MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
2. Paris
Travel by Eurostar - the Channel Tunnel regularly makes lists of wonders of the modern world, although you don't really experience this cruising through it at 99mph.
Key sites in Paris:
Art - Louvre, Musee d'Orsay, Modern art gallery on the top floor of the Centre Pompidou. The Louvre is sufficiently large and complex that it would be worth a group of Grand Tourists hiring a professional guide to identify the things they were interested in - it is one of the two museums on this list where you could usefully spend a full day.
Unique buildings - Eiffel Tower, Notre-Dame, Sacre-Coeur, the Garnier Opera House - consider the guided tour if you are not going to the opera.
Whatever-it-is - Catacombs tour
Wandering around - The Marais, Ile de la Cite
2a Suburban excursions - Cité des Sciences et de l'Industrie (science museum), Versailles, Euro Disney if you must.
2b Paris excursions
Chartres cathedral (about one hour by TER train) - the OG Gothic Cathedral. On the same TER line as Versailles so you could combine both in one long day.
Reims (46 minutes by TGV) - Cathedral and champagne. Cellar tours are in Reims or in Epernay, vineyard tours usually depart from Reims.
The Loire - this is the big one. The only reason why the Loire valley chateaux were not on the original grand tour was that they were not open to the public until after the French Revolution. They are a must-see for Grand Tourists, even though they are off-route. You could spend a whole week in the Loire valley if you wanted to.
The best chateaux in my view are Chambord (accessible by shuttle bus from Blois station) and Chenonceau (not accessible by public transport at all). There are various levels of commitment depending on how much time you have. A day trip by public transport is going to get you to two chateaux - probably Blois and Chambord (TER trains take to Blois take between 1hr36 minutes and 2 hours). Organised coach trips can get you to three in a day - various combinations exist. Two days lets you get more done, and also lets you get further away from Paris. Overnight in Blois or Amboise if you are staying in the Eastern Loire, and Tours if you are going further west. This is one of the places I would consider hiring a car(s), or even splashing out on a customised private minibus tour if the group is big enough. My 2-day hardcore Loire itinerary looks like: Day 1 - pick up car at Vendome-Villiers TGV to avoid Paris traffic. Do Chambord, Chenonceau, and Blois or Amboise on day 1. Stay in a motel near Tours. Do three of Chinon, Azay-le-Rideau, Fontevraud Abbey (not a chateau - but the highlight of my Loire trip. The Abbey Church is a key transitional form between Romanesque and Gothic architecture, and also has the tombs of the Plantagenets including Richard the Lionheart and Eleanor of Acquitaine), Saumur (only if there is someone horsey in the group). Return via Tours TGV.
2c Paris culture
Food - get a Michelin 2/3 star French meal if you can afford one. French haute cuisine is to gourmet cooking as classical music is to music. Just like curry in the UK, there are a number of fusion cuisines arising from French colonialism. Frenchified Lebanese and Moroccan are both great. I haven't tried Frenchified Vietnamese, but I want to next time I am in Paris. Traditional Paris cafe staples like croque monsieur should also be on the list.
France has a theatrical tradition almost as rich as England, but it isn't accessible to you unless you speak fluent French. There is a French performing arts tradition loosely defined as Cabaret which qualifies as a must-see - Moulin Rouge is canonical, but I don't know how much of a tourist trap it is. The Paris opera is excellent - the choice between Paris and Milan for Opera should be based on what is showing when you are in town. You might want to see a mime show, if you are into that kind of thing (you sick fuck).
3 Paris to Geneva
This is a case where the map tells me one thing and the train timetable something else. The train timetable tells me that the only sensible stopover is Lyon - the TGV makes the run in 2 hours non-stop. The map says we are going through the middle of Burgundy and it would be wrong not to stop off in Burgundy - the best destination is Beaune (Hotel-Dieu, wine tours). I am not familiar with Lyon, but it does seem to merit the stop. The old town has World Heritage Site status, and Lyon is now the gastronomic capital of France (as far as I can see, multiculturalism and high rents are driving traditional French haute cuisine out of Paris).
3a French wine
I think seriously engaging with the French wine-making tradition at some point on your trip through France is compulsory. Options for visiting vineyards and wineries on this route include Reims (Champagne), Burgundy, and Saumur (if you spend longer in the Loire valley). When eating out in France (except Paris), drink local.
4 Switzerland
We start with Geneva and Lausanne. As well as the usual urban sites, there are a couple of oddball attractions which qualify based on my criteria in the OP. Geneva has CERN. The visitor centre is good, but the public tours of the site are limited and only available by lottery on the day. If you have a physics major in your group it is worth trying to pull strings to get a scientific tour. Lausanne has the Olympic museum.
There are then two routes into the mountains - @2rafa recommended the Rhone Valley route with Zermatt as the stopover. I think this is a great route, but I mildly prefer the route through the Bernese Overland, including the scenic GoldenPass line from Montreux to Spiez and then a train through one of the Lochtsberg tunnels to Brig, where it joins up with the other route. Possible stops include Gstaad (the tradition of European luxury tourism that begins in the Victorian period is Grand Tour-worthy, and Gstaad is one of the best places to engage with it, particularly given that you are paying out-of-season prices) and Spiez (traditional Swiss lakeside resort popular with locals).
In either case you then go through the Simplon tunnel, famous for being the route used by the Agatha-Christie era Orient Express to cross the Alps, and continue to Milan.
Ground truth - I didn't realise that the NYT had stopped including staff-recommended comments, so that is irrelevant.
Highest voted comments are half
and half
Pre-registered prediction - most recommended comments selected by NYT editorial staff will be solidly pro-AA and treat the idea of SCOTUS banning it as monstrous. Most upvoted comments based on user sentiment will be AA sceptical but will avoid saying nice things about SCOTUS.
The clickbait era is over - the economic model that supported it (CPM ads) is now non-viable if you want to fund actual journalism. The media operations who are making money are doing it with subscription revenue from a smaller number of more committed readers - which is why everything is paywalled nowadays. The same is true of alternatives to traditional media like Substack.
Why don't we see it in the private sector?
We do. There is even a trade association for private fusion companies. Of the ones on that list, Tokamak Energy, Commonwealth Fusion Systems, and Helion are all serious operations that have raised nine-figure sums of money from private-sector investors. I suspect some of the others are as well - those are just the three I am familiar with.
It's easy to prove that COVID-19 caused megadeaths, but it isn't easy to prove that it started from a lab leak. My out-of-posterior probability on "The COVID-19 pandemic began with a leak from the WIV" is 60%. People who I trust not to be enstupidated by the culture war and who have understood the evidence on both sides and updated on it use words consistent with posterior probabilities in the 10-49% range. "The COVID-19 pandemic began with a leak from the WIV of a pathogen deliberately engineered as part of a gain of function programme for which identifiable US persons can be blamed" is obviously even less likely because of conjunction.
Even if COVID-19 wasn't a lab leak, it could have been. That is sufficient to make gain-of-function research into pathogenic viruses a universal jurisdiction capital offence going forward, but it isn't enough to punish the people who did it when it was legal.
The call to start punishing people for the COVID-19 lab leak without confirming that it actually happened is a call to punish people based on any conspiracy or cock-up theory which is at least as plausible as the lab leak theory and ends with megadeaths. FWIW, my out-of-posterior probability on "Climate change will kill more than a million people in Sub-Saharan Africa by 2050" is 80% - we know that some non-zero amount of climate change is real, that Sub-Saharan Africa was too hot already, and that it doesn't take that much to cause a million deaths in the third world. My out-of-posterior probability on "Cigarette marketing during the period where tobacco company executives knew that smoking caused cancer but publically denied this caused increased cigarette consumption leading to over a million worldwide cancer deaths" is 95%.
Given the politics of all this, it will be the tobacco executives who are first against the wall if we adopt this policy. I suspect that at least one wholly innocent group (vaccine manufacturers, Monsanto employees, water flouridators etc.) will be targetted before the mob gets round to the COVID-19 lab leak theory.
More seriously, part of the purpose of trials and such-like is that they affect the deterrent message that the following punishment sends. If the De Santis administration gets the Supreme Court to ignore the Bills of Attainder clause and terror-tortures Fauci for funding gain of function research in Wuhan, the actual lesson learned is "Don't do anything which might upset a noisy minority of partisan voters enough that they call for your head" which cashes out as "Don't do anything at all" because partisan rage-machines are fairly unpredictable. Even if you do prove that Fauci-funded research engineered the virus which escaped from WIV, if he is the only person you terror-torture with e.g. tobacco industry executives skating then you are sending the same message.
To send the message "Don't do stuff that has an obvious risk of a megadeath cock-up", you need to make the risk of being terror-tortured depend more on the severity of the cock-up than the political valence of it.
I would probably reduce ELA specific classes (writing can be learned in say history)
YES, YES, YES. See my comments in this thread, where someone was arguing against HS history altogether.
I agree with you that women who start public fights (both verbal and physical) and then cry misogyny when a man fights back are beneath contempt.
The claim that Taylor Lorenz's coverage of the Oshry sisters was unethical doxxing depends on an understanding of "doxxing" which is not universal, even among online communities (which have a much stronger rule against doxxing than IRL ones). The Oshry sisters were running a social media influencer operation which made minimal attempt to conceal their legal names and very much traded on their family relationship with each other. Taylor Lorenz did not unmask an actively-protected pseudonym, and she did not share non-public contact information, which are the central examples of "doxxing". She signal-boosted the true, publicly-available, fact that public figure X was semi-public figure Y's mother.
If you wanted to defend Taylor Lorenz using the traditional rules of journalism (which I won't - the article was clickbait), there is a very obvious argument to make that she was unmasking hypocrisy - the Oshry sisters were making a big deal about how important family was while cutting out their mother.
The claim that this article was so unethical that Taylor Lorenz should be unemployable is the claim that there should be some kind of ethical rule against signal-boosting true but embarrassing publicly-available information about public figures - in other words it is a claim that journalists should not do journalism. The claim that it was a trashy article because it treated an Instagram influencer as if they were an important public figure is valid and accurate, but that isn't and shouldn't be a career-ending offence.
Does the Daily Beast even count as mainstream media anyway? The Wapo not holding it against Taylor Lorenz that she did tabloid shit when she was working at a tabloid is normal business ethics, even if they do think it was a trashy thing to do.
The Cato Institute used to pay P. J O'Rourke to do this. I am a British /r/neoliberal-style neoliberal and I read it, because it was funny.
Crypto doesn't solve the problem with remote voting. If you can vote from home, you can vote in front of your spouse. If you can vote in front of your spouse, then your spouse can coerce you into doing so and control how you vote.
The crybullying only works at an individual level because the Blues have already won at the social level. Institutional rules that reward crybullying are imposed top-down by people who achieved power when the norms did not favour crybullying.
The bottom-up norms of the Blue Tribe treat white women’s tears - i.e. Blue elites and aspirant-elites crybullying each other - as almost as worthy of contempt as men’s tears.
Another way of thinking about it is that crybullying only works if you are a designated Blue client group. (The Red Tribe often try crybullying the Blues, and it doesn’t work). Crybullying culture only appeared when the Blues were powerful enough to have client groups.
Yes - I am pretty spergy (obviously, being here) and I always prefer social situations with written rules, whether that is a formal dress code, Robert’s Rules, or the rules of the board game we are playing.
Anthropologist Kate Fox in Watching the English talks about the “English social dis-ease” - a kind of national spergery - and how it causes the English to adopt formalised dress codes and form social institutions with clear rules of etiquette. I also suspect it is why we invented sports with written rules.
Gatekeeping access to a market based on willingness to obey laws and pay taxes is essential to a functioning market.
One of the weirdest ways of dividing people into two types is people who expect dishwashers to work and people who don't. It doesn't seem to be amenable to experience of your current dishwasher - I wonder if it is driven by the dishwasher in the house you grew up in.
We did this with, for example, smog, vacuum tube tvs, leaded petrol, lemon cars
Smog and leaded petrol both required government intervention because the pollution is an externality. Leaded petrol is still better than unleaded from the point of view of the engine, which is why Avgas is still leaded.
The same is true of CO2 - the reason why the worst-case scenarios associated with RCP8.5 (which people like David Friedman correctly point out won't happen, despite the amount of research funding going into working out just how bad they are and the media attention this attracts) will not, in fact, happen, is that governments saw the problem and acted to mitigate it - mostly by subsidising the R&D and early adoption of the technologies (PV cells, efficient wind turbines, electric cars etc.) that will support a lower-carbon society.
Achieving RCP4.5 instead of RCP8.5 is in everybody's interest (except for a few selfish Boomers) because it is the difference between your grandchildren thriving and (with an unacceptably high probability) frying. Fortunately, it doesn't require a Great Reset to achieve. But achieving it has required and will continue to require elites to talk to each other about decarbonisation at places like Davos, and COP meetings, and G20 summits. Going further to achieve RCP3.4 or RCP2.6 isn't in the interests of Red Tribe Americans who have large sunk investments in a high-carbon lifestyle, but it would be in the interest of a lot of people if the technology to do it at a reasonable cost exists. (Tip from a physicist - it does, it's called nuclear power).
In a sane world, working out whether RCP3.4 is a good idea or not requires both elites talking to each other about what can be done and what it might cost, and voters talking to each other about whether it is a good idea or not given the facts that emerge from that conversation. In the world we actually live in, this won't happen, among other reasons because the culture war is making us stupid and US climate policy is going to be decided by whether ragetweets about Hunter Biden's laptop are more or less viral than ragetweets about George Santos' CV. Davos is selling (at an extremely high price) the idea that these conversations are happening and that business executives are valued participants in them.
The thing to remember is that the Blue Tribe derives from the New England Yankee/WASP elite, which in turn derives from the section of the English upper-middle class which looked up to the upper class (and was frequently descended from the younger sons of upper class families). In that class, if someone commits a sufficiently grave faux pas you are unfalteringly polite to their faces and then quietly disinvite them from your social circle. (And if enough people do this to you, you fall out of the elite). You never shame people in public - that would be making a scene. In fact, the only people you even shame in private are your children and mentees, who need to learn what not to do to avoid getting cold-shouldered.
Getting fat is not acceptable in Blue Tribe elite circles. Public fat-shaming is even less acceptable. These are not inconsistent.
Laughing about the pussification of the Blue Tribe seems strange at a time when they run the world, are winning so much that they are tired of winning, and their opponents have basically given up to the point where their best hope is for the Blue Tribe to self-destruct in a woke-stupid dumpster fire (admittedly a highly plausible outcome). But the basic error isn't new - people were talking about how wealth made the British soft before, during, and after the peak extent of the British Empire. More recently, people were using "they/them army" memes to explain why Russia would win in Ukraine.
It's also the case that in low-crime societies "Group X is significantly more likely to commit crimes than the majority" and "Group X are sufficiently law-abiding that you don't need to take precautions around them" can both be true. This is true in respectable working class and above suburbs of London for various values of group X, and I suspect it is also true in Finland.
Judea was de jure incorporated into the Roman Empire in AD6 after Augustus lost patience with King Herod’s son’s incompetence. Pontius Pilate was the most famous Roman governor.
I am riffing on this one - based on Cummings’ other work the “predictive model of the electorate” that is the centre of his plan is a big ML model trained on opinion poll raw data - at the time he wrote the essay GPT-GOP was not technically feasible but it seems an obvious extension of other Cummings ideas now that it is.
Some of my in-laws live in a rural area, plus I spent a lot of time around the culture while trying to buy a cocker spaniel puppy raised in a shooting household - I can confirm that rural shotgun culture in the UK is as strong as rural gun culture in other countries, and that shotgun licenses are easy to get. The rules are designed to discourage using a shotgun which is owned for sporting purposes as a home defence weapon (you have to store the gun unloaded, with the gun and ammo in two different locked compartments), but 100% of the rural gun owners I spoke to planned to shoot a burglar if the opportunity arose. Armed farmers were generally aware of the Tony Martin case, and thought that he shouldn't have been convicted, but also that they were not in danger from the law because they wouldn't be as stupid as Tony Martin (who had already lost his gun license in a separate incident to the one he was jailed for for shooting at a moving getaway car).
Paul was on Roman territory when he famously said Civis Romanus Sum. At the time of Palmerstone's speech, the British monopoly on violence extended to anywhere within range of a navigable waterway, except for the territory of a small number of rival Great Powers - hence Gunboat Diplomacy. This level of pre-eminent sea power is rare - whether the United States had it for parts of the late 20th century is a good internet ranting issue. Nobody else has ever had it on the oceans, although Tyre, Rome and Venice all came close within the confines of the Mediterranean.
I find the idea of a network state having soft power which rivals the hard power of the Royal Navy at its height somewhat implausible. Particularly if the network state is, as you point out Balaji wants to do, shirking civic obligations by exiting from the world normal people have to live in.
Agreed that Avebury is great - in fact I consider it a better tourist visit than Stonehenge if you are not "big game hunting" - which admittedly Grand Tourists are and probably should be. But if you only have a week in the UK, then I wouldn't spend enough time in the area to do both, and if I am fitting something in as basically a stop-off on the way to or from Bath then Stonehenge fits the bill.

Flippantly, a civilisation that lasts forever preserves itself one century at a time.
More seriously, my social circle includes people involved with long-term planning at some of" the longest-lived Western institutions (the old universities), and 100 years is the longest timescale that they find useful to think about. I was just reading this Freddie de Boer comment thread where someone pointed out that Japanese companies that see themselves as perpetual also plan out to 100 years (but most of the long-term planning energy goes int 20, 30 or 50 year plans). The "Longtermist" movement within rationalism/EA are thinking about the far future, but their plans for getting there all play out in considerably less than 100 years.
Everything that can happen will happen eventually, and nothing lasts forever, so a prediction that something will eventually collapse is as valuable as predicting that the sun will rise tomorrow. Predictions have shelf-lives - if they expire unfulfilled then they are wrong, not just early. And 100 years is too long a shelf-life for a meaningful prediction. Saying that western civilisation is degenerate is a statement about something that is happening now. Saying that western civilisation is collapsing is a statement about something that is happening now with consequences that should be undeniable soon. Right now I see obvious downward trends (mostly high-IQ fertility) which are affecting all advanced human societies roughly equally badly. But if I look at the West vs the Rest at the highest levels of civilisational achievement, I see our weapons triumphant on the battlefield in Ukraine, I see the ARM/TSMC/ASML axis of semiconductor excellence consolidating its supremacy in a way which gives its customers in Silicon Valley and other Western countries a permanent edge over their Chinese competition, I see Gwynne Shotwell ignoring her boss's inane social media antics and building bigger, better rockets, and above all I see talent continuing to move west voluntarily.
Tiktok is bad, and a threat to corrupt our youth. But I don't see why it is scarier than the sort of challenge we eat for breakfast on every page of the history books.
More options
Context Copy link