording a personal expense (paying off Stormy Daniels) as a corporate expense (the Trump Organization paying a bill for legal services provided by Michael Cohen). Absent any other wrongdoing, this would be misdemeanor false accounting. Under NY State law, it gets upgraded to a felony because of the intent to conceal the campaign finance violations.
It would normally turn into felony tax evasion if the Trump Organization filed a corporate tax return based on the falsified accounts, but the indictment implies that the payments were 1040ed with the expectation that Cohen would pay personal income tax on them. This means that there was no revenue loss, so probably no tax evasion charges on the Trump Organization. (Cohen did not, in fact, pay the tax, and was jailed for personal tax evasion in 2018).
Apart from the tax angle, this would never normally be prosecuted unless an actual human being lost money as a result. But it is a real crime, not "three felonies a day" bullshit. Law-abiding businesses do not intentionally falsify their books and records. It certainly looks like the prosecutor has evidence of falsification and evidence of intent.
Sandy Berger got a fine and probation for doing worse than what Clinton did.
Has anyone ever been jailed for merely mishandling classified information without improperly disclosing it?
ETA - a quick google found this list of example cases. It looks like big shots like Berger and Petraeus get off with probation and fines, but small fry can get 3 months in prison if they are unlucky. The multi-year sentences all involved at least the appearance of unauthorized disclosure.
I think it is pretty clear Clinton would not have been jailed if she was prosecuted. Similarly, it would be an injustice if Trump gets jailed for mishandling classified information (assuming, of course, that he hasn't been disclosing it).
Hillary Clinton herself has repeatedly suggested that Trump's victory was rigged by the Russians
This is "words have meanings" pedantry, but Hillary Clinton did not accuse the Russians of rigging the election. A "rigged" election is one where the declared result deliberately does not match the votes cast. The Russians tried to rig the election (by hacking voting machines), but failed - the Clinton campaign and affiliated left-establishment groups had conceded this by the end of November. Other people, notably including Jill Stein, continued to run with the idea after it became clear that it didn't happen, but Clinton did not.
What Hillary said, correctly, was that the Russians improperly helped Trump by hacking and leaking John Podesta's e-mails. This is "interfering" with the election, not "rigging" it. Hillary Clinton and people speaking on her behalf have always been quite careful about this distinction, even if the broader left have not. The distinction matters because calling an election "rigged" is an implicit call to change the official result to match the votes cast, but (at least in the US) a complaint about interference is a call to punish (either judicially or politically) the people responsible without throwing out the validly cast votes.
There was no attempt by the Clinton campaign or anyone affiliated with it to overturn the 2016 election on grounds of Russian interference. Jill Stein requested recounts in several key states in accordance with state law, and they didn't find anything untoward.
The actual norm is that losing candidates do not challenge the transition of power with force, but of course Trump didn't do that, so that's not helpful to criticizing him.
Politics does not work by the rules of criminal trials. In the ordinary English meaning of the word, Trump (among others) incited the Jan 6th riots, which were an unsuccessful attempt to prevent the orderly transition of power by force. He should not have done this, and no other Presidential candidate has continued to publicly challenge an election after exhausting his State-law remedies since Hayes-Tilden in 1876. The fact that we can't prove the causal link between Trump's incitement and the events of Jan 6th 2021 means he probably can't be prosecuted for it (and in any case, he would probably be protected by the 1st amendment), but it doesn't mean that he didn't do it. As I have said elsewhere, if the King says "Who will rid me of this turbulent priest?" and Thomas a Becket gets murdered, he loses the benefit of the doubt.
In any case, the argument that Trump sought to overturn the 2020 election by force is not restricted to the Jan 6th riot. Per the evidence gathered by the House Select Committee, Trump held a meeting in the Oval Office on 18th December at which he suggested rerunning the election under martial law. Michael Flynn made the same suggestion publicly on multiple occasions, and there is reasonable evidence that he was doing so on behalf of Trump. Again, probably not enough evidence for a criminal conviction, but enough evidence for the establishment to conclude on the balance of probabilities that Trump would have overturned the election by coup if the military had co-operated.
I think "The President does not conduct coup plots in the Oval Office" is, and always has been a norm of American politics that Trump violated.
Given that the Russians did in fact hack and leak John Podesta's e-mails on behalf of the Trump campaign, why should I believe people who say he was joking when he asked them to do the same to Hillary Clinton? I think Henry II was probably joking when he said "Who will rid me of this turbulent priest?" but he doesn't get the benefit of the doubt after Thomas a Becket is murdered.
So the books and records of the Trump Organization show the payments to Cohen (which would ultimately go to Stormy Daniels) as a corporate legal expense. That would end up being claimed as a business expense on the corporate tax return.
I think you could argue that Cohen negotiating a hush money agreement with Stormy Daniels was legal work, in which case he could bill the actual hush money as a disbursement, and paying a lawyer's bill including disbursements could be included as a "legal expense" in the accounts. But it would be the Trump Organization paying Trump's personal legal expenses, which would need to be accounted for as an employee fringe benefit. I am not familiar with US tax law, but in the UK that would be taxable on the employee (i.e. Trump).
Glorious Technocratic Bugpod Future
Re-reading this, it sounds like I'm accusing my outgroup of being part of a vast conspiracy
Res Ipsa Loquitur
Memes about eating bugs and living in pods sound unhinged to normies and non-alt-rightists in the same way and for the same reason that Handmaid's Tale memes sound unhinged to normies and non-wokists - it is a call to resist a non-existent conspiracy.
Re. bugs, I move in circles where people would eat a bug in exchange for a Davos invite, and I haven't met anyone who regularly eats insects, or who lobbies for other people to eat insects. I am aware there was once a WEF panel on the advantages of insect protein, but as of the current year, the "meat is animal cruelty and climate change" crowd are pushing fake-meat products like Beyond Burgers.
Re. pods, it isn't even obvious what this means - there was a long thread on this forum discussing the confusion where it eventually became clear that "living in the pod" meant that WEF elites wanted non-elites to live in much less square footage than American suburbanites would consider acceptable. There are two problems with this one - the first is that if it took a 10+ post forum thread to explain it to a sympathetic audience on this forum, then normies who hear "I will not live in the pod" are just going to be confused. The second is that, although "non-elites should live in something smaller than the cookie-cutter 3000 sq ft suburban McMansion favoured by middle-class Texans" is indeed an idea held by most WEF attendees, the smaller homes they are promoting do not fall within the ordinary English meaning of the word "pod".
If you look at the Tiny House Movement, only one of the pictures on that wiki page is podlike. The Berkeley shared houses where the so-called "Rationalists" have weird sex while reading overlong Harry Potter fanfics are not pods. A 700 sq ft apartment in a converted industrial building is not a pod. A 1500 sq ft New Urbanist rowhouse is definitely not a pod.
In my experience, comparing someone to Mussolini is about making them sound more ridiculous than threatening, not about whether they look Italian or not. Trump is Hitler because he is a "fascist" and a winner. De Santis is Mussolini because he is a "fascist" and a cheap Trump knock-off. I don't think that the people writing these pieces know anything about Franco or Salazar, and anything they know about Peron comes from watching Evita.
One of the points made by the book Moral Mazes (also community discussion) is that Moral Mazes (the book is about the management hierarchy at large non-financial companies in the pre-shareholder value era, but the general principles apply to any sufficiently unethical bureaucratic hierarchy) are total institutions, and that anyone who has built a career in one loses the ability to understand people who are motivated by things other than office politics.
(Incidentally, once you understand the concept of a Moral Maze, the term Swamp as used by anti-establishment politicians clearly refers to the coalition of corporate, governmental, and machine-politics Moral Mazes that work well together because they understand each other in a way they don't understand startup founders, family-owned businesses, or charismatic non-machine politicians like Sanders and Trump).
Donald Trump has been a GC in his father's real estate empire, a real estate developer in his own right, a reality TV star, and a charismatic outsider politician. None of these careers involve working in a Moral Maze. If he is ethically compromised (and he probably is), it is about money and/or sex, not office politics. I can absolutely believe that a career bureaucrat or career machine politician would struggle to grok him.
You are correct. I should have scare-quoted something like "classified documents crime"
The crime shouldn't be scare-quoted either. Sandy Berger was prosecuted for mishandling classified documents as Clinton left office - he got a plea deal for a $50k fine plus probation, and lost his security clearance. The Trump case seems analogous. I agree that trying to jail Trump for the document-related crimes would be an escalation, although jailing him if he refuses a plea deal and loses at trial would not.
Car "free" cities ARE a future
If the scare quotes are intentional, then it is worth pointing out that low-car-use cities are the present, not the future. Above a metro area population of about a million, the city where most people don't drive most of the time is the default in Continental Europe and first-world Asia.
Nuclear fusion hasn't been 5 years away for a good century. The traditional wording of the joke is "nuclear fusion is 20 (sometimes 30) years away and always will be". It was indeed the case that the engineers' timetable for useful fusion power coming out of the big government-funded fusion projects was 20-30 years from 1952 (when the first H-bomb was tested) to 2014-5 (when Tokamak and Helion tested their first prototypes).
As of today, there are three private-sector fusion startups (Tokamak, Helion and Commonwealth) with SMART plans to build a useful fusion power plant within 10 years. This is different, and exciting.
Obama published a certified copy of his birth certificate, authenticated by the State of Hawaii, in 2008. Trump was pushing birtherism in 2011-2, when "falsely" is appropriate.
The "Communist Party of Britain" isn't even the British communist party. That would be the "Communist Party of Great Britain" (which was Soviet-backed, and disbanded after the fall of the Soviet Union, with its leaders drifting seamlessly into senior positions in the left wing NGO-sphere). The "Communist Party of Britain" was a tankie splinter group that split off from the "Communist Party of Great Britain" in 1985 (de facto) or 1988 (de jure).
The bit in The Life of Brian about the rivalry between the People's Front of Judea and the Judean People's Front was inspired by real events in British hard-left politics at the time Monty Python were making the film.
Of all British "communist" groups, the one you really need to watch out for are the "Revolutionary Communist Party", who appear to be libertarians (but are currently LARPing as anti-woke social conservatives).
Trump derangement syndrome is an escalation, but the blue tribe thought the Obama-Kenya conspiracy theories were a huge escalation and didn’t really distinguish between the randos who said it and the GOP higher ups who explicitly disavowed it. If Rubio had won the 2016 election we may well have been seeing the same level of derangement, admittedly with less ammo.
The "randos who said it" included Donald Trump - who became a GOP higher up when he was nominated for President. Both Trump's popularity with the anti-establishment right and his extreme unpopularity with the pro-establishment left (and large parts of the pro-establishment right) start here. When Obama published his birth certificate, Trump claimed the credit for making him do it. Per Wikipedia, Trump didn't publicly acknowledge that was a US citizen until September 2016 - i.e. after fighting the Republican primary as an ambiguously-repentant birther.
Falsely claiming that a major party candidate is ineligible is an attack on American democracy. The GOP primary electorate nominated Trump despite (definitely) or because of (probably) his willingness to do it anyway. Trump's base within the GOP is people who think that Democrats always cheat, that they get away with it because the GOP establishment are cucks, and that Republicans should cheat back harder. This is more obvious post-Jan 6 than it was then, but Trump's opponents brought receipts in 2016.
Fundamentally, the scary thing about Trump is that he behaves as if American elections are kayfabe on top of an underlying system of raw power politics, and his supporters love him for it. If American elections really are kayfabe, this makes him someone who breaks kayfabe and gets away with it, which any wrestling promoter knows can destroy the franchise. If you think that American elections are not in fact kayfabe, then he is the worst threat to American democracy since elections really were rigged in 1960's Illinois. In either case, he needs to be stopped.
I think someone who claimed a hooker payoff as a business expense on their taxes would be prosecuted for tax fraud if they had powerful enemies, which Trump does. But that would be a federal charge, and Merrick Garland is playing his cards close to his chest.
This particular indictment is driven by Bragg's ego and desire to advance in NY lefty politics, not by a desire to convict Trump. Hence the weak charges - Trump is guilty of a lot more serious crimes than misrecording the Stormy Daniels hush money, but nothing that is both media-friendly and chargeable in New York state court.
I suspect the federal indictments will be less bullshit and will include serious crimes of which Trump is actually guilty.
The Americans and the EU haven't colour revolutioned Poland or Hungary. There was definitely organised foreign support for the opposition in Hungary, but the plan (which failed) was to beat Orban at the ballot box (or possibly to force him into sufficiently blatant ballot-rigging that he could be colour revolutioned). In Poland, not even that.
Except these same urbanists then turn around and say we need to stop building suburbs, or start building denser suburbs or mixed-use neighborhoods or whatever you want to call it,
There is an important distinction between "we need to stop building suburbs because there are already too many suburbs, and what people want is more urbanism and less suburb than we have now" and "we need to stop building suburbs as a first step towards demolishing the ones that already exist, because nobody should live in a suburb". My impression is that the vast majority of online urbanism hold the first view, and definitely that the YIMBYs do - the whole point of YIMBYism is that places need to build more of what they don't have, not demolish what they already do. Of course, the American culture war is perceived as zero sum in a way which means that "we need more urbanism", "we need less suburbia" and "we need zero suburbia" all read to a moron in a hurry as "I stan fixed gear bicycle owners and spit on F150 owners".
My view is that America has too much suburbia, as demonstrated by the very large price premium housing commands in the small number of less-crime-ridden, less-car-centric places. America needs to build more less-car-centric places, and fix the crime problem in the existing ones. The UK, on the other hand, has a shortage of competently executed auto-orientated places - so Milton Keynes commands a price premium. In the British context, I am a housing maximalist - I favour more dense urbanism AND more suburbs (but please no auto-orientated suburbia in zones 1-4 of London or within walking distance of railway stations in the London commuter belt). The problem in the London commuter belt is that too much land is reserved for golf and horses, not cars.
There is a separate issue that the American model of one-car-per-adult suburbia sucks above a metro area population of about 5 million. If you look at the top-10 CSA's by population (I am using CSA's instead of MSA's because otherwise the Bay Area gets broken up which borks the statistics):
-
New York, Washington-Baltimore, Chicago, the Bay Area, Boston and Philly are all less-car-dependent by American standards.
-
LA is notoriously unlivable due to traffic and smog, and everyone agrees that further auto-orientated growth is a bad idea. In fact, you can make a decent argument that the financial failure of inappropriate auto-orientated growth in the LA exurbs was a major cause of the 2008 financial crisis - the mortgage bust began in the Inland Empire.
-
Houston is well aware that need to do something to stop their city turning into LA. Texan Republicans in the Houston suburbs are not willing to use public transport, but they are willing to vote higher taxes on themselves to subsidise other people using public transport. The success of Houston's light rail scheme suggests that there is unmet demand for public transport there. Greater Houston is also YIMBY in a way which makes densification of the core easier.
-
DFW is blithely turning into LA. For whatever reason coverage of DFW traffic jams doesn't cross the Atlantic the way it does for LA, Houston or Atlanta, but published surveys suggest that DFW traffic is actually worse than Houston.
-
Atlanta is in the middle of a political battle between the core and the suburbs about whether or not it wants to turn into LA, but so far a de facto alliance between the core and suburban NIMBYs seems to be slowing suburban growth, while the core is gentrifying and densifying.
So if you want to live in a large metro area and enjoy the benefits thereof (which by no means everyone does, but the most productive places are generally large metros) then urbanism is essential because suburbia doesn't scale. But at a national level, the whole point of YIMBY is that non-zero-sum outcomes are possible. More urbanism and about the same amount of suburbia is a thing that can happen, that would make both America and the UK better places, and that online urbanists would take as a win.
Parliamentary immunity protects current elected officials, not former ones. The purpose (to prevent the executive using criminal prosecution as a weapon against the legislature) is not served by protecting former officials.
It is almost exactly how it played out with John Edwards.

Some of this is urban-rural. If you lived in the country, you couldn't avoid getting your hands dirty - admittedly the peasants got theirs dirty working while the gentry got theirs dirty playing. If you lived in the city, there was a decent chance that the factory manager went home with clean hands while the factory workers were reaching for the Swarfega. Some of it is that the landed gentry tended to be physically tougher than the bourgeoisie in a way that manual workers respected.
More options
Context Copy link